What this covers

This is a solo episode of Brent Johnson's Milkshakes, Markets and Madness (episode 113), and it works as a primer on why the framework matters rather than a market update. Brent Johnson argues that knowing the mechanics of the monetary system gives a listener an Independent Analytical Framework. Without one, he says, you tend to believe whichever informed person you spoke to last. He also pitches the framework as preparation, so that people already have a frame of reference when a crisis arrives and don't have to improvise during it. The publisher's description adds a short look at US equities after a break below key support, and whether that points to a bounce or further decline.

The historical and mechanical material starts with 1971, when gold backing was removed from the dollar. Johnson says the world then doubled down on dollars, helped by the oil-pricing arrangement with Saudi Arabia. From there he turns to the carry trade: borrowing in a foreign currency that then surges against your own leaves you "upside down" quickly. He claims nearly every crisis of the past 40 to 60 years involved currency divergence or carry trades gone wrong, a claim flagged as contested. His 2022 examples are the Bank of England, the ECB, and the Bank of Japan each stepping into their bond markets, along with a tailspin in China.

Some of the more distinctive points are practical. Americans think in only one currency, while everyone else lives with continuous currency risk. Gold has fallen in every liquidity crisis since the 1970s, so a 100% gold holder with no other income could be forced to sell at the lows. Johnson also explains the cleanest dirty shirt, his argument for preferring the least-bad fiat currency. He closes by noting gold's move to $3,000 and expecting US outperformance to continue, with sharp drawdowns along the way.

Sharpest takeaway

The Dollar Milkshake theory explains how the global monetary system's dependence on the US dollar creates predictable investment outcomes—stronger dollar, rising US equities, rising gold, and rising interest rates—and understanding this framework is essential for portfolio construction and navigating future financial crises.

  • The dollar milkshake predicted dollar strength, rising US equities, rising gold, and rising interest rates—all have materialized despite predictions to the contrary
  • Understanding the dollar's role in the global monetary system allows investors to make independent decisions rather than being 'pinballed around' by conflicting expert opinions
  • Dollar strength is the catalyst for asset class performance, and relative dollar strength matters because every major financial crisis in 40-60 years involved either currency divergence or carry trade reversals

The claims · ranked57 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

Americans have a unique advantage in that they only have to think in one currency (the dollar) and never have to worry about currency hedging, whereas people outside the United States constantly operate with two, three, or four currencies and face continuous currency risk that Americans take for granted.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“the fact that you wake up every morning and only have to think in one currency you've taken it for granted your whole life but it is an extreme blessing everybody else all over the world other than the United States thinks in at least two currencies and probably two or three or four currencies”

0.80

Understanding how monetary and financial systems actually work provides knowledge that is power and helps investors make better decisions, while also allowing them to develop their own analytical framework rather than being dependent on whichever expert they spoke to most recently.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“anytime you understand how things work and understand accurately how it works rather than just some other you know an idea of how it might work when you actually understand how something works I think knowledge is power and that can help you make better decisions the other reason I think it's important is because by understanding the mechanics of how the system works it allows you to come up with your own opinion and it allows you to analyze things for yourself”

0.80

The constant dependency on the last smart expert you spoke to creates a vulnerability where you will believe whichever informed person you most recently interacted with, regardless of conflicting information, unless you have your own fundamental analytical framework to evaluate claims.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“if you don't have a fundamental base of your own or a fundamental view of your own or your own framework of how to analyze things then you are constantly going to be pinballed around and around and around based on every conversation you have with somebody smart who does have an opinion and your opinion is probably going to be based on the last smart person you spoke”

0.80

Even if someone holds 100% of their portfolio in gold as a long-term store of value, they are vulnerable during liquidity crises because gold historically falls during every liquidity crisis since the 1970s, forcing them to liquidate gold at the lows if they have no other liquid income source.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“if you have 100% of your portfolio in Gold well if that happens and then we get into a liquidity crisis in every liquid crisis that we have had since the 1970s gold has fallen...if you don't have any other source of income and you don't have any other part of your portfolio that is liquid or that you can draw on to either pay your bills...then you would have to liquidate some of that 100% portfolio of gold at the lows”

0.74

The speaker's goal is to help people get a frame of reference and framework to use during challenging times ahead, so they are prepared during the crisis rather than trying to figure everything out in the heat of the moment.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“we are going to have some very challenging days ahead of us and I think it's important to prepare for that...when you get into it you're a little bit ready for it rather than trying to figure it all out in the heat of the battle”

0.74

Financial crises have far-reaching impacts beyond investment portfolios: they affect employment (job losses, reduced raises, reduced hours), businesses (bankruptcies), and social policy (bailout laws, lockdowns to prevent chaos), making them relevant even to people who don't consider themselves investors.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“maybe it affects their job maybe they don't get that raise they were going to get maybe they get laid off or maybe they get their work hours cut maybe their job disappears altogether maybe businesses go out of out of business...maybe countries go into crisis and you know they have to you know in Institute new bailout laws or or or Institute you know new new new Society lock Downs”

0.70

When you borrow in a currency that is not your home currency and that currency rises dramatically against your home currency, you become 'upside down very quickly'

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“when you borrow in one currency that's not your home currency and then it rises dramatically against your currency all of a sudden you're upside down very quickly”

0.70

The dollar underlies the entire global monetary system and global economy, and despite the gold backing being removed from the dollar in 1971, the world doubled down on using dollars because of the petrodollar agreement struck with Saudi Arabia, which required all nations to hold dollars to purchase oil and energy.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“the dollar underlies the entire global economy the entire Global monetary system is levered off of the dollar it started out as a dollar that was backed by gold and then that backing was removed instead of the world rejecting the dollar they doubled down on it and the reason they doubled down on it is because at about the same time the United States removed the gold backing from the dollar they struck this agreement with Saudi Arabia who agreed to price their oil in dollars”

0.69

In 2022, the dollar's strength directly caused financial crises in multiple countries: the Bank of England had to bail out its bond market, the ECB had to bail out the Italian bond market, the Bank of Japan had to bail out the JGB market, and China entered a tailspin from their real estate and equity market collapse—all direct consequences of dollar strengthening.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“also in 2022 you know we've talked about this many many times but in that year the bank of England had to bail out its bond market the ECB had to bail out the Italian bond market the bank of Japan had to bail out the jgb market and China started to go in their tail spin from their real estate and Equity Market that is all the direct consequence of the dollar getting stronger”

0.69

Understanding accurate mechanics of how the monetary system works—rather than holding unexamined conventional opinions—is essential because it allows investors to develop an independent analytical framework and avoid being 'pinballed around' by the most recent expert opinion they encounter.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“when you actually understand how something works I think knowledge is power and that can help you make better decisions... by understanding ing the mechanics of how the system works it allows you to come up with your own opinion and it allows you to analyze things for yourself and it allows you to kind of come to conclusions for yourself and the reason that is important is because if you don't have a fundamental base of your own or a fundamental view of your own or your own framework of how to analyze things then you are constantly going to be pinballed around and around and around based on every conversation you have with somebody smart who does have an opinion”

0.69

The dollar underlies the entire global economy and monetary system; the global monetary system is levered off the dollar because when the US removed the gold backing from the dollar, the world doubled down on it rather than rejecting it, particularly after the US struck an agreement with Saudi Arabia to price oil in dollars.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“the dollar underlies the entire global economy the entire Global monetary system is levered off of the dollar it started out as a dollar that was backed by gold and then that backing was removed instead of the world rejecting the dollar they doubled down on it and the reason they doubled down on it is because at about the same time the United States removed the gold backing from the dollar they struck this agreement with Saudi Arabia who agreed to price their oil in dollars”

0.69

Getting the dollar wrong in your analysis makes it very hard to get everything else right, particularly if your business or portfolio is exposed to dollars, because the dollar affects all downstream asset prices and economic outcomes.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“it is very very hard to get every to get the dollar completely wrong and then get everything else right... if you get the dollar wrong your portfolio or your business especially if your business is exposed to dollars is going to be affected”

0.69

During liquidity crises, gold falls significantly even though it recovers faster and to higher levels afterward, so if someone owns 100% gold with no other income sources, they would be forced to liquidate at the lows during a crisis, making diversification essential.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“in every liquid crisis that we have had since the 1970s gold has fallen now does it recover yes does it recover faster than everything else yes does it then go on to even higher highs yes... if you don't have any other source of income and you don't have any other part of your portfolio that is liquid or that you can draw on to either pay your bills or live your life or operate your business then you would have to liquidate some of that 100% portfolio of gold at the lows”

0.66

Americans are extremely lucky to only think in one currency (dollars), while people everywhere else in the world must think in at least two, three, or four currencies simultaneously, making dollar volatility a constant concern for non-US investors.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“you as an American are extremely lucky the fact that you wake up every morning and only have to think in one currency you've taken it for granted your whole life but it is an extreme blessing everybody else all over the world other than the United States thinks in at least two currencies and probably two or three or four currencies and so it's an incredible blessing to not have to constantly think in two or different two or three different currency”

0.66

Financial crises have far-reaching impacts beyond investment portfolios: they affect employment (raises might not materialize, people get laid off or hours cut), business survival, and can force governments to institute new laws, lockdowns, or bailouts to prevent chaos.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“for just about everybody else a financial crisis will affect them maybe it affects their job maybe they don't get that raise they were going to get maybe they get laid off or maybe they get their work hours cut maybe their job disappears altogether maybe businesses go out of out of business and then investment portolos get affected maybe countries go into crisis and you know they have to you know in Institute new bailout laws or or or Institute you know social new new new Society lock Downs in order to prevent further you know chaos”

0.64

Over the last five to six years, the US has wildly outperformed the rest of the world, with money flowing into the US exactly as the dollar milkshake predicted, and this outperformance will likely continue and intensify in the endgame.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“all you have to do is look at the chart to see that over the last five or six years the US has wildly outperformed the rest of the world that's just a fact the money has flowed here just as the milkshake predicted and I think that that will continue and I think in the endgame it'll play out even more than it has played out already”

0.63

There will be dramatic drawdowns and volatile periods ahead, but these are expected within the framework; the key is to prepare mentally and strategically in advance so that when crises hit, investors are ready rather than panicking in the moment.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“will there be points along the way where that doesn't happen will there be points in time where money leaves the US for short periods of time or will the US Stock Market fall from you know and have the have these dramatic draw Downs on away absolutely it will this is not going to be easy this is the other thing why it's important it's important to understand that we are going to have some very challenging days ahead of us and I think it's important to prepare for that and I think it's important to prepare for it ahead of time and so that when you get into it you're a little bit ready for it rather than trying to figure it all out in the heat of the battle”

0.63

Carry trades are a consistent crisis mechanism: when investors borrow in a currency that is not their home currency and that currency rises dramatically against their currency, they become 'upside down' (negative equity) very quickly.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“when you borrow in one currency that's not your home currency and then it rises dramatically against your currency all of a sudden you're upside down very quickly”

0.62

Nearly every financial crisis of the past 40-60 years was either caused by or exacerbated by one fiat currency rising dramatically versus another, or involved carry trades gone wrong

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“every financial crisis of the last 40 50 60 years virtually all of them now there you can somebody can probably find an exception but in general the reason it's important is every one of these crisis was either caused by or exacerbated by one fiat currency Rising dramatically versus another one or it had some element of a carry trade gone wrong”

0.56

Understanding dollar dynamics and how the dollar system reacts under stress is fundamentally important to understanding where the world is headed and how crises will unfold, making it nearly impossible to get the dollar wrong and still get everything else right in investment or business planning.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“I think understanding how the dollar system works and how it reacts under certain circumstances and how the ingame regarding the dollar could play out is fundamentally important to understanding where the world is headed...it is very very hard to get every to get the dollar completely wrong and then get everything else right”

0.52

The dollar milkshake is fundamentally a framework for explaining how the monetary system works and why it functions the way it does, specifically predicting that despite monetary stimulus and arguments to the contrary, the dollar would strengthen versus peer currencies while asset prices would simultaneously rise.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“the dollar milkshake is really a way of explaining how the monetary system works and why it works the way that it works...what it is is it says that in the years ahead the dollar would get a lot stronger versus its peer currencies despite all the arguments to the contrary and that even though the dollar was going to get stronger that wouldn't necessarily mean that asset prices crashed”

0.50

Gold hit $3,000 per ounce this last week, becoming the best-performing asset since the speaker first started talking about the dollar milkshake in 2018, outperforming both equities and other asset classes.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“gold hit $3,000 this last week and as I showed earlier um you know gold uh is the best performing asset since I first started talking about the milkshake back in 2018”

0.50

The concept of holding 'the cleanest dirty shirt'—preferring the least-bad fiat currency (the dollar) over worse alternatives—is important because during rare liquidity crises, the cleanest dirty shirt becomes effectively pristine and can be used productively, whereas the dirtiest shirts are unusable.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“you want to own the cleanest dirty shirt...if I have to choose between dirty shirts I'm picking the cleanest dirty shirt...in those rare occasions where we get these liquidity crisis not only that dirty shirt all of a sudden becomes pristine and you can use that to to to help out in in in many many ways”

0.49

The dollar milkshake framework predicts that despite a stronger dollar, US equities would rise, gold would rise, interest rates would rise, and bonds would fall, creating measurable investment outcomes across multiple asset classes simultaneously.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“the dollar milkshake is really a way of explaining how the monetary system works and why it works the way that it works... what it is is it says that in the year years ahead the dollar would get a lot stronger versus its peer currencies despite all the arguments to the contrary and that even though the dollar was going to get stronger that wouldn't necessarily mean that asset prices crashed... when I very first started talking about it I said while the dollar would get stronger despite all the objections to the contrary it would actually make us equities go higher as well and it would make gold go higher as well interest rates would rise and bonds would fall”

0.49

The dollar milkshake theory explains that the US is relatively a pretty good place to be even though the endgame will be bad, so investors should not be forced into emerging market stocks or 100% gold; instead they should remain partially invested in US equities and dollars.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“I think the whole milkshake theory for one has tried to explain that even though this is probably all going to end really badly the US on a relative place or a relative basis is a pretty good place to be so if you're trying to decide where to allocate your portfolio even if it's just a small 401K you don't have to load up on emerging market stocks you know you don't have to put 100% of your portfolio in Gold it's it's okay to have some of these things”

0.48

The alternative media and alternative investing space often advocate for exiting the US, claiming the empire is crumbling and the dollar will collapse, recommending emerging market stocks and commodities instead—but this misses the relative strength dynamic the dollar milkshake predicts.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“I think it's important because I think a lot of times the alternative media the alternative investing space will say you have to get out of the United States it's an Empire ready to crumble the dollar is going to collapse you have to get out of it you're better off if you buy these Emerging Market companies who have come from commodity producing countries and you don't want to be exposed to all the debt in the United States”

0.48

The optimal portfolio allocation strategy for the dollar milkshake is: diversification across four asset classes: (1) cash in dollars, (2) gold in physical form, (3) US equities (not overseas risky stocks), and (4) real estate (rental properties, home ownership, or farmland), which together should allow survival of most scenarios.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“it would mean that you should be Diversified you should have some cash and that cash should be in dollars you should have some gold and that gold should be in physical form...you should have some exposure to the equity market...I think it should be to us equities...and then I think everybody should also have um you know probably some form of real estate...if you have those four Investments you're kind of ready for anything”

0.48

In liquidity crises, the cleanest dirty shirt (US dollar) becomes pristine and useful, making dollar allocation essential as a crisis hedge even though fiat currencies are fundamentally degrading in value long-term.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“in those rare occasions where we get these liquidity crisis not only that dirty shirt all of a sudden becomes pristine and you can use that to to to to help out in in in many many ways... if I have to choose between dirty shirts I'm picking the cleanest dirty shirt I don't know why anybody would want to wear the dirtiest dirty shirt”

0.46

Put volume reached all-time highs this week, but this is not a contrarian indicator of capitulation because call volume is simultaneously at all-time highs—investors are equally divided between betting on further downside (puts) and buying the dip (calls), so the put-call ratio remains non-extreme.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 0/4· Brent Johnson

“the reason and I didn't have my Bloomberg at the time but when I came back and I looked at it well the reason is because everybody's been trying to buy the dip with calls so this is puts everybody betting on it going lower but there's an equal number of people buying the dip buying calls expecting there to be so so this shows the call volume is at an all-time high and so when you look at the put call ratio it's actually at a pretty pretty uh you know non-extreme L level”

0.45

The Dow Jones index broke below the 200-day moving average this week, which indicates technical weakness, and the 50-day moving average is just beginning to cross below the 100-day moving average—a classic breakdown in trend that often precedes further weakness.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“the Dow broke below the two the 20 the 200 day moving average...the 50-day moving average is now just starting to cross the 100 day moving average that will often be seen as a breakdown in Trend and that will often when that happens you will often then see further weakness”

0.45

Gold hit $3,000 this past week and is the best-performing asset since the dollar milkshake framework was first introduced in 2018, validating the core prediction.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“gold hit $3,000 this last week and as I showed earlier um you know gold uh is the best performing asset since I first started talking about the milkshake back in 2018”

0.45

In equities, until just one month ago, equities and gold had been performing equally well, but over the past month equities have experienced a hard pullback while gold has continued higher, making gold the ultimate winner in the milkshake framework.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Brent Johnson

“you Equity the purple is the equities until just a month ago equities and gold had done equally well um now in the last month equities have had a hard pullback and gold has continued higher so gold has been the ultimate winner over this but remember the dollar mils like said in the year ahead rates would rise they did the dollar would rise it did US equities would rise it did and gold would rise it did these are all measurable”

0.45

It is possible for the dollar milkshake thesis to be completely wrong, and the speaker acknowledges this—the framework is only useful if it helps explain what's actually happening, not as ideology.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“is it possible that I'm right wrong about the milkshake sure it's absolutely possible and I test this all the time so far it is playing out”

0.45

Despite all the bailouts, QE, guarantees, and arguments about the dollar going lower that have been thrown at it, the dollar has risen 10% (and at one point was up 20%), showing structural dollar strength that overcomes policy efforts to weaken it.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“think about everything that has been thrown at the dollar over this time period all the bailouts all the QE all the guarantees all the all the job owning about the dollar going lower and yet the dollar is up despite everything that's been thrown at it”

0.45

The COT (Commitments of Traders) data shows that as gold prices rose over the last month, commercial traders began short-covering rather than adding shorts, which is a bullish signal suggesting potential for a significant move higher if the short-covering pattern continues.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“as gold went higher you started to see some short covering uh by the commercials...if this continues that's going to be a sign of man we we could really jump higher”

0.45

Alternative media often argues that the US empire is ready to crumble and the dollar will collapse, recommending investors flee to emerging market commodity companies, but this contradicts five to six years of observable market performance.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“the alternative media the alternative investing space will say you have to get out of the United States it's an Empire ready to crumble the dollar is going to collapse you have to get out of it you're better off if you buy these Emerging Market companies who have come from commodity producing countries and you don't want to be exposed to all the debt in the United States and listen it's not that these aren't important points to consider but all you have to do is look at the chart to see that over the last five or six years the US has wildly outperformed the rest of the world”

0.45

The speaker believed a currency crisis from dollar strength would have already occurred, but it has not yet manifested despite 10-20% dollar appreciation and unprecedented monetary stimulus, suggesting either the timeline is longer or the mechanism is more complex than initially modeled.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“it also said the dollar would rise over that time that's the orange line it's up 10 per. now some people say well that's not very much but 10% for a currency is quite a bit actually and at one point it was up 20% and it has not caused the currency crisis I thought we would have already had a currency crisis we haven't um so I'm happy to I'm happy to admit that I was wrong there um but think about everything that has been thrown at the dollar over this time period all the bailouts all the QE all the guarantees all the all the job owning about the dollar going lower and yet the dollar is up despite everything that's been thrown at it”

0.44

As gold rose over the past month, commercial traders have been covering short positions rather than adding to them, a sign of potential acceleration if this trend continues.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 0/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“over the last month as gold went higher you started to see some short covering uh by the commercials now if this continues that's going to be a sign of man we we could really jump higher”

0.44

The speaker has clients in Europe, Middle East, and Asia for whom dollar versus home currency movements are extremely important to their investment decisions and portfolio performance.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“I speak to a lot of people who aren't just in the United States I have clients in Europe I have clients in the Middle East I have clients in Asia and the dollar versus their home currency is extremely important”

0.43

In 2022, the strong dollar directly caused or exacerbated financial stress globally: the Bank of England had to bail out its bond market, the ECB had to bail out the Italian bond market, the Bank of Japan had to bail out the JGB market, and China began its real estate and equity market downturn—all direct consequences of the dollar strengthening.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“in that year the bank of England had to bail out its bond market the ECB had to bail out the Italian bond market the bank of Japan had to bail out the jgb market and China started to go in their tail spin from their real estate and Equity Market that is all the direct consequence of the dollar getting stronger”

0.43

The speaker has been testing the dollar milkshake framework against reality and admits that it has not played out as quickly as initially predicted, representing areas where his analysis was wrong.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“it's not playing out as quickly as I thought it would and I got that wrong and I don't mind raising my hand and saying I got that wrong part of the reason I don't mind saying I got something wrong is I'm not arrogant enough to think that I always get things right all the time”

0.43

For investors of any size (from small 401k holders to major portfolio managers), the recommended preparation strategy is diversification across four core assets: US dollars (cash), physical gold, US equities, and real estate—this combination provides protection against most scenarios.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“if I were to keep it really simple it would mean that you should be Diversified you should have some cash and that cash should be in dollars you should have some gold and that gold should be in physical form probably not just an ETF you should have some exposure to the equity market now I don't whether that's through your own business whether it's through some kind of private Equity that that you're involved in or maybe it's just your 401 part of your 401k or your your your your investment fund I don't think you should just be sitting 100% cash you should have some exposure to to equities now when you make that exposure to equities I think it should be to us equities...and then I think everybody should also have um you know probably some form of real estate and whether you know whether whether you have rental properties whether you own a home whether maybe you own some Farmland”

0.41

Silver recovered to where it was last year (hitting 34 bucks last fall) and is now almost back to those levels, and as silver rose the short positioning started to increase again, indicating the pattern of rising prices with expanding short positions that is typical of silver price dynamics.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“silver this is what I would have expected to see...you know I think silver hit 34 bucks last fall uh hasn't really done anything for the last six months but now it's gotten back kind of back up to where it was...as that has happened you've seen the short position start to get bigger again”

0.40

The Dow Jones broke below its 200-day moving average this week, with relative strength in the high 20s and stochastics falling to the floor, indicating potential for further downside as moving average crossovers typically precede additional weakness.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 0/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“the Dow broke below the two the 20 the 200 day moving average if you remember last week I said it was sitting right on the 200 day moving average it actually broke below that you can see the relative strength got down here into the 20s kind of the high 20s and stochastics felt all the way to the floor”

0.40

The VIX has been trending upward for almost a month (rather than spiking and reversing quickly as in past year), reached nearly 30 on Tuesday, then pulled back into the end of the week, indicating a volatile environment where put hedges are currently expensive.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 0/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“the vix was trending up upwards and it had been trending upwards for almost a month and in the past you know this past year whenever we would see spikes it would it would spike really quickly and then come back down Spike and come back down and this was just kind of a slow draw Higher and Higher and Higher and Higher and we had a really kind of a high on Tuesday it almost got to 30 and then it pulled back into the end of the week”

0.40

Silver has risen back to near its prior-year highs (around $34) after six months of stagnation, with short positioning increasing as the price rallied, similar to historical patterns.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 0/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“silver this is what I would have expected to see and what I would expect we see next week as the price of silver got back up to where it was last year so um you know I think silver hit 34 bucks last fall uh hasn't really done anything for the last six months but now it's gotten back kind of back up to where it was not quite to 34 but pretty close but as that has happened you've seen the short position start to get bigger again”

0.39

There will be volatile periods and dramatic drawdowns in the US stock market ahead, and money may temporarily leave the US for short periods, but the long-term trajectory in the endgame of the dollar milkshake will involve even more outperformance than has occurred already.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“will there be points along the way where that doesn't happen will there be points in time where money leaves the US for short periods of time or will the US Stock Market fall...absolutely it will...I think that will continue and I think in the endgame it'll play out even more than it has played out already”

0.36

The speaker expects potential downside extension in the near term (between now and end of month) as the broader indices potentially follow the Russell 2000's pattern, though he emphasizes this is not a certainty, saying 'would not surprise me at all if that breaks below and we see further downside.'

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“would not surprise me at all if that breaks below and we see further downside here sometime between now and the end of the month”

0.36

The VIX had been trending upward for almost a month (not spiking and falling like in the past year) before hitting nearly 30 on Tuesday, then pulling back significantly by Friday—suggesting volatility may be coming down, which creates an opportunity for investors to buy hedges at lower cost.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“the vix was trending up upwards and it had been trending upwards for almost a month...spike really quickly and then come back down...we had a really kind of a high on Tuesday it almost got to 30 and then it pulled back into the end of the week and it was a pretty dramatic down move on on um on Friday”

0.36

Put volume reached all-time highs because everyone was buying puts betting on further downside, but the put-call ratio was actually not extreme because there was also an equal volume of call buying from people trying to 'buy the dip,' so the put-call ratio data contradicts the narrative that investors are extremely bearish.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“somebody posted a chart of how much um the put volume was just off the charts meaning everybody was buying puts...everybody's been trying to buy the dip with calls so this is puts everybody betting on it going lower but there's an equal number of people buying the dip buying calls...the put call ratio it's actually at a pretty pretty uh you know non-extreme L level”

0.35

The speaker predicted a currency crisis sooner than it has materialized, and acknowledges this was wrong, but the timing error does not invalidate the framework

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“I thought we would have already had a currency crisis we haven't um so I'm happy to I'm happy to admit that I was wrong there”

0.35

People outside the US have benefited over the last 5-6 years by keeping their cash needs in US dollars rather than their home currencies, avoiding currency devaluation.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“I've talked to many people outside the United States who have done very well over the last five six seven years by keeping their money in dollars or at least their cash needs in US Dollars versus their home currencies”

0.32

The speaker's portfolio has been rolling puts down during market rallies and weakness, reducing put exposure compared to previous periods while maintaining some hedge for expected further downside

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“we have dur during this runup and during these rundown we've been rolling our puts down and so we don't have as quite as much exposure to puts now as as we did before but we still do have some uh because we're expecting more downside in the um in in the the weeks to come”

0.32

Further weakness is not yet complete; the speaker does not believe the market has found a bottom despite the Friday bounce

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“so it's going to be interesting to see how this week goes I think maybe we get a little bit of a bounce into the FED meeting but uh I I I don't think all the weakness is over yet I don't think that I don't listen maybe we'll find out that this was the bottom but I I don't think so”

0.17

The speaker invites audience feedback via DM, email, Twitter, or video comments and will respond with analysis if able

definitionspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“as always feel free to you know shoot me a DM or an email or you know ask me on Twitter or even comment in the section on the video uh if anything you want me to cover and if I have the ability to do so I will”

0.16

The coming weeks and months ahead will be interesting and not boring in terms of financial market developments

forecastspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Dollar Milkshake - Why Does it Matter...??? [zHzFLoMLfpA]

“it's going to be interesting to see what happens in in in the weeks ahead here but uh whatever it is it's not going to be boring”

0.10

The speaker is rolling put options down in price as markets have declined, reducing current put exposure compared to earlier in the market decline, but maintains some hedges because further downside is still expected.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 0/4· Brent Johnson

“we have dur during this runup and during these rundown we've been rolling our puts down and so we don't have as quite as much exposure to puts now as as we did before but we still do have some uh because we're expecting more downside in the um in in the the weeks to come”