YouTube10m· Feb 2025· cataloged

Former US ambassador to Russia reacts to Vance's speech | POLITICO at Munich Security Conference


What this covers

This is an 11-minute interview in which POLITICO defense reporter Jack D asks former ambassador Michael McFaul to react to JD Vance's address at the Munich Security Conference. Detsch frames the conversation around what he expected to hear: specifics on Ukraine, NATO, and the administration's unclear position on a peace process. Instead the speech dwelt on free speech and democratic practice in Europe. McFaul uses that gap to build his response, drawing on a conversation with Ukrainian soldiers an hour before the speech, who consider themselves European and name Russia as their threat.

The first half of McFaul's critique is empirical. He disputes that European voices are shut out, noting that parties sharing Vance's views sit in parliaments across the continent and are contesting elections, including one nine days away. He calls the image of EU commissars insulting, and contrasts it with Russia, where the opposition is jailed and its leaders killed. The second half is about credibility and contradiction. He points to Vance's own refusal to accept the 2020 election result and to Trump's release of the people who stormed the Capitol. He also sees tension between the America First emphasis on sovereignty and lecturing a continent on governance while wealthy Americans influence European elections. McFaul presents these as hypocrisy, and they are among the more contested points.

The remainder turns to policy. McFaul calls it a tactical mistake that Donald Trump phoned Putin before Brussels or other European capitals, since a Europe expected to carry its own security must be in the negotiations. Detsch raises Pete Hegseth's remark that Ukraine would end the war "not whole," later walked back, as an example of muddled messaging. McFaul lists open European questions about peacekeepers, the postwar arrangement, and the 5% Mark for NATO spending. He cites polling and congressional votes to argue that most Americans do not want to leave NATO. He ends on a normative note: this turning point in the transatlantic relationship could produce a stronger Europe, which supporters of democratic values should welcome.

Sharpest takeaway

McFaul argues that Vice President Vance's Munich Security Conference speech misread the European security context by prioritizing free speech and democracy critiques over Russia as the primary threat to Europe, and signaled reduced U.S. involvement in foreign policy while creating confusion about Trump administration intentions on Ukraine and NATO.

  • Russia, not censorship, is the greatest threat to Europe—confirmed by Ukrainian soldiers and European political consensus
  • The speech was orthogonal to the actual security concerns driving the Munich conference agenda
  • Contradictory messaging from the Trump administration on Ukraine peace negotiations and Secretary of Defense statements needed clarification that the speech did not provide

The claims · ranked42 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.76

The greatest threat to Europe is Russia, not internal censorship or democracy deficits as the Vice President claimed

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael McFaul

“for him to come to Europe and say the biggest threat to Europe is your lack of democracy uh is your uh censorship uh I just think is analytically incorrect uh the greatest threat to Europe is Russia”

0.75

The Vice President's claim that voices of Europeans are being censored and not represented is not supported by data, as parties with views similar to the VP's are represented in parliaments across Europe and are competing in elections

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael McFaul

“there was a hypothesis in the speech that the voices of Europeans and democracies are not allowed to to speak and do are not being represented I'm not an expert on elections in all of European countries but I know a little bit about it and I don't I don't think that hypothesis is is not shared by data uh the people that have his views uh in Europe uh are represented in all kinds of parliaments all across the all across the continent uh they're competing in elections in this country in nine days”

0.69

Ukrainian soldiers view themselves as European, not distinct from Europe, and believe Russia is their primary threat rather than internal European governance issues

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael McFaul

“I was just with some Ukrainian soldiers literally before his speech an hour before his speech they by the way consider themselves European that's how their identity uh censorship and and those kinds of threats are not the things that they think are the the biggest threat”

0.69

Describing the European Union as having 'commissars' is insulting and empirically inaccurate, especially when the VP ignores actual censorship, opposition jailing, and opposition leader assassination occurring in Russia

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael McFaul

“he kept he talk he used the word commissars uh to describe the European Union I know a little bit about real commissars I I I studied the Soviet Union that is just insulting uh and it's just empirically not true but then he left out the places where it is true you know Russia you know if you're worried about censorship if you're worried about jailing your opposition if you're worried about killing the leaders of the opposition that's what happened here a year ago in Munich when Alexa naali was killed”

0.69

The greatest threat to Europe is Russia, not lack of democracy or censorship as the Vice President claimed.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael McFaul

“the greatest threat to Europe is Russia uh I was just with some Ukrainian soldiers literally before his speech an hour before his speech they by the way consider themselves European that's how their identity uh censorship and and those kinds of threats are not the things that they think are the the biggest threat”

0.69

Vice President Vance's claim that censorship and lack of democracy are the biggest threats to Europe is analytically incorrect.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael McFaul

“for him to come to Europe and say the biggest threat to Europe is your lack of democracy uh is your uh censorship uh I just think is analytically incorrect”

0.68

JD Vance did not accept the results of the 2020 election, similar to how he is criticizing others' democratic practices

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Michael McFaul

“and as a footnote of course JD Vance did not accept the results of the 2020 election he did not”

0.68

President Trump called Putin before calling anyone in Brussels or other major European countries, which was a tactical mistake if Europe is supposed to be in charge of its own security

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Michael McFaul

“I think it was a it was just a tactical mistake that the president president Trump called Putin before he called anyone in Brussels before he called anyone in any of the the the major countries in Europe and before Rec called zalinski”

0.65

Hypocritically, the Trump administration is lecturing Europe about democracy while President Trump called the 2020 election illegitimate, inspired people to storm the Capitol, and then released those people from jail after being elected president

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael McFaul

“The irony of the United elected officials from the United States of America coming here and talking about individual problems of democracy when President Trump called the last election illegitimate he said it was not a fair election he then uh inspired people to storm our Parliament our capital building and then when he was elected president he he let all those people out of jail I'm sorry but there's a hypocrisy to be lecturing Europeans about how well they are practicing democracy when we are struggling with the practice of democracy at home”

0.65

The Trump administration's 'America First' approach contradicts its criticism of European sovereignty, as the administration lectures Europe about governance while allowing wealthy Americans to directly influence European elections

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael McFaul

“these guys are all about sovereignty when we're talking about America sovereignty America first right we get to govern the way we want to govern and yet to come here and to lecture an entire continent he didn't even talk about individual countries he he lectured an entire continent about their flaws I just would point out there's there's some real hypocrisy about our sovereignty we're going to defend but your sovereignty we it's free for us to tell you what to do and it's free for us to to to to have the richest Americans uh be very directly involved in your your election”

0.65

There is hypocrisy in the Trump administration's invocation of American sovereignty as a justification for defending U.S. interests while simultaneously lecturing an entire continent about how to govern and allowing wealthy Americans to directly influence European elections.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael McFaul

“these guys are all about sovereignty when we're talking about America sovereignty America first right we get to govern the wait we want to govern and yet to come here and to lecture an entire continent he didn't even talk about individual countries he he lectured an entire continent about their flaws I just would point out there's there's some real H hypocrisy about our sovereignty we're going to defend but your sovereignty we it's free for us to tell you what to do and it's free for us to to to to have the richest Americans uh be very directly involved in your your election as he joked about it but it's you know that's not actually a defense of sovereignty that's something else”

0.64

The claim that voices in European democracies are not represented is not supported by data—people with Vance's views are represented in parliaments across Europe and are competing in elections, such as those happening in nine days.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Michael McFaul

“there was a hypothesis in the speech that the voices of Europeans and democracies are not allowed to to speak and do are not being represented I'm not an expert on elections in all of European countries but I know a little bit about it and I don't I don't think that hypothesis is is not shared by data uh the people that have his views uh in Europe uh are represented in all kinds of parliaments all across the all across the continent uh they're competing in elections in this country in nine days”

0.63

The Munich Security Conference and its attendees believe Russia is the immediate security threat, not internal European governance issues

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Michael McFaul

“most people at this conference won't have much to say about that speech... my guess is we'll be waiting to hear uh about the what I consider to be the much more immediate threats to security uh you know he's he somehow thinks it's censorship I actually think it's Russia um and my guess is most people here still think it's Russia”

0.63

There is a major crisis in the transatlantic relationship that required attention at Munich Security Conference, not a lecture on European governance issues

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Michael McFaul

“everybody else at this meeting thinks we're in in a major crisis in terms of the transatlantic relationship”

0.63

JD Vance himself did not accept the results of the 2020 election, which further undermines his credibility when lecturing Europeans about democracy.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Michael McFaul

“as a footnote of course JD Vance did not accept the results of the 2020 election he did not”

0.62

President Trump called Putin before calling anyone in Brussels or major European countries, which was a tactical mistake because if Europe is supposed to lead on its own security, Europe must be part of the peace negotiations.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael McFaul

“they're send sending the signals that they want to to leave they want uh Europe to to be in the lead and so if Europe is supposed to be in the lead then one Europe has to be part of the negotiations and I think it was a it was just a tactical mistake that the president president Trump called Putin before he called anyone in Brussels before he called anyone in any of the the the major countries in Europe and before Rec called zalinski uh because ultimately if they're supposed to be in charge of their own security they have to be part of the negotiation”

0.62

A stronger Europe would result from this turning point in the transatlantic relationship, and those who believe in democratic values should welcome this shift.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael McFaul

“I think this is a turning point uh where from my point of view somebody also believes in Democratic Values uh we need a stronger Europe and um I hope that is a result of this conference”

0.62

There is hypocrisy in the Trump administration lecturing Europe about democracy when President Trump called the 2020 election illegitimate, inspired people to storm the Capitol, and then released those people from jail after being elected.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael McFaul

“the irony of the United elected officials from the United States of America coming here and talking about individual problems of democracy when President Trump called the last election illegitimate he said it was not a fair election he then uh inspired people to storm our Parliament our capital building and then when he was elected president he he let all those people out of jail I'm sorry but there's a hypocrisy to be lecturing Europeans about how well they are practicing democracy when we are struggling with the practice of democracy at home”

0.61

The characterization of the European Union as having 'commissars' is insulting and empirically false, particularly when compared to actual censorship in Russia where opposition is jailed and killed.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael McFaul

“he kept he talk he used the word commissars uh to describe the European Union I know a little bit about real commissars I I I studied the Soviet Union that is just insulting uh and it's just empirically not true but then he left out the places where it is true you know Russia you know if you're worried about censorship if you're worried about jailing your opposition if you're worried about killing the leaders of the opposition that's what happened here a year ago in Munich when Alexa naali was killed the fact that he would focus just on the crisis in Europe on these things and not speak about Russia I thought was a big missed opportunity”

0.59

Most Americans do not want to pull out of NATO, according to polling data, and when the last vote on Ukraine assistance was taken, majorities in both houses of Congress voted for it

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Michael McFaul

“most Americans don't want to move pull out of NATO by the way the polling on that very clear most Americans actually support uh ass assistance to Ukraine uh polling's very clear on that the last vote we had on it it was crystal clear majorities in both houses voted for that”

0.57

Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth's statement that Ukraine would end the war 'not whole' and then walked back his comments reveals messaging confusion within the Trump administration on Ukraine policy.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Jack D

“we saw defense secretary Pete heg of course at the Ukraine defense contact group earlier this week walk make some statements about how Ukraine would end up at the end of the war not whole and then of course walked those comments back later um it seems like this is creating a lot of confusion among the Europeans”

0.57

Europeans are asking important questions about a potential peace deal with Russia including whether there would be peacekeepers on the ground, what would happen after a peace deal, and what the '5% Mark' NATO spending target would mean.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Michael McFaul

“where does this leave the Europeans of course because they had a lot of questions of course about the peace deal they had a lot of questions about what would come after the peace deal would it be peacekeepers on the ground would it be some sort of Armed Force they had questions about the 5% Mark that we didn't hear any answers to”

0.57

Jack D expected the speech to address specific issues including Ukraine, NATO, and the administration's unclear positions on a Ukraine peace process, but the speech focused on free speech and democracy critiques instead.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Jack D

“a discourse from the vice president about free speech about what's going on in Europe uh very little mention if any mention of Ukraine NATO some of the big topics and confusion that's on the mind of European uh politicians here”

0.57

McFaul was with Ukrainian soldiers an hour before Vance's speech and they consider themselves European.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Michael McFaul

“I was just with some Ukrainian soldiers literally before his speech an hour before his speech they by the way consider themselves European that's how their identity”

0.56

There should be democratic debate in America about NATO and Ukraine policy because most Americans support the current positions, and the administration should not make a premature conclusion that the U.S. is leaving.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Michael McFaul

“My Hope Is that that will not be the case and and I as an American I hope I won't be censored by these these folks right I I hope I'll have the chance to articulate a different perspective in a democratic uh Society in a democratic country uh My Hope Is that we will have a debate about these issues uh because most Americans don't want to move pull out of NATO by the way the polling on that very clear most Americans actually support uh ass assistance to Ukraine”

0.55

The Trump administration is signaling it will not be afraid to take 'Trumpism' abroad, defining values in a very partisan way that is not neutral, and has decided this will be part of their foreign policy, which is something very new.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael McFaul

“the second thing uh that the takeaway is uh they are not going to be afraid to take you know trumpism abroad uh that that was you know he has a he has his definition of values uh that are not neutral they're they they're very partisan from my point of view uh and he's decided that that's they've decided that this is going to be part of their foreign policy that that is something very new”

0.53

Most Americans do not want to pull out of NATO, and polling shows most Americans actually support assistance to Ukraine.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Michael McFaul

“most Americans don't want to move pull out of NATO by the way the polling on that very clear most Americans actually support uh ass assistance to Ukraine uh polling's very clear on that the last vote we had on it it was crystal clear majorities in both houses voted for that”

0.52

The Trump administration has decided to incorporate its definition of 'trumpism' as a partisan foreign policy framework abroad, which is something very new compared to previous administrations

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael McFaul

“they are not going to be afraid to take you know trumpism abroad uh that that was you know he has a he has his definition of values uh that are not neutral they're they're very partisan from my point of view uh and he's decided that that's they've decided that this is going to be part of their foreign policy that that is something very new”

0.49

The Vice President's speech suggests he will not be involved in foreign policy, unlike Vice President Biden whose 2009 Munich Security Conference speech made clear he would be a major player in foreign policy

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Michael McFaul

“one takeaway I had is that uh our vice president's not going to be involved in foreign policy right so um uh when I was in the government uh that uh uh the 2009 speech was delivered by a vice president Vice President Biden uh and when he came to this conference it was very clear that he was going to be a major player in foreign policy whether that would good outcomes or bad outcomes for others to judge that was a very clear signal his speech was about security this speech was not which suggests to me that the vice president's going to be involved in these issues back home and not involved in foreign policy”

0.48

If Europe is to be in charge of its own security as the Trump administration implies, then Europe must be included in negotiations with Russia and Ukraine, not excluded from them

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael McFaul

“if Europe is supposed to be in the lead then one Europe has to be part of the negotiations and I think it was a it was just a tactical mistake that the president president Trump called Putin before he called anyone in Brussels before he called anyone in any of the the the major countries in Europe and before Rec called zalinski uh because ultimately if they're supposed to be in charge of their own security they have to be part of the negotiation”

0.48

The Vice President's speech was an opportunity to clarify the Trump administration's contradictory statements about its involvement in Ukraine peace negotiations, but he chose not to take it

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael McFaul

“I think the audience and most certainly I was waiting for clarification about what right now is a very convoluted um set of statements that the Trump Administration has made about uh their involvement in a peace process with respect to Ukraine and their negotiations with Putin this would have been a fantastic opportunity to clarify that he himself is somewhat contradictory has made contradictory statements compared to the Secretary of Defense this speech could have been a a moment of clarification and he chose not to do that he chose to do a different speech”

0.48

The speech represents a missed opportunity because it did not provide clarification on the Trump administration's contradictory and convoluted statements about involvement in a Ukraine peace process and negotiations with Putin.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael McFaul

“he obviously made it decision that he was going to give a political speech about you know uh the the the values that he he aspires to and you know that's okay uh but I think the audience and most certainly I was waiting for clarification about what right now is a very convoluted um set of statements that the Trump Administration has made about uh their involvement in a peace process with respect to Ukraine and their negotiations with Putin this would have been a fantastic opportunity to clarify that he himself is somewhat contradictory has made contradictory statements compared to the Secretary of Defense this speech could have been a a moment of clarification and he chose not to do that he chose to do a different speech”

0.45

The Munich Security Conference speech was intended primarily for American domestic audiences rather than for the European audience present at the conference

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Michael McFaul

“that speech was orthogonal that was off to the side that was a speech uh I think intended in many ways for American domestic audiences More Than This audience um maybe I'll be surprised by that but my guess is we'll be waiting to hear”

0.45

The takeaway from the speech is that Vice President Vance will not be involved in foreign policy, unlike Vice President Biden in 2009 who was clearly positioned as a major foreign policy player.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Michael McFaul

“one takeaway I had is that uh our vice president's not going to be involved in foreign policy right so um uh when I was in the government uh that uh uh the 2009 speech was delivered by a vice president Vice President Biden uh and when he came to this conference it was very clear that he was going to be a major player in foreign policy whether that would good outcomes or bad outcomes for others to judge that was a very clear signal his speech was about security this speech was not which suggests to me that the vice president's going to be involved in these issues back home and not involved in foreign policy”

0.40

The speech was intended as a political speech about the values the Vice President aspires to, rather than a security policy clarification speech.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Michael McFaul

“he obviously made it decision that he was going to give a political speech about you know uh the the the values that he he aspires to and you know that's okay”

0.40

Vance's speech was orthogonal to the actual security concerns driving the Munich conference, and was intended for American domestic audiences rather than the European audience at the conference.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Michael McFaul

“that speech was orthogonal that was off to the side that was a speech uh I think intended in many ways for American domestic audiences More Than This audience um maybe I'll be surprised by that but my guess is we'll be waiting to hear uh about the what I consider to be the much more immediate threats to security uh you know he's he somehow thinks it's censorship I actually think it's Russia um and my guess is most people here still think it's Russia”

0.37

The Munich Security Conference keynote is historically significant because these speeches echo in history.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Jack D

“the Munich keynote always kind of something that echoes in history a bit”

0.27

The last vote on Ukraine assistance in Congress showed clear majorities in both houses supporting assistance.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Michael McFaul

“the last vote we had on it it was crystal clear majorities in both houses voted for that”

0.22

McFaul hopes for debate within American democracy about Ukraine support and NATO rather than accepting the apparent Trump administration direction as inevitable

normativespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Michael McFaul

“My Hope Is that that will not be the case and and I as an American I hope I won't be censored by these these folks right I I hope I'll have the chance to articulate a different perspective in a democratic uh Society in a democratic country uh My Hope Is that we will have a debate about these issues”

0.22

A stronger Europe is needed and would result from the Munich Security Conference as countries recognize they must lead on their own security given the Trump administration's signals

forecastspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Michael McFaul

“from my point of view somebody also believes in Democratic Values uh we need a stronger Europe and um I hope that is a result of this conference”

0.22

McFaul hopes he will not be censored by the Trump administration and will have the chance to articulate a different perspective in his role as a democratic citizen.

normativespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Michael McFaul

“My Hope Is that that will not be the case and and I as an American I hope I won't be censored by these these folks right I I hope I'll have the chance to articulate a different perspective in a democratic uh Society in a democratic country”

0.12

Jack D and McFaul are having a casual chat to provide instant reaction to the Munich Security Conference keynote.

factual· Jack D

“I'm Jack D I'm a defense reporter here at Politico I have uh Ambassador Michael McFall the former US ambassador to Russia thanks for having me I'm not sure they thank you that you we're talking but well it seem like they're they're doing okay without us but I'm happy to be with you yeah no just just curious to uh casually chat about what we just saw”