What this covers

Keith Hennessey, a former Senate budget staffer, joins Russ Roberts to examine the mechanics of the debt ceiling and the congressional budget process during the summer 2011 standoff. The conversation operates at two levels: the technical and the political. Hennessey walks through how Treasury actually manages cash flow, how Congress structures spending authority, and what the August 2nd deadline truly constrains—and where it remains flexible. Roberts and Hennessey also trace the power structure in Congress: who controls votes, how information flows through the whip system, and why three people—the Speaker, the Senate Majority Leader, and the Senate Minority Leader—ultimately decide outcomes regardless of the president's position.

The substance hinges on Hennessey's central claim: that fears of literal default are overstated because the administration would deploy less catastrophic alternatives (delaying state reimbursements, for instance) before failing to pay bondholders, making the deadline more mushy than the political theater suggests. From there, the discussion branches into how baseline accounting distorts the meaning of "spending cuts"—a claimed $2 trillion reduction from a projected baseline can still represent an increase from current spending—and how both sides of the budget debate exploit different comparison points to describe identical numbers oppositely. Hennessey examines Iraq and Afghanistan war spending as the biggest accounting gimmick, since cuts measured from an inflated baseline of assumed continued war spending are partly illusory. The conversation also covers the McConnell proposal to transfer authority to the president and closes with Hennessey's assessment of which negotiating paths are most likely to survive congressional process and recess.

Sharpest takeaway

Hennessey argues that the August 2nd 'default' deadline is a softer, more manageable deadline than commonly portrayed, that talk of literal default is irresponsible because the administration would always prioritize debt payments, and that claimed 'spending cuts' must be scrutinized against baseline accounting gimmicks.

  • Treasury has debt-management and cash-management tools that make the debt limit a 'mushy' deadline unlike a hard government shutdown
  • The administration would delay payments to states or seniors before ever defaulting on Treasury debt obligations
  • Claimed spending cuts depend entirely on the chosen baseline (current law vs current policy, and assumed Iraq/Afghanistan drawdowns)

The claims · ranked26 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.86

Discretionary (annually appropriated) spending defaults to zero if Congress fails to act, while mandatory spending (entitlements) defaults to continuation by formula; the distinction is an artificial, manufactured artifact of how laws are written, since Congress retains discretion to change entitlement programs at any time.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Keith Hennessey

“this is it's an artificial distinction... it's a manufactured artifact of the way the laws have been written but you're right annual appropriations if Congress and the president do not act no money is spent mandatory spending programs almost all of which are entitlements tend to be determined by formula”

0.86

Whether a tax proposal is described as a 'tax cut' or 'tax increase' depends on whether it is compared to current law (Bush rates expiring Jan 1 2013, higher revenue baseline) or current policy (existing lower rates); both sides agree on actual revenue collected but describe the same proposal oppositely because of different comparison points.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Keith Hennessey

“if you compare it to current law you are comparing it to an area where the government a situation where the government is collecting a whole lot more money... If you're comparing it to current policy then you're starting from a much lower level... one person will say it's a tax cut relative to current law another will say it's a tax increase apparent policy”

0.81

On the expenditure side, the biggest baseline gimmick to watch for is Iraq and Afghanistan war spending: if cuts are measured from a baseline that assumes continued high war spending years out (which everybody knows won't happen), then much of the claimed savings is mythical because that money was never going to be spent.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Keith Hennessey

“the danger is is that some of that say two trillion dollars in spending cuts maybe mythical because you never really were gonna spend that money anyway because everybody knows that you plan to pull out of Iraq and Afghanistan”

0.81

The CBO's revision of a claimed $38 billion cut down to $350 million was not a gimmick but a misunderstanding of cash flow timing: when budget authority is cut, the actual cash reduction may occur mostly in future years (like a multi-year aircraft carrier build) rather than in the current year.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Keith Hennessey

“What happened with that 38 billion dollars as they said you have decided to cut 38 billion dollars but the cash that's being reduced is going to be reduced mostly in future years”

0.81

Treasury has declared debt suspension periods (already used by Geithner and his predecessors) where it withholds scheduled cash payments into the civil service retirement fund and credits them later, which is bad policy but legal until lawyers say it stretches the legal bounds too far.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Keith Hennessey

“they've declared a debt suspension period where they've said we're not going to credit we're not going to put that cash into the civil service retirement fund into it later”

0.81

The debt limit is a 'mushier' deadline than a government shutdown for two reasons: cash inflows and outflows are uncertain projections, and Treasury has debt-management tools (ranked from least-worst to most-worst policy) that it can deploy to postpone hitting the limit.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Keith Hennessey

“The debt limit is a mushy er deadline for two reasons one is the reason you describe which is you're making projections about the cash coming in and the cash going out the other is that Treasury has certain tools that it can use to manage its debt”

0.81

Ultimately three people decide the outcome—Speaker Boehner (controls House floor), Senate Majority Leader Reid (controls Senate floor), and Senate Minority Leader McConnell (can threaten filibuster)—notably not the president; the final outcome depends not on which option is best but on which can actually get the votes to pass.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Keith Hennessey

“it's three people who really matter... the speaker because he decides what comes to the House floor the Senate majority leader... and the Senate Minority Leader Senator McConnell because he can decide whether or not to let Reid do what we can tell Buster”

0.79

Successful budget deals negotiate not just numbers but the processes, order of events, and rules governing implementation, often spelled out in a public contract (like the 1997 agreement among Clinton, Gingrich, and Lott) to constrain the parties from reneging, because reneging on your word carries a huge cost on Capitol Hill.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Keith Hennessey

“the deal includes not just numbers but agreement on processes yeah on an order of events and on the rules that will govern those events”

0.79

Information in Congress flows through the whip system: the whip (e.g., Kevin McCarthy) and his team of member-lieutenants are each assigned 10-20 members to count votes and round up support, serving as both an intelligence network and a vote-marshaling apparatus, with much communication happening during the brief 15-20 minute voting windows on the floor.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Keith Hennessey

“the whips job is to round up the votes and to count the votes he is both the intelligence agent to know what's going on among those... House Republicans and it's also his job to try to get them to vote as a group”

0.78

Claimed spending cuts are misleading because they depend on the chosen baseline: a $2 trillion cut from the president's proposed $46 trillion (averaging $4.6T/yr) over ten years still leaves average spending at $4.4T/yr—an increase from the current ~$3.5T level—so it is really an increase dressed up as a cut, like a store marking up a price 50% then advertising 20% off.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Russ Roberts

“any Smart Shopper who goes into a slightly shady store and sees the sign that says 20 percent off... might say yeah but did you mark up the price at 50 percent and then knock 20 percent off”

0.76

The McConnell proposal transfers the authority to raise the debt limit from Congress to the president (in three chunks totaling ~$2 trillion through early 2013), with Congress reserving only the power to override; it is constitutional, modeled on the Congressional Review Act for regulations, and requires the president to propose spending cuts at least as large as each debt limit increase.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Keith Hennessey

“Congress would give the authority to raise the debt limit to the president they'd say mr. president for the next two years you can raise the debt limit in the following amounts and on the following schedule and we will reserve to ourselves only the power to override it”

0.75

The August 2nd deadline matters because Treasury projects it will not have sufficient cash both to pay interest and principal on debt obligations AND to make all other scheduled payments (benefits, state reimbursements, contractors), but 'default' technically refers only to failing to pay debt obligations to lenders.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Keith Hennessey

“default is a technical term that means not pay our debt obligations to those out there in the rest of the world from whom we've borrowed money”

0.75

The normal budget process (since 1974) is: president submits a non-binding budget proposal in February; the House and Senate each pass a budget resolution (a Congress-only blueprint, not signed by the president); they reconcile in conference; the resulting total is handed to the Appropriations Committee which divides it into 12 appropriations bills that must each pass both chambers and be signed.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Keith Hennessey

“the normal process is the president submits his budget in February... then the Congress first works on what's called the budget resolution the budget resolution is like a blueprint for a house”

0.73

Default is unlikely for two reasons: (1) if forced to choose between literal default and other bad policies like delaying reimbursements to states, the administration would always choose the non-default option; and (2) congressional leaders cannot politically afford to go on recess with this uncertainty hanging over markets, so they will stay until they reach at least a temporary solution.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Keith Hennessey

“there so there are two reasons why I don't actually worried about default okay one is that if Treasury and OMB if the administration ever did get put in the situation where they had to choose between default and some other bad policy... they would delay reimbursements to States”

0.73

The president's budget proposal carries almost no legal force—it is merely a proposal, and even a private citizen's budget would have nearly the same legal weight, because the power of the purse (to spend and tax) belongs to Congress.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Keith Hennessey

“you could put together your budget and submit it to Congress if you want it it would have almost the same legal force it is a proposal”

0.70

The current budget process, which began in 1974, may itself be unhealthy: the US government started running deficits systematically right around 1974, which though possibly coincidental suggests the process itself may not be a healthy one.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Russ Roberts

“start 1974 the US government started running deficits pretty pretty systematically suggesting it could be coincidence of course but it could be that the very process itself is not a healthy price”

0.69

It is irresponsible for the administration to threaten default on interest and principal, because the administration would never actually do so; threatening to shock financial markets when you know you would instead slow payments to states amounts to telling markets you might stick it to them when you wouldn't.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Keith Hennessey

“if you know that the alternative really bad scenario is slowing down payments to States or something other than shocking the financial markets you shouldn't go out there and tell the financial markets that you might stick it to them”

0.64

An early August deadline is useful as a forcing mechanism to compel hard fiscal choices, so even though the threats and debt-management maneuvers are distasteful, the overall goal of creating a deadline to force decisions is worth supporting.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Keith Hennessey

“I think it's useful to have that forcing mechanism absolutely and so all of the things that they're doing... those to me are all less important because I actually support the overall goal of let's create a deadline to try to force these hard choices to be made”

0.63

Republicans may actually deliver real spending cuts this time because their brand has been so degraded by past failures and the growth in government under their watch when they controlled the House, Senate, and presidency.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Russ Roberts

“there's a chance they'll actually do something because the brand name has been so degraded by past failures and growth in government under their watch when they had control the House Senate and the presidency”

0.50

The most likely outcomes are either a McConnell-style path (negotiations fail, McConnell proposal with some spending cuts passes the Senate bipartisanly then squeaks through a divided House before recess) or the Krauthammer short-term path (House initiates a ~$500B debt limit increase tied to $500B in cuts, daring the Senate to stop it); the president's stated refusal to sign a short-term increase is a bluff.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 1/4· Keith Hennessey

“I can see two paths that look fairly likely to me one is the McConnell path... the other obvious option out there is the one that Charles Krauthammer has scribe”

0.49

Members of Congress are good at rationalizing technical compliance with deals while undermining their spirit, saying 'technically I complied.'

factualestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Keith Hennessey

“members are also very good at rationalized in saying well technically I complied”

0.43

If none of the substantive options get done before the scheduled recess, Congress will not actually recess but will instead delay recess and pass a one- or two-week clean debt limit extension, continuing to negotiate week by week through August rather than allowing default.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 1/4· Keith Hennessey

“I think what happens is they delay the start of recess and they pass a one-week clean debt limit extension 200 billion dollars whatever it takes to go a week or two”

0.40

Failure to raise the debt ceiling in a responsible way, even short of a technical default, sends a signal to the world that the US is dysfunctional and cannot run its government, which is worse than merely spooking investors.

causalcontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Russ Roberts

“it's not so much people talk about all our investors are gonna get spooked to me it's just basically says we're dysfunctional which is not a good thing”

0.35

Party leaders function as agents/negotiators on behalf of large groups of members, and good leaders constantly consult their members both to draw on committee chairmen's expertise and to ensure they retain support, since they cannot risk negotiating a deal their caucus will reject.

factualestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Keith Hennessey

“the leaders are really just their agents their negotiators on behalf of large groups”

0.18

The Gang of Six proposal cannot pass the House because it raises taxes more than the president proposed and does not cut spending now.

forecastspeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Keith Hennessey

“I certainly don't think it could pass the house because because it raises taxes more than the president's proposed and I think at least it's important because it doesn't cut spending off now”

0.14

The US government will not have enough money to meet its obligations on August 2nd if the debt ceiling (currently $14.29 trillion) is not raised.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 0/4· Russ Roberts

“if the debt ceiling which is currently at a mere fourteen point two nine trillion dollars if that is not lifted... the US government will not have enough money to meet its obligations”