
New Survey: China’s Reputation Plummets To Worst on Record | Sino-Russian Order | TSMC & Huawei
What this covers
This 13-minute China Update episode, presented solo by Tony, moves through three segments: American public opinion on China, Xi Jinping's appearance at the BRICS summit in Russia, and the dispute over whether Huawei obtained chips made by TSMC. The first and longest segment works through a Chicago Council on Global Affairs survey, and the other two follow Beijing's side of the same rivalry.
The survey section is dense with numbers. Average favorability toward China is 26 out of 100, down from 32 in 2022 and the lowest since polling began in 1978. A 55% majority want the US to actively limit China's power, against 40% who prefer friendly engagement. Americans rank avoiding military conflict (69%) above keeping the technology edge (60%) as a goal, and 79% favor banning sales of sensitive technology to China. The partisan split gets attention: Republicans back broader cuts to exchanges, and Democrats resist them. Most respondents also prefer a mix of competition and cooperation over one blanket policy. Tony ends the section with a normative point, that any administration seeking warmer ties must still show it protects US workers, technology and domestic industry.
The BRICS segment covers Xi's speech framing a choice between chaos and peace, his five proposed directions for the bloc, and his promotion of the Global Security Initiative, the Global Development Initiative and the Global Civilization Initiative. The chip segment covers Tech Insights' teardown of an Ascend 910b that contained a TSMC chip, the US Commerce Department inquiry into know-your-customer diligence, and TSMC's statement that it has not supplied Huawei since September 2020. It closes with Huawei's Harmony OS Next, which drops Android Open Source Project (AOSP)) compatibility and already runs apps such as Grab and Emirates.
Tony argues that US-China relations have fundamentally shifted from engagement to competition, with American public opinion now at historic lows, while China actively pursues technological decoupling and promotes an alternative world order through organizations like BRICS.
- Chicago Council survey shows American favorability toward China at 26/100, lowest since 1978, with 55% supporting active limitation of China's power growth
- Xi Jinping's BRICS speech explicitly frames China's 'three Gs' (Global Security, Development, Civilization initiatives) as an alternative to the Western-led world order
- Huawei's development of Harmony OS Next and apparent circumvention of US chip export controls demonstrates China's strategy of technological self-sufficiency to escape Western restrictions
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The Chicago Council survey concludes that Americans view China as a rival rather than a partner and say the US should seek to limit China's power and influence in the world, representing a fundamental shift from the era of engagement to an era of wide-ranging competition.
“as the US China relationship has moved from an era of Engagement into an era of wide ranging competition American opinion has followed suit Americans today view China far more negatively than at any previous Point since the establishment of us China diplomatic relations in 1979 view China as a rival rather than a partner”
A majority of Americans, 55%, say the United States should actively work to limit the growth of China's power, while 40% say the United States should undertake friendly cooperation and engagement with China.
“a majority of Americans 55% say the United States should actively work to limit the growth of China's power while 4 and 10 40% say that United States should undertake friendly cooperation and engagement with China”
A majority of Americans, 56%, say US-China trade does more to weaken US National Security, while 39% say it does more to strengthen it.
“a majority of Americans 56% say us China trade does more to weaken US National Security 39% more to strengthen”
Americans broadly support subsidizing domestic production of a wide range of products from high-tech semiconductors and electric vehicles to basic household consumer products rather than importing them from China.
“the public broadly supports subsidizing domestic production of a wide range of products from high-tech semiconductors and electric vehicles to basic household consumer products rather than importing them from China”
Xi Jinping also gave a speech to the BRICS Plus leaders dialogue where he pitched his flagship foreign policy agendas known in English as the three G's: the Global Security Initiative, Global Development Initiative, and Global Civilization Initiative.
“she also gave a speech to the so-called bricks plus leaders dialogue where he pitched his Flagship foreign policy agendas knowing in English as the three G's the Global Security initiative Global development initiative and Global civilization initiative”
The Chicago Council on Global Affairs survey shows that American views of China have hit an all-time low in Council polling, with average American favorability toward China at 26 out of 100, down from 32 in 2022, representing the lowest recorded favorability since the organization began polling in 1978 before the US and China established diplomatic relations.
“American views of China have hit an alltime low in Council polling...the survey shows that Americans views of China have dropped significantly even in the last two years...the poll which asked participants to rate their feelings towards China from 0 to 100 found that Americans on average responded with 26 down from 32 in 2022 the lowest number recorded since the organization started polling in 1978”
The US Department of Commerce is investigating whether Huawei obtained advanced chips from Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company (TSMC) indirectly, using intermediary companies with different names to circumvent US export restrictions.
“the US Department of Commerce quote is looking into whether while way brought chips from Taiwan semiconductor Manufacturing Company tsmc indirectly using intermediary companies with a different name to place orders on its behalf end quote”
TSMC recently notified the US Commerce Department that one of its customers placed an order for a chip that resembled Huawei's Ascend 910b, indicating a possible violation of export restrictions.
“tsmc has recently notified the Commerce Department after a customer placed orders for a chip that resembled huawei's Ascend 910b end quote”
Americans identify avoiding military conflict as the top goal for US-China relations at 69% importance, followed by maintaining the US technology edge at 60% importance.
“Americans top goals for us China relations is avoiding a military conflict 69% very important and maintaining the US technology Edge 60%”
Xi Jinping proposed five policy directions for BRICS: build a BRICS committed to peace, build a BRICS committed to innovation, build a BRICS committed to green development, build a BRICS committed to justice, and build a BRICS committed to closer people-to-people exchanges.
“xiin ping proposed five policy directions for bricks namely build a bricks committed to peace build a bricks committed to Innovation build a bricks committed to Green development build a bricks committed to Justice and build a bricks committed to closer people to- people exchanges”
Roughly half of Americans (47%) say US leaders are not giving the issue of US competition with China enough attention, including a majority of Republicans (62%) and a plurality of Independents (46%), while half of Democrats (50%) and 40% of Americans overall say leaders are paying about the right amount.
“roughly half 47% say us leaders are not giving the issue of us competition with China enough attention including a majority of Republicans 62% and a plurality of Independents 46% by contrast half of Democrats 50% and four and 10 Americans overall 40% say us leaders are paying about the right amount”
Global apps running on Harmony OS Next include Grab, the popular ride-hailing app in Southeast Asia, and Emirates, one of the two flag carriers of the United Arab Emirates, indicating Harmony OS is gaining international adoption.
“Global apps running on the OS include grab the popular ride hailing app in Southeast Asia and Emirates one of the two flag carriers of the United Arab Emirates”
Huawei has launched Harmony OS Next, the fifth iteration of Harmony OS, which is said to have enhanced performance, improved system security, and a more seamless user experience compared to previous versions.
“the New Harmony OS next is entirely self-developed with a fully independent Foundation also the company claims this means that it no longer supports android-based applications and has been dubbed pure blood in China”
The US Commerce Department is scrutinizing whether TSMC conducted required know-your-customer due diligence when accepting orders that may have been for Huawei.
“the department has scrutinized whether tsmc conducted the required know your customer due diligence when accepting orders”
Canada-based tech research firm Tech Insights discovered a TSMC chip in a Huawei Ascend 910b after taking apart the product, revealing a possible violation of US export restrictions, and then informed TSMC of the chip before publishing findings.
“Reuters writes that Canada base Tech insights informed tsmc of the chip before publishing its findings in a report prompting the Taiwanese firm to notify the US Commerce Department”
TSMC states that it has not supplied chips to Huawei since mid-September 2020 and proactively communicated with the US Commerce Department regarding the matter, also asserting it is not aware of being subject to any investigation at this time.
“TS SMC is a law-abiding company and we are committed to complying with all applicable rules and regulations including applicable export controls in compliance with the regulatory requirements TS SMC has not supplied to Huawei since mid-september 2020 we proactively communicated with the US Commerce Department regarding the matter in the report we are not aware of tsmc being the subject of any investigation at this time”
49% of Americans view China as more influential than the US in Asia, 30% view them as equally influential, and 21% view the US as more influential.
“half of Americans 49% view China as more influential than the US in Asia 30% equally influential and 21% more influential”
Americans prefer a mix of competition and cooperation to either policy applied across the board in US-China relations.
“the public...prefer a mix of competition and cooperation to either policy applied across the board”
Xi Jinping is in Russia this week for the BRICS Summit and used the event to deliver a speech framing the world as facing a pivotal choice between allowing it to descend into chaos or striving to place it back on the path of peace and development.
“as the world enters a new period defined by turbulence and transformation we are confronted with pivotal choices that will shape our future should we allow the world to descend into the abyss of disorder and Chaos or should we strive to stare it back on the path of peace and development”
The Huawei Ascend 910b is viewed as the most advanced AI chip available from the Chinese company, making its acquisition a significant concern for US policy makers seeking to maintain US technological edge.
“The tear down was of huawei's Ascend 910b the 190b is viewed as the most advanced AI chip available uh from the Chinese company”
Previous versions of Harmony OS were partially built on the Android Open Source Project (AOSP) and required compatibility with Android apps, but the new Harmony OS Next is entirely self-developed with a fully independent foundation and no longer supports Android-based applications.
“previously released versions of Harmony OS were partially built on the Android open source project AOSP as a result they required compatibility with with some Android apps however the New Harmony OS next is entirely self-developed with a fully independent Foundation also the company claims this means that it no longer supports android-based applications”
The survey shows that Republicans consistently support broader reductions in US-China exchanges beyond just technology restrictions, while Democrats oppose such policies, indicating partisan divergence in how aggressive to be on China decoupling.
“opinions on other limitations on us China exchanges is far more polarized by partisanship with Republicans consistently more supportive of reductions in these exchanges while Democrats are opposed to such policies”
8 in 10 Americans (79%) favor prohibiting US companies from selling sensitive high technology products to China, up from 71% in 2021, including large majorities across party lines.
“8 in 10 Americans favor prohibiting us companies from selling sensitive high technology products to China 79% up from 71% in 2021 including large majorities across party lines”
The extensive trade ties that bind the US and China together are no longer seen by Americans as a benefit but instead as a danger to US National Security, representing a reversal of the rationale that justified decades of trade engagement with China.
“the extensive trade Ties That Bind the two largest global economies to one another are no longer seen as a benefit but instead a danger to US National Security”
Any US administration seeking a more confrontational approach with Beijing over trade or China's territorial claims will have to work to convince the public that the costs are worth it and that such an approach won't trigger an outright conflict between the two nations.
“should it want a more confrontational approach with Beijing either over trade or China's territorial claims it will have work to do to convince the public that the costs are worth it and that such an approach won't trigger an outright conflict between the two Nations”
Huawei's development of Harmony OS Next and apparent circumvention of US chip export controls represents another step toward complete technological decoupling from US and other Western systems.
“This development represents another step towards complete technological decoupling from us and other Western systems”
An administration seeking a more convivial relationship with China will have to assure the public that the United States remains focused on maintaining America's technological advantages, protecting US workers from what many Americans see as unfair competition from China, and supporting domestic production in key industries.
“an Administration seeking a more convivial relationship will have to assure the public that the United States remains focused on maintaining America's technological advantages protecting us workers from what many Americans see as unfair competition from China and supporting domestic production in key Industries”
Richard Yu, Huawei's consumer business group chairman, stated that Harmony OS Next already has 15,000 native applications and services, a number 10 times higher than in June when the beta version was released, claiming 'we have carved out a new field in just one year and achieved what foreign ecosystems have been doing for over a decade.'
“Richard Yu chungong chairman of huawei's consumer business group said at an event on Tuesday this week that Harmony OS next already has 15,000 native applications and services the number of native applications is 10 times higher than in June when Huawei released a beta version of Harmony OS next according to you quote we have carved out a new field in just one year and achieved what foreign ecosystems have been doing for over a decade end quote”
China's state media (China Daily) explicitly frames BRICS and China's alternative world order vision as appealing to the Global South because it opposes the post-World War II world order shaped by the US-led West, in which developing and emerging economies are significantly disadvantaged.
“dissatisfaction with the international political status quo opposed to World War II World Order shaped by the US lead West in which developing and emerging economies are significantly disadvantaged as a key reason for the appeal of bricks”
Critics have accused Huawei of completely ripping off Android with identical code bases in Harmony OS Next, despite Huawei's claims of complete independence.
“however critics have accused Huawei of completely ripping off Android with identical code bases”
If Huawei can obtain advanced chips from TSMC indirectly through circumvention, US export restrictions and policies maintaining technological advantage are undermined, creating a serious policy failure that contradicts majority American public support for technology restrictions.
“if Huawei is getting its hands on the most advanced chips in the world and getting around us export restrictions...restricting Chin's access to Advanced Technology and maintaining the US lead is considered a top policy priority by a majority of Americans”
Tony asserts that China working with Russia and others to create a new world order to replace the Western one is not a conspiracy but policy clearly and continuously articulated by Beijing and Xi Jinping.
“China working with Russia and others to create a new world world order to replace the Western one is not some conspiracy it is policy clearly and continuously articulated by Beijing and Xi Jinping”
Despite concerns about US-China trade impacts on American National Security, Americans oppose significant reduction in that trade given the costs it would impose on American consumers, suggesting a pragmatic preference for balancing competition with costs.
“despite concerns about the impact of us China trade on American National Security Americans oppose significant reduction in that trade given the costs it would impose on American consumers”
Support for broad trade restrictions has declined from 2021, possibly because of greater concerns about costs following the experience of higher inflation in the early 2020s, suggesting Americans distinguish between targeted technology restrictions and broad trade restrictions.
“support for broad trade restrictions has declined from 2021 possibly because of Greater concerns about costs following the experience of the higher inflation of the early 2020s”
Vladimir Putin was present in the audience listening to Xi Jinping's BRICS speech, indicating Russia's alignment with China's geopolitical positioning and the significance of the Putin-Xi partnership.
“we note that of course Vladimir Putin was in the audience listening to the speech”