
There’s a Reason Even ‘Smart’ People Surrender to Trump
What this covers
This is a conversation between Opinion deputy editor Patrick Healey and columnist Masha Gessen, who draws on years of writing about Russia. They ask why so many institutions and politicians, Democrats included, have bent to Donald Trump while disagreeing with him. Gessen's central frame is anticipatory obedience, a term with roots in analyses of Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union that Tim Snyder popularized in On Tyranny as "do not obey in advance." Gessen casts the present as a prisoner's dilemma, in which each concession worsens conditions for everyone else.
The examples span several sectors. Healey cites PBS closing its DEI) office to protect federal funding. Gessen adds hospitals that decline to defend trans patients, and business leaders who raced to pledge money and loyalty before the inauguration. She argues that small concessions do not insulate anyone already in the crosshairs, and that organizations with a megaphone, PBS among them, have a particular duty to lead collective refusal. She also points to the FBI's resistance to loyalty-based firings, and to trans young people speaking at a rally, as signs that resistance is possible.
The sharper disagreements concern Democrats and Trump's ideology. Gessen says early talk of common ground, from figures such as Elizabeth Warren and Hakeem Jeffries, abdicated their responsibility. She calls the party poorly suited to a moment that demands non-governmental resistance, and says it is fighting the last war by overcorrecting from January 6th. She argues one can accept a legitimate election while opposing illegal acts. Healey raises Mitch McConnell's obstruction of Obama as a model for being the party of "no." Gessen also rejects the view of Trump as an ideological blank slate, pointing to Stephen Miller and an inaugural address that declared only two sexes. Finally, she compares the pace of consolidation with Vladimir Putin's early years and calls it faster, warning that America lacks a culture of collective action and local media.
Gessen argues that institutions and individuals in America are engaging in anticipatory obedience to Trump's authoritarian agenda, rationalizing incremental concessions that cumulatively enable authoritarianism, and that only collective resistance and maintaining clear facts and values can prevent democratic collapse.
- Institutions like PBS and healthcare providers are obeying Trump's demands in advance to survive, but this strategy mirrors how elites in Putin's Russia eventually lost everything despite their compromises
- Democrats are abdicating their constitutional responsibility by seeking common ground with an illegitimate agenda rather than mounting collective opposition
- The speed and scope of Trump's attacks are unprecedented in American history, requiring extraordinary leadership and organizing to resist rather than individual survival strategies
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
No claims extracted from this asset yet.