What this covers

Sam Harris talks with the humanistic psychologist Scott Barry Kaufman, whose book Transcend reworks Abraham Maslow's ideas. Kaufman begins with a correction: Maslow never drew a pyramid. He described a Hierarchy of Prepotency, in which some needs demand more attention when they go unmet, and growth is a "two steps forward, one step back" choice made while fear stays dominant. Kaufman offers The Sailboat Model in its place: a secure boat, then an open sail toward the unknown. He also sketches the history of the field, from its 1950s–60s popularity to its decline and Martin Seligman's revival of it as positive psychology around 1998.

The middle of the conversation turns to Maslow's late distinction between self-actualizers and transcenders, who are driven by higher values and by peak experiences. Kaufman argues that purpose alone is not enough, and he uses Adolf Hitler as an example of purpose without integration or connection to others. He defines wisdom as holding dialectical opposites in mind at once. Harris pushes on the link between spiritual insight and ethics, noting that meditation teachers with real insight have still harmed their students. He also questions how much any peak state can show, since it comes and goes.

The range is wide. Harris describes non-duality as consciousness representing the world without a subject at its center, and he says that if this is the point, bliss has no ultimate significance. That position is contested, and the two men approach it from different directions. They discuss Maslow's wariness of psychedelics and his joke to Timothy Leary about taking an elevator up Everest. They also cover research on combining psychedelics with meditation or prayer, the risks for people prone to schizophrenia, and Kaufman's own hypomanic tendencies and his work on schizotypy and creativity. Other threads include practices meant to loosen self-esteem, the gap between what we expect to satisfy us and what does, and meaning in work.

Sharpest takeaway

Self-actualization and transcendence require integration of basic human needs with higher values and peak experiences, not escape from foundational needs; healthy transcendence is defined by harmonious integration of the whole self in service of a good society, not by ephemeral peak experiences or pseudo-spiritual bypassing.

  • Maslow's original hierarchy was about prepotency, not a linear progression—people must consciously choose growth while fear remains prepotent, requiring ongoing integration rather than reaching a level and moving past it
  • Pseudo-transcendence results from unresolved deficiency needs (safety, belonging, esteem) dressed in spiritual language, explaining why many meditation teachers and gurus with genuine insights still cause harm
  • Wisdom is the ability to hold dialectical opposites in consciousness—transcenders are motivated by being-values and peak experiences, but only those who integrate these with ethical grounding and connection to others achieve healthy transcendence

The claims · ranked46 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

Maslow never drew a pyramid in his own writings; the pyramid metaphor was added later by popularizers. Maslow was actually discussing a 'hierarchy of prepotency'—the idea that some needs are more potent or demanding than others when deprived, and they take up more attention and energy.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Scott Barry Kaufman

“a lot of people may have seen the pyramid may not even heard the name Abraham Maslow but certainly they've seen it on the internet maybe diagrammed as a pyramid with like now you see tolet paper at the bottom of the pyramid or in the age of kovat or or Wi-Fi battery was popular before that it's a meme and suggesting there's different levels of needs some are more foundational than others and Maslow's original theory he never drew a pyramid or in his writings I mean I was looking through the writings I was like where's the pyramid what I didn't I couldn't find a pyramid and he was talking about a hierarchy of pre potency do we have some needs that are more potent or over others that when they're deprived they take up more of our attention and we really focus all of our energy and resources to to satisfying that”

0.78

Non-duality or recognizing the emptiness of the self involves recognizing that consciousness can represent the world without representing a subject—that the sense of being the center of consciousness is a construction that can be taken offline, and this is compatible with ordinary functioning like driving a car.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Sam Harris

“it's the loss of this sense of subject object perception it's the-- and this is a completely coincident with ordinary perception you can drive a car in this state of consciousness this is a perfectly functional state because it's not actually a state I mean this is the way consciousness is when you're no longer constructing this sense of being the center of consciousness to speak of in representational terms it's like you can represent the world without representing a subject in your head in your body in the world most people have this additional sense that there's a homunculus in the head that's doing the thinking and the feeling and the reacting and that can be taken offline”

0.78

Breaking identification with thought through meditation—recognizing thought as an appearance in consciousness rather than being identified with it—is one of the subtlest aspects of meditation and is distinct from merely experiencing altered states or special experiences.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Sam Harris

“meditation can break that spell and breaking that identification leaves everything else untouched now it is in fact true that the more you do that and the longer those moments of true non duality or perception of emptiness last then that does begin to change the character of the contents of consciousness as well right so that can begin to you know seem more rarefied and more psychedelic and more dreamlike”

0.78

If being is really the point—if you've recognized something about the nature of consciousness that cannot be improved and is compatible with any contents of consciousness—then joy, bliss, and other positive experiences are not signs that meditation is working but merely appearances in a dream that is meaningless; positive feelings and experiences have no ultimate meaning.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Sam Harris

“the feeling of you know joy or the feeling of bliss I mean anything that becomes for most people certainly in the beginning of meditation a sign that meditation is actually working all of that gets disavowed as an appearance in a dream that is meaningless it has no meaning at that point the fact that you suddenly feel good that's not the point of meditation”

0.75

Contemplative traditions include practices that deliberately target the transcendence of self-esteem concerns by having meditators do something that would normally be mortifying—embarrassing themselves or engaging in status-reducing activities—to see how they can inhabit that channel of human experience and to demonstrate how vulnerable humans normally are to changes in social status.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sam Harris

“there are many practices in the contemplative tradition that explicitly target these opposites for this purpose right like if you're a great meditator who thinks he's transcended his concerns about self esteem well then your teacher may recommend that you do something that you would normally find just absolutely mortifying just to see how you can inhabit that channel of human experience right so you deliberately embarrass yourself or engage some way of life that reduces your status so the people begin treating you differently and you begin to feel what that's like and play with that mode of human experience”

0.75

Maslow emphasized that life is a 'two steps forward, one step back' dynamic where people are always choosing growth but fear is always prepotent, requiring conscious, ongoing choice of the growth option rather than a linear progression through need levels.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Scott Barry Kaufman

“he made it very clear that life is a always a two step forward one step back dynamic where we're always choosing growth we're always trying to choose growth but but the fear response is always prepotent you know fear is always gonna move over us in an uncertain sea but we have to consciously keep choosing the growth option he made that very clear”

0.74

Our implicit assumptions about what will ultimately be satisfying—embedded in how we spend our time and attention and whether we're trying to win skirmishes on Twitter or publish more papers—can be wrong; many people arrive at the fulfillment of these goals (more money, more status, more publications) and find that they don't actually satisfy.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Sam Harris

“embedded in that use of energy and attention are certain assumptions about what will be ultimately satisfying and you know this is a very common experience to arrive at the fulfillment of all of that you know you make a little more money you publish a little more your start plans”

0.71

Maslow viewed self-actualization as a commitment to a calling or something deep within oneself that brings out the best in you and that you work toward daily, similar to Viktor Frankl's approach to meaning.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Scott Barry Kaufman

“Maslow really was trying to hold off on that because he really reeled against these easy answers to so that he really viewed cell factorization is being committed to a calling or something deep within yourself that that you love that brings out the best in you and that you are committed to working towards day in and day out very much was in that sort of meaning mode similar to Viktor Frankl”

0.70

Recent large-scale studies show that the combination of psychedelics with spiritual practices like meditation and prayer is more effective than either alone for producing therapeutic effects.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Scott Barry Kaufman

“I'm really impressed with the scientific research that's coming out on showing that psychedelics in combination with spiritual practices show the crazy effects like meditation but also prayer there's some new studies large-scale studies that show that the combination is better than either alone and so the more you can integrate those psychedelic experiences into the rest of your life the more productive it'll be”

0.69

Those with potential vulnerability to schizophrenia should be cautious about taking classic psychedelics (LSD, psilocybin, mescaline, DMT) even if interested in the experience.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sam Harris

“for instance someone who has a greater than normal reason to worry that they might be prone to schizophrenia that's a real I say this without any clinical experience but just from what I of the literature that that seems like a contraindication for certainly psychedelic your real psychedelic so you know I would leave MDMA aside but LSD psilocybin mescaline you know DMT I think you would be wise to the very least be cautious”

0.69

Humanistic psychology was popular during the 1950s-1960s with the cultural spirit of that time (hippies, LSD, beat writers, creativity and spirituality), but declined afterward from the 1970s until Martin Seligman brought positive psychology back on a scientific foundation around 1998.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Scott Barry Kaufman

“humanistic psychology was quite popular in a 10 to 20 year period in 50s 60s it called the time of hippies sort of spirit of the 60s and you know LSD and the beat writers all this sort of idea of creativity and spirituality it was it was part of the the culture and you know III am trying to I try to think why it died out and because I did die out from like the 70s til Martin Seligman really brought brought it back in in a big way by putting positive psychology on a scientific foundation in nineteen ninety eight or so”

0.69

Scott Barry Kaufman is personally prone to hypomania (not the same as manic in bipolar disorder) which is a personality trait correlated with schizotypy, and he has conducted research on schizotypy and its relationship to creativity and the paradox of when it tips over into creative thinking versus when it tips into schizophrenia.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Scott Barry Kaufman

“I personally and have always been prone biologically just positionally to to hypomania which is not the same as manic you know an insert of bipolar there's actually hypomania is a personality trait that we all vary on it's correlated with schizotypy and and and this is actually what led into a whole rabbit hole of research i've been conducting on schizotypy in its relationship to creativity and how in some sense it can be related to schizophrenia but i've been really interesting that paradox of when does it tip over to schizophrenia versus when does it tip over into creative thinking”

0.69

Maslow was very wary of psychedelics despite being surrounded by major researchers and proponents of them; he used to tease Timothy Leary, saying that LSD was a shortcut like taking an elevator to the top of Mount Everest rather than climbing it, and Maslow really viewed self-actualization as requiring committed work toward a deep calling.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Scott Barry Kaufman

“there's a famous story of them walking together Harvard Square and nozzles saying that's they like you know would you want to take an elevator to the top of Mount Everest you know and you know so he was like teasing him about LSD is being a shortcut and Mosel very much viewed it as a shortcut and i read all these letters that that he had wrote and personal correspondence to various people about his thoughts on LSD”

0.68

At the extreme end of transcendence, it is possible to transcend basic needs (safety, connection, self-esteem) in some basic sense—for instance, achieving a mind that sees fame and shame as equally empty—which resolves some of the paradoxes of dialectical thinking, though this is not a norm one can recommend to other people.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sam Harris

“I mean I can see it break down at one point at the extreme end of of transcendence really where where the things that seem to be needs for most of us certainly most of the time and which was you know things that are part of the hull you know the deficiency needs the safety the connection the self esteem it really is possible or certainly seems to be possible to transcend those in some basic sense now that's that's not really a norm you can recommend to other people but it does seem like a way of resolving some of the paradoxes you you mentioned”

0.68

Peak experiences are moments of special insight or transcendence in life, and transcenders live for these kinds of experiences and the realization of being-values; however, the peak experience itself is not the ultimate insight into consciousness that will transform you because by definition it comes and goes.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Scott Barry Kaufman / Sam Harris

“you're motivated by these values but also you're motivated by peak experiences in life so these sort of spiritual I guess come transcendent experiences in your life and these transcenders this is what they they lived for is these kinds of experiences”

0.63

The default mode network in the brain is probably at least partly responsible for producing mind-wandering, daydreaming, and self-referential thinking, and there may be a specific strain of thinking that is explicitly self-referential that differs from just thinking without knowing you're thinking (being identified with thought).

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Sam Harris

“based on the current literature it seems like it's probably at least part of what the default mode Network is doing in addition to just producing mind wandering or daydreaming or just random thinking there's a strain of thinking that is explicitly self referential and and again I don't know if this has actually been studied but more than just self referential thought there's the the difference between noticing thought as an appearance in consciousness among all the other appearances and being identified with thought which is to say thinking without knowing that you're thinking”

0.63

More is needed for becoming a better person than peak experiences alone; there is a need for actual conscious integration with ethics and this requires culture and the relationship between the individual and society.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Sam Harris

“I've come away from my my collisions with this literature and to some degree these people feeling that there's more needed in the toolkit for you know living a truly examined life and becoming a better person than just having certain self-transcending experiences...there is an actual conscious integration with ethics that make sense and this is where culture comes in and just the relationship between the individual and society”

0.61

The 'bad is stronger than the good' principle suggests that humans are more focused on deprivation states and pressing concerns (depression, anxiety) than on further increasing satisfaction when already satisfied, which explains why therapeutic psychology has focused on reducing pathology rather than increasing flourishing.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Scott Barry Kaufman

“one way is recognizing that the bad is stronger than the good we are more focused on when we have deprivation zand and there's certainly no shortage of deprivation z' among humans to to work on depression anxieties things become more pressing concerns for us when we're in that deprived state if we're feeling satisfied we don't seek a therapist so that we are you know even more satisfied I mean if you go to a therapist and you say doc I only feel average life satisfaction but I want to be like these pop psychology want to be you you find something else you find a coach maybe or you find a you don't go to a therapist for that”

0.61

The connection between self-transcending experiences (peak experiences, meditative states) and ethics or pro-social behavior is not as direct or reliable as Eastern traditions and Buddhist teachings suggest; many meditation teachers and gurus from Eastern countries who came to the West to teach have produced significant suffering among their students despite having genuine spiritual insights.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sam Harris

“the connection to ethics and you know commitment to an intelligent commitment to helping other people same the kind of normative pro-social emotions in action that is I think it's there it certainly advertised to be there and in in Eastern context especially and in Buddhist one especially but it's not as direct or as reliable as I think we would hope and and you know to testify to that fact all you need to do is look at the careers of great meditators and you know teachers of meditation who have gathered students many of them have come from Eastern countries and come to the West to teach and this was obviously happening in in Maslow's time and so many of them have produced incredible suffering among their students”

0.60

Maslow discovered in his final years that there are different types of self-actualizing people: some who focus entirely on realizing their own potential without concern for maximizing the potential of society or others (whom he distinguished from 'transcenders'), and transcenders who are consistently motivated by higher values and peak experiences.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Scott Barry Kaufman

“and then it's germane to this idea that we're both interested in what transcendence he argued that the last couple years his life that self-actualization wasn't the highest motivation in his hierarchy of needs that there was a higher motivation in fact he realized that there were different types of self actualizing people this is an insight he wrote in a journal personal journal entry of his that I found he is like big insight today I realized that there are actually different types of self actualizing people there are self actualize errs who are perfectly perfectly content going their entire lives realizing their own potential and you know maybe they read all the books how to realize your full potential they're obsessed with realizing their potential and maximizing their potential but they really don't care much about maximizing a potential of society or maximizing the potential of others there's not a great connection between self and others they may dazzle with their talents and or at work they may be doing good good work and they feel self actualized but they're not what Maslow called the trend centers he argued the transcenders were a different kind of self actualize errs who were consistently motivated by higher values he called them the beef I use the values of being itself things where there's no means to an end there ends in themselves”

0.57

The sailboat model better represents healthy development than Maslow's pyramid: you need a safe and secure boat (basic needs met—safety, connection, self-esteem with no severe deprivation), and then you can open the sail to face the vulnerability and unknown of the sea, moving with purpose and direction, moving with integration of exploration and B-love rather than fear.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Scott Barry Kaufman

“I actually have a new metaphor a sailboat and in a sailboat model no reason why I think it works and I'd love to get your thoughts on that is that it it clearly shows that you need to have a safe and secure boat your basic needs need to be met there's no holes in the boat and they're severely deprived aspects of your needs or else you won't go anywhere you can't move in your desired direction when all you're focused on is securing the boat and for the boat I talked about the needs for for safety the needs for connection and the need for self esteem but once our boat is secured we can open the sail and we open the sail and and face the vulnerability and and the unknown of the sea we move with purpose and direction with that sale but we move with integration of the spirit of exploration not fear and love Universal over what Maslow called be love love for the being of others”

0.57

Yet if you've never experienced what radically different consciousness is like—the feeling of unconditional love, the sense of being inseparable from the world's energy, colors and beauty beyond imagination—your lack of imagination about what's possible in consciousness can be a reason why you are satisfied with Netflix and not hating your life, because you don't know what you're missing.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Sam Harris

“none of that can be the point and yet it again it's the thing that if you've never experienced it you know you're someone who just can't imagine how different a human experience can be and that lack of imagination becomes the reason why you are satisfied with Netflix and not hating your life you get up each day and merely repeat that project”

0.56

Wisdom involves the ability to hold seemingly incompatible or dialectical opposites in consciousness simultaneously—recognizing that at the highest state of consciousness, false dichotomies like selfishness versus altruism or evil versus good can be transcended as part of an integrated whole.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Scott Barry Kaufman

“at the highest state of consciousness lots of the academies that everyone else in our society is really interested and obsessed with and these false dichotomies we able to transcend them in some way and we're able to see how everything is just part of a larger whole this might even have to be a to make a concrete it could be like the distinction between selfishness and and altruism you know at the highest level of consciousness if you're and being the high soul of motivation if you're selfish in the sense that you're getting really enjoyment out of what you're doing but you are also connected to the world and and your enjoyment brings enjoyment to others”

0.55

Adolf Hitler had a clear sense of purpose and could be argued to be self-actualized, but lacked the integration and connection to others' being that characterizes healthy transcendence, illustrating that purpose and self-actualization alone are insufficient without integration.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Scott Barry Kaufman

“I have a section in my book called the Hitler problem so when I get to the need for purpose I ask well was it were self actualized because he clearly had a sense of purpose he had a purpose I'm arguing purposes a higher level of need the point here is that life is not like a mountain or a pyramid”

0.55

Cultural conditioning shapes what states of consciousness people find desirable and what outcomes they pursue; transcendence requires recognizing how culture has unconsciously bounded the horizon of one's aspirations.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sam Harris

“we've all been conditioned by culture to think certain things are possible and to hope for certain outcomes in our lives and we're continually having various states of consciousness advertised to us as desirable...what a self-esteem mean now well it means something different than in you know the 1980s before anyone had even heard of social media”

0.52

Everything can be understood as having both a 'D-flavor' (deficiency-motivated) and a 'B-flavor' (being-motivated or growth-motivated); for instance, one can have D-belonging (desperate need to belong because of severe lack) versus B-belonging (seeing people for who they are), or D-love versus B-love (love for the being of others, not for what they can do to satisfy a hole in yourself).

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Scott Barry Kaufman

“everything so nothing in and of itself is good or bad everything has a D flavor to it and a B flavor to it so the D flavor is a deficiency motivated flavor to it so you do it because you're trying to satisfy some hole in yourself in some way and and anything can apply to that you can have D humor versus them is being or growth motivated humor love you can have or belonging you can have D belonging where you have a desperate need to belong with others because you severely lack belonging and you're trying to change and control the world in some way or be belonging where you see people for who they are or be love love for the being of others not what use they can they exist to satisfy some hole in yourself”

0.52

Mental training and meditation are analogous to physical training; just as physical training is an uncontroversial way to improve strength, flexibility, balance, and athletic ability, and people know this is possible by watching the Olympics, mental training should be recognized as capable of transforming consciousness and awareness in analogous ways.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sam Harris

“the analogy that works for me is to think of mental training and meditation as a species of that somewhat analogous to physical training and and you know physical training is obviously something we it's a thing we know it's uncontroversial that you can get stronger and more flexible and improve your balance and them you can become an Olympic gymnast right and so everyone who begins working out does it in a context that they know that while they may not become an Olympic gymnast they know just how far this can be taken you know when you're just struggling to touch your toes or do one pull-up or one because you've been sedentary for the last ten years you know that extraordinary transformations of the body are possible”

0.52

Creative people are rule-breakers, but this must be distinguished between intentional, purposeful rule-breaking done as a means to an end for greater meaning and creative realization versus compulsive rule-breaking for its own sake.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Scott Barry Kaufman

“one of the most obvious things they do differently is that they do things differently you know they creative people are rule breakers in the sense that maybe they're not necessarily provocateurs and that's a different kind of rule breaking and I and I I think it's actually important to distinguish between those who are intentional like I would say compulsive rule-breakers versus those who do it as a means to an end for greater meaning and and creative realization”

0.52

Transcenders are motivated by 'being values' (values of being itself)—things where there is no means to an end but the end is in themselves—such as the search for beauty, justice, meaningfulness, and goodness.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Scott Barry Kaufman

“the transcenders were a different kind of self actualize errs who were consistently motivated by higher values he called them the beef I use the values of being itself things where there's no means to an end there ends in themselves like the the search for beauty the search for for justice for meaningfulness in the world for goodness and and and you're motivated by these values but also you're motivated by peak experiences in life”

0.52

The vast majority of Western assumptions about the superficiality or limited scope of meditation practice can be proven false through direct experience; the assumptions that most people hold about how far meditation can actually go are limiting factors on how people think about transcendence and its prospects.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sam Harris

“in my experience the assumptions that most Westerners and most you know most people such as Westerners at this point about the the superficiality of the project of you know let's say learning to meditate you know those assumptions can be proven false in a variety of ways and it's just it's interesting that that's kind of a limiting factor on how people think about transcendence and its prospects”

0.52

The changes from meditation and contemplative practice are mostly invisible and hidden in the internal landscape, so people only have testimony from practitioners to know how far the landscape actually goes; this lack of visible proof makes it hard to believe meditation is a path worth taking, unlike physical training where Olympic performances prove what's possible.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sam Harris

“but the problem with with the contemplative life and meditation and other tools is that the changes are for the most part invisible it's not that they don't have emotional correlates and therefore behavioral ones and and that's why the rampages of various gurus seem to be disqualifying the whole project but for the most part this is in an inner landscape and therefore a hidden one and therefore all we have is the testimony of people to say how far this landscape actually goes and so you can't see the gold medal floor exercise at the Olympics to prove beyond any possibility of doubt that it is possible to take the project of becoming stronger and more flexible and getting greater balance”

0.52

Meditation can be practiced more effectively when undertaken in the context of knowing that higher states of consciousness are actual potentials of the human mind and brain, not false projects; this knowledge that such experiences are possible gives practitioners a reason to believe the path is not futile.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sam Harris

“then meditation if you take it up as a practice can be practiced in the context of knowing that this is not a false project right just knowing that it's when someone says they've had this kind of experience you know from within that this is an actual potential of the human mind you know and therefore the human brain and there's no reason why it couldn't be a potential of yours given the right changes so that's the virtue is in again it's not the only virtue but for me the primary virtue is is almost rhetorical it's the only thing that would have convinced a skeptic like me that there was a path to go anywhere really”

0.52

Academic psychology may have distanced itself from humanistic psychology partly to establish scientific credibility and avoid association with the New Age movement and its non-scientific spiritual influences.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Scott Barry Kaufman

“I wonder if to certain extent the field of psychology which likes to see himself itself as a like physics you know like a science always a lot of psychologists do we're really put off by you know trying to buy that world and wanted to distinguish itself from you know we're not self-help you know we'll woo you know we're we're more scientific”

0.52

Intelligence is the ability to apprehend and perceive what is, while imagination is the ability to apprehend and perceive what could be, and creativity is the combination of both intelligence and imagination.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Scott Barry Kaufman

“intelligence I view as the we can just really shorthand it and say it's the ability to apprehend and perceive what is and when I got into imagination research I defined imagination as the ability to apprehend and perceive what could be and so I actually view creativity as a combination of intelligence and imagination”

0.52

Scott has spent significant time thinking about 'pseudo-transcendence' and 'pseudo-growth,' concepts that Maslow articulated—people who try to jump to the top of Maslow's hierarchy of needs without addressing their other needs, thinking that meditation, LSD, or spiritual practices will somehow eliminate their basic concerns.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Scott Barry Kaufman

“I've spent a lot of time was running this book thinking about pseudo transcendence what a pseudo transcendence look like mass will actually talk about pseudo growth he talked about people who tried to jump to the top of his hierarchy of needs without having without addressing their other needs thinking that it'll somehow if they just meditate or if they just do LSD or they do spiritual practices then suddenly they don't they won't have these abiding concerns any more than they had”

0.52

Psychedelics can serve as proof of principle that the human mind is capable of states of consciousness that are dramatically different from ordinary waking consciousness; experiencing a sweet spot on LSD, psilocybin, or MDMA shows you that certain experiences (like unconditional love or self-transcending unity with nature) are actually possible, even if you can forget about them on a daily basis afterward.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sam Harris

“if you if you hit any of those sweet spots that do you in there within their purview seem normative if you experience something like unconditional love on MDMA or you experience self-transcending unity with nature will say on psilocybin it is like you know experiencing physical perfection you know of a sort that you know only the most highly trained athlete would ever touch and you're just dropped into it and then you then you lose it again you come down but you realize okay that's possible even though you can forget it on a you know day-by-day basis you have seen something that you you know there's a there there”

0.52

Meditation is more orderly than psychedelics and less risky for most people, though there is still risk; some people can go crazy on meditation retreats as well, but the risk is different—meditation allows for more control and gradual progression, whereas psychedelics involve a spin of the roulette wheel regarding what you'll experience.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sam Harris

“you can get there with meditation and you can get there in a much more orderly way without the downside I mean some people can go crazy on a meditation retreat as well so it's not that there's no risk but it's not the same kind of spin of the roulette wheel where you're really not sure what you're gonna get until you get it all your attempts to control a set and setting notwithstanding so it is more orderly and it can go into very rarefied terrain”

0.52

Healthy transcendence is defined as a harmonious integration of the whole self in the service of realizing the good society; it is about connection between self and world, not transcending above the world, and it is distinctly not horizontal transcendence (transcending other people) but quite the opposite—unity with the world.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Scott Barry Kaufman

“that's why I think that this healthy transcendence model I talking about a book I specifically define as healthy transcendence is defined as a harmonious integration of the whole self in the service of realizing the good society that's how I define healthy transcendence to make clear that it's the connection between self and world not being above the world in some way my conception of transcendence might differ from other people's notions of transcendence but I wanted to make it very clear that it wasn't a horizontal thing it's not like we're transcending other people in sometimes it's actually quite the opposite healthy transcendence is when we have this great unity with the world”

0.48

William James should have been followed rather than Freud as the founding figure of psychology because James pursued research psychology on empirical data while Freud's ideas were armchair theorizing and personal projections.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Scott Barry Kaufman

“you know III was long believed that we should have listened to William James and not Freud mmm you know we should have listened to in some sense is the the originator of research psychology or empirical data psychology a lot of Freud's ideas were very armchair and were ironically projections of his own soul so to speak or his own issues projecting that on to all of humanity”

0.47

Wisdom is the integration aspect of development; people who appear to be enlightened or claim to be transcendent but then use people or create suffering are exhibiting pseudo-transcendence, which is built on a faulty foundation—they still have unresolved belonging needs, safety needs, or esteem needs.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Scott Barry Kaufman

“so the point here of wisdom is is the integration aspect so people who appear as though they're transmitted or will tell you because they're gurus are that you know that I'm a transcendent being you know and they then I go use people in there or do it or whatever they whatever you know you see you see all these atrocities from people who say they're enlightened not all of course but you you know the kinds you point you point out I would argue that they're pseudo transcending they have built their practice beautiful practices on a very faulty foundation there they still have unresolved deeply unresolved belonging needs or deeply unresolved safety needs or steam means you know the they desperately need a steam and so it's built on a very faulty foundation”

0.47

A great wave (external crisis or shock) can come crashing down on all boats at once, and then suddenly we realize we're all in the same sea together—the sailboat metaphor shows the interconnection of all people and that basic security can be disrupted for everyone regardless of their level of development.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Scott Barry Kaufman

“a great unknown a great wave can come crashing down on all the boats at once and then suddenly we were all moving our own direction and now we realize wait a minute we're all actually in the same sea together”

0.47

The very idea of culture modulates and shapes how self-esteem and need fulfillment get expressed; before social media existed, what self-esteem meant was different than what it means now, where it involves online standing and social comparison in a new domain.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sam Harris

“we you know we all have various self-esteem needs se and needs for belonging and in connection and then the fulfillment of those needs get advertised to us and modulated by culture so what a self-esteem mean now well it means something different than in you know the 1980s before anyone had even heard of social media you know or imagined that such a thing was possible now it means something online”

0.47

For someone who has not experienced extraordinary states of consciousness, the lack of imagination about their possibility leads to habitual patterns of living that are unsatisfying; the inability to imagine alternatives traps one in repetitive existence.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sam Harris

“that lack of imagination becomes the reason why you are satisfied with Netflix and not hating your life you get up each day and merely repeat that project...if you're spending more or less every moment of your life just trying to come out on the winning side of a skirmish on Twitter and eke out a few more publications and earn 50% more money than you did last year right like if that is taking up 90% of a person's bandwidth well you know embedded in that use of energy and attention are certain assumptions about what will be ultimately satisfying”

0.43

There are multiple different routes to the same transcendent states of being; psychedelics are not the only path, and there are many different practices (meditation, prayer, etc.) that can lead to similar insights and states of consciousness.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Scott Barry Kaufman

“there's lots of different routes to this this certain transcendent state of being there's lots of different routes I'm wondering is psychedelics is that do you think there's nothing else practices that can take us to that same to those same insights what are your thoughts on that”

0.17

Scott has written an article in Mindfulness magazine that relates to the topic of his skepticism about meditation or approaches to meditation, and this relates to the discussion of how meditation integrates with self-transcendence.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Sam Harris

“I guess this does relate somewhat you you wrote an article and mindfulness that I also wanted to talk about and it relates to your take on meditation”

0.17

Scott has noticed in himself that he can see beauty somewhere and start crying over it without psychedelics, and he is scared to take psychedelics because he fears having a wonderful experience and then it becoming overwhelming, or the transcendent experience becoming too intense.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Scott Barry Kaufman

“I've just noticed in myself that I I can see beauty somewhere and then just start crying you know over it and without psychedelics I'm kind of I'm kind of scared I once I want to do it with someone what that's a good guide you know or someone who's really experienced with it cuz I'm kind of scared of of being high and then or being kind of having this wonderful experience and then can you have too much of of this kind of trance and experience where it becomes overwhelming you know”