
The Battle Over Free Speech: Are Trigger Warnings, Safe Spaces & No-Platforming Harming Young Minds?
What this covers
This is a recorded Intelligence Squared debate from November 2018, built around Jonathan Haidt's book The Coddling of the American Mind. Haidt is joined by the former chief rabbi Lord Sacks, the author and activist Eleanor Penny, and the sociologist Kehinde Andrews, with a moderator and audience questions. Haidt's case rests on a mental health timeline: anxiety and depression in the US were fairly flat from 2000 to 2010 and then rose sharply, with male depression up about 30% and female depression up about 40%. He adds that UK teenage girls' suicide rates are at record highs, and that self-harm admissions are rising for girls but not boys. He blames social media, which he says hits girls harder, together with decades of overprotection. His clinical argument is that trigger warnings run against exposure therapy, the evidence-based treatment for PTSD.
The panel pushes back from several directions. Sacks supports the university as a community with its own identity, one that is careful about the signals it sends, and he warns about a society splintering into groups that only meet through algorithmic filters. He also draws on James Baldwin to link unexpressed pain with hate. Andrews rejects the idea that universities were ever neutral. He argues they have served state and market power and even justified slavery, and he says the groups now asking for protection are those only recently admitted. He cites the figure of 100 Black professors out of 18,000 in the UK. Penny calls the problem political rather than psychological. She argues that "coddling" distracts from real threats such as surveillance of Muslim students, and she disputes the claim that criticism of a platformed speaker is a free speech problem.
The sharpest disagreements are over no-platforming fascists, whether the "mind prepared for battle" framing fits campus politics, and whether rising diversity requires more charity and less offence. In the audience questions, Haidt concedes that most of the evidence is correlational and that nobody knows why depression is rising so fast across the Anglosphere.
Haidt argues that modern university culture—characterized by trigger warnings, safe spaces, and no-platforming—paradoxically harms student mental health and intellectual development by treating students as fragile rather than antifragile, preventing the stress inoculation necessary for psychological resilience and open intellectual discourse.
- Gen Z mental health crisis (anxiety, depression, self-harm, suicide) correlates with overprotection and safety-ism rather than bullying exposure
- Antifragility requires exposure to manageable stress; shielding from discomfort prevents development of coping mechanisms
- Framing universities as spaces of struggle between oppressor/oppressed groups replaces truth-seeking with ideological combat, harming learning
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Hospital admission rates for self-harm in girls are up in the same pattern as depression rates, but hospital admissions for self-harm in boys are not rising
“rates of hospital admission for self-harm are up in the same way for girls not for boys though”
Suicide rate for teenage girls in the UK has reached its highest level ever, with a 60-65 percent increase in completed suicides for English and Welsh girls
“the rate for teenage girls has reached its highest level ever you also have about a 60 or 65 percent increase in completed suicides for English English girls English and Welsh girls”
Antifragility is the concept that some things—like the human immune system and human beings generally—require exposure to stressors in order to strengthen themselves, in contrast to fragile things that break when stressed
“you know this is fragile and if I drop it it will break and it won't be better it will be broken and so we give kids plastic cups because plastic is resilient but if a kid drops a plastic cup it doesn't get better there are a few things that need to be dropped there are a few things that have to be challenged in order to configure themselves so the immune system is the best example if you protect your kids from bacteria and peanuts they will have more autoimmune diseases and more likely to have peanut allergies so the immune system requires exposure to all sorts of things well it turns out human beings are anti fragile”
Haidt has conducted research with clinical psychologists on trigger warnings and PTSD, finding that exposure therapy (graduated exposure to feared stimuli) is the evidence-based treatment, not avoidance; moving away from reminders is a symptom of PTSD, not a cure
“we did a lot of we talked to a lot of clinical psychologists about trigger warnings you're absolutely right that they're very rare they're not used often although the New York Times had an article yesterday they're now in theaters if you go into a play in America you might now see a trigger warning they're likely to become common in the future but you're right they have not been common on campus yet but it's an empirical question whether they help people who have PTSD that is not a question that we can just guess that oh it would probably be helpful to them that is an empirical question to be addressed by clinical psychologists who've done the research on it we spoke to a lot of clinical psychologists who work on PTSD and they they all said the same thing exposure to the thing that you are afraid of in a graduated way where nothing Bad's can happen is the cure for it moving away from reminders is a symptom of PTSD it is not a cure”
James Baldwin said people cling to hate because they're afraid that if they let go of it they will have to confront pain; when there's a lot of unexpressed pain it generates hate
“I think of James Baldwin for instance it was doubly marginal of being both black and gay who said one of the truest things about about hate which we really have to listen to today where there's a lot of hates sloshing around he said I think people cling on to their hate because they're afraid that if they let go of their hate they will have to confront pain so when there's a lot of pain going around that isn't able to be expressed it generates hate”
The concept of 'freedom from consequence' conflates free speech (freedom from prosecution for voicing opinion) with freedom from criticism or challenge, and powerful speakers expecting platforms without being challenged is not actually free speech but using free speech rhetoric to protect the powerful from accountability
“we're in danger of having exactly the kind of concept creep that you talk about in the book right from freedom of speech as freedom from prosecution and freedom from when you will voice your opinion to a kind of freedom from consequence so what we're expected is that powerful speakers often powerful right-wing men are expected to be invited along to very prestigious platforms to air their views and not be challenged for it and to me that's not that's not free speech it's it's the exact opposite it's using free speech that's using the trappings of free speech to essentially protect people who are already powerful from being challenged”
The claim that women earn only 70% of what men earn for the same work is a meaningless statistic unless corrected for hours worked and type of job; when corrected it shows women earning in the 90s of male earnings
“so let's take gender for example so it's commonly said that women earn be present as much as men now that's a true fact in the United States but that doesn't account for hours work or job picked if you correct for those then we're up in the 90s but it sounds better to say that women are only paid 70% as much as men for the same work any social scientist knows that that's a meaningless statistic unless you equate for the kind of job and the hours worked”
Universities have curriculum and bases of knowledge that have explicitly said minorities (like Black people) are NOT human beings, which is different from general discrimination
“these are the spaces into which we have put minorities women etc and then we are somehow surprised when people say we need a safe space or actually maybe I need a trigger warning to learn about European enlightenment because it's basically telling me that I can't think right and it's the fragility of the elite who will come into this space and now hear the actual voices of minorities right of people saying you need to work differently because this isn't gonna wrong for us”
In 1965, only 5% of the UK and US population went to university, who were rich white men; over the last 50 years universities have been opened up to women, minorities, and LGBTQ communities, and these are the groups now saying universities are harmful and require protection
“in 1965 in the UK and in the u.s. only 5% of the population went to university rich white men now what's happened over the last 50 years is it's been opened up you've got women you've got minorities you've got LGBTQ communities and not ironically not surprisingly these are the groups who are saying that the universities are harmful the universities we need protection from these institutions which not not too long ago would have determined that I wasn't a human being”
Andrews points out that universities have always been expressions of state power and market power, and justified slavery; the idea that they're a neutral third space has never been true
“the truth is that's not what happens and the idea that the university is a third space that's not true the university has always been an expression of state power and market power right so the university justified slavery at a time when you need slavery for example”
Sacks points out that he is now in a position where if he were Gen Z and had to pay current university fees without government grants, he could never have had the career he had, and that there are many groups with justified reasons to feel angry about current system
“if I were today a member of Gen Z or Gen Z I couldn't afford to go to university none of my family could have afforded we went with with with with no tuition fees and with a government grant and if I found myself having to go to university pan enormous some burden myself with that I could never have had the career that I've had”
Rates of anxiety and depression in the United States were fairly stable from 2000 to 2010, then began rising very sharply, with male depression up about 30% and female depression up about 40%
“rates of anxiety and depression were fairly stable in the early from 2000 to 2010 and then they begin rising very sharply for boys rates of made depression are up about 30% for girls they're up about 40%”
Minority and marginalized students already have the highest dropout rates and lowest degree completion rates in universities, and are the most robust people out there because they have had to survive oppressive society
“the dropout rate for minorities is higher in universities the more less likely to get a good degree in universities why because actually the curriculum the environment everything about it is alienating to you right so with students as a win Africa if you feel offended and actually are there is a I don't I use the word violence but I don't mean that in it what I mean is learning an institution so for example look around this was what my university experience was one black face and literally a hundred white people right learning only from learning only stuff written by white Europeans right in environments with dead white men hanging on the wall right that's an actual violence based on you”
Rabbi Jonathan Sacks argues that a university should be a community with its own identity that is careful about what signals it sends regarding who it welcomes and how seriously it takes potentially problematic voices, as opposed to an open platform where any idea can be explored
“when you look at the university is it a a platform is it an open platform in which any idea can be shared or rejected or explored or whatever or is it a community that has its own identity and you have to be careful as a university what signals you are sending out who you welcome and how seriously those words of people who might be undesirables are taken”
Jewish people have a noble history of drawing the line against fascism, including at Cable Street in 1936 and in Lewisham in 1978, and both times it worked; we should learn from that history
“Jewish people also have a very noble history of drawing a line somewhere and that line is always always to stop fascist mobilizing because we know that they pose us a direct threat that was the line that was drawn in Kayla Street in 1936 that was the line that was drawn in Lewisham in 1978 and both of those times it worked”
When you increase diversity in universities, you necessarily increase misunderstandings and have to learn to give people the benefit of the doubt and take less offense even as you give less offense
“if you're going to bring people together especially internationally if you have more people who have Asperger's or other mental mental illnesses you're going to have huge numbers of misunderstandings you're going to have language used in all kinds of ways that could offend people so yes we need to give less offence but we it can't work unless we have a general regimen of give people the benefit of the doubt”
Words have an impact and to say we shouldn't consider the impact of words in limited cases like fascism is an under-analysis of the importance of free speech itself
“free speech is fundamentally important because words have an impact and to say that like we shouldn't consider the impact of those words in a limited number of cases such as such as the you know fascism I think is ludicrous and I think is an under analysis of the importance of free speech”
A mind prepared for battle is not a mind prepared for learning, and the norms of combat and victory in public square discourse make it very difficult for universities to do their learning work
“the norms of combat the norms of victory in the public square make it very difficult to do our work in university the mind prepared for battle is not a mind prepared for learning”
Andrews argues that if you replace the word 'University' with 'Gentleman's Club', Sacks' vision of an open forum looks very different when you're the person who was explicitly excluded from that club
“let me take your imagination for a walk if you replace the word University with gentleman's club right which is what it may sound like if you come from a minority that does not expect you in it does that change if instead of saying University you say in this gentlemen's club we have to you know push back against the rule that doesn't allow women we have to push back against the law that makes black men feel uncomfortable does it then change”
The best and most likely explanations for the mental health crisis are a combination of social media, which is much harder on girls than boys, and vast overprotection of children starting in the 1980s-1990s when crime rates were actually plummeting
“the most likely explanations are the combination of social media which is much harder on girls than boys and the vast vast overprotection that we in the United States we decided to stop letting our kids out to tell them the world is dangerous to tell them that if they're ever not watched by an adult they will be abducted we started telling them this in the 1980s and especially in the 1990s just as our crime rate was plummeting”
When a society disaggregates into non-communicating groups with only Google filters and Facebook likes connecting people, non-communicating groups only develop fear and anxiety toward other groups, which is bad for all
“if you disaggregate society into little silos and little boxes of of of Google filters and Facebook Likes then you get non communicating groups who can only fear feel towards other groups fear and anxiety and that's just bad for all of us”
Eleanor Penny argues that what Haidt frames as a psychological robustness problem is actually a political problem that cannot be solved at the level of individual psychological resilience, and that focusing on 'coddling' distracts from real threats to free speech like mass surveillance and government collecting data on Muslim students
“what Jonathan's questions Jones's questions attempt to essentially frame what is a political problem as a problem that can be reduced to and solved on the level of like personal psychological robustness and I think that movement is something that is inherently flawed because what we're facing now is a series of overlapping political crises the students on campuses across the country across the world are attempting to develop frameworks and epistemological tactics and organizational tactics in order to change that and yes sometimes those look uncomfortable to the kind of colonists who are triggered enough to write an article about how they don't have a platform in a national newspaper however I think we're in danger of calling the people pointing out the problem the problem we're in danger of massively misdiagnosing the real existential threats to our freedom of speech which do exist but they don't look like the very overblown handful of cases of students on campus and over using tactics such as you know such as no platforming or such as trigger warnings they look like you know the mass surveillance that's going on in our society they look like government collecting data on Muslim students through prevent legislation”
Only 100 Black lecturers or professors exist out of 18,000 total in the UK, and there are no Black people in management in universities, showing that progress has been far less than Sacks suggests
“you're gonna see a black lecturer or a black professor only a hundred out of 18,000 in the whole entire of the UK and you're not going to see any black people in management”
Judaism as a tradition is fundamentally dialogical; there is no Hebrew word for obedience, and Jewish heroes like Moses, Jeremiah, and Job are known for arguing with God, making Judaism a model for intellectual antifragility.
“Judaism is a civilization all of whose canonical texts anthologies of arguments and I think that's all God actually does in the in the Bible is argue with people and the people he loves arguing with people I gave round Moses Jeremiah and Joe these are the heroes of faith there's no such thing there's no Hebrew word for obedience”
Bullying is not good for children, and chronic stress from bullying harms developing brains; the evidence in Haidt's book concerns the benefits of unsupervised free play that includes conflict and risk-taking, not bullying itself.
“I certainly didn't mean to say that bullying is good for you that kids who are bullied are gonna come out strong or bullying especially when it goes on it's if it goes on for weeks it really can have a lasting impact chronic stress is very bad for kids brains I'm not saying bullying is good the evidence that we refer that we cover in the book is not about benefits of bullying or even benefits of harm or that the evidence is on the benefits of free play unsupervised free play which includes conflict and risk-taking”
A student who recently read Deborah Lipstadt's 'Denial' asks whether Holocaust denial should be allowed under free speech principles and where the line is between free speech and facts.
“I raised recently read Deborah Lipstadt spoke denial and I was really really interested to hear what you think about of in the Holocaust yeah and I think just in general in terms of historical truths I'd be really interested to see at which point you would as you say draw the line in terms of free speech like at which point can you you know Deborah Lipstadt says you know there there are facts and there are lives and at which point can you just get away with anything because of freedom of speech right especially in regards to Holocaust denial”
Sacks argues that Deborah Lipstadt never sought to deprive David Irving of free speech to deny the Holocaust, but rather defended herself against his libel suit in court, showing confidence that truth would win.
“the important thing that happened with Deborah Lipstadt and and denial is that it wasn't Deborah who brought the case against Irving it was David Irving brought the case against her I think Deborah believes as we believe that free speech gets us beyond prejudice my hatred because in the end there's such a thing as historical fact so she never sought to deprive him of his freedom to speak”
Some European countries, including Germany and others, have enacted laws banning Holocaust denial based on their searing experiences during WWII and their need to heal historical wounds.
“I think there are some European countries obviously Germany but others likewise who have such searing experiences what were done during the Holocaust years that they did enact laws banning whole denial and so on and and that's got to do with their own inner history you know they needed time to heal those wounds”
A student asked whether the rise of overprotection and the rise of mental health problems in young people can be established as causal with statistics showing spurious correlation; Haidt acknowledged most studies are correlational and that they don't know why depression is rising so quickly in the Anglosphere
“do you also use statistics when you've in your papers and so these phenomenon of the rise of overprotection and the rise of psychological problems in young what is a statistic of significance that leads you to conclude the causality between these two phenomenons like other than just correlation”
Haidt has conducted surveys through his organization Heterodox Academy showing that students report they self-censor mostly because they're afraid of other students, and professors are mostly afraid of other students as well
“I run an organization or used to be called heterodox Academy we've surveyed students what we know is that they are afraid to speak up in class or many of them report that they self-censor mostly because they're afraid of other students professors are mostly afraid of other students”
A university conveys a stamp of approval through giving someone a platform, and someone like Steve Bannon who has no interest in protecting free speech and whose politics pose an existential threat should not receive that stamp of approval
“what we need to understand is that the University as a cultural institution also conveys a stamp of approval and that is a stamp of approval but I don't want to see given to someone who has no interest in protecting free speech and does pose and the politics that he has espoused does pose an existential threat to you know me and people like me”
Kehinde Andrews argues that the fantasy of universities as institutions based purely on equality and reason ignores that universities are rooted in fragility—the fragility of the white male elite
“because this is this fantasy version of the University where it is an institution is based on equality and reason and there's no power relations in its discussion the actually irony of this conversation is that it is rooted in frigidity but it's the fragility of the white elite and actually the white male elite in particular”
Andrews argues that the idea that reasoning together about these issues will lead to solutions is a fantasy that ignores 500 years of history; progress comes through organization and action, not debate
“the idea that we're gonna disagree cause of black who said that my point is that whether you like it or not you were seen as a black man and whether you like it or not that's gonna have an impact on your life now you can live in a dreamland where you think it does not but that's up to you right you stay there am I gonna set a real level because one of the problems with this debate is this idea that the route to equality is we sit down reason it out and we come to this wonderful new utopia we have been on the right side of the argument for 500 years it has gotten those are nowhere that is not how progress happens it's simply not that's not how progress happens progress happens through organization when people come together when people do things”
Andrews argues that African Caribbean societies and African American groups in universities create spaces where people can do things differently and engage in cultural practices, which empirically helps them do better at university
“what one of the things you can find evidence for both in the UK and in America is when you have groups African Caribbean societies or your African American groups those spaces actually because the unit's because this university generally is so is so problematic having no spaces of safety in that space of where you can just do things differently even if it's simple things like cultural things are a huge part of building resilience all the evidence will show you that if you're in these groups you do better at university”
Andrews argues that there was a major change in 2008-2010 when neoliberalism was unleashed on universities; the university sector is now just a market like any other market
“what happened in 2008 there was a major financial crisis which Unleashed neoliberalism in a way that had not been seen on the university sector the university sector is just a market like there is no barrier to that at all and when you look at things like fees you feel away the price of accommodation if you look at competition and market bit that is probably the better explanation for why you're having these problems with students then because they're being mollycoddled”
Haidt recounts a panel at NYU Law where a Latina law student described the university as violent for not being built for people like her; Haidt pointed out the panel included a Jew, a Chinese American, and a gay half-Black philosopher, all of whom the university wasn't built for but who now have a voice
“there was a panel organized at the New York University Law School to talk about this and one of the the one of the participants was a law student of Latin American descent who was talking about being a Latino student at NYU law and she was talking about the the constant violence perpetrated on her and I asked her to elaborate on that what do you mean violence like actual like physical violence and she said no no not physical violence but but violence nonetheless and she said well I mean you have to admit that this university was not built for it was not designed for people like me and I looked around the panel and I said okay I'll agree to that wasn't built for people like me I'm Jewish it wasn't built for people like her she's chinese-american it wasn't built for him he's a gay half black British philosopher wasn't built for any of us isn't that wonderful isn't that progress”
Haidt defines 'the untruth of emotional reasoning' as the idea that if you're catastrophizing or people are telling you an institution is against you and you should see oppression everywhere, this is a recipe to disempower people
“this is what we're talking about with great untruth number two that what we call the untruth of emotional reasoning always trust your feelings if your catastrophizing if you're deliberately trying to if you're deliberately telling students this institution is against you see oppression everywhere people here hate you they will do anything to stop you that's a really good recipe to disempower them”
Safe spaces are structures where people can confront difficult material and encounter new perspectives, operating analogously to CBT (cognitive behavioral therapy) where exposure in a supported environment allows growth.
“now in the book we talk about being triggered in the right circumstances as in CBT as a as a necessary process for growth I completely agree I've actually I've had a PTSD diagnosis myself I've been through CBT cognitive behavioral therapy have or therapy by the book but you took PTSD thank you but that's precisely what safe spaces are they are structures where people can people can allow themselves to confront material and to bring new perspectives in to institutions that usually exclude them”
Andrews argues that the convenient narrative Haidt is promoting (safe spaces/emotional reasoning are harmful) invites a damaging framework that harms the kind of free, robust institutions everyone is invested in
“I'm sitting and I'm saying that that of those kinds of convenient narratives that we are inculcating in our universities invite invite a kind of very damaging framework and I'm not talking about damaging as in like discomforting I'm talking about damaging to the fabric of exactly the kind of free robust institution that we're all invested in”
Andrews argues that minorities attending universities (where they are 10% in a room of 90%) face an immediate imbalance that needs to be corrected, unlike Haidt's claim about antifragility
“if you come in as 10% to a roomful of 90% then there is immediately that imbalance which needs to be corrected”
Feminist epistemology provides multiple ways of inquiry and ways of knowing things beyond the traditional logocentric model, and universities should embrace this proliferation of viewpoints.
“that's one of the gifts of feminist epistemology right that there are all kinds of ways of inquiry and all kinds of ways of knowing things and we should be embracing that that's not an t intellect”
Mainstream contemporary philosophy increasingly centers emotional and affective factors like intuition, pain, and distress as valid epistemic sources, which is a necessary corrective to a long history of dismissing marginalized people's experiences.
“when many mainstream philosophers at the moment Centre emotional emotional factors like intuition like private pain like distress what that is is a corrective to a long history of people who have experienced depression being told you're misdiagnosed in your situation you're lying you're overestimating what's happening to you when really all of these are just historical tactics that have been used to silence dissent”
Sacks argues that though justified anger exists, the question is what to do with it; Martin Luther King spoke from anger but spoke in ways that evoked not anger but an appeal to better angels of our nature
“the question is what do you do with that anger a number one I think it's terribly important to be able to speak from that anger to actually persuade people to listen to you and take you seriously and that that is obviously what I forgive the cliche but that's what Martin Luther King did he spoke to the better angels of our nature there was a lot of anger in that man but he nonetheless spoke in ways that evoked not anger but but a sense that you know what we have not lived up to our ideals”
Andrews argues that when looking at the statistics on minority outcomes in universities (admission rates, graduation rates, job placement), you see clear evidence of systemic racism, so to not talk about racial groups is to collude in racism
“I think I think that's maybe one of them and I have jokes but I really want to say look I mean the idea that talking about racial groups is the problem is complete nonsense look at any statistic will tell you that this society is racist I mean just fundamentally races so to not talk about it is to collude in racism”
The principle of charity is important for good faith discourse: when someone says something you find offensive, you should interpret it charitably in its best reading rather than its worst.
“there's a lovely phrase in your book which is about the principle of charity which is when somebody says something that you find offensive you have to work out whether it was intended to be or not give it it's more its best reading out its worst”
Society is like a symphony scored for many voices, and the university becomes important precisely when societies are disaggregating into non-communicating sects of the like-minded; excluded marginalized groups must be heard but by all of us, not just in separate spaces
“society is it's a symphony score choral symphony scored for many voices and that to me is the beauty of the university and why becomes so important when we are disaggregating our societies in tune on communicating sects of the like-minded now all the cries of pain that come from excluded marginalized groups have to be heard but they have to be heard by all of us I'm in favor of free speech because they're only out of that conversation that Democratic conversation do we arrive at a society where we can all feel we have a share we are heard”
Trigger warnings are not about coddling but about giving people the equipment (a brief moment to prepare) they need to address difficult topics with intellectual rigor.
“to think about this kind of like you know the trigger warning as like a cosseting mechanism when really it's about you know giving people the kind of equipment they need to address possibly difficult topics I think is a mischaracterization”
Trigger warnings are rare on campuses currently and have not been common, but may become common (the New York Times recently reported them in theaters); whether they help people with PTSD is an empirical question that clinical psychology research has not definitively answered.
“you're absolutely right that they're very rare they're not used often although the New York Times had an article yesterday they're now in theaters if you go into a play in America you might now see a trigger warning they're likely to become common in the future but you're right they have not been common on campus yet but it's an empirical question whether they help people who have PTSD that is not a question that we can just guess that oh it would probably be helpful to them that is an empirical question to be addressed by clinical psychologists who've done the research on it”
The far-right has explicitly mobilized around shutting down free speech and shows no interest in civility, truth, or freedom of speech itself, only in playing the victim and spinning a narrative of martyrdom
“the rise and rise of the far-right who have explicitly mobilized around things like shutting down free speech they like to play victims and they like to spin a narrative of martyrdom but really as the as Donald Trump has shown us they have very little interest in in the game that we think they we think we're playing they have no interest in civility they have no interest in truth and they have no interest in freedom of speech”
Haidt argues that increasingly, universities are teaching students to view society as a battle between good people and evil people, with white men as the oppressor group in an eternal zero-sum struggle
“we call it great untruth number three life is a battle between good people and evil people and increasingly what I'm seeing in American universities is students are being taught to look out on society look at all the people out there don't see people see groups locked in struggle with groups in an eternal zero-sum game the white men are the group on top they're the bad people they always have been they always will be unless we all organize to take them down”
Experiments that have tried to test trigger warnings show either no benefit or some backfire effect; the evidence so far suggests trigger warnings are not helpful to people with PTSD
“there are also a few experiments that have tried experimentally to either give or not give they suggest either no benefit we'll be some backfire we don't know the answer yet good experiments are going to be done it's an empirical question so far there is very there is no evidence to suggest that trigger warnings are helpful to people with PTSD”
Gen Z grew up with the ability to block things they don't want to see on social media, making them adept at digital curation but unable to trust each other in face-to-face settings because they cannot block each other in the real world.
“the students again gen Zed which grew up with the ability to block things that they don't want a lot of people they don't want they're very adept at social media and so what's happened is we don't trust each other we don't we it's very difficult for professors to trust their students”
The government and market have been the two dominant institutional sectors in recent decades, but healthy societies historically require a third sector—civil society (including universities)—organized around collaboration and cooperation rather than competition.
“we have always historically had healthy societies when we had a third arena because the state and the market are both about competition they're about what in the short term is zero sum games the more power I give away the less I have the more money I give away the less I have there has to be a third arena which we sometimes called civil society a key arena of which is the university which is not about competition it's about collaboration and cooperation and we need to learn how to cooperate as well as how to completely compete”
When students organize collectively to say they do not want a certain person speaking on campus, that is a perfectly fine expression of their free will and freedom of speech, not a violation of anyone else's.
“but I saw what you're always gonna have no platform there's always a level where you say look Holocaust denier don't come to university right but who is it that has the power to decide whether Steve banner should come I would argue if the students you should not be the danza nearly and if the students get together and say we don't want this person then that's a perfectly fine expression of their free will right to speak”
Universities are flawed and struggling institutions evolving just like the rest of society, and viewing them as sanctified repositories of apolitical knowledge is a mistake.
“the University in and of itself isn't this kind of like sanctified repository of of knowledge that cannot be that is apolitical and cannot be questioned there are cultural institutions they live in our society they are as flawed and as struggling and in evolution as the rest of us right”
Andrews responds that the questioners are 'wonderful exceptions to the rule' and that whether one likes it or not, being perceived as a black man or woman will have an impact on one's life in a racist society.
“look the idea that we're gonna disagree cause of black who said that my point is that whether you like it or not you were seen as a black man and whether you like it or not that's gonna have an impact on your life now you can live in a dreamland where you think it does not but that's up to you right you stay there”
Progress toward equality doesn't happen through reasoning and debate alone; it happens through organization, when people come together and take action like protesting at universities.
“one of the problems with this debate is this idea that the route to equality is we sit down reason it out and we come to this wonderful new utopia we have been on the right side of the argument for 500 years it has gotten those are nowhere that is not how progress happens it's simply not that's not how progress happens progress happens through organization when people come together when people do things like I don't know protester races speak a university”
The mental health crisis in Gen Z began when the first cohort of Gen Z (those born around 1995) reached university age around 2013, which is exactly when students began asking for protections from words, books, speakers, and ideas as though they were dangerous
“we have a mental health crisis it begins with kids born in 1995 we call them gen Z or Gen Zed you would say or the or I Gen for the internet generation so when this generation arrives on campus in the United States that's around age 18 they come to the University so in nineteen twenty thirteen they first the first members of Gen Z Gen Zed come to campus and that's when all of these things start none of us had heard of these terms practically but by 2014 in a few school students were asking for protections from words books speakers ideas”
Haidt describes three different psychological games universities play: truth-seeking (exploration/discovery with norms of claims/counterclaims), growth (therapeutic mindset of what students need to develop), and victory (defeating opponents in public square discourse)
“so if what we're doing is trying to find the truth what we're doing is exploration discovery we organize ourselves in a certain land we're all oriented towards claims and counterclaims this is what we think of ourselves as doing it kandi may be right that this is utilized view there's a lot else going on this is what Talmudic scholarship is about there's a phrase in the in the Bible maybe some proverbs iron sharpens iron we get smarter from contesting so if that's what we're trying to do we have one set of norms and that's going to favor favored fairly broad conception of speech free speech another thing that we might do in universities is help students grow and I've looked at a lot of university mission statements and they usually are about discovery and growth or learning now if we do that it's going to be a different mindset but it's going to be a kind of a somewhat therapeutic mindset of what do students need and what do they need to grow”
A questioner being black and half-white notes that they don't care that people in the room are white because there is diversity in the room and all people are different in their own rights, not reducible to racial categories.
“I'm half-black and half-white and the lady in front of me she was Brazilian she's got a black boyfriend and that goes black over there there's a Jewish man sitting over there like what I say is when you Iceman is loud like I'm looking at this room I don't really care that anyone's white like because there's a lot of because you're saying our COC of 80% white beef when it's like that all the time wait so you're that's what you're seeing as a as a black man yourself here but I'm not seeing that so I don't and I don't like how you are”
Milo Yiannopoulos was given platforms and book deals ($250,000+) not on neutral free speech grounds but because his views were acceptable to publishers; when he advocated for pedophilic relationships, his platforms were withdrawn, showing that platform provision is not neutral but editorial.
“that Milo gianopolous was given a a lot of platforms and a very sweet book deal on the basis that he was this free speech Crusader and that anyone who opposed him and opposed his his absolute god-given right to speak in front of thousands and thousands of people which he could have done anyway via the Internet which is you know another point you can't possibly know platform anyone ultimately these days because of the technology you know that seemed like a neutral choice but as soon as he came out and said something that people genuinely disagreed with which was when he said things in support of pedophilic relations he instantly had his platforms poles he had his book deal withdrawn which indicates that people weren't neutrally supporting free speech because they certainly weren't giving those kind of 250 thousand pound buck deals to kind of you know like crusty and narcos like rummaging through the bins at the back of the publishing house as well they were giving it to people who - whose views were acceptable to their world picture”
The approach of safetyism, trigger warnings, and safe spaces makes students see more threats, increases external locus of control (belief that vast forces determine outcomes), wastes their four years in college by focusing on defeating enemies rather than learning.
“thinking this way makes you see more threats makes you have more of an external locus of control because these vast forces are what determine your outcome and my god does it waste your 4 years when you could be learning and instead you're focused on defeating the enemy”
When teaching a class of 300 students, faculty must teach to the most sensitive student because any one of them can report you, creating a chilling effect even if most students are fine and not depressed.
“so we all share stories when I started this in 2015 people thought that we were exaggerating we're taught to talk about a few anecdotes because it was just starting then now it has spread so far that even though most students are fine most students are not depress they want to learn they want to be exposed but if you have a class of 300 students you now have to teach to the most sensitive student because any one of them can report you”
The BBC has had trigger warnings for 50 years with no problems until women, queer people, and people of color started getting input on what those warnings look like
“the BBC has been doing trigger warnings for 50 years and no one has had a problem with it until like women and queer people and people of color started getting a say in what those trigger warnings look like”
Haidt's daughter in third grade was part of a play group that excluded others, and the teacher addressed this by having the group discuss why excluding people is wrong, but Haidt worries that if his daughter never experiences exclusion during childhood, she won't be able to handle small social setbacks in college
“my daughter when she was in third grade last year in New York City public schools the girls would form play groups on the playground and hers was the kitty cat club and only members of the kitty cat Club could hang out in a certain place and so the teacher said well you know she led them through why we can't exclude people it's wrong to exclude people well okay it's a good discussion to have but if my daughter would go all the way through schooling without having those experiences when she gets to college she won't be able to handle small things”
Van Jones argued to Democratic activists planning to exclude a Trump administration official from University of Chicago that emotional/ideological safety is harmful; instead 'I don't want you to be safe emotionally, I don't want you to be safe ideologically, I want you to be strong'
“Van Jones said something I thought that was beautiful and and very wise he said if there's a certain conception of safety I mean physical safety or if people are screaming racial epithets at you of course you should be safe from that he said but there's another conception of safety which is terrible terrible for students he said I don't want you to hear he's speaking to the especially the the Democratic activists in the audience he says I don't want you to be safe emotionally I don't want you to be safe ideologically I want you to be strong and that's different”
Sacks grew up in a Jewish minority at Christ College but did not feel bothered because Judaism is a civilization of arguments; he found intellectual antifragility through being a cognitive minority
“I grew up as a Jewish pupil at a school called Christ College so I knew I was you know a cognitive minority but that didn't bother me because I've often argued that Judaism is a civilization all of whose canonical texts anthologies of arguments and I think that's all God actually does in the in the Bible is argue with people and the people he loves arguing with people I gave round Moses Jeremiah and Joe these are the heroes of faith there's no such thing there's no Hebrew word for obedience”
Haidt has changed the way he teaches because he is now reluctant to create emotional discomfort in students due to fear they will report him as making them unsafe, even though he used to be a provocative teacher who could tell jokes and show videos
“I used to be a provocative teacher I do not provoke anymore I just play it straight I don't tell jokes I don't show many videos because it's happened to you personally yes it happens to a lot of people”
UK schools banning snowball fights because of the risk someone might get hit in the eye exemplifies how overprotection from small risks prevents children from learning how to face larger risks
“one of your head teachers recently banned snowball fights because what if someone gets hit in the eye if we protect kids from small risks they don't learn how to face larger risks”
When black students go to university in jeans and trainers, they get harassed by security and have staff question where they're going, even after years of being staff; this is the type of racism that safe spaces respond to
“for example I went to university day in jeans and trainers I never do this at university because when I do this usually even though I've been a member of staff for years I get harassed by security I have staff questioning me where I'm going in the building so as he's anxious going into work dressed like this that were usually dressed right that's what is like at university and I go to Burnham City I work at Birmingham City which is one of the most diverse universities in the in the country”
Haidt distinguishes between political correctness (being more polite to not alienate people unnecessarily, which is good) and safetyism (treating ideas as dangerous, which is harmful)
“I also agree that a lot of political correctness is just being more polite updating language so that it doesn't alienate people unnecessarily so I think on free speech we're actually not that far apart”
Haidt acknowledges that his book attempts to infer causality from time lag data (changes in one place at one time followed by outcome changes in another place at another time), which provides some reason to think causality, but that they are careful about not overstating the causal claims
“we are very careful you're right that most most studies of human outcomes over many years can't be done experimentally so it is correlational so in the book we're very careful about that we draw on research that at least tries to look at time lag so if something changes in one place and one point in one place in a different time in a different place that and then the outcomes differ that is at least some reason to infer that there's probably causality we are very careful about that you're right frankly we don't know why the depression rates are rising and we deal very carefully with that we say here the hypotheses here's the reason to think this we don't know why they're rising so quickly in the Anglosphere in particular”
A woman said she never let her color or sex get in the way of progress and broke the glass ceiling through hard work, suggesting that if you see no color and prejudice, you get it reciprocated
“I've never let my color or my sex get in the way of the progress that I wanted to make I've managed to break the glass ceiling just through hard work and I've never made any excuses for you know where I wanted to go I think that if you see no color and you see no prejudice then you get it reciprocated”