
Climate researcher on what's causing the record rise in ocean temperatures
What this covers
This is a six-minute PBS NewsHour interview in which William Brangham talks with climate scientist John Abraham about the record warming of the world's oceans. It opens with the World Meteorological Organization's red alert that 2024 is on course for another record year. A chart of daily ocean surface temperature readings from 1979 onward shows 2023 climbing from the upper end of normal to a record, and 2024 already beyond it. Abraham stresses why even a degree matters: the oceans cover 70% of the planet and take enormous energy to heat. He says the main driver each year is global warming, with heat passing from a warming atmosphere, laden with greenhouse gas, into the water. El Niño adds to that baseline.
The contentious part is what remains unexplained. Abraham describes two camps: one holds that long-term warming plus El Niño is enough, the other suspects an additional ingredient. He places himself in the middle and offers an intuitive, admittedly rough split of about 50% global warming, a third El Niño, and around 20% unexplained. That remainder could be further warming not captured in models, or a different mechanism entirely.
Brangham raises the candidates other scientists are weighing: moisture injected into the atmosphere by a volcanic eruption (likely Tonga in 2022), solar cycles, and the cutback in shipping pollution. The last is a paradox, since cleaner fuel helps human health but removes aerosol particles that shade the oceans. Abraham is unconvinced by any of them because the warming is geographically uneven, concentrated in the Atlantic.
The closing minutes turn to consequences and response. He expects altered weather patterns worldwide, and he argues for conservation and renewable energy, noting that clean power is now cost-competitive with fossil fuels and that rooftop solar has shifted from a sign of altruism to one of fiscal prudence.
Ocean temperatures in 2024 are warming at rates that exceed what global warming and El Niño alone can explain, suggesting either undetected mechanisms or additional climate forcing factors, though the primary driver remains anthropogenic climate change.
- Ocean surface temperatures are in 'uncharted territory' with 2024 already exceeding 2023's record-breaking levels
- The warming pattern is geographically uneven (concentrated in Atlantic), inconsistent with volcanic or solar cycle explanations
- About 50% attributable to global warming, 30% to El Niño, with 20% remaining unexplained
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The elimination of pollution from shipping has paradoxical effects: while beneficial for human health, it removes atmospheric aerosols that act as a 'cooling umbrella' over the oceans, potentially contributing to ocean warming.
“Also the elimination of a lot of pollution from shipping which paradoxically, it is wonderful for human health but it is taking the umbrella off the oceans which can warm the oceans.”
For ocean temperature, even a one-degree Celsius or Fahrenheit warming represents a substantial change with significant global consequences because the oceans cover 70% of Earth's surface and require astronomical amounts of energy to heat.
“The oceans are colossal. A watched pot never boils. It takes a lot of energy to heat up water. If that is true for a pot on your stove, think about how true it is for the ocean to cover 70% of our planet. The amount of heat has to go into the oceans to raise their temperature a degree celsius or a degree fahrenheit is astronomical. A degree warming of the ocean, that is a different world.”
Current ocean temperatures are 'off the charts' and more than would be normally expected even accounting for El Niño effects.
“This is off the charts. It is more than we would have normally expected even within el niño.”
Average daily surface temperatures of the world's oceans are shown by thin gray lines representing readings from 1979 through 2023, with 2023 starting at upper end of normal but becoming a record-breaking hot year, and 2024 already showing readings in uncharted territory.
“This shows the average daily surface temperatures of the world's oceans. The thin gray lines represent one year and 79. His last years readings in Arndt. 2023 started out in the upper end of normal but soon became a record-breaking we hot year. Here in red, is just the beginning of this year. The oceans are already in uncharted territory.”
The primary driver of record-breaking ocean temperatures each year is global warming, not El Niño or other factors, despite the contribution of these other mechanisms.
“The majority of this and the reason we are setting records every year is mobile warming.”
Humanity can address climate change through conservation and wise energy use, specifically by not wasting the energy obtained from fossil fuels and by maximizing development of clean and renewable energy sources.
“That is the easy part. We need to do a couple things and we can do them with today's technology. We need to conserve technology. Use energy more wisely. Let's not waste the energy we get out of fossil fuels. Secondly, maximize our development of clean and renewable energy.”
There are two main scientific perspectives on current ocean warming: one group explains it through long-term global warming and El Niño, while another group believes there may be an additional undetected ingredient or mechanism at work.
“Behind the scenes, there are two groups of scientists. One group thinks what we are seeing can be explained by long-term global warming. And what is called el niño. There is another group who think there might be another ingredient. There might be something we have not detected.”
The World Meteorological Organization issued a red alert warning that 2024 is shaping up to be another record-breaking year for warming and climate change.
“The world meteorological organization issued a red alert running today about -- alert warning today about warming and climate change saying 2024 is shaping up to be another record year.”
The unexplained 20% of ocean warming could represent either additional global warming effects not yet accounted for in models or an entirely different mechanism.
“The 20% could be some extra global warming we had not accounted for. It could be something else.”
Maximizing clean renewable energy development is one of the most important actions people can take to change the climate change trajectory.
“Those things are the most important things people can do to change the trajectory we are on.”
Ocean warming will affect weather patterns all over the planet with tremendous impacts to humans and human society.
“It is going to affect the weather all over the planet. Tremendous impacts to humans and our society.”
A volcanic eruption (likely referring to Tonga eruption in 2022) injected significant amounts of moisture into the atmosphere, which some scientists consider as a possible contributor to ocean warming.
“This you to volcanic eruption that spent a ton of moisture into the atmosphere.”
Clean renewable energy is now cost-comparable to fossil fuels, eliminating cost as an economic barrier to deployment.
“The great thing is green energy is cost comparable to fossil fuels.”
Clean energy is now cheaper than coal, creating an inflection point in the scientific and energy communities toward renewable adoption.
“Clean energy is cheaper than coal. That has created an inflection point in the scientific community.”
John Abraham is not convinced that volcanic eruptions, solar cycles, or the elimination of shipping pollution are the primary causes of the observed anomalous ocean warming, based on geographic patterns of warming that don't align with these mechanisms.
“I'm not sold. The reason I'm not sold is we are seeing an incredible amount of heat in specific locations. On a particular in the atlantic ocean. We are seeing other parts of the planet that have lower surface temperatures. The patterns of warming we are seeing don't jive with some of the other options you mentioned.”
Historically, solar panels on residential homes were seen as indicators of altruism or environmental concern, but now they represent fiscal conservatism and economic rationality due to cost reductions.
“In the olden days, if you put solar panels on your house, that was a mark of altruism. Now it is a mark of fiscal conservatism.”
According to Abraham's rough estimate based on intuition, approximately 50% of observed ocean warming is attributable to long-term global warming, approximately 33% to El Niño, and approximately 20% remains unexplained.
“If you want me to quantify the effect and this is just off-the-cuff. This is a rough estimate based on my intuition. There is about half global warming and maybe a third of it is el niño. And the remainder, 20% or so is a question mark.”
John Abraham positions himself in the middle of scientific opinion, noting that the warming observed in the past year is somewhat out of the ordinary compared to what global warming and El Niño together would predict, and acknowledges uncertainty about whether an additional mechanism is operating.
“I'm sort of in the middle. The warming we are seeing this past year is a little out of the ordinary of what we would expect with global warning and el niño together. Maybe something else is happening but we don't know. This is what makes scientists excited and this is what makes science great.”
The cost competitiveness of renewable energy compared to fossil fuels gives optimism about the feasibility of addressing climate change trajectory.
“That is what gives us optimism. There is no reason not to maximize clean renewable energy.”
Record-breaking warming of the world's oceans is one of the many major concerns about how the planet is changing due in part to human activity.
“One of the many worries about how the plane is changing thanks in part to human activity is the record shattering warming of the world's oceans.”
El Niño weather patterns can warm the oceans in addition to the baseline warming caused by atmospheric greenhouse gas accumulation.
“Nino, that can warm the oceans as well.”
As the atmosphere warms due to climate change, the oceans become warmer due to heat transfer between the two systems, which is a well-documented physical fact.
“as we warm the atmosphere, the oceans do get warmer. We know that is a well documented fact”
Abraham acknowledges that other scientists are considering the volcanic, solar, and shipping pollution mechanisms as explanations even though he personally is not convinced they account for the observed warming patterns.
“They are under consideration by my colleagues.”
Solar cycles (variations in solar radiation output) may be a contributing factor to ocean warming and are considered by some scientists as a possible mechanism.
“Solar cycles.”
The temperature increases observed in ocean warming data are astounding in magnitude and significance.
“These numbers in terms of temperature increases are really astounding.”