
Broken Money Why Our Financial System Is Failing US And How We Can Make It Better 2 06 24
What this covers
This is a recorded Princeton talk with Lynn Alden, followed by conversation with Carolyn Wilkins, co-sponsored by the Griswold Center and the DeCenter blockchain group. Alden builds her case from monetary history. Money moved toward scarcer substrates, from shell beads and grains to silver and then gold, because technology made each earlier form easier to produce. Banking, she says, has long done two jobs: extending credit, which the Code of Hammurabi already documents, and moving, verifying and dividing money across distances, which she thinks gets too little attention. William Stanley Jevons is her example of the cost. In 1875 he observed a very efficient system of ledger entries, but one leveraged roughly 20:1.
The middle of the talk is about how a currency monopoly holds together. Alden names two enforcement points, bank wires and physical ports of entry, and argues that a memorized private key can carry value across a border undetected. The examples are concrete. A Cairo physician keeps savings in dollars bought on the gray market, a Nigerian designer asks clients to pay in a stablecoin through a QR code, and Egyptian restaurants cannot accept dollars even though demand for them is high. She also covers the roughly 40 currencies in Africa and 30 in Latin America. The Human Rights Foundation and Wikileaks appear as cases of people cut off from banking, and she raises cash caps and reporting thresholds in Europe as privacy losses.
She is also critical of the field itself. She calls crypto venture capital a structure that let investors profit through token lockups and exchange listings whether or not a project worked. She says DeFi adoption is rightly slowed by smart-contract bugs, and that most institutional Bitcoin buyers want price appreciation more than monetary properties. Her forecast, flagged as contested, is that many currency monopolies will break down over decades, turbulently but with an ethical payoff in monetary choice. Wilkins adds that adoption looks different in developing economies, where alternatives are scarce, than in developed ones, where it is more speculative.
Lynn Alden argues that monetary systems have historically solved frictions through centralization, but blockchain technologies like Bitcoin and stablecoins now offer the first credible path to decentralization without sacrificing efficiency, potentially disrupting the currency monopolies that have persisted for centuries.
- Every monetary friction for centuries has been solved by centralizing trust in intermediaries, creating layers of leverage and systemic risk
- Bitcoin and stablecoins enable decentralized ledgers that provide efficiency without requiring centralized intermediaries, breaking currency monopolies for the first time
- Over 1 billion people face daily currency instability, capital controls, and surveillance—problems that decentralized money can address by allowing choice of denomination and jurisdiction
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The history of physical money shows a progression toward ever-scarcer substrates: shell beads and grains gave way to silver coins, which gave way to gold, because technology made prior forms less scarce; gold persists as money because even modern technology cannot rapidly increase its supply.
“the history of physical money is kind of going up the stack in terms of finding the next scarcest thing figuring out how to make more of it going up to the next scarcest thing until we kind of settle on gold is a thing that we even to the day we we can't rapidly increase the supply of”
Bitcoin and stablecoins enable infinite value density through ports of entry because someone can memorize 12 words representing their private key and bring millions of dollars in value through an airport with no way to prove it is happening, disrupting the historical enforcement mechanism of currency monopolies.
“what things like Bitcoin or stable coins do is technically you now have infinite value density going through any sort of Port of Entry so you can memorize 12 words representing your private key and you can you can bring 10 million1 million dollars of value through an airport and there's really no way to prove a negative or prove that that's not happening um and so currency Brokers can get money in or out of regions at significant um densities that not existed before”
A physician in Cairo saves by hoarding physical US dollar cash bought on the gray market and stuffing it under his mattress—a 2024-era savings technology—because Egyptian pounds lose value too rapidly, illustrating how people in developing nations with unstable currencies are forced to use alternative assets for savings.
“I know a physician there and he Stacks physical cash dollars that he buys in the gray market and stuffs them under his mattress or the equivalent and that's his savings technology for liquid Savings in 2024 and he's not alone in that”
Banking and bank-like entities have existed for thousands of years serving two main roles: provision of credit (documented in the Code of Hammurabi 4,000 years ago) and physical movement, verification, and divisibility of money across long distances—with the latter receiving insufficient historical attention.
“Banking and bank-like entities have existed for thousands of years and the the two main roles one was the provision of credit that's been known for thousands of years if you look at the code code of hamurabi in in Babylon for example there's there's you know rules about lending and things like that 4,000 years ago um and but the other key thing that I I think doesn't get enough attention is is the physical movement verification and divisibility of other types of money”
William Stanley Jevons noted in 1875 that the banking system of his era had achieved remarkable efficiency (gold rarely changed hands, just ledger entries) but at the cost of extreme leverage and leverage—estimating the system was leveraged 20:1, such that if just 5% of people demanded their gold back, the system would be insolvent despite appearing sound.
“he's like marveling that this is so efficient gold rarely ever has to change hands you're just you're just constantly trading ownership for it on the other hand he's like this is extremely centralized and it's so hyper efficient that it's become hyper leveraged that he's like looking around in 1875 and saying this is lever 20 to1 if 5% of people ever want their gold back at once which never seems to happen because Gold's so inefficient but if it were to happen the system is is technically it's you know insolvent it's it's very IL liquid rela to The Leverage that build up”
If a business is financing operations and raising capital in one currency while their cash flows are denominated in a different currency that fluctuates significantly relative to their debt, they face material exchange-rate risk that can threaten solvency.
“if they're a business and they're getting financing and they're raising New York dollars for for their liabilities and their cash flows are denominated in New Jersey dollars that that might fluctuate significantly compared to the debt they just took out”
The Human Rights Foundation combats authoritarianism worldwide and sees that people have bank accounts frozen for arbitrary reasons—such as protesting police violence—and therefore must turn to Bitcoin or stablecoins to receive donations and work around their local banking systems.
“I have friends over at the human rights Foundation they work on combating authoritarianism worldwide um and they see that many people have bank accounts Frozen for arbitrary reasons um you know someone in Nigeria protests police violence and uh you know excessive use of police force and then their bank accounts are frozen so they have to turn to bitcoin or stable coins to get donations and try to go around their local banking system”
Some European countries ban cash transactions above certain amounts (e.g., €1,000), forcing all transactions above that threshold through corporate or government pipes—this represents a loss of privacy and should concern people even if the currency itself is stable.
“for example in Europe there's a number of countries that have bans on using cash above certain amounts so if you try to spend more than a thousand EUR you're technically now on the on the gray Market or the black market you're doing something illegal and it's basically saying that every transaction has to go through either a corporate pipe or a government pipe”
Surveillance capitalism and data collection by corporations is widespread, and while benign actors collect data, governments can demand access to it and use it in problematic ways, or hackers can steal it—this applies to both government and private financial systems and argues for privacy protections.
“we live in the age of surveillance capitalism where companies try to monetize our data as much as possible and a lot of times what happens is data gets collected by fairly benign actors you know they're not trying to freeze your stuff they're not trying to surveil it but then either one any given government so not just the United States but there's 200 some governments out there um they can tell data providers to give them all the data and then they can use that in ways that are problematic or two hackers can get the data and then just spill it out there”
Currency monopolies enforce themselves through two major portals: bank wires (with tight control over exchange rates, allowed currencies, and account safety) and ports of entry (physical currency transfer, declared and limited by customs regulations).
“there's really only two major ways to get money in or out of a given currency Monopoly one of them is through bank wires right so if I wire money to someone in Egypt for example I can send money to them the challenge of course is that the Egyptian banking system has very tight control over what types of money they lit in what exchange rate they they convert it to local currency before the recipient gets it...and the other method of course on the bottom there is Port of Entry you can physically bring money with you you can bring cash you can bring gold through an airport but anyone who goes through airports regularly knows it's all these signs saying you know if you're over 5,000 or over $10,000 worth of things you've got to declare it”
The US dollar has bottom-up demand in gray markets of Argentina, Egypt, Lebanon, and dozens of other countries because it solves a problem (store of value in high-inflation countries), not only because of top-down enforcement. This shows that even fiat currency can have organic demand when it provides utility.
“F currency interesting because it's both a top- down product but in some cases there's bottom up demand for it so for example the the gray markets for dollars in Argentina or Egypt or Lebanon or dozens of countries around the world these are bottomup phenomenons people are assessing all the different monies available to them and they're they're picking dollars because of the network effect that that's present”
A graphic designer in Nigeria can hold up a QR code on a video call and ask for payment in dollar stablecoins or Bitcoin rather than waiting for wire transfers that may not arrive in the exchange rate their central bank decides, thereby circumventing the local banking system entirely.
“if I wanted to pay a graphic designer in Nigeria instead of sending money to her that goes then through wires and may may may not get to her at in her currency at the exchange rate that that their Central Bank decides you know she can hold up a QR code on a video call and ask for payment in dollar stable coins or Bitcoin or whatever type of money she wants and I can send it to her and it goes around her local banking system”
DeFi adoption is being slowed (appropriately) by the fact that automated smart contracts contain bugs that can cause users to lose funds, and the more rapidly code changes, the more vulnerable it is to hacking—Bitcoin's slow-moving, well-audited approach is safer than constantly updating DeFi protocols.
“even if you're automating something you're hoping that that code is not buggy and you can lose funds and so with something like Bitcoin you have a a foundation that doesn't change very much it's a slow moving well audited thing...the more rapid something changes the more vulnerable it is to hack”
Restaurants in Egypt avoid accepting dollars despite high demand for them on the black market because their accounting and regulatory systems are not set up for dollar transactions, even though individual proprietors might accept dollars if not restricted by regulations.
“this is this like a dollar is like a treasured object there the you know if on the black market this is extremely desirable to have and um but the restaurants accounting system is not set up for it there's regulations around it so if you at like a small Ho inth thewall restaurant the owner might be like yeah we'll take dollars in fact that's great but at any sort of like larger scale one it's it's harder to actually have that payment friction”
Egypt has spent roughly equal amounts of time in double-digit inflation and not in double-digit inflation over the past 60+ years, and while not the worst case globally, this demonstrates a widespread problem affecting well over a billion people who live on a constant treadmill where they must achieve 10-15-20% nominal wage increases annually just to maintain their share of purchasing power.
“Egypt's a market that I follow a little bit more closely than any other...this chart here shows Egypt's inflation rate over the past 60 plus years and as you can see they spent about as much time in double digit inflation as they have not been in double-digit inflation...the fact that they actually managed to have under 50% inflation whole time puts them not anywhere near the worst camp”
For the first time since 2009, there is a credible way to decentralize monetary systems without sacrificing efficiency—through technologies like Bitcoin that provide a decentralized ledger achieving greater efficiency in many aspects without requiring greater centralization.
“what I I find so interesting ever since 2009 is that for the first time we have a pretty credible way to decentralize some of this um and so you know with Bitcoin for example...the underlying thing that's happening there is something that I think is unfortunately not getting the detention that it probably deserves because of all those issues and so really what Bitcoin represents is a ledger that is decentralized and so it's the first time arguably where you get greater efficiency in many aspects but it does not come at the cost of Greater centralization”
The earliest documented use case of Bitcoin was Wikileaks in 2011, when it was deplatformed from PayPal and other systems and began accepting Bitcoin donations—an early demonstration of Bitcoin's utility for circumventing financial censorship.
“one of the earliest known use cases of it was Wikileaks um they were deplatformed back in 2011 uh from PayPal and other systems they started accepting donations in Bitcoin”
Venture capital in the crypto space separated financial outcomes from operational outcomes: VCs would invest in token deals with 2-year lockups, hype the project, get coins listed on exchanges, sell to retail investors, and exit rich regardless of whether the project succeeded—unlike traditional VC where returns are tied to actual company success.
“In traditional Venture Capital um someone invest capital and their financial outcomes are tied to the outcome of the thing you're building...whereas what we've seen in the crypto space is you'll see a VC do a token deal lock up for two years um hype up a project get get the coins listed on a major exchange sell to the retail public and then they walk away rich and then that you know 5 years later that project is dead or just it's not relevant anymore and you've separated Financial outcomes from operational outcomes”
Over the next several decades, there will be a breakdown of many currency monopolies, which will be disruptive and politically tumultuous, but when reached on the other side, there is significant promise because people having choices for what they use as money is ethically justified, especially if stuck in a jurisdiction that does not provide that choice.
“I think that this is an era that's going to be heavily disrupted in a similar way that prior eras were and basically the I think the over the next several decades we're going to see a breakdown of a lot of these currency monopolies and it's going to be disruptive and it's going to be um you know politically tumultous um but that when we get to the side of that there's a lot of promise there that you know it's it's most people would argue that people having choices for what they use as money and if they're stuck in a jurisdiction that does not provide that to them that it's ethical that they should seek it”
Africa has approximately 40 different currencies and Latin America approximately 30 different currencies, fragmenting markets and creating friction similar to what would occur if every US state had its own currency requiring constant conversion at major fees.
“in Africa there are some something like 40 currencies and in Latin America there's something like 30 currencies and you can imagine in the United States if if every state had its own currency the frictions that this would cause”
The current monetary system has particular structural flaws, and while decentralization via blockchain may address some of these, adoption differs between developing economies where there are few other options and developed economies where it is more speculative.
“all monetary systems flaws the current one has a particular set of flaws and it seems from your book that you think decentralization via blockchain particular you seem particularly interesting um can address some of these and for sure a lot of this is being used in countries that really have no other to but in develop economies it's more of a speculative”
Most institutional Bitcoin buyers don't want it for its monetary properties; they want it because they perceive others will want to use it and therefore it has value and price appreciation potential.
“it's mainly held by people that don't want it for its monetary property so people that are in the United States or Europe or somewhere that don't really see themselves directly using Bitcoin in the future but they perceive that other people might want to use it and therefore it's valuable and they want to parti participate in the price action”
Stablecoins reached over $100 billion in market capitalization in recent years (up from only a few billion in 2018-2019) and are continuing to grow, partly because they provide actual utility to people in developing nations rather than pure speculation.
“you know I think the first one came out in 2014 and even as as late as 2018 2019 you're talking of a few billion dollars of of total total stable coin market cap um and fast forward over this past cycle you know now stable coins are worth over a hundred billion dollars in market capitalization and still having an upward trajectory they're they're one of the things that held up better in this in this bare Market in Industry because they're actually in many cases providing utility”
Taxation on Bitcoin can be tracked through exchanges, and governments are using surveillance techniques (tracking, analytics firms) to catch people who don't report transactions, similar to how they surveil gold purchases in Germany (€2,000 threshold reporting requirement).
“if the exchange will uh share that information with the government uh especially if it's above a certain threshold...Germany for example I think in in 2020 imposed you know if you buy more than €2,000 EUR worth of gold the the store owner is supposed to like capture information then and provide it”
Bitcoin is unlikely to displace fiat currencies from top-down enforcement, but rather will work bottom-up—first displacing the weakest currencies (those with little global demand), then progressively working up to stronger currencies over decades.
“it doesn't go after the dollar first it goes after the ones that have virtually no demand outside of their borders and only exist because there's a currency Monopoly...you kind of start from the bottom kind of eat your way up and we'll see how far it gets basically if a if a jurisdiction is strong enough to really kind of maintain its monetary Integrity it's it's kind of the last Target that these Technologies really eat at”
Bitcoin and crypto ETF approvals could theoretically have centralized Bitcoin ownership in the hands of large institutions if approved when Bitcoin was young and less distributed, but 15 years of dispersion makes it hard to pull coins back into centralized hands now.
“I think if so 10 years ago when the v winkl v twin they tried to get an ETF approved it's possible that if an ETF was approved then it might have been a problem it's possible that a lot of coins would have been held in a pretty centralized um entity then but I think that because Bitcoin had 15 years of dispersion um it it's pretty hard to rewind the clock and kind of pull a lot of those coins back into into centralized hands”
Bitcoin's value comes from network effects and liquidity: it's not hard to copy Wikipedia's data but you can't replicate the network of links pointing to it or the millions of people updating it; similarly, Bitcoin is valuable because of its liquidity, Lindy effect (15 years with no displacement), and utility for self-custodial portable value—not from inherent scarcity alone.
“what separates it from others is basically Network effects and liquidity so for example it's not that hard to copy all the data on Wikipedia and host it somewhere else but you won't have the same traffic because you can't replicate the millions of links all pointing to the real Wikipedia...Bitcoin has intrinsic value in the sense that it's the most liquid large and safest way to store self custodial portable value”
The problem of monetary hoarding (someone accumulating all the money and not spending it, creating scarcity) is addressed historically by societies through two mechanisms: natural emergence of alternative money forms (shells, tobacco money) when coinage is scarce, and taxation to redistribute wealth—transparency being preferable to inflation as invisible taxation.
“when people came to the Americas they didn't have much coinage with them uh and so they Ed things like shells they Ed things like tobacco money they they made their own money and and some would work better than others and they gravitate towards what is actually scarce what is actually hard to make more of...you can always there's always bottomup solutions for uh insufficient money...the other method that societies currently use used for um you know call Wealth concentration rather than hoarding is that you get taxation”
As an American helping someone in another country get paid in a stable currency around their broken local banking system creates value and is ethical, with the only exception being sanctioned countries like Venezuela or Iran, where technical capability exists but geopolitical risk prevents use.
“as an American I'm happy to help them go around their local system if it means getting them paid in in a in a curreny that's useful them that they can save that they can have autonomy over the only time I would have an issue is if it's a country that I'm sanctioned from sending money to so Venezuela or Iran I wouldn't put myself at risk um even though i' have the technical capability to do so I obviously wouldn't um whereas for the vast majority of countries the problem emanates from their side and Technology lets them go around their local problem”
When multiple entities use the same bank, they can send money to each other by instructing the bank to deduct credits and give credits without changing physical money, creating hyper-efficient settlement within a single institution.
“the top chart there shows a bunch of different entities using the same bank um and if you all use the same bank and you want to send money back and forth between each other you don't have to actually change physical money you can tell the bank deduct my credits give them credits and it's it's hyper efficient”
Governments have pursued privacy-technology-related criminal prosecutions more aggressively than other crypto-related crimes (pump-and-dump schemes, fraud), and this is likely to be an ongoing battleground between those who want privacy and those who want financial surveillance.
“we actually see the most kind of criminal prosecutions is anyone trying to make um private sort of transactions that's where they've been kind of most aggressive and I think that that's going to be actually even a big big Battleground”
The telegraph is the most important monetary technology rarely discussed because it was the first technology that separated transaction speed from settlement speed, allowing information to move globally while physical gold settlement remained slow, creating a gap that banking systems could exploit.
“the telegraph I I often like to say is the most important monetary technology that rarely gets talked about um because it it's the first thing that separated it greatly transaction speed from settlement speeds you know prior to the telegraph anytime you wanted to transmit information long distances especially high bandwidth information um you had to physically go there”
The Hawala system, used historically along the Silk Road, was a proto-banking arrangement where a person could give gold to a money changer in one city, receive an encrypted paper receipt, and redeem it for gold with a connected money changer in another city—an early technology solving friction in money transfer.
“the haa system along the Silk Road was was one of the more widespread systems and in that type of system and this is just an example that can be applied in multiple regions if you wanted to transfer money from one city to another city you could go to your local money changer your local hawaladar give them gold and they would give you a paper receipt or a messenger with a paper receipt...you take this analog encrypted paper instrument you bring it to another city and you go to a HR money changer in the network and you can redeem gold”
Bitcoin does not try to solve the problem of wealth concentration or hoarding—it solves a different problem: providing portable, self-custodial, non-censorable storage of value. Wealth concentration and redistribution are separate policy questions solved by taxation, not by monetary design.
“I I think that technology is going to disrupt that capability over long term...and I think that those are all going to be really big challenges”
The entire history of finance can be summarized as: whenever there is friction with money, the solution has been to centralize some aspect of it, trust an intermediary, and then solve that friction—creating layers of centralization that build on each other (bank to bank, bank to central bank, central bank to international ledger).
“if I were to summarize the history of Finance it's this chart which is essentially that every single time you run into a friction with money uh the solution has been to centralize some aspect of it trust an intermediary and then solve that friction”
The US displays structural imbalances including 50+ years of trade deficits (shown in blue) and decades of rising public debt relative to GDP (shown in purple), with Congressional Budget Office projections showing these trends continuing, yet the system appears stable because we have not yet reached a breaking point similar to how the Bretton Woods system seemed stable until it suddenly wasn't.
“these charts to show the you know 50 plus years of us structural trade deficits um in blue and uh Decades of rising public debt the GDP in purple and projections this is from the Congressional budget office for how things are likely going to be the future”
Federal Reserve chairman Powell acknowledged to 60 Minutes that fiscal sustainability is a major long-term issue and a very difficult issue to work through, indicating uncertainty about solutions to mounting US debt.
“the Federal Reserve chairman was just on 60 Minutes this past week and he was asked about fiscal sustainability and he said you know it's it's a major long-term issue that he's you know it's a it's a very difficult issue to work through”
Bitcoin is in a phase of market expansion where ETF adoption flows are coming from existing centralized custody (like Grayscale) to newer ETFs, but this represents movement of coins between custodians, not centralization into fewer hands.
“so you know prior to these ETFs who had grayscale a publicly tradable trust and a lot of what we're seeing recently is funds are flowing out of grayscale because it's higher fees and they're growing to these newer ETFs but most of them use coinbase as their custodian anyway uh with the exception of fidelity and a couple others so a lot of times you'll see coinbase just basically updating their Ledger saying okay these coins are no longer in grayscale they're now on Black Rock”
An unrealized capital gain (increase in value without selling) should not be taxable, similar to how a house that appreciates in value is not taxed unless sold. Taxing unrealized gains on cryptocurrencies would be insane policy—like taxing a house for gaining value without transaction.
“I don't own any cryptos but it will be subject to uh taxation just with the increase in the value my understanding that you cannot tax a capital gain that is not realized so this is an unrealized capital gain it's like capital gain with the house some politicians try to make capital gains on your property if it gains value even without transacting that property that's that's insane of course”
Regulating code is difficult because code is speech (numbers and words in a certain order), especially in open-source contexts where people decide to what extent they interact with it—but the real regulatory battleground should be around venture capital incentive misalignment.
“regulating code is hard because code is many ways speech you know you're putting numbers and words out there in a certain order and people are especially in an open source context deciding to what extent they want to interact with that it's very hard it's multi multifaceted thing to try to regulate um but what's more interesting I think and what I think we learned a lot from the past cycle is Venture Capital”
Bitcoin ownership distribution follows the pattern of startups: founders have large percentages initially, early investors have significant stakes, but as the network matures over decades, ownership naturally disperses as early holders sell and pass wealth down, similar to how corporate equity disperses over time.
“the coins are kind of dispersing in a similar way that um you know in a startup company in the beginning the founder might have 50% of the company and a couple other early investors might have you know several percentage points but then as the company grows matures and and becomes this widely held multi-decade existing thing ownership tends to diffuse eventually the owners you know sell some of their some of their Capital they pass away the ownership gets diffused and Bitcoin kind of going through a similar thing except instead of being Equity it's money”
Of the world's 160+ currencies, many operate like casino chips or arcade tokens with moneyness almost entirely confined to their issuing jurisdiction—an Egyptian pound has very little utility outside Egypt and is harder to exchange than a gold coin or Bitcoin, similar to how a casino chip loses value outside the casino.
“there's 160 different currencies in the world and many of them operate similarly to how we kind of think of arcade tokens or casino chips...There's very little I could do with this in New Jersey all the moneyness of this is basically void outside of Egypt there's there's nobody that wants this it's very hard to get this off my hands it'd be easier to get a gold coin or a Bitcoin off my hands for something than than this similar to how a casino chip or an arcade token mainly just has value in or near the issuer”
The crypto industry has been problematic in many ways (speculation, fraud, currency volatility), but the core underlying use cases—enabling people to go around their local banking systems—are important and deserve attention despite the industry's bad incentives.
“I would invite people to explore this technology not to miss it despite the fact that the industry as a whole has been very problematic but when you strip away a lot of the bad incentives that are overlaid on top of it some of the core underlying use cases um are impactful”
Stablecoins and CBDCs both use digital rails to move fiat currency, and both can be implemented through public-private combinations, but Alden is critical of CBDCs because they represent the capstone of centuries of centralization—extending centralized control down to the retail level and potentially eliminating privacy.
“stable coins and cbdcs have a lot in common they're they're using digital rails to move fiat currency...I've been critical of Central Bank digital currencies because you know I talked about in the talk there that you have centuries where almost every the solution to almost every money friction was further centralize it um and in some in many ways Central Bank digital currencies is kind of the Capstone of that everything down to the retail money level is basically centralized”
Carolyn Wilkins, a central banker, observes that the book's exploration of monetary history is notable because it invokes a grassroots element to money (seashells, video game currency) that people have forgotten about, especially in thinking everything is centralized.
“the thing that you really do notice is that you can have seashells you can have money that's coming from organically from video games um but there's this long history of Grassroots element to money that we've forgotten about especially if we thinker everything's centralized”
Trust in monetary systems is sometimes imposed by circumstance rather than choice—Egyptians never chose to trust the Egyptian Central Bank with their savings, yet they are forced to denominate wages, debts, and savings in Egyptian pounds, making whoever controls the ledger (whether benign, malevolent, or incompetent) wielder of the most powerful monopoly.
“Egypt's a country of a 100 million people and most people there never chose to trust the Egyptian Central Bank with their savings or or what they're denominating their wages in just by happen stance of where they're born this is the entity that has a pretty significant Monopoly over them MoneyWise which is arguably the most powerful Monopoly you could have the the Monopoly of what everyone's denominating their unit in what their debts denominated in um what their savings are denominated in”
The fundamental question of who controls the monetary ledger matters significantly to monetary policy, citizen welfare, human rights, and privacy—this is Alden's core argument that the book highlights but that is rarely discussed in mainstream monetary policy.
“the thing that you really do notice...it was quite interesting to me to see your perspective but the thing that you really do notice is...well how much does it matter who controls the Ledger it matter to monetary matter to the welfare of of citizens does it matter to their human rights or to their privacy”