What this covers

Bruce Meyer of the University of Chicago discusses with Russ Roberts how standard measures of middle-class stagnation, poverty, and inequality over the past three decades rest on flawed foundations. Meyer draws on a decade of research to argue that conventional narratives—of flat median incomes, rising poverty, and soaring inequality—are largely artifacts of measurement problems rather than economic reality. The conversation examines three principal sources of distortion: the CPI's chronic understatement of real price declines, the Census Bureau's reliance on pre-tax income while ignoring tax cuts and transfers, and the failure to look at consumption patterns and physical living standards alongside earnings data.

The episode moves systematically through the evidence. Meyer and Roberts explore how the CPI omits new goods and quality improvements—cell phones took fifteen years to enter the basket, and refrigerators were added long after most households owned them—inflating historical price growth by 0.7 to 1.1 percentage points annually. They examine how tax policy, especially the Earned Income Tax Credit, has substantially boosted after-tax incomes for lower earners, and how government transfers are severely undercounted in household surveys. The discussion turns to consumption data and physical ownership: the share of low-income households with central air conditioning, washers, and dryers has risen dramatically since 1980, and major housing defects like roof leaks have nearly vanished. Meyer argues median living standards have risen roughly 50% when properly adjusted, while inequality outside the top 1% has grown modestly. The conversation also addresses complicating factors like changes in household composition, the role of education costs, and the relationship between globalization and wage pressure, situating these measurement issues within broader debates about economic policy and the sources of inequality.

Sharpest takeaway

Meyer argues that the standard narrative of middle-class stagnation and runaway inequality over the last 30 years is largely an artifact of mismeasured inflation and reliance on pre-tax income; when inflation is corrected and after-tax income and consumption are examined, median living standards have risen roughly 50% and inequality outside the top 1% has grown only modestly.

  • Official price indices (CPI) overstate inflation by roughly 0.7-1.1 percentage points per year due to failure to capture new goods and quality improvements
  • Pre-tax income measures ignore tax cuts and transfers (especially the EITC) that substantially raised after-tax incomes at the bottom and median
  • Consumption data and physical goods ownership (housing, appliances, air conditioning) show the poor and middle class are materially much better off than 30 years ago

The claims · ranked33 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.91

The Hoynes, Page, and Stevens study found that between 1967 and 2003 every single demographic group's poverty rate fell by double digits (most by 20% or more, except single men), yet the overall poverty rate fell only about 4% (and official measures show rises) because the highest-poverty group—single women with children—grew as a share of the population (Simpson's paradox).

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 4/4durability 3/4· Russ Roberts

“every single demographic group had dramatic reductions in poverty over a long period of time ... and yet the overall poverty rate went up why because the group with the largest proportion which is ... single women with children that group got bigger”

0.88

Surveys like the Current Population Survey poorly capture government transfers: matching CPS data to government records shows the survey captures only about half of food stamps actually paid out, not necessarily from shame but because respondents skip the laborious reporting of benefits, so official income/inequality data understate the well-being of the poor.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 4/4durability 3/4· Bruce Meyer

“if you match the data from this survey to the government reports of how much they've paid out in food stamps for example the survey only captures about half of what's paid out”

0.81

It took the BLS about 15 years to include cell phones in the CPI basket after their introduction, and historically most goods (electric refrigerators, used cars) were included only long after the majority of people owned them; because new goods often fall dramatically in price, leaving them out misses a large component of real price decline.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bruce Meyer

“it took the BLS 15 years to include cell phones after they were introduced”

0.81

Inequality is not an inexorable fact but emerges from a complex process with good and bad sources: good inequality comes from value-creating entrepreneurs like Brin and Page who made others better off while capturing only a fraction of the value; bad inequality comes from bailouts of Wall Street and subsidies to rich farmers.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Russ Roberts

“the level of inequality emerges from a complex process some of the reasons it emerges are good ... Sergey Brin and Larry Page they found Google and they make our lives better ... and then there's the kind that's not so good which is to me bailouts of Wall Street or subsidies to rich farmers”

0.80

Consumption is a better measure of well-being than one year's income because families save for rainy days and can consume out of past savings; this is especially true for retired households (over 80% of those headed by someone 65+ own their home and at least one car), whose low current incomes badly understate their well-being.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Bruce Meyer

“one year's income is not really a good measure of a family's well-being because families save um for a rainy day ... more than eighty percent of households headed by someone 65 and older owned their own house own at least one car”

0.77

The popular claims that the middle class is being hollowed out, incomes are stagnating for all but the top, and the rising tide did not lift all boats are basically wrong, as shown by ten years of research with James Sullivan; properly accounting for inflation, median incomes have risen about 50% since 1980, and consumption has risen by a similar amount.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bruce Meyer

“they're basically Ron and that's what ten years of research by myself and James Sullivan at Notre Dame has shown if you measure incomes uh better accounting properly for inflation median incomes have gone up by about 50% since 1980 and if you look at consumption it's gone up by a similar amount”

0.77

Comparisons of the median or quintiles across decades are misleading because they are not the same people over time; in particular, the rising divorce rate since the 1970s splits households so that household-level analysis can show median income falling even when the original individuals are better off—a statistical paradox often ignored by those with an agenda.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Russ Roberts

“starting around in the 1970s it's not a coincidence that this is to me when the stagnation supposedly extorts starting in the seventies a big increase in the divorce rate so when you're doing household analysis ... you're talking about radically different groups of people”

0.77

Globalization and technological change both reduced demand for low-skilled US workers (their products are made overseas or by machines), and because the US K-12 school system is mediocre and has not responded vigorously to prepare strugglers for college, this is part of the inequality problem—yet because most of the period shows little inequality increase, globalization and immigration are not the threats to living standards that some claim, especially since their pace intensified precisely when inequality was not rising.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bruce Meyer

“one of the reasons that low scold been in less demand in the United States is that many of the things they produce are being produced overseas they now are competing with workers that are cheaper ... there's also technological change which has made low-skilled workers their own competition with machines”

0.77

The pace of improvement in daily life is itself what makes living standards hard to measure and creates the false impression of stagnation; in stagnant eras like the 1950s and 1960s cars and refrigerators looked similar decade-to-decade, whereas now everything improves within ten years, leading people to wrongly conclude they aren't catching up because the improvements are mismeasured.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Russ Roberts

“the pace of the improvement of daily life is what makes it hard to measure and gives you the impression incorrectly that the average person's calling mind ... ten years go by and everything's better and so people I think it's incredible that because of that people are led to the false conclusion that people aren't catching up”

0.75

Most of the measured 50% improvement at the median comes from the inflation adjustment, but a substantial part (particularly in the 2000s) comes from tax cuts; for those in the bottom 10-20%, transfers matter much more than taxes, and the combination of raising exemptions and expanding the Earned Income Tax Credit dramatically increased after-tax incomes of the poor relative to pre-tax income.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bruce Meyer

“most of it is the inflation adjustment but it is certainly true at the median that a substantial part of the increase particularly in the 2000 is due to tax cuts rather than just inflation”

0.75

Most charts circulated by the Census Bureau and media report pre-tax income and ignore transfers (welfare, etc.), and poverty is measured by people's own earnings rather than living standard after transfers; correcting for taxes and transfers substantially changes the picture, especially at the bottom.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Russ Roberts

“they're looking at pre-tax income not post tax income they're certainly looking they're not looking at transfers that people receive in the form of welfare or other things”

0.74

For people at the bottom, income is hard to measure because it comes from many irregular sources (formal/informal work, money from family, friends, boyfriends, fathers of children, and government transfers), as documented by Edin and Lein; these same people report rent and weekly food spending fairly accurately, so consumption gives a better read of their living standard.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bruce Meyer

“there is a wonderful study of single mothers by edon and Lane that talks about their various sources of income ... it's much harder to respond in a survey to what your income is on the other hand these same people do a pretty good job of reporting what their rent is what they're spending in a given week on food”

0.73

The after-tax 90/10 income inequality ratio in 2009 was about the same as in 1993 (dipping in the 1990s, rising in the 2001-02 recession), largely because the 10th percentile did quite well after accounting for taxes, including payroll taxes; meanwhile the 90/50 ratio rose from about 2.5 around 1990 to roughly 2.75 today—a relatively small increase compared to public perception.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bruce Meyer

“if you look at say after-tax income inequality say the 90/10 ratio it's about the same now well in no.9 as it was in 1993”

0.73

Poverty has declined much faster for households headed by someone 65 and older and for single-mother-headed households than for the overall population, while married couples with children have seen their poverty rate decline more slowly than other groups—even more so when measured by spending rather than income.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bruce Meyer

“those households that are headed by someone 65 and older have had their poverty declined much faster than the overall population that's also true for single mother headed households on the other hand married couples with children their poverty rate hasn't declined as fast”

0.73

Physical ownership data show the bottom 20% are materially much better off than in 1980: in 1980, 27% of those in the bottom income quintile had central air, versus 67% in 2009 (nearly triple), with similar gains in dishwasher, washer, and dryer ownership; structural housing problems like roof leaks and plumbing problems have nearly disappeared.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bruce Meyer

“in 1980 let me grab the numbers 27 percent of those in the bottom 20 percent of the distribution had central air whereas in 2009 it was 67 percent almost three times the share”

0.71

Policy should keep its eye on what sustains high long-term economic growth (which has been pretty widely distributed), distinguish recession-appropriate policies from long-term growth policies, and avoid using false claims of stagnation to justify measures like closing borders to goods and immigrants.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bruce Meyer

“we want to distinguish between policies that may be appropriate for a recession and policies that are focused on long term growth ... we shouldn't use false claims of stagnation to justify things like closing the borders to Goods and immigrants”

0.70

An independent way to confirm CPI overstates inflation is to find the income adjustment that keeps spending patterns (shares spent on food, clothing, leisure) constant over time at a given real income level; researchers like Costa and Bruce Hamilton have done this and arrive at CPI biases not very different from the Boskin Commission's.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bruce Meyer

“you look for well um what level you would have to adjust uh income by so that spending patterns stay the same over time and uh several people have done that door acosta right and Bruce Hamilton and they come up with biases to the CPI that aren't that different from what the Baskin Commission concluded”

0.69

Over the last 10 years, poverty measured by consumption has fallen much faster than poverty based on income (the official income measure shows poverty rising), and longer-term indicators like housing types and cars driven suggest the bottom has seen real improvement in living standards despite the awful last three years.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Bruce Meyer

“if you look at trends in consumption over the last 10 years at the bottom the rate of poverty indicated by what people are consuming has gone down a lot faster than a rate based on income in fact the official income measure says that poverty has gone up over the last 10 years”

0.68

Housing is about 40% of consumption across income levels, and the size of housing units has gone up dramatically while problems like roof leaks and plumbing defects have nearly disappeared, undercutting the claim that gains are merely cheap electronic 'toys' while big-ticket items got more expensive.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bruce Meyer

“housing is about 40% of consumption for the poor for the middle class for people at high incomes and the size of housing units that people live in has gone up dramatically”

0.68

The CPI overstates inflation because it fails to adequately keep track of new goods and to adjust for quality improvements; the Boskin Commission concluded in 1996 it overstated inflation by about 1.1 percentage points per year, and members polled more recently still estimate a bias of about 0.7 to 0.9 percentage points per year.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bruce Meyer

“back in 1996 the Baskin Commission concluded that our main rate of inflation the CPI you overstates inflation by about one point one percentage points per year at that time”

0.68

Education has become more expensive primarily because demand rose sharply (more people attending high school, college, community college, and graduate school) against a relatively inelastic supply, so an increase in demand pushes price up a lot relative to quantity; this reflects greater access, not unaffordability.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Russ Roberts

“the reason that that education has got more expensive is that a lot more people have access to it and they pushed up the price of something that has a relatively inelastic supply where supply doesn't respond very much so an increase in demand pushes a price a lot relative to quantity”

0.68

Meyer and Sullivan disaggregate by household type (married-parent, single-parent, single families without kids, married couples without kids, 65+ headed) and by race, employment, and education, then aggregate; doing so yields different answers than lumping everyone together, but they find changes in family composition do not play a big part in changes in median income or poverty over their period.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bruce Meyer

“we look at different types of households married parent households single-parent households ... and then households that are headed by someone 65 and older we also split up the population by race and whether or not the household head is employed and by education”

0.68

Much of the increase in inequality has been attributed to rising demand for high-skilled labor combined with the failure of the US to supply enough high-skilled labor; minimum wage changes and high early-1980s inflation are other suggested but uncertain factors.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bruce Meyer

“a fair amount of it has been attributed to changes in the demand for high skilled labor and the failure of us to supply enough um uh high skilled labor at the times when demand for it was increasing”

0.66

There was a large increase in inequality in the late 1970s and early 1980s by every measure, but since the late 1980s—when measured with after-tax income or better yet consumption—inequality has grown only modestly for the bulk of the population, and the 10th percentile has actually risen relative to the median, especially in the last 10 years.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bruce Meyer

“the late seventies early eighties were bad for inequality but since then the picture when you measure things better when you look at after-tax income or better yet when you look at consumption things aren't as bad for the bulk of the population”

0.63

Debt-fueled consumption is a real concern at the median (visible in the post-crisis decline as people repay debts and worry about the economy) but is not a big driver of increased consumption at the bottom near the poverty line, where little borrowing occurs.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Bruce Meyer

“when you look at people near the poverty line they're not doing a lot of borrowing so debt is not a big part of the increase in consumption at the bottom”

0.63

The picture of well-being looks much better if you account for what people can actually spend (after-tax income); taxes matter substantially at the median, particularly in the 2000s, because of the 2001 and 2003 income tax cuts which were spread fairly evenly across the income distribution in percentage terms rather than going entirely to the rich.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Bruce Meyer

“if you account for taxes the median has gone up much more than if you if you don't and that is because of cuts in in income taxes in the in 2001 and 2003”

0.63

Healthcare is deliberately excluded from Meyer and Sullivan's research because there is less professional agreement on how to handle the tremendous quality changes; children's access (e.g., share with annual checkups) has improved, but the share of median-income people with insurance has declined over time, which would offset some gains if access to better technology fell.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Bruce Meyer

“health care is complicated we we try and stay away from it actually in our research because there's less agreement in the profession about how to handle health care the quality changes there have been tremendous”

0.49

Looking around at your immediate environment is a dangerous basis for inference because it produces misperceptions—e.g., concluding a recession isn't bad because a thriving Washington DC mall is crowded.

normativeestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Russ Roberts

“looking around is dangerous it can do very bad misperceptions I live in Washington DC ... so if I say well the recessions not so bad I went to the mall the other day and everybody was in there ... that's a stupid claim”

0.49

Low-income workers pay a healthy amount of payroll tax as a percentage of income (because it is effectively a flat tax), and those rates have risen over time, so analyses must account for federal and state income taxes and payroll taxes when measuring after-tax income.

factualestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Russ Roberts

“they do pay a healthy amount of payroll tax and person as a percentage of their income because of flat tax and those rates have risen over time”

0.45

Mark Bils at Rochester has done careful work estimating quality-change bias on manufactured goods, finding the bias is quite significant for that important subset of goods, demonstrating that systematic correction is possible for narrow categories even if hard to generalize.

factualestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Russ Roberts

“there are people like mark Bill's at Rochester who's done I think extremely careful work on manufactured goods showing an actual careful estimate of the bias on one small portion of important portion of goods it's quite significant”

0.40

Many in the top 1% are entertainers, movie stars, sports figures, and entrepreneurs who have leveraged their skills via improved technology so they are more valuable than before, alongside some who earn through subsidies (e.g., subsidized borrowing/lending by large financial institutions), so the group is heterogeneous rather than simply an exclusive club extracting money.

factualcontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Russ Roberts

“the top 1% or a lot of them are entertainers movie stars sports figures people who've been able to leverage their skills in dramatic ways because of improvement in technology and then we're valuable than they used to be”

0.40

The 1950s and 1960s were relatively dull and stagnant with little innovation, so the popular nostalgia that those decades were 'more fair' confuses fairness with a lack of dynamic improvement.

factualcontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Russ Roberts

“people say well the 50s and 60s had was more fair well the fifties and sixties were pretty dull and pretty stagnant and there wasn't a lot of innovation”

0.38

A homeless person having a heart attack will receive emergency-room care in both 1980 and 2011 (required by law), but the drugs, treatment, and technology available are much better today, illustrating that healthcare quality has improved dramatically even at the bottom.

factualestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Russ Roberts

“if a homeless person has a heart attack on the street in 1980 versus 2011 the medical care is going to get in the emergency room which is required by law ... the drugs the treatment the technology that that person is going to have access to is much much better today”