definition

Two Competing Constitutional Visions

Per Randy Barnett, there are two competing visions of the Constitution: a 'presumption of liberty' under which people are free to pursue an occupation unless government shows a genuine need to intervene (dominant at the Founding through the late 1930s), versus a 'presumption of constitutionality' under which government may intervene unless the worker proves the action unconstitutional (dominant since the 1930s-1950s).

definitionpending

Speaker

Dick Carpenter

Evidence Quote

“two competing visions of what the Constitution says. One is the presumption of liberty... The other view is that, the government should have the ability to intervene, unless and until the person who wants to work freely shows that what the government is doing is unconstitutional.”

Source

Dick Carpenter on Bottleneckers— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:13:45 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...