
Craig Hemke – Analyzing Shifting Trends in the Gold and Silver Markets, CoT Reports
What this covers
This is a 25-minute interview in which a KE Report host questions Craig Hempy, founder of TF Metals Report, about the Commitment of Traders data for gold and silver. The conversation starts with the setup into 2024: gold's all-time daily, weekly and quarterly closes at the end of 2023, then a consolidation and a March breakout. From there it moves to the current $3,300 gold market. Hempy frames the analysis with the idea that the futures tail wags the spot dog, and then compares the textbook cycle between speculators and commercials) with what the data show now.
The middle of the discussion works through possible explanations and counterweights. Hempy cites open interest falling from 542,000 contracts in early February to 445,000 by late April. He argues this undercuts the claim that gold is an overbought blowoff. He raises Basel 3 and a shift in pricing power from west to east as possible reasons the game is changing, and he asks who would take the other side if the roughly 100,000 contracts of speculative buying power returned. The hosts bring in central bank buying and the first-quarter ETF inflow of $21 billion, with GLD) passing $100 billion in assets. Hempy treats that as modest next to stock-market swings, and he doubts it moves spot prices dollar for dollar.
The remaining themes are more philosophical or market-specific. One is gold as insurance, not a trade, an "uncurrency" held against the fiat system. It sits alongside the contested claim that the debt-based monetary system is nearing a mathematical end state. Hempy also argues that about 2% of financial advisors' clients hold any precious metals, and that people inside the sector overestimate how widely their focus is shared. The last stretch covers silver's consolidation near $30–32, the frustration of holders from 2011–2012, and why mining shares tend to need a silver breakout before they follow gold.
Gold market positioning in commitment of traders reports shows an unusual pattern since February where commercial banks are buying and covering shorts while speculators are selling, contrary to typical bull market dynamics, suggesting either a structural market change or that banks perceive a longer-term trend that retail traders are missing.
- Speculators have dumped 100,000 long contracts since February 4th while commercials covered shorts, yet gold rallied $500 over the same period
- Open interest has contracted from 542,000 to 465,000 contracts despite price appreciation, contradicting the 'overbought crowded trade' narrative
- Large speculator gross long positions are at their smallest level since February 2024 while gold trades 60% higher, suggesting unusual market dynamics
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Gold made all-time highs at the end of 2023 with all-time daily, weekly, and quarterly closes, which set up the major 2024 rally after two months of consolidation in January-February 2024, followed by a March breakout.
“Really, the all-time highs were made at the end of 2023. If you remember, we had those all-time daily, weekly, and quarterly closes at the end of 2023, which set up the big huge move. You know, after two months of consolidation, January and February of last year, then March was the big breakout.”
In a typical bull market for commodities, speculators get long and push prices higher by buying, while commercial traders (banks, producers, swap dealers) short and take the opposite side of the trade to meet speculator demand, establishing a self-reinforcing cycle until momentum exhausts.
“when you watch the the positioning as reported every week in these commitment of traders reports, generally speaking, when price is going up, the hedge funds, the speculators, the average trader, whatever, are getting long...And that's generally how it works. when the mag sevens are going up, people are buying the stock and they're getting excited and they're looking to make money on the upside...you get a big up move, the speculators are buying and then the commercials, be it the producers or the, you know, the banks, the swap dealers, whatever, they're usually shorting and you, you know, got opposite sides of the trade.”
The futures market is the primary driver of gold price movement, not physical demand or spot market activity, as illustrated by the concept that the 'futures tail wags the spot dog.'
“And at the end of the day, what has always been the driving force of price is the futures market. You know, my my old friend Ned Naylor Leland famously coined the phrase 15 years ago about the futures tail wagging the spot dog.”
Central banks have been a major driver of gold purchases in recent years, with 'all the buying has been central bank buying for the most part, not all, but a large percentage'.
“All the buying has been central bank buying for the most part, not all, but a large percentage.”
The futures market, not the spot market, has been the primary driver of gold price movements, with what was coined as the 'futures tail wagging the spot dog' being the fundamental dynamic.
“at the end of the day, what has always been the driving force of price is the futures market. You know, my my old friend Ned Naylor Leland famously coined the phrase 15 years ago about the futures tail wagging the spot dog.”
In typical bull markets, speculators add long positions when price rises, commercials short into that strength creating opposite sides of trades, and when speculators become fully long and buying is exhausted, price tips over and speculators dump positions while commercials buy back and cover shorts, creating a new equilibrium before the cycle repeats with higher highs and higher lows.
“when price is going up, the hedge funds, the speculators...are getting long...the commercials...they're usually shorting...got opposite sides of the trade...you get a big up move, the speculators are buying and then...they're usually shorting...everybody's going to buy is bought. Price begins to tip over...The selling accelerates the speculators begin to dump...The banks...buy back and cover their shorts...In a bull market, you know, it's a higher high next with a higher low”
First quarter 2025 saw $21 billion of net inflows into gold-backed ETFs, the largest quarterly inflow in three years, with GLD (the largest gold ETF) reaching over $100 billion in assets under management for the first time ever, representing significant but modest growth relative to the $2+ trillion swings in broader stock markets.
“first quarter of 2025, the largest quarterly inflow we've seen in three years, over $21 billion of net inflows. And something like the GLD, its assets under management are over a hundred billion for the first time ever.”
Open interest in gold futures has contracted significantly from 542,000 contracts on February 4th to 465,000 on April 22nd and further to 445,000 by Friday April 25th, contradicting the notion of a historic overbought blowoff top where all potential buyers are already in the trade.
“On that same report from dated in the survey February the 4th, total open interest that day was 542,000 contracts. Total open interest last Tuesday the 22nd, 465,000 contracts. It's fallen even more. Heck, as of Friday, 3 days after this most recent survey, we're down to 445.”
The debt-based monetary system is approaching its mathematical end state, and gold ownership is necessary preparation for this eventual collapse, providing motivation for long-term precious metals accumulation.
“I've for 15 years trying to get people to prepare for the end of this debt-based monetary system by owning gold and I still got people on my side. They're like, you know what, I'd have given up in 2015 if you weren't so damn ardent that the math was the math. And now I've hung in there and gold's three, you know, three times higher and I'm glad I got it.”
Silver has shown a multi-year consolidation pattern at the $30-32 level for approximately one year after a 2020-2023 period of consolidation between $20-30, which is a ratcheting higher pattern that, while less dramatic than desired, represents progress in establishing higher price floors.
“silver was moving down once silver gave up that $20 level back in 2013. It took until 2020 7 years to get back above $20 and then it it really did in a way try to stabilize above $20. Yeah, we had a little drop in 2022, but broadly silver was between about $30 and $20. And then we finally had that breakout above $30 after about 3 4 years of consolidating there. And now we're back holding above $30. This has been for about a year, a little over a year now. So this is a higher pricing environment.”
Gold made all-time daily, weekly, and quarterly closes at the end of 2023, which set up the big move in 2024, not the more recent April 2024 move, making 2024 technically a continuation of a setup from late 2023.
“Really, the all-time highs were made at the end of 2023. If you remember, we had those all-time daily, weekly, and quarterly closes at the end of 2023, which set up the big huge move. You know, after two months of consolidation, January and February of last year, then March was the big breakout.”
The unusual gold market structure (commercials buying while speculators sell despite rising prices) may signal a fundamental shift in market dynamics, possibly related to Basel 3 regulations or a shift in pricing power from west to east, suggesting 'the game' of gold trading may be changing.
“I'm wondering, you know, and again, I don't there's so many moving parts here, you can't really ascribe it to one thing, but you know, I read things about, you know, this Basel 3 deal, you know, and whether um uh pricing power is shifting east, you know, and all these different things. And it just makes you wonder if somehow the game is changing”
Only about 98% of financial advisors' clients own zero precious metals, indicating the sector is vastly underowned and not at saturation despite recent ETF inflows and rising prices.
“I mean still what 98% of financial advisors or something admit their clients don't have anything uh in the precious metals.”
When speculators in futures markets have a 100,000 contract reduction in buying power and commercials are not taking the opposite side, there is a structural question about who will provide the counter-liquidity if speculators re-engage the market.
“What if we go back from here to a kind of traditional sense where these hedge funds start buying again? Like I said, they're their gross position is a 100,000 contracts less than it less than it was two months ago. Well, what if that 100,000 contracts of buying power, buying whatever comes back in? Well, who's taking the other side of that trade if the if the commercials aren't?”
Mining stocks (specifically Ag Eagle) have appreciated 250% in the past year while showing relative underperformance compared to gold, yet this still represents significant returns for those holding during this period.
“If Ag Eagle is more than double, like to up 250% in the last year”
Central bank buying has accounted for a large percentage, though not all, of the recent gold demand driving prices higher, suggesting institutional (official sector) demand is supporting the bull market.
“all the buying has been central bank buying for the most part, not all, but a large percentage.”
Gold should be viewed as an uncurrency (a currency with no fiat connection to any specific country) and a currency of last resort or insurance policy against the fiat system, rather than as a momentum trade or crowded speculative position, which fundamentally reframes how to evaluate whether gold is 'overbought.'
“I think it's a good point, Craig, because people don't say that, you know, the dollar is a crowded trade or the yen's a crowded trade because they're currencies. And really, gold is an uncurrency. It's a currency that has no fiat connection to any country. So even if uh a lot more people piled into gold, it's not really a trade. It's an insurance policy. So it's it's kind of crazy to think of it as a crowded trade or even as a momentum trade because it's not. It's a currency of last resort and it's something to counterbalance all the risk in the fiat system.”
Despite extensive discussion online about gold being a crowded trade with overbought technicals, only about 2% of financial advisors admit their clients hold any precious metals, meaning gold adoption remains extremely narrow even at higher price levels.
“I mean still what 98% of financial advisors or something admit their clients don't have anything uh in the precious metals. So I mean maybe it's it's okay it can get overbought from a technical perspective but that's how you know bull markets operate.”
Mining share proxies (like GDX) have historically been more correlated to silver prices than gold prices due to computer-driven market dynamics, creating a dependency where silver must break out first to generate sufficient momentum in mining equities.
“the curious thing about our computer-driven markets is that the GDX and as a proxy for the shares seems linked long-term at least to silver prices more than gold. Now, this year it's performed kind of better than silver and closer to gold uh since the first of the year, but nonetheless, um we his history has shown that we need silver to go up to get the shares to go up for whatever reason.”
The impact of ETF purchases on spot gold prices is uncertain because it is unclear whether ETF inflows directly translate to physical gold purchases in the vaults or if ETF shares are sourced from existing holdings, making the dollar-for-dollar price impact of $20 billion in ETF flows unclear.
“Well, I would there's two points there. one, how much does that actually impact price? And I don't think anybody really knows the answer. You know, money flowing into the GLD or some other ETF, do they really immediately go right out and secure gold with clear title and they got to go buy it on the open market to put it in the vaults in London? I mean, so how much is is there a direct dollar fordoll impact or is it a dollar a penny impact? I don't know.”
If the 100,000 contracts of buying power that hedge fund speculators shed over the past two months were to return to the market as it has historically, and commercials are no longer shorting to absorb that demand, there would be no clear counterparty to take the opposite side of new speculative long positions.
“what if we go back from here to a kind of traditional sense where these hedge funds start buying again? Like I said, they're their gross position is a 100,000 contracts less than it less than it was two months ago. Well, what if that 100,000 contracts of buying power, buying whatever comes back in? Well, who's taking the other side of that trade if the if the commercials aren't? So, anyway, I I say all this because I read this stuff.”
Gold should not be conceptualized as a crowded trade or momentum trade because it functions as an uncurrency (a currency with no fiat connection to any country) and an insurance policy against systemic fiat risks, fundamentally different from traditional financial trades.
“people don't say that, you know, the dollar is a crowded trade or the yen's a crowded trade because they're currencies. And really, gold is an uncurrency. It's a currency that has no fiat connection to any country. So even if uh a lot more people piled into gold, it's not really a trade. It's an insurance policy. So it's it's kind of crazy to think of it as a crowded trade or even as a momentum trade because it's not. It's a currency of last resort”
The concept that everyone in the gold sector believes 'everybody else' is focused on gold reflects a selection bias where people in a niche sector believe the entire market shares their focus, when in fact mainstream markets are largely unaware or unconcerned with precious metals.
“It may seem crowded because some of us that we that focus on this we you know we think everybody else in our little sector is focusing on it but it doesn't seem like anybody else is.”
Many investors who purchased silver in 2011-2012 (at peak prices) have experienced 14 years of essentially sideways movement, making them psychologically frustrated despite silver's recent higher consolidation range, and this long-term holder frustration creates a perception bias toward negativity.
“so many of us still own silver from, you know, 2011 and 2012. And so, you feel like, you know, 14 years of basically going sideways. So it's a function of you know that perspective as well.”
Total open interest in gold futures has contracted significantly from 542,000 contracts on February 4 to 445,000 contracts by the April 22 survey, and further to 445,000 by Friday April 25, contradicting narratives that gold is in an overbought crowded trade where all potential buyers have been exhausted.
“That's contracting too, Corey. On that same report from dated in the survey February the 4th, total open interest that day was 542,000 contracts. Total open interest last Tuesday the 22nd, 465,000 contracts. It's fallen even more. Heck, as of Friday, 3 days after this most recent survey, we're down to 445.”
Commercial traders in the April 22 survey added 20,560 new long contracts and covered 9,084 short contracts, indicating they are not just doing forced short covering but actively taking fresh directional long positions in gold.
“we got to either cover some of these shorts where we're just getting our asses kicked, right? I mean in this report last week in that commercial sector they added 20,560 new longs and covered 9,084 shorts. So it's one we got to you know someone's out there going yeah we got to I mean we're just getting crushed here in this short. So we got So that's a short squeeze where you just you know you finally can't take anymore and you got to cover those shorts. But it's not just that. I mean, if it was just all short covering, okay, that'd be one thing, but it's the 20,000 new longs.”
The positioning of commercials (banks and swap dealers) in gold futures—adding 20,560 new longs and covering 9,084 shorts—suggests these institutions are making a conscious decision to be long gold from this level rather than simply being forced to cover painful short positions.
“they added 20,560 new longs and covered 9,084 shorts...if it was just all short covering, okay, that'd be one thing, but it's the 20,000 new longs. That's like kind of goes to your point, maybe they're just like, hey, we got to get on the right side of this this trade.”
Despite gold rallying strongly (approximately 3x higher from around 2011-2012 lows), retail and hedge fund investors who were persuaded to exit positions in 2015 and early years would regret abandoning their holdings given subsequent appreciation.
“I still got people on my side. They're like, you know what, I'd have given up in 2015 if you weren't so damn ardent that the math was the math. And now I've hung in there and gold's three, you know, three times higher and I'm glad I got it.”
The unusual gold positioning pattern (commercials buying and covering shorts while speculators sell during a rally) represents a continuation of a trend that goes back to February, suggesting either something fundamental has changed in how the market operates or the traditional analysis framework is missing something.
“it's the opposite that's a continuing a trend that goes all the way back to February. And so what we're left with is a picture that's totally different from what you'd expect...It's a very strange and conflicting signal and uh when I decide exactly what to make of it, I'll let you know. It's just so unusual. It's hard to um make any, you know, big statements about what's really driving it.”
Silver continues to lack bullish commitment of traders positioning relative to gold, with speculators adding only modest net long positions and commercials adding shorts in the traditional pattern, while open interest increases—indicating silver has not yet achieved the unusual reversed positioning that characterizes gold's current structure.
“the traditional form of commitment of traders report is still in effect in silver last week. Silver up 60 cents again while gold's up $180. Open interest was up and the large specs uh added increased let's put it that way their net long by about a,000 contracts and the commercials increased their net short by 1,600. That's kind of how it always works. That's what makes the gold thing even more peculiar.”
Social media commentary suggesting gold is overbought and a crowded trade reflects a false narrative that is misleading retail investors to exit positions, when the commitment of traders data suggests the opposite: retail and hedge fund participation is declining while institutions accumulate.
“I kept seeing the same message over and over last week. Oh, it's overbought. Oh, yeah. This is a chance you got to get out because, you know, it's a crowded trade. You know, it's a contrarian signal. You better get out. Well, maybe not. Um, maybe this is telling you a different story. And that's all I want people to consider.”
First quarter 2025 saw $21 billion in net inflows to gold-backed ETFs, the largest quarterly inflow in three years, with GLD assets under management exceeding $100 billion for the first time, yet these flows represent relatively small capital compared to broader market moves (e.g., a $2 trillion market cap loss in stocks represents roughly 100x the ETF inflows).
“first quarter of 2025, the largest quarterly inflow we've seen in three years, over $21 billion of net inflows. And something like the GLD, its assets under management are over a hundred billion for the first time ever.”
The gold-silver ratio reaching 100 represents an extreme level that historically has been followed by silver catching up to gold, though Craig is uncertain whether this historical pattern will repeat in the current cycle.
“And when you look at the gold silver ratio, as you mentioned, I don't put a ton of, you know, stock in that. But I do notice when it's at extremes and when it's at 100, that's an extreme...Is it possible it doesn't catch up this time? That for some reason all of history doesn't repeat itself and silver does not catch up to gold.”
The GDX mining shares index historically correlates more closely to silver prices than gold prices over long-term periods, such that silver momentum is required to drive mining share outperformance despite recent year-to-date performance being better correlated to gold.
“the curious thing about our computer-driven markets is that the GDX and as a proxy for the shares seems linked long-term at least to silver prices more than gold. Now, this year it's performed kind of better than silver and closer to gold uh since the first of the year, but nonetheless, um we his history has shown that we need silver to go up to get the shares to go up for whatever reason.”
Silver lacks positive momentum and pricing movement required to attract speculator attention and retail piling-in, such that the silver market functions like a 'perpetual motion machine' requiring an initial push from external forces to generate self-reinforcing price momentum.
“silver just doesn't have any positive momentum. You know, it's kind of like how did silver get going to the upside? Well, it got going to the upside. You know, it has to actually get moving for people to pile in...silver just doesn't have any positive momentum...it's like a perpetual motion machine. Something's got to get it shoved. Got to get the motion started in the first place, and we just can't seem to get that to happen.”
Positive sentiment toward precious metals among analysts and retail investors is good for the sector, as it represents a reversal from years of contraction, and should not be mistaken for exhaustion or reasons to exit positions.
“I see that as a drop in the bucket. I know it's like the old story, one of these days we're going to be talking about real money, you know, a lot of money, billions and billions, but...there is interest in here and it is growing which is nice to see hey look we saw the gold sector contracting for a long period of time that switch has flipped here there is money coming in right”
Silver has been rangebound since breaking above $30 roughly a year ago in April 2024, representing a higher price environment than the 2013-2020 period when silver was stuck between $12-$20, but still a consolidation pattern rather than a sustained breakout.
“let's go back to 2012, 2013. silver was moving down once silver gave up that $20 level back in 2013. It took until 2020 7 years to get back above $20 and then it it really did in a way try to stabilize above $20. Yeah, we had a little drop in 2022, but broadly silver was between about $30 and $20. And then we finally had that breakout above $30 after about 3 4 years of consolidating there. And now we're back holding above $30. This has been for about a year, a little over a year now.”
Commitment of Traders reports are released on Fridays with data as of the previous Tuesday, creating a 3-4 day lag between actual positioning and reported positioning data.
“Now, they are always done as of Tuesday and then released on Friday. We check in with you to see what some of the movements are in terms of commercial traders verse the funds and speculators long short as well as open interest.”
The perception that mining shares 'never do anything' or 'don't go up' is a perspective artifact: a cherry-picked time frame matters—for example, AG Eagle has risen 250% in the last year, which represents strong performance if that is one's relevant investment period.
“You know, uh it's like I I see people talk about, oh, the mining shares never do anything. They don't go up. Well, you know, if Ag Eagle is more than double, like to up 250% in the last year, if you just own that one and that's your time frame that you want to cherry pick, you're doing great.”
The gold-silver ratio reaching 100 (meaning it takes 100 ounces of silver to equal 1 ounce of gold in price) is historically an extreme level, suggesting potential catch-up buying if silver eventually moves.
“And when you look at the gold silver ratio, as you mentioned, I don't put a ton of, you know, stock in that. But I do notice when it's at extremes and when it's at 100, that's an extreme.”
Rapid silver spikes upward can signal a market top because they indicate frothy momentum and overextension in a small market, whereas a grinding consolidation pattern with gradual stair-step increases is more sustainable and bullish for longer-term appreciation.
“if we do see silver spike higher, that unfortunately can be a negative, I think, because it usually does signify top in the market. So, this grinding couple year consolidation then move higher can be, I think, more positive.”
Gold has been the subject of 15 years of consistent analysis by Hempy advocating for gold ownership as a hedge against the 'end of this debt-based monetary system,' and some of his original followers have remained invested through multiple cycles of skepticism because of this conviction.
“I've for 15 years trying to get people to prepare for the end of this debt-based monetary system by owning gold and I still got people on my side. They're like, you know what, I'd have given up in 2015 if you weren't so damn ardent that the math was the math. And now I've hung in there and gold's three, you know, three times higher and I'm glad I got it.”
Precious metals stocks have continued to perform well despite mixed bullion metals performance, with many mining stocks doing 'quite well' and suggesting that the entire precious metals complex is not underperforming despite silver lagging.
“I still see a lot of positives for the precious metals. Try not to uh pay too much attention to everyone trying to say that it's too overcrowded, Craig, because that that is actually a bull market...A lot of them continue to do quite well as well.”
Craig Hempy's personal forecast for silver is a move to $41-$42 by mid-year with a settlement back to $37-$38 by year-end 2025, representing solid single-digit percentage gains rather than the $48-$52 target some analysts project.
“I think even this year I said man we'll get up into 41 or 42 during the year and probably settle back to 37 or 38 by the end of the year. So I you know that's a solid year but I've I've I've yet to print a forecast where I'm like yeah this is a year we're going to go to 48 and 52 and all that kind of stuff.”
The 'K Report' is described as a 'daily editorial,' suggesting it is a news commentary or analysis program rather than a formal news broadcast or interview show.
“Welcome to the K report and a daily editorial.”