What this covers

This is a single-speaker FRONTLINE interview with Yale historian Timothy Snyder, recorded in September 2022 for the "Putin and the Presidents" documentary. Questions come from the Kirk Documentary Group's Michael Wiser, and the conversation moves between Russian domestic politics and the sequence of American administrations that dealt with it. Snyder begins with Vladimir Putin's own trajectory. Putin arrived promising a "dictatorship of the law," Snyder says, then abandoned the rule of law and made himself the top oligarch. His system survives on staged elections run through the administrative resource, which Snyder describes as democratic ritual.

The middle of the interview covers Ukraine and the war. Snyder points to Putin's long essay denying Ukrainian nationhood and to the Russian plan for a three-day political operation, which assumed few Ukrainians would fight. He argues that a Ukraine moving toward rule of law is what threatens Putin's model. He also describes how Maidan and the first war in 2014 built a civil society and a generation of leaders that mattered in 2022. Another thread looks at how Russian propaganda in 2014 kept Americans debating coups and Nazis instead of recognizing an invasion. Snyder links this to the KGB interrogation method of finding and exploiting weakness, which he says carried over to social media and the 2016 election.

The American side is where he becomes most contentious. He calls the end-of-Cold-War belief that capitalism brings democracy a tremendous mistake. He argues that Donald Trump's pressure on Volodymyr Zelenskyy amounted to blackmail. He also says the Biden administration faced a novel challenge in late 2021. Smaller turns include how Russians heard Mitt Romney's 2012 warning, and his claim that Putin's fear of ending up like Muammar Gaddafi is independent of American policy. He closes on preparing for the eventual fall of dictators and on the danger of treating democracy as inevitable.

Sharpest takeaway

The West fundamentally misunderstood Putin and Russia by projecting its own assumptions about inevitable democratic progress, allowing Putin to consolidate authoritarian power justified by foreign enemies, pursue spectacle-based foreign policy unconstrained by domestic reform, and ultimately invade Ukraine—a conflict rooted not in American actions but in Russia's internal choice to abandon democracy.

  • Putin's hostility toward the West stems from failed domestic policy and need for permanent foreign spectacle, not from American provocation or actual American threats
  • The West's belief that capitalism and economic integration would inevitably produce democracy in Russia was catastrophically wrong and enabled Putin's rise
  • Ukraine's actual transformation toward democracy and rule of law directly threatened Putin's regime in ways that had nothing to do with American rhetoric

The claims · ranked42 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.84

Vladimir Putin planned to invade Ukraine based on a systematically false understanding in which he does not believe Ukraine has independent existence as a state or nation, as evidenced by a 7,000-word essay he published articulating his views on history and Russian-Ukrainian relations.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Timothy Snyder

“Vladimir Putin in invades Ukraine on the basis of a systematically false understanding of what Russia is and what Ukraine is Putin helps us understand him by publishing a 7,000 word essay about his own views about history and in the essay he makes it clear that he doesn't really believe that Ukraine has any kind of independent existence there isn't really Ukrainian State there isn't really Ukrainian Nation”

0.80

If too few people own too much and too few people dominate the media, you will not end up as a democracy—whether in America, Russia, or anywhere else; this is a lesson visible in Russia's failure to democratize despite privatization.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Timothy Snyder

“if you seriously believe that just privatizing things is going to lead to a good political system then Russia should be a good political system because they did privatize things but in fact this is a lesson for everybody if too few people own too much of the stuff and if too few people dominate the media you're not going to end up as a democracy whether you're America whether you're Russia whether anybody else”

0.80

Putin came to power with the idea that Russia could become a 'rule of law state' through what he called 'dictatorship of the law,' but quickly realized this was not possible (or that he was not the person to do it) and shifted to a different program: becoming the top oligarch rather than eliminating oligarchy—turning the state into a Mafia clan.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Timothy Snyder

“Putin comes to power with the basic idea that Russia can be rigged up into some kind of rule of law state dictatorship of the law is the phrase that he uses he quickly realizes that that's not the case or at least that he's not the person to do it and shifts gears to a different program of rule which involves not getting rid of oligarchy but being the top oligarch which is a very fundamental difference it might look the same because you're rounding up people putting them in jail but becoming the top oligarch becoming the boss of bosses turning the state into the most important Mafia Clan is very different than cleaning out the Stables”

0.80

Putin's worldview is that Moscow and Kyiv are organically together and should be, and it is only because of outsiders (historically Austrians, Germans, Poles, Jews; currently the European Union and Americans) that this is not true.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Timothy Snyder

“Putin's worldview which I think he really believes is that Moscow and Kev are somehow organic together and always should be and it's only because of The Outsiders that this isn't true and so what he's talking about is not America as it is he's talking about a fantasy of America a fantasy of America that wants to to do these Insidious things like take Ukraine away from Russia”

0.80

Putin looks at the Arab Spring and Libya, and Gaddafi's fate, and thinks: I am a dictator like him, they're tyrants like me, they ended up in a cage, I could end up in a cage—this logic of tyrant's fear is ancient and inevitable regardless of American foreign policy.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Timothy Snyder

“when Putin looks at the Arab Spring or when Putin looks at Gaddafi it's absolutely right that he thinks they're dictators I'm a dictator they're tyrants I'm a tyrant they end up in a cage I could end up in a cage he certainly thinks that because that is the logic of being a tyrant you know as we know from Plato to Shakespeare the logic of being a tyrant is that you're going to be afraid of ending that way”

0.80

Dictators always fall from power; when it happens, Americans should not feel guilty or ashamed, but should be ready and preparing policy for succession—not hoping for specific leaders but ready to adapt.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Timothy Snyder

“I think it's pretty important for us not to get too emotionally involved as we have in the past with IND idual Russian leaders you know we wanted G orop to stay we wanted yelson to stay you know we don't like Putin but even so we're discomforted by the idea that Putin won't be in power they always fall from Power dictators always fall from power that it always happens and when it happens it's not something we should feel guilty or ashamed about we should just be ready for it and uh and be preparing our policy for for for the next person”

0.78

Ukraine changed between 2014 and 2022, undergoing a generational leadership change with talented people coming to power, and 2014's Maidan and first war opened a period of civil society cooperation that would be very important in the 2022 war.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Timothy Snyder

“Ukraine changed Ukraine between 2014 and 2022 saw a generational change in leadership where a lot of talented and interesting people actually came to power Ukraine changed in the sense that 2014 the maidon the first war opened up a period of cooperation in civil society and human networks which going to Pro be very very important in the 2022 War”

0.75

The belief that democracy is inevitable because there are no alternatives, or that capitalism will automatically bring political democracy, was a tremendous mistake made by American policymakers at the end of the Cold War, and this error enabled the rise of authoritarians like Putin.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Timothy Snyder

“I think it's better to say that democracy is a better system than it is to say that it's inevitable because once you say that it's inevitable you're forgetting all the things that you have to do or struggle for in order for democracy to come into being and that applies not just to us I mean our own democracy I think arguably is in a worse situation than it was in the late 1980s it applies to everybody the Russians nobody in Eastern Europe was going to get democracy inevitably and nobody was going to get it just because there was capitalism which I think was our big tremendous stupid mistake at the time relying on these larger structural forces not not paying attention to culture not paying attention to ethics and imagining that the economic transformation in the form of privatization was automatically going to bring about political changes that's what we were thinking and we were wrong about that”

0.75

Putin's system is based on turning democracy into a ritual using what Russians call the 'administrative resource,' and Putin only survives through the repeated legitimation that democratic theater and democratic performances provide him every six years.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Timothy Snyder

“the Putin system is based upon turning democracy into a r ritual using what Russians called the administrative resource because there's no alternative ideology to democracy Putin only survives with the repeated legitimation that Democratic theater acts Democratic performances provide him so every so often every six years we're going to have an election and Putin's going to win that election and he has to win it by a lot not because people actually believe in the results they don't but because the election proves that he's the one who's in charge because he's the one who's writing the election right that's how it works”

0.74

The Russians planned for a 3-day war as a political operation, based on the belief that there were not that many Ukrainians willing to risk their lives for their country, and were entirely wrong in this calculation.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Timothy Snyder

“The Russians were planning for a 3-day War they were planning for a political war they were thinking that there aren't really that many ukrainians in the sense of people who'd be willing to risk their lives for their country and in this they were entirely wrong”

0.73

We can't learn a lesson from something when we haven't understood that something is happening—even one straightforward column story saying 'Russia invades Ukraine' would have been more useful than endless discussions about whether a coup happened or other irrelevant matters that prevented recognition of the basic fact.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Timothy Snyder

“it's hard to take a lesson from something when you haven't really understood that that's something is happening and in the American mind if you go back and read the Press from those weeks and months this is very clear it just wasn't clear that an invasion of Ukraine was happening I mean if there had been a single column story in the New York Times one day which had just said Russia invades Ukraine that would have been so much more useful than the endless discussions we had about a whole bunch of things which either were relevant or weren't happening”

0.69

The Obama Administration was blindsided when Russia attempted to alter American electoral outcomes, but this was consistent with how Russia sees the rest of the world: Russia is not trying to make other places like Russia but to messing them up and bringing worst tendencies to the fore.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Timothy Snyder

“the Obama Administration was totally blindsided when the Russians decided to try to alter our electoral outcomes but it was totally consistent with the way Russia sees the rest of the world Russia's not trying to make America like Russia Russia's just trying to make it turn America into a total mess um that's what that's what they're going for and that's a kind of power and it's consistent by the way with a lot of Soviet history that it's not so much about necessarily making everybody believe your ideas it's more a matter of making sure that nobody else can mount a serious challenge to you”

0.69

The Russians did have initial advantages in the 2022 war but failed because Ukraine and Ukrainians turned out to be far more capable and committed to defense than Russia predicted, making this a story of Russia humiliating itself rather than Russia humiliating America by invading Ukraine.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Timothy Snyder

“how this was not going to be a story of Russia humiliating America by invading Ukraine how this was going to be a story of Russia humiliating itself because the ukrainians were going to fight back and win”

0.68

In late 2021, the Biden Administration faced an unprecedented challenge: a major power, the Russian Federation, was planning to invade its neighbor Ukraine, which sits on the border of NATO and the European Union, threatening the international legal framework established since World War II and the credibility of coherent American foreign policy.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Timothy Snyder

“in late 2021 the Biden Administration was faced with this challenge they didn't expect namely one a major power is going to invade its neighbor not just any major power the Russian Federation and not just any neighbor Ukraine which is on the border of NATO and the European Union what was at stake is the idea that countries shouldn't destroy other countries for no reason in a war what was at stake is the international legal framework which we've been trying to keep going since the second world war”

0.60

Trump tried to blackmail Ukraine and its newly elected president by threatening to take weapons away unless Zelenskyy pursued an 'insane investigation' into Joe Biden's son that Ukrainian investigative journalists knew was bogus.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Timothy Snyder

“he needs to stay in power personally because of course he needs to avoid prosecution and he needs to avoid challenges to his wealth so he needs to stay in power and order the state stay in power he's willing to try to Blackmail Ukraine and its newly elected president by saying we're going to take weapons away from you unless you pursue this basically insane investigation which by the way all the Ukrainian investigative journalists know is bogus this insane investigation of the son of my of my rival”

0.59

American enmity gives Russia a sense of meaning and purpose, whereas Americans do not need Russia for their own sense of identity or meaning—this is the fundamental psychological difference between the two nations.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Timothy Snyder

“Russian leaders are thinking about not thinking about domestic politics thinking about foreign policy all the time and foreign policy is a kind of duel of great Powers American Presidents American public opinion the American columnists they're not thinking that way we only react to Russia when we absolutely have to I mean we reacted very very late and very very weak to the Russian intervention in the American election in 2016 when Mitt Romney said when he was campaigning against Barack Obama that Russia was a serious threat everyone laughed at him except the Russians who who kind of like to think that they were a serious threat when Obama says that Russia doesn't matter because it's only a regional economy and so on um he's saying something which to the Russians is absolutely incomprehensible they think of themselves as a great power and they would have prove that they're a great power so the biggest difference is that Russians really like to think about America because American enmity the idea that America is trying to hurt Russia gives Russia a sense of meaning whereas Americans absolutely do not need Russia for their sense of themselves”

0.59

The Russian state is not about a creative project; it is about removing alternatives and making the normality of Russia—corruption, inequality, spectacle, constant propaganda—seem normal both inside Russia and in other places.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Timothy Snyder

“the Russian state is not about a creative project if the Russian state were about a creative project then in some sense President Obama would have been right when he said no no it's just a regional power because it's correct Russia doesn't have a big economy it doesn't really set an example for anyone else so in that narrow sense where you think economics and ideas that are familiar to us are all that matter then maybe Russia doesn't matter so much but that's imposing our own criteria on the Putin regime the Putin regime was never about creating things their Putin regime is about removing Alternatives it's about making the normality that is Russia the corruption the inequality the spectacle the constant line seem normal and the way you make it seem normal is by making it be normal not just in your own country but in other places”

0.59

Russians look at Ukraine and want to prevent it from becoming a functioning rule of law state that joins the European Union; this threat to Putin's model is what makes Ukraine real, and Ukraine did eventually prove that post-Soviet countries can develop rule of law and democracy.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Timothy Snyder

“Russia invades Ukraine because it looks like Ukraine could become a functioning rule of law state which would join the European Union it doesn't have a whole lot to do with America uh what it has to do with is the possibility that a post Soviet country next to Russia where lots of people speak Russian which is in some ways not so different from Russia that that country could actually become a rule of law state a democracy and join the European Union that is what Russia needed to prevent in 2013 and that's what Russia needed to BR in 2014 when it invaded that's what was really going on it was really about democracy it wasn't about American Presidents talking about democracy different subject it was about actual democracy in Russia's actual neighborhood which is an actual threat to Putin”

0.59

Americans could not learn lessons from 2014 because we hadn't realized we'd been fooled in 2014; Russia used the same people, institutions, and techniques in 2014 and 2016, but Americans didn't make the connection.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Timothy Snyder

“the lesson that we should have learned in domestic politics is that the Russians have found techniques using social media to structure and frame what's going on they did that in 2014 when they invaded Ukraine and then they did it in 2016 to great effect when they intervened in our presidential elections using the same people the same institutions and the same techniques so once we had been had in Ukraine in 2014 we should have been better prepared for being had in 2016 I made that connection at the time um and I tried to persuade other people that this was what was happening but so I remember this very vividly nobody was going along with that nobody thought there was anything we needed to learn from 2014 because we hadn't realized how much we've been fooled in 2014”

0.56

When Mitt Romney called Russia a serious threat during his 2012 campaign against Barack Obama and everyone laughed, the Russians understood his comment differently—they liked thinking they were a serious threat, whereas Obama's later dismissal of Russia as 'only a regional economy' was incomprehensible to them because they view themselves as a great power.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Timothy Snyder

“when Mitt Romney said when he was campaigning against Barack Obama that Russia was a serious threat everyone laughed at him except the Russians who who kind of like to think that they were a serious threat when Obama says that Russia doesn't matter because it's only a regional economy and so on um he's saying something which to the Russians is absolutely incomprehensible they think of themselves as a great power”

0.56

To understand Putin's turn against the United States, one should not feel guilty about American policy, imagine Americans are responsible for everything, or deny Putin and Russia agency; instead, understand the failure of Putin's domestic policy and his recognition that he needs permanent foreign policy spectacle.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Timothy Snyder

“the way to understand Putin's turn against the United States is not to feel guilty about American policy it's not to imagine that we're responsible for everything because we're not it's not to deny him or Russian's agency because they have agency it's to understand the failure of Putin's domestic policy and his recognition that what he needs is a kind of permanent spectacle which comes out of foreign policy and that the Europeans and the Americans are always going provide that now when I say that I'm not saying that American foreign policy has been good the Iraq War was an absolute disaster and I said so at the time and the Iraq War has played a later indirect role in the Ukraine war which maybe we can talk about but what I am trying to say is that it's very important as Americans not to think that everything that Putin does is because of some little thing that we did the most likely explanation is that what Putin is doing in foreign policy has to do with his needs in domestic policy”

0.56

Democracy is better than authoritarianism, but saying democracy is inevitable is dangerous because it makes people forget what they have to struggle for in order for democracy to come into being, and this applies to American democracy itself which is arguably in a worse situation than in the late 1980s.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Timothy Snyder

“I think it's better to say that democracy is a better system than it is to say that it's inevitable because once you say that it's inevitable you're forgetting all the things that you have to do or struggle for in order for democracy to come into being and that applies not just to us I mean our own democracy I think arguably is in a worse situation than it was in the late 1980s”

0.55

Putin wanted Trump to win the 2016 election, and what Trump does for Putin is normalize the Russian way of doing politics globally—where democracy is a joke, lying is normal, politics is about rich people getting richer, and corruption is standard.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Timothy Snyder

“it's clear that Putin wanted Trump to win he said as much um it's clear that he applauded Trump's idea that the European Union isn't really a thing and that NATO should perhaps be weakened um that's all clear because Putin has said so that's all absolutely clear in general what Trump does for Putin is he normalizes the Russian way of doing politics so Putin's view that democracy is a joke you can lie all the time politics is fundamentally about some rich guy becoming richer corruption is normal right Trump normalizes that for the whole world so it's a huge gift for Putin because the United States although it doesn't matter as much as it thinks it does it does matter a lot and so what what Trump did was he took Putin and he made Putin normal he put Putin at the middle Putin was now no longer something exceptional Putin was now normal thanks to Donald Trump”

0.55

In 2014, Russia convinced the world while it was invading Ukraine that the invasion was not happening; Russians had minds of the West in a trap with discussions about coups, Nazis, gays, and Jews—Russian propaganda was so successful that Americans could not talk about war or invasion.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Timothy Snyder

“Russia invaded Ukraine and basically persuaded us that it didn't actually happen while Russia was invading Ukraine the most important thing that was happening in the minds of the West not just Americans were discussions about whether there had been a coup in Ukraine or whether the ukrainians are all Nazis or maybe they're all gay or maybe they're all Jews depending on what social media you were following right the the Russians totally had our minds in a trap at that time and we were totally unprepared for that not just the Obama Administration but American public life in general they outsmarted us they ran circles around us”

0.55

When Americans talk about elections being real—whether Pompeo, Clinton, or others—Putin authentically regards this as a threat because he needs Russians to believe that elections are always a circus, a farce, and a fake; if Russians believe that British, German, and American elections are real, they might question why their own elections are fake.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Timothy Snyder

“the idea that elections could be real whether it's Pompeo who's saying it or Clinton who's saying it the idea that elections could be real is a threat Putin needs Russians to believe that elections are always a circus a farce and a fake because if Russians believe that British elections and German elections and American elections are also fake they're not going to mind that their own elections are fake so when Americans come to Russia and talk about votes being counted I think he authentically regards that as a threat”

0.55

Russians use interrogation protocols learned in the KGB where they seek out psychological weaknesses and expand them; the same protocol works on social media because they use data collection to reveal weaknesses (e.g., racism, class anxiety) and then exploit them through targeted messaging.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Timothy Snyder

“the KGB Instinct the Soviet Instinct that every psychology has a weakness and the way that you perform your work and indeed perform your life is to find that weakness and expand it and exploit it that can work on us that can work on American democracy so I'm not I'm not sure that they understand us normal sense they would understand I think they have a protocol that they follow and they use it interrogations and that protocol they follow in interrogations where they seek out weaknesses also works on social media because remember the the way they try to throw the election doesn't have to do with people in touch with people not really it has to do with the mechanical collection of data which reveals weaknesses so do Russians understand American racism no but do they understand that people reveal their racism on Facebook yes and so then they can appeal to racists on Facebook um do they understand what it's like to be an African-American in the US obviously not do they understand that African-Americans might be sensitive to claims that Hillary Clinton is a racist yes they get that and so what they're doing is they're they're following a protocol which says look for the psychological weakness expand it exploit it hit it make everything about that and they're taking the data which social media provides to generate a coherent approach to trying to affect an American election”

0.52

The Biden Administration did not take Putin's position seriously because they did not take Russian domestic politics seriously, and therefore the Obama 'reset' could not have worked because there was nothing America did that was actually important to Putin inside Russia.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Timothy Snyder

“I think that we generally just don't take Russian domestic politics seriously enough and therefore we don't take Putin's we don't take Putin's position seriously enough of course the reset wasn't going to work because there's nothing that America did which was actually that important inside Russia I mean I'm sorry if I'm like undermining the whole premise of your program but there's literally nothing that we do which is that important inside Russia”

0.52

Russians systematically overestimate how much attention Americans pay to Russia; Russians think about America constantly while Americans think about Russia only when necessary, a reality Russian leaders cannot afford to acknowledge because their ideology of power rests on the idea of Russia as a great power equal to America and China.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Timothy Snyder

“the Russians are systematically wrong about how much attention Americans pay to Russia the Russians think about America all the time Americans only think about Russia when they have to and that is not a reality which Russian leaders can afford to recognize or talk about because their power or their ideology of power rests on the idea that there are great powers in the world Russia America China Russia's one of these great powers and so the basic reality that Americans actually don't really like to think about Russia they don't think about Russia that much it would be something which is absolutely unacceptable”

0.52

Putin's cynicism about politics gave way to mysticism about Russia's historical mission and his personal legacy—a shift that occurred over time and is evident in his rhetoric over the last 10 years, leading him to actually believe that Russia and Ukraine are one country.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Timothy Snyder

“Putin also changed over time the cynicism gave way also to a certain mysticism a certain idea about Russia's Mission and his personal mission and how he would be remembered after he died that did change and if one follows his rhetoric um in the last 10 years it's clear that he's reaching a point where he actually believes that Russia and Ukraine are one country and that this means that Ukraine will collapse when he invades but it also means that this is his opportunity to somehow make history right again um which is the kind of thinking which it's understandable that democratically elected leaders are not going to really understand”

0.52

Putin has created the situation that could bring him down by mobilizing a million Russian soldiers for a pointless war in which many will die, going back to historical moments like 1917 and the 1560s when Russian leaders fought wars they shouldn't have and created domestic consequences they couldn't manage.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Timothy Snyder

“poetically you know he's created the situation which could bring him down which didn't have to happen by mobilizing him million Russian soldiers to go fight a war which was utterly pointless in which many of them are going to die he's created the situation where he could fall he's gone back to a place like 1917 you know where where a Russian government is fighting a war it probably shouldn't have been fighting he's going back to like the 1560s and Ivon the terrible like fighting a war he shouldn't have fought and creating domestic consequences which he may not be able to to to deal with that's that's all on him”

0.51

January 6th was a tremendous gift to Russia and Vladimir Putin; nobody loved January 6th more than the Russians, who celebrated it as proof that peaceful transitions of power, consensus, and the American Constitution are all illusions.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Timothy Snyder

“one thing which they wanted which they got and which they celebrated was a coup attempt they love January 6th nobody loved January 6th more than the Russians did January 6th showed that all this stuff about peaceful transitions of power and consensus and the American Constitution they just loved it they lapped it up they reproduce it all the time they talk about it all the time that was that that was I mean Trump gave them four years which was one big gift but January 6th was like the wrapping the beautiful wrapping you know the package um which is which they'll just never forget”

0.51

Putin learned from Georgia (2008) and Ukraine (2014) that military intervention works if you control the narrative; the US responded minimally to Crimea's annexation—a fundamental violation of the UN/Security Council principle that countries cannot invade and annex territory.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Timothy Snyder

“does Putin take a lesson from that Putin takes a lesson from Syria when we say there's a red line and there's not a red line and Putin takes a lesson from Ukraine when he's able to invade a country which is in seized territory which is a fundamental violation of everything that we say is the is the basis of our legal order the whole thing the idea that one country does not invade another country and Annex territory is the entire foundation of the United Nations and its Security Council of which Russia and America are members and our reaction is minimal right and so of course he takes a lesson from that the lesson he takes from that is that this kind of thing can work if we Jin it up properly and that's not the message that we really wanted to be sending at the time”

0.49

January 6th led directly to the war in Ukraine because it showed that America was not just morally discredited but weak—if Americans could barely get Biden into office and were tearing themselves apart, Putin would have no consequences for invading Ukraine.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Timothy Snyder

“January 6 apart from anything else leads directly to the war in Ukraine because it if it looks like America is not just morally discredited it looks like America is weak let about to pick up one thing about Ukraine which is we were talking about Ukraine as or you were talking about Ukraine as an example of this important conflict here between democracy and authoritarianism and being an actual conflict and not just rhetorical and Trump's approach to Ukraine which we know he described as sort of a corrupt country there's obviously the famous phone call what does Trump's approach to Ukraine tell us what does it tell us about democracy and authoritarianism and what would happen well in Trump's world is like Putin's world they're you know they're big guys they're little guys it's all about Force you respect you know you respect the person who can humble you therefore he you know therefore he respects Putin”

0.48

Trump personalizes everything about Russia and Ukraine, seeing it as all about Putin as the powerful figure, while Zelenskyy and Ukrainians don't really matter—they're secondary; in Trump's view, might makes right and the Russians will do what they will do.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Timothy Snyder

“what Trump does with Russia and Ukraine is he personalizes all of it it's all about Putin you know Putin I mean a lot of Americans have this problem we just talk about Putin Putin Putin Putin but Trump really personalizes it it's all about Putin pu is one who really has power the ukrainians in zalinski who are those people they don't they don't really matter they're just secondary so might makes right naturally the Russians are going to do what they're going to do”

0.48

The Biden Administration reacted to the Ukraine crisis by recognizing that the crisis was real and by correctly predicting Russian invasion, persuading others of this reality, and building a coalition to support Ukraine—distinguishing them from previous administrations since 1989.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Timothy Snyder

“I'm I mean I'm going to judge the Biden Administration from how it reacted to a crisis and the way they reacted to a crisis was to recognize that the crisis was real and that I think that does them credit they were right that Russia was going to invade Ukraine they were right to try to persuade other people that Russia was going to invade Ukraine and where I think they stand out both from not just other Democratic but all the previous administration since 1989 is they were right to to to believe that they couldn't handle the problem on their own you know that it wasn't they weren't going to be able to just say there's a red line or they weren't going to able to just conjure up a coalition because they said so that they were actually going to have to do the hard work of getting a coalition together”

0.48

The United States should focus on deterring nuclear weapons use and ensuring the Ukraine war ends as quickly as possible—which means Ukraine winning—and should not talk about what happens in Russia afterward or whether Russia falls apart; those outcomes are Russia's business.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Timothy Snyder

“I think it's very important for the United unit states to recognize that these things have their own logic and we should really do our very best to try to deter nuclear weapon use we should do our very best to try to make this war in Ukraine end as quickly as possible which means to be clear the ukrainians winning it as quickly as possible because that's the only way it can end and how things turn out in Russia we shouldn't be talking about who we want to rule Russia that's not our business we shouldn't be talking about whether Russia should fall apart that's not our business if the Russians start a war and they lose a war let them figure out what what happens next um don't talk too much about it just make sure that the right country wins the war and then you know the rest is up to the Russians themselves”

0.47

Biden calling Putin a war criminal and describing events as genocide uses language that is more straightforward and fundamental than the narratives about democracy and inevitability that Americans constructed after 1989, helping to escape American historical self-justification.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Timothy Snyder

“I think it's kind of refreshing for us honestly to be using this language which is more straightforward I I think it's important for Americans to be using a language which is more General and which is not of our own making because in our language there was 89 and 91 and democracy and it was inevitable and then maybe some people were going astray but the flat out say that what's happening in Ukraine is genocide which it is is to get out of our story of what's been happening the last 30 years and to bring in some more fundamental concepts which I think Biden has been doing and I think there's that's that what that involves fundamentally is recognizing our own mistakes that maybe more dramatic things have been happening that we have not quite been able to look at”

0.47

Putin, operating in capitalist systems with ideological pluralism, was able to represent an alternative ideology to the West, claim he embodies values (which the West wasn't talking about), and offer a counter-story to globalization—advantages the West was slow to recognize because we believed history was on our side.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Timothy Snyder

“Putin can represent an alternative he can come up with an ideology which draws people not only in Russia but in America he can come up with a counter story about globalization he can claim that he's the one who embodies values because we're not talking about values we're just talking about how stuff is inevitable which is not very attractive he can make all those claims and we're very very slow to pick up on it because we're in this story about how history is on our side”

0.47

Putin fundamentally misunderstands people who live in democracies because he cannot recognize that there are points where fundamental decency—not politics—governs democratic response; invading a country with the aim of wiping it out crossed a line of human decency that moved both American and European opinion.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Timothy Snyder

“there's a fundamental misunderstanding on the Russian side on Putin side of people who are used to living in democracies because in some ways he's right we are slow we're complicated the various forces inside our countries end up cancelling each other out but that doesn't mean that there aren't points where a fundamental sense of decency is involved and I think in not just an American public opinion but in in European public opinion invading Ukraine crossed that line it crossed that line for a lot of people and and here you can take President Biden as just as a person like other Americans or like others who just thought totally invading a country with the aim of just of wiping it out of existence is crosses a line which is not a political line but was some kind of line of human decency and I think it is a misunderstanding that Putin has about us that don't that we are just as cynical as he”

0.45

Putin is trapped in a conventional war he is going to lose, and the Ukraine war's chief danger is for Ukrainians under Russian occupation and the civilian deaths under occupation—not the danger to Putin or Western interests.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Timothy Snyder

“I think I think he's I think he's trapped in the conventional war that he's fighting so I think the chief Danger of this war we should remember is for the ukrainians who are under Russian occupation the civilian deaths of Ukraine I think are are the worst thing about this war and will likely Remain the worst thing about this War I think he's in a conventional War which he's going to lose”

0.45

When Biden said Putin 'had to go,' it did not have huge ripples in Russian media as Americans assumed; Russians tried to tuck it away because it's better for Russia to be in control of the story than for an American president to actually make such statements.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Timothy Snyder

“so when we actually do it actually they don't actually cover it so we assume that when for example when Biden said that pu had to go that that would have huge ripples in the Russian media and I'm here to tell you that it didn't I was following the Russian media after that if anything they tried to just kind of tuck it away on the side because it was a bit embarrassing um it's much better for them to be in control of the story than it is for an American president to actually come out and say these things”

0.45

If America had armed Ukraine more in 2014, following a strategy more like 2022, then 2022 would never have happened; the dancing around about whether to send Javelins was bizarre and an example of American vanity.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Timothy Snyder

“Ukraine could have defended itself if we had done in 2014 more like what we done in 2022 we never would have gotten to 2022 I think all the dancing around about whether we send javelins or not was just bizarre and and kind of a weird example of American vanity because you're not a party to a war because you give weapons if that were true then every country in the world will be a party to every war which is going on because we're constantly giving weapons and selling weapons we went on for years with this debate about whether we should arm ukrainians it's obvious that we should have armed ukrainians if we'd armed ukrainians earlier and better I think we'd be in a better world now”