
What this covers
This is a spoken walk-through of a memo Howard Marks dated October 22, 2024, shaped by recent client visits in Australia, where conversations about interest rates, credit's place in portfolios, and asset allocation came together for him. He begins with history: when he entered the industry 55 years ago, portfolio construction meant a classic 60-40 equity-bond split, and allocation as a discipline barely existed. His argument is that the goal is optimization suited to the investor's circumstances rather than maximization of return, and that the first step is choosing a risk posture, since preserving capital and maximizing growth cannot both be emphasized. He treats offense and defense as the only two basic orientations.
The middle of the talk separates ownership from debt. Ownership gives a claim on residual profits with no promised return; debt is contractual, so its return can be calculated up front if the borrower pays. Marks recalls that moving from Citibank's equity research to its bond department in 1978 taught him this difference. He also critiques the linear risk-return graph taught at Chicago since the 1960s, offering his own version of probability distributions turned on their side, in which higher risk widens the range of outcomes and worsens the downside. He doubts that computer models help much, since their inputs rest on historical data. He also disputes the academic efficient market view, a position he flags as contested, and warns that many managers believed to have alpha turn out not to.
The last stretch is the practical conclusion. Debt was unattractive from 2009 through 2021, when yields were very low, but expected returns are now around 7% on public credit and 10% on private credit. Marks says investors who want those returns, want less volatility, and will give up upside beyond today's yields should raise their allocation to non-investment grade credit, a group he thinks includes "a lot of investors." He also notes that an investor can hold a risk posture steady or vary it opportunistically with market conditions.
Marks argues that asset allocation fundamentally comes down to choosing the right balance between ownership (equities) and debt (credit) based on an investor's risk tolerance, and that in today's higher interest rate environment, credit offers attractive 7-10% returns competitive with historical equity returns while providing more predictable outcomes.
- Ownership and debt are the only two true asset classes with fundamentally different risk-return characteristics
- The optimal asset allocation process begins with identifying one's targeted risk posture (offense-defense balance), not with maximizing returns
- Credit yields of 7-10% today are competitive with historical equity returns while offering lower volatility and more dependable outcomes
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
In portfolio construction, the goal should be optimization (achieving the best relationship between return and risk appropriate for the investor's circumstances) not maximization (achieving the highest possible return)
“the goal should be optimization not maximization to my mind it shouldn't be wealth but wealth pursued in an appropriate way taking into account the Investor's wants and needs many people think the proper goal in investing is achieving the highest return more sophisticated thinkers understand either intellectually or intuitively that the goal should be to achieve the best relationship between return and risk”
The fundamental truth in asset allocation is that preservation of capital and maximization of growth are mutually exclusive—an investor cannot simultaneously emphasize both defense and offense, which are the only two basic orientations
“these two things are mostly mutually exclusive insistence on preserving capital or secondarily on limiting the portfolio's volatility calls for an emphasis on defense which precludes pursuing maximum growth correspondingly a decision to strive to maximize growth requires an emphasis on offense meaning preservation of capital and steadiness must be sacrificed to some degree it's one or the other you can't simultaneously emphasize both preservation of capital and maximization of growth or defense and offense this is the fundamental inescapable truth in investing”
The most important decision in the asset allocation process is identifying one's targeted risk posture—the desired balance between aggressiveness and defensiveness—and this decision should set the basis for all other asset allocation decisions
“one decision matters more than and should set the basis for all the other decisions in the portfolio management process it's the selection of a targeted risk posture or the desired balance between aggressiveness and defensiveness”
Because of their contractual nature, returns from credit are likely to prove much more dependable and less volatile than ownership returns from equities, offering lower uncertainty and volatility for investors seeking stability.
“because of their contractual nature the returns from credit are likely to prove much more dependable than ownership returns”
The difference between stocks and bonds is not just a difference in degree but a difference in kind, meaning they have fundamentally different characteristics and potential
“this isn't a difference in degree it's a difference in kind”
The essential difference between ownership and debt is that ownership provides no promise of return but a claim on residual profits after all obligations are paid, while debt is contractual and provides a fixed, predictable return
“owners put their money at risk with no promise of a return they acquire a piece of a business or other asset and are entitled to their proportional share of any residual that remains after the necessary payments have been made to employees providers of raw materials landlords tax authorities and of course lenders if there's something left over it's called profit or cash flow”
When Marks moved from Citibank's equity research department to its bond department in 1978, he learned that equities have no reliable way to forecast return, while bonds allow precise calculation of yield to maturity if held to maturity
“when I moved from City bank's equity research Department to its Bond Department in 1978 I learned firsthand that this is a matter of Night and Day on my new desk I found a machine called a Monroe 36065 Bond Trader if you typed in a Bond's interest rate maturity date and market price it would tell you the yield to maturity and other words what your return would be if you bought the bond at that price and held it to maturity and it paid this was revolutionary to me on the equity side I'd come from there was no place you could look to find out what your return would be”
Once an investor has identified their normal risk posture, they can choose to either maintain it consistently or vary it opportunistically—increasing offense when markets are beaten down and increasing defense when markets are riding high—based on changing market attractiveness
“they can maintain that posture all the time or they can opt to depart from it on occasion in response to the movements of the market and thus changes in the attractiveness of the offerings it provides increasing their emphasis on offense when the market is beaten down and on defense when it's Riding High”
The ratio of return to risk is similar at all points on the risk continuum in an efficient market, meaning there is no free lunch—you cannot get higher returns without taking proportionally higher risk
“the ratio of return to risk is similar at all points on the Continuum less of both toward the left and more of both toward the right set another way there's no free lunch”
A critical question in asset allocation is whether to depart from one's chosen risk level to invest in a riskier asset class or pursue a manager believed to possess alpha, but many managers believed to have alpha turn out not to have it, making this a very difficult decision
“this last idea raises one of the key questions in asset allocation should you consider departing from your sweet spot in terms of risk level in order to invest in a riskier asset class with a manager believed to possess Alpha there's no easy answer to this question especially given that many managers who are believed to possess Alpha turn out not to to”
The choice between ownership and debt is subjective and a function of the investor's circumstances and attitude toward bearing risk—which is better depends on the individual investor's situation, not on some objective reality
“the choice between the two is subjective largely a function of the Investor's circumstances and attitude toward bearing risk that means the answer will be different for different investors”
Computer models used in asset allocation require inputs regarding expected return, risk, and correlation, most of which are based on historical data and thus of questionable relevance to future outcomes
“many investors use computer models to help with these decisions but the models require inputs regarding expected return risk and correlation and most of these are based on history and thus of questionable relevance to the Future correlation between asset classes is particularly difficult to predict it's often a case of garbage in garbage out but with the added comfort that comes from using mathematical models”
In actual practice, markets are NOT efficient in the academic sense of always being right—they may rapidly incorporate information and reflect consensus opinion about prices, but that consensus can be far from correct, allowing skillful investors to identify superior risk-return bargains
“it's time for me to assert strenuously that in reality markets are not efficient in the academic sense of always being right markets may do an efficient job of a rapidly incorporating new information and B accurately reflecting the resulting consensus opinion concerning the right price for each asset given the totality of information but that opinion can be far from correct for that reason gains can be achieved by choosing skillfully among the options some assets markets or strategies can offer a better risk return bargain than others and some managers can operate within a marketer strategy to produce Superior risk adjusted returns”
In the low interest rate environment from 2009 through 2021, debt was extremely unattractive due to very low expected returns far below historical equity returns, but today debt's expected returns of around 7% on public credit and 10% on private credit are considerably higher and closer to equities, making credit more attractive
“in the low interest rate environment that prevailed from 2009 through 2021 the expected return from debt was extremely low in the absolute and far below the historical return on equities rendering debt relatively unattractive but today it's considerably higher than it was and closer to that of equities”
A more accurate representation of the risk-return relationship uses probability distributions turned on their side to show that as risk increases, not only does expected return increase, but the range of possible outcomes widens and the downside outcomes become worse
“in a memo in 2006 I took the same line and superimposed on it some bell-shaped curves representing probability distributions turned on their side I did this to indicate the uncertain nature of returns from riskier Assets Now we see that as the thing called risk increases that is as we move from left to right on the graph not only does the expected return increase but the range of possible outcomes becomes wider and the bad outcomes become worse that's risk”
The traditional risk-return graph taught since the 1960s at the University of Chicago is highly inadequate because the linear relationship makes it appear that increased risk always leads to increased return with certainty, which obscures the actual nature of risk
“the way this was taught at the University of Chicago beginning when I was there in the 1960s it's a graphical presentation we've all seen ever since in which as we move from left to right increasing the expected risk the expected return also increases as readers know I always felt this representation was highly inadequate since the linearity of the relationship in the graph makes it appear too certain that increased risk will lead to increased return this obviously belies the nature of risk”
Marks recommends that investors increase their allocations to non-investment grade credit if they meet three criteria: (1) attracted by returns of 7-10%, (2) desirous of limiting uncertainty and volatility, and (3) willing to forgo upside potential beyond today's yields, arguing this should include 'a lot of investors.'
“my recommendation at this time is that investors do the research required to increase their allocation to credit establish a program for doing so and take a partial step to implement it...if they are a attracted by returns of 7 to 10% or so B desirous of limiting uncertainty and volatility and C willing to forgo upside potential Beyond today's yields to do so for me that should include a lot of investors”
The concept of yield to maturity and fixed income returns is based on the assumption that the borrower will make promised payments when due, at which point the investor will receive exactly the return they calculated upfront
“for the purposes of this memo however it might help to think of it as fixed outcome investing”
The concept of asset allocation as a distinct portfolio management discipline is relatively new—55 years ago when Marks joined the industry, portfolio construction simply followed the classic 60-40 equity-bond split with little formal framework
“asset allocation is a relatively new thing no one used that phrase when I joined the industry 55 years ago structuring portfolios was a pretty simple matter generally following the classic 60/40 split”
The date of this memo is October 22nd, 2024
“October 22nd 2024”
Marks introduced the concept of representing the risk-return relationship using bell-shaped probability distributions superimposed on the traditional risk-return line, which he considers a lasting contribution to investment industry pedagogy
“I hope this way of presenting risk will be considered a lasting contribution to the investment industry when I'm gone”
Beta is defined as relative volatility—the extent to which an asset reflects market movements—and under efficient market theory, expected returns are proportional only to beta, not to the specific asset chosen
“since there's no such thing as Alpha the only only thing that differentiates assets is their beta or their relative volatility the extent to which they reflect Market movements in the theory it's beta that expected returns are proportional to”
Marks employs general statements, qualifications like 'usually', 'generally', and 'everything else being equal' throughout his analysis, which could apply to many more sentences than explicitly stated
“I want to mention that from time to time in this memo I'll say generally usually or everything else being equal these caveat are likely applicable to many more sentences and ideas herein but for the sake of readability I'm not going to repeat them at nauseum”
The presentation of this memo was informed by recent visits with clients in Australia, during which discussions about interest rates, credit's role in portfolios, and asset allocation coalesced into a new unified theory combining old ideas
“last month's visit with clients in Australia is a case in point we talked about the sea change I believe is taking place in interest rates and about the role of credit in portfolios and in a few cases this led to the general topic of asset allocation the result wasn't a lot of new ideas on the subject but rather a new way to combine old ideas into a unified theory”