What this covers

This is a Daily Briefing conversation from Real Vision in which Andres Dinolassen interviews Eric Johnston of Cantor Fitzgerald, with a segment from Jason Trinner on inflation. It was recorded after a hot CPI print. The inquiry is why equities have held up despite a hawkish Federal Reserve, and who is actually still holding them. Johnston describes the Fed as running an unprecedented experiment, moving from the most accommodative policy ever to the most restrictive in two decades within a single year. His answer turns on positioning. CTAs are net short and mutual funds hold about 6.1% cash. Individual investors, by contrast, have sold almost none of the roughly $1.5 to 2 trillion they added after COVID.

The range is wide. On inflation, Johnston argues it will not fade on its own and that the Fed must force demand destruction through lower asset prices and weaker employment. Trinner counters with three structural reasons inflation stays higher for longer: a tight labor market, lagging shelter costs, and Western environmental policy that keeps fossil fuel prices high. Dinolassen adds that the last stretch of disinflation, from 6% to 2%, will be harder than the move from 10% to 6%. Johnston also expects margin compression, because wages fall more slowly than prices.

The market-mechanics material includes flat S&P skew read as complacency, short dealer gamma amplifying intraday swings, and options activity that lets retail move single stocks. Consumer stress shows up in a $300 billion drop in checking deposits and rising credit card use. They also touch on a weakening yuan and the People's Bank of China's defense of it. The sector views are the most contestable: energy is favored on the end of the SPR release, a possible China reopening, and constrained drilling spend, and healthcare is favored as a defensive, yield-providing alternative.

Sharpest takeaway

Despite significant economic headwinds (high inflation, restrictive Fed policy, weak consumer positioning), equities are holding up well because institutional investors have reduced exposure while individual investors have not yet sold their post-COVID equity purchases; the next major market leg down will come when individual investors finally capitulate and when equity risk premiums normalize to historical levels requiring S&P 500 levels in the low 3000s.

  • Institutional investors (CTAs, mutual funds, hedge funds) have dramatically reduced exposure, but individual investors still hold ~1.5-2 trillion in post-COVID purchases with equities at ~60% of their allocation, leaving massive selling potential
  • Equity risk premium is at a 12-year low (2.4%) despite extremely high risks from Fed policy transition, creating a valuation disconnect that must correct
  • Earnings will face margin compression as inflation comes down because wages are sticky downward while prices can fall faster, pressuring corporate profitability in a deflationary environment

The claims · ranked40 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.75

Individual investors added approximately 1.5 to 2 trillion dollars into equity markets during the post-COVID run-up, and despite the ongoing sell-off, essentially none of that capital has come out yet.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Eric Johnston

“the individual investor put somewhere around 1.5 to 2 trillion dollars into the equity markets and what's happened during this sell-off is that essentially none of that has come out yet”

0.75

The Federal Reserve is conducting an unprecedented experiment, transitioning from the most accommodative monetary policy ever to the most restrictive monetary policy in the last 20 years, all occurring within a single year, creating extraordinarily high risks in the economic environment.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Eric Johnston

“we have a fed that's doing an experiment here that we've never seen before going from the most accommodative fed policy ever to the most restrictive fed policy in the last 20 years and it's all happening in a year so the risks including quantitative tightening etc so the risks right now are extremely high”

0.74

Over the last 12-13 years, there has been yield suppression where individual investors have faced alternative investment yields ranging from zero to a couple percent, creating a structural disadvantage compared to holding equities.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Eric Johnston

“we've had yield suppression now for essentially you know 12 13 years where the you know individual out there has been looking at an alternative to equities that's yielding you know anywhere from zero to a couple percent over the last 12 13 years”

0.74

Wages and employment costs represent a very high percentage of companies' operating expenses and tend to be much stickier downward than the pricing of goods and services, creating asymmetric margin pressure when inflation falls.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Eric Johnston

“wages employment costs are a very high percent of one's operating expenses those also tend to be much stickier and tend to lag other the pricing of your goods and services and so on the way up that lag helped and then you can think about it in an environment where demand starts to degrade which is what the fed is trying attempting to force to happen then the price of your goods can come down a lot uh more sharply than your employment costs”

0.70

Options market activity has enabled individual investors to move individual stocks based on heavy option activity over durations of days to weeks, allowing retail to impact broader market movements.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Eric Johnston

“the options market has been you know used more and more over the last couple years by the you know individual investor and at times they've been able to move individual stocks based on very heavy option activity typically with a duration of a day or a week um and they're able to as a result you know move many move many stocks”

0.70

During the current sell-off, CTAs have become net short equities and have sold a fair amount this year, while mutual funds have raised their cash levels in equity portfolios to some of the highest levels in a long time, possibly ever, reaching about 6.1% cash.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Eric Johnston

“so far during the sell-off institutions have brought down their exposure in a pretty significant way so if you look at ctas their net short equities they've sold a fair amount this year if you look at mutual funds they've raised their cash levels and their equity portfolios to some of the highest levels in a long time possibly ever they're at about 6.1”

0.69

Large moves across multiple asset classes (rates, FX, gold) typically precede either positioning breaks or economic breaks, suggesting elevated risk levels in current market conditions.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Eric Johnston

“i think one of the things that's going on really across all so many different asset classes that you're seeing these very large moves whether it's the rate market the fx market you know today gold was breaking down and when you get these types of moves whether it be in the two-year yield right when you look at a chart of that and it has absolutely surged these things typically happen typically something breaks um in whether it breaks in you know people's positioning or it breaks a economy in the in the circumstance of rates”

0.68

Inflation has benefited corporate earnings through supply chain advantages and the ability to pass through price increases, and as inflation comes down, these earnings benefits will reverse, creating margin compression.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Eric Johnston

“earnings were helped by inflation earnings were helped by the supply chain issues that everyone was talking about and so when people say inflation's going to come down it seems like that's only the conversation goes to and hence the fed is gonna can stop at four or four and a half percent but the part that's missing in that is that corporate earnings just like they benefited from inflation on the upside they are going to get hurt when inflation comes down”

0.68

Inflation will not come down magically on its own when it is this high for this long; the Federal Reserve must actively force demand destruction by reducing asset prices, wealth, and employment levels to bring inflation down and keep it down.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Eric Johnston

“inflation now you know people talk about the word entrenched um it's been going on for you know somewhere high inflation for somewhere around a year and a half and uh there's no end you know in sight so it is becoming entrenched so in order to get inflation down it doesn't magically come down on its own when it's this high for this long so if you have a unemployment rate at 3.8 percent in s p at you know 3 900 4 000 um if that's just not and you have a soft landing that's just not going to get inflation down you have to get asset prices lower you have to get wealth lower unemployment up”

0.68

Jason Trinner identifies three structural issues keeping inflation higher for longer: (1) tight labor market with twice as many job openings as job seekers, forcing wage increases; (2) housing prices up 20% year-over-year with lagging impact on rents and the 25% weight of shelter in CPI; (3) Western environmental policies keeping fossil fuel prices elevated.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jason Trinner

“there's three in particular that i would focus on the first would be wages and as you may know there there are about twice as many job openings as there are people that are actively looking for work that don't have a job and so particularly on the i would say entry level service oriented jobs there's a lot of pressure on wages... secondly um i think the housing market while it's it's weakening a bit if you can believe it house prices in the us are up close to 20 year-over-year... and then the third issue that's structural it seems to me um and i don't offend anyone's politics here but i do think that the west's environmental policies are keeping a price of fossil fuels higher longer than they ought to be”

0.66

As people have fewer assets, less wage growth, and higher unemployment, the demand to pay current prices falls and the supply of goods becomes more competitive, eventually allowing prices to move lower and stay lower.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Eric Johnston

“as people have fewer assets less wage growth and more people are unemployed then demand to pay those prices goes down and the supply of goods becomes more competitive and that's how there will be a you know shakeup in the economy to get prices to move lower and stay lower which is the key”

0.65

S&P 500 skew (implied volatility of downside options relative to upside) is relatively flat, indicating complacency around potential large downside moves and insufficient hedging demand for extreme losses.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 1/4· Eric Johnston

“if you look at sku in the s p 500 it's really quite flat and you know there's not i would say there's a little bit of complacency around the potential downside in the market uh meaning that there are there's not as much demand for hedging for a large downside move in the s p 500 which is one of the things that's keeping the sku fairly flat relative to the you know at the money or near the money”

0.64

Individual investors have allocated approximately 60% or more of their portfolios to equities, which is close to historic highs, leaving significant room for them to reduce exposure.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Eric Johnston

“if you look at the individual investors allocation to equities it's close to historic highs um somewhere north of of 60”

0.64

Credit usage has surged over the last six months as consumers are increasing their credit card balances and dipping into different financial sources beyond checking accounts.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Eric Johnston

“you've seen credit usage surge over the last six months and so what that tells you is is that the consumer starting to dip into different pockets they're different dipping to their their deposits at checking accounts they're increasing their balances on their credit card”

0.64

In the second quarter, approximately 300 billion dollars came out of deposits from checking accounts at banks, indicating consumers are beginning to deplete liquid assets.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Eric Johnston

“in the second quarter there was about 300 billion dollars that came out of deposits at from checking accounts at banks and you know in addition to that you've seen this you've seen credit usage surge over the last six months”

0.64

Recent moves in interest rates have been parabolic and have occurred in a very short period of time, with money market fund yields projected to reach approximately 4% within three to four months, a level that would have been considered unrealistic a year ago.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Eric Johnston

“the recent move that we've seen in interest rates has been you know parabolic right and it's happened and we can talk more about this related to the markets but it's happened in a very short period of time and so we're going to look up in three or four months and money market funds are gonna be yielding four percent if someone said we were going to see a four percent money market yield yield a year ago people would have thought you're crazy”

0.63

The energy sector has performed well this year and is positioned to continue performing well due to multiple structural tailwinds: (1) SPR (Strategic Petroleum Reserve) release ending, (2) potential easing of China's zero-COVID policy increasing demand, (3) reduced capital spending on drilling due to ESG and decarbonization policies.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Eric Johnston

“interesting sector that has clearly done you know very well so far this year is is energy um but i think it is something that is going to continue for for a few different reasons um so the first is that we're going to have a situation where the supply dynamic is going to change over the next you know month and a half with the spr release you know coming to an end and simultaneous with that we are going to sometime the next likely sometime within the next six months you're probably going to see an easing of the zero coveted policy out of china which is going to you know sharply increase the demand from from their perspective in concert with that you have you know less capital spending that's going on and that's part of this overall you know inflation for longer story is that as you know esg becomes much more relevant by the day um and the decarbonization you know spending and and you know views come you know you move forward then you're going to have less capital spending on drilling”

0.62

Individual investor positioning remains as the critical variable that will determine when the next leg lower in equities occurs, as this cohort has been the key source of market support during the current correction.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Andres Dinolassen

“we should watch the positioning among individual investors because that's essentially the shoe that needs to drop before the next leg lower in equities”

0.61

Rising mortgage rates are creating headwinds for the housing market while the wealth effect from simultaneous declines in bonds and stocks is dampening real estate demand.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Eric Johnston

“the sharp rise in mortgage rates clearly a headwind you know the wealth effect outside of one's home is is clearly getting hit based on uh you know bonds and stocks getting hit simultaneously”

0.61

Getting inflation from six percent down to the two percent Fed target will be much more challenging than getting it from ten percent to six percent, implying the market may be underestimating the difficulty of the final phase of disinflation.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Andres Dinolassen

“it's obviously fairly easy to get inflation from ten percent year over year to say six percent or at least manageable but it's probably trickier to get inflation from say six percent back to two percent the ultimate target for the federal reserve”

0.59

The Chinese yuan is weakening as the People's Bank of China attempts to defend it from falling too quickly, representing potential capital flight from China.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Andres Dinolassen

“we've had a couple of questions from the audience already surrounding the move that we've seen in the us dollar versus the chinese yuan i can add that it's fairly clear from the daily fixings being said by the people's bank of china that they're trying to um defend the yuan against weakening too fast right now”

0.59

Dealer gamma positioning is currently very short, creating exacerbated intraday moves in S&P futures as gamma hedging from dealers amplifies volatility.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Eric Johnston

“one of the things that we're looking at right now is that dealer gamma activity right now is uh or what gamma levels right now are very short and that's one of the things that's causing the exacerbated intraday moves that we're seeing so if you look at the s p futures the last 48 hours the intraday moves have been violent and the re one of the big reasons for that is that the active managers are fairly quiet much they're kind of watching and it's really being dictated by uh gamma hedging that's going on from a very large short gamma position”

0.56

Healthcare sector should outperform as a less cyclical alternative providing capital returns and yield while consumers reallocate into defensive sectors during economic uncertainty.

forecasthigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Eric Johnston

“i would add on to that that i think healthcare does well and i think healthcare you know can do well just because it is less cyclical um has you know has capital uh return in in parts of the you know non-biotech uh market um and will be i think would be a place where people want to move dollars into as a way to be in a less cyclical group and also get some yield while they're there”

0.56

The US equity market has significantly higher multiples than rest-of-world markets, with the US-ROW spread widening, reflecting market confidence that is not justified by comparative economic outlooks.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Eric Johnston

“you know the u.s market multiple is you know is far greater than you know rest of world and that spread has been widening”

0.56

Inflation has become entrenched after approximately 1.5 years of high inflation with no end in sight, with the problem broadening from supply-chain and oil-specific issues to a widespread 0.6% month-over-month core inflation rate (7.2% annualized).

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Eric Johnston

“inflation now you know people talk about the word entrenched um it's been going on for you know somewhere high inflation for somewhere around a year and a half and uh there's no end you know in sight so it is becoming entrenched it is broadening out right initially it was supply chain it was oil oil is now back to the high 80s supply chain has uh you know mostly rectified itself and yet we still have an inflation issue putting up a 0.6 month-over-month core number or 7.2 percent a year and a half later”

0.55

Housing market imbalances created post-COVID due to remote work and changed living preferences are quickly coming back into balance, setting up housing price declines.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Eric Johnston

“similar to the labor market there was a you know mismatch post covered you know a shift going on and how people live their lives remote work and everything that we know that that changed post covid so you know there was a imbalance but the imbalance i think is quickly coming into balance and there will be you know i think prices will begin to move lower”

0.52

Historical data from the last 60-70 years shows that in each major inflation spike, after inflation peaked, earnings declined over the subsequent 1-2 years, as demonstrated by analyzing snapshots at inflation peaks and tracking earnings outcomes.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Eric Johnston

“we looked at all the times in history in the last 60 70 years when we've had these big spikes in inflation we took a snapshot of the point where inflation peaked over the course of the next one to two years and what happened to earnings as inflation numbers came down and that's the chart that you see on your screen and that's a snapshot of all those different times and what you'll see is in each of those cases earnings came down”

0.52

Individual investors who have experienced 12 years of 'every dip is bought, stocks will go higher' market behavior may lose patience as the current sell-off continues, with losses in large-cap names and negative momentum being the primary triggers for equity selling.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Eric Johnston

“the individual investor has seen over the last 12 years every dip is bought just be patient stocks will go higher and at some point as this sell-off continues and as it drags on i think that patience will will go down the one other important point i would say is that if you look at some of the data that i think is really important in the second quarter there was about 300 billion dollars that came out of deposits at from checking accounts at banks”

0.51

Oil prices should remain supported as the SPR release ends within the next 1-2 months, creating a near-term supply dynamic shift that will remove a key headwind on oil prices.

forecasthigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Eric Johnston

“the supply dynamic is going to change over the next you know month and a half with the spr release you know coming to an end”

0.51

A labor union settlement in the rail industry produced a 24% wage increase, providing anecdotal evidence that wage pressures continue despite disinflation narratives.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Eric Johnston

“we saw today the settlement with the labor union related to rails a 24 increase in wages um it's still going on today the boeing ceo said we're going to have inflation with us for the next five years”

0.51

Natural gas markets should remain tight and support high US natural gas prices due to global demand pressures and structural supply constraints.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Eric Johnston

“we know the gas situation where you know there should remain high demand for uh us natural gas”

0.49

A potential next step in consumer financial stress is withdrawal of money from stock accounts to fund lifestyle costs in a 10% inflation environment.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Eric Johnston

“the next thing that could come is i need to withdraw some money from my stock account to fund my lifestyle with this 10 uh inflation environment”

0.45

Japan's equity risk premium is at a 12-year high, indicating Japanese equities are priced more attractively than US equities on a risk-adjusted basis.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Eric Johnston

“if you look at the equity risk premium for example for japan that's at a 12-year high”

0.45

There is no obvious place to hide from negative equity market pressures globally, given unfavorable fundamental outlooks across developed markets despite some valuation differences.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Andres Dinolassen

“it's not easy to say whether um there is any place to hide on the globe from from this list of of negatives in relation to equities”

0.45

The Canadian housing market has shown a terrible monthly print, but the US housing market has not yet provided final clear evidence of a decisive rollover, though early signs of weakening are emerging.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Andrea Dinolassen

“we've been talking about it uh for quite a while we've had an another terrible monthly uh print out of the canadian housing market today but i still think that we sort of lack the final evidence that the u.s housing market is rolling over”

0.45

Without knowing multiples, ranking regional equity markets would be easier because fundamentals favor the US; however, once valuations are factored in, the ranking becomes ambiguous and trading is difficult.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Eric Johnston

“i think we would you know if we had a rank order um where we wanted to be if we didn't know multiples i think that would be a much easier exercise and um and clearly you know the european outlook i think is far worse than it is in the u.s but when you actually do look at prices and and multiples it's a lot of that is being uh reflected and that's what makes it tough”

0.44

Yuan weakening is not yet on the radar of most equity investors, but macro professionals are clearly focused on it as a potential signal of systemic stress.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Eric Johnston

“it's on my radar i would say that it is much less so on the radar of equity investors um you know clearly clearly the macro world is focused on it but i would say equity investors are much less focused on it and you know i think it i think it should be”

0.39

Hedge funds have brought down both their gross and net equity exposure to somewhere in the 1st to 5th percentile over the last 10 years, indicating they are in historically underweight positions.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Eric Johnston

“hedge funds have brought down their gross exposure and have brought down their net exposure to they're essentially in the one to fifth percentile over the last uh 10 years”

0.39

To restore the equity risk premium to historical norms of 4%, which has been achieved in 9 of the last 11 years, the S&P 500 would need to decline to the low 3000s, assuming current earnings estimates are accurate.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Eric Johnston

“in nine of the last 11 years the equity risk premium has hit four percent has gone up to at least four percent in nine of the last 11 years and so if you were to get to a four percent equity risk premium you would be talking about a s p in the low 3000s”

0.39

The Boeing CEO has stated that inflation will persist for the next five years, providing senior corporate perspective on the durability of inflationary pressures.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Eric Johnston

“the boeing ceo said we're going to have inflation with us for the next five years”