What this covers

This lecture, from a college history-of-philosophy series, is a single professor's account of Alfred North Whitehead and where his thinking came from. The publisher notes a gap in the video, from roughly 12:33 to 23:24, so part of the argument is missing from this copy. The first stretch is about lineage. Whitehead absorbs Hegel's evolutionary idealism, in which spirit is a creative process with a fixed logos structure and not an unchanging substance, but he keeps it naturalistic and treats science as provisionally informative about reality. The lecture credits F.H. Bradley as the more direct influence, and the Romanticism of William Wordsworth, whom Whitehead read almost as scripture. It also traces the appeal of the Alexandrian Logos Doctrine and middle Platonism.

The middle of the lecture turns to physics. Field theory, quantum theory, and relativity theory are presented as the developments that led Whitehead to reject the Fallacy of Simple Location, the assumption of fixed points in uniform space and time. Philosophy is given a double job here: criticizing scientific abstractions that get mistaken for ultimate reality, and speculating imaginatively beyond what science establishes. Entities are described as relational units and not isolated atoms.

The longest stretch is Whitehead's theory of perception, which the professor sets against Locke. It runs through three modes: causal efficacy, presentational immediacy, and symbolic reference. The lecture treats causal efficacy as the primary mode, and the ringing phone and the freezing tulips serve as examples. The most contentious claim is that David Hume stayed trapped in the Lockean priority of ideas and so missed that we experience causal connection directly. The lecture also separates creativity from God, whom it describes as creativity's highest manifestation, in parallel with Bradley's Absolute.

Sharpest takeaway

Whitehead develops an evolutionary naturalism based on process philosophy in which reality is fundamentally constituted by creative events comprising objective causal data, eternal possibilities, and decision-making, rather than unchanging substances.

  • Whitehead translates Hegelian evolutionary idealism into a naturalistic metaphysic by replacing substance ontology with process ontology while maintaining the romanticist emphasis on value in nature
  • Every event in the cosmic process contains three irreducible elements: objective causal givens, eternal possibilities (eternal objects), and decision, making creativity the ultimate reality rather than any fixed entity
  • Whitehead's realism about both science and experience allows him to argue that physical facts are inherently value-laden through modern physics (relativity, quantum mechanics, field theory) rather than requiring idealist rejection of science

The claims · ranked37 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

Whitehead is a naturalist rather than an idealist who takes science as telling us provisionally about reality (scientific realism) rather than having a phenomenalist view of science like idealists, yet both idealists and Whitehead share the goal of preserving a romanticized view of life and nature.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“Now notice what's happening here. He is a naturalist rather than an idealist. Here he is interested in modern physics. He's going therefore as a naturalist interested in modern science going to be a scientific realist taking science as telling us in a provisional way about reality. The idealist had a phenomenalist view of science. Whitehead has a realist view of science. Yet both of them seem to have the same ends, purposes, namely preserving a romanticized view of life, nature, and as we'll see later, insisting that there is no ultimate separation between fact and value.”

0.80

For Whitehead, the ultimate reality is not a thing or substance but creativity—the process of the emergence of novelty—which pulses through everything, representing the ultimate nature of all phenomena.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“The ultimate reality for Whitehead is something that pulses through everything. is and the the ultimate reality for him is um wouldn't you know it creativity you say that's not a thing it's a property you're right it's not a thing is is not a substance metaphysic to have the ultimate as a You see creativity a property? No, not exactly. It's a process. It's the process of the emergence of novelty. And that's what's ultimate in all of novelty. Creativity. Novelty.”

0.80

In Hegelian thought, spirit is not an unchanging substance but rather a creative process with a logos structure (dialectical structure) that is unchanging, while the stuff it manifests in changes, representing a fundamental shift from substance-based to process-based ontology.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“Hegel doesn't think of spirit as an unchanging substance but as creative process. It's not substance but process. And so you have a change in the basic um notion of reality. uh from the changelessness of some basic stuff be it Thales water or whatever or Daycart's thinking thing or whatever from the unchanging substance to some sort of dialectical process which as as in Hegel it's overall logos structure but no unchanging substance it's the structure of the process that's unchanging not the stuff that's changing you see so uh that in Hegel um translates in whitehead into his notion of process”

0.80

Whitehead was profoundly influenced by 19th century Romanticism, particularly through Wordsworth, whom his daughter reported he read as if it were the Bible, and verbal identities can be found between Wordsworth's poems and language in Whitehead's technical metaphysical work 'Process and Reality'.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“I'm uh not sure that um Whitehead got this so much from Hegel as he did from Wdsworth. uh his daughter uh wrote that um there was a time in his life when he read Wordssworth as if it were the Bible... Um, but uh the Wordssworth themes run uh all the way through it. Uh you'll pick them up in a chapter called the romantic reaction in science and the modern world in which there is as much poetry as philosophy including Wsworth's poetry... I found um verbal identities between Whitehead's poems and some of the language in um did I say Whiteheads poems? Wdsworth's poems and some of the language in Whiteheads process in reality which is his long technical tome on metaphysics.”

0.80

The Alexandrian Church Fathers' logos doctrine appeals to Whitehead as a philosophical naturalist because he is seeking to purchase (adopt) their logos concept, having been impressed by Platonism, particularly middle Platonism, which developed the logos concept in talking about the ordered structure of nature.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“The third one may surprise you. The Alexandrian church fathers and you might say what is a philosophical naturalist doing trafficking with the Alexandrian church fathers. and uh he's trying in fact to buy their logos doctrine. That's what he's doing shopping there. He wants to buy the logos doctrine. He's very much impressed by Platonism, particularly the middle platonism, not so much just Plato, but the middle platonism which developed the logos concept in talking about the ordered structure of nature.”

0.80

If we consider the perceiver to be an entire psychosomatic unity (the entire human organism), then from a phenomenological standpoint the initial thing is causal efficacy, an effect that is felt, rather than ideas, with light bright enough being felt first before being cognitively represented.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“His point is that um if we consider the perceiver to be the entire psychossematic unity, the entire human organism. Then from a phenomenological standpoint in terms of the consciousness of the initial thing is the causal efficacy. There is some effect causally that is felt you see and um misled by the clarities of sense perception lock talked otherwise. But even in visual perception, if the light is sufficiently bright, it's felt first.”

0.76

Whitehead describes the perceptual experience as having three modes: perception in the mode of causal efficacy, perception in the mode of presentational immediacy, and perception in the mode of symbolic reference.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“Well, he um distinguishes in the perceptual experience three modes. Perception in the mode of Okay. The first is um perception in the mode of causal efficacy. The second is perception in the mode of presentational immediacy. The third is perception in the mode of symbolic reference.”

0.76

The third element involved in the perceptual experience besides objective data and eternal possibilities is decision, whereby in the process the lot is cast and one selects from a range of possibilities to go with it.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“What is this in these three which is the cause of the perceptual experience? What are the causes? What are the factors that create this experience of perception? Well, first there are objective data, objective givens that affect the present state of consciousness... Second as the ideas develop these are what he calls eternal possibilities... And uh then there is a uh third factor that makes the perceptual experience complete. Decision So you say hello and realize that you were wrong in your decision. But the decision you see is selecting from the eternal possibilities, the whole range of possibilities proposed by the stimulus.”

0.76

Eternal objects are possibilities (what could be), thought-objects or ideas as objects of thought, not objects in the sense of substance, and are distinct from objective data which are other actual events causally affecting the present.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“The objective data are simply other events, other spacetime events which causally affect the present status of this stream. You see, so there's an intersection of two causal streams. Um these eternal possibilities he calls eternal objects not objects in the sense of substance but in the sense of objects of thought. Ideas ideas are objects of thought. Thought objects. You see these are eternal objects.”

0.74

Even when Whitehead develops his conception of God more fully later, creativity is not God—God is simply the highest manifestation of creativity, similar to how in Bradley's system the absolute is not God but God is the highest manifestation of the absolute.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“Now be careful. This um creativity even when he develops his conception of God much more fully than at the beginning. Uh this creativity is not God. It's not God. Well, to one who's read Bradley, that's no surprise because for Bradley, the absolute is not God either. God is simply the highest manifestation of the absolute. And for Whitehead, God is simply the um highest manifestation of creativity.”

0.74

Like Hegel, Whitehead performs a phenomenology of consciousness and the process, providing a descriptive account of the structure of events that constitute the process, but models it as more organic than mechanistic, like a growth process rather than a machine.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“so uh that in Hegel um translates in whitehead into his notion of process and like Hegel He does a phenomenology, a phenomenology of um the process, that is to say, a phenomenology of consciousness. Uh a descriptive account of what the process is like, of the structure of events which make up the process. And the process is um not some kind of mechanistic thing as in 18th century science. But the uh the model is uh more organic than mechanistic, more like a growth process than a machine-like.”

0.74

Three modern developments in physics particularly influenced Whitehead's philosophy according to 'Science in the Modern World': electromagnetic field theory (thinking in terms of force fields rather than bodies with gravitational pull), quantum physics (units of energy rather than solid pellets of matter as basic units), and Einstein's relativity theory including spacetime and E=MC².

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“you'll find that in science in the modern world, he talks about the philosophical significance of three modern developments in physics. First of all, electromagnetic field theory. Electromagnetic field theory. whereby uh we think in terms of force fields rather than in terms simply of bodies with gravitational pull force fields. Uh second uh quantum physics where the basic unit if you like units of energy rather than solid pellets of matter third um Einstein's relativity theory including space-time relativity general theory of relativity E= MC²”

0.74

Philosophy has a two-fold function with regard to science: first, to critique scientific abstractions that take theoretical notions like 'equality' to be ultimate reality, and second, to engage in flights of speculative imagination based on modern science to extrapolate from science into speculative metaphysical schemes.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“he talks um a lot about science in his writings. He takes it that philosophy has a two-fold function with regards to science. Uh one is to critique scientific abstractions. There's that word abstraction again. the abstractions which take some um theoretical notion like um equality for being ultimate reality. A mistaken con abstraction. um to critique those abstractions is part of the function of philosophy and he critiques mechanistic science and you will find that's the major function of the first six chapters of the book you're reading. But then the second function is to engage in what he calls flights of speculative imagination based on modern science.”

0.74

Whitehead also denounces the fallacy of simple location, which assumes that there are fixed points in uniform space and uniform time of a Newtonian sort, failing to see that motion is in both place and time and that spatial coordinates change varying with time due to the relativity of spatial relationship to time.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“Then the other is the fallacy of simple location of assuming that there are fixed points in a uniform space uniform time of a Newtonian sort simple location. So all you have to do is to call out the coordinates and you can locate the thing. failing to see that um motion is in both place and time and the spatial coordinates change varying with the time. relativity of spatial relationship to time and uh consequently uh the notion of a simple location such as we use in geography just um is an abstraction that may be useful at some levels but quite useless at others.”

0.74

The notion of simple location, useful in geography at some levels, is an abstraction that becomes quite useless when applied to physics and metaphysics.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“the notion of a simple location such as we use in geography just um is an abstraction that may be useful at some levels but quite useless at others.”

0.74

One major influence on Whitehead's thinking was Hegel's evolutionary idealism, which integrated evolutionary theory (including natural selection) with idealism by arguing that while underlying reality is of the nature of spirit, there are varying degrees to which that immaterial creative spirit is manifested in nature and human history.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“the first is Hegel's philosophy what I called Hegel's evolutionary idealism. Uh you figure the idealism in Hegel. right? Evolutionary? Yes. Because of his emphasis on a historical development, a number of the 19th century idealists and their successors that we were talking about the week before break um can be thought of as evolutionary idealists. Yes, they they buy into the theory of evolution, natural selection if you like, or various other forms of the theory of evolution, but they're not philosophical naturalists, metaphysical naturalists. They're idealists. So that evolutionary theory is compatible with naturalism, compatible with idealism according to these people. And their point is that while the underlying reality is of the nature of spirit, absolute spirit in the case of Hail, there are various degrees to which that um uh immaterial free creative spirit is being fully manifested in the uh phenomena of nature and human existence.”

0.74

Whitehead was most directly influenced by F.H. Bradley rather than Hegel himself, as evidenced by his explicit citations of Bradley, and he agreed with Bradley's critique that appearances, qualities, and the substance-quality distinction are abstractions rather than concrete reality.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“Actually, the um Hegelian thinker who most influenced him was FH Bradley. And those of you characters who skipped out on the last day of class will forever be impoverished because that's when we talked about FH Bradley um whom Whitehead explicitly cites rather than Hegel. And in the uh Bradley material that you have in the gardener anthology, uh you will notice that Bradley speaks of um appearances and qualities and the substance quality distinction and that sort of thing as being sheer abstraction, not concrete reality by themselves. And Whitehead agrees.”

0.74

The case of freezing tulips demonstrates Whitehead's principle of gradualism: the tulips had many objective data affecting their development and various eternal possibilities, but the decision (the freezing frost) determined which possibility was actualized, showing that the same three-element structure applies to non-conscious natural processes.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“Example, in that beautiful weather we had the week before last, my daffodils, no, my tulips, big pardon, my tulips, bulbs in rows up the flower bed in the backyard, were getting to be that high, literally. And my mind was filled with possibilities for a blaze of color in a few weeks earlier than ever before in the season. Now there are other possibilities of course that came to my mind. But for the process of the development of my tulips, there were all sorts of possibilities. But then came the moment of decision, that cold snap last week, which froze my tear lips. So that as of now they are limp, dead, sagging to the ground. Okay, now that was a possibility all along. And the decisive moment was that deep frost down to 10 degrees one night. Exit my spring tulips. And you've got all the same there. You have the given process in which there are all sorts of objective data that affect them. You see and depending on the objective data which affect them whole ranges of possibilities now um it's much more deterministic with um tulips than it is with the conscious decisions that you and I make.”

0.73

Presentational immediacy provides a hypothetical idea without guarantee of correctness (like awakening to a bell and mistaking it for an alarm clock), but this hypothetical idea is then referred to the cause as a symbol rather than a representation or copy.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“presentational immediacy then follows. Yeah. An idea comes to mind. Now, there's no guarantee that the idea is correct. You know the way it is in the morning. You are awakened by a bell ringing and you grab the alarm clock and say hello. You you've got the wrong idea. But you got an idea. You see? No. Um so the um presentational immediacy provides you with a hypothetical idea. no guarantees. And what you do is to take that idea and refer it to the cause of the stimulus. Notice the idea is not a representation, a copy. It's a symbol.”

0.70

Whitehead's theory of perception is developed in contrast to John Locke's theory, which takes ideas as the primary content of consciousness, whereas Whitehead argues that causal efficacy is primary and presentational immediacy is secondary.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“Now, as he develops this, as he does in a number of places, as he develops this, it's always in contrast to John Lock's theory of perception. Now, as John Lock describes sense perception, what comes first? Causal efficacy or ideas? Huh? In the phenomenology of it, in the consciousness of it, what comes first? Ideas. That's the beginning place.”

0.70

In Whitehead's philosophy, entities are relational units rather than isolated atoms, meaning the ingredients of reality have essential relationships to other things rather than being atomistically independent.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“And the ingredients are not um atomistic in the sense of having no essential relationships to anything else. But the ingredients are rather um relationships than um isolated atoms. So an entity is a relational unit rather than anything else.”

0.70

Through symbolic reference, we use ideas as symbols to refer to causes, achieving an indirect knowledge of what an object is (its essence) while having direct awareness of that something exists (its existence).

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“So we take the idea and using it using it as use it as a symbol in referring to. So we have an indirect knowledge of the essence of an object. The essence is what it is. The existence is that it is.”

0.63

Hume stumbled over the fallacy of the primacy of presentational immediacy, being locked into the Lockean mode of thought which prevented him from recognizing that we experience causal connections directly, not through repeated constant conjunctions.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“Hume stumbled over the pre the fallacy of the primacy of presentational immediacy. You see with a big label like that you think he could have caught it. But um no he was so locked into the lock mode of thought. This awareness of causal efficacy has nothing to do with constant conjunctions. How many times does Ryan have to be hit on the chin before he's aware? You see, one pretty surely will do it. You see the immediacy of it.”

0.52

Each decision in the process brings satisfaction, meaning that the causal stimulus is assimilated in some way into the self, becoming an ingredient in the ongoing individuality and continuity of the process.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Philosophy Professor

“in every case brings what he calls satisfaction. Not necessarily emotive satisfaction but um in the sense that the uh the causal stimulus is assimilated in some way into the self. So it becomes an ingredient in the ongoing individuality.”

0.52

Eternal possibilities are logical possibilities that come to mind as ideas in response to a stimulus, with the example that when a phone rings at night, one might consider the possibility that it's the alarm clock, but the world is teeming with all sorts of logical possibilities that the mind might entertain.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Philosophy Professor

“as the ideas develop these are what he calls eternal possibilities. What is this? It's the phone ringing at this hour in the night. You say it's a possibility. You were wrong. It's the alarm clock. But the ideas are simply possibilities that come to mind. You see, and the world is teeming with all sorts of possibilities. objective logical possibilities that you think of.”

0.52

Natural processes are loaded with possibilities for good and bad, and value-laden, since the possibilities available in any event are inherent in the natural process itself, not imposed from outside.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Philosophy Professor

“Possibilities 1 2 3. You could go in that direction... corresponding to the various eternal possibilities... natural process is loaded with possibilities for good, for bad, value laden. You see,”

0.47

Whitehead's basic question is what is the source of these eternal possibilities (the possibilities available to and entertained in events), a question that leads to the logos doctrine and to God as the source or orderer of possibilities.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Philosophy Professor

“Whitehead's basic question is what's the source of these eternal possibilities and because I've already queued you in that he's looking for a logos doctrine what's the source God the logos who is not a creator in any sense of xd hello. God isn't a causal force. No, God is just the orderer, the providence, the logos.”

0.41

Whitehead cooperated with Bertrand Russell around 1903 on the Principia Mathematica, which introduced symbolic logic into the 20th century and demonstrated that mathematics is reducible to formal logic.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“He cooperated with Bertrand Russell in I think it was 1903 in a work which really introduced symbolic logic into the 20th century. a work called the tract the the Bertrand Brussell no not it's not not the tractatus that's what led me as well the Prancipia Mathematica the Prancipia Mathematica I have a prompter over here you'll see to help me the Prancipia Mathematica principles of mathematics in which uh Russell and Whitehead both of whom were teaching at Cambridge at the time cooperated on the volume essentially showing that um mathematics is reducible to formal logic”

0.41

Whitehead accuses mechanistic science of committing the fallacy of misplaced concreteness, which is a major function of the first six chapters of 'Process and Reality'.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“and he critiques mechanistic science and you will find that's the major function of the first six chapters of the book you're reading.”

0.38

Whitehead started as a mathematician at Cambridge, later became a philosopher of science at the University of London, and at age 63 became a professor of philosophy at Harvard for approximately 15 years before retiring and continuing to live near Harvard, where conversations with him were recorded until his death at age 88.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“He started as a mathematician at Cambridge. uh he later became a philosopher of science at University of London and at the age of 63 when he was thinking of retirement he became a professor of philosophy at Harvard for I think it was about 15 years and uh when he finally retired he kept on living there in the shadow of Harvard yard and um open house to students and faculty And so conversations uh with Whitehead from that point on were recorded until he died I think at the age 88.”

0.38

In his later work 'Adventures of Ideas' published in the 1930s, Whitehead shows a renewed interest in theology and particularly in Origin and the Christian Platonists of Alexandria, including Origen and Clement.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“later however in one of his later works that was published in the 1930s, a work called Adventures of Ideas. It's very plain that um he has a new interest in theology and particularly in origin and the Christian Platonists of Alexandria. Origin, Clement, that tradition, the middle platonism there.”

0.38

Whitehead grew up in an Episcopalian parsonage in Ramsgate, England (a southeastern town 20 miles from the speaker's home), where his father was an evangelical Episcopalian clergyman, influencing his later theological interests.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“The other is that uh he grew up in a parsonage. His father was an Episcopalian clergyman and of evangelical persuasion uh in the southeast English town of Ramsgate uh 20 miles from my home. Um so that um as a kid we used to ride our bicycles over to Ramsgate fairly often.”

0.38

At Cambridge as an undergraduate, Whitehead initially read theology avidly but decided against it, sold his theology books, and turned his attention to mathematics along with Bertrand Russell.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“when he went off to Cambridge as an undergraduate for a while he was reading theology avidly and then decided that wasn't for him he couldn't buy it sold all his theology books turned his attention to mathematics along with Bertr and Russell uh so that they were undergraduates together”

0.37

Whitehead is the most influential process philosopher of the second half of the 20th century, more so than other process philosophers like Bergson who Stumpf discusses in the same chapter.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Philosophy Professor

“I chosen to focus on Whitehead simply because of his very powerful influence in the development of process theology and we'll see the beginnings of it in Whitehead and later on I'll make some comments about further aspects of it. But um Whitehead is um without doubt of these two the most influential in the second half of the 20th century.”

0.30

Objective data in perception are simply objective givens that causally affect the present state of consciousness, with examples including causal stimuli and the existing objective world state that impinges on the perceiver.

definitionspeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Philosophy Professor

“first there are objective data, objective givens that affect the present state of consciousness. So if you like my um daydreaming is disturbed by these causal givens causal stimuli objective data that causally affect.”

0.26

Whitehead says that the whole history of philosophy is a series of footnotes to Plato, just as Hegelians would say that all subsequent philosophy is a series of footnotes to Hegel.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Philosophy Professor

“just as a Hegelian would want to say that all of subsequent philosophy is a series of footnotes to Hegel, White in one place says that the whole history of philosophy is a series of footnotes to Plato.”

0.19

A professor of Whitehead studies claimed that only two people really understood Einstein's relativity theory: Einstein himself and Whitehead, though the speaker expresses uncertainty about whether improvement has been made in understanding since that statement was made.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Philosophy Professor

“the um professor who taught the Whitehead course I taught in graduate school said that there were only two people who really understood relativity theory. One was Einstein, the other was Whitehead. Now whether there's been any improvement on that in the last 200 years or whatever it was, I I don't know.”