
Nobel Laureate in Economics: Bitcoin is worthless, gold is 'terrible' inflation hedge - Eugene Fama
What this covers
This is a 44-minute Kitco News interview in which host David Lin questions Gene Fama of the University of Chicago. It opens on the Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH)) and then works through what follows from it. Fama treats price volatility as expected, since new information keeps moving prices away from earlier equilibrium values, and he says market anomalies are hard to pin down because you must first specify a model of risk and expected return. He names insider trading as one of the few real exceptions. The host presses him from the other side, noting that the asset management industry presumes assets become over- or undervalued. He also raises Warren Buffett's argument that prices are set at the margin by the most emotional participant. On asset pricing, Fama says the aim is as few robust factors as possible. He expects value and small stocks to have bad stretches because they are risky, and he calls their relative performance unpredictable.
The second half moves to money and macroeconomics. Fama dismisses Bitcoin as lacking intrinsic value, and he points out that a business accepting it could lose its margin if the price fell 30% overnight. He also calls gold a poor inflation hedge because it is too volatile relative to goods prices. On inflation, he argues that under quantitative easing (QE)) with unlimited, interest-bearing reserves there is no meaningful money supply left. In his view this undercuts Milton Friedman's monetarist dictum and leaves the Fed without the tools Paul Volcker used, which is why he worries about current inflation. These claims are marked as contested. He also argues that reserve currency status for the dollar is overrated and that no other currency can replace it. The interview then touches on central bank digital currencies), global interconnectedness as the main new economic risk, and the case for free trade. It closes with career advice: pick work you love, and avoid fields that too many others want.
Fama argues that financial markets are fundamentally efficient because prices reflect all available information, making it nearly impossible for investors to consistently beat the market through active management, and therefore passive investing is the optimal strategy for most investors.
- Market prices incorporate all available information through the actions of informed traders, making it very difficult for individual investors to outperform
- Empirical evidence from multiple decades shows that active managers consistently fail to beat the market on a risk-adjusted basis
- The few documented exceptions to market efficiency (insider trading) are narrow and don't apply to ordinary investors without special information access
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The biggest risk in today's markets that didn't exist 50 years ago is global economic interconnectedness, which means one bad actor or extreme event can disrupt the entire world system.
“that's a good question so well i think what we're seeing now is that the world has become i mean just in the past couple of months what we've seen with the wall breaking out in the in in europe is that all the economies of the world all of the all of the economies are basically linked linked together much more than they ever have been in the past and as a consequence when you have one bad player fresh atmospheres does something extreme they can disrupt the whole system”
Milton Friedman's monetarist claim that 'inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon' no longer applies under modern quantitative easing because the definition of money supply has changed.
“no um well here's the problem with that see milton was nothing was right in his time you know and the way money's money was defined in those things so in those days we had two forms of money currency and reserves and reserves and currency were freely exchangeable but the reserves didn't pay any interest that they were just like carson basically but then when they started to do this quantitative easing business they said people are if we put in three trillion dollars worth of reserves and formerly we only had a couple hundred million what will people do with these reserves they won't want to hold them so we have to pay interest on them”
Volatility in asset prices is inherent and expected because information comes in every day, minute, and second and moves prices around from their previous equilibrium values, so volatility is not a sign of market inefficiency.
“volatility is inherent in in asset prices especially stock prices so you you expect volatility because information comes in out every day every minute every second and that moves prices around from their previous equilibrium values that's that's to be expected so so volatility is not a sign of marketing efficiency it's just a sign of lots of information coming in”
Market anomalies are very difficult to pin down because you must specify your underlying model for risk and expected return in order to determine whether observed prices deviate from that model.
“market anomaly is very very difficult to pat down because you have to tell me what your underlying model is for risky return so i can tell whether what you're showing me deviates from uh from that”
The asset management industry operates on the assumption that assets become undervalued or overvalued at certain points, but this contradicts the efficient market hypothesis which implies all assets are correctly priced.
“the whole asset management industry it seems is based on the uh assumption that assets are not fairly valued at a certain point things are undervalued and or overvalued and if you think that things are undervalued you should buy that asset”
A business accepting bitcoin as payment faces real risk because if bitcoin's price drops 30% overnight, the business's profit margin could be wiped out by holding the asset.
“suppose i'm a business and you you approach me that way you want me to take bitcoin and i say to you look the problem with bitcoin for me as a business is it can put me out of business in the sense that you give it to me and tomorrow's price goes down by 30 and my margin is only 10 so i'm out of business basically because i took bitcoin not because i did anything in my business that was wrong”
Economic theory suggests that free trade and open borders make people better off compared to trade wars and protectionism, yet humans continue to engage in conflict despite understanding this principle.
“now it's really when you think about it i mean every economist would say trade is better than you are traders better than more always you can always make people better off by trading than you can by attacking them you can make yourself better off by treating them because you're making the pie smaller but you could still we do it i mean the humans don't seem to be able to progress on that point to stop attacking each other you don't seem to be able to do it”
Fama's view is that a world without protectionism where people and capital can move freely is better than a world with protectionism, and free trade creates competition among political systems.
“the world without wars the world is better off without protectionism the world is better off being a free and open place where people can move around and go to the places that work best um and that that creates competition among political systems”
For younger people seeking a career in finance, the most important advice is to find something you genuinely love to do because you will spend at least a third of your life working.
“well basically what i say to every young person is find something you really like to do because you're going to you're going to spend at least a third of your life working at a job so you'll sleep with her in your life and work yet but anyway and you have another thing do what you want to do but if you enjoy your job that is the best possible life you're ever going to have because now you're basically all you all your hours are are spent in a way that satisfies satisfaction”
When choosing a career, ensure that not many other people want to do the same thing because if many people pursue the same field, wages will be driven down.
“but make sure not to many other people want to do it because then the prices will be too low”
The efficient market hypothesis states that prices reflect all available information, which makes it impossible to beat the market because market prices already incorporate all known data.
“it's a very simple statement since prices reflect all available information so basically in that world it's impossible to beat the market”
Under quantitative easing where reserves are unlimited and pay full market interest, there is no meaningful concept of money supply anymore because reserves lack opportunity cost relative to other assets.
“what monetary theory says is you have to have something that has an opportunity cost relative to other assets and it's in limited supply and that's not the case with the reserves anymore”
The US dollar's status as the world reserve currency is overrated; it primarily means international prices are stated in dollars, not that anyone holds dollars as a reserve asset.
“that's overrated and then in the sense that what does it mean to be there is your currency all that means is uh international prices get stated in your unit of account it doesn't mean that anybody actually holds you know unit of account they just stayed prices in that new account or internet international transactions so it's not really a reserve asset or anything in that sense it's just a word that's used”
The Fama-French factors have been applied globally and work to roughly the same extent across different markets and countries, though there is ongoing research about how to define the relevant investment universe (US only, developed markets, emerging markets) when testing such models.
“people have applied it pretty much everywhere and it you know it kind of works to the same extent everywhere so the question you're raising is that's a really good question is that how do you what do you do what do you decide at the market when you do these kinds of tests is it just your stocks is it the u.s plus the rest of the western world does it include japanese stuff”
In the Volcker era (1980s), the Fed contracted the money supply and raised interest rates to double digits simultaneously to fight inflation, a strategy unavailable today under the QE regime.
“in the 80s walker raised it to double digits to match inflation so if we were to be vocaresque we'd have to get inflation uh the interest rate up to nine percent yeah well right right i remember that time very very well so that's right so the rate people have been shocked that they pushed up the federal funds range from zero basically the 75 basis points”
Insider trading is one of the few exceptions to market efficiency because insiders have access to information that nobody else has, and insider trades are indeed profitable.
“there is a marketing efficiency that has always stood up so if you look at insider trades they make money at nine trades inside of trading is profitable to the people who do it so but that that's one of the few exceptions to the rule now you would expect it would be because they have access to information that nobody else has”
Current inflation at the highest level in 40 years worries Fama because the Federal Reserve has lost traditional tools for controlling money supply after adopting unlimited quantitative easing.
“that worries me a lot actually because way back when when the fed started doing this quantitative easing business i said no they're out of the business of controlling the money supply by controlling the amount of uh lending that banks can do because of limits on their reserves basically reserves are unlimited now and they're paying full market interest so i don't know what's determining the price level anymore”
The goal in asset pricing model development is to use as few factors as possible and to have factors that are robust across time, not to add more and more factors for greater predictive power.
“your goal is to do with this few as possible not as many as possible so you wanted a prosimonious model one planet doesn't have a lot of risk and you want to be robust in the sense that it it doesn't go away with time so these factors are always there sometimes the premiums are positive sometimes they're negative after the fact but the phenomena are always there”
Gold is not an adequate hedge against inflation because its price is too volatile relative to prices of goods and services, similar to bitcoin's problems.
“people who used to say gold was a hedge against inflation but it isn't terrible age against inflation because this price is too variable relative to the relatives of the prices of goods and services”
Value stocks had a bad performance period for the last 15 years, and small stocks had a bad period prior to that, but bad periods should be expected for these risk factors because they are inherently risky.
“value had a bad period um for the last 15 years or so and so the small stocks had a bad period prior to that you get the exact time but uh basically the problem with with saying what what the bad periods implies did you expect you expect the wrong blood you expect bad periods because these are risk factors you think it's a risky risky tact to take so you expect to lose lots of the time based on these these these dimensions of risk”
Value and growth stocks do not behave in predictable cycles where one outperforms the other; their relative performance is totally unpredictable.
“do you think value and growth stocks behave in cycles or certain cycles in which value outperforms growth stocks outperform no totally unpredictable”
No other currency can realistically replace the dollar as the international unit of account because every other country faces the same inflation and economic challenges the US faces, making them equally undesirable alternatives.
“my comeback question would be what's going to replace it potentially sorry everybody else around the world is going through the same problem right inflation's gone up to eight percent basically everywhere so everybody's facing the same problem the doll has been getting stronger in the past few months because relative to europe we're better off we don't have a water in our doorstop”
Bitcoin lacks intrinsic value and is not a store of value unless it becomes widely used as a medium of exchange and unit of account with stable real purchasing power.
“bitcoin is not a store in value unless it has some other value the core value has to come from something it comes from its use as a unit of account in transactions if people decide they don't want to take it in transactions its value is gone”
Warren Buffett argues that markets are inefficient because stock prices are set at the margin by the most emotional, greedy, or depressed person, and market prices are frequently nonsensical rather than rational.
“i'm convinced that there is much inefficiency in the market when the price of a stock can be influenced by a herd on wall street with prices set at the margin by the most emotional person or the greediest person or the most depressed person it is hard to argue that the market always prices rationally in fact market prices are frequently nonsensical”
Markets are efficient even if individual investors experience wins and losses—any given investor may outperform or underperform on a given trade, but 'on average it's going to go against us randomly,' meaning past winners are not systematically better forecasters.
“you know on average it's going to go you know against going to go against us randomly so”
The weak form of the efficient market hypothesis (that prices follow a random walk and short-term prediction is pointless) is outdated language from the 1950s; modern understanding is that prices fluctuate around risk-adjusted expected returns, not that they are random in the sense of having no mean.
“uh on the weak form uh theory of a market efficiency uh the theory states that markets move on a short-term basis more or less randomly also known as a random walk theory it's more or less pointless to make predictions on a short-term basis do you subscribe to this theory uh no because that's that's the goal that's the way people talked about it in the 50s 1950s you know long long time back when they first started to think about these issues they thought maybe prices should be random marks but then they figured out that no we have to have an expected eternity because people are bearing risk so and then the martin statement is that price variation around the risk-adjusted expected returns right”
The five-factor model was expanded to include profitability and investment factors because these factors would theoretically play a role in explaining returns if a more profitable firm has the same price as a less profitable firm.
“well it seems that if you want to go back to a kind of a really loose theory those factors would would play a role so if a firm does if the firm has the same price as another firm that's much less profitable then you think that somehow the more profitable firm is is more risky uh and the same with the investments”
The correlation between M2 money supply increases and CPI inflation in the last two years reflects luck rather than causation; the 2010-2020 period showed massive reserve expansion without inflation, proving that reserves that pay interest do not cause inflation.
“well if you go back what you're going to see is um they've been they've been lucky so it's go all the way back to uh 2010 okay when when the interest rate first hits zero and then they went into this quantitative easing business well reserves went from a couple hundred million up to three or four trillion dollars nothing happened to inflation so according to the monetary theory of inflation being everywhere in the monetary we should have had a hyperinflation but we didn't because those reserves paid interest full interest there was no opportunity to cost we were holding them so they had basically no effect on inflation”
Technical analysis (trading based on price patterns without knowing the underlying stock) is a hopeless activity according to Fama's view, comparable to throwing darts to pick stocks.
“how do you feel about technical analysis so analysts who trade based on just reading charts a lot of the times this is an extreme example a lot of the times they don't even know what the tickers are they just look at the charts and they pick and they trade based on price patterns um really used to say i can get you all of the uh targets you want for for 10 bananas a day because that's pretty how much she thought about what they what they actually did other than just monkeys basically but i i think yeah i don't want to be insulting too no basically i think that's a hopeless activity”
Fama wrote his thesis in 1962 showing that the distribution of stock returns has fat tails with too many extreme returns (both positive and negative), a phenomenon now called black swans that has always existed.
“i wrote my thesis on this section in 1962 uh so basically it was that the distribution of stock returns is way too fat tails there are too many extreme uh returns both positive and negative and you get these uh they call them black swans now that's a new name invented but they've been there forever”
The Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM) could not explain returns on small stocks and value stocks (stocks with low prices relative to fundamentals), which motivated Fama and French to develop the three-factor model.
“back in the early 80s uh when the first asset pricing model came out everybody thought this was bill shaft's uh so-called capital asset pricing model um at that point everybody that i was one of the first people to do work on that model i thought it worked great and then through time what we found was the model couldn't explain certain things basically we couldn't explain the returns on small stocks couldn't explain the returns on so-called value stocks stocks who have low prices relative what seems to be their fundamentals”
While World War II spurred innovation and technological development, the destruction and death toll associated with war far outweighs the innovation benefits.
“one could argue that speculation is the utility it's fine but you know i think that utility is short-lived okay the speculation can go the other way and then you're out of business all right what about gold do you think gold is an adequate store of value well you know you know do you think that makes up for the destruction they cause though and the number of deaths that go with it true that is the downside that is the trade-off you know i don't think if you were jewish you'd take that stance”
Bitcoin's price cannot be explained by fundamental value; instead, people invest in bitcoin because other people are holding it, which is a speculative bubble destined to crash.
“people who invest people say they're investing in bitcoin because other people are watch out it doesn't it's going to crash it is a very deep question a lot of people have argued with you that bitcoin has no intrinsic value”
The terminology around 'central bank digital currency' is sloppy because the Federal Reserve already has a digital currency (bank reserves), and what they're proposing is a new transaction mechanism, not a new currency.
“they're using words sloppily is what it comes down to so i jump on everybody who comes to chicago and gives a talk talks about the fed coming out with a digital currency because i say they've always had a digital currency that's what reserves are they're a digital currency that's all they are they're just entries in a bookkeeping and in a computer and then the trading takes place in those in those entries and they clear at the end of them every day so i said what is this new digital currency you're talking about”
A potential downside of CBDC is that the government could directly control and track all spending through a single central ledger, potentially enabling spending restrictions by time or other criteria.
“the worst thing is that the government can now track your spending and perhaps even control your spending directly by limiting the num the transactions you make given um i'll give you an example suppose this is just a hypothetical example suppose we were to have um some sort of curfew because of the pandemic or whatever the case may be i could say to you me being the government i could say to you dr farmer you cannot spend your money after 10 pm i'm gonna lock your account”
Fama has been incredibly lucky throughout his career, starting with being admitted to University of Chicago due to a serendipitous phone call with the dean who found no application record but offered a scholarship.
“i think i've been incredibly lucky actually so from the very beginning i'll tell you a story how the luck first started so i was a senior at college at tufts and i had switched to my junior year to economics from romance languages as is with my major so i was thinking of going to graduate school and when i go to a graduate business school and my economic professors at tufts oh they all love me they told me to go to university of chicago because they were more oriented towards you know uh basically uh theoretical kinds of economics and other subjects don't go to the outer business school and we're all graduates about it so i applied to chicago and i never heard anything so finally it came to be april and i said boy i should have heard from them right now so i called and the dean of students actually answered the phone nowadays he wouldn't even have a phone too important but he answered the phone and we chatted and he said well frankly i don't have any record of your application and he said what but how were your grades and i said basically all these he said well we just happen to have a scholarship of somebody from tufts do you want it that's how i ended up at the university of chicago where i've been ever since”
Despite the efficient market hypothesis suggesting you cannot beat the market, Fama personally holds stocks believing they have higher expected returns than bonds, and views both as correctly priced.
“so i believe that i believe in that strong and the market is efficient as far as i'm concerned so what does that say for my investing well i still hold lots of stocks i just told the marketplace i see so i think stocks have higher expected returns and bonds so i'm willing to take the risk of the stockholders and hold it you know but i think both the stocks and the bonds are correctly priced”
Even criminals and drugs dealers are unlikely to hold bitcoin long-term because it is too volatile, preferring to exchange it quickly for more stable currency.
“at the moment my guess is even the crooks don't want to transact and hold it they'll probably transact in it but then give it up quickly for something else because it's just too busy right”
All countries around the world are facing the same inflation problem (approximately 8%) because global economies are now highly interconnected.
“everybody else around the world is going through the same problem right inflation's gone up to eight percent basically everywhere so everybody's facing the same problem”
The proposed CBDC would give retail customers access to the Federal Reserve's clearing mechanism, but current banking clearing systems are slow (2 days) and should be instant electronic transactions.
“well they say well now we want to give let everybody have access to the clearing mechanism on the central bank well that's a different story it's not it's not a new digital currency it's a new way of accident conducting transactions they're misnaming it by calling a digital currency they already have a digital console it's called reserves but it's just traded by only the bank's trading you know you and i can't go in and trade three reserves we have to go through the banks and they have these slow systems of clearing uh transactions that people are really sick of at this point it takes you two days to get something to get through the through the system which it should take nothing because it's just an electronic transaction”
The dollar has been strengthening in recent months relative to other currencies because the United States is experiencing relatively better economic conditions than Europe, not because of reserve currency status.
“the doll has been getting stronger in the past few months because relative to europe we're better off we don't have a water in our doorstop”
If Jerome Powell were asked to control inflation in the current regime, the honest answer is he does not know what it will take, as the problem is unprecedented and unsolved.
“if you were jerome powell what would you do you get another job he does not know what it will take to control inflation give a lot of speeches but there is no experience in this regime that we have now”
Fama has never regretted missing out on specific stock or investment opportunities that later performed well; he does not second-guess his past investment decisions.
“you've never looked back and said oh i should have bought this stock or i should have made this investment look how much it's gone up i missed the boat everyone's missed a boat on something do you ever have regrets in that regard no i never even look pointless right”
Fama does not know whether protectionism is the solution to global economic problems and won't claim an answer on the topic.
“is protectionism the solution to the problems we have i know today i don't know i don't know that i know i would not claim an answer on that you know i don't know”