
Grant Williams (4th Turning, Helicopter Money, Pension Bubble, The END GAME)
What this covers
This is a long conversation between Grant Williams, the macro writer and Real Vision co-founder, and host George Gammon. It starts from the social and political backdrop, framed through the Fourth Turning, and moves to market structure, monetary and fiscal mechanics, and the psychology of investing. The common concern is that calm surface readings, such as low equity volatility and index highs, sit on top of fragile conditions underneath.
On markets, Williams spends the most time on passive investing. He argues it has taken most inflows in a cycle fed by about $23 trillion of central bank support. Buying is indiscriminate on the way up, but on the way down the bids could vanish and prices could gap sharply. He cites Mike Green's case that this tail risk is underappreciated, and Chris Cole's view that volatility is the one real asset class, with suppressed VIX against turbulent streets as an alligator jaws) divergence that must close. He also notes that only 11% of S&P 500 stocks are making new highs while the index does.
The macro section covers the TGA) as a fiscal "bazooka" and the more-cowbell) pattern of ever larger rescue packages. It also takes up monetization) of deficits, the gap between official CPI) and the cost of essentials, and the role of inflation expectations and velocity. The comparison with Japan after 1989 is notable: Williams describes a market that stopped rising and slowly declined rather than crashed. Stimulus inflating assets while food costs climb is presented as a source of resentment between haves and have-nots.
The last stretch turns to personal discipline. Topics include confusing luck with skill (the blackjack hit-on-19 example), trading price rather than thesis, position sizing, the arithmetic of a 51% hit rate, and fear and greed as the only market forces. Williams says a framework will lag in manias but pay off over a full cycle.
Grant Williams argues that we are in the dangerous phase of the Fourth Turning characterized by widening wealth inequality (haves vs have-nots rather than left vs right), passive investing and low volatility masking real economic instability, and fiscal stimulus likely to trigger inflation when combined with velocity increases—creating a systemic risk environment where understanding macroeconomic frameworks and psychological discipline matters more than stock picking.
- Conflict is shifting from political (left/right) to economic (rich/poor), with stimulus-driven asset price inflation while food and living costs spike, creating dangerous social tension
- Passive investing flows have levitated markets during stimulus regime; when reversed, algorithmic selling could cascade without bids, amplifying losses far beyond fundamental deterioration
- The Treasury General Account and monetization of deficit spending, combined with post-COVID velocity rebound and memory of scarcity, creates inflationary setup similar to late 1980s Japan before its 30-year deflation
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
When a stock pick works out, people mentally attribute it to being 'smart' rather than 'lucky', creating overconfidence that increases risk of catastrophic losses—the distinction between 'I was smart' vs 'I was lucky' vs 'I was lucky and it also happened to work for the reasons I thought' is crucial for long-term survival.
“people particularly in markets like we have now which is unlike anything i've seen catching that lightning in a bottle seems that much easier and and it's very difficult mentally for for human beings who who buy shares and they go up to think anything other than how smart i am very few people think wow that was lucky right people think i'm a genius”
Price is not a reliable confirmation that you were right—a stock can go from 100 to 110 for completely different reasons than you expected (lawsuit settlement, management change, regulatory event), and trading based on price moves while ignoring whether your thesis is still valid is dangerous because you're now long a price move, not long an investment thesis.
“price is as john burbank said a liar and he and he was so true when he said that people that get fixated on price and assume that price is the answer to everything and price is the arbiter of whether you're right and wrong right is a really dangerous thing to get into you know saying that because this thing has gone from 100 to 110 i'm right no it's it's not that way at all”
When asset prices and food prices rise simultaneously, tension builds dangerously in society because it creates the worst economic condition for ordinary people: their savings (if in cash) are devalued while their cost of living rises, with no offsetting gain from asset appreciation.
“you can distill it down to if asset prices and food prices are going up at the same time that's that's when you get a lot of tension right”
During passive-buying-driven rallies on the upside, markets go up smoothly because flows are bid-indiscriminate; on the downside, if those same passive investors have to sell (redemptions, fear), the bids disappear and markets can gap down 30% in a single trade because algorithms don't care about price, only about hitting their sales targets.
“the rise of passive has really happened in tandem with rising markets juiced by all kinds of stimulus dollars you know 23 trillion worldwide among the central banks so that's that's been the perfect backdrop for the for the for the algorithms and the passive investing to kind of take that lion's share of the market when things start to go south it's going to be hugely problematic”
Volatility is increasing everywhere except the stock market—in streets, politics, geopolitics, divisions—while VIX (implied volatility in equities) remains suppressed due to passive buying pressure and algorithmic dampening, creating a dangerous disconnect where realized volatility (life) is much higher than implied volatility (markets).
“volatility is increasing everywhere except the stock market everywhere we look around us on the streets of new york on the streets of california yeah in europe in turkey in in greece in asia the streets of australia everywhere you look our lives are becoming more volatile um you know the the the division over covet the division over lockdown so volatility is is rising everywhere except the stock market which is you know an interesting phenomenon”
When the stock market is rising steadily ('stocks only go up' mentality), people are not concerned with downside risk; the perceived risk shifts from 'market decline' to 'missing out on the rally'—this inversion of risk perception is a classic sign of market mania.
“when you see that as being the risk you know there are bells ringing all over the place the people will look at the s p at a new record high and they won't understand that only 11 of the shares in the s p are making new highs”
The average investor spends 99.9% of their time asking 'is XYZ going up or down' and 0.1% asking 'how should I structure a portfolio to match my goals, control emotions, and execute discipline'—but the second question is what actually determines success.
“i'll bet you people spend 99.9 of their time focusing on is xyz going up or down in price and they spend almost zero percent of the time focusing on how to structure a portfolio to where everything is is matching up and then how to control their emotions knowing when to buy when to sell having a specific strategy”
The blackjack analogy of hitting on 19 and getting a 2 (blackjack)—making a bad decision that luckily worked out—teaches that winning with bad process makes you MORE likely to repeat the bad process next time, not less, because you attribute the win to the decision rather than the luck.
“if you're at the table and you got a 19 and let's say for whatever reason you're drinking or whatever you hit you get a two you get blackjack but did you make the right decision or the wrong decision”
To have a successful investing career, you only need a 51% win rate (getting more than half your calls right) IF you can also minimize losses on the 49% you get wrong and maximize profits on the 51% you get right—the math is that winners don't need to be that much larger than losers in absolute terms, but discipline on sizing and exits is more important than being right most of the time.
“if you're running a portfolio and you get 51 of your trades right over the years and you can then add on top of that the ability to manage your losing trade so that you minimize the losses and maximize the profits you make on the on the 51 you get right you will make a hell of a lot of money right but it's about being disciplined”
Post-pandemic stimulus has primarily inflated asset prices (stock market) rather than helping wage earners, because wealthy people own equities while the average person does not—meaning stimulus is making rich people richer while those unemployed see no benefit, creating visible resentment when headlines show billionaires gaining $40-80B while ordinary people struggle to buy food.
“the response to the pandemic has been from the same playbook in terms of stimulus you know that the money has gone into assets it's gone to wall street yes there's been checks mailed to to people but but what where have you seen the uh the effects of that stimulus you've seen in the stock market pure and simple and most people in the united states don't have money in the stock markets”
Passive investing has absorbed 'the lion's share' of inflows in the current cycle, enabled by $23 trillion in stimulus from central banks worldwide, creating a self-reinforcing dynamic where passive buying drives prices up, which attracts more passive capital—but this dynamic reverses when flows reverse.
“the rise of passive has really happened in tandem with rising markets juiced by all kinds of stimulus dollars you know 23 trillion worldwide among the central banks so that's that's been the perfect backdrop for the for the for the algorithms and the passive investing to kind of take that lion's share of the market”
Inflation expectations matter more than current CPI for predicting near-term inflation dynamics—when inflation expectations start climbing, money begins moving through the economy faster (velocity increases) as people try to spend before further devaluation, becoming a self-fulfilling prophecy.
“my ears always prick up when people like russell who's been a hardcore disinflationist or deflationist for 20 plus years now when people like him start saying i'm switching and and you know russell switched hard he said he he expects four percent inflation by the end of this year and obviously that recent cpi print coming in double expectations has kind of again pricked a few ears up but we don't have that that blowout number that that that two plus percent print that will make people take notice”
Chris Cole's thesis: 'there is only one asset class and that's volatility'—what matters is getting volatility right; structural low volatility in instruments (VIX) combined with high realized volatility (streets) is one of those alligator jaws that must resolve, likely by instrument volatility rising to match reality.
“chris said said to me a long time ago when i when i first interviewed him maybe four or five years ago again something that stuck with me ever since there is only one asset class and that's volatility and he's right you know getting volatility right really answers a lot of the questions you need to know”
Mike Green made a case that markets could literally go to zero if passive indiscriminate selling hits without any active bids to support prices—the reasoning should be listened to directly from Mike rather than paraphrased, but the implication is that passive investing tail risk is larger than commonly understood.
“mike made a very good case and i won't take the words out as much i will let people listen to it as opposed to me but it's but it's concerning and we haven't seen it yet but professionals are aware that it's a problem um you know non-professional investors aren't and nor will they be this this thing will come out the clear blue sky forum”
The Treasury General Account (TGA) holds over $1.7 trillion and represents a 'war chest' or 'bazooka' of potential fiscal stimulus that could be deployed rapidly into the economy—analogous to QE3 ($80B/month) but as direct fiscal injection, which operates through a different mechanism and is more immediately inflationary than reserve-based QE.
“i don't know if you followed much about the tga the treasury general account and that i i believe there's over 1.7 trillion there was last time and that i i believe there's basically qe on steroids from the standpoint of it not only increases base money but it increases broad money as well”
It took the United States from 1776 to approximately 2000 (224 years) to accumulate $5 trillion in national debt, but the nation is now adding approximately $5 trillion in one fiscal year—an astronomical rate of debt accumulation driven by post-1971 inflation in the supply of dollars rather than actual production growth.
“this year that the projected deficit is north of 4 trillion and who knows where it will be and if you look back at a chart it took the united states if i'm not mistaken almost up to 2000 so 1776. 220 ods yeah to to to get up to let's call it 5 trillion and we're getting there in one year we're adding 5 trillion to the debt that took us 224 years”
Only 11% of S&P 500 constituent stocks are making new highs while the index itself hits new highs—this is a 'huge red flag' indicating the market is concentrated in a narrow group of stocks, and if you're not in that narrow set you're losing money, making the market appear stronger than it is.
“people will look at the s p at a new record high and they won't understand that only 11 of the shares in the s p are making new highs that to a seasoned market professional is a huge red flag it just tells you that unless you're in the the four or five or ten stocks that are really going nuts you're losing money”
Japan's market didn't crash from 1989-2000; it 'stopped going up and started going down'—the psychological difference is that in a crash people know something is wrong, but in Japan people kept expecting the 'next day rally' that never came, extending the decline through false hope rather than panic.
“you know i was there i was in tokyo we were all standing on the desk but they shut the market half day because it was new year market hit a record high everyone's on the desk clapping and applauding that was it the next day it went down and everyone said oh it's just gone down today but japan goes up every day and then the next day it went down the next day it went down it started to continue to go down and yeah you had some sharper downside but it never crashed”
The solution to current market problems (low growth, debt accumulation) is always 'more cowbell'—more stimulus, more QE, more monetization—but the amount of stimulus required keeps growing (TARP $787B → QE3 $80B/month → current trillions), and at some point the inflation output of that printing will become obvious and problematic.
“there is only one solution and it's like cowbell right the only solution is to do more of it and so as more of this stuff happens and we get more cowbell and more printing and more q then the inflation's going to come”
Financial professionals and regular investors alike struggle with accepting mistakes; the only people who achieve long-term investing success are those honest enough to admit when they're wrong and committed to never repeating the same mistake twice.
“it's very difficult to to accept that you've made a mistake we all struggle with it and so having a framework through which you invest and having a certain discipline around that and and understanding not to let shares get too big and understanding you know when to let winners run and when to take some of them off the table for pullbacks and and when to cut your losses first and foremost is is crucial and and it's something that it really can't be taught but you can learn it”
Real cost-of-living inflation (for essentials like food, housing, energy, healthcare, education) shows double-digit inflation, while CPI shows low single-digit inflation—the difference is explained by hedonics and substitution methodology, but real families experience the high number, not the low CPI number.
“if you look at the things you have to have you look at food costs you look at housing costs you look at energy costs you look at health care costs you look at schooling costs all those things i mean we have double digit inflation in all of those and you know hedonics and substitution help and the way the basket's calculated helps but i think anybody if you measure inflation as a government statistic it is what we're told if you measure it as a cost of living i what is your cost of living the same basket because that you actually need to put on your family's table uh and to keep them you know having health insurance and to keep the roof over their heads and to keep your gas in the car we all know we all live that day today and we all know that is not going up or it's not unchanged or creeping up every year it just isn't”
Having a framework and discipline for investing will generate better results over full market cycles even if it means missing out during manias; investors with discipline are underperforming in current bull market but will dramatically outperform when cycles reverse, while those chasing every momentum stock will experience severe losses.
“the people who have a framework and a discipline are not making as much money now but over the cycle and these things are cycles to get back to our earlier point they will do better over the cycle because it's it's it's it's very difficult to to ride a train like this and be making money every day and to know when to get off it's very difficult because it's such a seductive”
Fear and greed are the only real forces in markets; all market behavior can be understood as oscillations between these two emotions, and they are asymmetric: everyone feels fear in downturns but not everyone feels greed in upturns, making crashes more synchronized and severe than rallies.
“there really is nothing but that we have periods of fear periods of greed and very very short moments of apathy at bottoms where where people just don't want to know about stocks you know we had that 1982 was the last time really i guess when people didn't want to know about stocks”
Taking profits on lucky wins and not over-extending position size into concentrated bets is crucial risk management that protects portfolios over cycles; the discipline to walk away from a winning position before thesis confirms is rare but necessary.
“have the hubris or the lack of hubris rather to uh to take that position off and say hey i got lucky here i made 10 on this and out of nowhere i'm going to take that off the table and i'm going to wait for my investment case to come back and then i'll reinvest it's um it's i don't know i think you can only really learn these things the hard way”
People are psychologically hardwired to want delegation and shortcuts rather than doing hard thinking themselves—they want someone to tell them which stock to buy rather than understanding the framework for how to think about stocks, making them vulnerable to overconfidence and poor timing.
“i i think that's the way we're hardwired as human beings we want to delegate the the hard thinking and the heavy lifting to someone else so we can pay more attention to the things that we want to such as you know spending more time with our kids and worrying about the walking the dog and and soccer practice and all these other things”
Russell Napier, a 20+-year disinflationist, has recently switched to expecting 4% inflation by end of year (circa 2020), which is significant because his track record and contrarian shift is a reliable signal that inflation risk has substantively increased—people should listen to experts who have been wrong on inflation for decades when they finally flip.
“but for me my ears always prick up when people like russell who's been a hardcore disinflationist or deflationist for 20 plus years now when people like him start saying i'm switching and and you know russell switched hard he said he he expects four percent inflation by the end of this year”
Foreigners have 'stopped buying treasuries to a large extent', forcing the Federal Reserve to absorb more of the deficit spending through monetization—this is a structural shift in the Treasury market that weakens the fiscal system's ability to finance deficits externally.
“because you know foreigners have stopped buying treasuries to a large extent and and obviously with deficits of what we're up to three trillion deficit now and change um a lot more of that is having to be monetized by the fed”
Owning real assets (commodities, precious metals, real estate producing yield) is 'arguably one of the only ways to protect yourself' from the inflation that will come from increased stimulus and monetization.
“you know owning real assets is is arguably one of the only ways to protect yourself from that and i said i think more and more people are cutting on to that”
The economy and stock market are showing early signs of reconnection (rising delinquency rates, unemployment ticking up, stimulus ending) after a long period of decoupling—when they 'catch up', it will be because the stock market falls to meet the economy, not the economy improves to meet the market, making this one of the defining risks.
“if you watch what's happening now with the economy we're starting to see uh potential reconnections between the stock market the economy as delinquency rates start soaring as welfare checks start to run out as you know stimulus runs out as unemployment unexpectedly yesterday climbed above a million uh initial unemployment claims again we're starting to see we're starting to see potential ways that the two can reconnect the economy and the stock market”
Dave Portnoy's 'stocks only go up' is the classic rallying cry at market tops—it was said at the end of 1999 about tech stocks ('internet stocks, buy for eyeballs') and housing in 2007 ('housing always goes up'), and current 'stocks only go up' rhetoric suggests we're approaching a similar inflection point.
“that's the beauty of it we'll see this you know bill and i call that podcast the end game we know that there isn't an end to this there's an end to this chapter it's like there was an end to the japan chapter in 89 and into the tech chapter in 99 and into the housing boom in 2007-8 there'll be an end to this it won't be the end but it'll be an end”
Don't simply adopt one person's inflation or deflation thesis and structure your entire portfolio around it; instead, use arguments from both sides (Russell Napier for inflation, Lacy Hunt for deflation) as frameworks to understand what to look for, then stress-test that framework against real-time data to see which thesis is still holding up.
“both of them could be right frankly it's all a question of timing but understanding the arguments for them and not necessarily saying well lately told me it's deflation so i'm going to set my portfolio up for deflection or russell said the opposite so i'm going to go for inflation it's a very dangerous thing to do to just listen to small people you know what what the information they're giving you is a framework within which you can actually take what they've taught you and then do that next step apply that to what you see in front of you”
The wolf in the Aesop's fable always eventually shows up; the boy who cried wolf too early still gets eaten in the end, so repeatedly warning about inflation risks that haven't materialized yet does not invalidate the warnings—it only delays inevitable vindication.
“that is for sure yeah you'll find the end game... saying oh well grant and george they might be the boy that cried wolf regarding inflation at the end of the story the wolf shows up so maybe yeah that's the bit people forget right the kid gets eaten at the end of the story”
The conflict dynamic in developed countries is now primarily between the haves and have-nots (wealth inequality), not between left and right political factions, which is genuinely dangerous because wealth-based conflict is harder to reconcile than ideological differences.
“my point to eric was that we have conflict everywhere right this is an era of conflict whether it's left and right whether it's uh you know employed and unemployed now whether it's uh old and young you know we've got this boomer millennial kind of clash and more and more recently it's it's the haves and the have-nots the wealthy and the poor”
COVID experience of empty shelves and inability to buy basic goods (bread, toilet paper) creates a psychological memory that makes consumers willing to pay higher prices—they'll accept a $1 increase on bread if they remember not being able to get any bread two months ago, giving manufacturers a window to pass on cost increases while blaming supply chain disruptions.
“you know given the experience we've had in covid where everybody has a has a very recent experience of going to a grocery store and either finding basic everyday items not in stock or shelves empty or unable to buy bread or toilet roll or any of this you know basic necessities when you have a memory that recent it becomes much easier for people to pass costs on to consumers because if the choice is paying an extra dollar for your loaf of bread but you have a memory of not being able to get any a couple of months ago you're much more willing to tolerate that that one dollar increase in the price of bread”
The Fourth Turning, a generational cycle framework identifying current era as marked by upheaval, power transitions between generations, debt crises, and conflict—including potential cross-border wars, not just civil unrest—began around 2008 and will last another eight years from the time of speaking (circa 2020), entering its most dangerous phase now.
“the fourth turning is characterized by exactly what we're seeing now you know upheaval it's a change in power between generations uh society tends to break down we have uh you know debt crises the whole thing i mean it's an extraordinary book and if your viewers haven't read it”
Steve Diggle made a profound observation that 'it's never a good time to be poor but this is a very bad time to be rich' a few years ago; this has proven increasingly true as asset prices have separated from wages and real income for the non-wealthy majority.
“a great friend of mine steve diggle said to me a few years ago something which i kind of laughed off at the time was just a cute phrase but it's actually very profound you know he said to me four maybe five years ago he said grant this is a very he said it's never a good time to be poor but this is a very bad time to be rich and he was right then and he's even more right today”
Policymakers will face strong pressure to spend down the TGA despite inflation risks because the political cost of saying 'this would cause inflation' is higher than the cost of actually creating inflation, especially when 12 years of QE created no visible consumer inflation—giving politicians defensible cover ('your balance sheet is $7T and CPI is 1%, so stop complaining').
“there's going to be a lot of pressure on this how do you say no to doing that because it will cause inflation it's a very difficult argument to make because there's so much evidence to the contrary now this is a different mechanism but the pressure to spend that money is going to be coming from policy makers not central bankers it's going to be coming from people who who want to promise and spend to your point to buy the election right”
The host and Grant's role in creating content is to 'help people understand that this business is not about stock tips...it's about understanding what to look for'—the purpose is teaching frameworks, not making predictions.
“that's a big reason why bill and i have been doing this i know it's a big reason why you do this stuff is to help people understand that this business is not about stock tips it's not about someone saying hey you know buy xyz or buy silver or buy gold it's about understanding what to look for if you are gonna buy silver because if you understand what to look for you understand when you might need to sell it again”
The current market is unlike anything Williams has seen in terms of how easy it appears to be to make money, which is dangerous because it creates complacency and causes disciplined investors to abandon frameworks despite historically knowing this precedes crashes.
“look look i could get in the batting box in a major league game swing the bat and i may hit a home run i it may happen once i may just swing at the right time make contact with the ball and sails over the outfield who knows right it's unlikely let's face it but it could happen the chance of me striking out 9099 times out of 10 000 is very very high but with investing you know people particularly in markets like we have now which is unlike anything i've seen catching that lightning in a bottle seems that much easier”
The Fourth Turning framework predicts social conflict, but the specific form and trigger are less predictable—the 2020 election result (Trump winning EC but losing popular vote) could be a catalyst that 'escalates' internal conflict beyond the 'reasonably civil' response of 2016.
“and obviously with a with an incredibly polarizing election coming up in november we're just what 60 odd days away from that now i think maybe a little bit more um you have a potential catalyst should we see for example the same result we saw in 2016 i.e trump wins the college but loses the popular vote you know that that prospect frightens me enormously because the outpouring of anger when it happened the first time was was reasonably civil i suspect given what's happened in the intervening four years we wouldn't see the same kind of stability again if that result would have happened”
Durable goods purchases spiked during COVID lockdowns as percentage of income because people couldn't go to restaurants or movies, but this substitution effect will reverse as reopening occurs; monitoring where discretionary spending flows is key to understanding demand dynamics.
“you're not spending money at movie theaters and restaurants and stuff we've seen that velocity drop what's going to be very interesting is once things start opening up and you see it now mike greenberg great shot up on twitter this morning showing durable goods as a percentage of my personal outlets it's shot through the roof because of course people can't go out and spend on entertainment so there's you know they buy new washing machines”
The end game podcast series (End Game with Bill Fleckenstein, Super Terrific Happy Hour with Stephanie Pomboy, and The Narrative Game with Ben Hunt) provides different perspectives on macro risks and narrative-driven markets, with all three offering valuable insights into market psychology and structural vulnerabilities.
“there's there's kind of three different series i do under that banner one of them is the end game of bill fleckenstein uh there's another one called the super terrific happy hour with my dear friend stephanie pomboy which is again she's she's fantastic we have some great guests on there uh and then i do one with ben hunt called the narrative game where we we talk periodically about some of the narrative-based things that go on they're all fascinating in their own way and they're all very different in their own way”