
What should we do when a person attacks us physically?
What this covers
This is a twelve-minute answer Thich Nhat Hanh gave to a written question during the 21-Day Retreat at Plum Village on June 20, 2004. The question asks what to do when someone attacks you physically, and he answers in two registers. One is personal protection. The other is how a country should defend itself. He says force is permitted for both, but only after many nonviolent means have been used. Killing, in his words, is the last resort.
Most of the talk is a run of stories from the Buddha's life. The Buddha was trained in martial arts as a young man, yet after his enlightenment he faced attacks from figures such as Angulimala and Devadatta and relied on intelligence and compassion instead. The centerpiece is the wild elephant sent against him. Ananda was ready to die by stepping between them. The Buddha, who had spent months in a forest after a split in the Sangha and had learned to speak with elephants, made a call like the Elephant Queen's. The animal stopped and knelt, and he touched it with compassion. The detour into that forest also gives Thich Nhat Hanh room to say that a teacher may legitimately be sad when students cannot live peacefully together.
The talk then moves to practice and politics. For individuals he lists qigong, mindful eating, walking and sleeping, mindfulness, concentration and compassion, all meant to protect before any attack occurs and to make one someone nobody wants to attack. For nations he argues that a united country under wise leaders can make friends and neutralize enemies, so its soldiers can repair roads and build bridges. He names Jacques Chirac, Tony Blair and George W. Bush as leaders who should learn deep listening and nonviolent communication. He locates the danger in fear and misunderstanding, which push people straight to thoughts of guns and armies.
Physical self-defense and national defense are justified, but violence should be a last resort; cultivating compassion, mindfulness, and dialogue provides more effective protection and conflict prevention than military force.
- The Buddha was trained in martial arts but primarily used intelligence and compassion to neutralize attackers rather than violence
- Countries led by wise people with strong internal unity can neutralize enemies through friendship-building and dialogue, reducing reliance on military force
- Fear and misunderstanding drive premature resort to violence; deep dialogue and loving-kindness practice prevent conflict before it requires military response
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
When a wild elephant was released to attack the Buddha, the Buddha made an elephant call exactly like the voice of the Elephant Queen, causing the elephant to stop; the Buddha then advanced with his hand and the elephant knelt down, and the Buddha touched the elephant with compassion.
“Later on, when they released a wild animal to attack him, Ananda, his attendant, was so scared. Ananda was ready to die to protect the Buddha... Because the elephant was coming up, charging. And suddenly, the Buddha let forth an elephant call, exactly like the voice of the Elephant Queen. That kind of reaction was quite natural.”
The Buddha was attacked multiple times after his enlightenment by Angulimala, Devadatta, and others, and used various non-violent methods to protect himself from being destroyed by these attacks.
“The Buddha himself was attacked physically. Several times. After enlightenment, you know. Angulimala tried to kill him. And, Devadatta and others tried to kill him.”
Fear is dangerous and misunderstanding is dangerous because misunderstanding brings fear and anger, leading immediately to thinking of guns and armies as the only solution to conflict.
“You who practise, you should try to convey to your political leaders that fear is dangerous And misunderstanding is dangerous because misunderstanding brings fear and anger, and we immediately think of the gun and the army as the only solution.”
Mindfulness, concentration, and compassion can protect you; the Buddha primarily used his intelligence and compassion to neutralize attackers rather than resorting to his martial arts skills.
“Because mindfulness, concentration and compassion can protect you. Every time the Buddha was attacked physically, he used his mindfulness, intelligence, compassion, to support the person who is about to attack him. And he did not have to use his martial art.”
When a country is united and led by wise people, the country has many ways of making friends and neutralizing enemies, and does not have to use its army extensively; soldiers can spend time repairing roads and building bridges instead.
“When the country is united, when the country is led by wise people, the country has many ways of making friends, and neutralizing enemies. And that country doesn't have to use her army a lot. Maybe we need to have an army, but the soldiers may spend their time repairing roads, building bridges.”
The answer to whether a person or country can use force to protect itself is yes, but this is subject to the extensive prior use of nonviolent methods.
“The answer is "yes, you can neutralize someone who wants to attack you." But, don't think that the army, the gun, is the only way to do so.”
There are many ways to protect yourself and your country, and killing is only the last resort; one must use many nonviolent ways before resorting to violence.
“There are many ways to protect yourself. And killing is only the last resort. You have to protect yourself. You have to protect your country. But there are many, many nonviolent ways that you have to use before you think of the last ... means, which is violence.”
There are many ways to protect oneself from being attacked physically or mentally without waiting until attack occurs; one can learn to live in a way that nobody wants to attack you by generating energy of brotherhood and compassion.
“There are many ways of protecting ourselves from attack. And that is done by our way of living our daily life. You as a person, you as a country, you learn to live in such a way that nobody wants to attack you. If you know how to generate the energy of brotherhood, of compassion, always ready to help the people around you, you'll be protected by the energy of compassion, of understanding.”
Non-violent protection methods include practicing qigong, eating, walking, and sleeping in ways that preserve health and resistance, as well as cultivating mindfulness, concentration, and compassion.
“We can learn like him -- we practise qigong and other non-violent ways of protecting ourselves. We eat and walk and sleep in a way that we preserve our health and resistance. And we cultivate mindfulness and concentration and compassion.”
If political leaders practice deep dialogue, deep listening, and loving-kindness, and take care of and help other nations and countries and people, then even if they have a powerful army, they will never use it.
“But if they practise deep dialogue, deep listening, loving kindness, try to take care and help other nations and countries and people. Then even if we have a powerful army, we will never use it.”
The Buddha, when young, was highly skilled in martial arts and knew he could respond to any physical attack with his martial skills.
“The Buddha, when he was a young man, he was very versed in martial arts. He knew that with his skill, he can always respond to a physical attack.”
Political leaders like President Chirac, Prime Minister Tony Blair, and President Bush should learn from practitioners of deep listening, loving speech, nonviolent communication, and mindfulness practices.
“And people like President Chirac, Prime Minister Tony Blair, President Bush, should learn from you who know the practice of deep listening and loving speech, and nonviolent communication and so on.”
Ananda, the Buddha's attendant, was willing to die to protect the Buddha and wanted to stand between the charging elephant and the Buddha.
“Ananda, his attendant, was so scared. Ananda was ready to die to protect the Buddha. Ananda wanted to stand between the elephant and the Buddha. Because the elephant was coming up, charging.”
The Buddha once spent several months in a forest after a split in the Sangha, during which time he made friends with many animals, including an elephant and her baby elephants, and learned to speak the language of elephants.
“So, he was sad. You know, a teacher has the right to be sad, when his students do not live peacefully with each other. So the Buddha withdrew to a jungle, to a forest, and he spent a few months in that place. And he made friends with many animals, including one elephant, and the baby elephants.”
A teacher has the right to be sad when their students do not live peacefully with each other, as illustrated by the Buddha's response to a split in the Sangha.
“You know, a teacher has the right to be sad, when his students do not live peacefully with each other.”