What this covers

This nine-minute clip pulls from a Q&A in which Warren Buffett and Charlie Munger discuss banks as an investment category, with an unidentified questioner raising the valuation point. The conversation is less a bank pitch than a lesson in method. Buffett argues that the right PE multiple for any business relative to the S&P 500 turns on expected returns on equity and the ability to redeploy new capital at similar rates. Historical multiples and sector benchmarks don't settle it. Internet companies, banks and brick makers each have different economics, and each has to be analyzed on its own terms against intrinsic value, meaning the cash a business will produce over its life, discounted and bought at a meaningful margin below that figure.

The bank-specific material is where the clip gets concrete. Buffett cites returns of 12 to 16 percent on tangible assets at the commercial banks they own, set against a 2 percent long-term bond. Munger adds that several banks have exceeded 20 percent on tangible net worth over five or six years, which is hard to do in a commodity-like business. Buffett also says part of the improvement comes from higher leverage than was thought prudent decades ago, and that high returns redeployed at similar rates produce rapid compounding. The valuation claim is that bank PEs sit around 0.5x the S&P, against roughly 1x in the 1940s through the 1960s.

The speakers also stress that banks are not interchangeable. Bank of Granite earned 2% on assets for decades without real risk, while First Pennsylvania was run into the ground, and prestigious Buffalo institutions failed, apart from the one run by Bob Wilmer. The most candid stretch is historical. They looked at about half a dozen banks around 1969 before the Bank Holding Company Act ended their ability to buy whole banks. Munger concedes they misdiagnosed the sector by underestimating well-run banks and overweighting the risk of non-banker management, yet says their own stance hasn't changed.

Sharpest takeaway

Banks represent attractive long-term investments because they earn high returns on tangible equity (12-16%) that far exceed long-term bond yields, and market undervaluation relative to historical PE multiples presents opportunities for disciplined investors willing to analyze individual bank quality rather than applying blanket metrics.

  • Banks earning 12-16% returns on tangible assets significantly outperform long-term bonds at 2%, making them economically superior over time
  • Bank stock PE multiples trade at historical lows relative to the S&P 500 (0.5x vs historical 1x), suggesting market undervaluation
  • Individual bank quality varies dramatically based on management discipline and risk management, making stock-picking more valuable than sector-wide conclusions

The claims · ranked16 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

The appropriate PE multiple for any business relative to the S&P depends on expected returns on equity and the ability to deploy incremental capital at similar rates, not on historical multiples or sector benchmarks.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Warren Buffett

“if you've got two dying types of businesses and we'll say the s p earns Exxon equity and and can deploy an additional amount of capital at Y and then you compare that with any other business and that's how you determine which one is cheaper”

0.80

The economic characteristics of different businesses (internet company, bank, brick company) determine their long-term cash generation potential, and these characteristics must be individually analyzed rather than applying uniform multiples.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Warren Buffett

“whether the money comes from a bank whether it comes from an internet company or whether it comes from a brick company the money all spends the same now the question is what are the economic characteristics of the internet company or the bank or the brick company that tell you how much cash they're going to generate over long periods in the future and I would come to very different answers”

0.75

Banks have achieved high returns on equity in recent years partly by operating with higher leverage (more dollars of assets per dollar of equity) than was considered prudent 30-40 years ago.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Warren Buffett

“I think to some extent they've done it because they've stretched out equity much further than was the case 20 or 30 years ago I mean they they operate with more dollars working per dollar of equity than and then people thought was prudent 30 or 40 years ago”

0.74

Investors should focus on analyzing the total cash a business will produce between now and judgment day, discounted at an appropriate rate, and buy it significantly cheaper than that intrinsic value, rather than relying on formulas or metrics.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Warren Buffett

“what you're trying to do is look at all the cash a business will produce between now and Judgment Day and discounted back at a rate that's appropriate and then buy it a lot cheaper than that”

0.74

One should invest only in things you understand and where you can foresee the cash generation for many years in a general way, then buy at a discount to intrinsic value—the name or sector is irrelevant.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Warren Buffett

“you really want to look for things you understand and where you think you can see out for a good many years in a general way as to the cash that can be generated from business and then if you can buy it at a cheap enough price compared to that cash it doesn't make any difference with the name of it attached to the cache”

0.74

Regardless of the mechanism by which banks achieve high returns, if they continue to earn high returns on equity and redeploy that equity at similar rates, the compounding effect creates rapid world growth.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Warren Buffett

“however they've done it they've earned a number of banks have earned very high Returns on Equity uh in recent years and if you earn high enough Returns on equity and you can keep employing more of that Equity at the same rate that's also difficult to do you know the world compounds very fast”

0.69

Banks are not a homogeneous group; individual bank quality varies dramatically based on management discipline. Some banks like Bank of Granite have earned 2% on assets without taking real risk for decades, while others like First Pennsylvania were run into the ground.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Warren Buffett

“I would not characterize all banks as the same I mean we have in this room John four lines who runs the bank of granite Granite North Carolina and they've earned two percent on assets without taking any real risk for decades and it's a tremendous record and then you have other banks that have been run by people that took them right into the ground”

0.69

Commercial banks the speakers own earn between 12 and 16 percent on tangible assets, which represents a fantastic business compared to a 2 percent long-term bond instrument.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Warren Buffett

“the commercial Banks earn between 12 percent and 16 or so uh on tangent not tangible assets that's a good business it's a fantastic business against the long-term Bond uh you know at two percent”

0.69

Many banks have disappeared over time, and prestigious institutions in Buffalo (other than MT Bank run by Bob Wilmer) went down the tubes in the late 1980s or early 1990s, creating opportunities for better-managed competitors.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Warren Buffett

“there have been a lot of people that have run banks in the very in judicious manner but that's made for opportunities for for other people the uh there a lot of banks have disappeared over time I mean up in Buffalo where where Bob wilmer's runs m t uh uh there were some other very prestigious institutions that that went right down the tubes and a lot of that happened in the early 90s or late 80s”

0.64

Multiple banks over the last five to six years have earned over 20 percent returns on equity (excluding goodwill) based on tangible net worth, which is difficult to achieve in a commodity-like business with long-term interest rates at six percent or lower.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Charlie Munger

“there are a number of banks that over the last five or six years untangible net worth the number of them have a lot of Goodwill but untangible net worth have earned over 20 on equity you would think that would be difficult for an industry to do dealing in a commodity like money”

0.64

Bank stocks currently trade at PE multiples of 0.5x the S&P 500, compared to historical levels of 1x in the 1940s-1960s, representing a 50-year relative low in valuation.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — Warren Buffett: Why You Must Own Bank Stocks [qmpVABboOKQ]

“the relative PE multiples of Bank stocks versus the s p they seem to be at you know 30 35 to 50 year relative lows to the s p”

0.64

Banking as a whole has earned returns well beyond tangible equity that exceed what much more glamorous businesses have earned in recent years.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Warren Buffett

“banking as a whole has earned rates that are well beyond untangible Equity you know well beyond I think what much more glamorous businesses have earned in in recent years”

0.63

In 1969, the speakers looked at approximately half a dozen banks over a 2-3 year period seeking those with very low risk on the asset side, cheap deposit funding, and low prices, before the bank holding company act of 1969 eliminated their ability to acquire entire banks.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Warren Buffett

“we bought all of a bank in 1969 we bought a bank in Rockford Illinois Charlie and I went and looked at we must have looked at a half a dozen banks at that you know on a two or three year period absolutely yeah we we trudged around and and we found we found some very Oddball banks that we liked uh and they were characterized by uh by very little risk on the asset side and very cheap money on the deposit side”

0.57

Charlie and Warren have not changed their views on banking despite recognizing their analysis was incomplete, and they continue to avoid or underweight the sector.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“all right I say again we've we didn't diagnose it as a actually turned out and uh even worse than that we haven't changed and even worse than that we won't”

0.52

Charlie Munger believes he and Warren Buffett failed to properly diagnose banking because they underestimated the returns that well-managed banks would generate and were overly focused on the risks of non-banker management.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“I would argue that Warren and I have failed to properly diagnosed banking I think we underestimated the general uh good results that would happen because we were so afraid of what non-bankers might do when they were in charge of banks”

0.24

The bank holding company act passed in 1969 eliminated the speakers' ability to acquire entire banks, which has been a constraint on their bank investment activity.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Warren Buffett

“and then they passed the bank holding company act in 1969 and and they killed off our chances to do anything further in buying all of banks”