
US Treasury Gold Revaluation - Can They Do This?
What this covers
This episode of Milkshakes Markets & Madness (Episode 111, recorded February 6, 2025) is a single-analyst walk-through of whether the Treasury could revalue its gold and spend the result. The official reference price is still $42 an ounce, set in 1971-72, while the market price is around $2,900. Closing that gap would create roughly $750-800 billion in new Federal Reserve Notes to credit to the Treasury General Account (TGA)). The speaker's point is that the mechanics are simple on paper but depend on an institution the Treasury does not control. Treasury's gold sits at the New York Fed, and Treasury relies on the Fed as its banker. The speaker also notes that the regional Reserve Banks are privately organized, which leaves legal ambiguity over whether the Fed must follow Treasury directives.
Much of the episode is a history of Fed-versus-executive standoffs. It covers the 1951 Accord, where Thomas McCabe and William McChesney Martin refused Truman's demand for low rates to fund the Korean War. It then covers the 1960s, and Arthur Burns, who eventually gave way to Nixon, which the speaker uses to tally the score at 2-1 for the Fed. Paul Volcker is the next example, raising rates to 19% despite pressure from Reagan's circle. The 2018 clash follows, when Trump called Powell "the enemy," and the episode argues Trump may be less willing than Reagan to accept Fed independence. Powell's recent comments that a president cannot fire him are noted, as is his wariness after the 2023-24 inflation episode.
Other turns include the 1933-34 precedent, when the government took in private gold at $20 an ounce and revalued it to $35, producing a windfall Congress could appropriate. The speaker also covers the inflationary spiral that comes with trying to peg) gold, since the government must buy at the peg price with borrowed or printed money. Janet Yellen's heavy bill issuance and $1.5 trillion TGA drawdown during Powell's tightening illustrate Treasury-Fed friction. Bessent's writing that the U.S. is "not broke" because its asset side is ignored suggests an appetite for the idea.
The U.S. Treasury can revalue gold and deposit new funds into its account, but this process requires Federal Reserve cooperation and Congressional appropriation—it is neither impossible nor simple, and involves significant political, legal, and market complications that are often overlooked.
- Treasury cannot act unilaterally; it lacks its own bank and depends on the Fed to monetize gold revaluations
- Historical precedent shows the Fed has repeatedly resisted executive branch pressure on monetary policy, suggesting Powell may resist gold revaluation despite pressure
- Market and political complications—inflation fears, gold price volatility, derivative exposures, Congressional opposition—make execution far more complex than mechanically feasible
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The US Treasury cannot unilaterally revalue gold and spend the proceeds; it requires Federal Reserve cooperation because the Fed functions as the government's banker and the Treasury's gold is held at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York
“the treasury cannot on its own wake up revalue gold higher and then go spend the money as they want that is absolutely true...the treasury can absolutely revalue gold what they cannot do is then go spend that money all on their own however they want for two reasons number one they need the fed's help the FED is the government's Banker”
The Federal Reserve is not a fully government entity; Federal Reserve regional banks are privately organized and privately owned, their employees are not federal employees, and the Fed has legal independence that the president cannot unilaterally override.
“the individual federal reserve banks are not they are privately organized and privately owned organizations they are not government institutions they are not government funded the employees that work at the Federal Reserve are not federal employees and there is legal precedent laying this out in very clear detail”
The Fed has a dual mandate of full employment and stable prices, and this mandate has motivated the Fed to resist Treasury and executive pressure multiple times in history—particularly in 1951 (Korean War), 1960s (Vietnam War), and 2018–2019 (Trump's pressure on Powell)—because lower rates would risk inflation.
“the FED has a dual Mandate of um Full Employment and uh stable prices you know inflation basically and there's been times throughout history”
To peg the gold price, the government would have to be willing to buy gold at the peg price, which requires either borrowing additional funds or printing additional money, creating a vicious cycle where gold pegging becomes inflationary
“if you do say that you have to stand willing to buy it at that price that's what a peg is okay so then what does that mean that means that the fed or the treasury or whoever in the government decides to do it now has to start bidding for gold at $220,000 well where does that money come from to bid gold at $20,000 well they either have to borrow more of it or they have to print more of it so you start to get into this vicious cycle”
In 1929-1930, the US government forced private gold ownership surrender, paying citizens $20-$29 per ounce, then immediately issued gold certificates to the Federal Reserve priced at $35 per ounce, creating an automatic windfall for the government of approximately $5-15 per ounce multiplied by the total gold stock
“what happened back in the 19 I don't remember the exact date I'm going to guess it was I think it was 1920 or 1929 when sorry 1929 19 193 it was 1929 or 1930 when um you know the the the US said the private ownership of gold is no longer allowed you have to turn in your gold your gold certificates etc etc to the United States government and the United States government paid everybody I think it was $29 uh to um to do that and or maybe it was $20 I can't remember what what the exact number was I think it was $20 actually um and then um they took those they took that gold and they gave the Federal Reserve gold certificates and those gold certificates were priced at $35 so it was an automatic huge windfall for the government because they paid 20 bucks and they now they're getting 35”
In the 1951 Federal Reserve–Treasury Accord, the Fed successfully established its independence and ended its obligation to peg interest rates for government fiscal objectives, setting a precedent that has held since and constraining executive power over monetary policy.
“they even had this thing it was called the FED treasury Accord and it basically it ended the fed's obligation to Peg interest rates and it and it solidified that the the Fed Independence and and that has held since then”
Arthur Burns, Fed chair under Nixon, eventually cut interest rates in response to Nixon's pressure, making it 2–1 in favor of Fed victories over presidents (Nixon lost this battle, while Truman and Johnson also lost).
“now let's see what's the next one Richard Nixon and Arthur Burns you're starting to get the picture here presidents always want low interest rates because they want the economy to be better and the FED who is charged the Dual Mandate of Full Employment and low inflation or steady inflation has to fight back occasionally”
Paul Volcker raised interest rates to 19% to combat inflation despite pressure from President Reagan and Treasury Secretary Donald Regan, and Reagan eventually reappointed him in 1982–1983, establishing Volcker as legendary for Fed independence.
“the legend right now this is this is like bringing in you know Johnny Unitus to win the game because you know nobody is more revered in Central Banking than Paul vulker this guy raised rates to 19% I mean and and listen he he was like he I'm gonna kill inflation I don't care what you say and do you think President Reagan who had just gotten into office wanted 19% interest rates of course not and so you know uh the treasury secretary's name was rean so you had President Reagan and Donald rean um and they were trying to get uh they were trying to get interest rates lowered and vulker held them steady and they even they even leaked rumors that they were going to replace vulker but vulker didn't back down he refused to change policy”
The Federal Reserve is not a government agency; the individual Federal Reserve Banks are privately organized and privately owned entities with employees who are not federal employees, creating legal ambiguity about whether the Fed must comply with Treasury directives
“the Federal Reserve System is a government sasi government entity but the individual federal reserve banks are not they are privately organized and privately owned organizations they are not government institutions they are not government funded the employees that work at the Federal Reserve are not federal employees”
Historical precedent from 1933 shows the U.S. government confiscated private gold at $20 per ounce, then immediately revalued it to $35 per ounce when issuing Federal Reserve gold certificates, creating an automatic $15 billion windfall that could be appropriated by Congress.
“what happened back in the 19 I don't remember the exact date I'm going to guess it was I think it was 1920 or 1929 when sorry 1929 19 193 it was 1929 or 1930 when um you know the the the US said the private ownership of gold is no longer allowed you have to turn in your gold your gold certificates etc etc to the United States government and the United States government paid everybody I think it was $29 uh to um to do that and or maybe it was $20 I can't remember what what the exact number was I think it was $20 actually um and then um they took those they took that gold and they gave the Federal Reserve gold certificates and those gold certificates were priced at $35”
President Trump called Fed Chair Jerome Powell 'the enemy' and stated Powell was the biggest danger to the economy when Powell raised rates in 2018 against Trump's wishes, suggesting Trump would not accept Fed independence as easily as Reagan.
“Trump versus Powell I mean let's it wasn't that long ago that Trump was had his first uh first Administration right um so I think it was in 200 was it 18 18 when um you know Trump wanted uh lower interest rates... he wanted interest rates low but what does Powell do Powell raises rates... How did how did Trump react to that did Trump say hey that's okay you're independent you do what you want of course not what does Trump do Trump comes out and calls Powell the enemy like literally called him the enemy... Powell is the biggest danger to the economy rather than helping it he's hurting it”
Powell has stated that he believes the president does not have the power to fire the Fed chair, asserting the Fed's independence in recent press conferences (November or December and subsequent)
“Powell was very clear that he did not he believed that the president did not have the power to fire him and the reason is because the fed the government doesn't oversee the federal res the government does oversee the Federal Reserve but they are an independent institution”
Janet Yellen, as Treasury Secretary during Powell's rate hiking campaign (2021-2023), pursued a contradictory policy by issuing trillions in T-bills and spending down the TGA by $1.5 trillion while Powell was trying to slow inflation, creating institutional friction between Treasury and Fed
“let's think about why was fed why was the FED raising rates in the first place they're trying to to Stamp Out inflation they're trying to put a strangle hold on the economy so that it doesn't run too hot...well what does Janet Yellen do during this time do you think she met with with with with pal and said hey I'm gonna do everything I can to help you bring this economy to a halt and get inflation under control no this lady goes out and issues trillions of dollars of t- bills and Spins down like a 1.5 trillion out of the TGA”
The Treasury is responsible for dollar policy, the Fed is responsible for monetary policy, and these are overlapping but distinct domains that can come into conflict when one institution tries to influence the other's core function
“the treasury has always been in charge of dollar policy that has always been the case forever but the FED is in charge of monetary policy so the government's in charge of fiscal policy the treasury is in charge of dollar policy and the FED is in charge of monetary policy”
In 1951, when President Truman demanded lower interest rates to fund the Korean War, Federal Reserve Chair Thomas McCabe and William McChesney Martin refused, leading to the Fed-Treasury Accord which formalized Fed independence from presidential control over interest rate policy
“the first one that I can think of was in 1951 the government was spending a lot of money for the Korean War and you know the government w wanted uh lower interest rates...Truman wanted lower interest rates to fund the the the Korean War and fed share was Thomas McCabe later MZ William mzn Martin they said no because lowering interest rates would raise inflation...they put out their own press release saying that's a lie we did not agree to do it and so this erupted into a very public spat between the fed and the treasury and the White House and so they even had this thing it was called the FED treasury Accord and it basically it ended the fed's obligation to Peg interest rates”
With Nixon and Burns (1970s), Nixon pressured Fed Chair Arthur Burns to lower interest rates, and Burns initially refused but eventually cut rates, meaning Nixon won that battle, making the score 2-1 in favor of the Fed (Fed won against Truman and Johnson, but lost to Nixon)
“let's see what's the next one Richard Nixon and Arthur Burns...Burns telling him um you know you have to lower interest rates but and and there's even tapes there's this on tapes Nixon saying you know we've got to get Burns to lower interest rates um the thing is that burns actually ended up cutting he ended up cutting rates and so Nixon won that battle so now it's two to one right okay so two to one”
The 2023-2024 period involved a significant recent inflation episode that has shaped Powell's institutional memory and policy preferences, making him particularly risk-averse about actions that could reignite inflation
“we are just coming out of one of the other than the 1970s the greatest inflation scare that you know people have in living memory and and I think in the last hundred years other than the 70s they haven't had anything like that”
Powell has stated he believed the president does not have the power to fire him, citing Fed independence, in Fed press conferences held a few months prior to the episode (November, December, or January).
“and if if if if if there was any doubt about that that question came up in one of the FED PR pred conferences just over the last couple months I think it came up in November or December whichever one it was and then again in this last one and Powell was very clear that he did not he believed that the president did not have the power to fire him”
During Trump's first administration, Fed Chair Jerome Powell raised interest rates in 2018 against Trump's stated preference for lower rates; Trump responded by calling Powell 'the enemy' and criticizing him as hurting rather than helping the economy.
“I think it was in 200 was it 18 18 when um you know Trump wanted uh lower interest rates because now we're heading in yeah because it was 2018 2019 because now they're heading into 2020 and of course he wanted to have a good economy for getting reelected um in in in his uh in his in his race against Biden and so you know he he he wanted interest rates low but what does Powell do Powell raises rates”
Janet Yellen, as Treasury Secretary under Biden, issued trillions of dollars in Treasury bills and spent down the TGA by $1.5 trillion while Powell was raising rates to combat inflation, working at cross purposes with Fed policy.
“well what does Janet Yellen do during this time do you think she met with with with with pal and said hey I'm gonna do everything I can to help you bring this economy to a halt and get inflation under control no this lady goes out and issues trillions of dollars of t- bills and Spins down like a 1.5 trillion out of the TGA so on the one hand while Powell is doing everything he can raising rates from zero to 5 perc to get inflation under control yelling's over there like with a with a with a with the blowtorch you know he's trying to throw cold water on the economy trying to slow it down and she's got a blowtorch over there you know just setting everything on fire again by spending 1.5 out of the TGA”
In 1971-1972, the reference point for US gold was raised from $35 per ounce to $42 per ounce, where it remains officially today despite the market price being approximately $2,900 per ounce
“and then later on I think it was in 1971 72 time frame um that 35 reference that $35 reference point was raised to 42 and that's where it currently sits today”
Under current law, if the Treasury revalues gold from $42 per ounce to the current market price of approximately $2,900 per ounce, this would create roughly $750-800 billion in new Federal Reserve Notes that could be credited to the Treasury General Account (TGA)
“it's sitting at $42 if they were to price that at today's uh market value of gold which is 2900 so quite a bit higher than $42 then that would equate to approximately 750 or $ 800 billion dollar um New Found Federal Reserve notes in the treasury general account”
Secretary of the Treasury Bessent has written pieces before becoming Treasury secretary arguing that the US is 'not broke' because the government ignores the asset side of its balance sheet, suggesting Bessent supports using Treasury gold assets to address fiscal constraints
“secretary bessent has written um some pieces you know before he was treasury secretary and Trump has talked over time about the United States is not broke because everybody only focuses on the liability side of their balance sheet and never focus on the asset side of the balance sheet and that the US if they wanted to could use the asset side of their balance sheet to make things uh a much different story”
The Treasury cannot unilaterally revalue gold, deposit the proceeds into its account, and spend the money however it wants; the Fed's cooperation is required because the Treasury outsourced its banking function to the Federal Reserve, which is a quasi-government entity.
“the treasury cannot on its own wake up revalue gold higher and then go spend the money as they want that is absolutely true but the reason there is some confusion or some conversations or even debate on this topic is so there is an element of truth to it the treasury can absolutely revalue gold what they cannot do is then go spend that money all on their own however they want for two reasons number one they need the fed's help the FED is the government's Banker”
If the government pegs the gold price at $20,000 per ounce, it would need to stand willing to buy gold at that price, requiring the Fed or Treasury to borrow or print additional money to support the peg, creating a vicious cycle of monetary expansion.
“so then how do you Peg the price of gold well the you can't just say you can't just wake up and say okay gold is $10,000 Gold's $20,000 if you do say that you have to stand willing to buy it at that price that's what a peg is okay so then what does that mean that means that the fed or the treasury or whoever in the government decides to do it now has to start bidding for gold at $220,000 well where does that money come from to bid gold at $20,000 well they either have to borrow more of it or they have to print more of it so you start to get into this vicious cycle of back and forth of how do you Peg the gold price”
The medium-length answer to whether the Treasury can revalue gold and spend the proceeds is yes under certain circumstances, but only with Federal Reserve cooperation and Congressional appropriation.
“the medium length answer to that question is yes under certain circumstances”
If Powell accepts the gold revaluation and credits the TGA, he might then raise interest rates afterward to offset the inflationary impact, effectively negating the expansionary effects of the policy and putting the Fed back into conflict with the Treasury
“maybe he starts raising interest rates again rather than lowering them and when the treasury says what the hell are you doing he says hey you guys are in charge of dollar policy I'm in charge of FIS or I'm in charge of monetary policy and you guys just increase the monetary base you increase the amount of money that can be spent in the economy that's that I have to take that into account when I am you know figuring out what I'm going to do from a monetary policy perspective and that has the potential to reignite inflation so I'm going to take rates from 4% back to 5 per.”
The Fed has resisted presidential pressure on monetary policy 4 out of 5 historical confrontations (Truman, Johnson, Volcker, and Powell vs presidents; only Nixon successfully overrode Burns), establishing a pattern that suggests the Fed is more likely to resist than comply with executive pressure when inflation-fighting is at stake
“these are two examples I've given you where the FED has done the exact opposite of what the president or what the treasury wanted them to do...so the so the treasury what was the treasury 4- one against the the Fed was four- one against the the executive branch um all of the reason all of the times they stood up to the executive branch”
Federal Reserve independence is 'perhaps the greatest myth perpetuated by Business Schools today,' but there is some truth to it insofar as the Fed can resist executive pressure in the short term.
“I think fed Independence is perhaps the greatest myth that is perpetuated by Business Schools today but there is some truth to it as I just pointed out and so while ultimately the government could change the rules change the laws put incredible pressure get him out of there the point is is Powell doesn't have to agree right away he probably will I mean it would be quite a thing to not agree with and not accept the the gold certificates but it's not impossible that they wouldn't okay”
If gold is revalued to $2,900 or higher and then declines to a lower market price (e.g., from $3,000 to $2,400), the Fed balance sheet could become underwater on gold certificates, similar to losses on bond holdings.
“let's say that they do this let's say that Trump decides he wants to revalue gold at 3,000 they get the extra 800 billion the FED says yeah it's great no we don't worry about inflation anymore the Democrats they say yeah you know it's fine we love Trump let's just do it okay we do that so now what happens if gold goes from 3,000 to 2400 I know people don't like it the fact that they've bought a bunch of bombs bonds and then the B price of the bonds fell they've said that they've said that that means that the fed's balance sheet is upside down well what if the same thing happens with gold”
Trump's administration is part of a 'Grand Unified Strategy' that unifies monetary policy, fiscal policy, trade policy, and geopolitical policy under a single 'America First' objective, breaking from the prior siloed approach where these policies sometimes worked at cross purposes.
“there's really a move away from siloed American strategies whether it be monetary strategy or fiscal policy or trade policy or geopolitical policy see for a long time each of these different functions had their own strategies and sometimes they worked in concert and sometimes they didn't but Trump has kind of come in and said you know what that's not going to happen anymore”
The recent high inflation episode (2021-2023) is the largest inflation scare in living memory other than the 1970s, and the Fed would likely resist gold revaluation if it feared that injecting $800 billion into the TGA could reignite inflation rather than allowing it to trend down as expected.
“we are just coming out of one of the other than the 1970s the greatest inflation scare that you know people have in living memory and and I think in the last hundred years other than the 70s they haven't had anything like that”
Allowing gold price to float after revaluation means the TGA credits fluctuate with market price, destabilizing fiscal planning and monetary policy because the base money supply becomes tethered to commodity prices rather than policy decisions.
“what if the same thing happens with gold or let's take the other way they do this and they say it's $3,000 that's probably going to Spur a lot of people to you know get interested in Gold maybe people go buy gold maybe gold goes to 6,000 maybe it goes to 10,000 okay so then it goes to 10,000 right and they top up the TGA even more now you've really got a lot of money in the TGA what do you think you know Pal's going to do under those circumstances when when when Gold's at 10,000 or again what if it does go to 10,000 but then for whatever reason it goes back to 7,000 now they're underwater again right and so the FED balance sheet all of a sudden is jumping all over the place”
The US would not return gold owed to other countries; if another government requested repatriation of gold held at the Fed, the response would invoke the principle 'possession is nine-tenths of the law' or use possessory claims as leverage
“the FED is not going to sell their gold the FED is not going to get rid of their gold and if they owe if the United States owes gold to some other country that other country is not going to get it that's just not going to happen um or it's listen nothing is impossible but it's very unlikely uh and if and if another government says Hey I want my gold back my guess is that the response from Trump would be the same what's the Greek saying is it molan a or something like that come and get it I mean possession is nine10 of the law”
At some point in the future, the Fed might be folded into the Treasury to eliminate the institutional friction between the two, creating a unified monetary-fiscal authority under Treasury control
“it wouldn't shock me at all for this very reason that we're talking about now that at some point in the future that's what happens the FED gets rolled up into the treasury so they don't have these hassles they don't have the possibility of this happening we get back into this unified Grand Theory where everything is working towards the same goal”
Government employees have shown a pattern of not following Trump administration directives because they believe he is a threat to national security or violates the law, and this pattern could extend to employees at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York refusing to execute gold revaluation.
“now this isn't stuff I'm making up there's there's been different you know examples of this listed where you know employees you know were not doing what they they wanted to do or what they were supposed to do and because they thought Trump was a threat to National Security or you know breaking the law or whatever it was so am I really really way out on a limb to think that something as important as fiscal policy and monetary policy that there might be an employee or a set of employees who wouldn't necessarily do exactly what the president wants to do especially if their boss in Washington DC is saying don't do it”
The U.S. will not return gold held at the Fed to other countries that demand it, even if owed; possession is nine-tenths of the law, and Trump would likely refuse requests with defiance.
“the FED is not going to sell their gold the FED is not going to get rid of their gold and if they owe if the United States owes gold to some other country that other country is not going to get it that's just not going to happen um or it's listen nothing is impossible but it's very unlikely uh and if and if another government says Hey I want my gold back my guess is that the response from Trump would be the same what's the Greek saying is it molan a or something like that come and get it I mean possession is nine10 of the law right”
Fed independence is a myth perpetuated by business schools; ultimately the government could change the rules, rewrite laws, apply pressure, and remove the Fed chair, but this would require explicit action rather than being automatic
“at the end of the day the FED is not independent I think fed Independence is perhaps the greatest myth that is perpetuated by Business Schools today but there is some truth to it as I just pointed out and so while ultimately the government could change the rules change the laws put incredible pressure get him out of there”
Gold revaluation would create derivative exposure problems for market participants with gold ETF positions, COMEX shorts, naked shorts, and over-the-counter derivative contracts, and resolving these would require either stopping everyone out for cash or accepting enormous disruption to market confidence
“we haven't even got into what happens to the market participants who own gold ETFs who own gold on the comx who will have commercial shorts on the comx who have naked shorts on the comx who have derivative exposures um through various over-the-counter uh instruments all over the world um you know you start adding the how do you solve all that stuff does everybody get stopped out for cash on a Friday night before the revaluation probably but then what does that do for Market confidence when it reopens the next week are people going to trust the other comx contracts are they going to trust the other derivatives contracts”
It would not be surprising if the Federal Reserve were eventually rolled up into the Treasury to eliminate institutional friction and create unified policy coordination, removing the possibility of Fed-Treasury conflict.
“ultimately Jerome can be replaced they get the rules Rewritten and it would not Shock me at all for this very reason that we're talking about now that at some point in the future that's what happens the FED gets rolled up into the treasury so they don't have these hassles they don't have the possibility of this happening we get back into this unified Grand Theory where everything is working towards the same goal”
If the Treasury revalues gold to a higher price, Democrats and opposition media would characterize this as a constitutional crisis, using inflammatory language ('makes doge look like a picnic'), preventing Congressional cooperation on spending the proceeds
“what do you think is going to happen in Congress when they wake up and they find out that Trump has just revalued gold to $3,000 or $2,900 do you think the Democrats and the Deep State and the Main Street Media is gonna say wow that's a really smart idea...they are gonna say this is the biggest constitutional crisis we have ever had in our life this makes doge look like a picnic you know on a Sunday afternoon there will be absolute outrage”
The Trump administration is no longer playing by the rules-based international order; it is asserting US hegemonic power and stating 'we're the biggest boy on the block and we're gonna act like it'
“this is not the United States seeding hegemony this is the United States saying we're the biggest boy on the Block and we're g to act like it now I don't necessarily like this I wouldn't necessarily prescribe this uh remedy but this is what we're getting and this is the world we're living in”
If the Treasury revalued gold to $2,900 and deposited $800 billion into the TGA without Congressional appropriation, Democrats and opposition media would likely frame it as a constitutional crisis worse than DOGE, creating intense political opposition.
“what do you think is going to happen in Congress when they wake up and they find out that Trump has just revalued gold to $3,000 or $2,900 do you think the Democrats and the Deep State and the Main Street Media is gonna say wow that's a really smart idea I'm you know what you finally won me over I'm on board let's just do that hell no they're not going to do that they are gonna say this is the biggest constitutional crisis we have ever had in our life this makes doge look like a picnic you know on a Sunday afternoon there will be absolute outrage on the other side”
Trump is no longer playing by the rules-based international order and acts as if the US, as the strongest power, can unilaterally enforce its preferences; this represents a shift away from US hegemony based on consent toward hegemony based on power.
“and this kind of goes back to the Grand unified theory Trump is no longer really playing by the rules-based order I've written about this a lot on my substack and I would encourage people to go to the substack who are interested in this topic I will also write up this this conversation that I'm giving today I will write this up on a substack to see all the different angles and the important factors um listen I think this is an incredibly important incredibly interesting topic um but we are kind of moving into a period of time where the rules-based order is changing this is not the United States seeding hegemony this is the United States saying we're the biggest boy on the Block and we're g to act like it”
Despite Trump's Grand Macro Strategy goal of policy unification, there are still rules in place that Trump has not yet changed that keep the Treasury-Fed relationship compartmentalized, making gold revaluation legally and politically challenging even for Trump
“the treasury and the monetary and the fiscal where it has been AC cross purposes in the past and it could still be AC cross purposes now and this is part of the reason why it's not so easy necessarily for the tra treasury to do this they want it to be streamlined into one policy but there are still rules that are put in place that Trump has not yet changed that keep this in a situation where it could be challenging”
Trump's strategy involves the unification of monetary policy, fiscal policy, trade policy, military policy, and geopolitical policy into a single 'Grand Macro Strategy' where all functions are subordinated to 'America First' rather than operating independently as they have historically
“there's really a move away from siloed American strategies whether it be monetary strategy or fiscal policy or trade policy or geopolitical policy see for a long time each of these different functions had their own strategies and sometimes they worked in concert and sometimes they didn't but Trump has kind of come in and said you know what that's not going to happen anymore...it's essentially the unification of monetary policy fiscal policy trade policy military policy geopolitical policy you are no longer going to have any one of these pieces unless it is putting America first”
The speaker claims that Treasury Secretary Bessent and Trump have discussed the idea that the U.S. is not broke because policymakers overlook the asset side of the balance sheet, which includes substantial gold holdings.
“secretary bessent has written um some pieces you know before he was treasury secretary and Trump has talked over time about the United States is not broke because everybody only focuses on the liability side of their balance sheet and never focus on the asset side of the balance sheet and that the US if they wanted to could use the asset side of their balance sheet to make things uh a much different story”
Gold may be remonetized in some form in the future, but the process will not be smooth and will involve significant disruption across multiple constituencies.
“it wouldn't shock me at all if at some point down the road gold were to get remonetized in some form uh but I wouldn't expect there to just be peace love and Kumbaya when it happens and there's a lot of different factors to think about when it does”
In the 1970s, the gold price reference was raised from $35 to $42 per ounce, where it currently remains on the Fed's balance sheet.
“and then later on I think it was in 1971 72 time frame um that 35 reference that $35 reference point was raised to 42 and that's where it currently sits today”
Luke Groman posted the correct mechanics via which gold revaluation can work, and Yannis Kotsambanis posted a report explaining how the TGA can be refilled through this mechanism
“Luke groman posted the mechanics via which this can work and those mechanics that he posted are absolutely correct...Yan nious posted a a a report that explained how this can work and I I think he I'd have no problem with that either...they each referenced a piece by Mir mcon um who who had referenced this maybe in a in an investor letter last year”
It's possible that Trump and the Fed/Treasury could announce gold revaluation on a Monday morning press conference, effective immediately, though the speaker admits this is highly unlikely and not the most probable scenario.
“and listen I'm the first to admit that we could this is highly unlikely but it's very possible that we could come walking in the Market's closed on tues on Monday maybe we come in Tuesday morning 8 AM and the you know the the Federal Reserve and the treasury and the president have called a press conference and they say we have revalued gold on our balance sheet to to $2,900 an ounce and as a result there is you know $800 billion doll in the treasury general account you know update your your spreadsheets that's possible I you can't rule that out”
The speaker would not necessarily prescribe or like the Trump approach of abandoning the rules-based order and asserting nationalist power, but accepts it as the current reality.
“I don't necessarily like this I wouldn't necessarily prescribe this uh remedy but this is what we're getting and this is the world we're living in and I think we need to be ready for it”
Mir Macon previously referenced the mechanics of Treasury gold revaluation in an investor letter, establishing that this is not a new concept.
“they each referenced a piece by Mir mcon um who who had referenced this maybe in a in an investor letter last year and again I have no issue W with that either”
The conversation about Treasury gold revaluation originated on Twitter and involved discussions of Modern Monetary Theory (MMT), with participants including Keith Wiener and Luke Groman, who posted the mechanics of how gold revaluation could work.
“the reason this came up now is uh you know as I mentioned earlier on Twitter it started off of you know a conversation of whether the United States even has all the gold that they say they do and there it kind of meandered a little bit it ended up in you know a discussion of mmt and you know Keith weiner was involved and Luke Roman was in there and they were talking about well does the US currently do Mt do they not do mmt and then at one point I can't remember exactly how it went but something it went uh well you know the government can just print the money and then well you know the government might decide not to print the money the FED might not play ball and then another comment came back well if the FED doesn't play ball then the treasury can just use gold to kind of get around the fed and do this without their help and so that's what kind of led to this discussion and and I should say uh Luke groman posted the mechanics via which this can work and those mechanics that he posted are absolutely correct”
Luke Groman and Yan Nious have both published accurate mechanics showing how Treasury gold revaluation could work in practice, and Mir Mkonin may have referenced this mechanism in an investor letter.
“and and I should say uh Luke groman posted the mechanics via which this can work and those mechanics that he posted are absolutely correct and so I I have no problem with the mechanics that were posted you know a couple days later Yan nious posted a a a report that explained how this can work and I I think he I'd have no problem with that either and I think they each referenced a piece by Mir mcon um who who had referenced this maybe in a in an investor letter last year and again I have no issue W with that either there is a method via which this can happen”
The speaker will write up the gold revaluation topic on substack (Santiago Capital Substack) to elaborate on all the different angles and important factors in more detail.
“I will also write this up on a substack to see all the different angles and the important factors... Santiago capital. substack.com”