
Wafaya Abdallah on Hair and Running a Small Business 12/13/2010
What this covers
Russ Roberts talks with Wafaa Abdallah, owner of Oasis Hair Salon in Rockville, Maryland, about the economics of running a small service business. The talk begins with her route from would-be lawyer to salon owner and with her family's story. Her father arrived in Charlotte from Egypt in 1970 with limited English, worked at Hardee's and as a janitor, and by 1975 was running a hospital. She offers this as evidence of American mobility, set against the class barriers of Egypt. Roberts frames her position as that of a residual claimant, the person who keeps the bottom line and so decides whether to pay for employee requests.
The middle of the conversation is operational. She describes idle time in a traditional ten-operator salon, where productivity of about 50% is common. She also covers a level system built on productivity rate and pre-booking rate, an equal team bonus that includes shampoo assistants and the front desk, and financial numbers that any employee can check on the salon computer.
The range widens from there. Hiring, she says, is a crapshoot, so the salon uses scripted interviews with several team members. Her view on firing is that attitude problems should first send the owner back to her own mentoring, since the fish stinks from the head down. She also describes a "direct talk" rule against gossip. Her claim that licensing mainly serves sanitation and disease control, not haircut quality, is contested. The craft itself gets attention too: thorough consultation, clients leaving out of boredom, demand for low-maintenance cuts, and biweekly Tuesday workshops. She expects little technological change and no automation.
Wafaa Abdallah argues that a salon's pay structure determines its culture: replacing commission with guaranteed salary plus team bonuses turns stylists from competitors for individual clients into a team that shares business, mentoring, and accountability.
- Commission pay rewards individual chair behavior, which undermines team cooperation regardless of how much owners preach teamwork
- A guaranteed salary with a team-wide monthly bonus lets senior stylists mentor others and raises the salon's productivity
- Transparent numbers, daily huddles, and structured hiring and training build trust and accountability
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Under commission pay, stylists have an incentive to cut quickly to serve more clients per hour, while still needing enough quality to keep clients returning, which makes them look out for themselves rather than the team.
“if I'm in one of those salons and I'm cutting here I have an incentive to cut quickly so I can get more and more customers”
As the owner, Abdallah bears the residual claim on profits: she gets the bottom line, while employees have a stake that is smaller, so the owner decides whether to spend on employee requests such as better food or tea.
“you're what we call in economics the residual claimant so you get the bottom line does all flow to you which is means even though they have a stake it's not as big as your stake”
Hiring is a crapshoot: business owners across industries reach the same conclusion that candidates present well and that first-day performance is hard to predict, so the salon uses multiple interviews with scripts to reduce mistakes.
“I think everyone comes to the same conclusion it is a total crapshoot”
Traditional commission-based hair salons reward individual behavior, so however much an owner preaches team spirit and positive attitudes, the compensation structure works against teamwork.
“because it's traditionally a commission based business what you're rewarding is individual behavior... and as much as you want to preach team and you know positive attitudes the compensation doesn't really allow for that”
Licensing for cosmetologists exists mainly to protect public health through disease and sanitation control, not primarily to prevent bad haircuts, and cosmetology school teaches identifying scalp and nail infections and lice and preventing their spread.
“I think I has a lot more to do with disease and sanitation”
Abdallah's salon replaced commission with a guaranteed salary plus benefits such as health insurance, vacation pay, and some sick leave, which lets stylists earn the same or more while working less physically hard.
“what he did is he guaranteed my salary it then enabled the business owner to give benefits such as health insurance um vacation pay maybe a little bit of sick leave... basically you have the potential to make the same or more money but you don't have to physically work as hard”
In Egypt, opportunity depends heavily on social class: poor people cannot advance regardless of education, whereas the United States allows rapid upward mobility for immigrants.
“there's kind of more or less two classes in Egypt the poor and the rich and if you're poor your opportunity isn't great no matter how well educated you are”
Financial numbers are available to every employee on the salon computer, so staff can verify the owner's report of whether monthly targets were met and cannot assume she is withholding bonuses.
“those numbers are available to everyone... they can just look it up”
Firing an employee for theft or poor customer service is easy, but firing for an underlying attitude problem that cannot be pinpointed should start with examining the owner's own failure to mentor, coach, and communicate with that person, since fish stinks from the head down.
“you recognize fish stinks from the head down and so you first look at what conversations am I not having with that person”
Hair-cutting technology has changed little over 20 years, with better shears and new tools being mainly incremental, and the craft cannot be automated, so human contact remains central to the business.
“our business really can't be automated you know and it's going to keep the human aspect”
Her salon operates with 'direct talk' and no gossip, and accountability, which she calls the hardest thing to implement, is handled by asking anyone raising a problem about someone else whether they have talked to that person and held them accountable.
“we have no gossip we have to use direct talk... what I immediately say is have you talked to them have you held them accountable”
Abdallah's father, a well-educated Egyptian, came to Charlotte, North Carolina in 1970 with limited English, worked at Hardee's and as a janitor, earned another master's degree, and became head administrator of Charlotte Community Hospital by 1975, which she argues is possible only in America.
“he came to Charlotte North Carolina in 1970 and didn't have a lot of English he works in the Hardee's and he worked as a janitor... five years later in 1975 he was the head administrator”
The most common reason clients leave a stylist is boredom, so stylists must keep learning and be ready to lead clients into new looks.
“the number one reason they say the clients leave stylist is boredom they want something new”
Thorough consultation with clients is the key to avoiding bad haircuts; active listening and repeating back what the client wants can greatly increase the chance of a successful result.
“if you have a good consultation you have 99% reduce your your chances”
The state board conducts random inspections focused on sanitation and disease prevention, and Abdallah believes licensing exists mainly to prevent the spread of disease and infection rather than to prevent poor haircuts.
“I think I has a lot more to do with disease and sanitation”
Her salon pays a monthly team bonus, set as a percentage of total monthly sales once a financial goal is met, and every full-time employee, including shampoo assistants and the front desk, receives the same bonus, so the whole team stays aligned.
“we have a financial goal every month and each time that we meet that financial goal everybody in the business is going to get a bonus... everyone's in on it... the bonus is a percentage of total sales for the month”
Her salon does not pay the same salary to everyone; more productive stylists earn more, but the team bonus is equal across full-time staff, which she argues is fair because everyone contributes significantly.
“does everybody get the same salary absolutely not... so the best stylist you're gonna pay a little bit more to keep them”
Biweekly Tuesday workshops, where senior and junior staff practice new techniques on mannequins and each other, have improved Abdallah's own skill after 21 years in the business and keep the work fresh.
“we have bi-weekly workshops where on Tuesdays we meet and the senior and junior staff and we have to try different techniques... I have improved my skills tremendously by holding these workshops”
A guaranteed salary enables senior stylists to mentor newer stylists, which creates recognition for experienced stylists and builds a stronger team than commission would allow.
“it also enabled a busy stylist has been in the business a while to do is to mentor the kind of stylists that are coming up in the business”
Having several team members interview candidates rather than the owner alone produces better hiring results, because team members ask questions the owner misses and notice things the owner does not.
“I have found that to be much better than just me interviewing... I had you know some of the team make observations that I completely missed and so I find by getting more of the team involved in the interviewing process we have greater success”
Modern women want low-maintenance hair rather than the 1970s-style sets, so stylists must learn cutting techniques that make hair look good with little effort.
“women are much more natural now and they don't want to work that hard on their hair and so what we're learning the techniques... how to create a look so that they have to do very little”
In a traditional salon with ten operators, only about 50% productivity is common, meaning two or three stylists are overbooked while the rest are about 40% busy and sitting idle.
“you may have let's say ten operators your productivity means the hours that you're selling for service is maybe under average 50%... two to three stylists who are really producing... seven stylists who are maybe 40% busy”
Her salon uses a level system tied to productivity rate and pre-booking rate, along with attitude and contribution to the team, and these determine how staff advance from level one to level two.
“we actually have a broadband that tells you how do you get from level 1 to level 2... what's your productivity rate what's your pre booking rate those are the critical numbers we look at but also what's your attitude”
Abdallah argues that stylists who are not busy can be given other work such as promotions, redecorating, and retail, and that in a small salon the owner can easily see when someone is loafing or distracting others.
“those stylists that aren't busy we have them doing a lot of other things... in a small space... you see it you can always observe that”
Under a salary structure, the owner can shift work from overbooked top stylists to others, so guaranteed quality is maintained while the owner stops having to squeeze every possible client into her own schedule.
“it becomes less about me squeezing everyone that I possibly can in and more about guaranteeing the quality of the service”
Top stylists are paid more than others, but not because of their chair output: pay differences come from a career-level system that rewards productivity rate, pre-booking rate, attitude, and team contribution, not just what is produced in the chair.
“it's not all about what you're producing in your chair a lot of it is you know what's your productivity rate what's your pre booking rate”
Her salon's women's haircut price of 'from $65' was set by researching comparable local salons and pricing about $5 below them, while the stated minimum leaves room to charge more for thick, tightly curled, or time-intensive hair.
“we actually researched our area and we looked at salons that are comparable to ours and we tried to stay a little bit less than that about five dollars less”
Stylist earnings under commission average about $30,000 to $35,000 per year and stay flat for a long time, while a top stylist in a good salon can earn $80,000 or more, excluding tips.
“the average traditionally under Commission is about 30 35 thousand and they're kind of stuck there for a long time and then a superstar can make anywhere from 80,000 up”
During the 2008 downturn, Abdallah's salon grew about 20% because people shifted from premium products, such as 15-to-20-dollar deep conditioning and large shampoo bottles, to smaller purchases, but the business still expanded.
“the economy I think for about six months affected what we call up... we grew 20% Wow you're doing something right for sure”
Commission-based salons create cutthroat competition in which stylists guard their core clients jealously and may try to take customers from each other, which is destructive to the salon.
“you're very jealous of people stealing your customers within the bit within the salon which is very destructive”
Her salon buys 100% wind-powered electricity through a provider that matches its consumption with wind power generated on the grid, which Montgomery County rewards with a tax incentive, though the mechanism is hard to verify as physical power.
“whatever we use in electricity they equally will buy the wind power and so it offset... Montgomery County does give us a tax incentive”
Hiring in service businesses is a crapshoot: candidates can present themselves well and then turn out poorly on the first day, so the practical response is to address problems quickly.
“I think everyone comes to the same conclusion it is a total crapshoot”
Sanitation is the main regulatory concern for salons, since the state board inspects randomly for bacteria, fungus, and disease transmission, and one missed sanitation lapse can spread to many clients.
“sanitation is a huge one in our business... you mess one person up that way it's all over”
A cosmetology license serves as a signal that separates dedicated, educated practitioners from those who cannot pass a difficult test, even though the exam is not the main reason licensing exists.
“being able to get through a difficult test and passing will set people apart from those who can't”
Stylists' technique depends more on how they hold and cut with shears than on style trends, and Abdallah's Vidal Sassoon training in London, which she says roughly doubled her business, was about technique rather than fashion.
“my number soared once I went to Vidal Sassoon in London... it really wasn't so much style as much as technique”
When a competitor opened in her shopping center, her salon required staff to wish it well, on the principle that its success does not depend on the other's failure and that negative energy comes back to the sender.
“we weren't allowed to say negative things about it we had to wish them well because what I said to them is our success does not depend on their failure”
A stylist's professional shears can cost $500 to $600 for a good pair, and Abdallah owns three pairs, sends hers to Hikari in California for sharpening, and says cheap scissors cannot produce good haircuts.
“I've got personally I think three I just bought a new pair good ones about five to six hundred dollars... you can't do a good haircut with bags”
In a typical salon in the Washington-area market, stylists are paid about 50% commission, and the owner takes an additional 8 to 10 percent off the top for product and supply fees.
“usually it's 50% Commission and then somehow the owner will figure out a way to take money back for supplies... maybe anywhere from eight to ten percent off the top”
The salon avoids gossip by requiring direct talk, and being available means being willing to hear problems that others bring to you.
“we have no gossip we have to use direct talk and being available means when someone has issue that they bring to your attention are you available to hear it”
Cosmetology school prepares graduates only to pass the state board licensing exam and provides essentially no guidance on how to build a career once they start working in salons.
“after a cosmetology school they really only prepare you to pass the State Board Exam”
References are rarely useful in hair styling because stylists leaving a salon do not tell their owner, so her salon mainly hires people who are new to the area or just out of beauty school, for whom references can be checked.
“in this business you almost can't do that or not know because if they're getting ready to leave a salon they're not telling their owner”
Her salon requires employees to read specific books, including The Alchemist and The Five Dysfunctions of a Team, and every meeting asks what each person is reading and what they took from it, which she considers unusual for salons.
“part of our requirement for working in our salon is that you have to read certain books... every meeting is what are you reading what have you gotten out of it”
Roberts suggests that licensing requirements may screen for drive and dedication, and Abdallah agrees that passing a difficult test sets people apart from those who cannot pass, though she emphasizes the disease-control rationale more.
“being able to get through a difficult test and passing will set people apart from those who can't”
Her salon gathers client feedback through a survey given to first-time clients asking what they look for in a salon, their first impression, and why they left their last stylist, and reviews the surveys at every meeting.
“when people come in for the first time we give them a small survey and a letter about our salon... why did you leave your last stylist every meeting we go over these surveys”
Amenities such as tea, food, and music are chosen by listening to clients and by making the workplace enjoyable for staff, because an enjoyable staff atmosphere carries over to clients.
“if we're enjoying our atmosphere in our culture they're gonna enjoy it”
Abdallah reports that the salon is not only required to hold educational events but brings education in every six weeks, and she has attended at least six educational events every year since she started.
“there has not been a year that goes by where I'm not at least getting six educational events”
Her salon collects a 10% tanning tax that it passes on to clients after the state implemented it on July 1, and she inherited four tanning rooms that she expects to close.
“as of July first there was a 10% tanning tax that we had to implement we pass it on to the client”
Roberts argues that a salary-based salon structure should be evaluated against commission as an incentive design, noting that a salary structure can reduce owner upside, which Abdallah answers by saying owners gain from higher total productivity and sales.
“but that sounds like a bad deal for the owner now”
Her salon holds five-minute daily huddles to inspire staff and review goals, and monthly meetings of roughly 90 to 120 minutes where the critical numbers, SWOT analysis, and team challenges are discussed, with the owner talking less over time.
“we do have daily Huddle's which are kind of pre day meeting... maybe five minutes... and then we have monthly meetings... about an hour and a half to two”
Her salon teaches new stylists the business first (answering phones, booking, tracking the critical numbers), then shampooing and guest relations, and only then curly-hair technique, so that new hires can assist busier stylists immediately.
“first we teach them the business so we teach them about the task answering phones making appointments how to get the numbers... then we get into the skills”
Her salon's prices are disclosed as 'from' amounts and discussed in the consultation beforehand, because customers should not face a surprise at the counter, and misrepresenting a base price would be dishonest.
“if we say that the price absolutely 65 then we're going to be misrepresenting the facts... we tell people ahead of time”
A client who received an unexpectedly short haircut burst into tears, and the salon now uses structured consultations, including active listening and roleplay, to reduce the chance of such mismatches.
“that's something the we script and really work on is consultation... if you have a good consultation you have 99% reduce your chances”
The two things that most separate a superb stylist from a good one are continual education and a positive attitude, since clients want to be around positive energy and avoid negative energy.
“I think there's really two things one is the ability to continue growing in your education never stop learning... and who is your attitude”
Her salon's diverse, international staff, from Kenya, Ethiopia, Colombia, and Yemen, reflects the Washington DC area, where many people come from elsewhere and speak different languages, and she considers that diversity a strength.
“we live in the Washington DC area and every other person is from somewhere else... it's so nice to be in a place where everyone celebrates different holidays and speaks different languages”
Her salon requires entry-level and level-one and level-two candidates to pass two or three scripted interviews, with scripts that cover experience, punctuality, dress, eye contact, and whether a cell phone is used during the interview.
“people in the beginning at level one and level two are required to do secondary interviews... we script it... what time did they come in how are they dressed how's their eye contact was their cell phone on”
Her salon offers a two-week free service guarantee so clients can return for adjustments, though only a small percentage actually do.
“we give it two week service guarantee that you can come back free of charge for anything to be tweaked... it's not a large percentage but it does happen”
Early in her ownership, the monthly meetings were mostly the owner talking; she committed to talking less, and the split became roughly 50/50.
“in the beginning it was mostly me talking... each meeting I promised myself that I'm gonna talk less and so now it's maybe 50/50”
Abdallah's clientele and revenue rose sharply after she trained at Vidal Sassoon in London about ten to twelve years ago, which she saw as confirmation that successful stylists invest in that training.
“my number soared once I went to Vidal Sassoon in London”
Abdallah estimates that about 80% of successful stylist training is technique and the rest is customer service, and in her business there is no option to give less than full effort.
“I'd say 80% because it you know it's a hundred percent for everything it's a hundred percent customer service it's a hundred percent technique”
Abdallah chose cosmetology over law school because, while supporting herself in college, she realized the beauty industry let her earn a solid income quickly, and once she saw what successful hairdressers could make she decided to stay in the field instead of going to law school.
“once I was in the beauty industry and I saw what successful hairdressers could make I thought no way I'm staying right here”
Her salon's SWOT-style monthly meetings and team discussions of threats show that the salon is one of three hair salons in its small shopping center, with two more across the road and three more in another nearby center.
“we're one of three hair salons... in the shopping center across blue Parkway there's another two and in the shopping center that you know across Edmundston there's another three”
Abdallah works about 32 hours a week cutting hair while handling business administration, and she was a stylist for 21 years.
“roughly about 32 and the rest of the time you are keeping track of everything else”
Abdallah reports that the salon's success does not depend on putting down a competitor's staff, and she describes the salon as a place people want to be.
“everyone that walks in the door says the energy in here is great”