YouTube48m· Aug 2020· cataloged

Jason Crawford - The Roots of Progress & the History of Technology


What this covers

Jason Crawford discusses the history of technology and philosophy of progress with host Dwarkesh Patel, drawing on work from The Roots of Progress. The conversation traces how material life has improved dramatically over the past 250 years—a change unprecedented in human history—while arguing that this progress is neither automatic nor inevitable. Crawford and Patel examine why recent decades appear to show slowing progress and what that means for the future, framed around the question of whether progress can be reaccelerated rather than merely preserved or abandoned.

The discussion moves across several connected territories. Crawford explains how technological advance works through overlapping S-curves, where individual technologies mature and saturate while new ones must be ready to take off, and how the relationship between science and technology is cyclical rather than linear—inventions often precede scientific understanding, with the transistor and steam engine as examples. He addresses the stagnation hypothesis (that progress genuinely slowed over the last fifty years) as evidence that progress requires active maintenance rather than passive trust. The conversation then turns to contemporary friction points: accumulating bureaucratic overhead, how progress breeds specialization and fragility, and the post-World War II cultural shift toward skepticism of technology that may have weakened scientific talent recruitment. Crawford distinguishes between descriptive optimism (a prediction about the future) and prescriptive optimism (a commitment to act), arguing the latter remains rational even if one doubts the former. He contends that downsides of progress—vulnerability, existential risk—should be addressed through more and wiser progress, not by braking, and that the real problem is misallocated effort across types of progress rather than progress itself.

Sharpest takeaway

Crawford argues that material progress over the last ~250 years is historically unprecedented but not automatic or inevitable, and that the apparent recent stagnation should be addressed not by slowing progress but by reallocating effort toward a broader portfolio of progress (including safety and resilience) while maintaining a 'prescriptive optimist' commitment to act.

  • Progress proceeds through overlapping technological S-curves and can slow when society fails to seed and jump to new ones
  • Science and technology are distinct but cyclically interdependent rather than linearly causal
  • Downsides of progress (fragility, existential risk) should be solved with more, wiser progress, not by braking

The claims · ranked26 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.86

Inventions frequently emerge from tinkering at the frontier of science before anyone fully understands why they work, and the science often comes afterward, motivated by the invention itself—as with the transistor (where Bell Labs shuttled rapidly between failed experiments and new semiconductor theory) and the steam engine (which preceded and motivated thermodynamics).

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Jason Crawford

“new inventions often occur they are often the result of tinkering and exploration at the frontiers of science such that when the invention is created nobody actually even fully understands why it works”

0.80

Long-run exponential progress is produced by overlapping S-curves: each individual technology starts slow, hits an inflection point and accelerates, then saturates and matures; sustained progress requires that as one area levels off, another area (already being tinkered with) is ready to take off.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Jason Crawford

“we do it by overlapping the s curves right as one area starts to kind of level off and get saturated and mature we hopefully are finding some other air area”

0.80

The linear model of innovation (pure curiosity-driven basic science → engineers deductively applying laws → inventions → businesses distributing benefits) contains real truths but is oversimplified: science genuinely provides an indispensable foundation for technology, and the unpredictable long-term ramifications of science justify pursuing it for pure understanding alone.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Jason Crawford

“i think the linear model has some truth to it and is also oversimplified”

0.78

It is not meaningful to assign probabilities to far-future events (like an 800-year survival forecast) that depend on future human action and future human knowledge, since such knowledge is by nature unpredictable.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker

“i don't know how it's meaningful to assign probabilities to events that depend on human action and future human knowledge”

0.76

Science is often gated on technology, particularly the technology of measuring instruments and observation (microscopes, thermometers, pressure chambers), so technological advance enables scientific advance just as science enables technology—making the science-technology relationship cyclical rather than linear.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Jason Crawford

“science is sometimes gated on technology especially technology of measuring instruments and uh you know an observation”

0.74

Deep philosophical ideas have very powerful long-term effects on intellectual life, culture, government, and institutions, but the propagation from originators in academia to broad cultural impact takes decades, so anyone working on such ideas should expect to play a very long game.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Jason Crawford

“deep philosophical ideas do over the very long term have very powerful effects on intellectual life and ultimately on culture on the broader world”

0.72

Vulnerability to shocks created by progress can be addressed through the same fundamental mechanisms that created it—science, technology, mathematics, statistics, and applied intelligence—by analyzing systems for fragility and engineering in resilience: avoiding single points of failure, building buffers and slack, and absorbing shocks rather than letting them ripple through the whole system.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Jason Crawford

“it is also a risk that we can tackle through the very same fundamental mechanisms that we made the progress that created the risk in the first place through science uh through technology”

0.68

The stagnation hypothesis (that progress has actually slowed over the last 50 years, e.g. we still fly at the speed of the 1970s 747) gives extra urgency to studying progress because it shows progress is not automatic, inevitable, or self-sustaining and can run into friction and slow down.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jason Crawford

“this thing is this this progress thing is not automatic it's not inevitable it doesn't just keep going with its own momentum it can slow down maybe it's running into friction”

0.68

Creeping bureaucracy and accumulating safety-driven rules at the legal, corporate, and university levels may have added overhead and friction to the innovative process; though each rule was often added for a rational safety reason, we may never have evaluated the cumulative cost and may have unwittingly traded too much progress for safety.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jason Crawford

“have all of our institutions kind of evolved and accumulated a set of bureaucratic rules that have the uh you know that have the effect of essentially adding overhead and friction to the the creative and innovative process”

0.68

Recent underwhelming progress may be partly explained by how many S-curves are running simultaneously, how fast new ones are being found, and how ready we are to jump to the next when one levels off.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jason Crawford

“how many of these different s curves do we have going on at once and how fast were we finding new ones and when one starts to level off like how ready are we to jump to the next”

0.68

Moral, social, and governmental progress is the area where it is hardest to clearly see progress; the story is the most mixed, feeling like two steps forward and one (or more) steps back, even though there have been clear gains in some dimensions such as civil rights.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jason Crawford

“progress in uh morality society and government is the like that's the area where it is most difficult to clearly see progress and where i think the story is the most mixed”

0.68

Progress increases interdependence and specialization so that no one possesses all the knowledge needed to make even a pencil or smartphone, which can make civilization more vulnerable to black-swan shocks like coronavirus.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker

“no nobody has all the knowledge necessary to like make a pencil or a smartphone and so it makes you more susceptible to black swan events like coronavirus”

0.65

The scientific revolution, the industrial revolution, and the revolution of democratic republics all occurred around the same time in history, and this is not a coincidence; for example, the dissolution of the guild system was important for new businesses to form and new technologies to be adopted.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Jason Crawford

“it's it's not a coincidence that we kind of had three revolutions that all happened around the same time roughly speaking in history we had the scientific revolution we had the industrial revolution and then we had you know something that there actually isn't a good name for”

0.63

The right response to the downsides of progress is not to slow down, brake, or be ambivalent, but to take a wider view of what progress means: the real problem is an unwise portfolio allocation among types of progress, so we should reallocate effort and resources toward safety and resilience while still pursuing 'more, bigger, faster, better.'

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Jason Crawford

“the problem is uh an unwise portfolio allocation of resource of of what type of progress we are making let's reallocate so that we are making an appropriate amount of safety and resilience progress”

0.62

Post-WWII cultural shifts (the horror of the atomic bomb, fears of nuclear power, the rise of environmentalism in the 60s-70s, the oil shocks) may have created anti-technology, anti-progress sentiment that reduced young people's motivation to enter science, technology, and industry, weakening long-term talent recruitment into those fields.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Jason Crawford

“did this change the motivation of young people around that time to even go into science technology and industry right if people started to think that these were not forces for good in the world”

0.60

There are two distinct types of optimism: descriptive optimism (a prediction that the future will be better) and prescriptive optimism (a determination and commitment to act to create a better future); one can rationally be a descriptive pessimist while remaining an unwavering prescriptive optimist who refuses to give up no matter how bad the odds.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Jason Crawford

“descriptive optimism is your prediction for what's going to happen in the future ... prescriptive optimism is your determination to and your commitment to act to create a better future”

0.59

Combining prescriptive optimism with descriptive optimism yields bold, ambitious, expansive plans (colonizing the solar system, solving aging, universal material abundance), whereas combining prescriptive optimism with descriptive pessimism yields a 'fighting spirit'—a refusal to give up and a commitment to give one's best efforts regardless of the odds.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Jason Crawford

“if you combine descriptive optimism with prescriptive optimism then i think the ... attitude that comes out of that is bold ambitious expansive plans for the future”

0.56

Tyler Cowen predicts human civilization will not last longer than 800 years because the risk and capacity for mass destruction (e.g. accessible nuclear weapons) grows faster than our capacity to defend against such shocks, creating an asymmetry where destruction is easier to innovate than deterrence.

forecasthigh valuefringenovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker

“tyler cowan was on the podcast he said he doesn't expect human civilization to last longer than 800 years”

0.52

Whether progress slowed in the past is less important than whether it can be sped up in the future; what matters most is understanding the range of possible futures and identifying the control knobs or levers we can actually influence.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jason Crawford

“whether or not it has slowed down in the past is actually even less important than uh whether or not it could be sped up in the future”

0.52

Progress studies is not a new field meant to replace history or economics, but rather a school of thought: a set of premises and values holding that progress is real, important, can have tremendously good effects, and is not automatic, and that we should therefore study, protect, nurture, and accelerate it.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jason Crawford

“progress studies in my mind is more like a school of thought it's a set of premises and values uh it's a set of basic ideas about what is important”

0.52

The history of progress is neglected and underrepresented in education, so we graduate students who take the modern industrial world for granted; basic literacy in how our standard of living is delivered is necessary for citizens to debate industrial policy without inadvertently proposing things that would seriously degrade quality of life.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jason Crawford

“the history of progress is a neglected topic in education it is underrepresented in uh in history class”

0.48

Life is dramatically better in almost every way than it was 200-250 years ago, and this rapid improvement in living standards, life expectancy, health, and mobility is historically unprecedented after tens of thousands of years of near-stagnation.

factualestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Jason Crawford

“for thousands tens of thousands of years as far as back as you want to go really there was uh there was very little uh improvement in the standard of living”

0.43

Although science and technology are cyclically interdependent and inseparable in practice, it is still worth distinguishing and separating them for the purposes of specialized study—just as physics, chemistry, and biology are linked but specialized—provided we recognize their connections are neither simple nor linear.

normativeestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jason Crawford

“science and technology are distinct if inseparable um they are different things and they can be identified as such and uh and i think it's worth splitting them up just for the purposes of study”

0.43

A year ago Tyler Cowen and Patrick Collison coined the term 'progress studies' in an Atlantic article headlined roughly 'We Need a New Science of Progress,' arguing not that no work is being done but that more should be done and more attention paid to existing work.

factualestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jason Crawford

“tyler cowan and patrick collison coined the term progress studies in an article they published in the atlantic uh that ran under the headline something like we need a new science of progress”

0.35

Even if progress has slowed over the last 50 years, it is still far faster than the rate of the thousands of years before the industrial age, so progress has by no means stopped.

factualestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jason Crawford

“even if progress has slowed down the last 50 years ... it's still a lot faster than you know the thousands of years before the industrial age”

0.31

There is no existing academic paradigm that progress studies could simply graft onto (the way critical theory built on Marxism); it will likely need to be something new, even though there is already good existing academic work that could form its basis.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Jason Crawford

“i think it will need to be something new uh not that there aren't already there's already ... plenty of good work in academia that i think can form the basis of some new movement”