What this covers

This is a FRONTLINE interview with William Taylor, recorded on Sept. 29, 2022 by Michael Wiser for the "Putin and the Presidents" project. Taylor was U.S. ambassador to Ukraine under Bush and Obama and chargé d'affaires in Kyiv in 2019. He walks through the relationship among Vladimir Putin, Ukraine, and a sequence of American presidents. The sequence runs from the 2008 NATO summit in Bucharest, where Putin told George W. Bush that Ukraine "is not really a country," to the February 2022 invasion. Taylor spends time on that speech, noting that its first third to half dealt with the United States rather than Ukraine.

The middle of the conversation is a ledger of Western responses and what he thinks each taught Putin. He calls the Bucharest compromise, which promised NATO membership without a Membership Action Plan (MAP)), a mistake, and argues the war might not be happening had the plan been approved. That claim is contested, as is his view that the muted reaction to the 2008 invasion of Georgia (country)) set a precedent. He also discusses Obama's description of Russia as a regional power, the slow buildup of sanctions after Crimea in 2014 (finalized only after the downing of MH17), and Putin's conclusion that sanctions are "a cost of doing business."

The most specific material concerns Donald Trump. Taylor describes the debate over supplying Javelin missiles, the unexplained hold on security assistance announced at a mid-July 2019 National Security Council meeting, and the "favor" request in the Zelensky call. He then turns to Joe Biden: his familiarity with Ukraine, the spring 2021 three-part message to Putin, the Geneva strategic stability talks, and the intelligence question of intent versus capability. Taylor closes by tying continued support for Ukraine to the rules-based international order.

Sharpest takeaway

The speaker argues that Putin's 2022 invasion of Ukraine resulted from decades of misunderstanding Ukrainian independence and Western resolve, rooted in his 2007 Munich speech declaring the Soviet collapse a 'geopolitical catastrophe,' and that the U.S. must maintain unwavering support for Ukraine to defend the rules-based international order against Russian revisionism.

  • Putin has consistently viewed Ukraine as not a real country but as Russian territory rightfully belonging to Russia, as evidenced by statements to Bush in 2008 and his 2022 invasion speech
  • Western hesitation and mixed signals—from the 2008 NATO rejection to the Trump administration's aid freeze—emboldened Putin by suggesting the U.S. lacked resolve to defend allies
  • Biden's response mobilized international military, economic, and diplomatic support that must continue, including nuclear deterrence against Russian escalation, to re-establish the post-WWII rules-based order

The claims · ranked40 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.84

President Biden understood the historical importance of Ukrainian independence more deeply than most Western leaders because as Vice President he had visited Ukraine many times, knew the personalities and politics, and had witnessed firsthand how Ukrainians valued their 30 years of independence from Russian control after 300 years of being under Russia's thumb.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· William Burns

“President Biden as we know knew a lot about Ukraine as vice president he had been to Ukraine many times he knew the personalities he knew the politics and the important part there is I think President Biden understood in ways that many people didn't the importance of Ukrainian Independence he knew the history that Ukraine had been under the thumb of of Russia for 300 years and for the past 30 years it was independent it was free”

0.80

Supporting Ukraine's victory against Russia is necessary to re-establish the rules-based international order and restore principles of sovereignty that have kept peace since World War II

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· William Burns

“the ukrainians are trying to push the Russians back out of their country we support that that will re-establish this rules-based order that we can use to go forward”

0.80

During a 2008 NATO summit in Bucharest, President Putin told President Bush directly that 'Ukraine's not really a country,' revealing Putin's fundamental rejection of Ukrainian sovereignty and independence.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· William Burns

“he famously leaned over to President Bush at that Summit and said George you know Ukraine's not really a country”

0.78

President Putin has stated that the dissolution of the Soviet Union was the greatest geopolitical catastrophe of the previous century, and this belief drives his determination to reassemble former Soviet territories beginning with Ukraine.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· William Burns

“he famously said that the dissolution of the Soviet Union was the greatest geopolitical catastrophe of the previous century”

0.75

President Trump held views of Ukraine that were not true to reality—seeing it as corrupt and unable to resist Russian pressure—views he heard from some of his own political advisors and from Victor Orban of Hungary, who directly told Trump that Ukraine is not really a nation.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· William Burns

“president Trump did have this view of Ukraine that was not true to reality but that he heard from some of his own political advisors but he also heard it from Victor Orban in Hungary Victor Orban was in president Trump's office and told president Trump exactly the Putin line that is Ukraine not really a nation it's corrupt it it can't resist”

0.74

The 2014 Russian invasion of Crimea was the first time since World War II that one European nation invaded another to change borders, violating the rules-based order that had kept peace among major powers in Europe, and demonstrated Putin's determination to overturn the post-WWII international system.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· William Burns

“he invaded Crimea in 2014 and again at that point not a big reaction he went further invaded dombas a little bit later in 2014. that started to prompt some real concerns which then built up because by that time based on that that action the United States took seriously the fact that President Putin is ready to overturn a rules-based order that had kept the piece for so long by invading its neighbor so that Invasion made it crystal clear where President Putin was going”

0.74

During the Trump administration, there was a debate about whether to provide Javelin anti-tank missiles and Stinger anti-aircraft missiles to Ukraine; the Trump administration ultimately approved Javelins (which the Obama administration had refused to do), giving credit to the Defense Department and State Department advocates, though some top officials initially resisted.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· William Burns

“so it's very important as I say in 2019 the ukrainians had been fighting the Russians for five years by this time to the Trump administration's credit they had approved the provision of javelins which the Obama Administration never did so the Trump Administration finally agreed with the State Department of Defense department and the National Security Council and provided these weapons”

0.74

President Biden was briefed in January or December 2021 that Russian capability to invade Ukraine was present and imminent, and the key intelligence question became whether Putin would exercise that capability—a question of intent rather than capacity.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· William Burns

“when he was briefed that this could happen soon so now we're probably talking about you know January or even December of last year January of 2022 when it was clearer and clearer to our intelligence agencies that that the capability was there the Russian capability to invade Ukraine was there and the key question is always intent”

0.74

In a spring 2021 phone call, President Biden sent Putin a three-part message: (1) back off Ukraine and do not invade, (2) the United States will impose sanctions on Russia for election interference, and (3) Biden is willing to meet Putin face-to-face to discuss issues, offering both warning and diplomatic opportunity.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· William Burns

“this phone call that President Biden put in had three components had three messages first message was back off of Ukraine do not invade Ukraine stop the threat to Ukraine that is posed by your forces Mr Putin the second message and again we remember that this was shortly after President Biden was in office I mean so this was I think this was in like March he's been inaugurated in in January so he hadn't been in office more than a couple of months so so for him to call Putin and tell him back off of Ukraine and to tell President Putin that the United States is going to put sanctions on you for what you did during the election in our our election uh and and those sanctions are coming President Biden told President Putin in this phone call the third thing he said was and I'm willing to meet you”

0.74

At the 2008 NATO summit in Bucharest, Ukraine and Georgia applied for NATO membership and a membership action plan; however, Western European nations opposed the plan while President Bush and the U.S. supported it, resulting in compromise language that Ukraine and Georgia 'will be in NATO' without specifying when or how.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· William Burns

“the language was basically we're not giving you this membership action plan approval today but you will be in NATO they didn't say when they didn't see they didn't say how this exactly would happen but they made the statement that Ukraine and Georgia will be in NATO”

0.74

After struggling in the 2008 Georgia invasion (despite a 28:1 population advantage over Georgia), Putin recognized his military was not strong enough and launched a major military modernization program, spending heavily on building a stronger, larger military in preparation for future conflicts to bring neighboring former Soviet states back into the Russian sphere.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· William Burns

“he eventually occupied 20 percent of Georgian territory where they still are they continued to occupy abkazia and North assetia that are part of Georgia uh but he President Putin realized that his military was not in good shape and that prompted an enormous military buildup on the part of the Russians he said we are going we need to have a strong military it if we are going to have to use military force to bring the Georgians or eventually the ukrainians back into the Empire we're going to need a bigger stronger military”

0.74

The Western response to the 2014 Crimea invasion took time to build; the Obama administration began slowly to pressure Russia through sanctions and weapons provision, but it was not until Russia shot down Malaysia Airlines Flight 17, killing 298 civilians over Russian-occupied territory, that Europeans came fully on board with serious sanctions.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· William Burns

“it took however the Russians shooting down a civilian Airline the Malaysia airline that killed 298 civilians it took that Massacre it took that Russian action to kill most the Europeans over occupied russian-occupied territory for the Europeans to come on board with these sanctions but they did and they came on board with these sanctions in in a strong way Europeans responded the United States pushed hard the sanctions went into place and then were re-imposed re-upped if you will every six months on the part of the Europeans”

0.74

In mid-July 2019, during a National Security Council meeting, an Office of Management and Budget staffer announced that security assistance to Ukraine was being put on hold on orders of the White House chief of staff from the President, shocking everyone in the meeting who believed this must be a mistake, as there was no advance warning or decision process.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· William Burns

“in 2019. there was a normal meeting of the National Security Council staff which was other participants of course State Defense NSC Embassy normal agenda at the end of this meeting mid-july 2019 a person from The Office of Management and budget in the White House offices raised her hand and said I've Been Told that the security assistance to Ukraine should be put on hold now this was a shock this was an answer to your question about how did you hear about it no one could believe what they heard no one where I was in cave we were watching this on the screen from Washington could believe it no one in Washington who was there in person could believe it it was it was out of the blue it was not the result of any decision that anybody had heard of”

0.74

In a July 2019 phone call, President Trump, after President Zelensky thanked him for providing Javelins, responded with 'yes but we need you to do us a favor,' followed by a request for Zelensky to pursue a political investigation, conditioning weapons assistance on a political favor—revealed later in the whistleblower transcript.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· William Burns

“when President Trump um when he was talking with President zielinski about these weapons indeed about javelins president zielinski had raised and had thanked president Trump for providing these javelins in this phone call and that allowed president Trump to say yes but we need you to do us a favor in the context of these weapons and the favor of course was to to do a political investigation of what would turn out to be president Trump's rival in the upcoming election”

0.73

Putin credits the United States with sponsoring the 2014 Ukrainian Euromaidan revolution and the removal of pro-Russian President Yanukovych, refusing to acknowledge that Ukrainian people themselves rose up against Yanukovych's decision to crack down on peaceful protesters—a fundamental misunderstanding of Ukrainian agency and self-determination.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· William Burns

“President Putin thinks apparently that the United States sponsored Ukrainian Independence Ukrainian opposition to Russia he goes back to 2014 when the pro-russian Ukrainian president Victor Yanukovych decides to crack down on innocent protesters peaceful protesters and try to clear the streets of cave of these protesters and that generated what we now know as the revolution of dignity Euro maidan in Ukraine this was this great outpouring of Ukrainian outrage at the insult of their dignity represented by their president Victor Yanukovych being so beholden to Putin and the Ukrainian people ran this President out of the country and President Putin was sure that the Americans were behind that”

0.73

In Putin's February 24, 2022 invasion speech, the first third to half of the speech focused on the United States rather than on Ukraine itself, revealing that Putin viewed the U.S. as the true enemy and the root cause of all his problems, with Ukraine as merely a battlefront in a larger conflict with America.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· William Burns

“he gives a speech and one of the remarkable things looking back at that speech which is sometimes called the Empire of live speech is that the first I don't know the first third first half is about the United States and he's invading Ukraine he's announcing a war that he calls a special military operation and yet his speech is about the United States what does that reveal so President Putin thinks that the United States is behind all his problems is the cause of all his problems”

0.69

Biden and Putin agreed in Geneva in June 2021 to establish 'strategic stability talks,' which are broader discussions about nuclear arms control including cyber, hypersonics, and emerging threats, and Russian and American experts met approximately three times over the following six months to discuss these issues before talks broke down.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· William Burns

“they agreed the President Biden President Putin agreed in Geneva in about this must have been about June now of 2021 they agreed to have their experts get together and talk about an issue that was important is important to both countries and that strategic stability and so these are the so-called strategic stability talks and strategic stability is what the experts refer to how the experts refer to discussions about nuclear arms control it's broader than just nuclear arms because it includes some of these new weapons it includes you know cyber includes uh hypersonics”

0.69

At the time of the 2014 Crimea invasion, President Yanukovych had allowed the Ukrainian military to deteriorate, hollow it out, and corrupt it, leaving Ukraine unable to mount any defense against Russian invasion and unable to expel Russian forces from Crimea or Donbas.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Expert/Policy Official)

“president janakovich the the kind of Russia leaning president of Ukraine at that time had allowed the Ukrainian Army to deteriorate to be hollowed out to be corrupted and was unable to to mount any kind of a defense”

0.68

Burns argues that the NATO decision to reject the membership action plan for Ukraine and Georgia in 2008 was a mistake that emboldened Putin, and that if NATO had approved the plan, Putin would not have had the strength to invade—therefore the Ukrainian invasion and current war would likely not be happening.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· William Burns

“I think that was a mistake I think that decision in Bucharest uh by the NATO heads of state and again NATO is a consensus organization you have to have everybody agree to a big decision big policy changes or a big policy decision so if there were a couple of Nations as there were Western European nations who said no then that meant that the NATO Summit could not invite Ukraine and Georgia to start the process and I I think that was a mistake fact is I I would say we'll never know this but if the decision had been to start the the process of joining NATO Putin was not in the position at that time he wasn't strong enough at that time to do what he is now doing in terms of the invasion of Ukraine and we wouldn't be fighting today my bet is the ukrainians wouldn't be fighting with our support against the Russian army had they been offered the membership action plan um in in 2008”

0.68

President Obama's public characterization of Russia as 'a regional power' lacking economic model, political model, or soft power, combined with U.S. focus on Asia, meant the Obama administration did not take Russia seriously as a strategic threat and allowed Putin space to pursue his Ukraine agenda.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· William Burns

“President Obama's comment that Russia was a problem but not a big problem not it's a regional power it's not a superpower it has nuclear weapons he of course acknowledged but it had nothing really Russia had nothing really else going for it didn't have a political model an economic model it didn't uh have uh any soft power that would attract other nations to to Ally with it and President Obama like other presidents saw Asia as a problem that needed attention and so he didn't focus on on Russia as he probably should have”

0.68

Putin learned from the 2014 sanctions that 'sanctions are a cost of doing business,' meaning he calculated that economic sanctions could be absorbed and worked around, and therefore sanctions alone would not deter him from further military action such as the 2022 invasion of Ukraine.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· William Burns

“people have told us that one of the things Putin Learned was sanctions are a cut of doing business we can build up you know as he's going to be contemplating further action”

0.68

The West's response to the 2008 Georgia invasion was inadequate—characterized by outrage, some sanctions, naval presence, and humanitarian supplies but nothing that would have sent a message to Putin that serious consequences awaited aggressive action, therefore it did not deter his subsequent invasions.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· William Burns

“the response to the Russian invasion of Georgia in 2008 August 2008 was outrage the Europeans were outraged French president got involved in some of the discussions the United States put some sanctions uh on the Georgians this is in 2008 United States made some show of force in terms of Naval presence in the Black Sea and of humanitarian supplies being flown in to Georgia in support of the Georgians but it was not the response that would have sent the message to President Putin that the West Was going to do anything really serious about his invasion”

0.66

Burns believes that Ukraine's importance to U.S. and international security was not widely understood as a 'broad understanding' until the 2022 invasion, though it was understood by the policy community; the war and Russian atrocities have since translated into broader political support.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· William Burns

“that understanding was clear to many of us but not clear as broadly as it is today today we understand that today we now see that Ukraine is a linchpin um in this order and that if the Russians are allowed to stay in Ukraine that that order that kept the peace and allowed for Prosperity over many many years after World War II the only way to re-establish that is is for the Russians to get out of Ukraine”

0.65

The Biden administration's response to the 2022 invasion has been exceptionally strong, coordinating military support from the U.S. and NATO nations, achieving international agreement on sanctions and export controls, and rallying the international community diplomatically at the UN and G7, representing one of the most concentrated diplomatic and military efforts in recent years.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· William Burns

“I think they've done a very good job I think they have mobilized the International Community certainly the West in three ways certainly on the military side the amount of support Military Support to Ukraine from the United States and from NATO Nations has been extraordinary and I give the white Administration credit for that push uh for for that that amazing support the second thing that they did well which is hard to do and that is get agreement on sanctions get International agreement on economic sanctions International agreement to cut off supplies of of components electronic opponents microchips to the Russians which can only be done effectively if it's done by most of the International Community and the by Administration did that both the sanctions and the export bans so that's a second major accomplishment the third is rallying the International Community at in places like the UN places like the G7 the political support for Ukraine the condemnation of the Russian invasion was as concentrated a diplomatic and international effort as as most people in the state department or in the US government have seen probably since the gulf Wars”

0.64

Secretary Pompeo committed to changing Trump's mind about Ukraine and took steps including getting Trump to sign a letter to newly inaugurated Ukrainian President Zelensky, which Trump had previously refused to do

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· William Burns

“secretary Pompeo said I will change his mind and I believe Secretary of Pompeo thought he could do that and he took a couple of steps that indicated that he would be able to do that he got president Trump to sign a letter to the newly inaugurated Ukrainian president which president Trump had refused to do earlier”

0.63

In fall 2021, Russian forces began moving back toward Ukraine's borders—not just the eastern border but all three borders: the Ukraine-Belarus border, the Ukraine-Russia border, and the Ukraine-Crimea border, plus the border with Russian forces still in Moldova, indicating a renewed and broader threat.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Expert/Policy Official)

“later on in the fall so a year ago now so in the fall of 2021 sure enough these Russian forces start moving back toward Ukraine's borders not just the eastern border but no the all three borders the Ukraine border with Belarus grain border with Russia grain border with occupied Crimea even the Ukraine border with Russian forces that are still in Moldova in Ukraine's Southwest”

0.62

The concern expressed by top Obama officials about providing advanced anti-tank weapons (Javelin) was that it would provoke Russia and cause Putin to escalate, reflecting a misguided fear that defensive weapons would trigger Russian aggression rather than deter it.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Expert/Policy Official)

“the concern was that if we provide these weapons somehow the Russians would be provoked and they might do things that we didn't want them to do was the argument from the Obama Administration”

0.61

Ukrainian leadership under President Zelensky in 2019 had been fighting Russia for five years and already lost 14,000 soldiers, and desperately needed US military, political, and financial support to prevail against Russian forces

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· William Burns

“the ukrainians we're talking about here now is the government so we're talking about President zielinski and his administration and here they've been fighting in 2019 they've been fighting the Russians for five years in donbass they'd lost 14 000 ukrainians already in that fight so there's a serious fight between the Russians and Ukraine the Ukraine is defending their own territory from a Russian invasion”

0.61

A series of escalating meetings at ever-higher levels of the US government—ultimately reaching the Principals level (Secretary of State, Secretary of Defense, National Security Advisor, CIA Director)—all reached consensus that the military assistance should not be paused and should be provided, yet the hold was not overturned.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Expert/Policy Official)

“this led to a series of meetings at ever higher levels within the U.S government chaired by the National Security Council and again higher levels higher levels all the way up to the principal's meeting which means the Secretary of State and Secretary of Defense and the National Security adviser and the and the director of the CIA were in these meetings and there was consensus at every level up to that level of the principles that this assistance should be provided should not be paused should not be on hold where was this decision coming from and we never got an answer we w continued to believe out in cave that it was a mistake that it was a that someone just didn't understand how important this assistance was”

0.61

In order to push back against Russian aggression, an international effort with sanctions from the United States, Europeans, Japanese, South Koreans, Australians, and Canadians was necessary because US sanctions alone would not be sufficient

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· William Burns

“you need to have a an international effort to impose sanctions on a nation individual just U.S Russian sanctions that's not going to work you need to have the Europeans you need to have the Japanese you need to have the South Koreans the Australians you need to have the Canadians you need an international effort”

0.61

The US system of government institutions (State Department, Defense Department, Congress) was ultimately able to correct what the speaker calls Trump's 'bad decision' and 'political decision' to hold Ukraine aid, by applying pressure through Congressional action that forced Trump to release the aid

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· William Burns

“fortunately the regular channel the establishment of U.S foreign policy that is created and executed by the state department by the defense department governed by laws passed by the Congress supported by the American people that foreign policy that regular channel prevailed in the end in the end it got a bad decision overturned a political decision overturned so in the end the ukrainians got the assistance”

0.59

The bipartisan support for Ukraine in the U.S. Congress and establishment was as valuable an asset to Ukraine as any military or financial asset, and therefore Zelensky and his administration went to great lengths to avoid jeopardizing this bipartisan consensus, even when receiving confusing requests from the Trump administration.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· William Burns

“they didn't want to jeopardize this bipartisan support that they knew was important for them the bipartisan support in Washington for Ukraine was as valuable as any asset they had anywhere that was what they needed and they needed the president they needed the Congress they needed the American people they needed to have the support of the Americans so they went out of their way to try to figure out how to get that support”

0.57

Putin is an extremely dangerous actor at this moment because he is facing military losses and domestic consequences from his invasion, is carrying out partial mobilization, and is threatening nuclear weapons, creating unpredictability about what he might decide to do next.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· William Burns

“undoubtedly a dangerous moment and undoubtedly depends on what's in President Putin's mind throughout our whole conversation we've been trying to figure out what is in prison Putin's mind we don't know and we won't know but what we do know is what we have to do what we do know is we have to oppose him”

0.56

The Biden administration, through National Security Advisor Jake Sullivan, has made clear that the U.S. will not be intimidated by Russian threats of nuclear weapons or claims that Ukrainian territories annexed through sham referenda are now Russian territory, and has warned of 'catastrophic consequences' for any Russian use of nuclear weapons.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· William Burns

“most recently the Administration has made it clear that they will not be cowed by irresponsible talk coming from Moscow about nuclear weapons they will not be cowed by irresponsible talk coming from Moscow about how after these sham referenda that the Russians have have conducted in parts of Ukraine that now give as the Russians say the ability the right for them to use all weapons at their disposal to defend Russian land no these Ukrainian territories are Ukrainian everybody in the world except the Russians recognize these are Ukrainian territories so the by demonstration has not been cowed the blind Administration has made it clear to the Russians coming from the National Security advisor that if they were to the Russians were to take any action along the lines of these threats that there would be catastrophic response catastrophic responses the word that that Jake Sullivan used”

0.56

Burns was prepared to resign from his position as acting ambassador to Ukraine because he believed the Trump administration's freezing of aid represented the reversal of the strong bipartisan support for Ukraine that had characterized every administration since Ukrainian independence, and he told Secretary Pompeo he would resign if that support changed.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· William Burns

“I told him I was probably not inclined to say yes um and he asked me why and I said Mr secretary your boss does not like Ukraine and I expected that to kind of end the interview it didn't secretary Pompeo said you know Bill you're right he doesn't like Ukraine but it's my job as Secretary of State to change that and I said the reason I'm not inclined to accept your request to go out to cave is that since your boss does not like Ukraine the strong support for Ukraine which had characterized every Administration since Ukrainian Independence but in particular during the time from 2014 to 2019 when the Russians had invaded that strong support was bipartisan was Administration after Administration the strong support for Ukraine was there was was established was supported by the Congress by the state department by the defense department but was not supported by the president and so I said I was worried the reason I was not inclined to go out there because I thought the president might change that support might reduce that by change the policy of strong support and in which case I was not the person they wanted out there I would not do it in that case so so secretary Pompeo said I will change his mind”

0.52

Putin probably saw President Trump's statements about being willing to have good relations with Russia and his famous comment 'why not have good relations with the Russians' as indicating that he would not face resistance to his plan to reabsorb Ukraine and other former Soviet nations.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Expert/Policy Official)

“we all know um the statements that President Trump made we all know the assertions that President Trump made that he could both deal with President Putin and indeed might even be friendly with President Putin he famously said why not have good relations with the Russians that's a good thing so President Putin probably thought that he would not encounter resistance to this effort that was clearly still in his mind from 2007 2000 the speech in Munich the the invasion of Georgia in 2008 the invasion of Ukraine in 2014 all that indicated where President Putin wanted to go he must have concluded that he would not get resistance from president Trump um to that plan to reabsorb First Ukraine and and then other nations that had become independent”

0.52

The Ukraine aid incident damaged American moral authority and created doubt in the minds of international actors about US reliability as an ally, though many nations ultimately saw the US as continuing to be a reliable ally because it righted itself and continued strong Ukraine support.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Expert/Policy Official)

“the ukrainians need the United States to support them other nations need the United States to support them as well and Nations other nations International actors evaluate U.S government daily all the time and constantly and they understand that things can go wrong they understand that there are decisions sometimes made by the United States or by individuals in the U.S government that are at odds with the thrust with the basic rightness of U.S policy...It probably caused some problems in in these nations capitals thinking about what's going on there what's going on but in the end the United States righted itself did the right thing provided the weapons continued to support Ukraine against the Russians and move forward”

0.43

President Putin's phone call with President Obama about Crimea was marked by Putin's denial: when told 'You've got your guys in Crimea,' Putin lied and denied it, complicating the US response and adding to the shock and confusion about what was actually happening on the ground.

factualestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Expert/Policy Official)

“there's a moment that we've heard that Putin liked to Obama who'd been told these were Russian soldiers and he said you've got your guys in Crimea and Putin just lied to you did that complicate the situation of course it did and and that Invasion uh sending these little green men sending these Russian soldiers without insignia into a neighboring country into Crimea was such a shock”

0.37

The New START treaty between the US and Russia expires in five years (from the 2022 timeframe, implying 2027), making the question of what follows it critical for nuclear stability and involving important debates about whether the Chinese participate in future arms control arrangements.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Expert/Policy Official)

“there's an issue there that is important for the United States important for Russia important for the rest of the world indeed that is the new start treaty which President Biden extended as soon as he was in office expires in five years and so the question for the Russians and the Americans and the Strategic stability expert Community is what happens after the new start treaty expires is there something to follow on is there something to expand is there something to continue do the Chinese play these questions are really important ones for the big issues of nuclear stability strategic stability”

0.29

After the whistleblower's revelation and pressure from senators, Trump released the aid, which occurred within a week of the whistleblower coming forward and coincided with the release of the phone call transcript at the UN General Assembly meetings.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Expert/Policy Official)

“in the end a week later whistleblower a week after that pressure on on President Trump and he allowed the assistance to go forward until the transcript was released...the end of September during the United Nations General Assembly meetings and president zielinski finally had a meeting in New York not in the Oval Office as promised with President Trump and president Trump said I'm going to release the transcript”