What this covers

This is a single-lecturer survey of Erasmus's In Praise of Folly, delivered by Michael Sugrue as part of a series on Renaissance literature. The book is read as a satire in which Folly, personified as a pagan goddess and rival to the God of the Bible, praises herself. The lecture treats anyone who does not worship the biblical God wholeheartedly as one of her devotees. Much of the hour goes to comic particulars: Folly's genealogy, which makes pride in ancestry proof of folly; aristocratic arrogance; the intellectual who spends years in libraries writing for readers who never come; and marriage, which the lecturer says no one would enter if courtship's ploys were visible.

The lecture sets Erasmus against two other traditions. Jonathan Edwards and his "Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God" serve as the prosecutorial counterexample: powerful and frightening, but, the lecturer argues, self-defeating because no one recognizes themselves as a loathsome maggot. That contrast feeds a discussion of Psychological Defenses Against Criticism and of Intellectual Pride as Particular Sin, including the claim that those who condemn all humanity covertly justify themselves. Fanaticism is defined as redoubling effort while forgetting the end.

The second half turns to history and theology. Erasmus attacks scholastic logic-chopping and the sale of indulgences before Luther, and favors a humane, non-theological piety with echoes of Job. His debate with Luther over free will is the sharpest clash: Erasmus called the question beyond human understanding, and Luther answered that the Holy Spirit is not a skeptic. Both Catholic radicals and Luther attacked him. The lecturer ties the religious wars after 1536 to the loss of his temper of tolerance, then follows the quietist strand into Voltaire's Candide, where it reappears in secular and more cynical form.

Sharpest takeaway

Erasmus's 'In Praise of Folly' represents the most effective form of moral didacticism because it uses gentle, inclusive satire to reveal human sinfulness and pride rather than harsh condemnation, making vice ridiculous and thereby accessible to transformation without triggering defensive self-justification.

  • Folly praising itself universally achieves what condemnation cannot: the listener recognizes their own failings without defensiveness because the criticism applies to all humanity equally
  • Comedy sweetened with wit makes bitter medicine palatable, allowing moral improvement through recognition rather than rejection, contrasting with the counterproductive harshness of Juvenalian satire
  • Erasmus includes himself by name as a devotee of folly, establishing credibility through humility and fair-mindedness rather than claiming moral superiority, thus preserving his rhetorical and moral force

The claims · ranked47 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.69

Erasmus is remarkable among Reformation and Counter-Reformation figures for being a beacon of tolerance, intelligence, and humility during a period that lacked such qualities, making him particularly attractive and wise compared to the fanatics on both sides.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“erasmus is one of the most attractive and sane figures of the reformation or counter-reformation and this is remarkable because the reformation and its catholic counter-reformation is not remarkable for attractive sane level-headed figures erasmus was a sort of beacon of tolerance and intelligence and humility at a time that was really lacking in such things”

0.69

Both radical Catholic elements and Luther criticized Erasmus from opposite sides: the Catholic radicals thought he insufficiently defended the faith, while Luther saw him as a dangerous reactionary who made corrupt Catholicism appear morally acceptable through his reasonableness.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“even though he was abhorred by some of the more radical elements in the catholic church because they thought of him as insufficiently vigorous in defense of the faith and he was also roundly castigated by luther himself because he thought that he was in fact the most dangerous kind of reactionary because he appeared reasonable and in fact was and he appeared to make uh corrupt and evil catholicism appear morally acceptable”

0.69

After Erasmus's death in 1536, religious warfare in Western Europe rose sharply, destroyed the culture of Germany, disrupted European politics, and caused tremendous hardship and misery that could have been avoided with a more tolerant, reasonable, humane, and fair-minded approach to religious difference.

forecasthigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“to this in this respect he's largely correct after his period after he died in 1536 what we do is we see a rise of religious warfare in western europe which destroyed for example the culture of germany made a mess of european politics and caused a tremendous amount of hardship and misery which could have been avoided with a more tolerant and reasonable and humane and fair-minded approach”

0.69

Erasmus engaged in a controversy with Luther on the nature of free will, after Luther wrote a dogmatic pamphlet asserting his reading of Scripture was the only correct reading; Erasmus countered that the problem of free will and determinism is beyond human capacity to understand.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“he was at his best when writing on religious topics and he was also quite good at writing on classical topics with considerable reluctance he engaged in a controversy with luther on the nature of free will luther had written a rather dogmatic pamphlet in the beginning of the reformation about the nature of free will and the obligations of the christian conscience and luther for all his piety and seriousness was a real desk pounding kind of dogmatic fellow and he was full of the sort of self-righteousness that we associate with the prophet jeremiah those of you who know the old testament he's constantly telling the world and particularly the church how sinful it is and how much we need reformation with a capital r he did this on the basis of his particular reading of scripture which luther insisted was the only reading of scripture the right reading of scripture the one that could the only one that could be truly reconciled with the christian conscience what erasmus says is this after spending an entire lifetime of studying scripture and doing what he could to discern god's will in god's law he's thought through insofar as he could the problem of free will and his considered opinion is that it is beyond human capacity to understand”

0.69

Luther characterized himself as the mouthpiece of the Holy Spirit and responded to Erasmus's epistemic humility with the statement 'The Holy Spirit is not a skeptic,' implying the Holy Spirit sides with Luther's certainty.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“luther of course wrote back a thundering response saying the holy spirit is not a skeptic which strongly suggests the holy spirit is really an ally of luther rasmus says well look i don't have any monopoly on god i don't have any special access to the holy spirit i do what i can to live a holy life and to improve those around me and to do honor to the profession of learning and to be a good clergyman but i think that even though the holy spirit may not be a skeptic about some issues i am a skeptic because it's just an indication of the limitations of my knowledge and perhaps the entire limitations of human knowledge altogether”

0.63

The core Christian belief is that after death we will be judged; Erasmus opposes the elaborate ecclesiastical hierarchy and worldly corruption that has crept in because they distract from this central truth.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“you can't split too many hairs about this and we ought to reject the world and think about the other world we ought to do the best we can to be good down here but the key thing is that after we die we will be judged that's what christianity is about and the elaborate hierarchy and and all the corruption and worldliness that's come in he's clearly opposed to that”

0.61

The sale of indulgences is contrary to the spirit of the law, and Erasmus criticizes this practice prior to Luther, focusing on how it violates the spirit rather than debating theology.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“he also criticizes the fact that indulgences are sold and this is prior to luther prior to the 95 theses what he says is this is plainly contrary to the spirit of the law”

0.56

Erasmus criticizes scholastic philosophy and debate—particularly the schools of Thomas, Albert, Scotus, and others—for chopping logic and adding Scripture to create controversies that don't lead anywhere and serve only to display intellectual pride and vanity, becoming a form of worshipping the god folly rather than the God of the Bible.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“he goes beyond that and he criticizes the church of course but when he finishes up he starts to talk about scholasticism and that's a great thing to criticize because it deserves it so much he says i have heard a great many debates and disputes between the various followers of scholastic philosophy and he describes the rubbish that comes from the alchemists and the thomas and the albertists and the scotists and the various schools and how they by chopping logic and adding scripture to it come up with controversies that don't amount to anything that don't lead anywhere that are simply testimonies to their intellectual pride and their vanity and he says in fact this should be recognized for what it is another way of following the god is folly rather than following god the father the god of the bible”

0.56

Because those proud of their lineage are themselves children of folly (according to Erasmus), there is a clever and witty retort in Folly's genealogy: pride in ancestry is itself proof of folly.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“he says later on in the book that those of us who are proud of their lineage are in fact the children of folly a very clever and witty retort”

0.52

Voltaire has Candide say 'let us live without philosophizing' as the only way to make life bearable, which is a more cynical and extreme formulation of the Erasmian view but essentially spiritually kin to it.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“those of you who know candide and who know that the final moral is that we must we should cultivate our gardens and voltaire has candide say let us live without philosophizing it is the only way that makes life bearable well that's a somewhat more cynical and perhaps more secular more extreme formulation of the erasmian view but my understanding is is that essentially they are spiritually kin”

0.52

Folly is personified as a pagan goddess representing an alternative to the God of the Bible, suggesting that those who do not worship the biblical God with their whole heart and mind are willy-nilly devotees of folly.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“in addition to that folly is personified as a pagan goddess which is to say as a sort of alternative to the god of the bible right those of us who don't worship the god of the bible with our whole heart and soul and mind are willy-nilly devotees of folly what a clever and thoughtful idea this is”

0.52

After a couple of hundred years of misery, tumult, persecution, intolerance, and fanaticism stemming from religious schism, the anti-intellectual trend of living quietly and restraining sinful inclinations becomes secularized and emerges in Voltaire's Candide.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“if we take him to be an anti-intellectual thinker one who is able to criticize not just the the kind of ignorant and the common people but also professional scholars as well it seems to me that after a couple of hundred years of misery and terrible tumult and persecution and intolerance and fanaticism that we get with the rules of the reformation that this sort of anti-intellectual trend which says well look we should best live our lives quietly and peaceably and not trying and take things too far we ought to restrain our sinful inclinations when this when this tendency becomes secularized it seems to me that it's going to emerge later on in another book called candide”

0.52

Erasmus advocated for a humane, generous, and non-theological form of piety that suggests theology and piety are in tension or even incompatible, a view that harks back to the Book of Job's treatment of the relationship between theological knowledge and spiritual wisdom.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“what he mostly did was advocate a kind of humane and generous non-theological piety and in that respect perhaps his view of religion harks back to what we learned it when we read the book of job that perhaps theology and piety are in some respects incompatible or at least as a certain tension between the two”

0.52

By making vice ridiculous and accessible through gentle satire rather than direct accusation, Erasmus's approach makes the moral message palatable: the sweetness of mirth exceeds the bitterness of recognition, allowing moral reformation to occur rather than defensive rejection.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“not only does it make it ridiculous but it makes it accessible to the average person when you accuse some individual person of having some particular fault at some particular sin oftentimes just by the nature of the human psyche and the human demand for self-justification people will reject the message it strikes too close to home it cuts a little too deep erasmus understands that element in the human psyche and in writing in praise of folly he offers a gentle clever witty satire which is broad-minded which is fair-minded which laughs at all follies equally and shows how they're distributed all across human life and by not singling out one particular person or one particular kind of evil what he does is make it more palatable in other words the sweetness of the mirth exceeds the bitterness of recognition”

0.52

Erasmus is not opposed to marriage or courtship; rather, he argues that some follies and evils are intrinsic to human nature and cannot be eliminated through utopian efforts—we must live with them while attempting restraint when conscious of them.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“it's not that he's opposed to marriage it's not that he's opposed to courtship and love what he says is look there are some infirmities some evils some follies that are just intrinsic to human nature we can't get beyond them in other words we are sinful creatures we must live with that fact we perhaps when we become conscious of our follies can improve ourselves can perhaps restrain our follies but the idea of eliminating our follies or avoiding our follies is utopian in the pejorative sense of the term it just can't ever be done”

0.52

The besetting folly of intellectuals is that they believe their work is tremendously important while no one reads their books; they spend years in libraries growing pale doing research for two other pale people over the next hundred years to read.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“how about the follies of intellectuals now this is one that i particularly like all right i always read this passage twice when i read and praise the father this is a great part he says the besetting folly of intellectuals it's hard to really say where to start because they have such big heads first of all they think that what they're doing is tremendously important but on the other hand no one reads their books and the reason why no one reads their books is because what they're doing really isn't important they'll spend years in the library growing one and pale splitting hairs and doing research and cogitating and doing all these important things so that two other pale and juan people over the course of the next hundred years will read their book and think very highly of it this they're convinced is the most important thing in the universe and what could be a greater example of folly”

0.52

Edwards's harsh condemnation paradoxically fails because people don't identify themselves as loathsome maggots worthy of damnation; the bitterness of such language prevents recognition, whereas Erasmus's sweetness allows recognition despite psychological defenses.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“the difficulty is is that that's such a harsh kind of criticism that people don't think that the maggot is them in other words if you call me foolish and you call everybody else foolish i might be able to buy into that if you call me a loathsome maggot being held over the fires of damnation i'm much more likely to think you're talking about somebody else right just human pride and vanity being what it is in other words it's not that jonathan edwards is wrong in condemning the evil of the world it's just that he loses control of his rhetoric he loses a sense of how the human psyche works”

0.52

Among aristocrats, follies include pride, arrogance, and self-indulgence—the vices of people with little legal or social restraint—and the folly intrinsic to marriage, which would not occur without folly.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“now we go to the folly of aristocrats there are folly there are follies of pride arrogance self-indulgence all the things that you would associate with people who have rather little restraint imposed upon them by law and there's also of course the folly that comes from marriage he says that there would be no marriages at all without folly it's just part of human nature you have to accept it and do what you can with it”

0.52

The tradition of gentle, inclusive, broad-minded criticism (Horatian/Erasmian) is the most effective for moral didacticism because it pursues the goal of improving the world rather than serving as a stalking horse for the speaker's egotism and self-righteousness.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“and because comedy is often not always but most of the time concerned with morally improving the people who observe it there's often a didactic element in comedy the comedians who give gentle and thoughtful and fair-minded criticism of others are the ones who are most effective and if we are honest in saying that we want to improve the world rather than merely have that be a kind of stalking horse for our own egotism and for our own self-righteousness then the way to do that is the horation slash erasmian tradition the tradition of gentle inclusive broad-minded criticism”

0.52

There are two approaches to moral didacticism: accusatory/prosecutorial (like Edwards) that tells the listener they are bad and should reform, versus fellow-traveler (like Erasmus) who acknowledges shared sinfulness and walks alongside the listener in mutual acknowledgment.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“these two approaches to moral didacticism in other words both of these sermons attempt to improve the hearer but they represent two kinds of approach to improving the here one is to accuse the prosecuting attorney you are bad time to reform the other is a kind of fellow traveler in in this world of sin”

0.48

The father of folly is riches, because wealthy people have greater scope for practicing folly; the poor are too occupied with putting bread on the table to practice various follies, suggesting that poverty constrains but does not eliminate folly.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“he says well the father of folly is riches rich people tend to have greater scope for their folly and actually you see a little bit more in them when you're poor you're much too interested in putting bread on the table to practice the various follies which makes a certain amount of sense it rings true”

0.48

The Church's worldly political concerns represent a sign of terrestrial corruption; a cardinal trying to be a minister of state exemplifies folly because the roles are incompatible.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“in the first case it seems to him that the fact that the church is bound up with worldly political concerns is a sign that terrestrial corruption has crept in what could be more foolish than a cardinal trying to be a minister of state it just won't work that's a way of praising folly”

0.48

Juvenal represents an angry, harsh tradition of pointing out evil and moral bankruptcy in the world, with a self-righteous condemnatory tone; such angry people tend to lose a sense of proportion and undercut the moral force of their argument through excessive condemnation.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“the alternative tradition comes out of juvenile juvenile is a very angry man and very angry people who are insistent about pointing out how evil and perverse and uh morally bankrupt the world is tend to be very very self-righteous people in other words you don't put down all the rest of humanity unless you have a very very high opinion of yourself and not only does it require in the case of juvenile a very high opinion of oneself but it also requires that you lose a sense of proportion in your argument”

0.48

Fanaticism is defined as redoubling efforts while forgetting the ends; if the end is moral improvement, one must subordinate condemnation to that goal, or condemnation becomes so harsh and grating that people reject it rather than internalize it.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“someone wants to find fanaticism as redoubling our efforts when we have forgotten our ends well if the end of this sort of literature is to the moral improvement of the hearer you must always keep in mind what you are trying to accomplish and your desire to condemn the world must be subordinated to your into your desire to improve the world and if your condemnation becomes so harsh and grating and unpleasant that no one takes it to heart because they just can't face that as in is the case for example when you say that you're a maggot being held over hellfire and god should throw you and you loathe some vermin well that's the problem with juvenile as well”

0.48

In contrast to Edwards's approach, Erasmus's approach is more attractive from a Christian perspective because pride, particularly intellectual pride, is itself a sin; those who condemn all humanity covertly justify themselves and are among the greatest sinners.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“it seems to me that that of erasmus is much more attractive certainly it's much more attractive in a christian clergyman because as erasmus points out pride particularly intellectual pride is a kind of sin and those who think themselves sinless as we found out in the book of job are among the greatest of sinners we are not justified compared to god all those juvenalian critics who want to condemn all of humanity have lost a sense of proportion and are in a way covertly justifying themselves”

0.48

Politicians mostly spend their time committing adultery, blasphemy, war, and bribery while convincing themselves this is tremendously important; they are monuments to folly and the great high priests of folly.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“he says politicians mostly spend their time doing things like adultery and blasphemy and war and oh bribery and that kind of thing and they think that's really important and that's the way that societies ought to be run most politicians are monuments to folly they are the great high priests of folly to a great extent the kings and princes and emperors of the world who have somehow convinced themselves of what they're doing is tremendously important and that they are the most significant possible people are in fact trivial in their pursuits and foolish in their aspirations”

0.48

Intellectual interpretations of Scripture should guide readers to heaven rather than serve as vehicles for academic advancement (getting tenure); using Scripture as a vehicle for ego advancement is the intellectual analog of using the Church for political advancement.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“it is not the uh the matter for an ego trip scripture is meant as a kind of guide to getting us to heaven not a way of allowing us to get tenure which is again the kind of uh intellectual analog the kind of terrestrial analog of what this will get a christian theologian”

0.48

In Praise of Folly is simultaneously a work of imaginative art, a work of non-theological piety, and a lasting and improving sermon, making Erasmus both a Renaissance author and a great theological thinker.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“it is a masterpiece of clever and well thought out didactic comedy so it is both a work of imaginative art it is a work of non-theological piety and it is the most lasting and improving of sermons in that respect he is both a renaissance author and a great theological writer or thinker”

0.48

Jonathan Edwards's sermon 'Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God' is magnificent for its literary qualities and power to frighten, but it employs a harsh approach of calling people loathsome maggots held over hellfire rather than gentle critique.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“i would compare this to uh to an alternative kind of sermon um you perhaps know this seminar there was an 18th century american puritan speaker uh he's isn't it or divine his name was jonathan jonathan edwards and he wrote a magnificent sermon magnificent because it's furious like a hurricane and this sermon is called sinners in the hands of an angry god and he talks about what evil men do that evil is paraded throughout the universe and that god does not like this that god holds the sinner over hell fire the way a boy might hold an insect over a campfire a loathsome disgusting piece of vermin god is disgusted with our evil”

0.48

The nurses who raise folly to adulthood are ignorance and drunkenness, representing defects of the mind and defects of the body/passions; these defects amplify and develop the follies that begin in riches and youth into their larger adult form.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“in addition folly is also considerate and she thanks her nurses the nurses of foley the ones who raise folly up and bring it from an infancy to adulthood are ignorance and drunkenness defects of the mind and defects of the body or defects of the passions the desires these defects raise the follies that you started out with to their larger adult form”

0.48

If people could perceive what truly goes on in courtship—the ploys, stratagems, and hidden thoughts of suitors and those seeking marriage—no one would ever marry; the fact that marriage occurs testifies to our universal devotion to folly.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“but people are the way they are they will continue to get married like it or not but suppose hypothetically if we were able to realize what goes what goes on in the wings or behind the scenes in courtship how many ploys and stratagems there are in a suitor that wants to win a woman or a woman that wants to get married to a particular man what's going on in the back of their head there's a wonderful movie by woody allen what's it called annie hall where a man and a woman are talking to each other and that the real subtitles of what's going on in their head in fact are put beneath the dialogue and in fact what's going on in their head has nothing to do with what they're saying he says if people actually knew what was going on in the minds of other people when they talk to them particularly when they're involved in courtship and marriage no one would ever get married the fact that people get married generally speaking is testimony to the fact that we are all devotees of folly like it or not”

0.48

According to the Gospel, the spirit gives life while the letter kills; much of what people take to be important and serious worldly pursuits turn out to be folly, yet escape from all these follies is not the goal—acceptance and restraint are.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“what is it that they say in the gospels my kingdom is not of this world it seems that just about everything of this world turns out to be a kind of folly and it's not necessarily that that we're to escape all these follies they're part of the human condition but he shows us that so much of what we take to be important and serious is in fact folly”

0.48

Erasmus chose to withdraw from controversy and try to bring both sides together, which he felt was in keeping with the spirit of the law rather than the letter; he spent his life studying the letter and barely understands it, so he chooses conscientious humility.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“what he did in fact was try and withdraw from controversy and try and bring both sides together he felt that that was in keeping with the spirit of the law rather than the letter of the law and he said look i spent a whole lifetime studying the letter of the law and i hardly understand that i just muddle through as best i can a kind of appropriate conscientious humility comes out of this”

0.45

Erasmus does not justify himself but includes himself by name in his book, with Folly saying one of her great friends is Erasmus who also follows folly; this self-inclusion demonstrates he is a truly humble and sensible man who hasn't lost a sense of proportion.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“erasmus does not justify himself erasmus includes himself by name in his book saying having folly say one of my great friends is a rad erasmus he's a real dope too and the kind of guy that can say that in fact is not a real dope the kind of guy that can say that is in fact he has is in fact a kind of humble and yet sensible and yet thoughtful man who hasn't lost a sense of proportion”

0.45

Friendship contains a certain folly because friends overlook and soft-soap each other's vices; yet friendship is a good and necessary part of human life, making all who have friends necessarily devotees of folly.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“he says not only marriage but even friendship contains a certain amount of of folly he doesn't mean to say that friendship is an evil or that is the kind of thing we should avoid we should all become hermits but rather that don't we find that among our friends we're willing to overlook their vices kind of soft soap their vices i mean even if somebody is kind of rude or arrogant or dishonest we tend to overlook this in our friends to treat them as kind of minor vices he says what could be more foolish than that and yet all of us do it and can't avoid doing it right we can't become hermits we can't withdraw from society so although friendship is a good thing and a desirable and necessary part of human life inevitably it is accompanied by foley”

0.45

Folly tends to develop, improve upon itself, worsen, and increase; only by having folly praise itself and forcing people to look it in the face can readers see the follies inherent in their own lives.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“and folly tends to develop and kind of improve on itself and increase on itself and make itself worse so only by folly praising itself and by forcing us to look it in the face can we see the follies that are inherent in our own lives”

0.45

Another form of intellectual folly is the intellectual wannabe who pirates others' books and signs his own name to them, manifesting attachment to intellectual status while lacking the substance; this folly differs from the scholar's folly but remains folly.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“and because of that fact many people pirate editions of someone else's book and then sign their own name to it he says well this folly is different from the other folly of staying in the library and actually writing the book but both of them are folly one is the folly of actually thinking that intellectual stuff is really important in the cosmic scheme of things which is ridiculous and the other folly is attaching your name to a book and lying about it because you have bought into this ridiculous idea that this is really an important thing and a really praiseworthy thing to do it's all folly from top to bottom”

0.43

Erasmus's critique of scholasticism can be compared to Jonathan Swift's satire in Gulliver's Travels where commentators on Aristotle and Homer are shown not understanding the original authors they interpret, representing commentary industries built on misunderstanding.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“you might want to compare his criticism of the scotus and the albertus the various uh schools within uh scholastic philosophy to uh jonathan swift if i mean i'll be doing that next week when i come back but uh when uh gulliver goes to glub dub drib and it's the island of the enchanters and he's given a chance to bring up both aristotle and homer and in addition to aristotle and homer because he conjures them up out of nothing he brings not just aristotle and homer but the various commentators in aristotle and homer and aristotle and homer are given a chance to actually hear what people say about them and both aristotle the ghost of aristotle and the ghost of both say these guys don't understand our work at all”

0.41

Erasmus spent the greater part of his life studying Scripture and classical letters, making translations from Greek and Latin, and served as a pivotal figure in the Northern Renaissance by adapting and bringing classical writings into Northern European culture.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“he spent the greater part of his life studying scripture and classical letters he did translations from classical greek and latin he was a pivotal figure in the northern renaissance because he helped adapt and bring into the culture of northern europe important elements of the classical writings”

0.41

Erasmus lived in the late 15th and early 16th century, roughly contemporary with Martin Luther, and was a Catholic clergyman renowned for his piety and liberal learning in Greek and Latin translation, but never rose in the ecclesiastical hierarchy because he lacked interest in the political and administrative side of the church.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“Erasmus himself lived in the late 15th and early 16th century flourished at about the same time that the protestant reformation was beginning he was roughly speaking a contemporary of luther and he was catholic clergyman he was renowned for his piety and for his liberal learning he was an expert translator of greek and latin he was a very serious and devout figure in the catholic church but he never rose in the hierarchy he was renowned for his learning but never really developed much interest or inclination in the political or the kind of administrative element side of the church”

0.37

In Praise of Folly is a beautiful personification of sin, particularly pride, extended meditation covering all seven deadly sins; its humor, witticisms, and ridicule of virtue make vice ridiculous rather than merely condemned.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“in praise of folly is a beautiful personification of sin it's an extended meditation on sin particularly upon the sin of pride but in fact all of the seven deadly sins get mentioned in in praise of folly and not only are they mentioned but they are excoriated and held up to ridicule and this is very important because erasmus humorous book because it's a very funny book it you'll laugh through it and because it's full of w of witticisms and ironies and well thought out passages which hold virtue up to ridicule they make it laughable and by making it laughable two things happen first of all it's morally didactic it shows you the imperfection it shows you the disagreeable qualities of evil and sin and folly by making it ridiculous”

0.34

In Praise of Folly is an encomium (speech of praise) in which the pagan goddess Folly personifies and speaks for herself, using the device of Folly praising her own advocates and manifestations throughout human life.

definitionestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“first off he is most known for a book called the praise of foley which was written in latin and which was an encomium or speech of praise on the pagan goddess folly which is personified in this book in other words folly does all the speaking folly gives a lecture in praise of the various elements of folly and the devotees of folly and the subsets of folly”

0.34

Erasmus was a close friend of Thomas More, whose utopia contains similar criticisms of European political life; In Praise of Folly is dedicated to More—a pun on his name 'More' which sounds like Latin 'moriae' (folly).

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“erasmus was a friend was a close personal friend of thomas moore and you can see if any of you have read utopia and you see the sort of criticism that thomas more makes of the political life of europe during the you know around the time of say 1500 or 1520 around that time you'll find many of the criticisms that moore makes about the nature of politics in contemporary europe are just like those of erasmus in fact in praise that folly is dedicated to thomas more uh there's a play on words moore's last name uh sounds very similar to the latin mori a m-o-r-i-a-e and uh that's the word for folly she says my book is in praise of folly i didn't mean it in praise of you in fact you're as far from folly as your name is close to it but the fact of the matter is most people really are foolish”

0.29

The fellow-traveler approach to moral didacticism has a very long history tracing back at least as far as Roman satire, particularly Horace and Juvenal, who represent two different traditions.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“and this approach to morally didactic literature actually has a very very long history and it goes at least as far back as roman satire right so it's very very old and there are two romans i mean just to backtrack a little bit to show you where this comes from there are two romans that figure very heavily here and that's horus and juvenile both horus and juvenile roman satirists were wrote very very effective satires”

0.29

The companions of folly are the seven deadly sins plus additional vices: self-love, flattery, sloth, pleasure, madness, wantonness, oblivion, and intemperance; these defects of the human soul accompany and characterize folly.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“now once we get past the nurses of foley we have to think of what the companions of foley are what is it that we usually associate with folly well how about the usual gamut of human vices we will find that the normal companions of foley are the things called the theological books the seven deadly sins and to these seven deadly sins he adds a few other sins which perhaps aren't quite deadly but are pretty bad and tend to lead you to a life of vice and evil the thing the companions of folly are self-love flattery sloth pleasure madness wantonness oblivion intemperance yes indeed all of the usual defects of the human soul are the things that accompany folly”

0.26

Marrying for money rather than love is more foolish than marrying for love; those who marry dowries rather than women exemplify folly from top to bottom.

normativespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“beyond the folly of marriage there are some people who marry independent of love they marry for money and he says what could be more foolish if getting married for love or you know desire is foolish imagine the foolishness of a man who marries a a dowry rather than a woman foolish from top to bottom”

0.20

Erasmus criticizes common follies including: aged people behaving childishly, idiots feigning sagacity, ugly people using cosmetics to appear beautiful, the poor exceeding their income, and the rich being miserly—all representing human beings without sense of proportion.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Erasmus, In… [po7QCNVnIzw]

“he begins to inquire into the folly of common people and after going to common people he goes to the folly of nobles and from there to the folly of intellectuals and politicians and churchmen but let's start with the folly of noble of common people common follies well there's the folly of aged people behaving in a childish way and aged people do behave in a childish way sometimes there's the folly involved in idiots feigning sagacity acting as if they're intelligent folly from top to bottom there's the folly of ugly people trying to make themselves cosmetically beautiful which rings home i mean yes i said he's right about that absolutely uh there's the folly of those who are poor exceeding their income spending more than they have and there's the folly of the rich who are miserly and don't want to spend the money they have people who have no sense of proportion”