
Neil Howe: The Fourth Turning Has Begun, How Will It Unfold?
What this covers
This is a replayed Wealthion interview in which Neil Howe, a demographer and the originator of generational theory, walks through where America sits in the saeculum, the roughly 80-to-90-year cycle of four turnings. Most of the first half is historical groundwork. Howe describes the Fourth Turning as a period when the old institutional order collapses and a new one replaces it. He argues that every total war in American history fell inside one. He also makes some contested claims about the past: Americans at the time experienced the Revolution largely as a civil war, and its real climax was the 1788 Constitutional Convention rather than Yorktown. He sets this against the American High after World War II, citing the unusually fast gains in Black earnings and home ownership between the late 1940s and early 1960s.
The generational material applies archetypes to the present. Howe says Boomers, as Prophets, are better at vision than pragmatic execution and are hard to organize. Gen X, as Nomads, is suited to the midlife command role, and he compares it to the generals Eisenhower, Omar Bradley and George Patton. He also contrasts how generations have handled leaving home, from Boomers to Gen X boomeranging to Millennials never leaving.
The second half turns to economics and politics. Howe describes a shift from neoliberalism to fiscal dominance, in which the Fed can buy any asset and monetize deficits. He points to Treasury yields sitting below inflation and to the 12.5 percent of GDP deficit of the pandemic years. He forecasts that the Fed will tolerate inflation as a way to cut debt-to-GDP and lower the Gini coefficient, as happened from 1940 to 1981. He expects Congress eventually to face allocating pain rather than benefits. The most contentious threads are his claims that democracy copes poorly with fundamental problems and that younger generations are losing faith in liberal democracy because material progress has stalled.
Neil Howe argues that America is entering a Fourth Turning—a generational crisis period comparable to the Civil War and WWII—that will require fundamental institutional restructuring, likely driven by inflation and political polarization, but will ultimately resolve into a prosperous new order dominated by Millennials in the 2030s.
- The Fourth Turning cycle repeats every 80-90 years with predictable generational archetypes and phases; America matches all markers of entering one now (2020s)
- Wealth inequality and lack of material progress for younger generations makes liberal democracy illegitimate in their eyes, driving demand for autocratic solutions and radical political change
- Monetary and fiscal stimulus will eventually cause inflation that the Fed will accommodate to solve inequality and reduce debt-to-GDP ratios, creating a regime shift similar to 1940-1981, after which a new institutional order emerges
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
During 2020-2021, the federal government used unprecedented state control: people and businesses became wards of the state, everything from loans to corporate operations became dependent on state allocation—nothing remotely close has happened in American history, and this precedent will not be forgotten; it rewrites the regime rules.
“I mean think about it for for uh most of the year in 2020 uh the state took our breathing I mean we all became words of the state right businesses households everyone I mean nothing remotely close to that has happened in American history now that example won't go away quickly you know what I mean people will remember that yeah you can do that right every window is dependent on the state even major corporations you know to to renew their turn over their loans I mean everything right”
Liberal democracy requires material progress to remain legitimate; when generational advancement stalls, citizens regress into reactionary social modes, seeking monopoly positions (economic 'moats') instead of competing innovatively, creating an incumbent economy that is uncompetitive and uninnovative.
“well that is a real crisis in America right we were founded on the premise of um of the American dream which meant generational advancement and older Generations experienced that right the GI generation experienced it's usually over their own parents the the silent generation experience that most Boomers particularly the early wave of Boomers you know the Al Gore Bill Clinton Boomers kind of born toward the earlier end did much better than their parents at age 30 or 40. but you start getting the lightweight Boomers kind of more your you know Madonna Michael Jackson cohorts born in the league late 50s and then going on into your exers they are not right so that kind of generational progress is completely stalled and I actually do believe this is an essential ingredient Ben Friedman wrote a classic book about this about 10 or 15 years ago uh liberal democracy requires progress it requires material progress if you do not have that then we start regressing into a reactionary social mode right everyone just wants to drop the moats right bring up the the draw Bridges and and we become truly that incumbent economy we talked about and everyone will like you know Warren Buffett will be talking about investing in something with big moats just make sure you have a position which some Monopoly Market position which can't be assailed and that becomes a very uncompetitive uninnovative Society right”
Younger generations (Millennials and Gen X) are increasingly disillusioned with liberal democracy because it has failed to deliver material progress and generational advancement; younger men and women are significantly under-earning their parents at ages 30-40, violating the core American promise of generational advancement.
“uh namely that liberal democracy no longer works for them I mean it's all biased toward older people now it's all biased toward marketing comments I mean let's face it right it's all piled up toward the silent and the Boomers today and this generation um you know rides Chetty at Harvard has some wonderful slides on this he just shows that by the time and actually not just Millennials but even most exers most of them are not out earning their parents at age 30 or 40 right and particularly males are actually under earning their parents by a significant extent at age 30 or 40.”
Inflation historically reduced inequality in America much more effectively than other policies; the period from 1940-1981 saw a dramatic decline in the Gini coefficient (reaching all-time lows in the late 1970s) because financial repression plus inflation killed creditors for 20 years while workers captured wage growth.
“and it brings down the genie coefficient it helps solves inequality and uh remember you know inflation takes away from creditors it gives to debtors when you look at the huge growing equality of that whole Great Depression World War II era right and particularly went through the American high right and huge decrease in inequality in America most it really didn't occur much during the 1930s interestingly enough it started right around 1940 and particularly in World War II and the Korean War and after that why Financial repression plus inflation the treasury yield was stuck right the fed and the treasury conspired to keep it stuck at no higher than about 2.25 2.5 maybe at the highest inflation was racing into the double digits and we had price controls we didn't we don't know really what inflation was actually doing but creditors were getting killed right for 20 years that was when inequality went down in America that's when the middle class came back”
African-American earnings as a share of white earnings and home ownership rates rose faster in the late 1940s-early 1960s than in any other period in American history, showing that the post-war high period was economically beneficial for minorities despite cultural issues.
“you know African-Americans uh you know earnings as a share of white earnings home ownership is a share of uh White ownership Rose faster in the late 40s 50s and early 60s and any other period in American history this was a um a really great era for a lot of things that worked well”
Boomers never wanted to leave home or boomerang when faced with recession in the 1982-83 era under Volcker; by contrast, Gen X started boomeranging in the 1990s, and Millennials never left home in the first place, indicating a profound shift in generational relationships with family and economic independence.
“Boomers did not Boomerang okay and I remember uh the the Great Recession of of uh 82 83 you know when you went into the Reagan Administration volcker was tightening rates and so on it was a really pretty bad recession Boomers that do anything rather than return they would like sleep under a bridge or something right but they would not go back home right that Boomerang stuff started with Gen xers in the 90s and with Millennials they don't return home they just never leave you know they just keep their bedroom there”
The 40-year bond bull market that began October 1980 with 10-year yields at 15.84% is ending; despite economic recovery and S&P 500 doubling in 3 years post-pandemic, bond yields have not risen as valuation models would predict, signaling a regime change where old financial rules no longer apply.
“we've had the the 40th anniversary of the of the you know Bond uh bull market right we we saw September 30th 1980 we had uh bonds 10-year yield at 15.8 something I think 15.84 what's going on with that at a time now when the economy is recovering the the S P 500 doubled I mean how do you see bonds so low Well turns out now they're not quite so low maybe they're maybe they're shifting in a slightly different direction now”
The American Revolution was experienced by most Americans at the time as a civil conflict (civil war) rather than a revolution against a foreign power, with significant internal dimensions including Patriot-Tory conflict and Backwoods Regulators supporting the British because they opposed the coastal plantation aristocracy.
“the American Revolution however is interesting for people to know that the American Revolution at the time was referred to by most more Americans as a civil conflict as a civil war rather than as a revolution it had a very strong element of patriot on Tory conflict within the United States particularly within the southern states the Backwoods Regulators actually supported the British because they hated these big plantation owners near the coast who were always lording it over them right in other words it exploited and the British at one point did what Abraham Lincoln did he promised freedom to the blacks and then one of the things the British couldn't understand as well these Planters were you know constantly talking about Liberty you know and and yet they had all these sites so the British said well we're going to use that as a weapon we're gonna we're gonna promise freedom to anyone who wants to help it's exactly what Abraham Lincoln did right with his Emancipation Proclamation about 80 90 years later”
Democracy only works well when the problems being solved are trivial; when fundamental problems arise, democracy becomes dysfunctional because groups with mutually exclusive visions of the future cannot yield to each other, and totalitarian governments can implement drastic measures more effectively.
“and here's the irony and this has been pointed out by some you know brilliant uh Carl Becker pointed that out in 1940 just as we were going into World War II he said one of the problems with democracy does democracy only works really well when the problems you're trying to solve are pretty trivial all right yeah I mean think about it if it's a fundamental problem how does democracy work right and I think covid may have even sort of reinforced that argument where you looked at some of the more totalitarian governments and we can say whether it's right or wrong but they certainly took measures to clamp down uh and and really stop the virus spreading its tracks in a way that a democracy just couldn't”
America and the West are entering a Fourth Turning—a major crisis period comparable to the American Revolution, Civil War, and World War II—that occurs roughly every 80 to 90 years and involves the collapse of the existing institutional order and its replacement with a new one.
“Neil Howe coined that term years ago to describe the tumult and unwinding that occurs at major turning points in society when the status quo starts failing ultimately to be replaced by a new order think the American Revolution the Civil War and World War II”
The federal deficit reached nearly 5 percent of GDP in 2019 (a record for a non-recession year) under Trump, then jumped to 12.5 percent of GDP in the following two years, representing a 5.5 percentage point additional kicker that drove real disposable personal income up 7 percent while real GDP declined nearly 3 percent—a 10 percentage point gap unprecedented in modern recessions.
“we went into the recession by the way already under Trump at a uh Federal deficit of nearly five percent of GDP that was already a a record for a non-recession year before the pandemic we were 4.8 percent of GDP um and you know everyone was fine with that uh uh uh Jerome Powell is fine with that you know Donald Trump is obviously fine with that and then the next two years are at 12.5 percent of GDP right so that was an extra five and a half percent of GDP kicker in two years well that translates into about 10 of of DPI right disposable personal income so that's how you get there right this changes the rules of the regime”
Long-term Treasury yields are now several percentage points below CPI (Consumer Price Index) and 90 basis points below what bondholders themselves expect long-term inflation to be, and junk bond yields are below CPI—a situation where the only way to rectify this imbalance is through inflation.
“we have now uh long-term treasury yields which are not only several percentage points below the CPI or the pce but 90 basis points below even what bondholders themselves expect long-term inflation to be crazy junk bond yields below the CPI exactly exactly yeah well exactly you know high risk end so what that means is that the only way this can be rectified ultimately going down the road and it will you know it all depends the speed at which this happens depends a bit a little bit on Congress but it would be inflation and inflation expectations”
American society is currently experiencing high political polarization with Red Zone and Blue Zone populations barely communicating, and mutually exclusive visions of the country's future, raising fundamental questions about whether democracy can function when populations hold incompatible values.
“it's no be no surprise today and looking in America that people are going to say yeah I get the internal component right now right Red Zone versus Blue Zone I mean my God the two sides don't even talk to each other you know I live in DC I mean I've been sort of a DC guy uh they don't even talk to each other now I mean there's literally practically no communication there's nothing to say at this point Adam you know right so when you have mutually exclusive ideas of what the country's future is how does democracy work right”
Political participation and engagement have risen dramatically since the 2008 financial crisis; whereas in the Clinton and GW Bush eras voters saw politics as irrelevant, now investors and citizens cannot ignore Congress and presidential politics because policy directly impacts markets and life outcomes.
“you know the political participation is hugely risen right everyone knows that politics is really important now I think that's a real difference between the 1990s you know the Clinton era and the GW Bush era when everyone just tuned out on politics you know none of it matters uh investors don't have to care about what Congress is doing or or the president is doing I'm telling you Adam now they gotta care because what's coming out of Washington not just the FED I mean that you know the markets have always said you know never fight the FED right so that has always been taken for granted uh but now it's Congress now it's going to be presidential elections now it's going to be fundamental issues of of power top-down change that could come very quickly”
Fourth Turnings in American history have consistently featured total war—and all total wars in American history have occurred during fourth turnings—creating a pattern where public urgency and collective action are the defining features of crisis resolution.
“I mean just mentioning you know you said where might this lead every fourth turning in American history has featured a total war um and all total words in American history have come in a fourth term right who you want to think about that you know and this goes all the way back to the anglo-american succulum you know going back in the early modern era you know into British history but this is a pattern now sometimes it's um it's so it it's we don't say that war is necessary prayer forth turning but that sense of total public urgency and the need to band together and create a new sense of community is always required at some point before the fourth turning is over”
When rates rise and the government faces unsustainable debt service, fiscal policy will no longer be able to stimulate because Congress will be forced to choose between raising taxes or cutting benefits—shifting from allocating 'pleasures' to allocating 'pain,' which will make political struggle much more difficult and contentious than the current era of benefit expansion.
“by the way at that point the the federal government's gonna have to say no we either have to raise taxes or cut benefits this is not going to be any longer a game of handing out Pleasures could be a game of allocating pain that's by the way going to make the political struggle much more difficult it's been very easy in the past two years to handle the blue and red conflicts when all you're looking at is passing out different tax cuts or benefits right to groups wait until we have to do the reverse all right”
The American Revolution's real climax was arguably the Constitutional Convention of 1788 and the forging of a powerful central government—what Howe calls the 'miracle of 1788'—which was even more significant than the military victory at Yorktown in 1781, because it represents the institutional renewal that defines a Fourth Turning's resolution.
“but then again we were in chaos after that right and then we had to actually Forge a new Constitution and in some ways that was the real climax of the era as being able to actually then agree on a powerful central government and to some extent I would say that there was the miracle of of 1788 which is even more amazing than the miracle of uh you know 1781 which is the the defeating of uh of uh you know Clinton and Courtney Wallace”
A fundamental problem of Fourth Turnings is that institutions fail to supply enough order just as the public (especially younger generations) begins to sense that institutions aren't supplying adequate order, creating a context for crisis and demand for authoritarian solutions.
“the fundamental problem in an Awakening is that the public senses that institutions are supplying too much order but the fundamental problem of a crisis the fourth turning is it the public be particularly the younger public begins to sense that institutions aren't supplying enough order and that is always the context for a crisis right”
Gen X (Nomad archetype) is ideally suited for the midlife command role in the fourth turning—getting things done pragmatically—just as the Lost Generation was perfectly suited to the role of two-star and three-star generals in World War II (Omar Bradley, Dwight Eisenhower, George Patton).
“Generation X who will be of the age of um of George Patton or Ulysses Grant or George Washington they will be the midlife commanders the leaders right they will be the ones who actually are most responsible for actually getting things done right it won't be the big picture generation I mean good God knows right Gen X her attitude toward that is you know die Yuppie scum you know so Gen X is a beginning step done and they're actually very well suited to that role you know just as um The Lost Generation turned out to be perfectly suited to the role of the midlife uh you know two-star three-star Generals in World War II right the likes of Omar Bradley or Dwight Eisenhower or even George Patton uh talking about a real nomad that kind of but but these were guys who were get it done you know tough talking no-nonsense the doers uh and uh generally tended to be taciturn or kind of electronic in their personal they just you know focused on the bottom line getting stuff done”
Boomers are poorly equipped to lead through a fourth turning crisis because their generational archetype (Prophet) emphasizes big-picture vision rather than pragmatic execution; they are individualistic and resistant to authority (epitomized by the phrase 'herding cats'), making them unsuited for the consensus-building and collective action required in a crisis.
“what happens is is that it does does happen but it doesn't happen in a necessarily very pretty way a very easy way but I think what does happen is that each generation ultimately when a crisis works out well each generation in its phase of life actually contribute something essential to the resolution of the fourth turning and that is what what the profit archetype contributes is that sense of vision right the big picture right... and Boomers will be talking about you know and the the New Age of Aquarius I mean you know and you only imagine how Boomers would be but anyway Boomers would in the new fourth train we actually call this the role of the so-called gray Champion you know it comes back again in history the Elder leader who reminds people of the larger picture right Generation X who will be of the age of um of George Patton or Ulysses Grant or George Washington they will be the midlife commanders the leaders right they will be the ones who actually are most responsible for actually getting things done right it won't be the big picture generation I mean good God knows right Gen X her attitude toward that is you know die Yuppie scum”
Fiscal policy will become unable to neutralize monetary tightening because the Congressional Budget Office projects that nominal yields will remain below nominal GDP growth until 2038, meaning deficit projections depend critically on low interest rate assumptions; once yields rise, deficits will balloon from ~104 percent of GDP to 250-350 percent, triggering runs on the dollar.
“this is what scares me Adam is that in this coming era once you get those expectations of yields going way up particularly in the out years Congress won't be able to do that you know why because never before in history have the deficit projections dependent so critically on low interest rate assumptions I I go every every year I go over the the cbo's long-term budget projections right and then they're now projecting that nominal yields will be beneath nominal GDP growth all the way until 2038. think about that so this is how they get to borrow all that amount during the 2020s early 2030s without the GDP you know debt to GDP ratio growing because they just assume that we're going to have these extraordinarily low interest rates now once that assumption changes instead of rising from where it is now you know we're about what 103 104 of GDP in terms of publicly held federal debt instead of rising to make 150 percent or something that's already unsustainable we'll be talking about 250 300 350 at that point”
The Fed will likely accommodate moderate inflation (2-4 percent or even higher, possibly introducing price controls like in the Korean War and WWII) to solve three major problems: keeping the economy hot with low unemployment, reducing the debt-to-GDP ratio through inflation, and decreasing the Gini coefficient (inequality).
“I actually I think that even though we're going to have to tighten because we can't let inflation get out of control I mean obviously the FED is gonna have to be with instead of underneath price expectations it is going to go above it right and that's going to be the big revolution right but nonetheless I do think that the FED is going to accommodate as much inflation as it can while just making sure it doesn't accelerate and I'll tell you why they will do that because inflation will actually bring a solution to two three big problems right first of all it will help the economy run hot right and that's what the FED wants that's what everyone wants we want unemployment to be down the lowest possible number so we're going to let you know wage in price inflation go on maybe go gradually go up to two four three percent four percent five for even higher and finally maybe we'll put on price controls like we did during the Korean War particularly World War II”
Boomers had severe conflicts with their GI generation parents over cultural issues (sex, drugs, rock and roll) whereas Millennials and Boomers have much better personal relationships, creating a structural inversion: Boomers had cultural conflict but agreed with GI's governance approach; Millennials have personal harmony but fundamentally critique Boomer governance failures.
“here's where though it inverts Adam and that is that even though Millennia is going on personally very well with their parents and and Boomers did not I mean actually a good example of that would be boomeranging back home Boomers did not Boomerang... where I think there's a little bit of inversion because when it came to actually major structural substantive reforms and how the system worked and how it actually you know allocated income and rewards and how we actually built for our future Puma's had no problem with the gis were doing I mean they obviously ran things really well in fact the whole problem with the GI Generations they ran things too well they invested too much right it's too much repression you know we didn't enjoy ourselves more for today the millennial problem with Boomers is just the opposite right Boomers can't run anything they can't exercise Authority they can't invest in anything they can't do anything for the long term”
The fourth turning regime shift reverses the neoliberal trends of 1981-2021; we are now entering the gestation of a return to 1940-1981 conditions of higher inflation, more government intervention, stronger unions, higher minimum wages, and reduced inequality—a positive transformation on balance.
“and it is fair to say that you see us returning back you like reversing those trends of the past 1984. he's in the tea leaves I mean you just see it right you see the gestation of it right now and I I do think that that's where we're moving and I think some if you look at it really broadly Adam you kind of think yeah that's probably not all that bad for the country in a sense uh you know it's it's a very different world uh but it may not be bad in its overall impact right what kind of society we come out with on the other side I mean let's face it you know the 1950s and 1960s weren't the worst period you know of of American History uh there's a lot to a lot happened that actually worked uh and as I often point out it did a lot to improve uh the condition of minorities in America”
Boomers will not disappear during the Fourth Turning but will serve as 'Gray Champions'—elder leaders providing vision and big-picture purpose while Gen X and Millennials handle execution, with this multigenerational collaboration essential to successful crisis resolution.
“Boomers would in the new fourth train we actually call this the role of the so-called gray Champion you know it comes back again in history the Elder leader who reminds people of the larger picture right”
A regime shift from neoliberalism to MMT-like policy has occurred: the Fed used to buy and sell only the short end of the yield curve and keep rates steady over the business cycle while the federal government kept the budget balanced; now the Fed can buy any asset at any maturity, flatten the entire yield curve, pursue high-risk credit, and the federal government can cut taxes or expand benefits with the Fed monetizing the difference.
“we're changing regimes now we're going from an old regime which we we call the announcer the neoliberal regime the FED just you know buys and sells the short end influence interest rates over the business cycle and the federal government keeps the budget reasonably balanced because they can't expect the FED to bail that out right and then you know a little bit maybe uh in a crisis the FED will offer credit at penalty rates kind of the old budget rule in the new regime which you could call the mmt regime right well what what what what is it now the FED can by any asset at any maturity it can flatten the entire year curve down it can also go after high risk credit it can do anything it wants and the federal government can basically cut taxes or expand benefits any way it wants to in the FED will just monetize right monetize the difference”
Millennials (Hero archetype) are characterized by community-mindedness, cooperation, risk aversion, closeness to family, and openness to authority—traits historically associated with generational archetypes that come of age during crises and play essential roles in rebuilding and establishing the new order in their young-adult years.
“we noticed very different traits about Millennials right this new emphasis on community uh niceness on risk aversion closeness to family uh interestingly these are also traits we've seen in what we call the heroicetype in history who eventually comes of age during the crisis and as young adults plays a very important part in rebuilding right the order before they have moved on to midlife right so that so this this this project starts before they enter you know their before most of them enter their mid-40s so they are the ones who really participate collectively and sort of the establishment of the New Order”
The only remaining leaders with direct adult experience of World War II and the Great Depression are the late wave of the Silent generation (Nancy Pelosi, Joe Biden, Bernie Sanders), who remember these crises only as tiny children or babies; the Greatest Generation is mostly gone or in their 90s, leaving almost no one with real crisis-handling competence.
“the only person we have left the very eldest of our leaders now and they're still around Nancy Pelosi and Joe Biden and and uh you know uh uh uh Jamie Bernie Sanders a bunch of them are kind of late wave silent right they actually remember World War II as kids but as kids as Tiny kids you know maybe as babies right but the greatest generation is gone right I mean it's now in its 90s uh it's mostly gone we only have a few million left uh and uh they are the last ones who actually have any really degree of competence”
Traditional valuation metrics (Shiller PE, earnings-to-sales ratios) have been screaming 'sell' for the past half-decade but would have killed investors who actually sold, because the regime change makes valuation operate on a big delay and indirectly—it still matters but works differently under the new MMT-like policy regime.
“why do the old rules don't work why do the all those all those valuation rules we know that we talked about like like you know Schiller's PE you know uh uh you know earnings to sales ratios or or um right for the past half decade yeah so they've all you know they're they're off the charts they've all been screaming sell but if you had sold recently you would have been killed right so I this is a really important question for investors why are all these rules not working and I would submit that we're changing regimes now”
The fourth turning is extending slightly longer than historical pattern because the life cycle of generations has slowed down—young people are becoming adults later, Gen X is slow in rising to midlife power positions (oldest Gen Xers are hitting 60 with very little political or corporate visibility), and Boomers are still dominating institutions.
“the slowing down of the life cycle a little bit you know uh uh young people are a little bit older now when they actually become adults now they take all their courses in adulting yeah and then they become adults a little later uh gen xers are now very late in coming to real positions of midlife power they're still almost invisible in politics amazingly enough you know the oldest gen xers are already uh you know it you know at least by my Reckoning are hitting age 60. uh where we you know we had one 1960 born president uh I should say 1961 born President Barack Obama but we haven't really seen much from that generation uh at all uh they seem even in Congressional politics they're not terribly visible they're not even in the presidential primaries so they have been slow even in the corporate c-suite Gen X has been slow uh Boomer is still dominate”
About one-third of all Treasury debt is held by foreign creditors (sovereign wealth funds), so inflation will transfer the cost onto foreign creditors, with Americans having to negotiate new credit arrangements with those countries later—a form of shifting economic pain abroad and putting 'America First.'
“I didn't add one more benefit of inflation right about a third of all creditors to treasury debt our foreigners they're Sovereign wealth right so we push the cost onto them yeah exactly America first I mean have you heard of that I mean come on this works and you know they'll have no choice to come back to us later on you know for the new monetary system presumably if America's still strong and still around it's a little bit like uh like uh you know Argentina they can always come back you know and re-establish credit but but you understand my point these are solutions these are not bugs these are features of inflation”
Populist movements are now running both political parties: progressives/Democrats are pushing 'super infrastructure packages' and social programs, while populists on the right are also pushing anti-establishment agendas, and both movements share pro-inflationary policies that reorient rewards away from 'the haves' toward 'the have-nots.'
“I do find it very interesting that both parties are kind of drifting to their tour their populist fringes right see the populist really running the show now uh in among the Democrats pushing through their enormous new you know super you know quote-unquote infrastructure package the social infrastructure package as they call it um uh and then you see on the on the on the Red Zone you know popular is also running the show but you think about all the things that have in common right uh I think they're both pro-inflationary I think they're both um uh uh populist in the sense of wanting to upset the you know reorient the system away from the haves that they have nots”
The seasons of history are necessary—every season including the fourth turning is required for renewal and creative destruction; the destruction of old institutions in a fourth turning is essential to rejuvenate systems and allow them to grow again.
“the seasons are an interesting way of looking at history uh every season is necessary uh it is not like there's some Seasons that are just decline no that some things are getting worse some things are getting better it's the balance between them every season and necessary and frankly even the fourth turning when a lot of old institutions are destroyed that's necessary to rejuvenate us right to rejuvenate our institutions to make them young again so they're able to grow again right you need to do occasionally some creative destruction not just in the private sector right but in our public life uh and start over again and and do something new something uh something big”
The Fourth Turning requires thinking beyond today's narrow ideological frames and adopting a broader social, cultural, and historical perspective to recognize potential positives emerging from the crisis, including the possibility of bigger thinking about the future and renewed national inspiration.
“I think it's very often the hardest thing for people to do is to broaden their approach right get out of today's ideological you know narrow ideological frame and see it from a broader social and cultural point of view with a broader sense of history and say you know on balance you can really see some positives coming out of here right and and even positives about where we are today um the seasons are an interesting way of looking at history uh every season is necessary uh it is not like there's some Seasons that are just decline no that some things are getting worse some things are getting better”
The most likely outcome of the current Fourth Turning is not systemic breakdown or 'Lord of the Flies' collapse, but a different society with challenges but also positives—similar to the transition from Depression/WWII to the 1950s-60s American High with its period of peace, prosperity, planning, and security.
“the Lord of the Flies world is is I mean we have seen breaks in history where that has happened but I I absolutely don't think that's at all remotely the most likely scenario yeah I think you you want to be aware of that but I think most likely what's going to happen is going to be different and you hope it's different in a in a positive way”
The Federal Reserve will eventually have to reverse quantitative easing to quantitative tightening and raise the front end of the yield curve, which will cause the back end (long-term Treasury yields) to rise, deflating debt pyramids, collapsing buyback schemes, and undermining equity valuations through both higher discount rates and the deleveraging of high-risk investors.
“the FED has to change course and even the mmt theorists agree yeah once you get you know accelerating inflation you have to stop the whole credit creation Factory right so the FED is going to have to start you know reversing quantitative easing to quantitative tightening it's going to have to then start raising the front end and then of course the back end will rise as as as bond yields rise but but then what's going to happen is that's gonna not only will you have a higher discount rate to pull down the valuations and equities but also it will tend to deflate and make collapse all the debt pyramids which underlie a lot of the investing inequities right so all those buybacks all those borrowed to invest schemes or everyone has oh that's going to be you know going right particularly at the high risk at starting at the high risk end”
The coming first turning (the new institutional era starting in the 2030s after the fourth turning resolves) will be dominated by Millennials, creating a 'millennial-run world' very different from the current Boomer and Silent-dominated era.
“will that be the new golden age right after the crisis you know typically you get suddenly the sense of rebirth you know this new era of peace and prosperity and planning and security and when everyone feels great about the world in the future again what will that look like it'll be a millennial run World Adam I don't know whether you're ready for that”
Nothing is predetermined in history—only in 'its most general way'—and contingency and choice matter; the current fourth turning is recognizable by its polarization, institutional dysfunction, and experimentation with radical alternatives, but specific outcomes depend on decisions made in real time.
“no history is pre-scripted only in its most General way right and so a lot that happens which is individual and problematic and makes you think about contingency and choice and right I mean how you know uh nothing is predetermined uh nothing is written we always have choices and I do think it's very interesting this this this fourth turning that we're in um I think is definitely recognizable as a fourth turning I mean the the polarization the division of America into these two halves the the complete you know loss of functionality of central institutions uh is just sort of obvious”
Bill Clinton's statement 'the era of big government is over' and Tony Blair's Third Way neoliberalism represented the ideological consensus of the third turning, where even left-wing parties accepted deregulation and market solutions.
“and you remember even Bill Clinton uh the head of the democratic party the era of big government is over right so just a capitulation across the board and we saw this by the way in Britain with Tony Blair we said we saw that with this home you know uh kind of neoliberalism as a mechanical sort of the the Third Way that all of these uh Social Democratic parties were taking around the world right acknowledging markets right yeah I guess it is okay we just opened everything up you don't have to regulate anything anymore”
The first turning (post-crisis era, like the American High of 1946-1964 under Truman and Eisenhower) is characterized by high supply of and high demand for social order, with people willing to submit to strong institutions, low social disorder, high collective confidence, and cultural discipline.
“there is the Turning of the of the post-crisis ERA this is we call that the first turning and and we also call it a high like the American High you remember after World War II this would be the presidencies of of Truman and Eisenhower and John Kennedy a period of great Collective confidence um not much individuality not much a lot of cultural creativity but America felt like it was more than the sum of its parts uh social disorder was certainly at a very low ebb during that time in general I mean record low you know crime rates for example murder rates”
The second turning (Awakening era, like the 1960s-70s consciousness revolution) is characterized by rising demand for freedom and individual authenticity, declining demand for institutional order, cultural rebellion, fragmentation of social consensus, and the rise of the Prophet generation archetype (Boomers) who embody this idealism and self-discovery.
“the second turning was the Consciousness Revolution anyone who remembers the late 60s and 70s a lot of experts out there in the audience remember that it's kids so they remember that family breakup and you know Judy Bloom books and you just tell them all the chaos and dysfunction of that era and that was typical that's typical of an Awakening era now this is a time of rampant idealism reform utopianism self-discovery the whole emphasis now on self right and a certain individ new individualism breaks out a new kind of fragmenting of the old social consensus”
During the third turning (1984-2008), 'nothing really happened' publicly in America aside from the Soviet Union collapse; despite 9/11, no permanent imprint was made on the American political system or consciousness, reflecting the era's low institutional power and low demand for order.
“and that was a period in which public history nothing seemed to change right I mean nothing really happened publicly I mean aside from the very beginning it really didn't happen in America the the follow the Soviet Union right um and we had 911 which turned out to not have a hugely permanent imprint”