
A 97-Year-Old Philosopher Faces His Own Death
What this covers
"Being 97" is an eighteen-minute short documentary directed by Andrew Hasse, in which Herbert Fingarette speaks about his own old age. There is no interviewer in the foreground and no panel, only one man working through what it is like to be this old. He begins with a claim about understanding: younger people cannot grasp the psychology of aging, because they have not yet lost abilities they have had all their lives. He describes how people keep acting as though they still have those abilities, fail and are embarrassed, and only then accept what they can no longer do. Knowing this rationally, he says, does not change habits that have lasted a lifetime. He also names accepting help from others as one of the hardest adjustments.
The second half turns to death. Fingarette had written a book arguing that fear of death is irrational, since nothing follows death, no suffering and no consciousness. He now says that was not a good statement, because it misses why he and others are haunted by the prospect of dying soon. Two experiences complicate the argument. Looking at trees on his deck, he has what might be called a transcendent experience of their marvelousness, and realizes he never properly appreciated them, which makes death harder to accept. And since his wife's death, he describes her absence as having turned into a presence, a persistent emptiness, as if half of him were gone, even though he calls his life a happy one.
He also reflects on his own books. He felt he had solved the problems in each of them, but meaning, death, and grief resist theory. He suggests the answer to "What is the point of it all?" may be that there is none, and that the question is foolish. He ends in an unresolved state, still a puzzle to himself, existing and waiting.
A 97-year-old philosopher reflects on aging, mortality, and the persistent gap between rational understanding of death and the existential dread it evokes, arguing that the loss of physical ability, loneliness after losing his wife, and newfound appreciation of beauty make death harder to accept despite its logical inevitability.
- Rational arguments against fearing death (nonexistence is not suffering) fail to eliminate the emotional reality of mortality dread
- Aging forces acceptance of lost abilities, creating psychological tension between what one was and what one has become
- The death of a long-term spouse creates a lasting 'presence of absence' that reframes mortality as losing one's other half
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Rational knowledge that one should accept loss of ability does not translate into actual behavioral or emotional change because lifelong habits and patterns cannot be overridden by rational decision alone
“That's the rational thing to do. And it would be very nice if we just all did the rational thing to do, but we don't. You can't just decide rationally. Well, this is the way it's got to be now, even though it was the other way then. You can say that to yourself, but that doesn't mean you can do it.”
Being 97 years old is a difficult psychological experience that is hard for younger people to understand because they have not experienced the loss of lifelong abilities and the need to either accept these losses or face failure and embarrassment
“Being 97 has been an interesting experience. I'll say that. It's very difficult for people who have not reached a state of old age, whatever that is. Very difficult for them to understand the psychology of it. What is going on in the person?”
Rational acceptance of a new limitation is theoretically possible but emotionally difficult because lifelong habits cannot be simply decided away—knowing something intellectually does not translate to being able to execute the emotional and behavioral change.
“It would be very nice if we just all did the rational thing to do, but we don't. You can't just decide rationally. Well, this is the way it's got to be now, even though it was the other way then. You can say that to yourself, but that doesn't mean you can do it. These are lifelong habits.”
The speaker has written books on multiple topics and in each case felt he had solved the problem, but the existential questions of meaning, death, and grief are not resolvable through theory—they are personal, central to existence, and the speaker has ultimately failed to come to terms with them
“I've written books on a number of other topics. And in each case I felt that I had solved the problem. But this is not resolvable. It's not just a theoretical question for me, which so many things can be. It's the one thing that is central to my existence that I have tried to come to terms with... and have failed.”
Being 97 years old is difficult for people who have not reached that state of old age to understand because they cannot grasp the psychology of aging—what it feels like and how one's emotional and physical experience transforms.
“It's very difficult for people who have not reached a state of old age, whatever that is. Very difficult for them to understand the psychology of it. What is going on in the person?”
In his earlier book about death, the speaker argued that there is no rational reason to be afraid of death because when you die there is nothing—you will not suffer, will not be unhappy, and will not be conscious, therefore fear of death is irrational.
“What I said was, in a nutshell, is there's no reason to be afraid or concerned or anything about death because when you die, there's nothing. You're not going to suffer. You're not going to be unhappy. You're not going to... Well, you just... you are not going to be.”
The speaker argues in a published book that death should not be feared because when one dies, there is no suffering or unhappiness—one simply ceases to exist, making fear of death irrational
“In the book about death What I said was, in a nutshell, is there's no reason to be afraid or concerned or anything about death because when you die, there's nothing. You're not going to suffer. You're not going to be unhappy. You're not going to...”
The question 'What is the point of it all?' is asked with an ironic sense that there is no good answer, and the real answer may be that there is no point—the question itself is foolish.
“I think I ask the question with the sense that there isn't any good answer. It's a kind of ironic question. I think the answer may be... The silent answer may be there is no point. It's a foolish question.”
The heightened appreciation of life's beauty and simplicity in old age (seeing trees as marvelous) paradoxically makes death harder to accept, intensifying rather than reducing fear of mortality
“And in a way, it makes the fact of death even more difficult to accept. It just brings tears to my eyes.”
The speaker suggests that the answer to 'What is the point of it all?' may be that there is no point—that the question itself is foolish and the 'silent answer' is nothingness
“What is the point of it all? I think I ask the question with the sense that there isn't any good answer. It's a kind of ironic question. I think the answer may be... The silent answer may be there is no point. It's a foolish question.”
The speaker's ultimate condition at age 97 is simply to exist and wait for death, having failed to resolve the fundamental existential questions that preoccupy him
“So I just go on existing, that's the truth of it is existing. And waiting.”
Looking at trees on his deck that he has seen innumerable times, the speaker experiences a transcendent realization of their marvelousness, creating the painful recognition that he has not truly appreciated them until now, which paradoxically makes the fact of death even more difficult to accept.
“As I sit out now on my deck of the house. I look at the trees blowing a little in the breeze. And I've seen them innumerable times. But somehow seeing the trees this time is a transcendent experience. I see how marvelous it is and I think to myself I've had these here all along. But have I really appreciated them? And the fact is that I have not. Until now. And in a way, it makes the fact of death even more difficult to accept. It just brings tears to my eyes.”
Death is experienced by the speaker as a frightening thought that he does not want to happen, and while he recognizes life as often messy and difficult, he still wants to continue living without being fully able to explain why
“Death. it's a frightening thought. It's something I don't want to happen. Much as I think our life in this world is. often a pretty messy affair, I still would like to hang around. I don't know the basic reason why I should want to, or the basic reason why I should be afraid of it.”
Despite the logical argument that there is no good reason to be afraid of death, the speaker's sense of realism tells him that regardless of logical validity, the idea of dying soon haunts him psychologically—demonstrating that emotional reality overrides rational argument.
“My argument was there's no good reason for it. My sense of realism tells me well, no good reason or not, it is something that haunts me, the idea of dying soon.”
Despite having written books on many topics where the speaker felt he had solved the problem, the problem of death is not resolvable; it is not merely a theoretical question but the central existential reality of his existence that he has tried and failed to come to terms with.
“I've written books on a number of other topics. And in each case I felt that I had solved the problem. But this is not resolvable. It's not just a theoretical question for me, which so many things can be. It's the one thing that is central to my existence that I have tried to come to terms with... and have failed.”
The speaker's fundamental condition is one of simply existing and waiting—continuing to live without resolution of existential questions, until the time comes to say goodbye.
“So I just go on existing, that's the truth of it is existing. And waiting. Waiting until I have to say goodbye.”
The speaker now believes his earlier rational argument against fear of death was not a good statement because despite the logical absence of reasons to fear death, people (including himself) are actually haunted by fear of dying soon, which suggests something important was missing from the argument
“I now think that is not a good statement. Because... I think it's important to figure out why it is then that people are afraid of death. Why am I concerned about it? My argument was there's no good reason for it. My sense of realism tells me well, no good reason or not,”
The speaker's experience of his wife's absence has transformed over years from simple grief to a state where absence itself becomes a presence—a positive awareness of what is missing that manifests as persistent emptiness
“Her absence has been to me for a number of years now, has been a presence. An absence which was present to me. I don't know, call it emptiness. There's something missing. and of course I realize right away that she is what's missing.”
Aging involves a progressive loss of abilities that one has had all one's life, and people tend to act as if they still possess these abilities, leading to failure and embarrassment until they finally accept the rational necessity that they can no longer do what they once could.
“It's a loss of ability that you have had all your life. And there's a tendency to act as if you still had it and then fail. Or be embarrassed. Or you have to accept that finally that you can't do that anymore.”
One of the major psychological challenges of aging is coming to terms with the need to accept help from others, a shift that requires fundamental changes in self-concept and autonomy.
“And that's one of the challenges I have had is to come to terms with the need for help.”
The speaker now believes his earlier rational argument against fearing death is not a good statement because it misses something important about why people actually are afraid of death despite the logical soundness of the argument.
“I now think that is not a good statement. Because... I think it's important to figure out why it is then that people are afraid of death.”
The speaker still finds himself in many ways a puzzle to himself, and while he finds it interesting to try to figure himself out, the effort remains incomplete and unresolved.
“I still find that I am in many ways a puzzle to myself. I do find it very interesting to try to figure it out. What's going on?”
Death is frightening and something the speaker does not want to happen; despite acknowledging that life in this world is often a 'pretty messy affair,' he still wants to remain alive and does not clearly understand the basic reason why he should want to or should be afraid of death.
“Death. it's a frightening thought. It's something I don't want to happen. Much as I think our life in this world is often a pretty messy affair, I still would like to hang around. I don't know the basic reason why I should want to, or the basic reason why I should be afraid of it.”
The speaker acknowledges his great fortune in having had a happy life, yet describes himself as feeling that half of him is gone due to his wife's death and absence, creating a persistent presence of emptiness.
“I know how fortunate I have been to have had a happy life. But half of me is gone. Her absence has been to me for a number of years now, has been a presence. An absence which was present to me. I don't know, call it emptiness. There's something missing. and of course I realize right away that she is what's missing.”
The speaker's marriage of approximately 70 years created a profound bond where work, travel, and life were shared, and the death of his wife has resulted in a literal experience of losing half of himself, creating persistent loneliness and absence
“If I had to say... if I had to say something... I would say that loneliness and absence is an absolute part of my life. And that has to do with my wife. We were very close. We were married for probably around 70 years.”
Despite spending much of his life thinking about existential issues, the speaker finds that the work is hard and he usually just drops the subject, suggesting that existential questions may be permanently unsolvable and that sustained engagement with them is emotionally exhausting.
“And I've spent a lot of my life thinking about such issues. But it's hard. I don't know. I just, usually, just drop the subject.”
The speaker often walks around his house and asks himself aloud 'What is the point of it all?', suggesting something is missing from his rational argument about death and that the existential meaninglessness of mortality cannot be resolved through logic alone.
“I often walk around the house and I ask myself, often out loud, What is the point of it all? There must be something I'm missing in this argument.”
Observing trees blowing in the breeze at age 97 has become a transcendent experience that makes the speaker realize he has possessed and seen these trees his whole life but has never truly appreciated them until now
“As I sit out now on my deck of the house. I look at the trees blowing a little in the breeze. And I've seen them innumerable times. But somehow seeing the trees this time is a transcendent experience. I see how marvelous it is and I think to myself I've had these here all along. But have I really appreciated them? And the fact is that I have not. Until now.”
At age 97, accepting the need for help from others has been one of the major psychological challenges of aging
“And that's one of the challenges I have had is to come to terms with the need for help.”
The speaker experienced a long marriage of approximately 70 years with his wife, and they were very close, worked together, and traveled together, sharing a happy life—until her death.
“If I had to say... if I had to say something... I would say that loneliness and absence is an absolute part of my life. And that has to do with my wife. We were very close. We were married for probably around 70 years. And that is another dimension of this whole situation that I am preoccupied with at times. Because she's gone and she has been for several years. And I feel that a part of me is gone. We worked together and traveled together. We were happy together.”
The speaker and his wife were together when she was dying, and at that time they embraced, held hands, and listened to music together—creating a final moment of connection despite the difficulty of the experience.
“I was with her even when she was dying. That was a difficult experience. At least we got to embrace at that time. That's something I used to listen to with Leslie, right here. And we held hands.”
At age 97, the speaker naturally thinks about death, placing mortality contemplation as an age-appropriate cognitive focus.
“At this age, naturally I think about death.”
The speaker was born in Brooklyn in 1921 and is now 97 years old, which he describes as a 'big surprise'
“I was born in Brooklyn in 1921. I am 97 which is a big surprise to me.”
The speaker taught philosophy at UC for approximately 40 years, starting his career in psychoanalysis and publishing books on self-deception, Chinese philosophy, ethics, law, responsibility (particularly in relation to alcoholism and drug addiction), and death
“I taught philosophy in the University of California, about 40 years, I guess. As a young philosopher I started out going deeply into psychoanalysis. I have published books on self-deception and Chinese philosophy. And I also was working in the theory of ethics and the law. Problems of responsibility, in particular in connection with alcoholism and drug addiction. and I also wrote a book about death.”
The speaker taught philosophy at the University of California for approximately 40 years, specializing in psychoanalysis, self-deception, Chinese philosophy, ethics, law, and problems of responsibility related to addiction and drug use, and wrote a book about death approximately 20 years ago.
“I taught philosophy in the University of California, about 40 years, I guess. As a young philosopher I started out going deeply into psychoanalysis. I have published books on self-deception and Chinese philosophy. And I also was working in the theory of ethics and the law. Problems of responsibility, in particular in connection with alcoholism and drug addiction. and I also wrote a book about death. That was about 20 years ago.”
The speaker was born in Brooklyn in 1921, making him 97 years old at the time of this recording, which is itself surprising to him.
“I was born in Brooklyn in 1921. I am 97 which is a big surprise to me.”
The speaker has spent much of his life thinking about existential and philosophical issues like the meaning of life and death, yet still finds them hard to resolve and often drops the subject
“And I've spent a lot of my life thinking about such issues. But it's hard. I don't know. I just, usually, just drop the subject.”
At age 97, the speaker naturally thinks about death regularly
“At this age, naturally I think about death.”
The speaker still finds himself in many ways a puzzle to himself and finds it interesting to try to figure out what is going on with himself
“I still find that I am in many ways a puzzle to myself. I do find it very interesting to try to figure it out. What's going on?”
The speaker describes his wife's death as a frightening and difficult experience, though it was made meaningful by the opportunity to embrace and hold hands with her at the end
“I was with her even when she was dying. That was a difficult experience. At least we got to embrace at that time. That's something I used to listen to with Leslie, righ here. And we held hands.”
Most activities of daily life can still be performed at age 97, but they are now done with effort, special care, and often with the help of another person.
“I can do a lot of the usual things of life. But now they are, most of them, done with effort and special care. And often enough with help of somebody else.”