YouTube12m· Aug 2023· cataloged

Ken Burns on why the Republican Party completely changed | The Warning Podcast with Steve Schmidt


What this covers

This is a short conversation in which Ken Burns talks with Steve Schmidt about what happened to the Republican Party and what citizens owe the country now. Burns places himself as someone from a moderate Republican tradition in New Jersey. He also says he has been on both sides of the concession transaction, having helped arrange John McCain's call to Obama on election night 2008. He recalls forbidding Sarah Palin from speaking that night because he expected her to desecrate the moment. The party's origins give the contrast: founded in 1854 against the slave-holding oligarchy, he says, its mission has "all been switched."

The middle of the talk is about history as a way to hold complexity. Burns raises the hypocrisy of the founding, including slaveholders who complained of enslavement by George III and Thomas Jefferson writing "all men are created equal." He also notes that Black Americans in the Revolutionary era sometimes sided with the British, who promised freedom, at times cynically. He argues the founding ideals are still worth preserving. He mentions a neon sign in his editing room reading "it's complicated," and the lesson he draws from his Holocaust and Civil War films: "there's only us."

The sharpest turns concern cowardice and expediency. Burns calls the failure to confront extremism a new phenomenon in American culture, and he links it to political expediency and to a "what's in it for me" mentality that he ties to Marshall McLuhan and media proliferation. He compares today's enablers to the 1932 Berlin conservatives who thought Adolf Hitler could be controlled. He credits Liz Cheney, Adam Kinzinger and David Jolly but says there are too few like them. He describes the Proud Boys as an Americanized SA (Stormtroops)) and says Americans resist taking such groups literally. He says he may have understated the danger, and that he does not know whether democratic institutions will hold.

Sharpest takeaway

Ken Burns argues that the American experiment's foundational ideals of liberty and equality are under unprecedented threat from authoritarianism and political cowardice, requiring citizens to actively preserve democratic institutions and constitutional principles or risk repeating historical fascist patterns.

  • The U.S. represents 'the most important event since the birth of Christ' and a light that must be preserved despite its historical contradictions
  • Modern political leaders have systematically abandoned principles for expedience, mirroring how conservatives empowered Hitler by believing they could control him
  • Cowardice in confronting extremism is a new phenomenon in American culture, driven by short-term power consolidation rather than constitutional fidelity

The claims · ranked24 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.84

The contradictions in the American founding—slave owners claiming enslavement by George III, Jefferson writing 'all men are created equal' while owning hundreds of enslaved people—represent hypocrisy that must be acknowledged and worked through rather than ignored, because the underlying ideals still represent a light worth preserving

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Ken Burns

“slave owners talking about how George III is enslaving them right Thomas Jefferson writing these Immortal words we hope these truth to be self-evident that all men are created equal and he owns hundreds of human beings and doesn't see that contradiction or that hypocrisy we still represent a light that we have to actually at this moment preserve”

0.81

The contemporary moment requires citizens to 'constantly remind ourselves of our history with all its complexity' and 'speak to our brothers and sisters in a way that reminds them of the seriousness of this moment that the law does matter that these are not minor things'

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Ken Burns

“we have to just constantly remind ourselves of our history with all its complexity and I have in my editing room this neon sign that says it's complicated you know because there's not a filmmaker on Earth if the scene's working you want to leave it alone but no we open those things up when we learn new and contradictory information and we have to go forward finding some way where we can speak to our our brothers and sisters in a way that reminds them of the seriousness of this moment that the law does matter that these are not minor things”

0.80

Despite the prominence of cowardice in contemporary politics, there are striking historical examples of American courage—including that Native Americans suffered 'proportionally the greatest number of casualties in the Vietnam War' while still serving, contrasting with political leaders' abdication of responsibility

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Ken Burns

“a history as you're suggesting and implying that is so filled with moments of Courage including by the way the group of people people who suffered proportionally the greatest number of casualties in the Vietnam War Native Americans Native Americans right”

0.80

The Republican Party founded in 1854 'had as one of its principal things the emancipation of the black man the elimination of the oligarchy the domination of the very rich is represented by the plantation no aristocracy in America out of the ashes of the Whig party' but this mission 'has all been switched' to supporting the opposite

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Ken Burns

“the switch of the party that was founded in 1854 which had as one of its principal things the emancipation of the black man the elimination of the oligarchy the domination of the very rich is represented by the plantation no aristocracy in America out of the ashes of the Whig party we're going to form this thing and we're going to support small farmers and small businessmen and African Americans as they live out the full meaning of our Creed as Dr King said that's all been switched that's all been switched around”

0.80

Burns forbade Sarah Palin from speaking on election night 2008 after Obama's victory because she 'wanted to go out and desecrate the moment which she certainly would have'

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Ken Burns

“it's also why forbade Sarah Palin to speak who wanted to go out and desecrate the moment which she certainly would have um even as the president-elect was speaking”

0.78

The American Revolution represented a liberation of humanity to 'the next stage of our rocket from where it had been heretofore,' and this principle—not the historical exceptions or contradictions—must be what we remember and preserve in the current crisis

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Ken Burns

“at the heart of this is the most noble experiment in the most noble aspirations of humankind that liberated it like the next stage of our rocket from where it had been heretofore and that's what we are required now particularly in this grave crisis we're in to remember and to try to save”

0.78

The fundamental lesson of Burns' work—particularly films on the Holocaust and the Civil War—is that 'there's only us there's no them and whenever anyone tells you there's a them just run away'

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Ken Burns

“the lesson of my work is that there's only us there's no them and whenever anyone tells you there's a them just run away I mean there's no them it's only us”

0.76

Black Americans during the Revolutionary era 'wanted to side with the British because they saw a clearer path to freedom and Liberation,' though the British sometimes made these promises 'cynically'

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Ken Burns

“the fact that more black Americans wanted to side with the British because they saw a clearer path to freedom and Liberation sometimes cynically promised by the Brits”

0.75

Blind adherence to personality rather than principle or policy has replaced traditional political party organization and represents a fundamental failure of democratic practice: 'it's just a kind of blind adherence to personality and and that doesn't make for a political party and it doesn't make for the future of a democracy'

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ken Burns

“there are no policies that go along with it it's just a kind of blind adherence to personality and and that doesn't make for a political party and it doesn't make for the future of a democracy”

0.74

The 1932 case of Berlin offers a historical parallel: conservative elites believing they could control Hitler ('in six months he will be singing our tune') were proven catastrophically wrong within a year when 'they were dead or marginalized or you know complete Toadies'

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Ken Burns

“if you wanted to be in the hippest place on Earth where everything is happening in cinema and in architecture and in painting and in music in 1932 there's no better place to go than than Berlin and the next year not so much the people who permitted him though he had nowhere near a majority of votes not even a significant plurality the conservatives who put him in saying in six months he will be singing our tune in six months they were dead or marginalized or you know complete Toadies”

0.74

The behavior of taking short-term rewards over long-term benefits—what Jefferson called being 'disposed to suffer while Evils are sufferable'—is deeply rooted in human nature, exemplified by the child who takes one M&M rather than waiting for three, and this explains contemporary political actors' abandonment of principle

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Ken Burns

“this is not new in human existence the the ability to to take an expedient route that that speaks to some sort of short-term game is basically what Jefferson was talking about when he said we're disposed to suffer while Evils are sufferable we'll we'll take that short-term reward the kid who'll take the one Eminem and not wait for the 15 minutes for the three”

0.71

Modern political culture is characterized by a 'what's in it for me' mentality driven by media proliferation—echoing McLuhan's 'the medium is the message'—where everyone is an 'independent free agent' with insufficient focus on collective responsibility to the country

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ken Burns

“there is something about the proliferation of media like the dangers in um you know Fantasia of Mickey Mouse and The Sorcerer's Apprentice of all that stuff all those places everybody's an independent free agent and it's now what's in it for me and there's not enough about what I can do as Kennedy out challenge for our country”

0.69

Political cowardice is 'motivated by political expediency and that means power and holding on to it and not upholding the oath that you've taken'—a prioritization of institutional power over constitutional fidelity

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ken Burns

“cowardice is exactly the word obviously it's motivated by political expediency and that means power and holding on to it and not upholding the oath that you've taken”

0.68

Burns has been uniquely positioned to understand political transitions because he is 'one of a very very small number of living Americans that have been deeply involved on both sides of the concession transaction on The Winning Side,' having coordinated John McCain's call to Barack Obama on election night 2008

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Ken Burns

“I'm one of a very very small number of living Americans that have been deeply involved on both sides of the concession transaction on The Winning Side and I placed the phone call for for John McCain to Barack Obama uh he became the first person to say the following words congratulations Mr president-elect God bless you sir”

0.66

In the current political era, 'with a handful of exceptions and by handful I mean literally I can count them on a hand, every single person I ever worked with' in government responsibility 'abandoned everything that they said that they believed in and they got in line as fast as any group of people anywhere in the world have ever gotten in line behind something they knew to be wrong for their convenience'

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Ken Burns

“every single person I ever worked with in a in a business that ultimately if you are are invested with any type of government responsibility you taken of yes every single person I've ever known and ever work with abandoned everything that they said that they believed in and they got in line as fast as any group of people anywhere in the world have ever gotten in line behind something they knew to be wrong for their convenience”

0.66

The core problem is 'cowardice in confronting' extremism and authoritarianism, which Burns describes as 'a new phenomenon' in American political culture—unlike historical examples of American courage in confronting challenges

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Ken Burns

“whatever you say about the country cowardice in confronting some of this stuff has never been top of the list it's a new phenomenon and I'm not sure I understand what drives it”

0.64

Examples of political courage do exist (citing Liz Cheney, Adam Kinzinger, David Jolly), but 'they're not enough of them'—suggesting a systemic failure of moral leadership in contemporary politics

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ken Burns

“the extraordinary examples of courage and when they stand out they're in Broad relief but they're not enough of them they're not enough Liz Chinese they're not enough Adam kinzingers they're not enough you or others who have just said you know David Jolly who just says you know I'm I can't associate myself with this set of of actions”

0.63

American culture has developed an 'allergy' to taking extremist movements literally and seriously, exemplified by widespread disorientation about what the Proud Boys actually are—a fascist paramilitary organization equivalent to an Americanized 21st-century SA (Stormtroops)

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Ken Burns

“there's an allergy for some reason in our culture to take what the extremist movement says both literally and seriously case and point to the proud boy Stand By and stand back there seemed to be a real disorientation around what it is that a proud boy is which is a fascist paramilitary they are a version Americanized 21st centuryized of the SA”

0.59

The birth of the United States is the most important event since the birth of Christ

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Ken Burns

“the birth of the United States is the most important event since the the birth of Christ and I believe that in all my heart”

0.59

Burns has an 'editing room' with a neon sign that reads 'it's complicated' because filmmakers must continuously revise scenes when new and contradictory information emerges, reflecting the necessity of holding complexity rather than seeking simplification

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Ken Burns

“I have in my editing room this neon sign that says it's complicated you know because there's not a filmmaker on Earth if the scene's working you want to leave it alone but no we open those things up when we learn new and contradictory information and we have to go forward”

0.45

Burns has been accused of being hyperbolic about the nature of the political threat, but he believes he has actually been understated, not overstated, in his warnings

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ken Burns

“I have been accused of being hyperbolic about the nature of the threat I don't think I have been I think I've been understated if anything”

0.45

Burns states 'I don't know the answer' to whether America will successfully defend its democratic institutions in this crisis, but 'we can't' afford to fail—establishing that the outcome is uncertain and depends on citizen action

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ken Burns

“it really remains to be seen particularly today as as we are recording this um how we will how we will come out I don't I don't know the answer but I know that we can't you know now now is the time as the old typing thing goes for all good Patriots to come to the aid of their country”

0.34

Burns previously made a documentary called 'The U.S. and the Holocaust,' which is 'a very difficult a a work of Genius of profound importance and relevance' that 'will endure for Generations'

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Ken Burns on why the Republican Party completely changed | … [zW-T7AoKxrI]

“my film before the Buffalo was one called the U.S and the Holocaust a very difficult a a work of Genius of profound importance and relevance and you honor the memory of the Dead with that work and your country's history with it and I hope it gives you deep satisfaction that it will endure for Generations”

0.24

Burns came from 'a moderate Republican tradition' in New Jersey, establishing his political background as center-right rather than leftist

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Ken Burns

“I came from New Jersey a moderate Republican tradition”