What this covers

This is the opening chapter of Hicks's audiobook Explaining Postmodernism, read by the author. It works by contrast. Hicks first argues that an intellectual movement is defined by its premises about reality and human nature, about value, and about how knowledge is acquired, and that postmodernism has a consistent set of these despite claiming to be anti-philosophical. He then sets out the modern worldview it opposes. That worldview came out of the Enlightenment and rests on Philosophical Naturalism, confidence in empirical reason, and individualism. René Descartes, Francis Bacon and John Locke serve as his examples of core agreement among modern philosophers.

A long middle stretch is a history of what modernism produced. Hicks traces calculus, Newton's Principia, Linnaeus and Lavoisier in science, and then medicine, including Edward Jenner's smallpox vaccine and falling child mortality in London. He covers the Industrial Revolution and textile machinery, Adam Smith and freer markets, liberal revolutions, and the first anti-slavery societies and early feminist texts. He also notes that the roots of the opposition reach back to Kant, Hegel and Schopenhauer.

The postmodern side comes in the later part. Hicks quotes Foucault on reason and truth as baggage to be swept aside, and on prisons as the place where power shows itself most nakedly. He cites Derrida tying deconstruction to a spirit of Marxism, Stanley Fish saying it asks only that he be interesting, and Richard Rorty arguing that postmodernists must speak ironically. He also describes collectivist accounts of identity and an education built around non-canonical works and equal receptivity to all epistemologies. The most contested material includes the argument of Andrea Dworkin and MacKinnon that pornography is oppression rather than speech, and the claim that science and technology betray sexism and elitism. Hicks closes on a paradox: themes of exhaustion and cynicism now dominate a culture that is richer and freer than any before it.

Sharpest takeaway

Hicks argues that postmodernism is a comprehensive philosophical movement that systematically rejects the Enlightenment's core commitments to reason, individualism, and objective reality, replacing them with anti-realism, collectivism, and social constructionism in service of radical political activism.

  • Postmodernism inverts every essential premise of modernism: anti-realism vs. natural reality, linguistic constructionism vs. reason and experience, group identity vs. individualism, conflict vs. harmony
  • Leading postmodern thinkers explicitly connect epistemological deconstruction to political activism against what they identify as the oppressive structures of Western reason and power
  • Postmodern critique has penetrated academia across multiple disciplines (literary criticism, law, education) where it replaces objective standards with subjective judgment and group-based political advocacy

The claims · ranked44 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.74

Any intellectual movement is defined by its fundamental philosophical premises—its metaphysics (what is real, what is human nature), its axiology (what is valuable), and its epistemology (how knowledge is acquired)—and postmodernism, despite claiming to be anti-philosophical, offers a consistent framework of such premises.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Stephen Hicks

“modern and postmodern any intellectual movement is defined by its fundamental philosophical premises those premises state what it takes to be real what it is to be human what is valuable and how knowledge is to be acquired that is any intellectual movement has a metaphysics a conception of human nature and values and an epistemology post-modernism often builds itself as anti philosophical by which it means that it rejects many traditional philosophical alternatives yet any statement or activity including the action of writing a postmodern account of anything presupposes at least an implicit conception of reality and values and so despite its official distaste for some versions of the abstract the universal the fixed and the precise post-modernism offers a consistent framework of premises within which to situate our thoughts and actions”

0.74

Individualism applied to politics yields liberal democracy, with liberalism being the principle of individual freedom and democracy being the principle of decentralizing political power to individuals.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Stephen Hicks

“individualism applied to politics yields liberal democracy liberalism is the principle of individual freedom and democracy is the principle of decentralizing political power to individualism”

0.74

Science applied to the understanding of human beings yields medicine, and the new approaches to understanding humans as naturalistic organisms swept aside supernaturalistic and other pre-modern accounts of human ailments; by the second half of the 18th century, medicine increasingly put itself on a scientific footing.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Stephen Hicks

“science applied to the understanding of human beings yields medicine the new approaches to understanding the human being as a naturalistic organism drew upon the new studies begun in the Renaissance of human physiology and Anatomy super naturalistic and other pre-modern accounts of human ailments were swept aside as by the second half of the 18th century medicine put itself increasingly on a scientific footing”

0.74

Even deeper roots of postmodernism run to Georg Hegel, Arthur Schopenhauer, Immanuel Kant, and to a lesser extent David Hume, and the battle between modernism and the philosophies that led to postmodernism was joined at the height of the Enlightenment, with knowledge of that history being essential to understanding postmodernism.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Stephen Hicks

“those figures in turn cite Georg Hegel Arthur Schopenhauer Immanuel Kant and to a lesser extent David he'll the roots and initial impetus of post-modernism thus run deep the battle between modernism and the philosophies that led to post-modernism thus run deep the battle between modernism and the philosophies that led to post-modernism was joined at the height of the Enlightenment knowing the history of that battle is essential to understanding post-modernism”

0.74

Science applied systematically to material production yields engineering and technology, and the new culture of reason, experimentation, entrepreneurship, and free exchange of ideas and wealth beginning in the mid-1700s led to the discovery and creation of knowledge and technologies on a historically unprecedented scale, exemplified by the Industrial Revolution beginning in the 1750s and accelerating with James Watts's steam engine after 1769.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Stephen Hicks

“science applied systematically to material production yields engineering and technology the new culture of reason experimenting entrepreneurship and the free exchange of ideas and wealth meant that by the mid 1700s scientists and engineers were discovering knowledge and creating technologies on a historically unprecedented scale the outstanding consequence of this was the Industrial Revolution which was metaphorically picking up steam by the 1750s and literally picking up steam with the success of James Watts engine after 1769”

0.69

Foucault identifies the major targets of postmodernism as universal necessities in human existence and the concepts of reason, truth, and knowledge, which must be swept aside as baggage from the past.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Stephen Hicks

“Michele Foucault has identified the major targets quote all my analyses are against the idea of universal necessities in human existence unquote such necessities must be swept aside as baggage from the past quote it is meaningless to speak in the name of or against reason truth or knowledge unquote”

0.69

Foucault argues that prisons reveal power in its naked state and most excessive form, where power doesn't hide or mask itself but manifests as pure tyranny, making prison the exemplary site for understanding the oppressive essence of Western civilization.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Stephen Hicks

“rarely do we catch an honest glimpse of its underlying essence for that glimpse Foucault tells us we should look to prison quote prison is the only place where power is manifested in its naked state in its most excessive form and where it is justified as moral force what is fascinating about prisons is that for once power doesn't hide or mask itself it reveals itself as tyranny pursued into the tiniest details it is cynical and at the same time pure an entirely quote justified unquote because its practice can be totally formulated within the framework of morality its brutal tyranny consequently appears as the serene domination of good over evil of order over disorder unquote”

0.69

Jacques Derrida identifies deconstruction as a radicalization within the tradition of Marxism and states that deconstruction never had meaning or interest in his eyes except as connected to a certain spirit of Marxism.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Stephen Hicks

“finally for the inspirational and Phil Safa coal source of postmodernism for that which connects abstract and technical issues in linguistics and epistemology to political activism Jacques Derrida identifies the philosophy of Marxism quote deconstruction never had meaning or interest at least in my eyes than as a radicalization that is to say also within the tradition of a certain Marxism in a certain spirit of Marxism unquote”

0.69

Postmodern ethics and politics are characterized by identification with and sympathy for groups perceived as oppressed in social conflicts and a willingness to enter political and social struggles on their behalf.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Stephen Hicks

“finally postmodern themes in ethics and politics are characterized by an identification with and sympathy for the group's perceived to be oppressed in the conflicts and a willingness to enter the fray on their behalf”

0.69

Postmodern education must emphasize works not in the canon, focus on achievements of non-whites and females, highlight historical crimes of whites and males, and teach students that science has no better claim to truth than alternative ways of knowing, making students equally receptive to all epistemologies.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Stephen Hicks

“postmodern education should emphasize works not in the Canon it should focus on the achievements of non-whites females and the poor it should highlight the historical crimes of whites males and the rich and it should teach students that sciences method has no better claim to yielding truth than any other method and accordingly that students should be equally receptive to alternative ways of knowing”

0.69

Stanley Fish states that deconstruction relieves him of the obligation to be right and demands only that he be interesting, suggesting that postmodern deconstruction can serve aesthetic rather than epistemological purposes.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Stephen Hicks

“deconstruction Stanley fish confesses happily quote relieves me of the obligation to be right and demands only that I be interesting unquote”

0.68

Modernism emerged in the Enlightenment and is characterized philosophically by naturalism (starting from nature rather than the supernatural), confidence in reason (especially empirical reason), and individualism (seeing the individual as the unit of reality and value).

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Stephen Hicks

“modernism and the Enlightenment in philosophy modernism's essentials are located in the formative figures of Francis Bacon 1561 216 26 and Rene Descartes 1596 to 1650 further influence upon epistemology and more comprehensively in John Locke 1632 to 1704 for his influence upon all aspects of philosophy bacon Descartes and Locke are modern because of their philosophical naturalism their profound confidence in reason and especially in the case of Locke they're individualism”

0.68

Although modern philosophers disagreed among themselves about many issues, their core agreements outweighed their disagreements: all three of Descartes, Bacon, and Locke gave central status to reason as objective and competent, in contrast to the faith, mysticism, and intellectual authoritarianism of earlier ages.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Stephen Hicks

“the modern philosophers disagreed among themselves about many issues but their core agreements outweighed the disagreements des cartes account of reason for example is rationalist while Bacon's and locks are empiricist thus placing them at the heads of competing schools but what is fundamental to all three is the central status of Reason as objective and competent in contrast to the faith mysticism and intellectual authoritarianism of earlier ages”

0.68

It is paradoxical that postmodern themes of exhaustion, nihilism, and cynicism have come to cultural dominance while the broader culture is richer, freer, and more vigorous than any culture at any other point in history, requiring explanation of how these intellectual themes coexist with material and social progress.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Stephen Hicks

“and how can those intellectual themes coexist with a broader culture that is richer freer and more vigorous than any culture at any other point in history”

0.68

Dworkin and MacKinnon argue for the censorship of pornography on postmodern grounds: pornography is a form of language that constructs a violent and domineering reality for women to submit to, and therefore is not free speech but political oppression.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Stephen Hicks

“Dworkin and her colleague Catherine MacKinnon then called for the censorship of pornography on postmodern grounds our social reality is constructed by the language we use and pornography is a form of language one that constructs a violent and domineering reality for women to submit to pornography therefore is not free speech but political oppression”

0.68

As individualism rose in the modern world, feudalism declined, and England's liberal revolution in 1688 began the trend of modern political principles spreading to America and France in the 18th century, leading to liberal revolutions in 1776 and 1789.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Stephen Hicks

“as individualism rose in the modern world feudalism declined england's liberal revolution in 1688 began the trend modern political principles spread to America and France in the 18th century leading to liberal revolutions there in 1776 since 1789 the weakening and overthrow of the feudal regimes then made possible the extension practically of liberal individualist ideas to all human beings”

0.68

Racism and sexism are obvious affronts to individualism and therefore became increasingly on the defensive as the 18th century progressed; for the first time in history, societies were formed for the elimination of slavery in America in 1784, in England in 1787, and in France in 1788, and in 1791-1792 Olympe de Gouges and Mary Wollstonecraft published landmark texts demanding women's liberty and equality.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Stephen Hicks

“racism and sexism are obvious affronts to individualism and so had been increasingly on the defensive as the 18th century progressed for the first time ever in history societies were formed for the elimination of slavery in America in 1784 in England in 1787 and a year later in France and in 1791 and 1792 the publication of Olympique de gouges declaration of the rights of women and Mary Wollstonecraft's a vindication of the rights of women landmarks in the push for women's liberty and equality”

0.68

Adam Smith's Wealth of Nations, published in 1776, is the landmark text in the history of modern economic theory and practice, and as markets became freer and more international with the application of Smith's insights, the amount of wealth available increased dramatically.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Stephen Hicks

“capturing and extending those insights Adam Smith's Wealth of Nations published in 1776 is the landmark text in the history of modern economics theory and practice developed in tandem and as Marcus became freer and more international the amount of wealth available increased dramatically”

0.68

Thomas Arkwright's water frame (1769), James Hargreaves's spinning jenny (around 1769), and Samuel Crompton's mule (1779) revolutionized spinning and weaving between 1760 and 1780, during which period British consumption of raw cotton increased 540 percent from 1.2 to 6.5 million pounds.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Stephen Hicks

“Thomas Arkwright's water frame 1769 James Hargreaves spinning jenny around 1769 and Samuel Crompton's mule 1779 all revolutionised spinning and weaving between 1760 and 1780 for example British consumption of raw cotton went up five hundred and forty percent for 1.2 to 6.5 million pounds”

0.68

Combined with the rise in wealth from capitalism, modern medicine increased human longevity dramatically; Edward Jenner's discovery of the smallpox vaccine in 1796 provided protection against a major 18th-century killer and established the science of immunization; and advances in obstetrics contributed to significant decline of infant mortality rates, with London's death rate for children before age five falling from 74.5 percent (1732-1749) to 31.8 percent (1810-1829).

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Stephen Hicks

“the outstanding consequence was that combined with the rise in wealth modern medicine increased human longevity dramatically Edward generous discovery of the smallpox vaccine in 1796 for example both provided a protection against a major killer of the 18th century and established the science of immunization advances in obstetrics both established it as a separate branch of medicine and more strikingly contributed to the significant decline of infant mortality rates in London for example the death rate for children before the age of five fell from 74 point 5 percent in 1732 1749 to 31.8% in 1810 to 1829”

0.68

Science and technology are either good for all, extending human knowledge and making the world healthier, cleaner, and more productive, or they betray elitism, sexism, and destructiveness through discriminating against certain speeds, choosing phallic symbols, and building weapons of destruction.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Stephen Hicks

“whether Science and Technology are good for all extending our knowledge of the universe and making the world healthier cleaner and more productive or whether science betrays its elitism sexism and destructiveness by making the speed of light the fastest phenomenon therefore unfairly privilege in it over other speeds by having chosen the phallic symbol I to represent the square root of negative 1”

0.68

The application of reason to understanding nature, systematically pursued by Enlightenment thinkers, yielded the foundations of all major branches of modern science: Isaac Newton and Gottfried Leibniz independently developed calculus (Newton in 1666, Leibniz publishing in 1675); Newton's Principia Mathematica appeared in 1687; Linnaeus published Systema Naturae in 1735 and Philosophia Botanica in 1751; Antoine Lavoisier published his Traité Élémentaire de Chimie in 1789.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Stephen Hicks

“Enlightenment thinkers lay the foundations of all the major branches of science in mathematics Isaac Newton and Gottfried Leibniz independently developed the calculus Newton developing his version in 1666 and Leibniz publishing his in 1675 the most monumental publication in the history of modern physics Newton's Principia Mathematica appeared in 1687 a century of unprecedented investigation and achievement led to the production of carolus linnaeus --is Systema naturae in 1735 and philosophia Botanica in 1751...to the production of Antoine Lavoisier's traité élémentaire de chimie treatise on chemical elements in 1789”

0.65

Richard Rorty argues that postmodernists must use language ironically because to assert that postmodernism is true would be self-contradictory, and therefore philosophers sympathetic to postmodernism must avoid suggesting their philosophy corresponds to how things really are.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Stephen Hicks

“Richard Rorty has elaborated on that theme explaining that that is not to say that post-modernism is true or that it offers knowledge such assertions would be self contradictory so post modernists must use language ironically quote the difficulty faced by a philosopher who like myself is sympathetic to this suggestion for example fuko's one who thinks of himself as auxiliary to the poet rather than to the physicist is to avoid hinting that this suggestion gets something right that my sort of philosophy corresponds to the way things really are for this talk of Correspondence brings back just the idea that my sort of philosopher wants to get rid of”

0.65

Postmodernist accounts of human nature are consistently collectivist, holding that individual identities are largely constructed by the social-linguistic groups to which they belong, with groups varying radically across dimensions of sex, race, ethnicity, and wealth.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Stephen Hicks

“postmodernist accounts of human nature are consistently collectivist holding that individuals identities are largely constructed by the social linguistic groups that they are a part of those groups varying radically across the dimensions of sex race ethnicity and wealth”

0.64

We have entered a postmodern intellectual age in which modernism has died and a revolutionary era is upon us that is liberated from the oppressive strictures of the past but quieted by its expectations for the future.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Stephen Hicks

“by most accounts we have entered a new intellectual age we are postmodern now leading intellectuals tell us that modernism has died and that a revolutionary era is upon us an era liberated from the oppressive strictures of the past but at the same time is quieted by its expectations for the future”

0.64

In postmodern literary criticism, authors and characters who least embody the correct (politically approved) attitudes are subject to the greatest amount of deconstruction; for example, Nathaniel Hawthorne's ambivalence about Hester Prynne's moral status in The Scarlet Letter reveals his complicity with an authoritarian, conformist, and repressive masculine religious establishment, or Herman Melville's Moby Dick, while presented as exploring universal themes, actually represents the exploitative authoritarianism of imperialistic patriarchalism.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Stephen Hicks

“authors and characters who least embody the correct attitudes are naturally subject to the greatest amount of deconstruction Nathaniel Hawthorne for example in the scarlet letter seems at least ambivalent about Hester Prynne's moral status and this ambivalence reveals that he has sold out to an authoritarian conformist and repressive masculine religious establishment or Herman Melville and Moby Dick may have thought he was exploring universal themes of personal and social ambition man and nature but what Captain Ahab really represents is the exploitative authoritarianism of imperialistic patriarchal ism”

0.63

The Renaissance and Reformation thinkers undermined the medieval worldview and paved the way for the revolutionary modern philosophy of the 17th and 18th centuries, and by the 18th century, pre-modern medieval philosophy had been routed intellectually at the philosophical level.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Stephen Hicks

“in a centuries long transition period the thinkers of the Renaissance with some unintended help from the major reformation figures undermined the medieval worldview and paved the way for the revolutionaries of the 17th and 18th centuries by the 18th century the pre-modern philosophy of the medieval era had been routed intellectually at the philosophic wickley”

0.63

According to estimates by NFR Crafts accepted by both pro- and anti-capitalist historians, British average annual income rose historically unprecedented amounts from $333 in 1700 to $399 in 1760 to $427 in 1802 to $498 in 1830 and then experienced a big jump to $804 in 1860, demonstrating the material wealth increases from free-market capitalism.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Stephen Hicks

“for example NFR crafts estimates of British average annual income accepted by both Pro and anti-capitalist historians show a historically unprecedented rise from 333 dollars in 1700 to $399 in 1760 to 427 dollars in 1802 $498 in 1830 and then a big jump to 804 dollars in 1860”

0.63

The pre-modern medieval worldview and the modern Enlightenment worldview were coherent, comprehensive, and entirely opposed accounts of reality and the place of human beings within it, with medievalism dominating the West for a thousand years from roughly 400 CE to 1400 CE.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Stephen Hicks

“the pre-modern medieval worldview and the modern enlightenment worldview were coherent comprehensive and entirely opposed accounts of reality and the place of human beings within it medievalism had dominated the West for a thousand years from roughly 400 seee to 1400 c/e”

0.62

The first goods to be mass-produced in the new factories were cheap goods for the masses—soap, cotton clothes, linens, shoes, Wedgwood china, iron pots—rather than luxury goods, suggesting that industrialization primarily benefited ordinary people rather than the wealthy.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Stephen Hicks

“the rich stuck to their handmade goods for a while so the first things to be mass-produced in the new factories were cheap goods for the masses soap cotton clothes and linens shoes Wedgwood China iron pots and so on”

0.62

In postmodern legal theory, versions of legal pragmatism and critical legal theory embody postmodern positions: pragmatists distrust abstract and universal legal theory, holding that theories are worthwhile only insofar as they provide useful verbal tools, with usefulness standards being subjective and variable, turning law into a postmodern battleground where legal arguments become rhetorical battles of wills with no universally valid principles of justice.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Stephen Hicks

“in law versions of legal pragmatism and critical legal theory embody the new wave for the pragmatist version of post-modernism any abstract and universal theory of the law is to be distrusted theories are worthwhile only to the extent that they provide the lawyer or judge with useful verbal tools standards for usefulness however are subjective and variable so the legal world becomes a postmodernist battleground as there are no universally valid legal principles of justice arguments become rhetorical battles of wills”

0.62

Postmodern education rejects the notion that the purpose of education is to train a child's cognitive capacity for reason to produce an adult capable of functioning independently in the world, instead viewing education as taking an essentially indeterminate being and giving it a social identity through linguistic molding.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Stephen Hicks

“in education post-modernism rejects the notion that the purpose of Education is primarily to train a child's cognitive capacity for reason in order to produce an adult capable of functioning independently in the world that view of Education is replaced with the view that education is to take an essentially indeterminate being and to give it a social identity education method of molding is linguistic”

0.61

Postmodernism's metaphysical position is anti-realism: it holds that it is impossible to speak meaningfully about an independently existing reality and substitutes instead a social-linguistic constructionist account of reality.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Stephen Hicks

“abstracting from the above quotations yields the following metaphysically post-modernism is anti-realist holding that it is impossible to speak meaningfully about an independently existing reality post-modernism substitutes instead a social linguistic constructionist account of reality”

0.61

Many postmodernists are less interested in aesthetic play than in political activism, and they deconstruct reason, truth, and reality because they believe Western civilization has wrought dominance, oppression, and destruction in the name of reason, truth, and reality.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Stephen Hicks

“many post modernists though are less often in the mood for aesthetic play than for political activism many deconstruct reason truth and reality because they believe that in the name of Reason truth and reality Western civilization has wrought dominance oppression and destruction”

0.60

John Locke's Letter Concerning Toleration (1689) and Two Treatises of Government (1690) are landmark texts in the history of modern individualism because they link the human capacity for reason to ethical individualism and its social consequences: the prohibition of force against another's independent judgment, individual rights, political equality, and religious toleration.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Stephen Hicks

“in six locks a letter concerning toleration 1689 and two treatises of government 1690 our landmark texts in the modern history of individualism both linked the human capacity for reason to ethical individualism and its social consequences the prohibition of force against another's independent judgment or action individual rights political equality limiting the power of government and religious toleration”

0.57

Postmodern cultural debates concern whether the Western canon is the best of the West or an ideologically narrow exclusive canon; whether Columbus was a modern hero bringing mutual benefit or a point man for European imperialism; whether America is progressive on liberty and equality or sexist, racist, and class-bound; whether social conflicts should be diffused through individual merit or affirmed through group identities; whether life in the West is improving with rising longevity and wealth or whether America has abandoned its underclass; and whether the liberal West is leading to freedom or exporting oppression.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Stephen Hicks

“these broad academic themes in turn inform our more specific cultural debates whether the Western canon of great books is a distillation of the best of the west and reflective of a multi-faceted debate or whether it is ideologically narrow exclusive and intolerant whether Christopher Columbus was a modern hero bringing two worlds together to their mutual benefit or whether he was an insensitive smugly superior point man for European imperialism whether the United States of America is progressive on liberty equality and opportunities for everyone or whether it is sexist racist and class bound whether social conflicts should be diffused by encouraging the principle that individuals should be judged according to their individual merits and not according to morally irrelevant features or whether group identities should be affirmed whether life in the West and especially America is improving with average longevity and wealth increasing or whether America has abandoned its urban underclass whether the liberal West is leading the rest of the world to a freer and more prosperous future or whether its heavy-handed intrusiveness in foreign policy is exporting”

0.57

Andrea Dworkin argues that normal sexual intercourse as practiced by men is an act of invasion and ownership undertaken in a mode of predation, characterizing sexual relations as inherently violent and exploitative.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Stephen Hicks

“the normal [ __ ] writes Andrea Dworkin by a normal man is taken to be an act of invasion and ownership undertaken in a mode of predation unquote”

0.57

Stanley Fish combines pragmatist and critical legal approaches by arguing that if lawyers and judges think of themselves as supplementary to law rather than bound by legal texts, they will be marginally freer to infuse into constitutional law their current interpretations of society's values, suggesting that liberation from legal constraint through rejection of textual fidelity enables political activism through judicial interpretation.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Stephen Hicks

“Stanley fish marries the pragmatist and Krita proaches in arguing that if lawyers and judges come to think of themselves as quote supplementary unquote rather than quote textual lists unquote they quote will be therefore marginally more free than they otherwise would be to infuse into constitutional law their current interpretations of our society's values unquote”

0.55

Postmodern literary criticism rejects the notion that literary texts have objective meanings and true interpretations, treating all claims to objectivity and truth as deconstructible; in one version, literary criticism becomes subjective play where the reader pours subjective associations into the text; in another version, objectivity is replaced by the view that the author's race, sex, or other group membership most deeply shapes the author's views.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Stephen Hicks

“postmodern literary criticism rejects the notion that literary texts have objective meanings and true interpretations all such claims to objectivity and truth can be deconstructed in one version of deconstruction represented by those who agree with the quotation from Stanley fish earlier literary criticism becomes a form of subjective play in which the reader pours subjective associations into the text in another version objectivity is replaced by the view that an author's race sex or other group membership most deeply shapes the author's views and feelings”

0.52

Lyotard argues that reason and power are one and the same, both leading to and synonymous with prisons, prohibitions, and selection processes, making postmodernism an activist strategy against the coalition of reason and power.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Stephen Hicks

“quote reason and power are one and the same Jean Francois Lyotard states both lead to and are synonymous with prisons prohibitions selection process the look good unquote post-modernism then becomes an activist strategy against the coalition of Reason and power”

0.47

Having deconstructed reason, truth, and the correspondence of thought to reality, postmodernists conclude that reason is the ultimate language of madness, and therefore nothing constrains our thoughts and feelings, allowing us to do or say whatever we feel like.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Stephen Hicks

“if there is no world or self to understand and get right on their own terms then what is the purpose of thought or action having deconstructed reason truth and the idea of the correspondence of thought to reality and then set them aside quote reason writes Foucault is the ultimate language of madness unquote there is nothing to guide or constrain our thoughts and feelings so we can do or say whatever we feel like”

0.46

Individualism and science are consequences of an epistemology of reason, and both applied systematically have enormous consequences: individualism applied to politics yields liberal democracy, and individualism applied to economics yields free markets and capitalism.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Stephen Hicks

“individualism and science are thus consequences of an epistemology of Reason both applied systematically have enormous consequences individualism applied to politics yields liberal democracy liberalism is the principle of individual freedom and democracy is the principle of decentralizing political power to individualism”

0.45

Lyotard argues that Saddam Hussein is a victim and spokesman for victims of American imperialism, a product of Western departments of state and big companies just as Hitler, Mussolini, and Franco were products of the post-WWI peace, and that the Iraqi dictatorship results from the transfer of capitalism's insoluble problems to vanquished less developed countries.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Stephen Hicks

“for a striking example leotard asks us to consider the American attack on Iraq in the 1990s despite American propaganda leotard writes the fact is that Saddam Hussein is a victim and a spokesman for victims of American imperialism the world over quote Saddam Hussein is a product of Western departments of state and big companies just as Hitler Mussolini and Franco were born of the peace imposed on their countries by the victors of the great war Saddam is such a product in even more flagrant and cynical away but the Iraqi dictatorship proceeds as do the others from the transfer of aporia's that is insoluble problems in the capitalist system to vanquished less developed or simply less resistant countries unquote”

0.37

The postmodern vanguard includes Michele Foucault, Jacques Derrida, Jean-François Lyotard, and Richard Rorty as leading strategists who set the direction of the movement and provide its most potent intellectual tools.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Stephen Hicks

“the names of the postmodern vanguard are now familiar Michele Foucault Jacques Derrida Jean Francois Lyotard and Richard Rorty they are its leading strategists they set the direction of the movement and provided with its most potent tools”