YouTube11m· Jul 2020· cataloged

Brains in Vats & Invisible Horses | Existential Basics ep.2


What this covers

This episode of The Modern Existentialist's Existential Basics series is a twelve-minute solo talk by Mark, split into sections on brains in a vat, a horse race, faith and fantasy, and conclusions. It starts from the skeptical point that nobody can be certain the world is real, that the senses are reliable, or that we aren't living in a perfect simulation. Mark's question is what that leaves us entitled to trust. He also asks what makes assumptions based on observation any better than blind belief, since an assumption is still only an assumption.

The horse race section uses an invisible horse called Fantasmas to make the point about decisions under uncertainty. Even if such an unperceivable thing existed, we could never confirm it ourselves, so we could never rationally bet on how it would behave. Popularity doesn't change this. For the same reason, Mark argues, we shouldn't trust anyone who claims certainty. We can trust only what we can perceive or infer for ourselves. He contrasts empirical assumptions, which support predictions and coherent theories, with dogmatic belief, which can't be tested against experience. Science, he adds, has never aimed at absolute certainty, only at being as certain as the evidence allows.

The last sections turn more contentious. Mark treats the vat scenario as a description of ordinary perception, not a startling revelation, and calls perception a subjective fiction we project onto the world. He defines existing as living by faith and fantasy: building a fiction from perceptual data and believing it to be reality. On this view, truth cannot be an inherence in the world, because inherence can be neither observed nor inferred. Truth becomes a value we assign to claims we trust. The description ties this to what it calls "fundamental subjectivity," the idea that objective metaphysical facts lie beyond our access.

Sharpest takeaway

We cannot achieve absolute certainty about reality, but we can rationally prefer empirically verifiable claims over unverifiable ones; our perception necessarily constructs reality as a subjective fiction, yet this does not diminish the rationality of trusting what we can perceive and infer over what we cannot.

  • We can only rationally bet on what we can perceive or legitimately infer, not on unverifiable claims no matter how popular
  • Truth is not an inherent property of the world but a value we assign to claims based on our ability to confirm them through perception and inference
  • The fact that we live in a 'simulation' of perception does not change how we should live—we should still trust empirical data over dogmatic belief

The claims · ranked12 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.84

The rational way to make decisions under uncertainty is to bet only on what we can perceive or legitimately infer, not on unverifiable claims regardless of how many people believe them or how popular the belief is.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Mark

“we can't bet on fantasmas at least not rationally that's because we have literally no information about this horse that we can confirm because we know nothing aside from the fact that everyone seems convinced that he both exists and will win but hang on as far as you know nobody seems to really be able to justify their belief what if they're all wrong... it only ever makes sense it's only ever rational for us to bet on varus even if there's a sense in which our perception may be unreliable”

0.80

Nobody can know anything for certain, which means we cannot rationally trust anyone who claims they can know something with certainty; we can only trust claims about things we can perceive or infer for ourselves.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Mark

“what if they've all been tricked and lied to or what if they've all just fallen for the rumors and hype of the phantasmus fandom... what if phantasmus is actually real actually the magical invisible horse that turns his jockey invisible too well we can't know that nobody can know that which means that we can't rationally trust the judgment of anybody who tries to tell us that they can nobody can know anything for certain”

0.80

Even if an unperceivable entity (like the invisible horse Fantasmas) were actually real, we could never confirm it for ourselves and therefore could never rationally guide our decisions by assuming it exists or will behave in any particular way.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Mark

“actually the magical invisible horse that turns his jockey invisible too well we can't know that nobody can know that... if he were real that he was ever actually anywhere at all we could never say for certain that at the start of the race he would even be standing in his stall when it comes time to bet”

0.74

An assumption is still just an assumption, and if we base our understanding of the world on the assumption that what we perceive is real, that assumption itself is not confirmed and is therefore no better justified than dogmatic belief unless we can show what makes empirical assumptions superior to blind faith.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Mark

“if we stop and think for a sec an assumption is still just an assumption right... if our theory that what we see when we look at the world lets us understand its properties is actually just an assumption that we make then how can it really be confirmed... what is it that makes our empirical assumptions any better than dogmatic ones what is it that makes science any better at answering our questions than just plain old blind faith”

0.74

We cannot know with absolute certainty that the world we perceive is actually real, that our senses are completely reliable, or that we aren't trapped in a perfect simulation or living as brains in a vat hooked up to machinery.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Mark

“how can we confirm that the world that we see is actually real in itself... how do we know that our data isn't wrong that our senses are completely reliable that our world isn't actually fake or that maybe the world we see isn't actually the world that is”

0.72

We cannot perceive what is beyond our perception by definition; the only rational way to live is to assume our fictional perception is accurate because it is the only thing we can ever experience.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Mark

“we can't perceive what's beyond our perception that's implicit in the concept itself so the only rational way in which we can live is by assuming that their fiction is truth through faith and belief that our fantasy is an accurate representation of reality because the fiction we create is the only thing at least to the best of our knowledge that we will ever be able to experience at all”

0.71

To exist is to live as a subject, to live by faith and fantasy, to take perceptual data and use it to build a fiction that we then believe to be truth and reality.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Mark

“to exist is to live as a subject to live by faith and fantasy to take data from appearance from what we perceive and to use that to build a fiction for ourselves to believe that the fiction we perceive is itself the truth and is what makes up reality”

0.71

Truth cannot be an inherent property of the world because inherence cannot be observed or inferred; therefore truth is a value that we assign to things we believe are true, something we create through faith in the reliability of our perceptions.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Mark

“truth can't be an inherent property that would be impossible to claim or prove after all inherence can't be observed or inferred... truth is a value a name that we give to things that we believe are true that's how we create it through our faith and the idea that our perceptions are real”

0.68

Our perception is a subjective fiction and fantasy that we project onto the world; we can only see the world as we imagine it, which means our reality is necessarily a fiction that we create.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Mark

“our perception is a fiction a subjective fantasy which we project onto the world we perceive through faith we choose to believe that the things we see are real... the only way that we can see the world is the way that we imagine it”

0.68

The fact that we are 'trapped in a perfect simulation' or are brains in a vat (meaning we experience reality only through perception) is not a startling revelation but simply the way existence has always worked—it is identical to what we call perception.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Mark

“we are trapped in a perfect simulation a fiction and a fantasy that we can perceive only through the lens of our biology but we need to keep in mind that that's not really significant at all not any kind of reality bending world altering revelation that that's literally just the way it's always been all along the way that we've always existed that in the end it's not anything more than just what we would call perception your brain is trapped floating in the vat but that's just what we'd call your skull the simulation is nothing more than just the way that we perceive”

0.66

The goal of science has never been to achieve absolute certainty about truth; instead, science aims to be as certain as possible given available evidence and to form theories from data that we believe we perceive and assume to be real.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Mark

“we can never be certain we can never know that we know what's real the best we can ever do is make an educated guess to form a theory from the data we believe we perceive and from information we assume to be true and real the goal of science after all has never been absolute certainty instead it has only ever been to be certain to the best of our ability”

0.66

Empirical assumptions allow us to make predictions and form coherent theories from observable data, while dogmatic belief cannot be tested against experience and therefore offers no basis for reliable decision-making.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Mark

“what is it that makes our empirical assumptions any better than dogmatic ones what is it that makes science any better at answering our questions than just plain old blind faith well that's pretty simple actually”