
The Negotiating MASTERCLASS | Chris Voss and Shane Parrish
What this covers
This is a long conversation between Chris Voss, a former FBI hostage negotiator, and Shane Parrish. It starts with how Voss came to the work and what his first annual review taught him: negotiating skill is perishable, and trained negotiators pick up bad habits within a year if they stop practicing. From there it becomes a critique of the standard negotiation playbook, set against Voss's own toolkit. That toolkit includes labels, the negotiation one-sheet used for preparation, and the idea that curiosity about the other side is also a way to regulate your own emotions.
The middle of the conversation takes on conventional wisdom directly. Voss calls BATNA intellectually brilliant but practically harmful, because it becomes a threshold you settle at. He says high anchoring starts from dishonesty and frames the deal as win-lose. Compromise, in his telling, produces half-measures, and he illustrates it with a company that built a new learning center while keeping its old headquarters. He also says Getting to Yes would read differently if it had been written after current work on emotional intelligence. Against these, he offers a contested claim that letting the other side speak first takes less total time than opening with your own position.
The conversation then widens to the psychology underneath. Voss ties loss aversion to the prospect theory of Danny Kahneman and Amos Tversky, argues that deal-breakers should be cleared before value is pitched, and says half of one telecom's signed deals never get implemented. He describes three response types (fight, flight, make friends) and how each reacts differently to questions and statements. Other threads include the soothing voice and mirror neurons, flow state, and deference as a tool across power differentials. The closing stretch covers negotiating with kids and partners, and judging whether someone can be trusted.
Chris Voss argues that effective negotiation relies on tactical empathy and understanding the other party's emotional drivers (especially loss aversion) rather than traditional positional tactics like high anchoring or fixed BATNAs, making emotional intelligence the core skill for faster, more durable agreements.
- Letting the other side speak first saves time and gathers critical information about their true constraints and fears
- Fear of loss is 2-3x more powerful than desire for gain in driving decisions, so identifying and addressing deal-breakers matters more than selling benefits
- Implementation quality depends on whether the agreement was the other side's idea, making collaborative approaches superior to win-lose tactics
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Skills in negotiation and emotional intelligence are perishable—trained negotiators become noticeably worse within a year if they do not practice actively, as evidenced by Voss's first annual review where a supervisor identified bad habits accumulated after initial sharp training.
“the go tasted skills are perishable and you don't know they they wrote it visibly you get done with your training and if you go through good training you're sharp I mean you're on it you know you're on it you know you're very sharp and you don't know that it's perishable so I finished my training I remember I was sharp because I was a bunch of people in a that were all sharp and the training was good and a year later I had no idea how many bad habits I picked up”
Getting the other side talking and collaborative by gently saying 'how am I supposed to do that?' to problematic requests is highly effective because the phrasing makes the other side feel collaborative and powerful, more likely to throw out alternative options that work for both parties.
“if you get you get the other side talking and you're very collaborative if you find a way to gently say no to the bad stuff like how am I supposed to do that it's a great way to say no to something bad how am I supposed to do that and the other side feels very collaborative they feel a lot of collaboration there and they feel very powerful and the more likely to throw out some more options”
It is possible to underpay someone and still have them be highly satisfied if you are focused on their growth, development, and involvement in meaningful work; meaningful work and professional development are stronger motivators than money.
“you can actually fix that too depending upon how you take care of them as an employee like if you can under pay somebody and if you're really focused on their growth and development as people and professionals they'll be really happy in the job and they'll do great because you know the old phrase money is not a motivator what is a motivator the meaningful work within that profession”
In negotiation, letting the other side speak first will take less total time than initiating with your own position, contrary to the intuitive belief that directness is the fastest route to agreement.
“if you let the other side go first it'll take less time you know we used to a judge in a federal trial that had a great saying he says we're gonna delay things in order to save time and we think in the the most direct route you know let me just tell you what I want so you can give it to me like that's the most direct route and it's a mess”
BATNA (best alternative to negotiated agreement) is intellectually brilliant but practically a horrible idea because it becomes your goal, and once you pass that threshold, you stop negotiating and settle for less, when in fact having no BATNA (or letting it go entirely) puts you in a better mindset.
“you know again intellectually brilliant idea and practice a horrible idea...here's here's the problem with bad net that becomes your goal and so therefore if you say to yourself and the vast majority of people who calculate their Batna you know as long as I do better than my worth alternative as soon as I get past that I'm good and I can quit right”
The best indicator of future behavior is past behavior; if a company has poor follow-up historically, expect them to continue having poor follow-up regardless of promises.
“the best indicator of future behavior is past me here so if I'm dealing with a company that has horrible follow-up I should expect them to continue to have horrible follow I can't trust them to suddenly be smart”
Compromise is intellectually sound but practically harmful because it creates half-measures that destroy everybody's idea; an example is a company that compromised by building both a new learning center and keeping old headquarters, wasting hundreds of millions and causing executive departures, when choosing one would have been optimal.
“compromise is I got this killer gray suit and I got a pair of black shoes that I love and I got a pair of brown shoes that I love I think I should wear the black shoes you think the brown shoes are gonna look great let's compromise I'll wear one black and one brown I mean compromise in in in theory supposedly you're open to the other side's position theoretically that's a great idea in practicality its implementation is absolutely one black shoe one brown shoe her earnest story recently of a horrible compromised two companies are merging...they found out there's this phenomenal building worth eight hundred million dollars for sale they get a chance to get it for two hundred million dollars...the CEO from the prestigious...firm says we can't do that because we'll look like it'll violate what we stand for...the guy from the new...company was like we got we how could we how could we pass this up...so what they do they compromised they bought the building for the new Learning Center they kept their old headquarters too for the images in fact they're wasting hundreds of millions of dollars because of the compromise”
Anchoring high (opening with an inflated initial offer) is a bad recommendation because it starts with dishonesty, defines the negotiation as win-lose, and risks leaving significant money on the table due to psychological adjustment effects.
“you got to go first you got you got hanker high and you know in practice that interferes with collaboration if you anchor high it's it's basically it's starting out by not telling the truth it's defining it as a win-lose scenario and it's also taking it's taking a risk of leaving a tremendous amount of money on the table”
Flow is a mental state where pattern recognition, decision-making, mental endurance, and overall performance peak; X Games athletes aren't physically superior but achieve performance equivalent to doubling their vertical jump through flow state.
“flow is where your pattern recognition and your decision-making is at its peak your mental endurance increases and your overall performances is much better like X Games athletes are doing things that the world thought was previously physically impossible are they physically can an X game athlete is their vertical jump five feet instead of two feet no but their performance in what they're doing is the equivalent of taking a vertical jump and doubling it or tripling it but they're physically the same specimen”
70% of purchase decisions are made more to avoid loss and prevent problems than to accomplish gain or seize opportunities, emphasizing that understanding the other side's fears and deal-breakers matters more than selling benefits.
“there's an interesting stat out there that says 70% of the buy decisions are made more to avoid loss and to accomplish gain so think of the reasons why they wouldn't do business with you first”
Prospect theory, developed by Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky (who won the Nobel Prize posthumously; Tversky died before the prize was awarded), shows that fear of loss is 2x more powerful than desire for equivalent gain—a principle that hostage negotiators had discovered empirically decades before prospect theory was formulated.
“Danny Kahneman and Amos Tversky come along and unfortunately you know when the Nobel Prizes handed out Amos Tversky has already died of cancer otherwise he would have got it all so the kind of and Traverse could come up with prospect theory and win the Nobel Prize for it after hostage negotiations been invented which is the fear of loss is the single biggest driver of human behavior prospect theory says you know law strengths things twice as much as an equivalent game”
Using a soothing, calming tone of voice activates mirror neurons in the listener's brain, which can calm them down; additionally, speaking positive self-statements aloud in a soothing tone (rather than internally) can calm the speaker themselves by triggering this same neural mechanism.
“on a suicide hotline I learned really early on the soothing calming tone call me other side down but you know there's there's a reason why if you talk to yourself sometimes you're actually smarter if you talk out loud in a soothing calming voice that voice comes out of your mouth it goes through the air comes back and through your ear and hits your mirror neurons and calm you down so if you say to yourself out loud not internally but if you say to yourself out loud you know you got this you got this I got this I can do this you can actually calm yourself down”
Never be mean to somebody who could hurt you by doing nothing; even in transactional interactions like ordering music rights from a corporation, the person taking the order can delay, deprioritize, or 'lose' your request if they feel disrespected, making time an indirect negotiation commodity.
“never be mean to somebody who could hurt you by doing nothing so the reality is that's probably true of everybody you interact with because you're interacting with them because you want them to do something...so depending upon if she takes the other person for granted that person writes down her information and her order does he put it on the top of his pilot as he put it on the bottom of the pile because he didn't like being treated like by like an order taker if if she approached him an emotionally intelligent way maybe not only does he not put it on the top of the pile maybe by hand he walks it down the hall to the next person in the chain because of time is money and time is always an asset in the negotiation”
Preparing for a negotiation should focus on being genuinely curious and prepared to learn rather than on knowing everything, because the other side will provide critical information faster than any preparation could.
“it's impossible to know everything going in to start with and it's a lot faster to hear it from the other side so prepare to be genuinely curious you know like and tell yourself you know that's a pretty cool stuff here if I if I can if I can just find out what it is”
The most effective close to a deal is when the other side proposes a solution and you respond 'that was brilliant, let's do that,' because this makes implementation more likely—they will execute more effectively with fewer reminders if the solution was their idea.
“the real the real issue with any deal is implementation it's not agreement yes is nothing without how I can I can give you fake yeses all day long and you're never gonna get what you wanted and that's that's why you want it to be the other side's idea because they'll implement more effectively and with fewer reminders and fewer follow-up if the implementation was their idea”
Deference is a powerful tool that works across all power differentials (when the other side is superior, equal, or subordinate to you) because people appreciate and respect genuine deference from those who don't need to offer it.
“deference is this great tool for 360 degrees of influence if someone is perceives themselves to be superior to you and you're deferential to them they love it because they think that they a they're entitled to it so makes them very happy if you're on a peer level with them and you're deaf you treat them with deference they love it because you didn't have to and they felt tremendous respect and appreciation for if your subordinate to them in any way and your deferential to how they feel they loved it even more”
Deal-breakers should be identified and eliminated before pitching positive value, because ignoring them leaves land mines; most businesses waste time pitching value propositions while completely missing the deal-breakers that will prevent implementation.
“eliminate deal-breakers before you can make deals you cannot leave land mind deal breakers out there and I think most people are you know we're taught over and over and over again in business what's our value proposition which is very one-sided point of view of things and takes and takes into account in no way shape or form what the deal-breakers are and that's why with that telecommunications company I was telling you about 50% of their deals never get implemented because I'm not paying any attention to deal breakers and that's how costly that is”
Different personality types respond differently to questions versus statements; the analytical/flight-oriented type resists questions and prefers to think through answers, so saying 'it seems like you have some next steps in mind' triggers immediate response, while asking 'what are the next steps?' causes them to delay and say 'let me get back to you.'
“the flight the analytical type guy is very leery of questions and if I ask you a question even if it's a really good opening a question a really good calibrated question like what do you think the next steps are our analytical flight oriented guy which is basically not fight every battle but fight only if I have to and they need to and it's smart but the analyst is going to want to think about that answer for an extended period of time because they want to think through all the implications of the answer before they come up with it so if I say what are the next steps to an analyst and now it's gonna say you know let me get back to you in a week mmm but if I say for whatever reason seems like you got some next steps in mind the analyst is very likely to board him right out”
The second step of the negotiation one-sheet is to identify the 'crazy wacko bizarro schizophrenic' fears and concerns that the other side might harbor about you in the back of their mind, because fear is a major deal-killer and addressing it proactively eliminates a mine field.
“then start to look for emotionally intelligent what are the crazy wacko bizarro schizophrenic reasons fears that the other side might have in a back of their mind about us and a lot of this is really kind of intuitive but if you're a bigger company than they are then a fear that they might have in the back of their mind is that you're gonna bully well that they see you as bullies so take the circumstances and if you were a neutral third party what are the fears the other side might have and lay out what those fears are because fear gets in a way of deals anyway from 3 to 9 times more than benefits make deals”
Genuine curiosity about why the other party is behaving the way they are acts as an immediate hack for emotional control and self-regulation, because focusing on understanding them naturally compartmentalizes one's own emotional reactions.
“one technique is you're really focused on using your radar or your sonar or whatever metaphor or your gut instinct your intuition if I'm really focused on what emotions are driving you there's an instant compartmentalization that takes place where my negativity is no longer gonna get my way I mean just in genuine curiosity is a hack for emotional control if I'm genuinely like I'm genuinely curious as to why you're crazy you know that's that's an that's one instant hack”
Of a major telecommunications company's signed deals, fully 50% never get implemented; this represents a massive hidden cost that rivals or exceeds the cost of making better deals in the first place.
“we were in competition for a negotiation contract with one of the major telecommunications companies and through the process of that found out that fully 50% of the deals they sign never get implemented half Wow their signatures talked about they're killing themselves on implementation I mean they are destroying their profit”
Labels (statements like 'it seems like you have some next steps in mind') are more effective at unlocking information than direct questions, because labels bypass the cognitive processing required by questions and tap directly into the other side's thought stream.
“labels...if I ask you a question it has a tendency to get you to stop and think and contemplate and formulate an answer if I just use a label it seems like you've got something on your mind there's something about that that instead of you formulating an answer it tends to just remove a barrier and I tap directly into your thought processes and your thought processes come streaming out of your mouth so it's almost like you eliminate the system to thinking and just get the raw system won”
The order-taker (music licensing company employee) has more discretion than apparent: they can place a request at the top of the pile, bottom of the pile, or in the trash based on how they are treated, which means implementation time (a form of value) is a direct function of relationship quality.
“depending upon if she takes the other person for granted that person writes down her information and her order does he put it on the top of his pilot as he put it on the bottom of the pile because he didn't like being treated like by like an order taker if if she approached him an emotionally intelligent way maybe not only does he not put it on the top of the pile maybe by hand he walks it down the hall to the next person in the chain because of time is money and time is always an asset in the negotiation”
There are three primary human response types to threat (fight, flight, make friends), and the world splits roughly evenly into thirds: about one-third are direct/assertive types, one-third are accommodators, and one-third are analytical types who prefer distance.
“the assertive voice is the direct and honest guy you know just here's what I won't give it to me if you think of and the world breaks up in a pretty much evenly into thirds it's our caveman days its fight/flight make friends response to threat we do fight it we've run from that oh we make friends with it and the world really does pretty evenly split up into thirds and so about a third of the planets the direct and honest”
The phrase 'you never get fired for hiring IBM' reflects loss aversion: people are willing to fail in a socially acceptable way (IBM fails → it's 'IBM's fault') rather than risk novel failure (hiring Jobs and Wozniak fails → it's your fault for taking a risk), because novel failure damages self-esteem more than predictable failure.
“you never get fired for hire an IBM is like if we hire IBM and we fail it's already demonstrated to be a socially acceptable outcome but let's say let's if we go out you know when when was when was Apple started when do they first make the first Mac if we go out and hire these guys you know named Jobs and Wozniak that built some stupid computer in their garage you know that could go bad...so let's hire IBM first because that's that's the safe failure right”
Voss believes there are deeply ingrained 'two lines of code' (core beliefs formed in childhood) that drive behavior; something someone said when a person was young becomes a foundational belief that shapes their direction, and identifying and changing these core beliefs can help people avoid self-defeating patterns.
“I was one of the things that talking to my girlfriend recently I was saying like you know I think everybody's got two lines of code somewhere deep down inside somebody said something to everybody when we were little kids there was like our two line of Mad two lines of magic code in there and figuring out what the code is those two lines is what really drives the direction of people go and something you know something it has to do with self-esteem it has to do with you know I met a guy one time who was was he was a surprise to his family you know they thought they were done having kids and ten years after they were done having kids you know another one is on his way and he used to love to tell this guy he was an accent and he grew up that his two lines of code you know that I mean that makes the animals made him feel like he was unwanted right”
Getting to Yes is an intellectually sound framework but falls short in practice because it does not adequately account for human emotions, passion, and emotional intelligence; Voss observes that if the framework had been written after current understanding of emotional intelligence, it would have been a different book.
“getting to tes is intellectually sound there's nothing intellectually to be challenged on getting to yes and unfortunately that does you know good as soon as you involve human beings because none of us really it elects lease out you know we're all driven by emotion of passion and emotional intelligence if we didn't own as much about specifically articulating emotional intelligence like we do now as we did when getting tes was written I think that would have been a different book”
Flow state operates in a highly positive frame of mind bordering on euphoria, which combines with emotional intelligence to improve business negotiation and decision-making; historically negotiators were trained to be dispassionate, but flow offers a better alternative.
“flow is where your pattern recognition and your decision-making is at its peak...flow is where your pattern recognition and your decision-making is at its peak your mental endurance increases and your overall performances is much better...flow is a highly positive frame of mind bordering on it's fun they're having fun bordering on euphoria their pattern recognition and their decision-making is near perfect in that state of mind that's what we need a business we need more mental endurance we need better pattern recognition we need fearless decision-making - as soon as fear drops away we can think better it's a positive frame of mind”
The negotiation one-sheet framework begins with a completely truthful, spin-free summary of the facts and circumstances that have brought both parties to the table, which the other side would agree is accurate; this foundation is essential for subsequent steps.
“take a take a completely truthful version of what are the facts and circumstances have brought us here to get today you know don't put any spin on it from your side you know a summary summary of the facts just the facts man and not not because say something like well were the smartest people that ever lived and if they had any sense they should be doing business for us it's not a summary the facts you know and really drive for a summary that the other side would agree is true again the no spin zone is real hard”
The monetary goal should not actually be the final goal, because beating someone badly on price can result in poor implementation and putting them out of business; instead, a negotiator should arrive at a dollar figure that the other side is comfortable with, because comfortable parties implement more effectively.
“your high goal mei-mei shouldn't actually be money because you gotta hit a range in money let's say let's say you beat somebody on the money issue really badly well your implementation is gonna be horrible or you're gonna put them out of business so you need to come up with a dollar figure the other side is comfortable for”
A Washingtonian magazine editor found that paying employees at the higher end of their salary expectations (rather than lower or exactly at their target) resulted in better performance and satisfaction, because they felt valued rather than anxious or taking the salary for granted.
“a friend of mine was running a magazine when he ran Washingtonians magazine in Washington DC and we talked about salary negotiations and he said you know I tend to pay slightly on the higher end of people's expectations because if I pay him lower than they hoped for they tend to be really anxious throughout the term of their employment and you're not going to do a good job if I pay more than they expected they actually they're gonna think they were worth that all along and they're not gonna be that appreciative they're gonna take it for granted but if I can pay him at the higher end of their expectation they're gonna feel really good about the salary they'll be very comfortable and that's when they're gonna be at their best”
Better relationships with the people you interact with create options and opportunities they will offer you that you didn't know existed; people want to help those they like if given the chance.
“I want to get every edge I can so I want people to feel like helping me or even offering to help me in ways I didn't even know they could do and and that's where we gain our edges across the board with everybody in my company and also with the people that we coach because the better your relationship is the more the other side is going to want to help you out if they have an option to and people have tons of options that most of us don't even know about”
Active listening is important, but 'proactive listening' is better—listening with a specific purpose, proactively listening for where negatives and fears are located so they can be addressed directly.
“and it's you know what in it and then see beyond active it's proactive listener because all right so what am i proactively going after I know that the negatives are a bigger deal I'm proactively listening for where the negatives are I'm proactively listening for their fear of loss having hearted now I have a very specific toolkit designed to deal with that”
The difference between 'okay' and 'okay with empathy' can be detected in tone of voice; empathy allows a negotiator to identify when the other side is genuinely okay versus when there's something lurking beneath the surface.
“when you're trying to Telegraph there's a problem in your tone of voice if you ask me if something is possible and I say okay or if you ask me if it's possible I go okay with empathy I know the difference between those two things I got a set of tools proactively where I go right after the second one and I'll say you know it sounds like there's more here than meets the eye”
Empathy works where people are involved; even sociopaths and emotionally constrained individuals are driven by loss aversion and self-interest, so tactical empathy (finding their drivers) works on everyone regardless of emotional range.
“I don't again it only works where people are involved yeah but even somebody who doesn't have a full range of emotion still got and I don't care what the range is I just need these my proactive skills you know my tactical empathy skills to figure out where your drivers are everybody's driven by laws you know are our social paths which there is no shortage of them functioning in the business world they're self-interested they have desires they're driven by loss loss aversion there's no get around and unless unless you're catatonic there's gonna be emotions that are driving you”
Negotiation skills can be used to manipulate or for genuine understanding; emotional intelligence is powerful and can be 'used for good or evil,' so the intent behind using these skills matters ethically.
“Grant wrote an order great article called the dark side of emotional intelligence like you know we joke around use your use your use your powers for good and not evil but emotional intelligence really powerful thing it's potentially ridiculously manipulative use it in your relationships if you're trying to make things better like are you are you trying to get the other side to just lay off of you and go back to what you're doing are you trying to actually understand more so you could have a better relationship”
Trust is better understood as 'predictability'—the ability to forecast what someone will do based on past behavior; this frame removes emotional judgment and enables more rational decision-making about whether to continue dealing with someone.
“take the word trust out and put it in predictable what am I gonna deck these people are gonna do yeah if you can substitute the word predict for trust or predictable for trust then put you in a much more rational frame of mind and you and you can see things easier and then you can make better decisions”
The biggest difference between people open to learning and those resistant to it is an embarrassment factor: people resistant to learning are deeply embarrassed by being wrong, and new ideas threaten their self-concept, making it difficult for them to accept feedback even when their performance is failing.
“what do you think the difference is between the people who are open to learning and not open to learning I think there's I think there's an embarrassment factor I think people are really embarrassed of being wrong I I you know that's kind of the only way I can can couch it because I I know that I'm I know that I'm very open to learning and I know that there are a bunch of people out there that are not and I am kind of mystified by by myself and so when I'm trying I got a few of those in our classes you know for a company brings all their sales people in it's gonna be some people in there that that are before the year is out are gonna get fired by that company because they didn't make their numbers and they're not open to learning”
Mirrors—repeating the last one to three words of what someone has said—cause them to re-engage with their own statement in a slightly different way, increasing their thinking and self-reflection.
“another one that a lot of parents have a lot of success with is also the mirror which is just repeating the last one two three words on what someone has just said I mean and you know sometimes your kids say stuff to you what you want to say to yourself did you actually hear what you just said I the only one that heard how crazy that was right but the mirror actually gets them to reliated again with slightly different words”
Real estate agents universally face a preconceived fear in buyers' and sellers' minds that they are only motivated by commission and will exploit clients; acknowledging this fear proactively (via labels like 'I'm sure you think real estate agents are just trying to get a quick commission') is far more effective than denying it, because denial makes it worse.
“every buyer and seller of a house they all say to each other look your real estate agent is not on your side real estate agents are only there to get a fast buck...just because it's not true if you doesn't mean that it's not in in your potential clients in the back of their mind before before they get started...if it's lurking in the back of their mind it's a distraction so let's let's go back again and let's take it to circumstances that if you weren't involved you know what's a reputation in the industry what's the reputation of the people in your position let's address that up front”
A negotiator's goal should be lofty and aspirational, not the BATNA or worst alternative; they should set a high goal and challenge themselves to beat it by discovering new information, because human beings are goal-oriented and perform better with ambitious targets.
“we do want you to pick out a good goal to begin with cuz human beings are goal oriented but we don't want your goal to be your best alternative or your worst alternative you know come up with a lofty goal and then think of how you're gonna beat it so human beings need to do in fact need to be goal-oriented in order to perform which is the old bat and a problem because a battement your goal in is very low pick a high goal and then challenge yourself to beat it by discovering new information”
The parable of the Scorpion and the Frog illustrates that if someone's nature is to betray (they are a 'scorpion'), the frog's mistake is not in helping them but in leaving itself vulnerable; instead, put the scorpion on a twig to tow them across, so they cannot sting.
“another analogy I like I think everybody knows the story the Scorpion a frog trying scorpions try to get across a river and he jumps on a frog's back and the Frog says you know if you sting me then we'll both drown and we'll both die scorpion says why would I ever do that they get halfway across the river to skort store scorpion stings them and the folks is why'd you do that Scorpion said I'm a scorpion it's in my nature yeah so the frogs mistake not was not in helping the Scorpion the Frog you know put put the scorpion on on a twig and tow him across so that he can't stab you right if he's gonna stab me that doesn't mean I can't collaborate it just means that I'd be stupid if I don't think I'm gonna get stabbed”
The smallest and most powerful habit Voss practices is letting the other side articulate what's burning on their mind before inserting his own agenda; this saves time, builds relationships, and makes people feel heard and appreciated.
“I think just taking a moment to let the other side articulate what's really burning on their mind the the the other person is gonna be highly appreciative with that and you're gonna save a lot of time you know again it's a great mercenary missionaries skill saves you a lot of time it has better relationships people are gonna like dealing with you even more if they get a chance to have their say and if they feel really listened to the amount of time it takes to have their say tends to be really short because people find being listened to being very satisfying”
A new or unknown startup can use its lack of established track record to its advantage in negotiation by acknowledging the fear directly ('I know you're taking a risk on an unknown company') and thus reducing the barrier to deal-making.
“if you're a new company and you have no real established track record hey is there a way to use that to your advantage or shape the perceptions of somebody taking a risk on you yeah because again then then you call it out you know the elephant in the room so to speak you can call it out and it's not that it's guaranteed that you're gonna make the deal if you caught it call that out it just increases your batting average”
When standing in front of an audience for the first time, calling out a fear directly ('seems like listening to a hostage negotiator is a really dumb idea') is more effective than ignoring it, because the audience will articulate their objection and Voss can then address it, rather than leaving it as a hidden barrier.
“before all you know before we've had this kind of success with the book if I stood up in front of a group I would say to him why in god's name would you ever listen to a hostage negotiator because that's what's going on they're on in their head right they're asking themselves that question so I'll just go ahead I'll call it out for the very beginning boy seems like listen to a hostage negotiators a really dumb idea and people go like no it's not maybe you might you might not you might know something we don't know and I'm like okay good I got you to say it that's why I don't have to yet”
The direct and honest (assertive) voice type, when used in its natural state without modulation, comes across as blunt and brick-like, often obscuring the speaker's message despite their intent to be clear; this is particularly problematic for naturally assertive people.
“I once had of an FBI hostage negotiator when I was just talking to him in my natural normal tone of voice he said dealing with you is like getting hit in the face with a brick that's what their direct and honest voice does if you think of yourself as a direct and honest person and you're just trying to get your point across you're so blunt that it obscures your message right”
An executive from the General Services Administration advised to 'run to trouble'—focusing on the company's biggest problems is advantageous because failure is already baked in, risk is low, and success makes one a known problem-solver and increases job satisfaction and future earning potential.
“I had a an executive from the General Services Administration who got ahead really fast he once said run to trouble like if you like working on the company's biggest problems there's a couple good things about that I mean if the company's really having some serious problems in a certain area number one you're not gonna make it any worse you're not gonna be the guy that screwed that up because it's already screwed up so it's like a failsafe area to be in and then if you succeed you become known as a troubleshooter”
Teenagers persist in asking for things they've already been told no to, not because they're particularly stubborn, but because they've learned that people become more open-minded after saying no—once a parent feels protected by saying no, they are more willing to hear the other side out.
“teenagers have learned that once a parent says no they're probably actually more persuadable because the act of saying no makes people feel safe like when my son was 17 and he said dad can I and I'm saying now before he finished his sentence yeah but then I would also having said no having felt like I protected myself I would almost always find myself saying I not talk me through this again let me hear this because I've already said no so I can't be hurt”
Voss is willing to do business with people he dislikes if it benefits his company, and he accepts this as a calculated risk ('having a tiger by the tail'), as long as he is not self-deceived about the other party's intentions.
“I you know you can sniff that out pretty fast so a lot of it really has to do with you know not as the other person trying to collaborate with me but really are they trying to hurt me and I and I'm good I'm absolutely good with somebody negotiating with me as long as they're trying to make a better deal Brent not if they're actively seeking to hurt you yeah and even then at that point in time I just want to know for sure because I might not back out of that deal that you know I might not like them and we we have some people were doing business with that I really don't like but it benefits my company a lot and so I'm not kidding myself about who I'm dealing with is there's nothing wrong with having a tiger by the tail as long as you know you got a tiger by the tail”
When labels were tested in an MBA classroom at Georgetown where all students had day jobs, labels proved to be the most universally applicable tool, raising everybody's effectiveness by at least 30-33%, with the strongest effect on previously silent respondents who would have had a 0% success rate.
“the part-time program which mean everybody had a job during the day so I said take these skills back to your day job and triumph we found out the labels were the most universally applicable skill of all the tools and what was the success rate on them as reported by uh well the success rate it went from it increases everybody's batting average but that one of the but the best things it did was it then it created some responses and people that were going completely silent otherwise where the batting average was zero right so the labels the labels across the board probably raises everybody's effectiveness no less than thirty to thirty three percent”
A business founder Voss coached who wanted 10% equity for herself and an additional 10% for her husband as compensation for his unpaid work approached the negotiation with emotional intelligence (opening with 'I've got a lousy proposition for you') rather than high anchoring, and ended up with a third of the company for her husband—far exceeding the 10% she would have asked for.
“she wants to pull 10% of her business she wants the other side to give an additional 10% to give to her husband...she doesn't high anchor she comes in with an emotional intelligence approach...she starts a conversation by saying I've got a lousy proposition for you which is enormous ly disarming...she ended up with a third of the business for her husband”
Voss uses deference as a mercenary tool (not moral) because it works on everybody and doesn't require common ground, leverage, or power; he is unwilling to be handicapped by restrictions like 'I need leverage over them' or 'we need common ground'.
“I do not want the negotiation approach that I used to be restricted because I have to have common ground with you or because I have to have power over you those are all restrictions if I don't have common ground where am i I'm not willing to be handicapped by that if I don't have leverage on you where am i I'm not willing to be handicapped by that I want an approach where I'm not handicapped by what other people perceive to be strengths”
Reframing yes-oriented questions into no-oriented questions ('would you like to try X?' becomes 'are you against trying X?') has achieved a 100% success rate in practice, with people often saying no initially but then opening to deal-making after the no.
“the other thing while we're talking which has the most most universal success rate and somebody on the phone was telling me today that rate the success rate was 100 percent is intentionally getting people to say no that that rewarding all your yes oriented questions into no oriented questions and said would you like to do this say are you against this that's an insane success rate and people you know have literally gone out and gotten on the phone as soon as we taught them how to do what we referred to as a no oriented question and simply said I said would you like to try this option said are you against this option and a person gives them a no and instead of rejecting the deal it makes a deal”
The most dangerous negotiation is one you don't know you're in; anytime the word 'yes' or the concept of 'I want' is in play, a negotiation is occurring, and recognizing hidden negotiations early is critical.
“we like to believe the most dangerous negotiation is one you don't know you're in so first of all anytime the word yes is in your is in the air somebody's trying to get a yes out of somebody or something you're in a negotiation or if if I want is in your brain you're in a negotiation and there's there's no two ways about the most dangerous negotiation is one you don't know you're in”
Time is the most common commodity involved in every negotiation (more universal than price or money); recognizing time as a negotiation asset in seemingly transactional interactions (even routine order-taking) can create value.
“the most common commodity the commodity that sin needs in every negotiation is time not price not money dollars are not all dollars are not always involved with time always is right so as soon as you begin in collaborationist time internal internal internal collaboration among colleagues trying to implement a project trying to get somebody just to support you in what your proposal is those are all negotiations”
Parents can use labels and mirrors with children of appropriate age to encourage them to think deeper and engage more fully; asking 'can I have the car Friday?' can be reframed with labels like 'it seems like you think you don't have to earn that privilege.'
“labels and mirrors open into questions calibrated questions those are all real good depend upon the age of the child you know you want your kids to think and and a good label is designed to encourage the counterparts thinking you want your kids to think you want your counterparts to think and you chose is you know dad can I can I have a call late this weekend or Friday night can have a car Friday night and your answer could be like it it seems like you think you don't have to earn that privilege you know draw them in get them engaged how can I give you the car on the weekend if you're not responsible during the week”
When negotiators lose flow or become mentally exhausted, meditation (even 10 minutes) can provide enough of a brain reset to return to peak performance; other hacks include physical movement, forced laughter, and deliberate body resets.
“the old the old remedy was just rest you know an exhausted hostage negotiate at the end of the day I just I just got to take him off the phone and let him get a good night's sleep but you know the new remedy what are the hacks how can we get this guy recharged I mean it's one of the right it's one of the reasons why I think people are meditating a lot more now you know 10 minutes of good meditation might give you enough of a brain reset that that you're back in the game 10 minutes later I mean that that's that's a hack into flow”
Ronald Reagan and Donald Trump had similar political goals (pro-American, anti-Russia, pro-business, aggressive) and both fired many people, but Reagan was perceived as a nice guy who smiled, which gave him more political influence and fewer enemies than Trump's more confrontational approach.
“I'd ask you what are the biggest differences in the overall goals and objectives of Ronald Reagan versus Donald Trump you know Ronald Reagan fired more people when he fired the air traffic controllers I think that Donald Trump has an entire career Ronald Reagan was seen as a nice guy but he very aggressive very pro-american right and very anti Russia pro-business you know fired their traffic controllers I mean that was an aggressive guy but the he was he was video used to always say I'm a nice guy he smiled at people”
A Georgetown student who anchored at $110k (a $25k jump from his $85k salary) expecting to negotiate down negotiated the deal and was later told by a colleague that he was paid less than $125k (and the colleague was likely earning $125k+), illustrating that anchoring high does not guarantee better outcomes and can leave money on the table.
“he goes into the interview and they say you know where do you sell are your expectations and he puffed himself up and proudly says 110 110 and he negotiates the deal and ago you know they give him give him the 110 so he's on a job after a couple months and he's talking to a colleague hired at the same time same basic pay grade and he's in any and he says to the guy says you know what do you think our company his colleague says to him what do you think our about compensation he says well look I Got News for you I negotiated my own deal and this guy says you're getting paid more than 125”
A student of Voss's conducted research showing that using empathy saves time; the faster resolution comes from identifying problems earlier and extracting information only the other side will offer if they feel connected.
“one of my students did an actual study on our conclusion was empathy safes don't use empathy because you're a missionary because you're a soft touch use empathy because you want to get stuff done faster and you've got other stuff to do to get after how does it help you save time well we're not spinning our wheels as quickly you know if I'm if I'm I'm rooting out the problems earlier I'm figuring out what you can throw on the table that you'll only throw on the table if you feel like if you feel connected to me”
One of Voss's team members, a New Yorker named Charlie Beaudoin, was a natural accommodator who could enter unfamiliar bars and introduce himself to everyone one-by-one with genuine warmth; he wrote 'smile they can feel it in your voice' on a board, which proved very effective at breaking down barriers during hostage negotiations.
“I had one of the hostage negotiators on a team and a New Yorker guy named Charlie beaudoin and Charlie was a natural accommodator you know we'd walk into a bar that we'd never been in before maybe we were someplace you know working a case we'd never been there before walking to the bar Charlie walk around and literally introduce himself to everybody in the bar one at a time and he'd just walk up and say hi I'm charlie and he'd smile at people and when we were in hostage negotiations Charlie dried a note on a board that said smile they can feel it in your voice”
Voss's son learned hostage negotiation skills from growing up around FBI negotiations; he would proactively seek out the vice principal when he'd violated a uniform code (rather than hiding), and by approaching authority with respect and honesty, he'd receive favorable outcomes like free passes for the rest of the day.
“there's nothing in the book he'd go to school and be something wrong with the uniform and when a student say hey you know you may you did you screwed this up today you're not wearing this properly watch out for the vice-principal most kids are gonna spend the entire rest of the day running from the vice-principal because they don't want to get in trouble as soon as he realized he'd made a mistake the very next place he would go would be the vice principal's office he'd knock on door he'd go straight in and he was telling me one time he walked in and he's telling the vice principal you know he's a disrespectful student...the Vice Principal stopped and said hold her hold her hold on-hold he said who sent you and he said said nobody I you know soon as I realized I was wrong I came in and the Vice Principals you know scribbled him a note the game of free pass for the rest of the dance”
Voss views success as creating new problems (people trying to exploit his work) rather than failures; he reframes this as a 'first-world problem' that results from the book's success and his legitimate impact, which allows him to manage the stress.
“does that caused you a lot of stress if I let my if I let it cause me stress I realize now that every now and then the people that we're doing business with that are trying to exploit us that isn't as they say a first worth first world problem or a success problem right you know I'm only dealing with these because the book is so good right and because we make a difference in people's lives I mean make no mistake we make a difference in people's lives you go on you on Amazon and look at the reviews and this person after person after person but we made a difference in their lives we made their lives better”
If Voss could give advice to his 20-year-old self, he would say: don't change your positions or values (his directness and commitment to right and wrong), just be nicer about how you express them.
“I would tell me just be a little nicer don't compromise who you are don't take any different positions you know I've been I've always been highly guided by what I believe to be you know right and wrong set of rules you know do the right thing is a phrase that matters to me so you know I'll I'll punch you in the face by trying to get you to do the right thing and thinking that my motivations are good enough to cover up my delivery so I'd tell my younger self just be nicer don't don't change any of your positions don't go in any other directions just be nicer about it you get a lot farther”
Hostage negotiation has taught Voss to expect failures and even deaths; he learned from cases where outcomes went bad, but he doesn't blame himself for circumstances beyond his control while remaining open to learning from preventable mistakes.
“can you tell me a bit of time that you failed and what you did to recover and learn from that yeah you know I mean there's all kinds of failures you know one we talked about in the book hostages die yeah we didn't expect them to die and at that time I mean I I've always I was a big proponent of a strong team game so I was really satisfied that that I included my team we'd done everything we knew how to do and what we knew how to do wasn't enough”
An example of limiting 'two lines of code': a colleague's grandmother said 'self praise is no praise,' creating a code where he could never internally praise himself, limiting his self-esteem and growth.
“I had another colleague that I worked with they used to always say my grandmother always said self praises no prints well I'm thinking like so you know you can never praise yourself you can you can never say is to yourself internally you know I did a good job here”
Tony Robbins pioneered physical hacks for achieving and maintaining flow state before the neuroscience was fully understood, using techniques like forcing people to move and engage physically during 12-14 hour seminars to keep large audiences in flow despite uncomfortable conditions.
“it's kind of what Tony Robbins is doing it in his in his seminars Tony Robbins is in before the neuroscience was there he figured out the physical hacks and the flow that's why he sleeps four hours a night you know that's why he can stand up and do a 14 hour seminar essentially with no breaks I mean if you if you go to his one of his seminar ABBA's on a stage for anywhere from you you you got to be prepared to sit there for anywhere from 12 to 14 hours on top of that Robbins is gonna make you do a number of things physically to put you in flow”
The book has made a measurable difference in people's lives (evidenced by Amazon reviews), including a woman who gave her daughter the book and the daughter negotiated a 30% salary increase for herself.
“you go on you on Amazon and look at the reviews and this person after person after person but we made a difference in their lives we made their lives better men and women Facebook posting the other day a woman gave her daughter my book and she went out and negotiated a 30 percent salary increase for herself yes”
A Silicon Valley female executive discovered that her fiancé had started using Voss's negotiation training with her, which improved their conversations; she then bought 10 copies of Never Split the Difference to distribute to her girlfriends' husbands and boyfriends, indicating that the skills improve relationships.
“a Silicon Valley a female executive one day is talking to her fiance and she says why do I like talking to you all of a sudden last couple days conversation great what's going on and he said well I'm taking his training and they're making me use it with you and she found out the book was never split the difference and she went out and she bought 10 copies and gave them to all of her girlfriends husbands and boyfriends”
Becoming an FBI hostage negotiator was not a deliberate career aspiration but an accident that emerged from a knee injury sustained on a SWAT team, combined with curiosity about what negotiators actually do.
“I had a recurring knee injury...was on a SWAT team with the FBI and we injured my knee again and then instead of completely blowing it out I still want to be in crisis response I knew we had hostage negotiators negotiators I don't know what they did I figured you know how hard could it be I talked to people I could talk to terrorists how hard could that be”
The late-night FM DJ voice (flight response type) is naturally calming and collaborative; smiling while speaking modulates the tone, and this voice type instinctively seeks safety through distance before reconsidering threats.
“the flight guy is a late-night FM DJ voice he's a guy who thinks that like you know it's stupid to fight let me let me get let me get far enough away where I could be safe and then I'll then I'll rethink this and then there's make friends and it's a person who naturally smiles when they speak to you”
The book Never Split the Difference has been called one of the seven best negotiation books ever written and leads its category on Audible in the business category since publication.
“the book has been called one of the seven best negotiation books ever written it leads its category the audible version of the book has been leading the business category and Amazon basically since the book came out”