
How do I stay in the present moment when it feels unbearable?
What this covers
This is a single answer from Thich Nhat Hanh to a question put to him during a May 2014 retreat at Plum Village. The question is how to stay in the present when it feels unbearable. He begins with the Plum Village instruction not to get caught in past and future. He treats both as mental images, and the present moment as the only place where suffering can be understood. He describes two things a person finds on returning there: refreshing conditions of happiness that mindful breathing can reach, and painful emotions that call for direct care.
Much of the answer is about why people run. He says most fear being overwhelmed if they touch the pain inside, so they turn to consumption: magazines, television, food, music, phones. Others retreat into imagined futures or remembered pasts. He argues this leaves no one tending the feeling, which lets it grow. His alternative is to use the energy of mindfulness, built through mindful walking or breathing, to embrace the pain tenderly, and he says a few minutes of this can calm it.
The second half turns to community and service. He invokes the Bodhisattva Kṣitigarbha, who vows to go to places of great suffering, and he points to doctors, nurses, social workers and young volunteers as living examples. Their fearlessness rests on aspiration, but he argues it cannot last without a Sangha, where workers can return home to rest, heal and be encouraged. He also claims that deep compassion protects a person from being overwhelmed by the collective suffering of those around them, a point stated more as assertion than argument. His advice on bringing family into the practice is to skip argument and let one's own visible change do the persuading.
Thich Nhat Hanh teaches that returning to the present moment, even when painful, is the only path to understanding and transforming suffering, and that this practice is strengthened through collective community support rather than individual isolation or avoidance.
- The present moment is the only reality where suffering can be directly understood and addressed, unlike the past and future which are merely mental images
- Attempting to escape pain through consumption, distraction, or imagination perpetuates suffering rather than resolving it
- Compassion and mindfulness generated through group practice create collective healing energy that protects practitioners from being overwhelmed and enables them to serve others
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Service workers and Bodhisattva figures should be actively supported by their communities so they do not lose their aspiration after years of service; after difficult work periods, they need to return home to rest, heal, and receive encouragement from their communities, enabling them to return to service multiple times
“These Bodhisattvas should be supported by us. You want to support them so they do not lose their aspiration after a few years of service. We have to send them our energy of encouragement They need nourishment and healing So, after six months of working in a very difficult situation, they go home and they have us taking care of them, time to heal, so they will go out again the second time and the third time”
Even when the present moment is unbearable, returning to that moment is the only opportunity available for doing something to calm down and transform the suffering
“So, even if the present moment is unbearable, to go back to that moment is the only chance for us to do something in order to calm it down and to transform it.”
Getting in touch with suffering through mindfulness brings about understanding of suffering, and the energy of understanding and compassion together has the power to heal both oneself and the people around one at that time
“Getting in touch with the suffering, brings about understanding of suffering. And... the energy of compassion - understanding and compassion - has the power to heal. To heal you and to heal the people who happen to be around you at that time.”
The practice of mindfulness requires returning home to the present moment, which is the only reality where understanding and transformation of suffering is possible, unlike the past and future which are merely mental images
“Only the present moment is real. Many people try to cover up the pain inside not only by going back to the past or running to the future, to imagine that there will be some hope, some end of suffering in the future but that cannot last long”
When practitioners work with suffering collectively in a group, they experience collective energy of compassion that heals them more powerfully than individual practice, and when they suffer less, they become capable of helping others to do the same
“if there is a group of people practicing, together, embracing the suffering with tenderness, they will experience that collective energy of compassion that will heal them. And when they suffer less, they are in the situation to help other people to do the same.”
When returning to the present moment through mindfulness practice, one encounters two kinds of situations: first, many refreshing and healing conditions of happiness available in the here and now that can be accessed through mindful breathing; second, painful emotions and feelings that manifest and require direct care and transformation rather than avoidance
“When you go home to the present moment, you can find... two kinds of situations: The first kind of situation is there are so many conditions of happiness available in the here and the now. When you breathe in and bring your mind home to your body you establish in the present moment. And you notice there are so many refreshing and healing elements available in the present moment.”
Bodhisattva service workers are not afraid of going into suffering situations because they know they can bring relief, and this fearlessness is rooted in a strong source of energy that is aspiration and volition—the recognition that one's life can be useful and meaningful through helping people who suffer
“They are not afraid of suffering. Because they know that they can bring relief And Bodhisattva Kṣitigarbha has a strong power or source of energy that is the aspiration the third kind of nutriment, volition You know you are there - alive. And you want to do something with your life You want your life to be useful, meaningful. So, you make a strong vow to go to help people who suffer.”
Most people attempt to escape internal suffering through consumption-based practices—reading magazines, watching television, eating, listening to music, using phones—because they believe these activities will prevent them from confronting the suffering within, but this avoidance allows the pain to continue growing unaddressed
“Most people try to cover up the suffering inside by the practice of consumption. We read magazines and watch television we try and find something to eat we listen to the music, we pick up the phone to talk, everything we do, we do because we hope by doing these things, we don't have to confront the suffering in us. And we allow that pain to continue to grow in us.”
When one's family and community enjoy increased harmony, health, brotherhood, and sisterhood through collective practice, one's personal aspiration to serve can be more easily realized because the foundation of support is stronger
“So, when your family, your community, enjoy more harmony, health, brotherhood, sisterhood, and then your aspiration can be more easily realized.”
A Sangha (community or group of practitioners) is necessary for Bodhisattva practice to continue long-term, because practice should not only be individual but collective; individual practice cannot sustain aspiration, but group practice creates conditions for continued service
“Bodhisattva Kṣitigarbha knows that they, that he needs a Sangha in order to continue for a long time. So, the practice should not only be individual the practice should be collective also.”
The energy of mindfulness and compassion generated through group practice has healing power that extends beyond the individual practitioners to heal people around them in that moment
“the energy of compassion - understanding and compassion - has the power to heal. To heal you and to heal the people who happen to be around you at that time.”
The energy of mindfulness generated through mindful breathing or mindful walking practice creates sufficient strength to recognize, counter, and embrace pain tenderly, and embracing pain with tenderness for even a few minutes can calm it down
“If you know how to practice mindful breathing, or mindful walking, you're generating the energy of mindfulness and then that energy of mindfulness generated by the practice helps you to be strong enough to recognize and counter the pain and embrace it tenderly. And embracing your pain tenderly in a few minutes, you can calm it down”
The best way to convince family and community members to join mindfulness practice is not through argument but through the visible transformation of the practitioner themselves—becoming increasingly pleasant, more smiling, and sweeter each day, which demonstrates that the practice works
“So, let us try to convince people in our family to join the practice. And the best way to do it is to become more and more pleasant, every day. More smiling, more sweet... sweeter and they'll believe that the practice will work for them also.”
When one encounters painful feelings or emotions in the present moment, most people instinctively run away and pretend the pain doesn't exist, leaving no one there to take care of the painful feeling, which allows it to persist and grow
“But when it begins to manifest, you don't like to be there. So you try to run away, pretending that it's not there. So no one is there in order to take care of the painful feeling or the painful emotion.”
In Plum Village teaching, practitioners are instructed not to get caught in past and future, and instead to go back to the present moment as the primary practice
“Because in Plum Village we always say that 'Let us not get caught in the past and the future' 'Let us go back to the present moment'”
Having sufficient compassion provides protection against being overwhelmed by the collective energy of suffering emitted by people around one, and this protection is available to those with deep compassion
“So, if you have compassion, you don't mind being in a difficult, suffering situation. And if you have enough compassion then you are protected. You will not be overwhelmed by the collective energy of suffering emitted by the people around.”
Bodhisattva Kṣitigarbha is a figure who has made a vow to go to places of great suffering in order to serve and help, and this archetype is exemplified by real people today—doctors, nurses, social workers, and young volunteers—who deliberately go to painful situations on Earth to provide relief
“There is a Bodhisattva whose name is Kṣitigarbha [?] the vow of Kṣitigarbha [?] is to go to the places where there's a lot of suffering in order to have a chance to serve, to help.”
Most people are afraid that when they come home to themselves and touch the pain inside through mindfulness, they will be overwhelmed by suffering, and this fear drives their practice of running away—imagining the future or going back to the past—as a strategy to forget
“Most of the people don't do that because they're afraid that when they come home to themselves, and touch their pain inside, they will be overwhelmed by the suffering and that is why their practice is to run away, imagine something about the future to forget go back to the past to forget”