What this covers

On this episode of the American Compass Podcast, Oren is joined by Michael Pettis, senior fellow at the Carnegie Endowment, for an in-depth discussion of the dollar as the global reserve currency: pros, cons, and what it all means for the American economy.

Further Reading: - The High Price of Dollar Dominance (Michael Pettis, Foreign Affairs): https://www.foreignaffairs.com/united-states/high-price-dollar-dominance - Bad Trade (Michael Pettis, American Compass): https://americancompass.org/bad-trade/ - Talkin’ (Policy) Shop: Balancing U.S. Trade: https://americancompass.org/policy-in-brief-balancing-u-s-trade/

Source description (no synthesized summary yet).


The claims · ranked31 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.78

The US does not control its capital account; foreigners can invest in US assets whenever they choose, so the US cannot control the gap between investment and savings—by definition, if foreign inflows do not increase investment (which they do not in the 21st century), then savings must fall, manifesting as household debt or fiscal deficits.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Michael Pettis

“if the US does not control its capital account and it doesn't if you want to invest in the US you can do so any time you want so the US does not control the capital account that means by definition the US cannot control the gap between investment and savings uh again in the 19th century foreign inflows cause Investments to go up today that doesn't happen but they still cause the Gap to to expand so savings must go down”

0.76

After German labor reforms, the gap between German wages and productivity became larger than the Spanish gap, making German workers 'cheaper' in competitive terms (relative to productivity) even though German absolute wage levels remained higher than Spanish wages.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Pettis

“after 2003 German Workers became cheaper than Spanish workers many people think that means that German wages were lower than Spanish wages and they say of course that didn't happen German wages were always higher than Spanish wages but what matters is not the level of wages what matters is the level of wages relative to productivity and so what happened in Germany the gap between wages and productivity was much greater than in Spain so German Workers became cheaper”

0.74

The US possessed capital controls until 1983, during which period a eurodollar market developed offshore to handle dollar transactions outside US regulatory jurisdiction, demonstrating that the dollar's dominance as a transaction medium could survive separation from its role as a surplus absorption mechanism.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Michael Pettis

“the US had capital controls until basically 1983 uh there were difficulties in moving money in and out of the US and so what ended up happening is you saw the development of the euro dollar market which was the dollar market outside of the US when I first started in Investment Banking the euro dollar market was extremely important its importance has faded away because there's no longer a distinction between offshore dollars and onshore dollars but when there was um the the dollar market dominated International transactions”

0.73

The claim that Americans are inherently low-savers and high-consumers is false; rather, the US is structurally forced to become the 'consumer of Last Resort' because it must absorb global excess savings, making consumption the inevitable result of its role in the global system, not a cultural preference.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“when people talk about Americans being inveterate consumers and reluctant to save that's not true the us because of its role of absorber of global savings has no choice but to become the consumer of Last Resort it's the same thing right”

0.73

Trade deficits represent flows of manufactured goods into the US offset by flows of assets (equity ownership, real estate, and government debt) back out, meaning the US receives goods and sends back IOUs (Treasury bonds) that represent a promise to produce goods and send them to foreigners in the future.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Pettis

“if if people are sending us more goods and services than than we are sending back then what we're sending back instead are assets and so in in a sense the trade is okay the rest of the world manufactures a lot of of stuff that we consume here in the United States obviously we manufacture stuff that others consume but on on balance a significant share of what we send back is assets meaning ownership of corporate equities ownership of real estate and then importantly debt the funny thing to remember is that if when when the US government issues a treasury bond that's an asset it it is it is US borrowing but but what it means is it's an IOU”

0.73

Savings reduction in deficit countries occurs through one or more of three mechanisms: rising unemployment as consumers buy fewer domestic goods, rising household debt as households increase consumption beyond wage-justified levels, or rising fiscal deficits as governments increase spending to offset demand gaps.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Pettis

“there are three ways savings can go down one way is with a rise in Spanish unemployment so as Spanish consumers buy more and more German Goods they buy fewer and fewer Spanish goods and so Spanish factories have to fire workers workers have a negative savings rate...there's two things they can do to uh to beat that one is to encourage how household debt so you see an increase in household debt as households increase consumption faster than their wages justify and the other way is with an increase in the fiscal deficit”

0.73

A strong dollar resulting from foreign capital inflows transfers income from net importers (households) to net exporters (manufacturers) in the US, while a cheap currency does the opposite, making it no surprise that manufacturing migrates to countries subsidizing it through currency depreciation.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Pettis

“a cheap REM andb is a way of transferring income from net importers to net exporters so who are net importers all households are net importers who are net exporters the tradeable goods sector manufacturers so in China a cheaper m&b is a subsidy from household consumers to the manufacturing sector in the US it's the obers whether we like it or not the expens of dollar means that there is a transfer from net exporters to net importers again net exporters are the manufacturing sector net importers are the household sector”

0.70

The US is approximately 23% of world GDP but accounts for 28-30% of global consumption and only 17% of global manufacturing, while China is ~17% of world GDP but accounts for 13% of consumption and an astonishing 31% of global manufacturing—this allocation directly reflects the subsidy structure created by the dollar's reserve status.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Michael Pettis

“the United States is 177% I'm sorry the United States is about 23% of the world of global GDP it accounts for 28 29 30% of global consumption and only 177% of global manufacturer China which is about 177% of the world accounts for 133% of global consumption and it accounts for an astonishing 31% of global manufacturing”

0.68

The US dollar, British pound, Canadian dollar, and Australian dollar represent 60-80% of all global trade deficits despite economic theory predicting that rich countries should run surpluses and poor countries deficits, because rich countries should export capital to poor countries with high investment needs.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“when I tell you that group of currencies you'll immediately understand the connection among them it's basically the US dollar the British pound the Canadian dollar and the Australian dollar and what those uh four countries have in common is that contrary to what economic theory would tell us uh they represent something like 60 to 80% of all global trade deficits that should surprise us because what economic theory tells us is that um developing countries should have high investment needs and scarce domestic savings so they should be net importers of capital from the rich countries”

0.68

A well-functioning trading system based on comparative advantage cannot sustain persistent surpluses and deficits; penalizing trade imbalances restores genuine free trade rather than undermining it, because countries currently subsidize exports and suppress imports through policies that violate comparative-advantage principles.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“the irony is that many people argue that these are protectionist policies that undermine a well-functioning global trading system but it's exactly the opposite we don't have a well-functioning trading system in a well-functioning trading system you can't run persistent surpluses uh a well-functioning trading system operates on comparative advantage and the benefits of comparative Advantage are realized only in the exchange of goods not in the production of goods so what we would be doing is forcing the world back into really a kind of optimal free trade uh uh area uh and you have to do that by penalizing countries that currently undermine Global free trade right”

0.68

Countries implement 'beggar thy neighbor' policies—reforms like Germany's 2003 labor reforms that suppressed wage growth relative to productivity—to make their manufacturing sectors extremely competitive by transferring income from workers to manufacturers, forcing those countries to run trade surpluses that must be absorbed by other economies like the US.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“there have been a number of uh uh policies implemented around the world which we're familiar with in the 1930s we call those beggar Thy Neighbor policies the point of which is to make the manufacturing sector extremely competitive at the expense of domestic demand and the result is countries that follow these policies have to run trade surpluses”

0.68

Most economists hold a 19th-century view of the balance of payments that leads them to incorrectly argue the US would suffer from trade deficit elimination; they fail to understand that deficits force adjustment through debt rather than investment in modern economies.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“most economists and certainly most economists above a certain age an age which I include myself uh are locked into really a 19th century view of the balance of payments so they don't really understand this so their argument is that without the current account deficit or without the trade deficit American consumption would be lower”

0.68

The power of the dollar as a tool of sanctions and financial dominance is not fixed but depends on the credibility of the US economy; as the US increasingly relies on household debt and fiscal deficits to generate growth, the economic credibility underlying dollar power should decline, eventually undermining its geopolitical utility.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“the power of the dollar is not fixed you know by God the power of the dollar is determined really by the power of the US economy and The credibility of the US economy and as the US economy relies more and more on a rise in household debt or fiscal deficits to generate growth that seems to me it should undermine that credibility and eventually we lose the ability to use the dollar as a uh as a source of global power”

0.64

Without the current account deficit, American consumption levels would be as high as ever (or higher), but would be driven by higher wages and production rather than by household or fiscal debt, because Americans are both producers and consumers and consumption depends on production plus debt.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“without the trade deficit American consumption would be as high as ever but it would be driven by higher wages rather than by higher debt because what you would end up having as American production would would expand and the idea that Americans exist only as consumers is of course total nonsense you are both a consumer and a producer so your consumption levels depends on your production levels plus your debt so without the current account deficit consumption would be as high as ever or even higher except it would be driven by a a rise in production rather than a rise in household or fiscal debt”

0.64

Capital controls—taxes on foreign capital entering the US—represent a more nuanced and historically precedented policy option than tariffs, as the US imposed capital controls until 1983 and such controls can restrict asset purchases without eliminating the dollar's role in foreign trade transactions.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“the second solution is uh if the problem is that foreigners are uh dumping their excess savings into the US economy then just prevent that so one way of doing that would be to impose taxes on foreign Capital entering into the country there's a number of ways of doing it and I always remind people people because you know they say this is something the US has never done on the contrary the US has often done it it was only in 1983 that we stopped imposing any form of capital controls we can go back to those previous periods um the the dollar market dominated International transactions”

0.64

Economist across both parties (Democrats with industrial policy and Republicans with trade policy) are increasingly recognizing that the US role in absorbing global imbalances has significant costs, representing a major shift in political consensus compared to the post-Cold War consensus favoring unfettered trade.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Michael Pettis

“one of the good things that has happened in in recent years and partly thanks to your work is that we're seeing a shift in the perception of the role of the US in global imbalancing so whether you talk about uh uh the Democrats with their industrial policies or the Republicans with their trade policies and basically there's no difference between the two in both cases there is a recognition that this has a significant cost for the us”

0.62

The main barrier to deficit country agreement on reformed trade rules is that it would require only major deficit countries (the Anglosphere) to agree; once they agree, surplus countries would have no choice but to conform because they cannot trade with deficit countries while being blocked from those markets.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“we don't need everyone to agree we just need the major deficit countries to agree because once they agree then the Surplus countries have to conform they have no choice”

0.61

Using import tariffs to rebalance the economy would be effective but requires levying enormous tariffs on all trading partners, both mercantilist and non-mercantilist, making it a blunt instrument that punishes countries not engaged in aggressive export-led policy.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“one way is through import tariffs um if you increase import tarff C enough it's the equivalent of depreciating the dollar or appreciating foreign currencies...now that requires an enormous amount of tariffs and that requires punishing all of our trade Partners uh the good ones and the bad ones the the ones that are following mercantilist policy and the ones that are not it's effective but it's pretty um it's it's it's maybe not terribly nuanced”

0.61

The eurozone's existence prevented Spain from devaluing its currency in response to German wage suppression and competitiveness gains, forcing Spain to resolve the resulting deficits through unemployment, debt, or fiscal deficits, demonstrating the trap of the euro for deficit countries.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“because uh uh because of the existence of the Euro there was nothing Spain could do about that and it started to run the large deficits that corresponded to German surpluses”

0.61

The eurozone system can be understood through papers by Atif Mian, Sofia Amir, and Ludwig Straub showing that an increase in savings by one group (e.g., German households or corporations) does not increase investment but instead reduces savings in other groups (Spanish households), keeping aggregate investment constant while shifting its source.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“there's a Ser there's a series of papers done by uh um Atif mean Sofia Amir and L strob that addressed that issue for most economists an increase in savings by definition means an increase in investment so if you increase the savings of businesses or if you increase Savings of the rich investment must go up and what they show is that that doesn't happen now investment is always equal to savings so what ends up happening is that if you increase the savings of certain groups the savings of other groups go down”

0.61

If foreign inflows into the US reduced American interest rates, then interest rates in surplus countries (which export capital) should be lower than in deficit countries (which import capital), but in reality the opposite is true: surplus countries have lower interest rates than deficit countries, disproving the claim that foreign inflows reduce US rates.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“for those people who believe that foreign inflows reduce American interest interest rates there would be a very simple experiment look at countries that are receiving foreign money look at advanced economies forget about developing economies look at advanced economies that are receiving foreign inflows and look at advanced economies that are sending Capital abroad the latter's interest rate should be lower than the forers right uh because they're receiving all of this capital from the former and yet if you look you'll see that generally the interest rates Surplus countries is lower than the interest rate in deficit countries that's certainly the case today”

0.61

Advanced economies do not naturally manufacture less as they develop; rather, deficit economies manufacture less and surplus economies manufacture more because surplus countries subsidize manufacturing while deficit countries subsidize consumption.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“you will hear some economists say uh that actually advanced econom advanced economies like the US manufacturing naturally becomes a lower share of GDP that just shows that many e many US economists don't really look at the rest of the world if you look at other advanced economies like Germany South Korea Japan the manufacturing share of GDP is much larger than it is in the US uh it's not advanced economies that manufacture less it's deficit economies that manufacture less Surplus economies manufacture more”

0.61

When the US imposed sanctions on Russia in recent years, the display of dollar power initially impressed observers, but Russia quickly adjusted and the experience demonstrated that the threat of financial exclusion is less powerful than previously believed, validating Pettis's skepticism about conflating dollar dominance with economic power.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Orin Cass

“when the US imposed the sanctions everyone said like whoa look at this what a what an extraordinary display of dollar dominance if anything maybe may may maybe we sort of you know slam the button too hard uh but but that quite quickly people discovered actually uh Russia had no problem adjusting accordingly and that whereas everyone is happy to sort of pretend that the dollar has this power when when we're not using it as soon as we actually tried to use it it turned out not to be nearly as powerful”

0.61

Federal government spending effectively launders foreign capital inflows into cash transfers back to the public for consumption rather than productive investment, completing the cycle in which foreign savings finance domestic consumption rather than capital accumulation.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Orin Cass

“the federal government serves to launder that investment into uh cash transfers back out to the public to consumed and so it it essentially all comes back to the story that that you started with where the these savings ends up Landing back as household and and fiscal debt that finances consumption but but has no productive capacity underlying it”

0.61

The US trade deficit surge in the last 40-50 years corresponds directly to the surge in American household and fiscal debt, which itself is a consequence of surging surpluses in the rest of the world resolved by acquiring dollar-denominated assets.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“so I would argue it's not a big surprise in the last 40 to 50 years we've seen a surge in American debt that surge in American debt corresponds to the surge in the American deficit which is itself a consequence of surging surpluses in the rest of the world”

0.61

China is competitive not because Chinese manufacturers are efficient but because they are extremely subsidized through weak labor rights that prevent wage increases, artificially low interest rates, and excessive infrastructure spending—making Chinese competitiveness dependent on subsidies rather than productivity.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“many people think that China is a big exporting Nation because Chinese man manufacturers are extremely efficient and I think that's a mistake they're not efficient they're extremely subsidized uh sometimes directly but more importantly in the form of very weak labor rights if if if a labor has very weak rights then they can't raise wages which is a subsidy for uh employers of course um very low interest rates uh very low interest rates artificially low interest rates are a transfer from net Sal to net borrowers”

0.61

Chinese excess savings flowing to the US do not result in increased American investment but rather in reduced American savings, and this is bad for both countries long-term because it creates a systematic tendency to suppress demand that requires compensatory debt growth in both countries.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“Chinese excess savings are coming to the US and they're not resulting in an increase in American Investment they're resulting in a reduction in American Savings that's how savings and investment uh uh balances globally and I would argue that that's bad not just for the us but also for China in the long term it's bad for the global economy because it means that uh there is a systematic tendency to suppress demand and the only way to overcome that demand suppression is with the rise in debt”

0.56

The trillion-dollar annual US trade deficit is matched by roughly a trillion dollars in corporate stock buybacks, reflecting the fact that corporations cannot find productive uses for the capital and instead return it to shareholders, where it becomes trapped in the financial system or finances government deficits rather than real investment.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Orrin Cass

“it's really interesting to to line up the now approaching trillion dollar trade deficit and therefore Capital account Surplus next to the roughly trillion dollars in annual stock BuyBacks right that that corporations are professing they simply have have no no way to productively deploy the capital”

0.56

The dollar's reserve currency status and the ability to finance deficits through it benefit certain US constituencies (major banks, Wall Street, the foreign affairs establishment, owners of movable capital) while harming others (farmers, workers, small businesses, producers), creating a distributional conflict that should be debated explicitly rather than resolved through claims about economic efficiency.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Pettis

“if you are um uh uh a major US Bank or Wall Street firm or if you are a major owner of movable capital or if you are in the Foreign Affairs establishment then the global role of the dollar is a very good thing if you are an American Farmer worker producer small business it's a bad thing and so I think that's really how we have to think about the role of the of the dollar it benefits certain constituencies in the US and it hurts other constituencies so we have to decide as a country what's more important uh the underlying economy and our manufacturing capacity or our ability to dominate Global finance and to impose Financial sanctions on enemies”

0.51

The US has historically been able to rebuild entire industries despite claims they are permanently lost to foreign competition, as demonstrated by the chemical manufacturing industry which was dominant in the 1990s but declined due to subsidies given to foreign competitors; gradual rebalancing over 5-10 years would allow the US to rebuild industries it has abandoned.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Michael Pettis

“the US didn't go from Surplus to deficit in a couple of months it took several years and over that period we saw the undermining of a whole series of American Industries in the 1990s for example the US was the leading manufacturer of chemicals today it doesn't do chemicals almost at all and you can go industry by industry so the the solution is not solve it overnight the solution is to solve this problem over a several year period so that what the US was able to do a few years ago and is no longer able to do because of massive subsidies to its foreign competitors it ends up rebuilding”

0.17

American Compass has published research demonstrating that the mechanism described in the podcast (trade deficits financing household and fiscal deficits rather than productive investment) is empirically correct and measurable, providing detailed policy recommendations on both current-account and capital-account mechanisms for addressing imbalances.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Orrin Cass

“we've done a bunch of research on this at American compass and okay well if you know supposedly people defend defend buybacks on the grounds that well that lets someone else deploy the capital instead but no one else does it it ends up Landing one way or another in treasuries and financing fiscal deficits”