causal

PR instability can be designed away

The claim that proportional representation is inherently unstable is flawed because PR spans a wide variety of systems; design features like Germany's constructive vote of no confidence (you cannot dissolve a government without another already in place) and a 5% electoral threshold make PR systems far more stable than the Weimar-style chaos critics cite.

causalpending

Speaker

Jonathan Rodden

Evidence Quote

“lots of proportional countries have institutions like these that make them a lot more stable.”

Source

Jonathan Rodden on the Geography of Voting— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:30:35 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...