
A History of Philosophy | 03 The Greek Sophists
What this covers
This lecture, the third in a university history-of-philosophy series, sets the sophists against the presocratic thinkers who came before them and the Socratic tradition that followed. The presocratics had tried to draw a parallel between the ordered unity of nature, of the city-state, and of a person's moral life. The lecturer frames the sophists as a break from that project. They were not an organized school but itinerant teachers who claimed wisdom (the word means "a wise one"). The lecture draws on Alasdair MacIntyre's claim that today's ethical scene can only be understood by going back to Greece.
The sophists themselves get a range of treatment. Protagoras and his "man is the measure of all things" is read as an early relativism about truth, where truth is made rather than discovered. Gorgias offers three skeptical theses: nothing exists, anything that exists cannot be known, and anything knowable cannot be communicated. He also gets credit for a surprisingly old-fashioned list of heroic virtues, and for a passage on the power of speech to remove grief and create joy. Thrasymachus holds that justice is the interest of the stronger, a view the lecturer ties to Friedrich Nietzsche. Antiphon, whose status as a sophist is uncertain, contrasts consensual civic law with compulsory natural law and argues that all people are born alike, Greeks and barbarians both. The lecture also looks at Plato's criticism of Pericles for a foreign policy of helping friends and harming enemies.
The final stretch turns to Socrates, known mainly through Plato's dialogues. His concern is the care of the soul, not success. He describes his Socratic method as intellectual midwifery and treats it as the start of dialectic, "thinking through," not the Marxist triad. He refuses to abandon his mission even to escape execution. The lecture sets his reflective argument against the sophists' rhetoric of emotional persuasion and offers an echo of Jesus's question about gaining the world and losing one's soul.
The sophists represent a fundamental rejection of the presocratic project to ground morality and knowledge in the nature of reality, instead embracing ethical relativism, skepticism about truth, and the use of rhetoric to achieve power rather than knowledge—a position that Socrates and Plato opposed through dialectical inquiry into moral truth.
- Sophists abandoned the presocratic attempt to find metaphysical grounding for morals, replacing it with the view that morality is merely conventional social agreement
- Sophists practiced skepticism about the possibility of knowing truth about reality, using arguments from equipollence and incommensurability to reject all philosophical systems
- Sophists turned from philosophy to rhetoric—the manipulation of emotion to achieve persuasion and power—which Socrates and Plato saw as antithetical to the genuine pursuit of truth and justice
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The presocratic philosophers attempted to understand a parallel between the ordered unity of nature, the ordered unity of a city state, and the ordered unity of one's moral life, grounding ethics in the very nature of reality itself.
“running through all that and in some regards underlying it all is their attempt to understand this so noteworthy remarkable parallel between the ordered unity of nature and the ordered unity of a city state and the ordered unity of one's moral life as it should be at least and accordingly what you might call the metaphysical grounding of morals. Thinking in terms of an ethic that is grounded in the very nature of reality.”
Socrates asks 'will life be worth living if that higher part of man is destroyed?'—the soul which is improved by justice but depraved by injustice—echoing Jesus's question 'what will a man profit if he gain the whole world and lose his own soul?'
“says he in another place, will life be worth living if that higher part of man is destroyed? The soul which is improved by justice but depraved by injustice. Sounds almost as if uh it's the same thing that Jesus said. What will a man profit if he gain the whole world and lose his own soul?”
Alasdair MacIntyre argues that to understand the ethical scene of the 1990s (or 1980s when he wrote), one must go back to ancient Greece and understand the story of how we arrived at contemporary ethical positions.
“according to McIntyre to understand the scene in the 1990s well 1980s because he wrote it in the 90s even the in the 80s even though it's now the 90s uh to understand um the ethical scene in the 90s is you have to go way way back to ancient Greece. You see the story of how we got to where we are”
Plato criticizes Pericles, the great Athenian statesman, for operating on principle in domestic policy with justice and virtue but in foreign policy with the principle that 'justice means doing good to your friends and evil to your enemies,' prioritizing power over equal justice.
“But on the other hand, in his relationships with other states, the key to what he did was not justice, equal justice for all as it was in his domestic policy, but power. You see, and even at home, some of his policies of what and how they rewarded citizens for generated idleness and avarice. But particularly in his foreign policy, he seems to have operated on the policy that justice means doing good to your friends and evil to your enemies.”
The sophists purported to teach the youth about the good, but they were really teaching rhetorical skills—how to be successful in the public arena, how to get ahead in life, how to win friends and influence people.
“they purported to um teach them um about the good. But what were they really doing? Well, you see, the complaint is that they're not teaching them knowledge of what is good and true. They're teaching them rhetorical skills. How to be successful in the public arena as an aristocratic young person, how to get ahead in life, how to win friends and influence people, you see.”
The sophists are skeptical about the possibility of knowing the truth about reality and nature, rejecting the presocratic enterprise wholesale rather than engaging in the disputes between competing presocratic systems.
“if you add to the two things about the prescratics that we've been stressing, if you add the third thing that we noted in passing, namely their attempts to understand or the beginning development of some god concept. Okay, they're skeptical about that as well. Uh so in effect what you find in the sophists is first of all skepticism about the possibility of knowing the truth about reality about nature”
The sophists view morality as conventional—a matter of social agreement and social practice—rather than grounded in the nature of reality, making their ethical position thoroughly relativistic.
“They rather view morality as conventional, simply a matter of social agreement, social practice, perhaps what we would call social contract, and therefore quite relativistic. They are more oriented to achieving success, winning a debate, winning an argument. rather than the pursuit of truth and justice.”
Socrates refused to renege on his philosophical mission even at the end to escape execution, saying 'the difficulty is not to avoid death but to avoid unrighteousness' and that life is not worth living if the higher part of the soul is destroyed.
“he was willing to take it and uh he refused even at the end to back away in order to um escape execution...The difficulty is not to avoid death but to avoid unrighteousness. You see to rene on what he had been doing because he believed it was right. to renegade on that treachery to the truth. And says he in another place, will life be worth living if that higher part of man is destroyed? The soul which is improved by justice but depraved by injustice.”
Antiphon argues that we revere and honor those born of noble fathers while not reverencing those from non-noble houses, but notes that we are like barbarians in this regard and are all by nature born the same in every way, both barbarians and Greeks, with natural laws open to all men to observe.
“We revere and honor those born of noble fathers. But those who are not born of noble houses, we neither revere nor honor. In this we are like barbarians... We're all by nature born the same in every way, both barbarians and Greeks. And it's open to all men to observe the law of nature”
Protagoras claims 'man is the measure of all things'—meaning the individual is the judge of what is true, and truth is a matter of making rather than discovery, anticipating contemporary relativism about truth.
“Essentially, man is the measure of all things. Um, okay. You notice it in the first paragraph there, um, at the bottom of 53. Of all things, the measure is man. Of things that are, that they are. Of things that are not, that they are not. Okay. Who says what is? You see the individual seemingly is the judge. It is we who make our truth. Truth seems to be a matter of the making rather than the discovery.”
Speech is a great power that can put a stop to fear, remove grief, create joy, increase pity—demonstrating the tremendous potential of rhetoric for good or evil.
“Speech is a great power that achieves the most divine works by means of the smallest and least visible form. It can put a stop to fear, remove grief, create joy, increase pity. The power of rhetoric.”
The fundamental contrast that emerges in the move from sophists to Socrates and Plato is between the use of careful thinking and reflective argument (philosophical inquiry) versus the use of rhetoric (emotional manipulation).
“This uh poses a fascinating kind of contrast that we're going to be um working with as we move into Socrates and Plato. The contrast between the use of careful thinking, reflective argument, philosophical inquiry as against the use of rhetoric.”
Thrasymachus claims 'justice is the interest of the stronger'—that those who exercise power tell you what is right, a position Friedrich Nietzsche would later develop around 1900 in his Genealogy of Morals.
“to Thrmicus is ascribed the saying that justice is the interest of the stronger. Justice is the interest of the stronger. Or if you like, might makes right. that it's those who exercise power who tell you what's right which is precisely the thesis that Friedrich nee eliberated around 1900 in his work on the genealogy of morals.”
Socrates' main concern is not success but the moral nurture of the human soul and the care of the soul, with his well-known saying 'know thyself' because only by knowing your soul's condition can you cultivate its further nurture.
“his main concern is not success, but the moral nurture of the human soul, the care of the soul...well-known saying of Socrates, know thyself. Because it is only when you know yourself, know the condition of your soul that you can cultivate the further nurture of your soul.”
Antiphon, who may or may not have been a sophist, argues that justice requires one to uphold the laws of the city in the presence of witnesses but uphold the edicts of nature when without witnesses, because natural laws are compulsory while civic laws are merely consensual.
“A man can best conduct himself in harmony with justice if when in the company of witnesses he upholds the laws and when without witnesses he upholds the edicts of nature. Now notice that the edicts of nature, the edicts of laws are artificially imposed. Those of nature are compulsory.”
The sophists are oriented toward achieving success and winning debates and arguments rather than pursuing truth and justice, valuing practical victory over philosophical inquiry.
“They are more oriented to achieving success, winning a debate, winning an argument. rather than the pursuit of truth and justice”
Gorgias ascribes to certain virtues a mix of heroic virtues (courage, beauty, nobility) rather than justice-based virtues, reflecting an older Greek ethical tradition.
“What kinds of virtues are these? He's talking about the glory of a city is courage of a body beauty of a soul wisdom of action virtue of speech truth. It's right in all circumstances to bring to praise what's praiseworthy and blame what's blamew worthy. Now notice that mix of virtues. You see to talk of courage and beauty. Why? That's those old heroic virtues.”
The sophists were not a school of thought in any organized sense, nor were they all located in one place; the term 'sophist' means literally 'a wise one,' as they claimed wisdom while functioning as itinerant teachers.
“Uh, they weren't a school of thought in any organized sense. uh they weren't all in one location. The term sophist means literally a wise one because they claimed wisdom. They were popularly regarded as wise people who um usually in an itinerant fashion um spent time in one city, state or another teaching the youth.”
The Socrates known to us is primarily the Socrates from Plato's dialogues, with little independent knowledge of him available from other Greek writers.
“So when we're talking about Socrates, we're talking really of the Socrates we know through Plato's dialogues. A little bit is known about him independently through other Greek writers. not much.”
It is not a criticism of the Ten Commandments that people do not observe them; rather, it is a criticism of the people who do not observe them—natural moral law is not dependent on human compliance for its validity.
“it's no criticism of the Ten Commandments that people don't observe them. That's the criticism of the people who don't observe them. You see, that's the kind of point that he's making”
Gorgias presents three skeptical theses: (1) nothing exists, (2) if anything exists, it is incomprehensible and cannot be known, (3) if it is comprehensible, it is incommunicable and cannot be talked about.
“Gorgias appears and notice the three main points of the outline at the beginning. One, nothing exists. Two, if anything exists, it is incomprehensible. Can't be known. Three, if it is comprehensible, if you can know it, it is incommunicable. You can't talk about it.”
Socrates developed the Socratic method, describing himself as an intellectual midwife following his mother's trade, bringing to birth the brainchildren and ideas that people are pregnant with so they can be examined.
“he developed what has become known as the Socratic method as he himself put it he was following in the family trade His mother was a midwife. He said he's following in the same business. Uh he's an intellectual midwife bringing to birth the brainchildren that people are pregnant with. The ideas that are formed in their minds and need now to get out into the open and be examined.”
Dialectic begins with the Socratic method and means 'thinking something through' derived from the verb 'to think' and the preposition 'through,' but it is not the Marxist notion of thesis-antithesis-synthesis.
“That's the beginnings of the kind of method that Plato calls dialectic. Now don't associate that with any notion of a Marxist dialectic, thesis, antithesis, synthesis. That's a later use of the term. Okay. This um notion of dialectic is um literally um rooted in the etmology of the term. There you've got the verb lego to think. Logos of course is is the noun correlative with it. Dr. the preposition through. So dialectic is simply thinking something through.”
The Socratic method involves searching questions that force a person's line of thought to open up, take it further, and further until self-contradictions are exposed or ridiculous conclusions emerge or else the truth begins to emerge as reasonable, plausible, and consistent.
“that process of searching questions to force a person's line of thought to open up to take it further and further until self-contradictions are exposed or ridiculous conclusions come into the open or else the truth begins to emerge reasonable plausible consistent. That's the Socratic method. You see that's the intellectual midwifery.”
The edicts of laws are artificially imposed and arrived at by consent, whereas those of nature are not a matter of consent; disagreeing with a natural moral law does not change the law—it harms the person who disagrees.
“Where's the higher authority? The edicts of the laws are arrived at by consent, not by natural growth. Whereas those of nature are not a matter of consent. If you disagree with a natural moral law, too bad for you. Doesn't do anything to the moral law. Does something to you.”
Protagoras is ascribed the saying 'to make the weaker cause the stronger,' which sounds like an inversion of the natural order of things.
“interesting again 6B that little dictim to make the weaker cause the stronger. I don't know what he had in mind there. But to make the weaker cause the stronger sounds like something rather unnatural. you see as if there's an inversion of any kind of order to things.”
Speech is not the same thing as things that exist; therefore we communicate not the things that exist but only speech itself, making speech unable to represent reality.
“that with which we communicate is speech. Speech is not the same thing as things that exist. So that we communicate not the things that exist but only speech. And at the bottom of that column, speech can never exactly represent perceptibles. Perceptibles are obviously what we perceive. Speech can never exactly represent what we perceive since it's different from them.”
Socrates seems to have been regarded by the Athenians as another of the wise people, perhaps associated in their minds with the sophists, though he was fundamentally different from them.
“Socrates seems to have been regarded by the Athenians as another of these wise people rather like the sophists and perhaps may have been associated in their minds as um one of the same sort. uh that is to say he was accepted in an undiscriminating way by his peers you say as were also the sophists but Socrates was different he was different”
Plato criticizes Homer for having no experience as a statesman or military advisor, yet writing about those subjects, merely copying other people without any judgments of his own.
“Oh, Plato criticizes the poets Homer. Oh, listen. He had no experience as a statesman or military advisor and yet he writes about all that stuff just copying other people. He doesn't have any judgments of his own to make. Homer, you see, that's one of the reasons why he says that art is just a copy of something. Homer just copied copycat Homer.”
Protagoras expresses skepticism about knowing whether gods exist or what they are like, claiming 'the factors preventing knowledge are many: the obscurity of the subject and the shortness of human life.'
“I'm not able to know whether they exist or do not exist, nor what they're like. The factors preventing knowledge are many. The obscurity of the subject and the shortness of human life.”
Running through Plato's writings is a critique of sophistic rhetoric that extends into Aristotle's work, and in English language today we retain the word 'sophistry' meaning fancy-sounding talk that really isn't very rational.
“And running through Plato's writings, there is this critique of sophistical rhetoric. Yeah. The rhetoric of the sophists way on into Aristotle. Aristotle talk Aristotle talks of the errors of the sophists and even in English language nowadays we have the word sophistry fancy sounding talk that really isn't very rational sophistry”
Socrates tries to get people thinking about truth, goodness, and virtues through dialogue, with Plato's dialogues exploring different questions and different virtues—the entire Republic concerns the question 'What is justice?'
“One, he tries to get people thinking about the truth, about goodness, about virtues. And if you look over the list of Platonic dialogues that I've given you, you'll notice that there are all sorts of dialogues on different questions and different virtues. The whole of Plato's Republic is about the question, what is justice?”
Plato treats the sophists as traitors to the heritage of truth and justice, suggesting they corrupted their educational mission.
“And so Plato treats them as if they are traitors to the heritage of truth and justice um which they should be spreading.”
If the concepts of the mind are not realities—if what we are thinking about is not real—then reality cannot be thought; the question is whether there is correspondence between thought and reality.
“how he develops this under Roman 2 at the bottom of the first column on 55. If the concepts of the mind are not realities, that is to say, if what we're thinking about is not real, reality cannot be thought. Reality cannot be thought. If we can't think about it, reality cannot be thought. So the question is whether there is any correspondence between thought and reality. Presumably he's thinking that truth would be some sort of correspondence between thought and reality.”
Antiphon represents the 'good guy' position among sophist-era thinkers, standing on the side of people like Hesiod and Socrates who believe in natural moral law rather than ethical relativism.
“And Andon seems to be in this sort of conflict one of the good guys rather than one of the bad guys...So Andon very plainly is on the side of people like uh Heziard and Soc.”
Persuasion by speech is equivalent to abduction by force—the listener has no choice, making rhetoric fundamentally coercive.
“Persuasion by speech is equivalent to abduction by force. I didn't have any choice.”
Socrates was accused of corrupting the youth of Athens, and teaching people to think can be dangerous because parents and constituents don't always like it when young people start thinking things they don't want them to think.
“the story of Socrates uh how he was accused of corrupting the youth of Athens. Sure, it's dangerous business to teach people to think, you think. Um, yeah. Uh, parents and constituencies don't always like it when their young people start thinking things that they don't want them to think.”
What medicine and exercise are to the body, good laws and the administration of justice are to the soul—they maintain its health and virtue.
“Sounds almost as if uh it's the same thing that Jesus said. What will a man profit if he gain the whole world and lose his own soul? You think Plato's concern, Socrates concern is there what medicine and exercise are to the body, good laws and the administration of justice are to the soul.”
Plato argues that Pericles should have used his powerful rhetoric to implant temperance and justice in people's souls and to take away all thought of injustice, but he did not.
“No, because Pericles misused his powerful rhetoric. He should have used it to implant temperance and justice in people's souls and to take away all thought of injustice. And he didn't.”
Pericles hovered in his career between the tradition of relativist rhetoric and the rational appeal of those who believe objective justice is rooted in the nature of things.
“and he hovered in his career between the tradition of the relativist rhetoric, okay? And the rational appeal of those who believe that there is such a thing as objective justice rooted in the nature of things.”
We need a methodology of knowing, which the presocratics apparently did not have; Plato and Aristotle address this need and make the understanding of proper knowledge and methodologies of knowing—epistemology—an explicit and major part of the philosophical agenda.
“In other words, we need something of a methodology of knowing, which the pcratics apparently didn't have. And it's precisely that which Plato and Aristotle address. Not only that, but they address that obvious need. And the attempt to understand the proper nature of knowledge in relationship to methodologies of knowing is of course the branch of philosophy that is known as epistemology. And so that part of the agenda for philosophy that was tacit in the prescratics becomes an explicit part of the philosophical agenda, a major part of it from Plato onwards.”
The power of speech over the constitution of the soul can be compared with the effect of drugs on the bodily state, suggesting rhetoric chemically alters mental states.
“The power of speech over the constitution of the soul can be compared with the effect of drugs on the bodily state. Put you to sleep. Okay.”
It is wrong to manipulate emotion through rhetoric such that reason is turned off, bypassed, or put to sleep—though appealing to emotion per se is not inherently bad.
“It's not that rhetoric per se is bad, that it's wrong to appeal to the emotions, but it's wrong so to manipulate the emotion that reason is turned off, bypassed, put to sleep, drugged.”
Thrasymachus represents an ethical relativism that understands the power behind moral persuasion is the power of rhetoric—persuasion through emotion rather than reason.
“Thrmicus then comes out as if you like the ethical relativist but the ethical relativist who sees that the power behind moral persuasion is the power of rhetoric. You see now what is it about rhetoric that's so significant that it appeals to the emotions rather than the reason.”
The only alternative to the sophistic replacement of knowledge-pursuit with rhetoric and power-pursuit is not the sophistic path; there must be a theory of knowledge that can maintain that knowledge is possible.
“is the only alternative to replace the pursuit of knowledge with rhetoric and the pursuit of power. No, not necessarily. But you notice if there is to be another alternative, then we've got to have a theory of knowledge that can maintain that knowledge is possible.”
The problem with the presocratics was not that they were seeking knowledge, but that they were not methodical enough about it; they were speculating, taking shots in the dark, intellectual guesswork, coming up with likely stories rather than working through problems and difficulties to reasonable conclusion.
“Maybe the problem with the prescratics was um not that they were seeking knowledge, but they weren't methodical enough about it. They were speculating, taking shots in the dark, sort of intellectual guesswork, coming up with likely stories rather than working through the problem, the issue, the difficulties to some reason sort of conclusion.”