What this covers

This six-minute School of Life film is narrated by Alain de Botton. It treats modern anxiety and low-level depression as a byproduct of how society is organized, not as private failings. It grants that modern life brings real material gains, such as reliable dentistry and cars and easy long-distance communication. It then goes through six structural features, pairing each with a corrective that culture could adopt. The film adds that the forces producing distress are currently wealthier and more active than the cures, so society has little structural incentive to reduce anxiety.

The sharpest argument concerns meritocracy. If success is wholly deserved, failure must be too, and poverty turns from a material problem into moral evidence against the person. De Botton contrasts the modern "loser" with the unfortunate of pre-modern societies, and proposes cultural belief in luck and tragedy as the remedy. Individualism makes ordinariness feel like a curse, since it is what most people statistically get. The answer is a "cult of the good ordinary life," close to the idea of the Revalorization of Ordinariness. Secularism strips away any perspective larger than ourselves, so personal triumphs and mishaps feel like everything. Music, night skies, deserts and oceans are offered as regular sources of transcendence.

The remaining three turns are more unusual. Romanticism, the belief in one person who can make us completely happy, leaves most people disappointed with relationships that are decent in a few ways and difficult in many. The media is charged with steering attention toward fear and outrage, showing the least admirable side of human nature, and at its worst nudging audiences toward mob justice, while offering no way to act. Its cure would be solution-focused news that reminds viewers that the news they most need comes from their own lives. Finally, perfectibility, the idea that contentment and accomplishment are within reach, leaves people feeling they have wasted their lives. The film ends by asking for a culture that insists perfection is unattainable and values honest friends, and by suggesting that people born into modernity deserve tender pity.

Sharpest takeaway

Modern society's structural features—meritocracy, individualism, secularism, romanticism, media sensationalism, and perfectibility—systematically generate anxiety and depression, but each has identifiable cultural and psychological cures that societies can collectively implement.

  • Meritocracy reframes poverty as personal failure rather than misfortune, requiring cultural belief in luck and tragedy to restore compassion
  • Individualism makes ordinariness feel like failure, requiring revaluation of everyday life and friendship as sources of meaning
  • Secularism removes transcendent perspective on personal sorrows, requiring regular use of music, nature, and cosmic humility as antidotes

The claims · ranked20 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.84

Meritocratic societies tell citizens that success depends entirely on talent and effort, which creates the inverse corollary: any lack of success signals a personal deficit of talent or laziness rather than external misfortune.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Alain de Botton

“in our societies tell us that everyone is free to make it if they have the talent and energy the downside of this ostensibly liberating and beautiful idea is that any perceived lack of success is taken to be not as in the past an accident or misfortune but as a sure sign of a lack of talent or laziness”

0.84

In meritocratic societies, a successful person can be understood as deserving all their success, which logically means an unsuccessful person must deserve their failure, thereby converting poverty from a material problem into moral evidence of personal damnation.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Alain de Botton

“if those are the top deserve all their success then those at the bottom must surely deserve all their failure a society that thinks of itself as meritocratic turns poverty from a problem to evidence of damnation”

0.79

The media has immense prestige and a huge place in modern lives but routinely directs attention to things that scare, worry, panic, and enrage us while denying us agency or any chance for effective personal action.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Alain de Botton

“the media has immense prestige and a huge place in our lives but it routinely directs our attention to things that scare worry panic and enrage us while denying us agency or any chance for effective personal action”

0.73

The media typically attends to the least admirable aspects of human nature while denying audiences balancing exposure to normal good intentions, responsibility, and decency, and at its worst edges audiences toward mob justice.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Alain de Botton

“It typically attends to the least admirable sight of human nature without a balancing exposure to normal good intentions responsibility and decency at its worst it edges us towards mob justice”

0.55

Modern society provides material benefits like reliable dentistry, reliable cars, and ease of long-distance communication, but simultaneously generates high background anxiety and widespread low-level depression through its structural features.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Alain de Botton

“the modern world is wonderful in many ways dentistry is good cars are reliable we can so easily keep in touch from Mexico with our grandmother in Scotland but it's also powerfully and tragically geared to causing a high background level of anxiety and widespread low-level depression”

0.55

Meritocratic societies create a category of people they call 'losers'—those who have failed—rather than treating them as unfortunates deserving of compassion as pre-modern societies did.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Alain de Botton

“those who have failed from unfortunates to losers”

0.55

The cure for meritocracy's psychological damage requires culturally endorsed belief in two concepts: luck (acknowledging that success depends on factors beyond personal talent and effort) and tragedy (accepting that good, decent people can fail through circumstances beyond their control and deserve compassion rather than contempt).

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Alain de Botton

“The Cure is a strong culturally endorsed belief in two big ideas Luck which says success doesn't just depend on talent and effort and tragedy which says good decent people can fail and deserve compassion rather than contempt”

0.55

Individualistic societies preach that the individual and their achievements are everything, that everyone is capable of a special destiny, and that community and groups are hopeless, making ordinariness feel like a curse because it is statistically what most people will be.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Alain de Botton

“an individualistic society preaches that the individual and their achievements are everything and that everyone is capable of a special destiny it's not the community that matters the group is for no hopeless to be ordinary is regarded as a curse the result is that the very thing that most of us will end up being statistically speaking is associated with Frank failure”

0.55

The cure for individualism's psychological damage requires cultivating a 'cult of the good ordinary life' with proper appreciation of the pleasures and quiet heroism of everyday experience.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Alain de Botton

“The cure is a cult of the good ordinary life and proper appreciation of the pleasures and quiet heroism of the everyday”

0.55

Secular societies cease to believe in anything bigger than or beyond themselves, losing the psychological function that religion traditionally performed of keeping human petty ways and status battles in perspective.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Alain de Botton

“secular societies cease to believe in anything that is bigger than or beyond themselves religions used to perform the useful service of keeping our petty ways and status battles in perspective”

0.55

The forces of psychological distress in the modern world are currently much wealthier and more active than the cultural cures needed to address them, meaning societies have structural incentives to perpetuate anxiety rather than reduce it.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Alain de Botton

“the forces of psychological distress in our world are currently much wealthier and more active than the needed cures”

0.47

The cure for secularism requires regularly using sources of transcendence—music, the stars at night, vast spaces like deserts or oceans—to generate a benign, relativizing perspective on personal sorrows.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Alain de Botton

“a cure would involve regularly using sources of transcendence to generate a benign relativizing perspective on our personal sorrows music the stars at night the vast spaces of the desert or the ocean would humble us all in consoling ways”

0.47

The cure for romanticism requires realizing we did not go wrong in our relationships but were simply encouraged to believe in an improbable dream, and instead building ambitions around friendship and sexual love as sources of meaning rather than around perfect soulmate union.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Alain de Botton

“The cure is to realize that we didn't go wrong we were just encouraged to believe in a very improbable dream instead we should build up our ambitions around friendship and sexual love”

0.47

In secular societies without transcendence, human triumphs and mishaps end up feeling like the be-all and end-all, causing psychological distress because personal concerns lack perspective or diminishment.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Alain de Botton

“but now there is nothing to all or relativize humans whose triumphs and mishaps end up feeling like the be-all and end-all”

0.47

Romanticism—a philosophy telling us each of us has one very special person who can make us completely happy—creates psychological damage because most people must settle for moderately bearable relationships with someone who is nice in a few ways and difficult in many others.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Alain de Botton

“the philosophy of Romanticism tells us that each of us has one very special person out there who can make us completely happy yet mostly we have to settle for moderately bearable relationships with someone who is very nice in a few ways and pretty difficult in many others it feels like a disaster in comparison with our original huge hopes”

0.47

The cure for media's psychological damage would be news that focuses on presenting solutions rather than generating outrage, that is alive to systemic problems rather than gleefully emphasizing scapegoats or emblematic monsters, and that regularly reminds audiences that the news they most need comes from their own lives and direct experiences.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Alain de Botton

“The Cure would be news that focused on presenting solutions rather than generating outrage that was alive to systemic problems rather than gleefully emphasizing scapegoats or emblematic monsters and that would regularly remind us that the news we most need comes from our own lives and direct experiences”

0.47

Modern societies stress that it is within human remit to be profoundly content, sane, and accomplished, which results in people level-setting themselves, feeling weak, and sensing they have wasted their lives when they fail to achieve this unattainable standard.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Alain de Botton

“modern societies stress that it is within our remit to be profoundly content sane and accomplished as a result we end up leveling ourselves feeling weak and sensing that we've wasted our lives”

0.47

The cure for perfectibility requires a culture that endlessly promotes the idea that perfection is not within human grasp, that being mentally slightly unwell and apathetic is an inescapable part of the human condition, and that what people need above all is good friends with whom they can sit and honestly discuss real fears and vulnerabilities.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Alain de Botton

“a cure would be a culture that endlessly promotes the idea that perfection is not within our grasp that being mentally slightly and appoints very unwell is an inescapable part of the human condition and that what we need above all our good friends with whom we can sit and honestly discuss our real fears and vulnerabilities”

0.47

Despite the structural obstacles to change, cures for modern anxiety are now open to individuals and collectives if they recognize with sufficient clarity the sources of their true anxieties and sorrows.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Alain de Botton

“but more hopefully cures are now open to us individually and collectively if only we recognized with sufficient clarity the sources of our true anxieties and sorrows”

0.43

People deserve tender pity for the psychological price they have to pay for being born in modern times.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Alain de Botton

“we deserve tender pity for the price we have to pay for being born in modern times”