
How social narratives stop us from being happy | Andrea Breanna | Big Think
What this covers
Andrea Breanna, founder and CEO of RebelMouse and openly transgender, speaks alone in this six-minute Big Think piece, drawing on her own life rather than on research. She begins with her childhood: she always knew she was trans, though she says that isn't true of every trans person and doesn't define one. She felt she lost part of her childhood by not being fully herself in public, yet she always had small private spaces to be herself. Growing up in Silicon Valley, with a father who founded a software company, she learned to code in order to password-protect a file, which gave her her first private space. From this she suggests that many trans people end up in tech because it offered them a place to be themselves.
The central turn comes after coming out. Breanna says she met few people who were trans themselves and many who identified with trans people, in the sense of not fitting existing boxes. From there she argues that a paradigm requiring people to fit established identities and roles produces stress and anxiety, since few people fit them. She also treats happiness as the most important measure of a life, and passion as a guide to what a person is meant to express.
The talk covers several other topics. She describes the confusion she and her wife faced over gender identity versus sexual orientation, a person being a girl who is attracted to girls, which they had no cultural narrative to explain. She criticizes asking children, from middle school onward, to pick a specialty, and she thinks aspirations like president or firefighter are too narrow compared with inventing something that doesn't yet exist. She forecasts that humanity could keep creating new roles and identity categories for centuries. A brief anecdote about a shaman in Costa Rica's Osa Peninsula makes the point that you understand deeply only what you love, not what you hate.
The speaker argues that modern society's insistence on fitting into pre-existing identity and career narratives causes unnecessary stress and anxiety, and that human flourishing requires creating new roles and narratives rather than conforming to existing ones.
- Living within paradigms that force us to fit into existing roles causes tremendous stress and anxiety because very few people fit perfectly into those roles
- Coming out as trans revealed that most people identify with the sense of not fitting into existing boxes, not just trans people
- Society should encourage people to invent new roles and narratives rather than asking them to choose from existing options as early as middle school
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The greatest aspirational dream society presents to children is limited—encouraging them to become a president or fireman—when instead the goal should be for them to invent something new that does not yet exist.
“The biggest dream we can put out there for them is the president. But the biggest dream should be, you're going to invent something we don't know yet.”
The speaker met a shaman in the Osa Peninsula of Costa Rica who demonstrated a principle about understanding: if you love something, you will pay attention to it and understand it deeply, but if you hate it, you will only have a superficial understanding—as he illustrated with a jungle flower.
“we met this shaman who was really amazing... he said, 'Listen, see this flower?' and it was a gorgeous complicated jungle flower He says, 'If you love it, then you'll understand. Because you'll pay attention and [INAUDIBLE]. And if you hate it, then you'll only have that thin little photo of it. You won't ever understand it.'”
The confusion between gender identity and sexual orientation is significant—a person can be a girl and be attracted to girls, but this combination was confusing for the speaker and their wife because they lacked cultural narratives to make sense of it.
“if I could whisper back to myself as a teenager, you can be a girl and like girls. But it was also confusing through all of this. And for her, there's no narratives.”
Growing up in Silicon Valley with a father who started a software company gave the speaker access to computers, and they learned to code initially as a way to create private space—specifically by writing code to password protect files—because they had no privacy from family members.
“Growing up in the Valley, and my dad started a software company, I learned to code. And the first reason I learned to code, the first thing I did with it, was create I wrote a little thing of code to password protect a file... It was the first private space that I had.”
There is potential for humanity to expand and create new narrative roles and identity categories for centuries to come, and we are nowhere near exhausting what it could mean to be human.
“we have hundreds of years of expanding narratives before we've exhausted what it could mean to be human”
Happiness is the most important metric in human life—more important than any other measure—and everything else is noise in comparison.
“happiness is the most important thing in our lives. It's the most valuable metric of our lives is how happy we were. Everything else if noise.”
Many trans people work in technology because, as children, it was a place where they could be themselves—technology provided private space for identity expression that physical environments did not.
“I think a lot of trans people work in tech, because as kids it was a place we could be ourselves.”
Children are asked from middle school onward to decide on a specialty or career path, but this is problematic because children cannot know their true calling at that age—most people, even the smartest, don't know what their core skill or passion is until much later in life, if ever.
“they ask from middle school for kids to think about their specialty. And it's like, how could you know? You don't know. You won't I think the smartest people don't know what their thing is when they're 70.”
When people live within a current paradigm that requires them to fit into already-existing identity and role categories, it causes tremendous stress and anxiety because very few humans fit perfectly into those pre-existing boxes.
“when we are living in a paradigm, which is our current one, where we are trying to find the role already existing that we fit into, I think when we try to exist in modern times in that paradigm, it causes a tremendous stress and anxiety. Because as humans, it turns out, that very few of us fit so perfectly.”
Understanding what you love to do and what makes you happy is how you find what your soul is fighting to express and create—happiness and passion are guides to authentic identity.
“What do you love to do? What made you happy? And those are the things that your soul are fighting to find again.”
Coming out as trans allowed the speaker to see that while they meet people who identify as trans, they overwhelmingly meet people who identify *with* trans people in the sense of not fitting into existing identity and role boxes—suggesting the experience of not fitting is nearly universal, not specifically trans.
“coming out as trans, what has been beautiful for me is to see that while I get to meet a lot of people who identify as trans, I meet, overwhelmingly people who identify with trans people. With this sense of not fitting into those things”
When the speaker came out as trans, their biggest fear was that their wife would want a divorce, but their wife accepted them because the speaker had always been attracted to girls and the speaker's gender transition did not change their sexual orientation.
“what I think I found when I came out of the closet, the biggest fear, that once my wife accepted me instead of wanted a divorce and she understood I didn't, I actually, I've always been attracted to girls.”
Historically, all people alive have chosen from existing narrative roles that society has given them, rather than inventing new roles, though the existing narratives have become less primitive than they once were.
“everyone who's alive picks from the existing narrative roles that we've been given. And they used to be terribly primitive, but they were shockingly primitive”
The speaker felt they lost or missed aspects of childhood because they could not fully be themselves publicly while growing up, though they could find private spaces to express their authentic identity.
“I sometimes feel like many of us do a lost childhood that I didn't get to fully be myself. But on the other hand, I also feel like I was able to frequently be myself because I was never in the closet to myself.”
The speaker always knew they were trans from childhood, though they acknowledge this early self-knowledge is not universal among trans people and does not define what it means to be trans.
“I always knew I was trans. And I think that's not true of all trans people. It's not what defines us. But it is true of a lot of us.”