What this covers

This is a live-event talk by Jeff Deist, delivered to the Austrian Economics Discord Server in January 2023, followed by audience Q&A in the final third. Deist compares the current economy with the one before 2008 and argues that the earlier crisis was a banking event. After 2008, quantitative easing (QE)) largely recapitalized insolvent institutions such as Bank of America, and the new base money sat as bank reserves instead of circulating. He adds that the Federal Reserve (the Fed)) began paying interest on those reserves in October 2008. The 2020–21 response, by contrast, put more than $5 trillion of cash directly into household accounts, PPP loans (Paycheck Protection Program)), and airline and state budgets.

The middle of the talk covers the Fed's failed "normalization." Deist cites the balance-sheet reduction begun in 2018 and abandoned during the September 2019 repo crisis, when the New York Fed had to supply $75 billion. He quotes David Andolfatto on how permanent Treasury holdings amount to monetizing debt. He also argues that central bankers improvise, pointing to Jerome Powell's reversals and Bernanke's 2006–07 remarks on housing. Federal debt of about $31 trillion makes interest rate increases a fiscal trap, since interest payments could become the largest budget line. He argues that higher rates also hurt supply by raising capital costs and pushing leveraged firms toward bankruptcy.

The talk then branches out. Deist discusses brittle just-in-time supply chains, California's dependence on a few high earners and on capital gains, and pension liabilities. He also notes that some states, such as Alabama and Florida, ran record surpluses, which he treats as a reason for Austrians to revise their expectations. His forecast that the dollar stays strong because the euro and yuan are in worse shape is among the more contested claims, as is his view that derivatives and shadow banking pose more danger than a Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC)).

His closing advice is rhetorical. Austrians should speak to ordinary people about purchasing power and wages, not hyperinflation or exchange rates, and should anchor their case in Production Precedes Consumption (Law of Production)).

Sharpest takeaway

The 2020-2023 economic crisis differs fundamentally from the 2008 crisis in its cause (fiscal stimulus rather than monetary policy) and impact (widespread across the economy rather than concentrated in finance), requiring Austrian economists to reframe their analysis and messaging to remain relevant by focusing on production-based solutions rather than monetary mechanics.

  • The 2008 crisis was monetary (QE recapitalized banks without reaching the broader economy), while 2020 was fiscal (direct cash stimulus of $5+ trillion reached households and businesses immediately)
  • Austrian School must shift messaging from hyperinflation predictions to explaining how government-directed spending misallocates resources and impedes genuine capital formation and productivity

The claims · ranked48 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

The Federal Reserve began paying interest on excess reserves held by member banks starting in October 2008 as an acceleration of a law passed by Congress in 2006, which further reduced banks' incentive to lend out reserves and circulate them in the broader economy.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Jeff Deist

“the FED started paying interest on excess reserves held by member banks so this was actually something that a lot of people think the FED just end up on its own as a policy this was actually a law passed by Congress back in 2006. and it was designed to go into effect in 2011. uh this was actually a long time monetary policy tool the FED that sought even Milton Friedman advocated this they wanted to be able to control the FED funds rate better uh by or the targeted fed funds rate better by paying interest on reserve so what happened is this law passed in 06 was accelerated to go into effect in October of 2008.”

0.80

A Federal Reserve official (David Andolfatto, 2013) admitted that if the Fed's Treasury debt holdings remain permanent, money creation becomes a permanent source of government financing, effectively monetizing government debt.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Jeff Deist

“they basically came out with this you know this paper saying hey look everyone's telling us the FED is just monetizing debt and we're financing the federal government through this modernization no no that's not true you know that because this treasury debt isn't going to be permanent um you know that that would mean that the supply of new money would also be permanent uh that would mean the Federal Government Can essentially borrow and spend this new money for free so you know they said very honestly they said thus under this scenario money creation becomes a permanent source of financing for government spending”

0.69

The 2020-2021 COVID fiscal stimulus of more than $5 trillion in direct cash payments to households, businesses (PPP loans), states, airlines, and other sectors was fundamentally different from 2008 QE because it directly entered bank accounts and the real economy rather than becoming inert bank reserves, guaranteeing much stronger immediate effects on consumer prices and demand.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jeff Deist

“this was a fiscal phenomenon so that's what's so different between the 2020 crisis and the 08 crisis this was a fiscal response and so we have to understand that under both the Trump and Biden administrations uh Congress passed two huge stimulus bills in 2020 and 2021 now these pumped five more than 5 trillion with a t capital T directly into the economy okay this was this was cash cash as I'd like to say right”

0.69

The US dollar's status as the world reserve currency provides an enormous economic subsidy to Americans by allowing them to export inflation and enabling cheap imports, a privilege most Americans do not understand and which is at risk of being lost.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jeff Deist

“I do think that the rest of the world has a very very dollar off its World Reserve currency pedestal and that we as Americans are really quite clueless about the enormous subsidy that status provides Us and how we're able to export inflation how rich we are how cheap everything is that Walmart and Target as a result I think most Americans really don't have any sense of that and I hope that they don't have to get a sense of that in a very harsh way uh sometime in the future”

0.69

The Federal Reserve has been attempting to reduce its balance sheet to pre-crisis levels (below $1 trillion from over $4 trillion post-2008) since 2018, but this effort was abandoned during the 2019 repo crisis, making clear that 'normalization' was never credible.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jeff Deist

“you fast forward to about 2018 and it actually kind of start Ed trying to do that a little bit and there's a a statement from the St Louis fed in 2013 By a paraphed economist David endelfato”

0.68

The Federal Reserve's quantitative easing after 2008 largely recapitalized insolvent banks like Bank of America through Treasury and mortgage debt purchases rather than creating broad money supply growth, because the newly created base money became bank reserves deposited with the Fed and was not lent to the general public or commercial borrowers.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jeff Deist

“Bank Reserves by definition are not lent uh to the general public uh or to to commercial borrowers they're just lent uh between Banks”

0.68

The September 2019 repo crisis—where overnight lending between banks seized up requiring $75 billion in emergency liquidity from the New York Fed—was inexplicable given that trillions in bank reserves had been created and left in the system for years, suggesting deeper structural liquidity problems the Fed's monetary tools could not address.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jeff Deist

“with all of that new monetary base created how in the hell in the fall of 2019 was there a liquidity crisis in overnight repo lending between Banks I mean after all those trillions of new Bank Reserves how is it possible that we could get to September 2019 and have find banks in an overnight crunch to the extent that the New York fed had to provide 75 billion of overnight liquidity um in the fall of 2019. well I don't really know the answer”

0.68

The US dollar will likely remain strong relative to other global currencies in the medium term, not because of its fundamental strength but because other currencies (euro, yuan) are in equally or worse condition and reflect equally or more troubled sovereign policies.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jeff Deist

“if there's a real shutdown or Slowdown in 2023 that that probably creates a flight to U.S treasuries a flight to U.S dollars as a perceived uh Safe Haven relative to these other currencies which are just crappier and even uh as inflated if not more um so I don't think that that the the you know the dollar is dying I don't think that's a good narrative for us”

0.68

The bizarre U.S. ideology that government should spend more during recessions while the private sector tightens its belt has produced perverse outcomes including explosive pension fund liabilities that will become unsustainable when interest rates normalize.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jeff Deist

“we have this bizarre idea in in the US that when there's a an economic slowdown a recession the government should spend more and that you know the private sector should tighten its belt now that's led to some very perverse outcomes um you know I mean some of these pension fund liabilities for example uh boy oh boy”

0.66

Just-in-time inventory systems and global supply chain lean manufacturing have made modern economies brittle: companies don't maintain reserves of inventory, relying on streamlined global shipping to function, so disruptions cause widespread shortages.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Jeff Deist

“remember these are this is a just in time uh Society we live in in terms of inventory everything is about lean everything's about um you know not having a ton of inventory everything is about streamlining uh using economies of scale around the globe and having huge container ships just take everything around and of course that's a miracle we're all for global trade and specialization uh uh comparative advantage I mean that's one thing that makes us all so wealthy today but you know when you shut it down you got some problems because companies don't have inventory laying around the way they might have had 30 years ago”

0.66

Most people under age 40 have never lived in an economic environment with positive real interest rates and true time value of money pricing, making them unfamiliar with how economies function under scarcity discipline.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Jeff Deist

“there haven't been real interest rates and so anybody who's under about age 40 um doesn't really has never really lived in an environment where we truly understood or recognized the time value of money so that's unusual”

0.65

Very large US federal debt ($31 trillion gross, ~$26 trillion excluding interagency debt) combined with near-historically-low interest rates creates a fiscal trap: raising rates to combat inflation will cause interest payments to become the largest budget item, ahead of defense and Social Security, putting fiscal unsustainability pressure on Congress.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jeff Deist

“if you look at that 31 trillion dollars of debt that the U.S federal government carries not really only about 26 of it if you consider interagency debt uh well the average interest rate on that for the last you know 20 30 years has been very low it's weighted average has been below two percent so you get that up closer to historical Norms of five six seven percent and all of a sudden very quickly interest becomes the single biggest line item in the Congressional budget ahead of Defense ahead of Social Security Medicare all these things people want from government”

0.65

Central bankers and monetary authorities are not secret geniuses capable of fine-tuning the economy but rather are making policy ad hoc and often contradicting their own prior statements, as exemplified by Jerome Powell's statements contradicting his positions from a year prior and Ben Bernanke's 2006-2007 claims that housing was stable.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jeff Deist

“there's really nobody flying the plane uh that these guys are making it up that they're this is all ad hoc that some of the things like for instance Jerome Powell is saying are directory directly contradictory to what he was saying a year or so ago and it Harkens back to when uh Benjamin Bernanke was saying oh you know the housing market looks pretty good he's saying this is an 06 or whatever”

0.65

California's state budget is particularly vulnerable to collapse because it raises tax revenue from a disproportionately small number of high-income individuals and heavily depends on volatile capital gains taxes; as these earners flee to low-tax states, California's revenue base will crater.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jeff Deist

“look at California I mean how you know California raises an enormous percentage of its tax revenue from a tiny percentage of individuals tiny it's even more skewed than Federal and a lot of that revenue is not just regular income taxes capital gains and so if if those capital gains returns drop and and more importantly increasing those you know just literally less than a million people a few hundred thousand people who really fund California if they increasingly flee as they are they're going to Incline Village Nevada they're going to Florida they're going to Palm Beach they're going to Austin they're going to wherever they're going um you know the the drying up of tax revenue is going to just challenge the hell out of these Governors”

0.64

Despite austrian predictions, some state governments (e.g., Alabama, Florida) have entered 2023 with record budget surpluses due to tax revenue growth during COVID; Austrians should be willing to revise their worldview when facts on the ground contradict expectations.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Jeff Deist

“I thought covid would cause huge decreases in state tax revenue and it didn't I mean it just doesn't matter of fact it didn't um I was wrong and sometimes you just got to look at that so I don't know I can't imagine um as Uncle Sam uh gets increasingly dysfunctional uh maybe state and local governments are actually going to increase what they do we'll do one last question here and we'll take a break from the economics and finance our last question here is do you think that the latest All Quiet on the Western Front movie did just the book oh boy I've read that book a million times”

0.62

The amount of outstanding derivatives and shadow banking system contagion is terrifying and potentially more dangerous to financial stability than CBDCs; the debt system has grown much larger since 2008 without addressing the underlying structural problems.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jeff Deist

“well it's it's one of the biggest threats facing us along with what I would say is you know along with maybe second is the the amount of derivatives out there the shadow banking uh contagion uh is pretty terrifying if you think about how much bigger all the debt has gotten since 08”

0.61

The economic crises occurring roughly every 10-15 years during the 21st century (2008, 2020, implicitly another in 2023) suggest that the Federal Reserve's founding goal to 'smooth out booms and busts' has failed.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jeff Deist

“notice we're having these economic upheavals every 10 or 15 years we're we're on our second one and we're only a quarter of a way in into the new century so it strikes me uh that one of the goals of the Federal Reserve Act was to smooth out these booms and busts uh not sure that that's working out as well as advertised”

0.61

Airlines exited the 2020 COVID crisis with larger cash balances than they entered despite having grounded most of their aircraft and suspended travel, thanks to government subsidies that exceeded their operational losses.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jeff Deist

“huge cash subsidies to the airlines I'm not sure many Americans understand the airlines came out of the travel shutdowns of 2020 with more cash on their balance sheets than they went in after having mothballed all those planes in the desert with nobody flying that's a neat trick if you can shut down your business and come out on the other end with more cash on your balance sheet”

0.59

The Federal Reserve's response of raising interest rates to combat inflation is counterproductive because higher rates reduce productivity and supply by increasing capital costs for firms and pushing marginal, leveraged firms into bankruptcy, when the correct response to rising prices should be increased production.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jeff Deist

“the natural response to Rising prices would be more production not less and so there's almost like bloodletting we're trying to get less production we're trying to quell wages and let's not forget it's not proven that raising interest rates per se reduces inflation because if anything increases the cost of capital for firms trying to create goods and services but also those marginal firms that are more leveraged than others those ones that are shakier in their Industries a lot of them might go out of business”

0.53

Austrians should focus messaging on what matters to ordinary people: the dollar's purchasing power relative to goods and services (not its exchange rate relative to other currencies), since ordinary people care about whether their wages keep up with the cost of living, not currency exchange rates.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Jeff Deist

“the point here is that well we ought to care about and what Americans ought to care about is the dollars that what the dollar strength against actual goods and services that's what we care about uh not not it's it's uh strength necessarily against other currencies”

0.52

The general public divides into categories by what they care about: academics and wonks care about the 'why' (theoretical foundations), entrepreneurs care about the 'how' (mechanisms and execution), and the majority of ordinary people care about the 'what' (immediate outcomes: wages, prices, interest rates, vacation affordability).

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jeff Deist

“there's a whole segment of the U.S population or any anywhere you go who simply don't believe in the concept of economic laws right they they would never view it like gravity you know if if the Wing's not curved and the air on top of the Wings not moving faster than it is under the wing and thus creating lift the airplane crashes into the ground you know everyone would nod their heads if the bridge is not uh constructed using the right mathematical calculations to Bear a certain load when the truck drives over it maybe the hundredth time the bridge collapses I think you know people can understand their head and understand that but when you talk about economic laws a lot of people think that's just all nonsense”

0.52

The American public's understanding of money has been distorted by mainstream media and economic discourse into viewing money as a political tool created by government, rather than as a commodified information system that naturally emerged from human exchange to solve the problem of barter.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Jeff Deist

“what you'd come away with is that money is a political tool right it's a creation of government it's a political tool it's a weapon and that interest rates are policy tools they're like nah they're like dials that you turn an old tube amp or something you know I mean this idea of money as a political tool is very very harmful”

0.52

The public should be made to understand that Federal Reserve and government monetary/fiscal policy actions are 'done to us, not for us'—benefiting financial and political elites while imposing costs on ordinary citizens through inflation, asset price bubbles, and financial instability.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Jeff Deist

“we should be uh out there making the case that hey you know um there's a populist case to be made here that these guys are are not exactly what you think they are are that they don't really understand as well as they think and they really are just kind of Flying Blind and they Pro they spent you know the last 10 years uh caterwalling about how there's no inflation”

0.52

The goal of economics as a discipline is to help humans understand the world and become happier, healthier, wiser, and wealthier—not to provide academic tenure, central bank employment, or intellectual cover for bad policy.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Jeff Deist

“economics is a social science it is supposed to help us understand the human world and make better sense of it it's not there to help us understand atoms or molecules or statistical models and so is economics doing its job is the profession doing any good I mean that's that's a pretty serious question from where I sit I would argue that the profession is doing a fair amount of harm in that it's providing intellectual cover for a bunch of bad uh what I guess I'll call public policy ideas”

0.52

The path to prosperity and solving current economic crises is not through new monetary systems, central bank digital currencies, or international currency arrangements under the IMF or World Bank, but rather through returning to traditional Austrian economic principles: production precedes consumption, capital accumulation drives productivity.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Jeff Deist

“you know there's the The Way Forward is not through some esoteric new knowledge or through some you know new monetary system central bank digital currencies or some new currency under the auspices of the IMF or the World Bank you know we we have the knowledge uh everything uh old is new again and and I think uh we just have to have the courage to go out there and challenge the so-called mainstream the so-called Orthodoxy and just talk to normies”

0.51

The Federal Reserve will ultimately prioritize supporting bond and equity markets over protecting ordinary people, which will lead it to pivot away from rate hikes in 2023 to prevent financial market collapse.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Jeff Deist

“I mean I think it has to do that just because of the solvency of its own member banks their stock price at the end of the day um so if you had to guess if I have to guess I will say that the FED will pivot on rates this year and that they won't go up that much more”

0.48

A severe global recession in 2023 would provide political justification for centralized global currency and banking systems under international institutions like the IMF or World Bank by framing decentralized sovereign debt issuance as causing market dislocations.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jeff Deist

“if this if this uh recession which was appears to be unfolding in 2023 if it turns really really serious into some sort of global uh you know deep recession like we saw in 2008 they might seize on that to say well look folks we can't have all these countries just issuing their own currencies and their own bond that willy-nilly and competing with each other you know it causes too many dislocations so now we're gonna we need to centralize all this um uh you know that's gonna hold an awful lot of appeal to politicians”

0.48

Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs) represent one of the biggest threats facing individual liberty because their stated purpose is to enable government surveillance of transactions, selective taxation enforcement, negative interest rates on personal accounts, and potential account freezes for political dissent.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jeff Deist

“it's it's one of the biggest threats facing us along with what I would say is you know along with maybe second is the the amount of derivatives out there the shadow banking uh contagion uh is pretty terrifying if you think about how much bigger all the debt has gotten since 08 but uh if you Google there's a great short segment neocashcari I think he's at Chicago fat excuse me if I'm wrong um and he gives about two or three minutes on how terrible Central Bank current digital currencies are the only reason you would have them is to spy on people to tax their transactions to impose a negative interest rate on them on their accounts”

0.48

Austrians should avoid discussing hyperinflation and dedollarization narratives in the near term, as these are implausible given the relative weakness of other currencies and likely distract from more pressing policy critiques.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jeff Deist

“I think first it's very important that we avoid uh discussions of hyperinflation and this D dollarization rhetoric which is growing I mean we've been talking about the dollars fall for a long time and the idea that the world is going to get sick of having to do international business and clear transactions in dollars”

0.48

Austrians have a strong rhetorical opening when asking ordinary people 'How is the Fed working out for you?'—if they are not receiving 8-10% annual raises or experiencing business growth at that rate, the answer demonstrates the Fed has failed to create prosperity.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jeff Deist

“and I think uh we just have to have the courage to go out there and challenge the so-called mainstream the so-called Orthodoxy and just talk to normies and say look you know how is that fed working out for you my friend you know are you getting an eight nine ten percent raise every year at work or is your business growing eight nine ten percent you know the answer is probably no and and that's our opening”

0.48

Mainstream economists will respond to 2023 inflation by pivoting to sound Austrian-like rhetoric about inflation being harmful, but will then prescribe the same failed policy interventions (fiscal stimulus, monetary manipulation) that created the problem, making them unreliable guides.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jeff Deist

“I think they're going to just pivot and start sounding like austrians on inflation and of course they're going to prescribe the same uh terrible kicking the can down the road that they prescribed the last time around so these are not the people who are going to save America from its own uh political High Time preference Tendencies right if we listen to them we're cooked”

0.46

Economists and mainstream media have a vested interest ('bad incentives') in defending the existing monetary and fiscal policy regime because their careers, funding, and institutional positions depend on that system remaining dominant.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Jeff Deist

“because they still have the bad incentives uh to keep parroting this idea that you can Tinker with knobs and you can use fiscal and monetary policy to somehow create a greater wealth in society through financial engineering when we all know the only way to create great wealth in society is to have profits which produce capital accumulation which produce Capital Investments which produce greater productivity”

0.43

CBDCs are likely to be introduced first as hybrid systems partnering private banks (Citibank, Bank of America) with the Fed in technical trials, before potentially evolving into pure Fed-controlled systems.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jeff Deist

“I think what you'd see at first would be a straddle a hybrid where they're ostensibly private Banks B of A and such involved it wouldn't just be a Fed account but then it could it could lead to that so um it's really quite terrifying and uh you know I think what what it's going to take for them to try to to engineer that would be another real crisis”

0.40

The Federal Reserve's current inflation strategy of accepting higher nominal inflation for a time (to average out to 2% over longer periods) represents 'Monday morning quarterbacking' and 'cover your ass' reasoning rather than principled policy.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Jeff Deist

“now all of a sudden they're like well you know we just need two percent average over time and it's been so low for the last few years you know it's good to have six six or eight for a while because that'll bring the average up and if you look at a sine wave you know against an X Y axis uh you know then it will average out to two percent I mean this is just this is just complete uh Monday morning quarterbacking this is just cya you know come on”

0.37

US financial and military dominance of the world underpins the demand for dollars as a global reserve currency and as the medium for international trade and commodity transactions.

causalestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Jeff Deist

“and let's not forget our military as well and so the point here is that well we ought to care about and what Americans ought to care about is the dollars that what the dollar strength against actual goods and services that's what we care about uh not not it's uh strength necessarily against other currencies”

0.35

Lynn Alden's framework of three types of inflation (monetary inflation, consumer price inflation, asset price inflation) is useful for understanding what happened in 2008 versus 2020.

definitionestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jeff Deist

“I'm going to recommend to our listeners a great article some of you are probably familiar with Lynn Alden she is a she's an investment advisor she published an article called The Ultimate Guide to inflation uh back in 2021 and for a long time it was paywall but anyway when I just Googled Lynn Alden uh guide to invitation at current it's not paywall you'll come up with her website and so this is a great quick and dirty little explainer uh for people who just want to be able to read it themselves or maybe circulate to their friends in the beginning of the article is the three types of inflation so we have monetary inflation we have Consumer Price inflation we have assets right price inflation so understanding those three types I think helps us understand better what happened you know 708 in the in the aftermath”

0.33

Bond yields rising sharply in 2022 has made state government borrowing (bonds) more expensive, particularly for lower-credit-quality states like California, forcing increased fiscal discipline.

causalestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Jeff Deist

“with bonds getting crushed this year could we expect greater fiscal constraints on state governments moving forward as deficits become harder to finance God I hope so um look look at California I mean how you know California raises an enormous percentage of its tax revenue from a tiny percentage of individuals”

0.32

The 2008 financial crisis was correctly analyzed as a monetary phenomenon by Austrian economists, but its contagion to the broader economy and Main Street impact were amplified by extraordinary Congressional fiscal stimulus and Fed monetary expansion that were not necessary for containment.

causalcontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jeff Deist

“that was largely a monetary phenomenon and if you read David Stockman's book The Great deformation there are in my opinion some pretty strong arguments that the contagion would have been restrict to the financial sector if Congress and the FED had not taken all the dramatic actions they did take on both the fiscal and monetary side uh to stimulate and that in fact Main Street could have been okay we could have had maybe a rough year or two”

0.30

Bitcoin enthusiasts have been valuable in directing attention to Austrian economics, and the two communities have overlapping interests, though Deist criticized some Bitcoin discourse as 'new agey' or treating money as an 'information system' rather than a practical solution to the barter problem.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jeff Deist

“there's been a conversation about money in in recent years but I think it's been a distorted one and as much as I love our Bitcoin friend ends and have learned a lot from them and and you know Bitcoin people have said a lot of people to Austrian economics and vice versa um you know what I don't like is some of these almost new agey discussions around money you know money isn't money is an information system you know okay uh money is a way to help us avoid barter barter and it's the most salable commodity”

0.29

Many people reject the existence of economic laws analogous to physical laws, viewing economics as subject to political override and government command rather than as law-like constraints on human action.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Jeff Deist

“they think that economies can be just commanded by legislative Fiat you know you just raise the minimum wage uh and that economics is just complete BS it's just a bunch of intellectual Judo intellectual cover for for moneyed interest in capitalists you know a lot of people believe that”

0.29

Enhanced unemployment benefits ($600/week supplemental payment) during 2020-2021 were part of the direct cash stimulus, incentivizing some workers to remain unemployed rather than return to work.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Jeff Deist

“payments to households remember all the stimulus checks uh enhanced unemployment benefits uh employer payroll loans remember those PPP loans if you stayed open a lot most of us did not have to be paid back if you met certain requirements”

0.29

Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) loans to employers during 2020-2021 were effectively grants rather than loans for most businesses that met requirements, as the debt was forgiven and did not need to be repaid.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Jeff Deist

“employer payroll loans remember those PPP loans if you stayed open a lot most of us did not have to be paid back if you met certain requirements like you didn't go out and buy a Ferrari with them as some business owners did actually um”

0.28

States with fiscal surpluses (Alabama, Florida) will weather economic slowdowns better than states with chronic deficits (California), but the US political culture—which expects government spending to increase during recessions—will pressure even surplus states to spend more and constrain their flexibility.

causalestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Jeff Deist

“as long as you're in a state that's not dying as long as you're in a state like Florida or something like that you um the right now the state budget's coming out of covet are actually pretty healthy I live in the state of Alabama and it has record surpluses”

0.26

The COVID lockdowns represented a dramatic government overreaction to the virus, which enabled policymakers to justify extraordinary fiscal and monetary stimulus that would otherwise have faced public scrutiny.

causalcontestednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Jeff Deist

“because of the severity of the crisis I would argue there was a dramatic overreaction by governments worldwide to this virus that's a separate uh debate but nonetheless nobody questioned in the face of this virus and the lockdowns the economic lockdown that extraordinary fed action was necessary”

0.24

Supply chains remain constrained as of 2023 due to lingering COVID effects, with auto manufacturers still expecting chip and component shortages throughout 2023, which will reduce new car availability and support used car prices, continuing inflationary pressure.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Jeff Deist

“even today Supply chains are still screwed up and constrained from the covid period okay even today things are not back to normal look at the auto industry they're still expecting chip shortages and basically shortages and the amount of new cars available in the United States throughout 2023 which of course is going to put pressure on used car prices because there's fewer new cars to buy so these things still have not worked themselves out okay”

0.24

Technology companies (tech industry) have enabled a small fraction of talented individuals to earn $200k-$400k+ annually without being entrepreneurs, creating wealth concentration in the tech sector since the late 1990s.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Jeff Deist

“I mean America was a real leader and we talked about all we've lost all our manufacturing jobs and we don't make steel and all that yeah but we were I mean we were a king hell uh leader in software and Silicon Valley was a real bright spot and there even today they're an awful lot of people who who you know without being entrepreneurial just you know having some brains and being being good at their jobs and you know make two three four hundred thousand dollars a year”

0.24

The Brent Johnson 'Dollar Milkshake Theory' provides a valuable perspective worth considering that explains why the dollar may remain strong relative to other major currencies despite fiscal deterioration.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Jeff Deist

“I would suggest people go check out the dollar milkshake Theory um uh Brent Johnson at Santiago capital is credited with coming up with that and I think his pin tweet is a YouTube a brief YouTube which explains it and I'm not saying that I'm 100 in agreement with the dollar milkshake Theory but I think it's important as austrians that we're looking at other perspectives and considering them and I think he makes a lot of good points about uh why the dollar might well be strong uh relative to other currencies for some time coming”

0.17

Technology companies tend to lay off a higher percentage of workers than traditional industries during recessions because they have higher average salaries and operated with less efficiency pressure during growth periods.

forecastspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Jeff Deist

“I mean I think that just makes sense but um you know oh I it's it's hard to say I mean how much Tick Tock and how much coding do we need”