
What this covers
This Aspen Ideas Festival panel, moderated by Alexandra Galone, brings together Bill Browder, Maria Pevchikh of Navalny's anti-corruption foundation, the historian Simon Sebag Montefiore, and the exiled journalist Mik Ziger (Mikhail Zygar). It starts from the murder of Alexei Navalny and the earlier death of Browder's lawyer Sergei Magnitsky, who was held for 358 days after exposing a $230 million fraud. From there the panel asks how Corruption and fear hold the Kremlin together, and what could loosen that hold.
The disagreements are sharpest on a few points. Pevchikh describes Navalny's death as a planned, multi-stage killing tied to a failed exchange deal with the West. She rejects the US intelligence view that Vladimir Putin did not directly order it. Montefiore backs her, arguing that decisions like this are made in small conversations with nothing written down, so Western analysts looking for signed orders are naive. He also places Putin below Stalin in scale of terror, and he describes a system that prizes loyalty over competence and works like a mafia boss balancing rival factions.
On pressure, Browder points to the roughly $300 billion in frozen central bank reserves and a similar sum in oligarch assets. He notes that oil still brings in $500 million to $1 billion a day and that about 40% of the budget goes to the war. He also quotes a Jake Sullivan remark to argue that Western aid is calibrated so Ukraine does not lose but does not win. Ziger argues that Sanctions should hit the elite, including relatives who still travel freely, rather than ordinary Russians. Zygar says a meaningful share of Russians still follow exiled independent media. Montefiore adds historical context on how dictatorships fall from within, and the panel considers whether a post-Putin Russia must remain an empire. It also takes up Donald Trump's promises about ending the war and Montefiore's worry about American democracy.
Putin's regime sustains power through corruption and fear, but faces mounting economic and military strain from the Ukraine war; its collapse within years is possible if Western sanctions target the inner circle effectively and internal regime fractures accelerate.
- Putin values money more than human life and uses targeted killings (Navalny, Magnitsky) to maintain control through fear
- Sanctions have frozen $300B in Central Bank reserves and oligarch assets, but Russia generates $500M-$1B daily from oil sales funding the war effort
- The regime's stability depends on the war itself; without military victory or internal support, Putin cannot sustain power against a unified Western response
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Dictatorships are extremely hard to destroy through popular movements because of the vast scale and size of their security forces; this is true in Iran and Moscow. The best hope for destroying a dictatorship is when the regime turns against itself, typically when a trusted insider initiates a mutiny, as occurred with Chechens and many Russian emperors and tsars who were killed from within the regime.
“Dictatorships are extremely hard to destroy with popular movements because of the vast scale and size of their security forces and this is true in Iran this is true in Moscow and that's why it's very hard to overthrow them by popular uprisings because in fact that moment that moment seemed like such a promising moment if you will but then it dissipated”
Navalny's wife Yulia Navalnaya has stepped in after his death, made a public statement to continue his work, and has a very large organization (the anti-corruption foundation) behind her.
“Nani's wife jul Nal has uh stepped in quite a bit and she um she she she has made a public statement that she's going to continue the work of her husband and she has a very large uh organization behind her which is as the anti-corruption foundation”
Post-Putin Russia does not have to be a dictatorship or an empire; Russia itself has only existed in its current form for about 300 years (founded around the time of America); the Russian state was created by Peter the Great and based on empire and military autocracy, but this could change.
“Russia itself in the form that it exists today has only existed for two it was founded not much before America in fact so one always thinks of Russia as this kind of huge block that has to exist in world affairs other other countries come and go Russia itself could change and democracy in Russia one day is not out of the question I believe”
Alexei Navalny was murdered in prison on February 16th; the murder was planned as a multi-stage process; it was directly linked to an attempted exchange deal with the West, and Maria Pevchikh's investigation confirms Putin wanted Navalny dead and succeeded.
“we know for sure is that he didn't just die he was murdered he was killed uh it happened in prison um and it happened in a specific prison on a specific day we have an understanding of how the planning was happening we understand that it was a multi-stage process that prepared for a while and then 16th of Fe February was the day that they decided to uh to pull the trigger”
In Stalin's regime and compared to Nicholas I, the Kremlin works through decisions made by a tiny group of people—ultimately one-man government—but functioning like a mafia boss constantly balancing different groups, ensuring no one gets too strong, and any air who emerges must be diminished so they can never succeed the leader.
“decisions made with a tiny group of people ultimately one man government but at the same time like a mafia boss constantly balancing different groups and all the time um trying to make sure no one gets too strong any air who emerges must be diminished so they can never actually succeed the leader”
In Russian autocracy, loyalty is valued more than competence; the leader identifies capable people but only promotes them if they are loyal first; competence is secondary to loyalty.
“when he said he was bringing up people he wasn't just talking about getting the most talented people and promoting them he often meant it didn't matter how talented they were they had to be loyal first and if they were loyal he'd promote them didn't really care what happened how well they managed things but of course if you could find people who were loyal and capable like barrier for example then they could they would went to the very top”
Only people with access to Putin physically—those invited in the same room—can apply pressure on him; external pressure through sanctions requires activating internal family conflict among elites.
“they are the only people who have access to Putin they are the only people who are invited physically in the same room um Banker whatever you call it and um of course it's that that's the way that we can externally apply pressure so let's”
Corruption is a fundamental mechanism through which Putin sustains and remains in power.
“corruption is such an important mechanism for Putin to uh sustain and remain in power”
US intelligence agencies have said they believe Putin did not directly order Navalny's death; Maria and her organization strongly disagree with this assessment and question how US intelligence has access to such information.
“us intelligence agencies have said that they believe that Putin did not directly uh order his death we we strongly disagree with that and I'm I'm I'm not sure how um the US intelligence Source says how how they even have any access to any information there”
Sanctions that target broad populations (like Starbucks and IKEA leaving Russia) do not effectively pressure decision-makers; sanctioning regular Russians does not create leverage. Sanctions should be focused on Putin's elite—his family members like his son-in-law and other relatives are not sanctioned at all and remain free to travel.
“I always get like a little bit weird when I don't know initiatives like um taxing profits at 150% of every Russian company like all all these sort of sanctions they always like bother me a little bit because I don't see much point and like Starbucks left Russia okay like Russian people don't have Starbucks Starbucks now belongs to ramzan kadirov president of China great I mean same happened to Ikea Etc and and you know doing that makes a lot a lot of people in Russia not suffer but okay face some consequences whereas at the very same moment those people who are actually directly involved in in the war those people who are family members of Vladimir Putin like his son-in-law for example his other relatives um they're not sanctioned at all they're free to travel so like this hypocrisy is like a little bit it's a little bit weird and we always suggest that sanctions should be focused on Putin's Elite rather than just regular Russians”
Bill Browder's mission was born from the murder of Sergei Magnitsky, his lawyer who uncovered a $230 million government corruption scheme; instead of pursuing the corruptors, the regime arrested, tortured for 358 days, and killed Magnitsky; Browder made a vow to pursue the killers, which led to involvement with Alexei Navalny and others, and many more people died.
“my my um uh my my mission as was born from a tragedy of the murder of Sergey magnuski who is my lawyer who um was working for me he uncovered a $230 million government corruption scheme he exposed it and and for doing that instead of going after the people he exposed he was arrested tortured for 358 days and killed and um 15 years ago and I made a vout his memory uh to myself that I was going to go after the people who killed him and that's led to this you know one thing has led to another and and in fact Alexi nalni um her colleague got involved and many other people got involved and many more people were killed”
Simon Sebag Montefiore expressed worry about the future of American democracy and compared it to the collapse of Russian democracy in the 1990s under Yeltsin; he recalled democratic journalists telling him they wanted Yeltsin to win against the communist competitor because they thought he was the only one capable of saving democracy, and he is now hearing similar concerns about Biden from American journalists.
“I'm I'm very worried about the uh the future of the United States and American democracy as once we we barely had de we didn't have democracy in Russia but we saw it collapsing uh um or we saw it stillborn uh and um the N the 90s in Russia in yon's presidency was was a failure and was a disgrace uh and I I still remember um very um Democratic and very sincere Russian journalists uh uh telling me the the stories that they wanted yelen to be uh the president and to beat um the Monstrous communist um competitor uh and for them yelson was the the only one capable to to save democracy and they were afraid that if he uh misspeaks if he falls that would be the end of thei civilization recently I've heard something from uh from an American journalist and they were they were speaking about President Biden and it scares me a bit”
According to John Bolton, he had to place other papers in front of Trump to prevent him from tearing up the NATO agreement; at the Helsinki Summit, Putin offered a deal to hand over 12 Russian Military Intelligence Officers indicted by Robert Mueller in exchange for Bill Browder, and Trump called it 'an incredible offer'.
“according to John Bolton he had to put a whole bunch of like other papers in front of trump not to to tear up the NATO agreement and in my own case I mean this was a shocking thing at the um Helsinki Summit it was right after Robert Muller had indicted 12 Uh Russian Military Intelligence Officers um the question for Putin at the press conference is are you going to hand them over and and Putin said um as long as um America hands over Bill Browder and um and then they asked Trump what do you think about this and Trump said I think is an incredible offer”
Despite extensive sanctions, Russia continues selling oil and generates between $500 million and $1 billion per day from oil sales; this money is spent on North Korean artillery, Iranian drones, and Russian weapons factories; 40% of the Russian government budget is spent on the war in Ukraine; the Russian economy survives only because of this oil money.
“we've made that decision because we don't want the oil price to go up because if the oil price goes up then we have inflation and so as a result Russia generates between half a billion and a billion dollars a day from the sale of oil and that money is being spent on North Korean artillery on Iranian drones and and on weapons factories in Russia 40% % of the government budget is spent on on the war in Ukraine and to the extent that the economy is surviving at all it's because of this oil money”
Putin can sustain 100 times more economic pain, physical pain, and soldier deaths than the West can sustain, and he is hoping the West will collapse and fold before he does.
“and so Putin is able to stain 100 times more [23:00] pain economic pain physical pain death in of soldiers uh 100 times more than we can sustain and he's hoping that we're going to collapse and we're going to fold before he does”
Most Russian opposition and independent media are in exile, but this does not mean they are not heard in Russia; at least 10% of the Russian population watches and follows closely independent sources on a daily basis.
“most of Russian uh opposition uh oppositional media Independent Media are in Exile and but that doesn't mean that they are not heard in Russia uh a lot of independent journalists who work uh from Europe uh from from uh Lithuania or Poland or Germany or Netherlands they have huge audience in Russia we have at [12:06] least 10% of the population of Russia who are uh watching and following closely on a daily basis uh all the news from the the independent sources”
Simon Sebag Montefiore does not rank Putin among the worst historical figures; he paraphrases Stalin saying 'one person killed is too much'; Stalin killed tens of millions; Putin is not yet at Stalin's level because he has not launched the vast mass terror Stalin did in the 1930s and after the war when a million innocent people were shot by quota.
“I always just say you know to to paraphrase Stalin himself you know you know once you get into counting statistics you know one person killed too much is is too much um one innocent civilian um Stalin was right up there in the tens of millions um Putin is not yet Stalin I mean first of all he's he's nothing like as capable as Stalin for all Stalin's monstrosity Stalin was in many ways extraordinary um Putin is a much less interesting character but he hasn't yet um launched the um the the the vast Mass Terror that Stalin did”
Jake Sullivan, US National Security adviser to Biden, stated at Aspen shortly after the war started that 'we want to give the Ukrainians enough so they don't lose but we don't want to give them so much so they win because we're afraid of what would happen if Ukraine wins'; this policy of providing enough but not so much is evident in all Western decisions on frozen assets, tanks, missiles, and F-16s.
“Jake Sullivan who was the US National Security adviser to Biden was here and he pretty much said it outright he said um we want to give the ukrainians enough so they don't lose but we don't want to give them so much so they win because we're afraid of what would happen if Ukraine wins and pretty much every bit of policy whether it comes to freezing the frozen assets I mean to seizing the frozen assets um giving tanks giving long range missiles giving f-16s everything is all about giving enough but not so much”
Western support for Ukraine (US, G7, EU) has not gone as far as it could have, particularly in preparation for the US election in November.
“The US the the G7 the European Union have tried to keep supporting uh you know Ukraine and to especi in particular to shore up Ukraine ahead of the US election I would say in November um but the truth is they have not gone as far as they could have”
Sanctions and asset freezes totaling approximately $300 billion of Russian Central Bank reserves will not return to Russia and will go to Ukraine, plus another $300 billion of frozen oligarch assets, and Russian banks and companies cannot access international capital markets.
“first of all we've Frozen $300 billion doar of Russian Central Bank Reserves and that money is not going back to Russia that money is going to go to Ukraine second [21:26] we've Frozen oligarch Act assets about the same amount of money is frozen around the world that money can't go back to Russia third all of the um uh Russian Banks companies government organizations are no longer able to access any money from the international Capital Market”
No one is making money in Russia now except some oligarchs who own oil companies; it's not a profitable place; a few Western companies (Rif, Bank) and BP are still there, hoping to keep their heads down and continue making money.
“nobody's making money in Russia now other than than the um some of the oligarchs who own the oil compan companies I mean it's it's not a profitable place and and U you know there's a few Western companies that are still there rifi and Bank is still there interestingly BP um is still there”
Simon Sebag Montefiore argues that Western media and intelligence are naive about whether Putin directly ordered Navalny's murder; they look for formal signed documents, but major decisions like this in authoritarian regimes are made in small conversations with nothing written down, and there is no doubt Putin directly ordered the killings of Navalny and others.
“there's a great naivity in the west about you know did Putin order this or that murder and you know the the murder of Naval for example and American intelligence has been very successful for example predict ing the actual invasion of Ukraine um but on this question Western media Western intelligence is is astonishing night naive they're looking for a sort of formal long document you know giving signed permission well you know as I know from you know studying Stalin's papers the real decisions like this were made in are made in little conversations and nothing is written down and um and there's no doubt that someone as major as noal would not be murdered in Russia and have two attempts on him beforehand without Putin's direct orders”
Stalin was the most successful Russian statesman at an unbearable cost in killing innocent people; he created a Soviet Union larger than the Tsarist Empire with nuclear weapons, but turned the country into a prison camp.
“he he he he's neither um he he's deliberately um uh channeling both [26:42] of those because you know Stalin was um by Far and Away the most successful Russian Statesman at at an unbearable cost in killing innocent people but he was you know he he he created a Russian State a Soviet Union that was had a larger Empire than the Zars that had nuclear weapons and so on he also turned the country into a prison camp”
When Trump won in 2016, there were champagne parties in Moscow; Putin was excited to have Trump in the White House because Trump was ready to forgive Putin's murders, ready to tear up NATO, and delivered on these promises—abandoning US positions in Syria which Putin then took over.
“when when um Trump won in 2016 there were champagne parties in Moscow the um Putin regime this was such a glorious thing for Vladimir Putin to have Trump in the white house because um Trump different than any other Republican all previous Republicans have always been tough on Russia um hard hard on on National Security and all of a sudden um Putin got a guy who um uh was uh ready to forgive all of his murders um uh ready to tear up the NATO agreement and and all sorts of stuff and um and Trump uh delivered in in a lot of different ways for so for example um America had had positions in Syria military positions in Syria we abandoned them and guess who took them over Putin”
Trump has said he will bring everybody to the table on day one or two to map out a solution to the Ukraine conflict, but this is unrealistic since Trump has also made false promises (Mexicans will build a wall) and Putin will not back down from Ukraine because he needs the war to stay in power.
“Trump has said very clearly that sort of day one or day two he would uh bring everybody to the table to map out a a a a solution yeah he also said that they're going to that there's the Mexicans are going to build a wall I mean that that's not going to happen there's Putin is not going to back down from Ukraine um as as Mikel said um he's he's as strong as he ever has been in Russia because he has this war this war is not because he hates NATO or hates wants an Empire this war is because he needs a war to be at in power in Russia”
In 2013, a prominent member of Putin's inner circle told Mik Ziger that Putin understands he cannot win competing with the West economically, so he needs to create chaos; he cannot play chess obeying the rules—he must throw away the chessboard, and this was the initial strategy from the beginning that Putin has been following.
“I was talking to to a very prominent uh um member of of Putin's in a circle back in 2013 and that that that that was before the uh the beginning of the first war before the occupation of Crimea and he told me trying to explain Putin's psychology that uh Putin understands that just competing with the West economically he cannot win that's why he needs to create the chaos he cannot play uh chess uh obeying the rules he must um to just to throw away uh U the chess board so that that was the initial strategy from the beginning and and actually he's um he's following the the same pattern”
If Trump wins the November election, US support for Ukraine will stop; Trump's participation in NATO will be diluted; this emboldens Putin; if the US stops funding Ukraine, either Europe must double down or Putin may overcome Ukraine and reach NATO borders (Estonia, Lithuania, Poland), creating a scenario where NATO either fights Russia or ceases to exist.
“in November if Trump wins that us support for Ukraine will stop um I think that that's that's the that's the Assumption we have to make and then um we should also make an assumption that um us participation in NATO then gets diluted down and that's a pretty scary thing to think about because that just emboldens Putin more um and if by the way if if we stop funding Ukraine then then one of two things has to happen either the Europeans have to double down or eventually Putin may be able to overcome Ukraine if he overcomes Ukraine then then he's going to be at the border of Estonia or Lithuania or Poland who happen to be members of NATO and then we have the even worse situation is does NATO exist anymore or does it not”
The situation in Russia may change; the Prigozhin mutiny created a psychological moment when police decided not to go to streets and everyone was afraid because they knew what would happen; this is a model of how revolution starts.
“the situation may change as we saw it last year when when uh pran started his his Mutiny and the psych and psychologically it was completely different situation you know I I worked as a war correspondent for um for about 10 years I know exactly how it looks like when the revolution starts that's the moment when the policemen somehow decide not to go to the streets not to wear their uniform outside because they feel that it's a bit too dangerous and that was the moment um June 24th of the pran speing there was no police in Moscow everyone was afraid”
Putin uses fear and targeted killings (like Navalny) through a massive intelligence apparatus to terrorize people; as the war goes worse, Putin gets older, his autocracy becomes more rigid, ammunition shortages increase, and second-rate ammunition from North Korea is purchased, Putin will have to kill more people to keep the regime running.
“he's using fear so far and a massive intelligence um or massive intelligence organ to to terrorize people using key killings like the killing of navali and others um as at to frighten people um but the worse the war goes the older Putin gets the more rigid his autocracy teams the shorter of um ammunition they get the more second rate ammunition they have to buy from North Korea the more people he's going to have to kill in order to keep this show on the road”
Putin's inner circle is very different from Stalin's or Brezhnev's in that neither Stalin nor Brezhnev wanted to have a yacht, but Putin's inner circle wants very glorious lives—they want to be rich, have good French or Italian wine, yachts, and various luxuries.
“neither Stalin nor brn didn't want to have a yacht uh that that's the new kind of dictatorship they want they have very they they are henis they want to have very glorious life they want to be rich they want to have very good uh French or Italian wine um would want it at the same time”
Thousands of Western companies have pulled out of Russia, and a million able-bodied Russian young men have left the country, making Russia's situation 'a disaster' despite Putin's public claims of normalcy.
“we've Frozen oligarch Act assets about the same amount of money is frozen around the world that money can't go back to Russia third all of the um uh Russian Banks companies government organizations are no longer able to access any money from the international Capital Market so there's no money coming into Russia thousands of Western companies have pulled out a million able-bodied Russian young men have left the country it's a disaster”
Alexei Navalny believed that Russia should be a normal country and democracy, not an exceptional empire; his death represents a sacrifice to this idea, and Ziger and others continue fighting to prove that sacrifice was not for nothing.
“and Alex Nal believed in that we have the proof we we know the person the the uh the most popular Russian politician who gave his life for that idea that Russia is not uh doomed to be an Empire Russia should be normal country should be democracy”
Bill Browder states that Putin is definitely not winning the war in Ukraine, citing 500,000 young men killed, hundreds of billions of dollars spent, destroyed equipment, and barely any progress in the last two years.
“he's definitely not winning this this is costing him dear 500,000 young men have been killed hundreds of billions of dollars down the drain all their equipment has been destroyed and he's barely made any progress in the last two years”
The war in Ukraine is in its third year; Russia continues to batter Ukraine particularly in the East; Ukrainian military commanders are more open than ever about the war having sapped resources, manpower, and morale of their military.
“the War uh in Ukraine is in its third year and Putin seems uh to be right High um you know he's in his fifth uh term of office uh his uh you know Russia continues to batter Ukraine particularly in the East and when you speak to Ukrainian military commanders they are more much more open than ever before about the fact that this war two years on has really sapped the resources the Manpower the uh morale of of the uh of of their uh military”
Maria Pevchikh frames her work as a job, not a dedication; there are firefighters, doctors, and people with dangerous jobs, including people like her; they invented their own strategy based on beliefs to end something very evil destroying Russia.
“I don't want to say any loud and big words about dedicating your life to something Etc it's it's just a job to be honest there are firefighters there are doctors there are people who have very very dangerous jobs and there are also say people who have jobs like us like I we don't even know how to describe it I wouldn't know are we journalists are we politicians are we something it's it's it's we invented our own um our own strategy and our own set of beliefs we are trying as an organization to do everything possible to put an end to something very very evil that is destroying the country where I'm from”
Mike Johnson, the Speaker of the House, was told by Trump not to put the $61 billion Ukraine funding bill on the agenda for vote; it took six months, enormous pressure, and considerable Ukrainian deaths before the funding was approved, demonstrating Trump's control over Congress and obstruction of Ukraine aid.
“Mike Johnson who is the um speaker of the house he's the person who could decide what was voted on and he was told by Trump in no uncertain terms not to not not to put it on the agenda to vote for the 61 billion and it was it took an enormous amount of pressure for that to happen it took six months a lot of dead ukrainians as a result of that”
Bill Browder proposes that Western governments (US, EU, UK) should implement a policy taxing all profits earned by Western companies still operating in Russia at 150%, with all revenue going to Ukraine.
“I I think there should be a government policy United States EU UK Etc that any comp any Western company that is still in Russia um any profits that they earn on their Russian assets should be taxed at 150% and all that money should go to Ukraine”
During the Moscow terrorist attack, the majority of Russian viewers switched to independent exile media rather than traditional Russian mainstream TV channels, which did not interrupt programming to report the attack.
“couple of months ago there was a brutal terrorist attack uh in Moscow and you guess what the majority of Russian viewers uh started doing when they heard about that that terrorist attack did they switch on the first TV channel no they because uh none of traditional Russian mainstream media none of the traditional TV channels uh interrupted the programming to report about the the terrorist attack no uh the audience switched on the uh uh Independent Media working in Exile and started following the news uh from U broadcasted from Amsterdam from vus or from Berlin”
Putin has now embraced the war and knows that war makes his regime stable and allows him to control his inner circle; the Kremlin has started talking about creating a Christian Orthodox theocracy in Russia because religious countries are easier to control, but Russia is very atheistic with less than 1% attending church on Sunday, making this theory impractical.
“he he now embrace the war he know he knows that uh the war makes his regime stable the war allows him to control his inner circle actually now during uh this year it's amazing that they have started uh talking in Kremlin uh that it would have been very Pro very useful to have some kind of Christian Orthodox Iran in Russia so the more religious becomes the country the better because they they wanted um some kind of ocracy in Russia and and uh Putin started appointing like uh the the new minister of of defense is known for two things for being super loyal to Putin and for being very Rel religious he is like religious fanatic um and it's amazing but uh there is one little uh obstacle Russia is very atheistic country less than 1% of Russians go to church on Sunday”
Putin values money more than human life, and has targeted Bill Browder directly.
“Vladimir Putin is a guy who really values his money he values money more than human life and um he's come after me in a big way”
The Russian opposition movement is not gone; it has been silenced and forced into exile, but members still meet, have big plans, and will continue fighting.
“Russian opposition movement is not gone we may have been silenced we may have to we may have left Russia but we're still there uh we occasionally meet we have big plans and uh we're going to continue fighting no matter what”
Since the beginning of the war, thousands of people have been arrested and imprisoned in Russia; there have been some protests against the invasion, but generally there are no signs of a possible uprising because Russian society has been hijacked by a gang of terrorists for decades.
“we had thousands of people arrested uh and imprisoned since the beginning of the war we know that uh there were some uh some protests against uh the The Invasion um during all those months but generally yes definitely we don't see any signs of uh of possible Uprising in Russia because for for decades Russian Society uh was kidnapped uh the gang of terrorists hijacked the whole country so R Russia is is an occupied country”
Mik Ziger believes Russia is not doomed to be a dictatorship forever and will become a democracy one day; he writes books and articles to prove this and debunk Putin's historical myths; his recent book was banned from Russia as a national security threat.
“I strongly believe that Russia is not doomed to be dictatorship forever and I strongly believe that that Russia will become a Dem disent democracy one day and I think that that uh there is no any kind of predetermination in our history and I'm I'm write I write my books and my articles to uh to prove that to to the Russian people to debunk all Putin's historical myths uh I think I I'm I'm I'm doing that successfully because uh a couple of weeks ago my my recent book was banned from Russia and anyone who is trying to bring it uh in a luggage um is going to be arrested”
Maria's organization hopes for a beautiful and great Russia in the future, which is possible; the obstacle is a relatively medium-sized group of people headed by Putin who are preventing this path; they are just KGB agents—not gods or wizards—but people with weaknesses like everybody else.
“essentially it doesn't change the fact that we there is a goal of beautiful and great Russia of the future which is possible on our path towards this goal there is not a large but like a relatively mediumsized group of people headed by Putin who is preventing us from walking up that road they're just people they're just KGB agents they're not gods they are not wizards they are people with their weaknesses with just like everybody else and I don't see why not and I don't see how it's possible to live without without was even trying to put an end to this”
Mik Ziger claims Putin is not winning militarily in Ukraine but is definitely winning in Russia; his regime is much more stable than before the war and much more stable than during the first year of the war when he was losing militarily.
“I don't think that he's winning militarily in Ukraine but he's definitely winning uh in Russia his regime is much more stable than uh it used to be before the beginning of the war and so much more stable than it was during the first year of the war when when he was losing militarily”
Kremlin sources have a nickname for Donald Trump: 'American Gorbachev', because they view him as a narcissist, demagogue without strategy who will end up dismembering the US Empire through fragmentation, and they expect the United States to collapse under Trump.
“there is funny uh a funny nickname for uh for Donald Trump uh I've heard from from some of my sources in Moscow he's called American gorbachov and that doesn't mean that they consider him to be um reform potential reformist or or democrat or something uh for them for for people from KGB gorbachov is uh the narcissist uh demagogue a person who doesn't have strategy and who finally is going to end up with uh dismembering the country with losing like um fragmenting the Empire so they expect um the United States to collapse under Trump's president”
After recent elections, Putin is promoting young people, many of them members of families of existing leaders like Putin's own family (princelings), including about three members of oligarch families in the Ministry of Defense, as part of planning for succession one generation down to make dictatorships last eternally.
“with the latest promotions after the so-called election um with all these young people many of them members of families of of existing leaders like Putin himself patri um the Prime Minister fradkov son who are all now appearing suddenly um these princelings there about three of them in the Min in the ministry of Defense in the new in the new government so that is a sort of um creating a sort of plan for one generation down”
Mik Ziger wrote an article in Vanity Fair stating that Trump's plan with Putin is to redraw the map; Putin's dream is a 'new Yalta' where three greatest world leaders (Putin, Xi Jinping, Trump) divide the world as happened in 1945.
“Mel you are you just wrote an article at uh I think in Vanity Fair uh which said that's exactly the plan that that Trump would come in and together with with uh Putin sort of redraw the map yeah liking that's Putin's dream he's got very uh very precise plan and he's been very transparent for many years uh promoting his plan he wants new Yalta he wants uh three greatest world leaders and in his uh dreams that's him shinpin and Donald Trump get together and divide the world as uh once happened in in 1945”
Maria Pevchikh claims Putin is winning, but not forever.
“Maria I think he is uh but this is not forever”
Putin's regime could collapse within weeks but more likely within years.
“Putin's regime can collapse within weeks but more likely uh it's going to collapse within years”
Mik Ziger observed that the wife of one of Putin's closest associates was enjoying a lavish holiday in the south of France, which does not suggest trouble in the inner circle.
“you tweeted I believe last week that the wife of one of Putin's closest Associates was was enjoying a lavish holiday in in the south of France that does not suggest that there is trouble in the Inner Circle”
Mik Ziger is the founding editor of Russia's only independent television channel and left Russia in 2022 after publicly opposing the invasion of Ukraine.
“Mik ziger uh who is the founding editor of Russia's only independent television uh Channel also the author of several books in particular about uh Putin's inner uh Circle he left Russia in 2022 after publicly opposing uh the War uh the invasion of Ukraine”
Mik Ziger has been watching Putin's inner circle for many years and wrote about the transformation of his inner circle more than 10 years ago; he now follows them and writes a weekly newsletter called 'The Last Pioneer', observing how Putin's circle differs from Stalin's or Brezhnev's.
“I've been watching put in a circle for many years now um I uh I written Al the crem men uh the book about the transformation of his in a circle more than 10 years ago and and now I'm continue uh following them writing Weekly Newsletter the last Pioneer”
Maria Pevchikh was a close collaborator of opposition leader Alexei Navalny and led investigation of his poisoning featured in the Oscar-winning documentary about him.
“Maria perkovich a journalist who was a close collaborator of opposition leader the late opposition leader alexe navali her investigation of his poisoning in fact was at the core of the Oscar winning documentary”
Simon Sebag Montefiore is the world's leading historian on Russia and has written bestselling books translated into 48 languages including 'Stalin', 'The Court of the Red Tsar', and 'The Romanovs'.
“Simon SE seag Monte he is the world's many of you know him the go-to historian on uh Russia he of course has written many books you saw some of the uh covers uh in the video uh including the bestsellers Stalin the court of the red Zar and the romanovs he sold millions of copies they have been translated in 48 languages”
Bill Browder is a financier and former investor in Russia who has been waging a campaign to expose Russian human rights violations, and has been knighted by King Charles.
“Bill Browder uh financier former investor uh in Russia who has exposed corruption there uh and who since has been waging a yearslong war to uh or campaign rather to unveil uh and Lead uh to the uh pun M of Russian human rights violations his work has led to legislation in the US and most recently he was kned uh by King Charles”