
Can We Actually Turn Russia Into a Normal Country?
What this covers
This is a single-speaker video essay in which Elvira Bary works through what it would take for Russia to stop producing rulers like Putin. She starts from the logic of autocracy. Democracy, in her account, is an artificial construct that needs constant upkeep, while authoritarian rule is closer to humanity's default and is modeled on the patriarchal family. She argues that such systems have no emergency brake, and that loyalty-based appointments produce decay at home that pushes rulers toward war. The framing is institutional: the problem is how Russia is governed, not how large it is.
The middle of the talk lays out the machinery. A caste system with a wide privilege gap keeps the upper tier defending the ruler. Natural-resource income pays that tier, and the state holds monopolies over education, land, information, religion and foreign trade. She treats the USSR as the ideal monopolist state and argues that these systems are fragile when their income is disrupted. Breakup is rejected as a fix: fragments lack ports, capital and infrastructure and would drift back together "like drops of mercury." Her proposed remedy is to strip the elite of four powers, namely distributing budget money, appointing officials, controlling information and using violence.
The reform agenda then gets specific. She covers fiscal decentralization, since regions depend on subsidies from Moscow, and the decorative character of legislatures. She also calls for elected judges, free media, education and religion, and a new identity built on achievement rather than empire. Her most contested proposal is to disband the FSB, Rosgvardia and other security services entirely. She also warns that punishing and isolating Russia risks a Weimar-style revanchism. The closing sections admit the central difficulty: the group that would lose from reform controls the resources needed to launch it. She rates democratic transition as the least likely near-term scenario, and the last chapter considers who might plausibly act as reformers.
Russia cannot become a normal, peaceful state through simple interventions like replacing Putin or breaking apart; instead, it requires comprehensive institutional reforms that dismantle the caste system, redistribute control of money/power/information/violence, and rebuild national identity away from imperialism.
- Authoritarian systems are self-perpetuating: replacing one tsar with another preserves the underlying mechanism of arbitrary rule
- Russia's geographic and economic conditions make fragmentation temporary; pieces naturally recombine into centralized states
- The caste structure (elite privileges funded by natural resource monopolies) is the mechanism that enables dictators to hold power; breaking it is necessary
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Simply replacing Putin with another leader will not solve Russia's systemic problems because the underlying autocratic system remains unchanged; the next ruler may be kinder or worse, but the fundamental structure of arbitrary power by one person persists.
“If we replace Putin with anyone else, we still get the same system: a country of many millions whose fate depends on the whims of a tsar, while the level of repression at home and aggression abroad is determined by his personal tastes, fears, and fantasies. In that situation, all you can do is pray that the next tsar will be kinder than the previous one. But after a kind tsar, another psychopath can easily arrive — and everything begins again.”
A dictator needs natural resources as a steady source of income to reward members of the ruling elite to keep them personally invested in his rule, because natural resources are more reliable than taxing the general population (who rebel, get sick, and constantly want things).
“For that, he needs a steady source of income. The population can serve that purpose, of course, but people are troublesome: they rebel, get sick, and constantly want things. Natural resources are much better. Then everything becomes wonderfully simple: you sell them, collect the money, feed the courtiers, and they secure your power. Meanwhile, the population lives somewhere out there, mostly on its own.”
Democracy is not humanity's natural state but an artificially created social construct designed to help people live better, richer, and safer lives; maintaining it requires constant effort, and if that effort ceases, authoritarianism will naturally assemble itself.
“Democracy is not the norm. It is an artificially created social construct that helps people live better, richer, and safer lives. Political scientist Ekaterina Shulman has a wonderful metaphor. Tooth decay is normal; brushing your teeth is a human invention created by people who are not satisfied with the natural norm. Tooth decay will develop by itself. But to brush your teeth, and generally to maintain your health, you have to make an effort. If people do not make an effort to maintain democracy, the result will be authoritarianism. It will assemble itself.”
To maintain autocratic power, a ruler must divide society into a higher and lower caste with an enormous privilege gap, where the lower caste strives to climb upward while the upper caste fears losing privileges and defends the dictator.
“There is an ancient and highly effective mechanism that allows one person to subjugate millions. We need to divide society into castes — a higher caste and a lower caste — and make sure that the higher caste has privileges that are unthinkable for the lower ones. The gap has to be enormous. Then those below will climb upward with all their strength, while those above will fear losing their privileges and will defend the person who guarantees them.”
The real problem in Russia is not the country's size, but how it is governed—a distinction that frames the entire analysis as institutional rather than geographical or demographic.
“So the real question is not the size of the country. The real question is how it is governed.”
All of the reforms discussed would be opposed by the privileged class who would suffer as a result, so the question becomes: who can launch these changes if all resources are concentrated in the hands of the group that would suffer from reform?
“The privileged class will not give up power voluntarily. That much is obvious. So what options do we have?”
Authoritarian regimes have no emergency brake—once a dictator orders something, the entire country snaps to attention and carries it out, unlike democratic systems which have institutional checks and restraints.
“And the country snaps to attention and carries out the order, because authoritarian countries have no emergency brake.”
To cement autocratic rule, a dictator must establish as many monopolies as possible—on education, weapons, foreign trade, information, land, and religion—so that only the ruler can allow or forbid major property transfers and make/apply/enforce laws.
“To cement this structure, you need to establish as many monopolies as possible: so that only you are the supreme arbiter, only you can allow or forbid the transfer of major property, and you yourself make the laws, apply them, and control their enforcement. You need monopolies on education, weapons, foreign trade, information, land, religion — the more, the better.”
The collapse or fragmentation of Russia would not permanently solve the problem because the pieces lack the infrastructure, capital, skilled people, and access to ports needed to survive independently, causing them to naturally drift back together like drops of mercury, as has occurred multiple times in history with China.
“Russia is not so large because every little Siberian town has a military garrison standing over it. They do not. The reason is that it is extremely difficult for these regions to survive on their own, because they lack infrastructure, capital, skilled people, and access to navigable rivers and ice-free ports. In such conditions, you can sit on enormous natural wealth and still be terrifyingly poor — as in Africa.”
The USSR was the ideal monopolist state because its citizens owned nothing of their own—not even their homes—with the state controlling land, mineral resources, education, healthcare, capital, industry, communications, and all information.
“The ideal monopolist state was the USSR. Its citizens owned nothing of their own — not even their homes. The state, headed by the leader, owned the land and mineral resources, the education and healthcare systems, capital, industry, all communications, all information…”
Monopoly-based autocratic systems are not viable because they are fragile when their source of income is disrupted—they either lose wars they start or simply fall apart.
“The problem is that such systems are not viable. As soon as trouble begins with their source of income, they either lose the wars they themselves started, or simply fall apart.”
Authoritarian rulers systematically move toward war because loyalty-based appointments create governance decay and corruption, causing the ruler to seek external conquest as a solution to internal decline, and dictators psychologically crave victories and dominance, making war desirable for both political and psychological reasons.
“A dictator usurps the highest office in the state and begins to control all of its resources. To secure his power, he appoints people not because they are the most competent, but because they are the most loyal — people who depend on him completely and therefore will defend him to the end. As a result, the quality of governance moves steadily toward zero, while the level of corruption, on the contrary, breaks every record. The country clearly loses the competition with other geopolitical players at its level, and everyone can see it: the elites, the ruler himself, and ordinary people. So the conclusion almost suggests itself: let us start a war, take from our neighbors what we need, distribute the wealth among the elites, and delight the ordinary people with greatness and new territorial acquisitions.”
Living or working inside a system where everything depends on one person's mood leads everyone to adapt instead of telling the truth—this is presented as a personal question for viewers to reflect on, drawing a parallel between authoritarian systems and dysfunctional hierarchies more broadly.
“Have you ever lived or worked inside a system where everything depended on one person's mood — a boss, a parent, a principal, a local official, a family patriarch — and everyone around them learned to adapt instead of telling the truth?”
Punishing and isolating Russia will only lead to a surge of nationalism, the emergence of a new authoritarian leader, and another war in 20-30 years, paralleling how Germany was treated after WWI defeat, which produced thirst for revenge, nationalism, and desire for a 'strong leader.'
“Many people in Ukraine and in the West want to punish and isolate Russia. As I have said in my previous videos, this will only lead to a surge of nationalism, the emergence of a new Führer, and another war in 20 or 30 years. Humanity has already been through all this: this is exactly how Germany was treated in 1918, after its defeat in the First World War, and the result was a thirst for revenge, nationalism, and nostalgia for a 'strong leader.'”
In Russia, almost all taxes and fees flow to the center and are distributed from Moscow, giving Moscow and the federal government enormous power over the regions to appoint officials without considering local wishes, and making regions completely dependent on subsidies from the center.
“In Russia, almost all taxes and fees flow to the center and are distributed from there. That is why Moscow and the federal government have such enormous power over the regions. That is precisely why Moscow can appoint officials in the provinces without taking the wishes of the population into account at all. The locals have to obey, because without money, there will be nothing.”
The Russian parliament and legislative bodies of federal subjects are purely decorative institutions that pass any laws handed down from above with no ability to challenge anything, and dangerous candidates are not even allowed to reach elections.
“At the moment, the parliament in Russia, as well as the legislative bodies of the federal subjects, are purely decorative institutions. They are not independent political players. They pass any laws handed down from above and have no ability to challenge anything. And there is no one there to act as opposition anyway, because dangerous candidates are not even allowed to reach the elections.”
The goal of all media, education, and religious reforms is to guarantee free access to information and the exchange of opinions.
“The goal of all this is to guarantee free access to information and the exchange of opinions.”
The judiciary must be made independent with judges elected rather than appointed from above as they currently are, where judges are built into the privileged class.
“The judiciary must be independent: right now judges are appointed from above, and they are built into the privileged class. Judges should be elected.”
A democratic transition is the least likely scenario in the coming years because it requires more than people protesting—it requires institutions, legal politics, independent media, an elite group ready to negotiate, and a social consensus that the imperial war was a catastrophe, and almost none of this currently exists.
“Unfortunately, at the moment, a democratic transition is the least likely scenario in the coming years. A democratic transition requires more than people protesting. It requires institutions, legal politics, independent media, an elite group ready to negotiate, and a social consensus that the imperial war was a catastrophe. Right now, almost none of this exists.”
Subsidies in Russia support not only regional budgets but also entire industries including the military-industrial complex, auto industry, air travel, construction (through subsidized housing loans), and banking (through Central Bank support), and the state is the direct or indirect employer for the overwhelming majority of the population.
“Subsidies support not only the budgets of individual regions, but entire industries as well. For example, the military-industrial complex, the auto industry, air travel, and much else. There are also countless state programs without which whole sectors of the economy would simply collapse. For instance, the construction industry is heavily dependent on subsidized housing loans for the population. The banking sector would not survive without help from the Central Bank. The state is the employer and source of income for the overwhelming majority of the country's population — directly or indirectly.”
Authoritarian rule is the norm for humanity because our biological species has lived under autocratic rule for most of its existence; it is modeled on the patriarchal family where the father controls all property and life, with no external authority above him.
“Here, we should note that humanity has lived this way for most of its existence, because for our biological species, authoritarian rule is the norm. It is natural because it is modeled on the ordinary patriarchal family, where the head of the family controls all property and the lives of his relatives. His word is law. Nobody elected him. There is no authority above him. You can run away from him — and not always — or you can kill him and take his place. Those are the options.”
The FSB, Federal Service of Troops, Rosgvardia, and Federal Protective Service must be completely disbanded because these state structures bring Russia nothing but systematic harm.
“The FSB, the Federal Service of Troops, the Rosgvardia, and the Federal Protective Service must be completely disbanded. These state structures bring Russia nothing but systematic harm.”
Military reform is a separate enormous task because after many criminals were brought into the army during the Ukraine war, military culture has effectively fused with prison culture, resulting in monstrous corruption and extreme cruelty toward Russia's own soldiers, which would have to be rebuilt from scratch.
“After so many criminals were brought into the army during the war in Ukraine, military culture has effectively fused with prison culture. The war has produced monstrous corruption and extreme cruelty toward Russia's own soldiers. All of this would have to be rebuilt from scratch.”
Russia must build a new self-identity based on real achievements, creativity, and discoveries, not on the idea of imperial conquest.
“And most importantly, Russia must build a new self-identity, based on real achievements, creativity, and discoveries, not on the idea of imperial conquest.”
To reform Russia, the first step is to break the caste system by stripping the ruling elite of four key privileges: (1) the right to receive and distribute money from the state budget, (2) the right to appoint and remove top officials, (3) the right to control information, and (4) the right to use violence.
“To reform Russia, the first thing that needs to be broken is the caste system. The main privileges of Russia's highest caste are: A) the right to receive and distribute money from the state budget. B) the right to appoint and remove top officials. C) the right to control information — what people should know and what they should believe. D) the right to use violence.”
In a military defeat and army revolt scenario, military people usually do not know how to run a state, and if they seize power, the current elite will scatter, unknown successors will take over, wreck the remains, blame external/internal enemies, redistribute property in their favor, and trigger mass emigration that deteriorates the economy further.
“This situation is much more complicated. Military people usually do not know how to run a state. If they seize power, the current elite will instantly scatter in their business jets, and God knows who will take their place. They will wreck what remains, blame everything on external and internal enemies, redistribute property in their own favor, and trigger mass emigration, which would only make the economy deteriorate even faster.”
In a military takeover scenario, if a constructive military figure can be found for negotiations, there is hope for a positive outcome, but it is very possible there will be no one suitable to negotiate with, and authoritarianism will reassemble itself at a much lower level.
“If events unfold this way, it will be necessary to look for someone in the military with whom constructive negotiations are even possible. If such a person can be found, there is hope for a positive scenario. But it is very possible that there will be no one to choose from. Then authoritarianism will reassemble itself again, but at a much lower level.”
Censorship and internet restrictions must be abolished, all state media must be privatized, and state funding of media outlets must be banned so that the state cannot impose its will on journalists.
“The next essential element is the abolition of censorship and internet restrictions, the privatization of all state media, and a ban on state funding of media outlets, so that the state cannot impose its will on journalists.”
The task of the outside world is to support healthy forces inside Russia rather than punishing and isolating it.
“So the task of the outside world is to support healthy forces inside Russia.”
In authoritarian regimes, money is the most important thing, so financial reform is where reform must begin to break the system.
“How can this be done? The place to begin is financial reform, because in authoritarian regimes, money is the most important thing.”
Officials should not run the country's economic life or decide who gets to earn money and who does not—the goal of subsidy reform is to remove these economic gatekeeping privileges from officials.
“The goal is simple: officials should not run the country's economic life, and they should not decide who gets to earn money and who does not.”
Official budget distributors become 'masters of fate, almost celestial beings' because without their decisions about budget allocation, regions and individuals have nothing to live on, creating a power relationship where officials are functionally like gods.
“Naturally, in such a setup, the official who distributes the budget becomes a master of fate, almost a celestial being.”
State contracts and subsidies cannot be abolished all at once because Russian businesses have been trained to depend on the state rather than on end consumers, and the film industry example shows how state subsidies determine what gets produced rather than market demand.
“Under Putin, a large part of Russian business was trained to depend not on the end consumer but on the state. As a result, these businesses become uncompetitive because their money comes not from customers, but from officials. The film industry is a good example: it is almost entirely subsidized from the state budget. So what gets filmed, and how, is decided by officials, not producers. What the audience actually wants barely matters.”
Education must be decentralized with curricula developed and approved at the local level rather than by a single ministry, and teachers should not receive orders from the Ministry of Education under threat of dismissal.
“The decentralization of education is also essential. Right now, there is a single curriculum and a vertical chain of command that subordinates teachers to the Ministry of Education. Teachers receive orders from above and are forced to follow them under threat of dismissal. Curricula should be developed and approved at the local level.”
The Federal Penitentiary Service must be reformed so that the prison system stops crippling convicts and instead actually corrects them.
“The Federal Penitentiary Service must also be reformed, so that the prison system gets rid of practices that cripple convicts instead of correcting them.”
Most importantly, the president's power must be significantly limited and Russia must become a parliamentary republic where major questions are decided through debate and coalition-building rather than the will of one person; perhaps the presidency should be abolished entirely to remove the temptation for the next autocrat.
“And, most importantly, the president's power must be significantly limited. Russia must become a parliamentary republic, where all major questions are decided not by the will of one person but through debate, discussion, and the formation of coalitions. Perhaps the office of president should be abolished altogether, so there is no temptation for the next autocrat.”
Police should be funded and formed at the local level and subordinate to local authorities rather than having a vertical power structure with all top figures appointed in Moscow, as is currently the case.
“The police should be funded and formed at the local level and subordinate to local authorities. Right now, as everywhere else, there is a vertical power structure, and all top figures are appointed in Moscow.”
Universities must be made independent from state control, with university leadership appointed by boards of trustees rather than by the state, since currently they are funded by the state and leadership is appointed from above.
“Universities will also have to be made independent somehow. Right now, they are funded by the state, and therefore, university leadership is appointed from above, not by boards of trustees.”
No religion should receive state support, and the Russian Orthodox Church must not be financed from the state budget despite the fact that the absolute majority of Russians do not live a church life and do not want to go to church regularly; religion must be a free choice, not imposed on society.
“No religion should count on state support. Right now, the Russian Orthodox Church is practically financed from the state budget, despite the fact that the absolute majority of Russians do not live a church life and do not want to go to church regularly. Those who need the church should contribute to its needs. And religion certainly must not be imposed on society. It must be a free choice.”
There needs to be a mass information campaign explaining exactly how and by whom Russians were deceived, seduced, and coerced into the Ukraine war; how much it cost; what results it produced; why the deception worked; and identifying everyone who gave and carried out criminal orders leading to casualties and destruction.
“There needs to be a mass information campaign about what actually happened in Ukraine. People need to be told exactly how, and by whom, they were deceived, seduced, and coerced; how much it cost; and what results it produced. It is necessary to explain why the deception worked. It is necessary to identify everyone who gave and carried out criminal orders that led to human casualties and destruction.”
A window of opportunity for democracy to take root in Russia will eventually appear, though it is impossible to say when or how; Putin will eventually leave power one way or another, and when that moment comes, it will be crucial to help healthy forces inside Russia turn the wheel in the right direction.
“What the world needs is a window of opportunity for democracy to take root in Russia. That window will appear. It is impossible to say when or how, but Putin will eventually leave power one way or another. And when that moment comes, it will be crucial to help healthy forces inside Russia turn the wheel in the right direction.”
A palace coup scenario—where the upper caste realizes Putin's course will lead to military defeat and economic problems and removes him—will not actually save the economy, and requires careful attention to lessons from the 1980s-1990s when the West initially helped the USSR/Russia but then allowed authoritarianism to reassemble itself.
“A palace coup. The upper caste realizes that the course chosen by Putin will lead the country not only to military defeat, but also to serious economic problems. The president is removed, but in reality, this will not save the economy. It is very important to take into account the lessons of the 1980s and 1990s, when the West helped the USSR and then Russia, but ultimately let the situation drift and allowed authoritarianism to reassemble itself.”
Sanctions should only be lifted and financial aid provided on condition that meaningful reforms actually begin, and negotiators on the Russian side need incentives—they will lose their status as untouchable gods, so they must receive something in return, otherwise they will dig in their heels and bet on a North Korea-style isolated regime where they remain comfortable while the population pays the price.
“Sanctions should be lifted, and any financial aid provided, only on the condition that the reforms we discussed earlier actually begin. At the same time, the negotiators on the Russian side will need some kind of incentive. They will lose their status as untouchable gods, so they must receive something in return. Otherwise, they will dig in their heels and bet on a North Korea-style regime — one in which they personally remain comfortable while the rest of the population pays the price.”
Moscow would remain the center of power after fiscal decentralization because it is the largest and richest region, but it would no longer drain the life out of other regions, allowing other regions to develop independently.
“Moscow would still remain the center of everything, because it is the largest and richest region, but it would no longer be draining the life out of the other regions.”
Gubernatorial and mayoral elections must be restored, a mass of insane laws adopted since the early 2010s must be repealed, and the Ukrainian territories inserted into the Russian Constitution must be removed from it.
“Gubernatorial and mayoral elections must be restored. A mass of insane laws adopted since the early 2010s must be repealed, and the Ukrainian territories inserted into the Russian Constitution must be removed from it.”
The most likely scenario at the moment is inertia—Russia remains in a state of prolonged war without major political explosion, with the government continuing to tell the population 'we are suffering because we are fighting the West,' and the economy gradually becoming poorer with less private initiative, more military spending, more state dependence, and greater reliance on China, raw materials, and gray market schemes.
“So the most likely scenario at the moment is inertia. Russia remains in a state of prolonged war, but without a major political explosion. The government continues to sell society the same idea: 'We are suffering because we are fighting the West.' The economy does not collapse, but it gradually becomes poorer and worse: less private initiative, more military spending, more dependence on the state, China, raw materials, and gray schemes.”
Examples of dictators being driven by personal rivalries and the need for conquest are visible throughout history: the endless rivalries of European kings, the wars among the khans of the Golden Horde, and the conflicts between Chinese princes.
“Do you want examples? Just look at the endless rivalries of kings in Europe, the many khans of the Golden Horde, or the fights between Chinese princes.”
A revolution is not currently visible because everyone who could have carried it out has left the country, and Russia has a very low percentage of young people, so there is no one to wave flags on the barricades.
“A revolution is not really visible at the moment, because everyone who could have carried it out has left the country. In addition, Russia has a very low percentage of young people, so there is no one to wave flags on the barricades.”
You can sit on enormous natural wealth and still be terrifyingly poor, as in Africa, because the economy depends on geography and geography is what it is; natural resources alone mean nothing without institutions and infrastructure to extract and benefit from them.
“In such conditions, you can sit on enormous natural wealth and still be terrifyingly poor — as in Africa. There, too, the ground contains almost the entire periodic table, but that alone means nothing, because the economy depends on geography. And geography is what it is.”