What this covers

This is the fifth episode of the Existential Basics series, narrated by Mark of The Modern Existentialist. It works through what it means to be human using the vocabulary of Sartre and Martin Heidegger. The episode is organized in four parts: a section on subject and object, a thought experiment about a hermit, the case of a wild child, and a short set of conclusions. Mark's central move is to treat humans as both agents and objects at once, an idea he frames as Subject-Object Duality. He also argues that Sartre inverts Heidegger's terms: being a subject makes us a nothingness rather than a being, dependent on dazen (Dasein)) being incomplete without our status as objects of the world.

The range is partly polemical. Mark describes nihilists as people who see themselves only as acted upon and therefore powerless, and absurdists as people who see the world as merely subjective and therefore free to do anything. He argues both are empirically mistaken, since a mere object could not hold beliefs and a pure subject would not be constrained by biology, physical reality, and society. Along the way he takes up the idea of being born as a tabula rasa, defined only through choices, and the role of The Gaze of the Other in fixing people within a shared facticity.

The most concrete material is historical. Victor, the boy found in the forests of southern France around age twelve, serves as the main example of a feral child. Jean-Marc Gaspard Itard tried to teach him language and empathy. Victor made some progress with empathy but never meaningfully acquired language, and Itard judged the effort a failure. Mark reads this as evidence that being born with human biology is different from becoming human, which happens only through other people.

Sharpest takeaway

Humans are neither purely free subjects nor purely determined objects, but rather fundamentally interdependent beings who become human through social interaction and the gaze of others; this dual nature means individual agency and collective constraint are inseparable.

  • Nihilists and absurdists are empirically wrong in claiming humans are either pure objects or pure subjects—we are demonstrably both actors and acted upon simultaneously
  • The concept of the individual itself is meaningless without contrast to the collective; humans only become fully human through socialization with others
  • Feral children like Victor lack essential human capacities (language, empathy) not from biological deficit but from absence of social development, proving humanness is socially constructed

The claims · ranked35 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

We are born as nothing—as children with nothing more than human biology; being biologically human does not make us human by birthright but gives us the potential and opportunity to become human through socialization.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Mark

“we are born as nothing as children with nothing more than just human biology a biology the simple fact that we are beings doesn't make us human by birthright what it does instead is give us the chance the fundamental potential and opportunity to become human”

0.80

Man is neither purely object nor purely subject, neither purely being nor purely nothingness, but instead is both all at once—simultaneously object and subject, being and nothingness.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Mark

“man isn't either object or subject not either a being or a nothingness instead he's both all at once object and subject being and nothingness”

0.80

Humans are both subject and object simultaneously—they both act and are acted upon in every moment as both agents and people constrained by reality.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Mark

“we can't be purely subject in the world can't be purely actors because we're acted upon we also however can't be purely object in the world because we are also actors within it who act upon it we can't be only either subject or object because we can see that empirically we're both in every moment as people and as agents we're both subject and object we both act and are also acted upon as human beings”

0.80

As social animals, human interaction with the other is fundamentally what defines us—we think and learn and grow together, shape one another through socialization, and express ourselves through language and empathy.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Mark

“as social animals our interaction with the other is fundamentally what defines us we think and learn and grow together and we shape one another through our socialization we speak and communicate through our use of language we feel and know through our use of empathy that is what makes us human”

0.74

We learn how to be human—to act like people—because we learned how to be people from other people through socialization and observation.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Mark

“in other words we only act like people because we learned how to be people from other people”

0.74

The way the gaze of the other fixes us in a common reality is the fundamental mechanism through which our interactions with one another constitute us as human.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Mark

“in other words the way in which the gaze of the other fixes us in a common reality”

0.74

Dr. Jean-Marc Gaspard Itard concluded from Victor's condition that he had lived alone in the wild for most of his life, noting that Victor resembled less a man than a beast.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Mark

“the evidence here seemed to point to the theory that victor had lived alone in the wild for probably most of his life that at least was how it seemed to one jummah gaspar itada a doctor of the time he remarked after all that when victor was discovered he resembled less of a man than a beast”

0.74

Sartre flips Heidegger's terminology upside down to argue that man's nature as a subject does not make him a being but instead makes him a nothingness.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Mark

“sartre goes on to flip heidegger's terminology upside down in order to show us that he's actually empirically wrong sartre argues after all that man's nature as a subject doesn't make him a being but instead actually makes him a nothingness”

0.74

Sartre argues that the gaze of the other fixes us in facticity and the existence of the world which we share with one another—in what is popularly considered to be reality.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Mark

“sartre said this that the gaze of the other fixes us in facticity and the existence and the world which we share with one another and what's popularly considered to be reality”

0.74

It is empirically impossible that humans are purely objects in the world because we believe that we think and feel within our minds; if we were just objects like a stick or a rock we would be incapable of believing anything at all.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Mark

“it can't possibly be the case that we're purely objects in the world because we believe that we think and feel within our minds if we were just objects like a stick or a rock then we'd be incapable of believing that we're anything at all to believe to think implies that we must first exist”

0.74

Humans are only truly human when they are together—as social animals, humans need and desire contact and companionship that is hardwired into their biology.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Mark

“as human beings we're only truly human when we are a we when we're together you and i are social animals the need and desire for contact and companionship is hardwired into our biology we only function in a way that we consider normal or human when we've had the chance to live and learn in the company of others”

0.74

Victor, the Wild Child of Aveyron, was found at age 12 in the forests of southern France, naked with scars and calluses, unable to speak or form words, suggesting he had lived alone in the wild for most of his life.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Mark

“in the 1700s a feral child around the age of 12 was found roaming the forests of southern france today he is known as victor the wild child of aberro when he was discovered he was naked his body covered in scars and calluses and he was unable to speak or form words rather than just being mute it was discovered that in reality he just never learned how to talk”

0.74

Man is defined by his choices; how he chooses to exercise his agency and act within shared reality is how a nothingness becomes a something, how a nothingness becomes a being.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Mark

“man is defined by his choices but how he chooses to exercise his agency and how he chooses to act within the reality which we share that is how a nothingness becomes a something a being”

0.74

Sartre argues that man is not and cannot be only a being alone, neither only a subject within a world of objects nor dazen as Heidegger claims, because man is necessarily also equally an object of the world.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Mark

“sartre says this that man is not and cannot be only just a being alone not only a subject within a world of objects or dazen as highdigger might claim this is because man is necessarily after all also equally just as much an object of the world”

0.74

We are born into the world tabula rasa as blank slates with nothing but human biology; because we are fundamentally subject—agents responsible for our own actions—we are therefore undefined until we make our choices.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Mark

“we are born into the world tabula rasa as blank slates as locke would say as children with nothing but human biology because we're fundamentally subject because we're agents who are personally responsible for our own actions we are therefore undefined until we make our choices”

0.70

Dr. Itard's attempts to civilize Victor were ultimately unsuccessful—while Victor made some progress in acquiring empathy, he was never able to learn or understand language to any meaningful degree.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Mark

“in the end the doctor was unable to civilize victor he noted that while victor did make some progress in acquiring empathy he was never really able to learn or understand language at least to any meaningful degree”

0.69

Absurdists believe that because the world is fake (composed only of subjective truths), they are therefore perfectly free with all the agency and power to do whatever they want.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Mark

“absurdists on the other hand believe that these fake subjective truths are the only thing that we have the only thing we'll ever be able to experience and so they manage to reason themselves into believing themselves to be pure subject they believe that because our world is fake we're therefore perfectly free with all the agency and the power to do whatever we want”

0.69

Dr. Itard adopted Victor and made it his mission to civilize the boy—to teach him to be human—by instructing him in two fundamental characteristics that separate humans from beasts: language and empathy.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Mark

“the doctor adopted victor making it his mission to try and civilize the boy that's to say that he wanted to try and teach the boy how to be human how to walk and talk like a man he put him in clothes and cut his hair then he began to instruct him trying to imprint onto the boy the two traits that the doctor believed made people human two fundamental characteristics that separated beast from man for the doctor these were language and empathy”

0.69

Nihilists believe that because consciousness is a biological trick, they can only be acted upon by circumstances and therefore possess no agency or power to act, making them completely impotent.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Mark

“because the consciousness that they believe they feel is just a trick played on them by their biology that they can only ever be acted upon by their circumstances they're therefore completely and irreconcilably impotent with no agency or power to act”

0.69

Nihilists believe metaphysically objective truths are the only real truths and that our fundamental inability to access them means we can only have fake truths that are not truly real.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Mark

“we established that nihilists and absurdists both believe that metaphysically objective truths are the only real truths and that our fundamental inability to access them means that we are only left with fake truths that none of the things that we consider to be real can actually be thought of as truly real”

0.66

We are not born human biologically—we are born with human biology, but humanness in the behavioral and social sense is not innate and must be learned through socialization.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Mark

“we're not born walking and talking like any normal average person those are things that we learn and we learn them from watching each other”

0.66

Itard considered his work with Victor to be a failure, abandoned his efforts, and left Victor in the care of an older local woman where Victor lived out his remaining life until dying of pneumonia at age 40.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Mark

“the doctor came to think of his work as a failure and so giving up left victor in the care of an older local woman there he lived out the rest of his life eventually dying of pneumonia at the age of 40”

0.66

It is empirically impossible that humans are purely subjects in the world because we are always constantly being acted upon by biological constraints, physical reality, and social constraints.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Mark

“it also however can't possibly be the case that we're purely subjects in the world we know empirically that we must also be objects after all we're always constantly being acted upon if we were pure subjects then that couldn't be the case but in reality we can observe that we're biological beings which exist within the constraints of a physical world even beyond that though we can observe that we are social beings which live within the constraints of a social world”

0.65

Language and empathy together allow the human individual to live and exist in the company of others and are today considered normal and essentially innate to the nature of human beings.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Mark

“the two traits that together allow the human individual to live and exist in the company of others two traits that today we'd consider to be normal essentially innate to the nature of human beings”

0.60

Feral children are incomplete—they lack something that is fundamentally human that can never be recovered because it was never developed in the first place, rather than missing from birth as a biological deficit.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Mark

“feral children are incomplete there's something missing from them something that we considered fundamentally human but that can never be recovered because it was never there in the first place it wasn't missing at birth it was never a function of their biology they weren't born without their humanity instead it was denied to them in their process of becoming human”

0.56

The concept of the individual is necessarily contrastive—it can only exist in contrast with the collective, meaning the individual subject can only exist in relation to and distinction from all other people.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Mark

“individual is a contrastive descriptor a word that describes a specific person in contrast with a general everybody else that means that the concept of the individual the subject can only exist in contrast against its opposite the collective the objective or essentially all the other people that aren't this one”

0.56

If there were no other people to stand in contrast against the individual, the concept of being an individual would be meaningless and unintelligible.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Mark

“if there was no one else no other person to stand in contrast against the individual then what could it even mean to be an individual an individual what”

0.56

What makes us human—what shapes and distinguishes us as human—is both the unique choices and actions we make as individuals and equally our unique interactions with others and our collective experience.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Mark

“what makes us us what shapes us and distinguishes us as human is the choices that we make and the actions that we take our goals and desires and our unique subjective experience but just as much as any of those things it's also equally our interactions with one another the things that we choose to do together and our unique collective experience”

0.56

Even though a hermit abandons society, he still retains his prior status as a product of his society because he was born to a mother, grew up alongside others, and learned human behavior through observation.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Mark

“while it might be true that he's given up his continued involvement in society it will never be the case that he can consider himself to no longer be an object because he'll always still have been acted upon as a product of his society after all he was born to a mother grew up alongside others even if he never had any friends he still spent years watching and learning as human children do by observing the behavior of others”

0.53

We are human not by right of birth but because we have made each other so through our interactions and mutual development.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Mark

“we are human you and i not by right of birth but because we've made each other so”

0.53

A hermit who abandons society still cannot exist as purely subject or purely object because he retains the ability to make choices (making him subject) while still being acted upon by wild animals, weather, and his biological inheritance from society (making him object).

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Mark

“he can't be purely object because even though he's alone he still has choices that he must make he also can't be purely subject because he can still be acted upon for example by the wild animals living on the island and also by objectivity itself by the sun and the rain and the seasonal hurricanes which bother the island in the summer months of every year”

0.52

People missing language and empathy capacities are considered abnormal, disabled, and broken in need of fixing because we assume they are missing something that should be innate.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Mark

“after all when we look at examples of people who are missing these traits who can't walk or talk or intuit feelings the same way as other people we consider them to be abnormal to be disabled in some way broken and in need of fixing because they're missing something”

0.51

The hermit example demonstrates that even when someone has abandoned society, they retain the fundamental human condition of being both subject (with choices) and object (acted upon by nature and their social past).

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Mark

“we can say pretty conclusively that the hermit is free to make this choice that he might be considered generally eccentric but that he's free to exercise his agency in his pursuit of abandoning society but we can never say though is that in choosing to abandon society he now exists all alone in the world as purely and only either subject or object because he must still be both”

0.49

Future choices and actions can never undo or make humans any less human than they have already become through their past social development.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Mark

“that is what made him human and that is what makes us human and now no matter what choices he might make nothing can undo what's already been done nothing that we could do in the future can ever make us any less human than we've already become”

0.45

Because nihilists are invested in their dogmatic system, they have reasoned themselves into believing they are pure objects with no agency.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Mark

“because of their investment in their dogmatic system nihilists have managed to reason themselves into believing themselves to be pure object”