
China Stocks Already Plunging | EU-China Trade War | Chinese Economy
What this covers
This is a single-host China Update episode in which Tony works through three items in turn: China's retaliation against the EU, Premier Li Qiang's economic symposium, and the post-holiday swings in Chinese stocks. The trade segment begins with Beijing's anti-dumping and anti-subsidy investigations into EU pork, dairy and related products, which most commentators read as payback for the EU's electric vehicle tariffs. Importers of EU branded goods now face security deposits of roughly 34.8% to 39% of import value under China's anti-dumping penalties. Brussels, through the European Commission, is taking the case to the WTO and calls the measures unfounded. France accuses Xi Jinping of breaking a promise made to Macron, and Sophia Prima says she will raise it at the G20. Tony also covers the lobby group Spirits Europe's denial of dumping.
The segment turns on whether this is a real trade war. Beijing is studying higher tariffs on large-displacement fuel vehicles, which would hit Germany hardest even though it voted against the EU tariffs, and Oliver Bloom of Volkswagen warns of the risk. EU officials, however, describe China's response as calibrated. Tony also offers a counterpoint to Beijing's framing of a civilizational struggle: many non-Western developing countries have put up barriers against similarly subsidized Chinese sectors.
The domestic half covers Li's call for faster rollout of incremental policies and his pressure on local governments over arbitrary fines, inspections and detentions of entrepreneurs. Joel Tong had warned of such "ransom" detentions, and Tony notes that a censored article on the practice shows how sensitive it is. Behind it lies strained local finances: sharp falls in land sales shrink extra-budgetary revenue, and analysts expect pressure to lift the fiscal budget ratio above 3%. The closing section sets a sharp market reversal, with the CSI 300 down 6% in two days, against holiday data on property, tourism and consumption. Analysts from Bank of China International disagree on whether monetary easing can lift the real economy without fiscal stimulus, and warn that added liquidity could inflate a bubble.
Tony argues that China's retaliatory tariffs against EU goods represent an escalating trade conflict driven by Beijing's existential view of competition for global dominance, while underlying real economic weakness (property sales decline, consumption softness) suggests monetary stimulus may inflate asset prices without restoring genuine growth.
- Beijing has reframed EU tariffs on Chinese EVs as a civilizational struggle for global dominance rather than a sectoral trade dispute
- Real economy indicators (property, consumption, tourism) show mixed signals with policy stimulus having limited transmission to household behavior
- Monetary easing risk creating stock market bubbles disconnected from economic fundamentals without complementary fiscal stimulus
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
A counterargument to Beijing's civilizational struggle framing is that dozens of non-Western developing countries have also erected trade barriers against sectors similarly subsidized by China, suggesting protectionism is not unique to Western dominance-preservation
“one obvious push back to this argument is that dozens of non-western developing countries have also erected trade barriers against sectors similarly subsidized by Beijing”
Shual Chief Economist at Bank of China International argued that stronger-than-expected monetary easing will significantly boost market sentiment, but whether it can stabilize real economic growth depends on fiscal easing policies, and that because liquidity from the central bank's structural policy tools (such as swap programs) could raise the domestic stock market somewhat independently of the real economy, regulators must do more to prevent this increased liquidity from creating a bubble
“sual Chief Economist at Bank of China international quote the stronger than expected monetary easing will significantly boost Market sentiment but whether it can help stabilize real economic growth remains to be seen as accomplishing that goal will depend on the fiscal easing policies that come out because of the liquidity provided by the central bank's new structural policy tool tools such as the swap program the domestic stock market could rise somewhat independently of the real economy Regulators must do more to prevent this increased liquidity from creating a bubble end quote”
The fact that Beijing discussed arbitrary detention and fines against business people at the premier-level State Council study session suggests this was seen by Beijing as a significant problem threatening economic stability
“The fact that this has been discussed in this meeting at the highest s and included in the readout suggests that this was seen by Beijing as a significant problem”
Jing Chief macro analyst at Bank of China international observed that one should not expect too much from follow-up fiscal policy this year, and that the key to fiscal policy this year lies in the easing of fiscal constraints rather than an increase in stimulus, with local government debt risk still constraining fiscal expansion to a certain extent
“Jing Chief macro Analyst at Bank of China international China in a note this week observed quote we should not expect too much from follow-up fiscal policy this year the key to fiscal policy this year lies in the easing of fiscal constraints rather than an increase in stimulus we believe that local government debt risk is still a con restraint on fiscal expansion to a certain extent end quote”
Beijing announced that increasing import tariffs on large displacement fuel vehicles are being studied, which would especially hurt Germany, which voted against the recent EU tariffs
“meanwhile the same day Beijing also announced that increasing import tariffs on large displacement fuel vehicles were being studied this would especially hurt Germany which actually voted against the recent EU tariffs”
EU officials speaking to UK-based Financial Times stated that the Chinese response has been calibrated and that they believe Beijing does not want to initiate a tit-for-tat trade war that would hurt its exporters and cost jobs, with officials noting that even with these tariffs Chinese EVs will still be sold in Europe, unlike the US which effectively closed its market
“EU officials speaking to UK based the financial times said quote the Chinese response has been calibrated adding that they believed Beijing did not want to initiate a tit fortat trade war that would hurt its exporters and cost jobs an official reportedly told the outlet quote even with these tariffs Chinese EVS will still be sold in Europe it's not like the US which effectively closed its market end quote”
Tourism spending during the National Day holiday was characterized by travelers seeking value, with stimulus policies announced on September 24th having limited impact on tourist consumption, despite bookings for domestic flights and hotels on the first day of the 7-day holiday increasing by 177% and 40% respectively, while prices for corresponding services fell by 23% and 4.5%
“consumption tourism spending during this holiday was characterized by Travelers looking for more bang for their buck stimulus policies announced on the 24th of September had a limited impact on tourists consumption although bookings for domestic flights and hotels on the first day of the 7-Day holiday increased by 177% and 40% respectively prices for corresponding Services fell by 23% and 4.5%”
Volkswagen AG chief executive officer Oliver Bloom stated that any possible Chinese tariffs would be particularly risky for the German automotive industry and that the company would face significant disadvantages in the Chinese market
“Volkswagen AG chief executive officer Oliver Bloom has said that any possible Chinese tariffs would be particularly risky for the German automotive industry and that the company would face significant disadvantages in the Chinese market”
France accused Xi Jinping of breaking a promise made to French president Emmanuel Macron of not imposing temporary duties during Xi's visit to Paris in May, with France's Junior trade Minister Sophia Prima expressing disapproval and stating she would raise these concerns at the G20 Summit in Brazil
“the same day Paris accused Xi Jinping of breaking a promise he had made to French president Emanuel macron of not imposing temporary duties during a visit to Paris last May France's Junior trade Minister Sophia Prima expressed quote I find these measures incomprehensible there is no justification for them we are very disappointed by this announcement which goes against the comitment made by President XI during his visit to France I will soon be attending the G20 Summit in Brazilia where I will be taking the opportunity to hold a dialogue with my Chinese counterparts I'm ready to go to China to put forward our positions end quote”
As of Friday, importers of branded goods originating in the EU will have to put down security deposits mostly ranging from 34.8% to 39% of the import value as part of China's anti-dumping penalties against EU products
“importers of brand originating in the EU will have to put down security deposits mostly ranging from 34.8% to 39% of the import value end quote as part of anti-dumping penalties”
An article originally titled 'Urgently Prohibit and Stop Local Governments from Supplementing Fiscal Revenue by Detaining Private Entrepreneurs and Releasing Them for Money' was quickly censored after publication, indicating the sensitivity of the topic within China's political system
“the original article shedding light on this issue was called urgently prohibit and stop local governments from supplementing fiscal Revenue by detaining private entrepreneurs and releasing them for money and was quickly censored after publication”
According to estimates by Jung Chief macro researcher at Jong Tha Securities, accounting for the sharp fall in land sales (traditionally local government's biggest source of extra-budgetary revenue), actual revenue this year could be 3.4 trillion yuan, about 0.5 trillion USD less than what was budgeted
“according to estimates by Jung Chief macro researcher at Jong Tha Securities taking into account the sharp Fallen land sales traditionally local government's biggest source of extra budgetary Revenue actual Revenue this year could be 3.4 trillion yen about half a trillion US dollar less than what was budgeted”
Analysts have projected that the central government would need to lift this year's fiscal budget ratio above the current 3% proportion to gross domestic product due to sluggish land sales and declining tax revenue widening the deficit
“analysts have projected the central government would need to lift this year's fiscal budget ratio above the current 3% proportion to gross domestic product as sluggish land sales and declining tax revenue have widened the deficit”
Chinese financial media outlet Yicai published an article discussing whether enthusiasm in the stock market over the holiday was reflected in household consumption and investment demand as seen in three dimensions: property sales, tourism, and consumption growth
“Chinese Financial media Outlet tyin published an article discussing whether enthusiasm in the stock market over the holiday was reflected in household consumption and investment demand as seen in three dimensions property sales tourism and consumption growth”
Premier Li Qiang held a symposium with economic experts and entrepreneurs and a State Council study session on the economy, during which he told the group that China should promptly implement packages of incremental policies to stabilize the economy, accelerate implementation of already-introduced policies for early results, and develop specific plans for policies under study, with tracking and evaluation of policy transmission efforts
“yesterday Tuesday afternoon PLC Premier leang chaed a symposium with economic experts and entrepreneurs and held a state Council study session on the economy the Symposium was to quote here opinions and suggestions on the current economic situation and future economic work end quote Lee told the group that quote we should promptly implement the package of incremental policies to stabilize the economy accelerate the implementation of policies already introduced to ensure early landing and early results and quickly develop specific plans for policies under study we should track and evaluate the transmission efforts of policies optimizing and strengthening them where necessary”
A few weeks prior, senior official Joel Tong warned against the arbitrary detention of business people and entrepreneurs in some parts of China by local governments under acute fiscal strain essentially for ransom, cautioning that if the issue were allowed to spread it could devastate the national economy
“now regular viewers will remember a few weeks ago we covered a senior official Joel Tong warning against the arbitrary Detention of business people and entrepreneurs in some parts of the country by local governments under acute fiscal strain essentially for ransom the official warned that if the issue was allowed to spread it could devastate the national economy”
Officials at the National Development and Reform Commission meeting warned local governments against illegally imposing fines, carrying out random inspections, or seizing assets, and stressed the need to create a positive environment for the private sector
“officials at Tuesday's National development and Reform Commission meeting warned local governments against quote illegally imposing fines carrying out random inspections or seizing assets end quote and stressing the need to create a quote positive environment for the private sector end quote”
Most commentators agree that China's anti-dumping investigations and tariffs are clear retaliation for EU tariffs on Chinese electric vehicles, an industry for which there is clear evidence of strong State subsidies
“indeed most commentators agree that this is clear retaliation for EU tariffs on Chinese EVS an industry for which there is clear evidence of strong State subsidies”
Premier Li stated that the key to stabilizing the economy is to stabilize enterprises and that the government must effectively assist enterprises in alleviating difficulties, guide localities to make good use of preferential policies for enterprises, and resolutely tackle issues such as arbitrary fines, inspections, and seizures
“Lee told the group that... the key to stabilizing the economy is to stabilize Enterprises we must effectively assist Enterprises and alleviating difficulties guide localities to make good use of various preferential policies for Enterprises resolutely tackle issues such as arbitrary fines inspections and seizures end quote”
On market reopening after the National Day holiday, the rally was more cooled as investors were disappointed in the lack of details from Beijing on fiscal stimulus, with the CSI 300 down 6% and the Hong Kong Hung index down over 10% over the last two trading days
“the week before on the market reopening yesterday the rally was more cooled as investors were were disappointed in the lack of details from Beijing on fiscal stimulus in trading today as of filming which is about midday chinat time the market the CSI 300 is down 6% the Hong Kong hung index is also down over 10% over the last two trading days”
China's Ministry of Commerce announced anti-dumping and anti-subsidy investigations on pork, pork byproducts, dairy products and other items imported from the European Union, with China claiming these products are dumped on the Chinese market and sold cheaper than cost price to undercut local competition
“the ministry of Commerce announcing that the quote anti-dumping and anti-subsidy investigations launched on certain pork and pork byproducts dairy products and other items imported from the European Union end quote is underway China claims the costly beverages are dumped on the Chinese Market sold cheaper than the cost price to undercut local competition”
Brussels immediately announced it would bring a case against China's tariffs at the World Trade Organization, with the European Commission expressing belief that the measures are unfounded and that the EU is determined to defend its industry against the abuse of trade defense instruments
“Brussels immediately hit back against the measures announcing that it would bring a case against the tariffs at the World Trade Organization with the European Commission in the statement expressing quote we believe that these measures are unfounded and we are determined to defend EU industry against the abuse of trade defense instruments end quote”
This year's National Day holiday followed the announcement of policy measures aimed at stabilizing growth, which significantly boosted the Hsun-Tech index, Hsun-China Enterprises index last week, and the CSI 300 in mainland China the week before
“this year's National Day holiday followed the announcement of a slew of policies aimed at stabilizing growth uh which significantly boosted the hsung tech index and the hsung China Enterprises index last week as well as the CSI 300 in the mainland the week before”
Inbound travel during the National Day holiday increased year-on-year, with popular inbound destinations including Guangzhou, Sanya, and Shanghai, attributed to factors such as expansion of China's visa-free policies
“inbound travel During the period increased here on year according to online Travel Agency tar.com Inc that could be attributed to factors such as the expansion of China's Visa free policies popular inbound destinations included Guang Joo Shan and Jang”
Lobby group Spirits Europe disputes China's dumping claims, stating it has been transparent with Beijing and that evidence provided clearly demonstrates the absence of dumping and even the potential for it
“Lobby group Spirits Europe says it has been transparent with Beijing and its quote evidence provided clearly demonstrates the absence of dumping end quote or even the potential for it”
Sales of secondhand properties shot up by 164.5% (decline in September), with sales in first four tier cities soaring by 173.0% from September, while those in second and third tier cities shifted from decline to increase
“sales of secondhand properties shot up by 164.512 per decline in September sales in the first four tier cities soared by 173.04 from the hole of September while those in second and third tier cities saw sales shift from decline to increase”
Sales of newly built properties in 60 major Chinese cities rose by 1.1% year-on-year from October 1-5, compared with a year-on-year decline of 28.4% in the selected cities in September, but sales in smaller cities among the 60 contracted even further in the period compared with the month before
“sales of newly built properties in 60 major cities Rose by 1.1% year on Year from October 1st through October 5th according to financial data provider wind information code limited that's compared with a year-on-year decline of 28.4% in the selected cities in September however sales in smaller cities among the 60 contracted even further in the period compared with the month before”
For outbound travel, there was a significant increase in visits by mainland Chinese tourists to Hong Kong, Macau, and Taiwan, with most outbound tourists during the holiday choosing short-distance trips to cities within 5-hour flight distance such as Hong Kong, Bangkok, Seoul, and Osaka
“in terms of outbound travel there was a significant increase in visits by May Mainland tourists to Hong Kong Macau and Taiwan according to online travel operator trip.com group limited most outbound tourists during the holiday chose short distance trips data from tar.com indicate that the top cities for outbound travel were all within a 5-hour flight distance such as Hong Kong Bangkok soul and Osaka”
Travel volume hit a record high over the week-long National Day holiday, with the total number of trips taken via rail, road, waterway, and aviation reaching about 1.46 billion from October 1-5, with the average number of trips each day increasing by 24% compared to the same 5-day period in 2019, surpassing the increase recorded during the mid-autumn Festival in September
“travel volume hit a record high over the week long holiday data from the Ministry of Transport showed that the total number of trips taken via Railway Road Waterway and Aviation reached about 1.46 billion from October 1st through October 5th the average number of trips taken each day increased by 24% compared to to the same 5-day period in 2019 surpassing the increase recorded during this year's mid-autumn Festival holiday in September”
Big ticket items like cars showed signs of recovery during the National Day holiday, possibly reflecting improvements in consumer sentiment and the effect of policies such as the nationwide vehicle trade-in program
“Big Ticket items like cars showed signs of recovery possibly reflecting improvements to Consumer sentiment and the effect of policies such as the Nationwide vehicle trade in proog”
Jen Jinbo, deputy director of the China EU relations Research Center at Fan University and deputy Secretary General of the Shanghai Europe studies Association, argues that the ultimate goal of protectionist measures against China is to maintain the EU's product technology and economic advantages, maintain its high position in the global value chain, and preserve the liberal international order based on rules and the West's dominant position—framing the China-EU EV dispute as China's struggle with the West for dominance this century
“Jen jinbo deputy director of the China EU relations Research Center at Fan University and the deputy Secretary General of the Shanghai Europe studies Association for example in a recent article argued quote the ultimate goal of protectionist measures against China is to maintain the eu's product technology and economic advantages maintain its high position in the global value chain and maintain its dominant position in the global economic system thereby maintaining the liberal International order based on rules and the core position of the West and the world this is the essence behind the China EU electric vehicle dispute”
A European counterargument could be that China has used state policies and protectionist measures to climb the value-added chain, so Europe has the right to use similar state and protectionist measures to maintain its position in the value chain
“another push back from a European perspective could also be you China have used State policies and protectionist measures to climb the value added chain we have the right to use State and protectionist measures to maintain our position in the value chain”
Since the rally began, the CSI 300 still remains up about 30% despite the recent decline, and the next few days will be critical to determine whether there is still life in the rally or whether it will continue to fizzle out, potentially costing investors trillions of yuan
“nevertheless since the rally began the CSI 300 Still Remains up about 30% the next few days will be critical to see whether there is still some life in this Rally or whether it will continue to F out costing investors potentially trillions of Yen”