What this covers

Gary Taubes and Russ Roberts examine how the medical consensus around dietary fat and heart disease took root and persisted despite weak evidentiary foundations. Taubes, author of Good Calories, Bad Calories, traces the hypothesis back to Ancel Keys in the 1950s and argues it was never rigorously tested—the largest clinical trials either found no benefit to low-fat diets or, in one Minnesota study, actually found harm that investigators suppressed for sixteen years. He contends that observational comparisons between populations, though suggestive, cannot establish causation; Japanese and American diets differ in sugar consumption as much as fat, yet only fat became the focus because it matched the leading hypothesis.

The conversation moves into the institutional and psychological mechanisms that entrench weak science. Taubes identifies cognitive dissonance as a barrier—it is easier to dismiss an experiment than to abandon decades of public health advice. He describes how reputational stakes, career incentives, and the presumption of truth granted by major institutions like the American Heart Association all work to suppress falsification rather than encourage it. Roberts and Taubes discuss a parallel theme: both medicine and economics struggle with causation in complex systems, and both risk mistaking statistical association for proof. Taubes advances an alternative hypothesis—that refined carbohydrates and sugar, acting through insulin dysregulation, better explain the clustering of obesity, diabetes, and heart disease. He argues this framework aligns with historical patterns of these diseases emerging together only after populations adopted white flour and sugar, and suggests that correct diagnosis must precede treatment.

Sharpest takeaway

Taubes argues that the dietary-fat-causes-heart-disease consensus was built on weak observational evidence and ego-driven advocacy rather than rigorous experiment, and that the true driver of obesity, diabetes and heart disease is refined carbohydrates and sugar acting through insulin dysregulation.

  • No clinical trial ever confirmed that low-fat/cholesterol-lowering diets reduce heart disease mortality; the largest trials found no benefit or harm.
  • Obesity, diabetes, heart disease and hypertension cluster together and are linked by insulin resistance, suggesting one underlying cause rather than separate ones.
  • Scientific institutions defend the fat hypothesis through cognitive dissonance, advocacy and reputational stakes rather than testing it rigorously.

The claims · ranked49 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.86

Observational comparisons (e.g., Japanese vs Americans, Korean vs American soldiers' autopsies) can only generate hypotheses, not establish causation, because you don't know what variables you're not looking at — sugar consumption tracks just as well as fat, but is ignored because it isn't the hypothesis.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Gary Taubes

“the problem with those observational studies is you know or those comparisons you don't know what you're not looking at so you focus on fat because that's what your hypothesis about this is a endemic problem in public health you just don't pay attention to anything else so for instance sugar consumption is very low in Japan”

0.81

Humans are wired to reject evidence against beliefs once those beliefs become part of identity (the people you hang out with, the uniform you wear, your self-perception), making it extraordinarily costly and painful to change them — so debates framed as scientific are often really debates about dogma, ideology or philosophy masked in the language of data.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Russ Roberts

“it becomes part of the people you hang out with the uniform you wear out in the world the club you're in your self-identity your self perception and it's extraordinarily costly to change those things”

0.80

It is psychologically easier to believe an experiment was done wrong than to accept that one has been giving wrong advice for decades — a form of cognitive dissonance that protects established recommendations against contradicting data.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Gary Taubes

“it's always easier to believe with this kind of cognitive dissidence that you did the study wrong than you've just been giving the wrong advice”

0.79

The largest dietary study ever done, in Minnesota, found that cholesterol-lowering diets increased mortality (more deaths in the intervention group), but the investigators withheld publication for roughly 16 years because they did not like how the results turned out.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 4/4durability 3/4· Gary Taubes

“the biggest study ever done which was in Minnesota actually suggested that if you put people on cholesterol-lowering diets you increase mortality they had more deaths in the intervention group and the control arm and in that case it just didn't publish the study”

0.79

The first U.S. government document recommending a low-fat diet (the 1977 Dietary Goals from McGovern's subcommittee) was written by a former labor reporter with no expertise in nutrition or health, after a single day of hearings.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 4/4durability 3/4· Gary Taubes

“they assign a formal labor reporter from the Providence Rhode Island Journal to write the first dietary goals for the United States it's the first document ever from a government body of any kind suggest that we said that a low-fat diet to healthy diet”

0.79

In the Harvard Nurses' Health Study, every time a hypothesis of causation was generated from its data and then tested in a clinical trial, the trial without exception failed to confirm the hypothesis and often found the opposite.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 4/4durability 3/4· Gary Taubes

“every single time they've had a hypothesis of causation from their data that was tested in a clinical trial without exception the trial failed to confirm the hypothesis doesn't mean the hypothesis wasn't true but the trial found the opposite”

0.79

Insulin, secreted primarily in response to dietary carbohydrate (especially refined carbs and sugar), regulates fat accumulation; this hypothesis fits the historical observation by Cleave and others that isolated populations developed obesity, then diabetes, heart disease and cancer in sequence only after adopting sugar and white flour ('the saccharine disease' / diseases of civilization).

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 4/4durability 3/4· Gary Taubes

“insulin is secreted primarily in response to the carbohydrate content to the diet so the more carbs and more refined carbs and sugars in particular seem to cause this thing called insulin resistance so you've actually got a hypothesis that really nicely fits with what Cleve documented”

0.78

The 'best we can do' / precautionary-principle argument used to justify dietary advice without definitive data is self-defeating from a scientific standpoint, because not having time to get definitive data means you don't have time to know whether you are right.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Gary Taubes

“not having time to get definitive scientific data means you don't have time to know if you're right or not yeah it's that simple”

0.78

Using the word 'yet' (as in 'we don't have the data yet') is a marker of bias that destroys good science, because it presumes the conclusion is true and merely awaits confirmation; in fields like nutrition you may never have the data and should never use the word.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Gary Taubes

“the word yet shows up all the time in these studies... one of the things I'm always arguing to people in these fields is you may never have the data never use the word yet... as soon as you start thinking in terms of yet... you become biased and you're not going to be able to do good science”

0.78

Bias enters research at the funding stage: because Keys was the leading proponent, he was the one given money to test his own hypothesis, rather than having an unbiased researcher design and run the test — once you bet your reputation on a hypothesis you cease to test it and become an advocate looking for confirming data.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Gary Taubes

“because he's the leading proponent he's the one you give money to to test the study and this is how bias can interject itself into research from the very GetGo”

0.78

The modern incentive structure rewards being loud, certain and dismissive of ideological enemies (in economics and science alike); scientists like Carlo Rubbia advanced to the top of their fields by making declarative pronouncements on preliminary data and moving on, while no one builds a career by carefully checking whether others' work was right.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Gary Taubes

“by making declarative pronouncements based on preliminary data and standing and then you know fighting viciously to get people to believe it you can do very well for yourself in these careers nobody moves forward by spending their career checking other people's work to see if it was right or not”

0.78

The body, like the economy, is a complex system in which cause and effect are hard to assess, and epidemiology resembles macroeconomics in having abundant data and statistical techniques attempting to isolate the impact of one variable on another.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Russ Roberts

“the body like the economy is a complex system where it's hard to assess and measure cause and effect and second because epidemiology the study of what causes various disease... is very much like macroeconomics there's a lot of data a lot of statistical techniques trying to isolate the impact of one variable on another”

0.77

The hypothesis that dietary fat raises cholesterol which causes heart disease originated from one zealous University of Minnesota nutritionist, Ancel Keys, in the 1950s, and at the time there was no experimental data to support it.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Gary Taubes

“this is a hypothesis that grew out of the observations of one very zealous University of Minnesota nutritionist in the in the 1950s fellow named Ancel Keys who came up with this idea that dietary fat raised cholesterol and it was raised cholesterol that caused heart disease and at the time there was effectively no meaningful experimental data to support”

0.77

If obesity and diabetes are caused by carbohydrates rather than overeating and inactivity, then making obese/diabetic children eat less and exercise more is torture that doesn't reverse the problem, just as you wouldn't make bedridden cancer patients run to treat their cancer; correct diagnosis of the cause must precede treatment.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Gary Taubes

“starving them and getting those kids to run around the track you know an hour a day is just torturing the kids and it's not actually reversing the problem... imagine you could find cancer patients who are bedridden and don't exercise at all you're not going to run them around the track because you think sedentary behavior must be the cause of their cancer”

0.75

In any growing biological system, growth is the cause and positive energy balance (taking in more energy than expended) is the effect — a child grows because of growth hormone driving it, not because it eats more; likewise fat accumulation is driven by insulin, so eating more is a compensation for fat storage rather than its cause.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 4/4durability 3/4· Gary Taubes

“in any growing system in nature in effect growth is the cause and... taking in more energy than you expend is the effect... she's growing because she's secreting growth hormone... the sort of woods called positive energy balance is the effect not the cause”

0.75

An individual can run an experiment of one on weight (try cutting carbs and observe weight loss), and even a placebo effect makes belief in the diet potentially beneficial; but a single observation cannot tell you about long-run effects such as whether you are harming your arteries, which only clinical trials can address.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Gary Taubes

“everyone can do an atom one experiment here when it's coming to wait... you don't know if you're gonna kill yourself right you don't know what the longer-run... that's where you need the clinical trial”

0.73

Trial after trial failed to prove the diet-heart hypothesis true, yet the more it was studied the more people believed it must be true, while supporting observations were compiled by ignoring contradictory evidence ('Bing Crosby epidemiology' — accentuate the positive, eliminate the negative).

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Gary Taubes

“trial after trial was sort of unable to prove the hypothesis true but the more we studied it the more people simply believed that must be true”

0.73

Treating high cholesterol as a disease/symptom to be treated with statins assumes a causal role for cholesterol that has never been established, so doctors think they are treating symptoms when they have no idea whether they are preventing death or real disease.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Gary Taubes

“what we've done is create a whole you know world of doctors now who think high cholesterol to disease... and then they could treat it with statins and they think they're treating symptoms when they have no idea whether they're actually preventing death or did you know real disease and hard endpoints”

0.73

Industry influence is far less important in distorting nutrition science than ego, funding, fame, and career-building incentives.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Gary Taubes

“I've argued actually I think industry influence is far less of a factor in determining how these sciences play themselves out and the kind of issues you just talked about the ego funding fame building a career”

0.73

Once the American Heart Association endorsed the low-fat hypothesis in 1961 without experimental data, it acquired a presumption of truth, leading researchers, journalists and politicians to treat it as probably correct and merely awaiting confirmation rather than something to be falsified.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Gary Taubes

“once the American Heart Association got behind it it got a kind of believability that the attitude was it's probably right and all we have to do is test it or we're going to believe it's true but we don't have the data yet because we haven't done the test yet”

0.73

The Women's Health Initiative diet trial, costing half a billion to a billion dollars and randomizing ~49,000 women, found no effect of a low-fat diet on heart disease, diabetes, or breast cancer; yet NIH, WHO and CDC issued press releases saying the trial should not change dietary recommendations, assuming the trial rather than the advice was wrong.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Gary Taubes

“forty nine thousand women are randomized into two groups and twenty thousand are put on a low-fat cholesterol-lowering diet... and despite that you see no effect from this study there's no effect on heart diseases no effect on diabetes no effect on breast cancer”

0.73

Keys's Seven Countries Study selected nations in advance where he already knew the heart disease rates and diets, omitting countries like France and Switzerland that had high saturated-fat diets but low heart disease, thereby stacking the deck to confirm the fat-cholesterol-heart-disease hypothesis.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Gary Taubes

“he picks countries where he knows in advance you know kind of what the answer is and then he gets the answer he expects for the most part so saturated fat tracks with heart disease ergo”

0.73

Despite worsening evidence against the hypothesis that salt/sodium restriction reduces blood pressure and heart attacks, the institutional effort to restrict salt grows more vigorous each year — the establishment responds to each non-confirming paper by pushing harder to translate the hypothesis into action.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Gary Taubes

“there's precious little evidence to support the idea that that sodium restriction will reduce blood pressure... and yet with each year that goes by the effort to restrict salt in the diet gets greater and greater... the data just get worse like the evidence gets worse but the efforts to do something about what did the perceived problem gets gets more vigorous”

0.73

In nature a unified theory is a virtue (physicists seek one), but in medicine the desire for a unified theory of disease is treated as quackery; nonetheless Occam's razor should apply and the hormonal/enzymatic regulation of fat tissue (i.e., carbohydrates) should be the null hypothesis that must be refuted.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Gary Taubes

“physicists love unified theories... in medicine it's quackery okay we don't want a unified theory of disease... if I argue that you should begin with Occam's razor... they'll argue that then no no no no we were far beyond that”

0.73

Rigorous metabolic-ward style controlled feeding trials with humans — feeding subjects specific foods in an enclosed environment over long periods to detect changes in well-established disease risk factors — are feasible and necessary to settle nutrition questions, but are not part of the field's culture and would require dedicated (e.g., nonprofit) funding.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Gary Taubes

“you can do if you think about it far enough and you're willing to spend the money pretty rigorous control trials with humans... you can treat humans like laboratory rats it's not easy it's expensive but you could do them where you would affect feed them specific foods make them eat it”

0.73

Economists explain rising lifespan partly by dramatically improved nutrition in raw caloric terms and cheap food, but the puzzle remains that poor people are fatter than rich people and that unimaginably poor populations have had obesity rates equal to today's U.S. — undercutting the simple 'food is cheap so we're fat' explanation.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Gary Taubes

“yeah food's cheap but why is it that poor people are fatter than rich people and why is it that you could find populations that at levels of obesity equal that we have in the u.s. today that were unimaginably poor”

0.73

The historical maternal-mortality debate (childbed fever blamed on bad air versus doctors failing to wash hands after the morgue) shows that conceding you had been killing patients for decades is so unbearable that practitioners resist contrary statistical evidence — yet science did eventually advance and resolve it.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Russ Roberts

“maternal mortality before we understood hygiene... one group that said it was something in the air... and there was another group that said no actually doctors should wash their hands... the idea that you had been in killing women for decades is unbearable so you're going to have a very hard time conceding the statistical evidence”

0.73

Epidemiologic studies can tell you that something like high blood pressure is associated with increased heart disease risk, but they cannot tell you what dietary or lifestyle factors cause high blood pressure; only experimental trials can establish those causal links.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Gary Taubes

“you can learn from these epidemiologic studies your high blood pressure is associated an increased risk of heart disease but you can't learn from an observational study what causes high blood pressure”

0.73

We rarely if ever get definitive proof in science; results either support, contradict, or raise questions, and eventually you lose the ability to generate alternative hypotheses that explain the data — so demanding 'definitive' data is the wrong standard, though hard sciences with reproducible experiments allow far more confidence than soft fields.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Russ Roberts

“we rarely if ever get definitive proof so in science by almost by definition it's not definitive it either supports or contradicts or raises questions of eventually you lose the ability to come up with hypotheses that can explain the data other than the one you've got”

0.70

Obesity, type 2 diabetes, heart disease, hypertension and gout cluster together in patients and populations and are connected by metabolic syndrome, which is driven by insulin resistance and chronically elevated insulin levels — suggesting one underlying cause rather than separate causes for each.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Gary Taubes

“metabolic syndrome is a disorder of various metabolic abnormalities that are all in effect caused by this condition or associated with this condition called insulin resistance... you could make the argument that whatever it is that causes insulin resistance causes all these diseases”

0.70

By 1984 the NIH held a consensus conference declaring consensus on low-fat diets despite having no single meaningful experiment showing such diets reduce heart disease risk or extend life; some studies even suggested reduced heart disease came at the cost of increased cancer.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Gary Taubes

“by 1984 the NIH holds a consensus conference claiming that they have a consensus of opinion that we should always low fat diets when they still don't have a single meaningful experiment showing that a low-fat diet or cholesterol-lowering diet will reduce the risk of heart disease”

0.70

Yalow and Berson's radioimmunoassay measurements found that type 2 diabetics and obese subjects have high insulin levels (not low as in type 1 diabetes), yielding the hypothesis that elevated insulin drives calorie storage in fat tissue independent of how much one eats or exercises.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Gary Taubes

“one of the first measurements at yellow inversion did was insulin levels in type 2 diabetics and obese subjects and they realize that lo and behold they both had high levels of insulin... now you've got this hypothesis that all you have to do is increase insulin levels and you store calories in your fat tissue”

0.66

A heart attack is more likely caused by metabolic abnormalities (metabolic syndrome) tied to insulin resistance and high insulin than by high LDL cholesterol as the conventional wisdom holds.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Gary Taubes

“if you have a heart attack almost assuredly it's not going to be because you have high LDL cholesterol to the conventional wisdom but because you have these metabolic abnormalities called metabolic syndrome and they're all tied together by insulin resistance”

0.66

Sugar consumption tracks heart disease as well as saturated fat does, since affluent nations eat a lot of both; Keys dismissed sugar (championed by British nutritionist John Yudkin) by rationalizing it away as a marker of smokers who put sugar in their coffee.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Gary Taubes

“sugar actually tracks just as well with saturated fat basically affluent nations eat a lot of saturated fat and a lot of sugar and Kees is a believer of the fat hypothesis not the sugar hypothesis that was a British nutritionist named John Yadkin”

0.66

In five (later dozens of) clinical trials comparing an ad libitum low-carb/high-fat (Atkins) diet against a calorie-restricted low-fat AHA diet, the low-carb group lost more weight despite eating as much as they wanted AND their heart-disease risk factors improved — contradicting both the 'eat less to lose weight' and 'fat causes heart disease' hypotheses.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Gary Taubes

“in every one of these five studies not only did the Atkins diet group lose more weight remember they're allowed to eat as much as they want but they lost more weight than people who were calorie restricted... their heart disease risk factors improved as well”

0.66

The Finland study showing heart disease declined in one region after a low-fat intervention was undermined when later research found the same decline occurred all over Finland in regions without the intervention, showing the apparent intervention effect was illusory.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Gary Taubes

“a famous study in in Finland where Finland change their diet and heart disease rates came down in this one part of Finland... but they also were quitting smoking... and then other research came along... you've got the same decreases in heart disease rates all over Finland in places where you didn't do the intervention”

0.66

Body type and obesity are largely genetically determined through how well one tolerates dietary carbohydrates: a lean person can tolerate a carb-rich diet and retains energy to exercise, while a fat person cannot tolerate carbs, stores too much fat, and lacks energy to exercise because energy is sequestered in fat tissue — so it is essentially never true that lean people are lean simply because they eat in moderation and exercise.

causalhigh valuefringenovelty 4/4durability 2/4· Gary Taubes

“a lean person is a person who can tolerate a carb rich diet and has the energy to exercise and a fat person is a person who can't and who because of the insulin signaling they end up with too much fat in their fat tissue and now they don't have the energy to exercise because all that energy is being sucked up by their fat tissue”

0.65

The argument that 'low-carb diets are hard to sustain, therefore carbohydrates don't make you fat' is a logical fallacy equivalent to saying 'cigarettes are hard to quit, therefore cigarettes don't cause lung cancer' — difficulty of adherence does not bear on the causal claim.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Gary Taubes

“a common argument you hear is it's hard to stay on the diet therefore carbohydrates don't make you fat and that's like saying it's hard to quit cigarettes therefore cigarettes don't cause lung cancer”

0.63

No Keynesian abandoned their belief that government spending creates prosperity even after the 2009 stimulus failed to keep unemployment below the predicted 8% (it reached 10%); they instead argued it was worse than thought or not large enough — demonstrating that beliefs in economics resist disconfirming evidence just like in nutrition.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Russ Roberts

“predicting 8% unemployment after a stimulus package has passed and getting 10 is not going to dissuade anybody No Keynesian in the face of the alleged or apparent... failure of the 2009 stimulus package nobody changed their mind they just said well it was worse than we thought or we didn't spend enough”

0.63

The popular view that refined carbs and sugar are bad has already been widely accepted; the remaining battle is getting acceptance that fats — including saturated fats — are not merely harmless but may be necessities, which will take longer.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Gary Taubes

“this idea that refined carbs and sugars are bad has actually already been accepted sort of popularly... the battle is getting it accepted that that fats are not only good including saturated fats but they might be necessities... and that's going to take more time”

0.63

Diabetes diagnoses have tripled since 1980, and regardless of how much is attributable to changing diagnostic criteria, something real has changed during the same decades the establishment insisted it knew the cause of obesity and diabetes — which should prompt reconsideration of whether the advice was wrong.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Gary Taubes

“diabetes rates the diagnoses have tripled since 1980 in 30 years I mean that's an enormous increase and no matter how much is a diagnostic effect or changing diagnostic criteria something has changed and it's changed during this period that you've insisted you know what causes obesity”

0.62

Same-researcher, same-criteria diagnostic studies found significantly higher Alzheimer's rates among African-Americans in the U.S. Midwest than among a genetically similar population in Nigeria, suggesting a lifestyle/dietary factor in Alzheimer's.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Gary Taubes

“the same researchers diagnosed Alzheimer in in african-americans in Cincinnati... and then they went to Nigeria and did it there... you got significantly higher rates of Alzheimer's here than you got in a similar... African population in Nigeria”

0.61

Nutrition has been a pseudoscience since World War II because the rigorous, skeptical scientific culture imported into physics via European émigrés (built for atom bombs and the Cold War) never took hold in medicine, public health, or economics, allowing assumptions to masquerade as facts.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 4/4durability 3/4· Gary Taubes

“one of the reasons we got into the situation in nutrition is because it's been a pseudoscience since second world war... we embraced all these European physicists who got chased out of Europe... but in other fields particularly medicine in public health and probably economics as well we didn't want anything to do with these people so the ideas of rigorously testing hypotheses have not... taken hold”

0.59

Over nine years Taubes estimates support for his low-carb hypothesis among the medical research community rose from about a thousandth of a percent to roughly 1-2%, with the remaining ~98% largely refusing to engage his evidence ('it's crap, I haven't read it').

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 1/4· Gary Taubes

“nine years ago I probably had a thousandth of a percent of the medical research community on my side and now I might be up to 1% or 2%”

0.57

Whenever anyone invokes Galileo as a personal role model, they are probably a quack — because the rhetorical move (claiming the establishment paradigm is wrong like geocentrism) is the same one cranks use.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Gary Taubes

“one of my rules of science writing now is that whenever somebody evokes Galileo as a personal role model he's a quack”

0.49

Sugar and white flour spread globally because, being essentially nutrient-free, they could be shipped worldwide without spoiling and without attracting rats, so they were the first Western foods adopted by populations transitioning from traditional diets.

factualestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Gary Taubes

“you could ship sugar and white flour all around the world without it being spoiled because effectively there's no nutrients and... the rats aren't interested in it”

0.44

Einstein, when asked what he would have done if the 1919 eclipse experiment had failed to confirm his prediction that the Sun's gravity bends starlight, replied he would not have believed the results because he knew he was right.

factualcontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Russ Roberts

“Einstein after the famous study... somebody asked Einstein afterwards what would you have done if the theory if the results hadn't confirmed your experiment he said well I wouldn't have believed them because I know I'm right”

0.25

The latest Dietary Guidelines still try to get people to limit fat and saturated fat intake, so the low-fat hypothesis remains commonly believed by most people.

factualestablishednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Gary Taubes

“I think it's still commonly believed by most people on the latest Dietary Guidelines once again are trying to get us to limit our fat intake and limit our saturated fat intake”

0.17

Roberts personally cut back dramatically on sugar and refined carbs for ten weeks and lost a lot of weight, which he acknowledges is a small, single-observation data set that nonetheless inclines him to want to believe the hypothesis.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 0/4· Russ Roberts

“for the last ten weeks I personally have started cutting back dramatically on sugar... and I have lost a lot of weight by the way... this small data set one didn't want observation”