YouTube10m· Feb 2017· cataloged

A VC Reveals the Metrics They Use to Evaluate Startups — The Startup Tapes #031


What this covers

This is a ten-minute conversation in The Startup Tapes series, in which Tim Anglade interviews Susan Liu, an investor at B2B software firm Scale Venture Partners. She describes how the firm screens hundreds of companies a year and deep-dives into tens of them. The talk centers on the handful of financial metrics used for that first pass, and on how a founder can prepare so diligence goes smoothly. Liu says the metrics only filter. They measure unit economics, not market size, team quality, or competitive position.

The metrics themselves get concrete treatment. ARR growth over eight quarters is read as a sign of product-market fit, with net new ARR ideally compounding from one quarter to the next. The magic number compares sales and marketing spend with the following quarter's new revenue, targets about 1.0, and is expected to dip while a company invests heavily in growth. Gross margins of 60-70% are treated as a structural requirement, since thin margins at current pricing are unlikely to improve. Cash runway of two years is the fourth, tied to reaching the next order of magnitude before raising at a higher valuation. Liu also ties runway to capital markets: planning should assume tighter conditions, and a company that cannot raise within a year should cut spending.

The more contentious material concerns what the numbers leave out. Liu argues that a VC may pass on a healthy company because its likely return doesn't fit the fund's stage expectations, even though another investor would back it eagerly. She notes that the market now rewards profitability more than pure growth. She separates SaaS, which usually requires deliberate spending to grow, from products with virality or network effects. On the practical side, she says investors prefer raw underlying data to founders' pre-calculated figures, because miscalculation is a common problem.

Sharpest takeaway

When evaluating SaaS companies for investment, VCs use a multi-factor framework combining financial metrics (ARR growth, magic number, gross margins, cash runway) with qualitative assessments (market size, team quality), but financial metrics alone are only a filtering mechanism—raw data integrity and business fundamentals matter more than polished presentations.

  • ARR growth trajectory and magic number (sales efficiency) are primary filters for product-market fit and sustainable growth
  • Two-year cash runway is a critical threshold because it allows companies to reach meaningful scale before needing to raise again at higher valuations
  • VCs reject companies based on return expectations relative to fund strategy, not business health alone—a well-performing company may be passed if returns don't match stage expectations

The claims · ranked22 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

Insufficient margin capture at current pricing is unlikely to improve over time, so if a SaaS company cannot maintain 60-70% gross margins today, the business model is structurally flawed and will remain so.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Scale Capital VP

“if you're really not able to capture a margin on your current pricing now, it's unlikely to change in the future, right?”

0.75

A VC may pass on a well-performing company if it doesn't meet the fund's return threshold relative to stage expectations, even though another VC with lower return targets might enthusiastically invest in the same company.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Scale Capital VP

“If you feel like you're not going to get a big enough outcome and you have this model that you have for your fund and it doesn't fit, then, most likely, the VC won't invest.”

0.75

Sales momentum provides operational buffer against mistakes, bad quarters, and bad hires, allowing companies with strong growth trajectory to absorb setbacks without existential risk.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Scale Capital VP

“if you have sales momentum that buys you so much freedom in terms of a bad quarter, a bad hire, or any number of things that might happen. If you have that sales momentum, you can afford to do a lot of mistakes.”

0.75

Magic number can decline when companies rapidly increase sales and marketing spend (investing in growth), but VCs expect it to normalize around 1.0 as the company matures, with understanding that the metric's deterioration during growth phases is expected and acceptable.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Scale Capital VP

“If the company is ramping very quickly, as in they're investing more in sales and marketing spend, this will often come down, but it's something that we expect as you grow. But typically we like to see one when we invest, and that's the metric that we look for.”

0.73

Companies achieving high growth with low spending typically have some form of virality or network effects that drive organic adoption, distinguishing them from traditional SaaS businesses that require paid customer acquisition.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Scale Capital VP

“Generally, the companies that do have this have some sort of virality. So there's some portion of it that can make it go viral. Most traditional SAS businesses are just not like that. You have to invest money into sales, and marketing, and sales people in order to drive the growth forward.”

0.73

Financial metrics (ARR growth, magic number, gross margins, cash runway) serve as effective filters for rapidly screening hundreds of companies, but should not be used as the sole evaluation criterion since they only assess business unit economics, not market size, team quality, or competitive positioning.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Scale Capital VP

“At our stage, it is good to use financial metrics as a filter, because we'll get many companies, right? And if you have more than a million AR, then the financial metrics are a good way to gauge the health of the business, but at the same time, we also take things like market size, team, et cetera, into consideration.”

0.69

Cash runway of at least two years from the investment date is a critical threshold for SaaS companies because it allows them to reach sufficient scale and metrics to raise the next funding round at a higher valuation.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Scale Capital VP

“we want to make sure, when we invest in companies, that the cash will last them at least two years.”

0.69

The maximum company size (total addressable market and growth trajectory) determines potential return, with the general principle that higher returns are preferable but return expectations vary by stage: early-stage investments expect higher returns than late-stage investments.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Scale Capital VP

“essentially, what we're looking for is how big can your company become, and, based off of that, what can we potentially make on the company? So generally, the higher return the better, but it depends on stage. So if you're investing in a more early-stage company, then the return, we expect it to be a lot higher. If the company is more leader stage, then we expect the return to be a bit lower.”

0.69

Magic number metric measures sales efficiency by comparing quarterly sales and marketing spend to incremental revenue generated in the following quarter, with a target of 1.0 indicating one dollar of new revenue for every dollar spent on sales and marketing.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Scale Capital VP

“for us, our metric is looking at the magic number. And what the magic number does is it looks at, based off of your sales and marketing slant for the last quarter, what new revenue are you adding for the next quarter?”

0.69

Companies with higher capital efficiency (achieving growth while spending less) benefit from extended cash runway, allowing them to reach profitability or larger scale before needing external funding.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Scale Capital VP

“If you're more capital efficient, then the cash will last you even longer. And we love finding companies that look like that.”

0.69

Annual Recurring Revenue (ARR) growth trajectory over eight quarters is a primary metric for identifying product-market fit, with strong signal when net new ARR compounds quarter-over-quarter (e.g., 10k → 20k → 40-50k ARR).

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Scale Capital VP

“The first I would say is we like to make sure that there is AR growth, meaning if you're looking at AR for the last, maybe, eight quarters, we want to make sure that net new AR is growing over time.”

0.68

Market preference has shifted: VCs increasingly value profitability and a path to profitability over insanely high growth, though companies combining both are rare and highly valued.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Scale Capital VP

“I feel like the market has changed a little bit, where at lot of VCs now value profitability, a path to profitability, versus the insanely high growth. Ideally, you can find companies that have both, but it is really rare.”

0.63

VCs consider potential return as a critical factor in investment decisions, incorporating multiple dimensions including financial trajectory, market size, and team quality, rather than financial metrics alone.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Scale Capital VP

“We definitely look at potential return. But the return part is a little bit tricky, right? Because we look at a whole bunch of different factors for this. So, financial is only one aspect of it. We also look at market size and all that.”

0.63

Gross margins for SaaS businesses should typically be in the 60-70% range to ensure sufficient cash flow for reinvestment and to avoid cost of goods sold (COGS) spiraling out of control.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Scale Capital VP

“We also look at gross margins, so you want to make sure you're in line with other SAS companies, so typically around 60, 70%.”

0.63

The primary data quality issue for VCs is that founders present pre-calculated metrics that may be computed incorrectly, making it necessary to request raw underlying data rather than accept calculated figures.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Scale Capital VP

“Sometimes I find that it might not be calculated correctly, and I just want to get the raw data and then figure it out myself.”

0.61

If a company's annual planning shows it cannot raise capital within the next year, it should reduce spending to extend cash runway; conversely, if funding appears available, it should spend more aggressively to capture higher growth.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Scale Capital VP

“if you think you're not going to be able to raise for another year, then you should probably spend a little bit less. But if you think you can raise money in the next year, then you can probably spend a little bit more and get higher growth.”

0.56

Capital market conditions directly affect how long cash needs to last: in favorable markets (recent past), companies could raise annually; in tight markets (current conditions), cash must last longer, so current planning should assume 2-year runway is necessary.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Scale Capital VP

“How often you can raise, it depends on a mixture of things. Like the capital market, so I would say funding came a little bit easier in the last couple of years, now it's getting a little bit more challenging, so the cash has to last a little bit longer.”

0.55

VCs prefer to receive raw underlying data from companies rather than pre-calculated metrics, as this allows independent verification and reduces the risk of miscalculation or intentional misrepresentation.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Scale Capital VP

“So if people were to send us data, I would prefer it if they just sent us all the raw data and have us figure it out, versus calculate the magic number.”

0.37

SaaS companies are structurally different from consumer companies in their growth dynamics: SaaS requires deliberate sales and marketing investment to drive growth, whereas consumer products can achieve virality or network-driven adoption.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Scale Capital VP

“They're not consumer companies, they're different models, after all.”

0.32

Scale Capital looks at hundreds of companies and conducts deep dives into tens of them per year, representing a systematic filtering funnel from broad market scanning to intensive due diligence.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Scale Capital VP

“We typically look at hundreds of companies, and then we do deep dives into maybe tens”

0.32

VCs maintain portfolio balance by holding a mixture of early-stage and late-stage investments, with allocation based on stage-specific return expectations and fund strategy rather than single-stage focus.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Scale Capital VP

“And we like to have a balance in terms of having a certain number of early-stage companies, and then a certain number of late-stage companies.”

0.32

The prototypical growth trajectory for funded SaaS companies involves taking an influx of capital, using it to grow to the next order of magnitude in scale and metrics within approximately two years, then raising another round at a higher valuation.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Scale Capital VP

“the prototypical gross curve would be, you're able to take this influx of funds, right, and really grow your company, and get to the next benchmark, the next order of magnitude, in that two-year period. Right, yes, that is the goal. And do another round, right?”