
What this covers
This is a panel at the 2023 Bloomberg New Economy Forum in Singapore, moderated by Tom Orlik of Bloomberg Economics. It asks whether China is heading toward a Japan-style lost decade. Orlik himself draws one distinction: Japan's GDP in 1989 was already about 80% of the U.S. level, while China's per capita figure is still a fraction of America's. He also notes that China's working-age population is now shrinking. Fred Hu, Gary Rieschel, Benjamin Deng and Jennifer Welch respond from the perspectives of investing, venture capital and geopolitics.
The domestic discussion starts with the real estate correction: falling prices in major cities and developers squeezed on liquidity. Rieschel adds that over 70% of Chinese household savings sit in property, in part because equity markets have been flat for 15 years. He argues that consumers will not spend until they trust the capital market. Hu says the biggest upside comes from market reforms that revive the entrepreneur class, not from cyclical stimulus, and he names rule of law as the key structural reform. He also suggests pension funds could be mobilized for long-term investment as the population ages. Rieschel makes the case for China's innovation base. He cites stable venture capital concentration (U.S. and China at 84% of the global total in 2005 and 83% today), a shift from foreign funding to RMB funding, and China's stock market producing more exits than the U.S. market in three of the last five years. He expects advanced manufacturing, AI and gene therapies to stay strong.
The second half turns to U.S.-China relations. Welch describes a move from a neoliberal approach focused on military technology toward broader limits on civilian technology, and she predicts the restrictions will keep expanding. That forecast is the most contested point. She also stresses the global risk of a Taiwan Strait crisis, given Taiwan's role in semiconductors. Deng offers historical examples of exchange during adversarial periods, including John Murray Forbes and the East India Company's role in the British civil service. Rieschel urges pursuing discrete wins instead of grand bargains.
China faces a critical transition from property-driven growth to innovation and entrepreneurship-led development, requiring institutional reforms centered on rule of law and market confidence, while U.S.-China relations demand pragmatic engagement despite structural tensions.
- China's property sector correction is a multiyear process more similar to Japan's 1990s than the 2008 U.S. crisis, requiring policy management rather than panic.
- Entrepreneur confidence has collapsed due to uncertain commitment to market reforms and rule of law, which is the single biggest barrier to sustained growth.
- Both nations benefit from continued dialogue and small-win collaboration rather than confrontational industrial policy, as evidenced by historical precedent of cooperation even during adversarial periods.
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Collaborations and investments between the U.S. and China never stopped, even at times when people didn't imagine things would happen that way, suggesting continuity despite political tensions.
“PEOPLE HAVE TO LEARN FROM HISTORY. ONCE WE STUDY HISTORY, WE KNOW THE COLLABORATIONS AND INVESTMENTS NEVER STOPPED, EVEN AT THE TIME WE DON'T EVEN REMEMBER, WE DON'T IMAGINE THAT THINGS WOULD HAPPEN THAT WAY DURING THAT TIME.”
China's demographic challenge is similar to other developed countries', but China has the opportunity to respond by leveraging more long-term savings for old-age and pensions, with potential for mobilizing Chinese pension funds for long-term investments.
“DEMOGRAPHIC CHALLENGE IS SIMILAR BUT CHINA HAS THE OPPORTUNITY TO RESPOND BY LEVERAGING MORE LONG-TERM SAVINGS FOR OLD-AGE AND PATIENTS. WITH THAT U.S. INVESTORS, IN CHINA FROM CHINESE PENSION FUNDS , GIVEN THE SHEER SIZE AND OPPORTUNITY IN CHINA, IT IS NOT REALISTIC TO RELY ON THE INTERNATIONAL CAPITAL AND THE CONFIDENCE ALONE AND TO HAVE ENOUGH DOMESTIC CAPITAL MOBILIZED FOR LONG-TERM INVESTMENTS. THERE IS OPPORTUNITY THERE.”
Chinese consumers lack trust in equity markets and capital markets, so when you reform, you have to establish trust, because if consumers don't feel comfortable, their hands get jammed in pockets so deep that no force on earth will make them spend money.
“PART OF IT IS TRUST. WHEN YOU REFORM, YOU HAVE TO MAKE SURE THE REFORM IS ESTABLISHING TRUST. IF CHINESE CONSUMERS DON'T FEEL COMFORTABLE, THOSE HANDS GET JAMMED IN THE POCKETS SO DEEP, NO FORCE ON EARTH WILL GET THEM TO SPEND MONEY.”
Foreign venture capital initially funded innovation in China and is now transitioning to RMB funding, representing a shift in capital source for Chinese entrepreneurship.
“THERE WAS A GREAT DEAL OF MONEY THAT CAME IN, FOREIGN MONEY INITIALLY FUNDED THE INNOVATION IN CHINA AND IS NOW BEING TRANSITIONED TO RMB.”
Over 70% of Chinese consumer savings are in property, representing a major allocation mistake that is going forward, driven by the fact that capital markets and the stock market have flatlined for 15 years.
“IN CHINA RIGHT NOW, OVER 70% OF CONSUMER SAVINGS ARE IN PROPERTY. THAT WAS A MISTAKE TO EVER HAPPEN AND IT'S A MISTAKE GOING FORWARD. WHY DOES THAT HAPPEN? BECAUSE YOU HAVE CAPITAL MARKETS AND A STOCK MARKET FLATLINED FOR 15 YEARS.”
Jennifer Welch advises the business community to understand and get inside policymakers' heads to see how they look at the world, as geopolitics is back and here to stay, and policy steps will influence economics.
“MY ADVICE WOULD BE TO THE BUSINESS COMMUNITY AS WE HAVE DISCUSSED ALL DAY TODAY, GEOPOLITICS IS BACK WHETHER WE LIKE IT OR NOT. IT IS HERE. IT BENEFITS US TO UNDERSTAND AND GET INSIDE POLICYMAKERS HEADS AND LOOK AT HOW THEY LOOK AT THE WORLD.”
China's biggest upside is not from conventional cyclical stimulus but from pushing forward market reforms, which have unleashed China's potential, particularly in rekindling the entrepreneur class.
“BUT FOR ME THE BIGGEST UPSIDE IS NOT FROM CONVENTIONAL, CYCLICAL REASONS. CHINA HAS BEEN SUCCESSFUL THUS FAR MAINLY BECAUSE CHINA HAS BEEN PUSHING FORWARD MARKET REFORMS. THOSE HAVE REALLY UNLEASHED CHINA'S POTENTIAL, PARTICULARLY TO REKINDLE THE ENTREPRENEUR CLASS.”
The lines in technology are becoming more blurred, with advanced semiconductors having military patents but also commercial applications, and civil-military fusion making it unclear who is developing and using technology.
“YOU ADD TO THAT AT THE LINES IN TECHNOLOGY ARE BECOMING MORE BLURRED. THERE ARE ADVANCED SEMICONDUCTORS WITH MILITARY PATIENTS BUT ALSO COMMERCIAL APPLICATIONS. YOU HAVE BLURRING LINES IN TERMS OF WHO IS DEVELOPING AND USING THE TECH WITH CIVIL MILITARY FUSION.”
The U.S. has shifted from traditional neoliberal policies restricting China's access to military-relevant technology toward a broader approach targeting civilian technology applications due to concerns about technology leadership's impact on industrial capacity and workforce.
“FOR DECADES, THE U.S. HAS HAD POLICIES IN PLACE THAT RESTRICT CHINA'S ACCESS TO TECH PRIMARILY USED FOR MILITARY. BUT RECENTLY, WE'VE SEEN WASHINGTON BECOME MORE CONCERNED ABOUT THE ROLE OF TECHNOLOGY LEADERSHIP AND THE IMPACT IT CAN HAVE ON INDUSTRIAL CAPACITY AND THE WORKFORCE. THAT HAS BECOME CONSENSUS ACROSS BOTH POLITICAL PARTIES. THEY HAVE SHIFTED AWAY FROM THE TRADITIONAL NEOLIBERAL APPROACH TO TECHNOLOGY, ECONOMICS AND TRADE.”
If a Taiwan Strait crisis breaks out, it is difficult to understate the risks for the global economy, as Taiwan produces a large portion of cutting-edge and mature node semiconductors that many sectors rely on, from smartphones to home electronics to autos.
“IF A CRISIS BREAKS OUT I THINK IT IS DIFFICULT TO UNDERSTATE THE RISKS FOR THE GLOBAL ECONOMY. IF WE TAKE A LOOK AT ONE SIDE OF THE TRIANGLE, AT TAIWAN AND ONE THING TAIWAN MAKES, THE VERY IMPORTANT THING THEY MAKE A LOT OF, SEMICONDUCTORS, THE NUMBER OF SECTORS THAT RELY ON TAIWAN'S CUTTING EDGE AND MORE MATURE NODES, EVERYTHING FROM SMARTPHONES TO HOME ELECTRONICS AND AUTOS, YOU HAVE A HUGE PORTION OF THE GLOBAL OUTPUT AND A LOT OF SERVICES THAT RELY ON THESE PRODUCT.”
Japan had no innovation society, but China has been entrepreneurial-driven for the last 20 years, with new growth primarily generated by private companies and entrepreneurs driving innovation.
“I THINK IF I DREW ONE COMPARISON TO JAPAN, JAPAN REALLY HAD NO INNOVATION SOCIETY, BUT CHINA HAS BEEN ENTREPRENEURIAL DRIVEN FOR THE LAST 20 YEARS. WE LOOK AT THE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT IN VIRTUALLY ALL THE NEW GROWTH HAS BEEN IN PRIVATE COMPANIES. ENTREPRENEURS HAVE DRIVEN INNOVATION.”
China's working-age population is shrinking, marking a fundamental demographic shift from the 2007 period when the workforce was still growing.
“CHINA'S WORKING AGE POPULATION IS SHRINKING.”
China will need to transition from high and middle income country status to high income country status for development, and rule of law is the single biggest structural reform needed, essential for a functioning market economy.
“CHINA WILL CONTINUE TO NEED THE NEXT LEVEL FROM HIGH AND MIDDLE INCOME COUNTRY AND HIGH INCOME COUNTRIES FOR DEVELOPMENT. THAT'S WHAT I WILL WATCH CLOSELY . IN PARTICULAR, I WOULD SAY ALL THE BROAD REFORMS CHINA NEEDS, THE SINGLE BIGGEST IN MY MIND IS TO REALLY START A TRUE RULE OF LAW THAT IS ESSENTIAL FOR THE FUNCTIONING OF THE MULTIMARKET ECONOMY.”
In 1806, the East India Company set up a college near London and recommended to the U.K. government to establish the civil service system based on the Chinese national examination system, before the Opium War, showing mutual learning happened during adversarial times.
“ONE IS BACK IN 1806, THE EAST INDIA COMPANY SET UP A COLLEGE NEAR LONDON RECOMMENDING TO THE GOVERNMENT, THE U.K. GOVERNMENT TO SET UP THE CIVIL SERVICE SYSTEM BASED ON THE NATIONAL EXAMINATION SYSTEM. THEY WANT TO LEARN FROM CHINA. IT WAS BEFORE THE OPIUM WAR.”
Japan's GDP in 1989 was about 80% the level of the United States, indicating Japan was already a rich country that had exhausted development space, whereas China's GDP per capita is still a fraction of the U.S. level, pointing to enormous potential ahead.
“JAPAN'S GDP IN 1989 WAS ABOUT 80% THE LEVEL OF THE UNITED STATES. JAPAN WAS ALREADY A RICH COUNTRY THAT HAD USED UP. . DEVELOPMENT SPACE CHINA'S GDP TODAY IS GROWING REALLY QUICKLY BUT GDP PER CAPITA IS STILL A FRACTION OF THE U.S. LEVEL, AND THAT POINTS TO A HUGE AMOUNT OF POTENTIAL IN THE YEARS AT.”
John Murray Forbes of the Boston Forbes family started his career in China in 1834, returned to Boston in 1850 with $1 million given to him by his Chinese mentor, invested that money in Chicago railroads, which established railroad systems, and Forbes became chairman of the national committee of the Republican Party.
“THE SECOND STORY IS JOHN MURRAY FORBES, PART OF THE FORBES FAMILY IN BOSTON, STARTED HIS CAREER IN CHINA IN 1834 AND RETURNED TO BOSTON IN 1850 BRINGING BACK THE MONEY HE MADE IN CHINA AND HALF $1 MILLION GIVEN TO HIM BY HIS CHINESE MENTOR. THE MONEY WAS INVESTED IN CHICAGO RAILROADS. THE RAILROAD SYSTEM WENT BEYOND THAT AND FORBES BECAME THE CHAIRMAN OF NATIONAL COMMITTEE OF THE REPUBLICAN PARTY IN THE U.S.”
Gary Rieschel advises the U.S. and China not to try for grand bargains, as there won't be broad-based agreement on hundreds of points, but instead to find discrete areas where both sides can win.
“THE ADVICE WOULD BE DON'T TRY FOR THE GRAND BARGAIN. I DON'T THINK YOU WILL HAVE A VERY BROAD-BASED AGREEMENT ON HUNDREDS OF POINTS.”
In 2005, the U.S. and China together combined for 84% of global venture capital, and today they combine for 83%, showing remarkable stability in the concentration of venture capital despite perceptions of decline in China's share.
“IN 2005, THE U.S. AND CHINA TOGETHER COMBINED FOR 84% OF GLOBAL VENTURE CAPITAL. TODAY, THEY COMBINED FOR 83%.”
In the last three of the last five years, the Chinese stock market generated more exits in dollars and number of deals than the U.S. stock market, representing a significant shift from 20 years ago when this would have been unexpected.
“WHEN YOU LOOK AT THREE OF THE LAST FIVE YEARS, THE CHINESE STOCK MARKET GENERATED MORE EXITS IN DOLLARS AND NUMBER OF DEALS IN THE U.S. STOCK MARKET WHICH IS NOT SOMETHING PEOPLE WOULD HAVE EXPECTED 20 YEARS AGO.”
China's real estate sector is in a significant correction, with prices in major cities falling and developers facing liquidity crunches and pressure to restructure balance sheets.
“PRICES IN MAJOR CHINA CITIES HAVE BEEN FALLING. MANY OF THE BIGGEST DEVELOPERS FOR THEMSELVES, THE LIQUIDITY CRUNCH AND TREMENDOUS PRESSURE TO RESTRUCTURE AND REPAIR THE BACK OF THE BALANCE SHEETS.”
China's innovation economy is quite robust and very broad, affecting healthcare and semiconductors, with areas like advanced manufacturing, AI, and gene therapies expected to be very robust for venture capital investment going forward.
“THE INNOVATION ECONOMY IN CHINA IS QUITE ROBUST AND VERY BROAD. IT'S AFFECTING THE HEALTH CARE SYSTEM. IT WILL OCCUR IN SEMICONDUCTORS PARTLY BECAUSE OF U.S. POLICY AND PARTLY BECAUSE OF THE NEEDED SKILLS. THERE ARE AREAS THAT ARE MORE CHALLENGING BUT AND BAD -- ADVANCED MANUFACTURING, AI, GENE THERAPIES, THESE ARE AREAS THAT WILL BE VERY VERY ROBUST IN TERMS OF VENTURE CAPITAL INVESTMENT GOING FORWARD.”
Private sector entrepreneurship and competition at the point of innovation, supported but not directed by government, is where changes and innovation will occur, rather than government picking winning companies.
“WE ARE UNABASHED SUPPORTERS OF ENTREPRENEURS AND SUPPORTERS THAT THE PRIVATE SECTOR AT THE POINT OF THE SPIRIT IS WHERE THE CHANGES WILL OCCUR AND WHERE THE INNOVATION WILL BE DEVELOPED. THE GOVERNMENT CAN BACKFILL AND SUPPORT FROM BEHIND, NOT PICKING THE WINNERS AS COMPANIES, BUT PICKING SECTORS THAT ARE STRATEGIC.”
More competition in the financial services market from global players is something promised as part of WTO membership but hasn't materialized in China.
“MORE COMPETITION IN THE FINANCIAL SERVICES MARKET FROM GLOBAL PLAYERS IS SOMETHING THAT WAS PROMISED AS PART OF WTO BUT HASN'T MATERIALIZED.”
Jennifer Welch has low expectations for major deliverables from the Xi-Biden meeting, viewing the negotiations as having moved past the paradigm of grand agreements, instead looking toward working groups and dialogue mechanisms for relationship management.
“I HAVE LOW EXPECTATIONS FOR MAJOR DELIVERABLES. I JUST THINK WE ARE PAST THAT PARADIGM AT THIS POINT. BUT WE COULD SEE THEM LOOK TOWARDS OTHER MECHANISMS FOR MANAGING THE COMPETITION. NEW WORKING GROUPS AND DIALOGUE MECHANISMS. IT DOESN'T SOUND EXCITING BUT THEY ARE PRETTY IMPORTANT FOR STABILIZING THE RELATIONSHIP”
The moment China commits to rule of law and market reform, confidence will slowly but surely come back, and Fred Hu is quite optimistic about both short-term outlook and medium-term outlook for China, with China achieving high-quality growth in the short-term and next five years to 2030.
“THE MOMENT CHINA COMMITS TO THE RULE OF LAW AND MARKET REFORM, I THINK CONFIDENCE WILL SLOWLY BUT SURELY COME BACK. THEN I'M QUITE OPTIMISTIC NOT ONLY ABOUT THE SHORT-TERM OUTLOOK. IN THE IMMEDIATE TERM NEXT FIVE YEARS, 2030, CHINA SHOULD ACHIEVE HIGH-QUALITY GROSS.”
The lack of quality analysis by most Chinese investment banks compared to their foreign counterparts is a problem, and allowing markets to open up so the best bankers in the world could establish a presence in China would support capital market development.
“I THINK THE LACK OF QUALITY ANALYSIS BY MOST OF THE INVESTMENT BANKS IN CHINA COMPARED TO THEIR FOREIGN COUNTERPARTS IS A PROBLEM. ALLOWING THE MARKETS OPEN UP SO THE BEST BANKERS IN THE WORLD COULD ACTUALLY GET IN AND ESTABLISH A PRESENCE IN CHINA AND SUPPORT THE CAPITAL MARKET I THINK WOULD BE GOOD.”
Finding discrete cooperative initiatives where both governments can say they win, like the cancer initiative, and accumulating 8-10 such initiatives over 5-10 years would establish a norm of cooperation instead of conflict.
“FIND THINGS LIKE THAT ARE THE TWO GOVERNMENTS CAN SAY WE BOTH WIN. AFTER FIVE OR 10 YEARS IF YOU HAVE EIGHT OR 10 OF THOSE, THAT WILL BE THE NORM INSTEAD OF THE THINGS THAT AREN'T WORKING.”
Gary Rieschel argues the fantasy of industrial policy should have been laid to rest long ago, citing Japan's failed industrial policy and skepticism about China's industrial policy effectiveness, with the U.S. now having to go through the process of understanding what industrial policy will waste.
“I THINK THE FANTASY OF INDUSTRIAL POLICY SHOULD HAVE BEEN LAID TO REST A LONG TIME AGO. JAPAN HAD INDUSTRIAL POLICY, DID NOT WORK OUT SO WELL. CHINA'S INDUSTRIAL POLICY I THINK HAS NOT BEEN EFFECTIVE.”
Washington will continue to expand technology restrictions because underlying concerns and structural factors are persistent, a policy that began in the Trump administration and continued under Biden with strong Congressional support, and the metaphorical fence will continue to go up as the yard expands.
“I THINK BECAUSE OF THOSE UNDERLYING CONCERNS AND STRUCTURAL FACTORS ARE PERSISTENT, AND THIS IS A POLICY THAT BEGAN IN THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION AND HAS CONTINUED UNDER THE BIDEN ADMINISTRATION, STRONGLY SUPPORTED IN CONGRESS, AND CHINA'S CONTINUING TO MAKE PROGRESS DESPITE THOSE RESTRICTIONS, I THINK WASHINGTON WILL CONTINUE THE APPROACH AND THE MEDICAL OR ASH METAPHORICAL FENCE WILL CONTINUE TO GO UP AND THE METAPHORICAL YARD WILL BE EXPANDING.”
China's property sector correction is a multiyear process more analogous to Japan's slow-motion real estate crisis in the 1990s rather than the 2008 U.S. housing crisis, which was abrupt, full-blown, and resulted in a violent global implosion.
“I THINK WHAT HAS HAPPENED IN CHINA HAS BEEN DIFFERENT TO WHAT HAPPENED IN THE U.S. DUE TO THE HOUSING CRISIS IN 2008. THAT WAS, IF YOU RECALL, PRETTY ABRUPT, FULL-BLOWN AND A VIOLENT IMPLOSION WITH A GLOBAL CRISIS. THE CHINESE REAL ESTATE I THINK IS A MULTIYEAR PROCESS. IT IS MORE LIKE IN JAPAN, THE REAL ESTATE CRISIS IN JAPAN IN THE 1990'S WAS A SLOW-MOTION CRISIS. CHINA WILL HAVE TO DEAL WITH THE PROBLEM FOR A FEW MORE YEARS TO COME.”
Rule of law requires protection of copyrights, protection of entrepreneurs from political interference and persecution, and the Chinese entrepreneur community has not felt this insecure since 1978.
“PROTECTION OF COPYRIGHTS, PROTECTION OF ENTREPRENEURS FROM POLITICAL INTERFERENCE, AND WORSE, EVEN PERSECUTION. THIS SENSE OF INSECURITY IN MY OBSERVATION IN THE CHINESE ENTREPRENEUR COMMUNITY, I'VE NEVER SEEN THIS SINCE 1978.”
Different segments of China's property market will behave differently going forward: traditional residential housing could remain depressed for a long period, while multi-family and rental properties are trending and attracting investor interest, along with commercial real estate, infrastructure, and logistics investments.
“DIFFERENT PARTS OF THE PROPERTY WILL BEHAVE DIFFERENTLY. YOU HAVE OLD, TRADITIONAL RESIDENTIAL HOUSING. IT COULD HAVE A LONG PERIOD OF BEING COLD, BUT ALSO WE HAVE MULTI FAMILIES, WE HAVE RENTAL PROPERTIES THAT ARE REALLY TRENDY TODAY. WE ARE INVESTING MORE INTO THOSE KINDS OF PROPERTIES. ALSO THE BECAUSE I REAL ESTATE, WE HAVE INFRASTRUCTURE, THE LOGISTICS.”
Chinese entrepreneurs are currently lying low with weak sentiment because people are uncertain whether the leadership is committed to market reforms.
“FOR NOW, CHINESE ENTREPRENEURS ARE LYING LOW. SENTIMENTS ARE WEAK. THAT'S BECAUSE PEOPLE ARE NOT CERTAIN WHETHER THE LEADERSHIP IS COMMITTED TO THESE REFORMS.”
The situation in the Taiwan Strait is at its most dangerous point in the last 20 years, with three sides of a triangle each moving away from the other: Taiwan developing increasing affiliation with a different sense of identity and democratization, Beijing expressing less friendliness and more adversarial stance, and Washington growing tension and distrust with China.
“I THINK IN MANY WAYS THE SITUATION IS AT ITS MOST DANGEROUS POINT IN THE LAST 20 YEARS. THERE ARE THREE SIDES TO THE TRIANGLE AND EACH SIDE IS MOVING AWAY FROM THE OTHER. YOU HAVE IN TAIWAN INCREASING AFFILIATION WITH A DIFFERENT SENSE OF WHAT TAIWAN IS AN TAIWAN'S DEMOCRATIZATION, AND AN INCREASING SENSE THAT BEIJING RECENTLY HAS BEEN LESS FRIENDLY AND MORE A FOE TOWARDS TAIWAN.”
Beijing has expressed a sense of concern about Taiwan's trajectory and an affirmation that Chinese leaders don't want to hand the Taiwan issue off to the next generation, as they have said clearly.
“IN BEIJING YOU HAVE A SENSE OF CONCERN ABOUT TAIWAN'S TRAJECTORY AND AN AFFIRMATION THAT CHINESE LEADERS DON'T WANT TO HAND THE ISSUE OFF TO THE NEXT GENERATION AS THEY HAVE SAID CLEARLY.”
Government stock market interventions when the government buys stocks are mistakes that misallocate capital and damage market confidence.
“THESE MARKET INTERVENTIONS THEY DO WHEN THE GOVERNMENT BUYS STOCK, I THINK IT IS A MISTAKE.”
China has key differences from Japan that suggest a better outlook: China has a bigger, more diverse economy with deeper economic structure composition, and the execution of policies in China is quite efficient and effective compared to Japan's policy implementation.
“THERE ARE A LOT OF SIMILARITIES OF COURSE, BUT I THINK THERE ARE KEY DIFFERENCES. CHINA HAS A BIGGER ECONOMY, MORE DIVERSITY IN TERMS OF THE COMPOSITION OF THE ECONOMIC STRUCTURE AND DEPTH, AND ONE MORE THING, THE EXECUTION OF POLICIES IN CHINA IS QUITE EFFICIENT AND EFFECTIVE.”
Interest rates in China are too high, and on the fiscal front, beyond municipal governments, the national government still has strong fiscal space with clearly a lot of work that can be done.
“INTEREST RATES AND CHINA ARE TOO HIGH. ON THE FISCAL FRONT, OTHER THAN NATIONAL -- THE MUNICIPAL GOVERNMENTS, THE NATIONAL GOVERNMENT STILL HAS A STRONG FISCAL DECISION. CLEARLY A LOT OF WORK CAN BE DONE.”
Industrial policy will not be the path of success for the U.S., nor has it been for China in the past.
“INDUSTRIAL POLICY WILL NOT BE THE PATH OF SUCCESS FOR THE U.S. IT HAS NOT BEEN FOR CHINA.”
Fred Hu advises politicians, diplomats, security experts, and business investors that despite short-term challenges, China has enormous resources and capacity to deal with challenges and still untapped long-term potential, so the advice is to invest in China.
“FOR POLITICIANS, DIPLOMATS AND SECURITY EXPERTS, THIS IS -- AND FOR BUSINESS AS -- AND INVESTORS, DESPITE THE SHORT-TERM CHALLENGES, CHINA HAS ITS SHARE OF DIFFICULTIES AND CHALLENGES. BUT CHINA ALSO HAS ENORMOUS RESOURCES, CAPACITY TO DEAL WITH THE CHALLENGES AND STILL UNTAPPED LONG-TERM POTENTIAL. MY ADVICE IS SIMPLE. INVEST IN CHINA.”
An initiative sponsored by Bloomberg, Chinese counterparts, and McKinsey focuses on cancer—the largest cause of death in China and second-largest in the U.S.—with the goal of normalizing guidelines to solve cancer for both countries and bring solutions to the developing world.
“BEFORE THIS SESSION THERE WAS AN IMPORTANT INITIATIVE SPONSORED BY BLOOMBERG, CHINESE COUNTERPARTS, MCKENZIE AND SO ON , AND IT IS ON CANCER. IT IS THE LARGEST CAUSE OF DEATH IN CHINA, SECOND LARGEST COLLEGE OF DEATH -- CAUSE OF DEATH IN THE UNITED STATES AND IT IS AN INITIATIVE TO NORMALIZE GUIDELINES AROUND BEING ABLE TO SOLVE THIS FOR THE U.S. AND CHINA AND BRING THAT TO THE REST OF THE DEVELOPING WORLD.”
Xi Jinping's 'common prosperity' objective cannot be achieved without entrepreneurs, as they are the primary drivers of wealth creation and opportunity.
“I WOULD SAY THE XI JINPING COMMON PROSPERITY HAS NO HOPE OF BEING ACHIEVED WITHOUT ENTREPRENEURS IN CHINA.”
This shift in U.S. technology policy has become consensus across both political parties, moving away from the traditional neoliberal approach to technology, economics, and trade.
“THAT HAS BECOME CONSENSUS ACROSS BOTH POLITICAL PARTIES. THEY HAVE SHIFTED AWAY FROM THE TRADITIONAL NEOLIBERAL APPROACH TO TECHNOLOGY, ECONOMICS AND TRADE.”
The CSRC governor stated that policies will come out gradually, with the government taking a measured approach to test the waters and ensure things don't become overly corrected, with the expectation that sentiment will eventually turn.
“I WANT TO QUOTE THE GOVERNOR OF CSRC. HE SAID THE POLICIES WILL COME OUT GRADUALLY. I THINK THE GOVERNMENT WILL TAKE A VERY MEASURED APPROACH. NOT TO FLOOD THE MARKET WITH ALL KINDS OF POLICIES PEOPLE DON'T HAVE DIRECTION WITH. WE WILL TEST THE WATER AND MAKE SURE THINGS DON'T GO OVERLY CORRECTED, AND EVENTUALLY THE SENTIMENT WILL TURN.”
There is a gulf between the U.S. policy world and private sector with lack of communication that often happens.
“I HAVE WITNESSED THE GULF BETWEEN THE TWO AND THE LACK OF COMMUNICATION THAT OFTEN HAPPENS.”
Policymakers should talk to the business community because they are not just stakeholders in U.S.-China relationship issues, but actors with their own role to play and with unique and important insights on economic implications of policy steps.
“MY ADVICE WOULD BE TO THE BUSINESS COMMUNITY... FOR MY FORMER POLICY COLLEAGUES, I WOULD REINFORCE THE IMPORTANCE OF TALKING TO THE BUSINESS COMMUNITY. THEY AREN'T JUST STAKEHOLDERS IN ISSUES LIKE THE U.S.-CHINA RELATIONSHIP. THEY ARE ACTORS WITH THEIR OWN ROLE TO PLAY IN THAT RELATIONSHIP AND THEY HAVE A LOT OF UNIQUE AND IMPORTANT INSIGHTS TO BRING, IN PARTICULAR ON THE ECONOMIC IMPLICATIONS OF POLICY STEPS.”
China has demonstrated effective strategic sector support without picking individual company winners, notably in clean energy and semiconductors, which the U.S. could learn from.
“CHINA HAS DONE THAT QUITE WELL.”
When you put a dollar into the Chinese stock market in 2009, you have maybe a dollar now or $0.98, illustrating 15 years of flat or negative returns for stock market investors.
“YOU PUT A DOLLAR IN INTO THOUSAND NINE IN THE CHINESE STOCK MARKET, YOU HAVE MAY BE A DOLLAR NOW OR $.98.”
The CHIPS Act has been loaded with so many conditions and bells and whistles that no companies want to take the money, with 15 months passing and not a single dollar deployed because companies reject government-attached conditions.
“IF YOU LOOK AT THE CHIPS ACT, THEY LOADED IT UP WITH SO MANY THINGS THAT NO ONE WANTS TO TAKE THE MONEY. 15 MONTHS LATER, NOT A SINGLE DOLLAR OF THE CHIPS ACT HAS BEEN DEPLOYED BECAUSE THE COMPANIES WANT THE MONEY FROM THE BELLS AND WHISTLES THE GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATED WITH IT.”
Historically, families won't spend regardless of income if they feel insecure, and government policy to increase consumption will not work unless trust is established.
“HISTORICALLY, AS FAMILIES PICK WHATEVER HISTORICAL REFERENCE THEY WANT, THEY WON'T SPEND. THE GOVERNMENT POLICY OF INCREASING CONSUMPTION WILL NOT WORK UNLESS THEY ESTABLISH TRUST.”
The upcoming Xi-Biden meeting is a bullish signal for the equity market because when looking at U.S., European, and Japan rate cycles, lower rates follow higher rates, and China is going into a lower cycle which will be bullish for equities and real estate sectors.
“I THINK IT IS A BULLISH SIGNAL FOR THE EQUITY MARKET. I THINK IF WE LOOK AT U.S. RATE CYCLES, EUROPEAN RATE CYCLES AND JAPAN RATE CYCLES, LOWER RATES WILL FOLLOW HIGHER RATES AND WILL COME UP. CHINA IS GOING INTO A LOWER CYCLE, WHICH WILL BE BULLISH FOR EQUITIES AND THE REAL ESTATE SECTORS.”
There are not as many startups today, but the problems they are trying to solve and the depth of technology innovation are high, and there are still enough entrepreneurs and enough money with China being 40% of global venture capital ecosystem and enough market demand.
“I WOULD SAY THERE ARE NOT AS MANY STARTUPS TODAY, BUT THE PROBLEMS THEY ARE TRYING TO SOLVE, THE DEPTH OF THE TECHNOLOGY INNOVATION IS HIGH. THE NUMBER OF ENTREPRENEURS IS STILL ENOUGH. CHINA IS 40% OF THE GLOBAL VENTURE CAPITAL ECOSYSTEM. THAT'S ENOUGH MONEY. THERE'S ENOUGH MARKET DEMAND.”
People need to be willing to move money from the property market era to the capital market to have the capital market be a sustainable long-term story of value, but it's not seen that way today and the government has done precious little in the last five to six years to encourage people to do that.
“PEOPLE NEED TO BE WILLING TO PUT MONEY IN THE STOCK MARKET FROM THE PROPERTY MARKET ERA TO HAVE THE CAPITAL MARKET BE ANOTHER SUSTAINABLE LONG-TERM STORY ARE OF VALUE. IT'S NOT SEEN THAT WAY TODAY AND THEY'VE DONE PRECIOUS LITTLE IN THE LAST FIVE TO SIX YEARS TO ENCOURAGE PEOPLE TO DO THAT.”
There has been a shouting match across the Pacific over the last couple of years, but now that leaders are engaged and talking, and there are minister meetings, they will find ways to work together as necessary.
“WHAT'S REALLY TROUBLING IS THE LAST COUPLE YEARS, THERE HAS BEEN A SHOUTING MATCH ACROSS THE PACIFIC. SO NOW THE LEADERS ARE ENGAGED, THEY ARE TALKING, AND THERE ARE MINISTER MEETINGS. THERE ARE STILL DIFFERENCES, BUT THEY WILL FIND WAYS TO WORK TOGETHER AS NECESSARY.”
The capital market is the second-largest in the world, but unlike the U.S., there is not enough liquidity, transparency, or critical mass of institutional investors; instead, it is individuals and speculative property trading.
“IT IS THE SECOND-LARGEST CAPITAL MARKET IN THE WORLD. THE BOND CAPITAL MARKET IS TRADING. UNLIKE THE U.S. THERE IS NOT ENOUGH LIQUIDITY OR TRANSPARENCY . THERE IS NOT ENOUGH CRITICAL MASS, INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS. AS WE DISCUSSED, IT IS INDIVIDUALS AND SPECULATIVE PROPERTY AND THE LIKE.”
There are new and significant barriers to trade and technology transfer between China and the United States, unlike the vibrant ties in 2007.
“THERE ARE NEW AND SIGNIFICANT BARRIERS TO TRADE AND TECHNOLOGY TRANSFER BETWEEN CHINA AND THE UNITED STATES.”
Xi Jinping's crackdown on corruption has been a positive development, though recent policy direction (common prosperity, tech regulation) has created uncertainty about government commitment to market reform.
“XI JINPING HAS CRACKED DOWN ON CORRUPTION AND THE BELT AND ROAD INITIATIVE HAS PUT CHINESE CAPITAL AND EXPERTISE TO WORK AROUND THE WORLD AND DRIVING ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT.”
China announced a consolidation of the steel industry and majorly reduced steel companies, demonstrating that industrial policy has not been effective in achieving its stated goals.
“THEY ANNOUNCED A CONSOLIDATION OF THE STEEL INDUSTRY AND MAJORLY REDUCED STEEL COMPANIES.”
Both sides have taken steps the other does not appreciate, with chips restrictions being one of them from Beijing's perspective, and there will be traditional exchange of complaints but the tensions will not go away.
“BOTH SIDES HAVE TAKEN STEP'S THE OTHER DOES NOT APPRECIATE. THE CHIPS RESTRICTIONS BEING ONE OF THEM FROM BEIJING'S PERSPECTIVE. THERE WILL BE THE TRADITIONAL EXCHANGE OF COMPLETES -- COMPLAINTS ON THAT POINT. THE TENSIONS WILL NOT GO AWAY.”
Tensions in the Taiwan Strait have seldom been higher, in contrast to 2007 when they were not top of anyone's worry list.
“TENSIONS IN THE TAIWAN STRAIT HAVE SELDOM BEEN HIGHER.”
Belt and Road Initiative has successfully deployed Chinese capital and expertise around the world, driving economic development in participating countries.
“THE BELT AND ROAD INITIATIVE HAS PUT CHINESE CAPITAL AND EXPERTISE TO WORK AROUND THE WORLD AND DRIVING ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT.”
China's growth, which was comfortably in double digits in 2007, is expected to come in at around 5% in 2023, roughly half the prior rate.
“CHINA'S GROWTH, WHICH IN 2007 WAS COMFORTABLY IN THE DOUBLE DIGITS, WILL IN 2023 COME IN AT AROUND HALF THAT. 5% GROWTH, NOT BAD IN INTERNATIONAL COMPARISON, BUT PRETTY LACKLUSTER COMPARED TO CHINA'S RECENT HISTORY.”
There are areas to share interest and share challenges between the U.S. and China.
“THERE ARE AREAS TO SHARE THE INTEREST AND SHARE THE CHALLENGES.”
This is the first time President Xi and President Biden have met since last year at the G20, and a lot has happened in the world since, including the ongoing war in Ukraine and tensions in the Middle East.
“THIS IS THE FIRST TIME THEY WILL HAVE MET SINCE THIS TIME LAST YEAR AT THE G20. A LOT HAS HAPPENED IN THE WORLD SINCE. I THINK THEY TALK ABOUT GLOBAL EVENTS. THE ONGOING WAR IN UKRAINE, NOW THE WERE IN THE MIDDLE EAST.”
Fred Hu is hopeful the Xi-Biden summit will dial down tensions several notches and both sides can become more pragmatic in their approach, acknowledging differences while finding shared interests and challenges.
“I'M HOPEFUL THE SUMMIT WILL DIAL DOWN THE TENSIONS SEVERAL NOTCHES, AND BOTH SIDES CAN BECOME MORE PRAGMATIC. OF COURSE THERE WILL BE DIFFERENCES, BUT THERE ARE AREAS TO SHARE THE INTEREST AND SHARE THE CHALLENGES.”
Benjamin Deng acknowledges he personally experienced the 2008 global financial crisis while concerned about his job security, having moved from New York to Hong Kong in 2007 and starting work for Ping An in 2018.
“I STILL REMEMBER THE DAY I WAS WORRIED ABOUT MY JOB THE NEXT DAY. COINCIDENTALLY, YOU MENTIONED SOMETHING INTERESTING. I MOVED FROM NEW YORK TO HONG KONG IN 2007, WHEN YOU MOVED TO BEIJING. I STARTED WORKING FOR THE COMPANY IN 2018.”
Benjamin Deng advises people to stay connected and invested in China, or they will regret it.
“THE LAST ADVICE TO THE PEOPLE IS, STAY CONNECTED. STAY INVESTED. OR YOU WILL REGRET IT.”