
Stephen Hicks: From the Falsification of Marxism to Post-Modernism
What this covers
This ten-minute clip, cut from a longer talk by philosopher Stephen Hicks, starts from Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels and their scientific socialism. That framework claimed the economy runs on natural laws that can be understood and used for prediction, and it cast its authors as heirs of the Enlightenment. Hicks then goes through the forecasts one by one: wealth would concentrate in a tiny capitalist class, the petite bourgeoisie) would be squeezed out, and the majority would sink to subsistence. He says that by mid-century the opposite had happened, with more wealthy people, a larger middle class, and falling poverty. He adds that postwar Western Europe and Canada were visibly prosperous, which made the failure personal for intellectuals who had spent careers opposing those systems.
The second half is about psychology. Hicks describes two responses to evidence against a faith central to one's identity: revise the faith, or attack reason itself ("it's all semantics," "that's just your interpretation"). He illustrates the second with the image of someone who has hated a high school rival and then finds that rival thriving. He treats socialism as both a scientific theory and an eschatological promise, so the stakes are higher than in an ordinary scientific dispute. From there he moves to the skeptical epistemological tradition and to relativistic cognitive strategies. He describes a shift from constructing new frameworks to deconstructivism, and from relativism about truth to relativism about culture and morality.
Two points are flagged as contested: that postmodernism emerged as a response to the postwar crisis of the left, and that skepticism appeals as a way to avoid admitting error. A shorter aside charges that postmodern writers borrow quantum mechanics, relativity, Gödel and chaos mathematics as rhetoric without grasping their content. Hicks also notes that Marxist fervor draws on hostility to capitalism and on the expectation that it would fail.
The speaker argues that when Marxist predictions failed to materialize in the 20th century, left-wing intellectuals abandoned scientific epistemology for postmodern skepticism and relativism as a psychological defense mechanism to preserve their ideological commitments rather than accept empirical falsification.
- Classical Marxist predictions (wealth concentration, middle-class elimination, increasing poverty) were empirically falsified by 1950, yet socialists maintained ideological commitment
- When evidence contradicted their theory, leftists adopted skeptical epistemology and relativism as defensive strategies rather than revising their framework
- The psychological mechanism mirrors religious believers confronting evidence against faith—some change beliefs, others attack reason itself
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
When people hold strongly-held idealistic faith that is core to their identity, and evidence against it accumulates, they face a psychological choice: either revise their faith to match evidence, or attack reason and evidence as unreliable.
“if you have a strongly held idealistic faith in something it's part of the fiber of who you are What do you do when the data and the arguments and the evidence seems to be against it? Right? So, if you think of people who are very religious, but they're also intellectual and they think seriously about the arguments for and against the existence of God... What do you do right at that very pregnant moment right inside your head? And you have a couple of strategies”
The Marxist prediction that 'the rich get richer and the poor get poorer' forecasted a progressive concentration of wealth through competitive elimination, resulting in a tiny capitalist class controlling all resources while the vast majority faced subsistence-level poverty.
“Marxist slogan uh you know the rich get richer and the poor get poorer... in this brutal competitive capitalist uh struggle for resources... what you end up with is a very few capitalists at the top who are in control of all of society's resources and the vast majority of people are forced into subsistence level right poverty”
Marx and Engels developed 'scientific socialism,' a framework claiming the economy operates according to natural laws that can be understood and used to make predictions about future phenomena, positioning themselves as children of the Enlightenment.
“Marx and Engles as they enunciated their version of socialism... the label was scientific socialism. So in one respect they did see themselves as a child of the enlightenment, right? the the world works according to certain natural laws that we can understand”
One psychological strategy when evidence contradicts deeply-held faith is to prioritize truth-seeking by revising faith to match evidence, changing one's religion, becoming non-religious, or adopting a different belief system that aligns with data.
“One thing is to do is to say, well, if the reason and the evidence and the logic are going against my faith, then I need to change my faith. I need to get a different religion, become non-religious, right? Or something like that because it's important to get the truth. And the way we get the truth is by looking at the data and the evidence”
By the mid-20th century, all major predictions of classical Marxism had not only failed to materialize but their exact opposites had come true, creating a fundamental crisis between theory and empirical reality.
“all of the major predictions of the classical Marxist model uh were not only just not coming true but the exact opposite right of them seem to be coming true”
Contrary to Marxist predictions, the 20th century saw an expansion rather than contraction of the wealthy; more and more rich people developed in free market systems rather than progressive elimination of all but a few capitalists.
“it's not the case that we're having a smaller number of rich people right at the top of the heap. Instead, what happens is we have more and more rich people right developing in the free market capitalists”
Contrary to Marxist predictions, poverty rates declined and people were lifted out of poverty rather than being forced into subsistence-level poverty as capitalist competition progressed.
“It's not the case that most people are being forced into poverty and instead what happens is the poverty rate is going down and people are being lifted out of poverty”
Marxists predicted the middle class (petite bourgeoisie) was a temporary class that would be squeezed out and eliminated by free market competition, but instead the middle class expanded throughout the 20th century, the exact opposite of the prediction.
“They had also predicted that the middle class was this temporary class that it was going to be squeezed out right by the uh by the free market competition. The pet bourgeois... but what [was] happening was the exact opposite of that. The middle class, right, was expanding”
Beyond psychological defense mechanisms and epistemological relativism, Marxism and socialism derive fervor from critical opposition to free market capitalism and its perceived sins, and from predictions that capitalism would worsen and ultimately fail, igniting revolution.
“the flip side of that is that Marxism and socialism, right, more broadly, part of its fervor, right, comes from being critical of free market capitalism, the sins of uh of free markets as they uh as they see them. And part of Marxism, of course, was making predictions, right, that capitalism was going to get worse and worse and then ultimately fail and implode. and out of that right would come the revolution”
When an ideologically committed movement experiences theoretical failure, a skeptical or anti-Enlightenment epistemology becomes psychologically attractive as it provides an alternative to admitting the theory was wrong while preserving ideological commitment.
“How come then the skeptical epistemological tradition or the anti-enlightenment epistem epistemic tradition becomes so attractive for a movement that is trying to cope with its disappointment and and failed predictions”
After World War II, the left faced a crisis requiring rethinking of the classical Marxist framework because empirical outcomes contradicted predictions, and postmodernism emerged as one intellectual variation attempting to resolve this crisis.
“by we get by the time rather we get to uh the 1950s people are rethinking after World War II what what's going to happen next the left is rethinking we we have to do something to the classical Marxist framework because it's just not working. So what do we do? Postmodernism is one of the variations that come”
From deconstructivism and relativism about truth, intellectuals proceed to relativism about culture and morality, claiming 'all cultures are equal' and 'all truth is relative,' abandoning truth-seeking as a coherent project.
“Then you deconstruct and then also I guess you could become a bit of relativist in a sense that that all cultures are equal. There is no there all truth is relative”
By the 1950s, as social scientific data accumulated throughout the 20th century, Marxist intellectuals recognized a major mismatch between their theory and empirical practice, forcing a rethinking of the classical Marxist framework.
“as the social science data, right, came in and it got better as the 20th century went on. Then clearly the Marxists are looking at the data. They're looking at the theory. we are social scientists and they're recognizing that there's a major mismatch between the theory and the practice. Uh and so that is I think one of the things that by we get by the time rather we get to uh the 1950s people are rethinking”
After World War II, liberal capitalist nations (including their allies like Canada and Western Europe) recovered from the war, began producing consumer goods (TVs), achieved widespread affluence (cars, vacations), and achieved widespread prosperity—making this empirical reality a psychological problem for the far left.
“after World War II uh the liberal capitalist countries they picked themselves up. They started producing TVs. Everybody had a car. They're taking vacations. Life was pretty good, right? And that's a problem for the far left”
The deployment of complex scientific language and concepts in postmodern discourse that misappropriates them as rhetorical tools is 'really just a rhetorical strategy' used by people who don't understand the science well but want to sound sophisticated while avoiding scientific claims that can be empirically tested.
“So, it then just becomes a semantics issue. But it's really uh just a rhetorical strategy, I think, as you're suggesting by people who don't really know the science, right, very well”
Socialism functions simultaneously as both a scientific theory attempting to understand the world and an eschatological/religious theory promising heavenly transformation, making the psychological stakes much higher than ordinary scientific disputes.
“if you think of socialism, it's not just a scientific theory trying to understand the world that it also is an esquetological theory. It's a it's a it's a a theory of high idealism that if we commit ourselves to we are going to transform the world and and create so to speak heaven on earth and so all of that religious language I think is important to understanding the psychology right of people who buy into the Marxist tradition”
When intellectual constructions fail to match reality, believers shift from constructivism (building new frameworks) to deconstructivism, attacking the foundations of knowledge itself rather than admitting error, changing from 'creating a new earth' to deconstructing existing certainties.
“So you when your constructions fail, you start to be a deconstructivist. That's right. That's right. And so and so instead of saying that we are creating a new earth and new heavens... So when you cannot create anymore then you have to be destruct or con deconstruct at least. That's right. That's right. Then you become deconstructionist”
Intellectuals without deep scientific knowledge appropriate quantum mechanics, relativity theory, Gödel's incompleteness theorem, and chaos mathematics as rhetorical tools to justify epistemological relativism, conflating scientific uncertainty with the claim that 'nothing can be known' despite the theories' actual content supporting specific knowledge.
“Then you start to try to marry yourself into quantum mechanics or relativity theory but not necessarily by understanding it but right just as a rhetorical tool right so uh to come back yeah to the issue of science right we've all heard you know Einstein relativity theory right well you just glom on to relativity and then from the uninformed humanity's educated right perspective right that sounds like relativism of course it isn't right or girdle's incompleteness theorem Oh, incompleteness. Oh, that sounds like us too, right? Or chaos mathematics, right? And so forth”
By the 1950s, socialist intellectuals faced a psychological crisis not only because their theory was falsified but also because they could see that free-market capitalist nations (Canada, most of Western Europe) were flourishing while they had spent their careers bitterly and violently opposed to this system.
“by the time we get to the 1950s the socialist intellectuals can see that there are serious troubles with their theory but they also can look at the relatively free market capitalist nations around the world you Canada most of the western European nations as well and they can see that the countries that have gone more free market are all flourishing right and doing really well And then again psychologically how does that fit right when you have spent a significant amount of your intellectual career invested in being bitterly and violently opposed right to that movement”
An alternative psychological strategy when evidence contradicts deeply-held faith is to attack reason, evidence, and logic itself, claiming 'everything is just semantics,' 'nobody really knows the truth,' or 'that's just your interpretation,' using skeptical and relativistic strategies as defensive mechanisms for values one wants to preserve.
“the other strategy people can follow psychologically is if the evidence and the data goes against something that they really want to believe deeply, they will go on the offensive against reason. They will go on the offensive against logic. They will say everything is just semantics. Nobody really knows the truth. Right? That's just your interpretation. Right? That is to say, they bring in skeptical epistemological strategies or relativistic cognitive strategies, but it's a defense mechanism for a value system or a belief system that they want to hold dearly”
The psychological dynamics of ideologically committed intellectuals confronting evidence against their worldview mirror the situation of a person who spent years hating a high school rival and then encounters that rival thriving while one is personally failing—resentment and existential despair compound into emotional investment in maintaining opposition despite evidence of success.
“I would put it this way. If you just put it on a personal level, suppose you think of the person you hated the most in high school, right? Or in middle school, right, who was kind of you just didn't like this person, he didn't like you, right? And then you go to your high school reunion 20 years later, right? And right, you're working your deadend job, right, that you hate and you're just going through your second divorce, right? And then your hated rival, right, shows up, right, in a beautiful car with a beautiful spouse and clearly is, you know, a multi-millionaire and flourishing, right?”