What this covers

This is an interview in which the BBC's Justin Webb questions George Packer about how the United States arrived at its current divisions and what might repair them. Packer's account starts with class. He describes an educated professional top ten percent that has secured its own advantages and passed them to its children, while social mobility shrinks for everyone else. He treats this as a bipartisan, structural problem, since elites in both parties move between government and private industry. He then lays out four competing national narratives, Free America, Smart America, Real America and Just America, and argues that none of them is built for shared problem-solving.

The middle of the conversation covers the parties. Packer traces how the Democrats became the party of professionals and minority voters and the Republicans the party of resentful white working-class voters. He calls Sarah Palin a forerunner of Donald Trump and describes the Free America creed of the Ronald Reagan era. He also argues that Real America voters want a welfare state, but one restricted to "us", which he compares to Marine Le Pen's politics. He says Republican leaders who briefly resisted Trump after January 6th backed down. The structural bias of the Senate, the Electoral College and gerrymandering also comes up.

The more contested material concerns the left and the media. Packer says Smart America's cosmopolitan elite has abandoned patriotism. He objects to framing race as a fixed essence, which he contrasts with Martin Luther King's aspiration, and he points to Eric Adams's mayoral win as evidence that most voters want pragmatic governance. He calls social media, Facebook especially, corrosive because it runs on contempt, and he proposes transparency rules for algorithms and limits on targeted advertising. The war in Ukraine, the 2020 defeat of Trump by seven million votes, and what it would take for Americans to believe in renewal fill out the rest.

Sharpest takeaway

American democracy faces existential threats from hardened class inequality and political tribalism, but renewal is possible if the country can restore patriotism, bridge generational divides, and rebuild faith in democratic institutions—a path Biden and some Democratic leaders are attempting but may not achieve in time.

  • The U.S. has calcified into an aristocracy of the educated top 10% with less social mobility than most European countries, corroding the foundational American promise of equal opportunity
  • Four competing narratives (Free America, Smart America, Real America, Just America) have replaced bipartisan governance, making democratic problem-solving impossible when both parties view the other as morally illegitimate
  • Renewal requires restoring patriotism and a sense of shared national obligation among elites, which professional classes have abandoned in favor of cosmopolitan globalism

The claims · ranked41 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.79

Inequality in America has created a hardened class system where the top 10 percent—an educated professional class (journalists, lawyers, doctors, tech workers, academics)—have secured their own benefits and ensured their children maintain that position, while the middle and working classes have less and less chance to rise, destroying the foundational American promise of social mobility.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“we have become almost an aristocracy uh in which there's a business class and a professional class at the top that keeps securing its own benefits its own place and making sure the children hold that place and a falling middle and working class that have less and less chance”

0.75

Both Democratic and Republican elites have become self-perpetuating professional classes that rotate between government and private sector (tech companies, consulting, etc.), making the problem of captured governance bipartisan and structural rather than merely partisan.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“members frankly of recent democratic administrations who go you know after the administration goes go off to the west coast work for a a tech company etc go back to an administration some have come back to the biden administration now it's it's a more complex picture isn't it politically”

0.71

The Democratic Party is being pulled apart by generational divisions between the professional Smart America elite and the Just America younger generation; this is not only a political phenomenon but appears across journalism, the arts, and philanthropy.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“it is pulling itself apart and the inability of the bide administration to pass most of its legislative agenda in spite of having very thin majorities very thin but majorities in congress um shows how destructive the divisions have become it's generational i mean justin you you probably feel this here too but this is a generational clash between parents and children almost and it's a it's not just in politics it's in journalism it's in the arts it's in philanthropy”

0.71

American leaders, both elite and ordinary, have lost the ability to govern themselves by solving problems together; instead they are rewarded by voters and media for pandering, performing for social media and cable news, and building personal brands rather than representing the public and solving collective problems.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“our leaders our are seem to have no sense that they have an obligation to solve problems instead they are rewarded by the voters not for solving problems but for pandering for parading on twitter and on cable news for making a name and a brand for themselves they're more in it for themselves than to represent the public”

0.71

Social media, particularly Facebook, is poison that corrodes democratic discourse by privileging contempt—the language of social media—which is fundamentally antithetical to democracy, which requires minimal respect for fellow citizens as a precondition for solving collective problems.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“it is poison it corrodes the veins of our discourse it it seems to uh to privilege contempt contempt is the language of social media and contempt to me is antithetical to democracy in which for me democracy means you have to have a minimal respect for your fellow citizens in order for this to work”

0.71

Real America and Just America (the two rebellions from below) have increasingly become the dynamic energy in their respective parties, making debate impossible because their positions are not policy-defined but emotion-defined—based on resentment, fear, and anger rather than specific proposals—leading inexorably toward authoritarianism.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“so as you can see that as we get closer to real and just america as the energy of our politics there's just less and less debate to be had and more and more existential battle to be fought”

0.70

Most Americans (non-white working-class voters in particular) don't want to live according to Just America ideology; they want basic pragmatic governance and decent lives—as evidenced by Eric Adams, a Black working-class former cop, winning New York City's mayoral election by opposing defunding police, opposing elimination of gifted programs, and promising to actually govern.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· George Packer

“so in my city new york we've elected a mayor eric adams who's a former cop black uh working class from outer borough you can hear it as soon as he starts talking and he won in one of the most liberal cities in the country by saying i'm not going to defund the police”

0.70

The Ukraine war is changing American politics in a subtle way by making hawkish internationalism briefly popular across party lines—even left-wing Democrats are urging Biden to do more, contradicting the recent isolationist drift following the Afghanistan withdrawal.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· George Packer

“it the ukrainian position in the war is immensely popular in the united states and it's nearly unanimous support in congress with about eight lunatic far-right trumpists voting against”

0.69

Democratic governance requires that people be brought along through persuasion; pure force of numbers fails because it eventually provokes backlash—yet contemporary Americans have abandoned the capacity for these essential conversations, each side viewing the other as mortal enemies requiring destruction.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“you don't govern a democracy by pure force of numbers you also have to bring people along or else eventually you're going to run into a backlash and today we no longer know how to do that instead each side sees the other as a mortal adversary that has to be destroyed”

0.69

Since the end of the industrial age, Democrats have become the party of professionals and white-collar cosmopolitans combined with minority groups, while Republicans have become the party of resentful white working-class voters who've lost status—a reversal from the 20th century party division.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“since the end of the industrial age the democrats have become the party of professionals more and more combined with non-whites and other minority groups although those are in play they're certainly not uh the the property of the democratic party and to the shock of a lot of democrats latino voters moved over toward trump in 2020”

0.69

Rural and small-town working-class Americans now suffer from the same pathologies—drug addiction, fatherless families, multi-generational poverty—that Democratic politicians attributed to urban minorities in the 1980s, creating a convergence that should have bridged the racial divide but instead deepened the geographic political divide.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“their lives look more and more like the lives of uh people in the cities who suffer from drug addiction fatherless families multi-generational poverty you see that in all kinds of towns and rural areas outside the big metropolitan centers”

0.69

The red-blue geographic and partisan divide that crystallized around 2000 has favored Republicans because America's anti-democratic structural features—the Senate empowering small states, the Electoral College, and gerrymandering—align with Republican strength in rural areas, allowing Republicans to hold power with a minority of the popular vote.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“the red blue divide which really became entrenched starting around the year 2000 has favored republicans because the anti-democratic structure of our government with the senate the electoral college and other things too gerrymandering of political districts has played into the republican hand so that they can hold on to power with a minority vote”

0.69

Americans threw out Donald Trump in the 2020 election by seven million votes in the middle of a pandemic, which is remarkable because among populist authoritarian rulers worldwide, there is only one place where the public successfully removed such a leader from power—the United States—making this a statement of faith in democracy despite deep divisions.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“when you look around the world at populist authoritarian rulers there's only one place where the public got rid of him and that's the united states it's hard to do once they're in they have a way of staying in and so the tremendous turnout in the middle of the pandemic in the november 2020 election was a statement of faith perhaps tattered and skeptical but still a statement of faith in democracy on the part of the american people”

0.69

Free America is the Reagan-era narrative that government should get out of the way, there is no such thing as society (only individuals), and lower taxes and deregulation will create both freedom and prosperity; this mantra still dominates business-class and Republican ideology despite decades of contrary evidence.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“free america was the reagan era and here it was thatcher it was the idea that government should get out of the way that there is no such thing as society they're only individuals that lower taxes and deregulation will create both freedom and prosperity and that has had a stronghold on the business class and the republican party for decades up till now you'll still hear this same mantra of tax cuts”

0.68

Sarah Palin was an important precursor to Trump, not a marginal figure—she was John the Baptist for Trumpism—because she initiated right-wing populist rhetoric about 'Real America' and 'real Americans' meaning white Christian heartland people, creating the base for Trump's later takeover of the Republican Party.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“she's uh perhaps underestimated as an important figure because i think she was the john the baptist for donald trump she came in in 2008 and began talking about real america”

0.68

Real America (right-wing populist) voters want a welfare state—they oppose cutting Social Security and Medicare—but want it restricted to 'us' (working-class white Americans) and denied to 'those people' (immigrants, minorities), making them more similar to European identity politics movements like Marine Le Pen's than to traditional American conservatism.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“they still want a welfare state they don't want to get rid of their social security and their medicare they just don't think it should go to those people it should go to us because we paid for it we deserve it so when you hear marine le pen talking about this mix of getting rid of immigrants but keeping social security that's very much what real america is about”

0.68

For Americans to feel that renewal is possible, they need to believe that everyone has a fair chance at success—this requires that government policies actively help the bottom 60 percent and limit the power of the top 10 percent, not through punishment but through enabling opportunity.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“that's the key for everyone to feel they have a fair chance that was biden's agenda and for me that was the best chance for us to get out of the poisonous atmosphere that we're in today”

0.68

The professional metropolitan elite (Smart America)—living in cities, feeling closer to London than to places 30 miles outside their city—has abandoned patriotism, seeing nationalism as retrograde like 'dog racing, cigarette smoke' or dogeared notions Americans should be beyond, which damages the country's ability to solve problems.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“the era of globalization has made a lot of people in new york feel closer to people in london than to people 30 miles outside new york city and that is uh maybe an inevitable trend in in a global era but it's also quite harmful to the ability of the country to do things”

0.68

Looking honestly at America's history, including racial injustice, is necessary and has been accelerating since 2014; however, framing this history in categorical, metaphysical terms that trap people in identity and erase individual variation and social fluidity is destructive and produces a different kind of authoritarianism based on oppression and identity.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“the best version of that is that we are facing our history more honestly now than we ever have and that is something deeply necessary the george floyd protest forced that out into the open it's been coming for years it's not as though it began with george floyd i think it's been coming since about 2014. you can see a lot of markers what books were the best sellers and the prize winners how did teachers talk in the classroom but since george floyd there has been a really passionate desire to look at the history of this country and to see how the present has been shaped by it especially the racial history that's necessary”

0.66

Republican elites (like Mitch McConnell and Kevin McCarthy) attempted to stand against Trump after January 6th but backed down within days or weeks because their fellow Republicans told them Trump is a hero in their districts and opposing him would be political suicide, showing that Republican elites have lost control of their party to the populist base.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· George Packer

“the elites still have a lot of power especially in congress and while trump was president very little happened except one big tax cut which would have been fine with every republican administration from ronald reagan to donald trump in other words something fundamental didn't change much there was a lot of rhetoric it's a lot of turmoil and ugliness but trump didn't he made some changes on trade policy and immigration policy but they didn't fundamentally change the country so in a way the populists have not won but the elites know that they are up against the future because every time the elites try to stand up to trump they backed down within days or weeks”

0.62

The Republican Party under Trump's leadership became explicitly authoritarian in ways that damage democratic institutions—routinely trashing the courts, CIA, FBI, media, and Congress itself—showing acceptance of the January 6 mob assault as the moment authoritarianism seeped into the party's bones.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“the republican party used to stand up for and now routinely trashes whether it's the courts the cia and fbi uh the media the congress itself which now seems the republicans there seem pretty much okay with having been assaulted by a mob that tried to kill them”

0.61

Historically, there were liberal Democrats from small rural states (George McGovern from South Dakota, Frank Church from Idaho) and they were great senators, showing that the red-blue divide wasn't always geographically hardened and that political competition in red states was possible.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“when i was young there was a democratic senator from south dakota his name was george mcgovern he was the most liberal member of the senate there were democrats from iowa i forgot that he came from south dakota that's an extraordinary fact it was a democrat from idaho named frank church very liberal”

0.61

Specific, non-speech-suppressing regulations could address social media's toxicity: making algorithms public, preventing algorithmic targeting of advertising, and enforcing basic transparency—reforms that could reduce the weaponization of discourse without violating free speech.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“there's some obvious regulations that could be looked at have the algorithms made public have the algorithms uh be unable to target advertising in certain ways uh just in basic things that could be done that don't suppress speech but that force the the tech corporations to stop uh poisoning the well”

0.61

The Martin Luther King vision of judging people by their character and aiming for a society where skin color doesn't matter has been replaced by an ideology treating race as an immutable essence defining what you can say, think, and who you are—a fundamental reversal from an aspiration for race to disappear to an insistence it becomes the defining feature of identity.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“it's become an essence which it never was and never should be we should always be striving for it to disappear uh my solution for our racial problems is just intermarriage as far as the eye can see but what's happened ideologically in the last few years and this is an orthodoxy really of professional people on the left”

0.61

For democratic renewal to happen, Americans must restore a sense of patriotism—love of country as something worth improving and defending, like allegiance to family—not because America is better than others but because 'we are stuck with each other' and must see each other as brothers and sisters to solve problems.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“i don't think you can solve big problems without patriotism without a sense that this country is worth improving and is ours and it in a sense we have an allegiance to it like the the allegiance we have to our own family”

0.59

Four competing narratives of what America should be have come to dominate politics: Free America (Reagan-era libertarianism: deregulation and tax cuts create freedom and prosperity), Smart America (professional-class cosmopolitanism: education and expertise lead to prosperity), Real America (right-wing populism: white Christian heartland is the 'true' America being displaced by elites and immigrants), and Just America (left-wing generational rebellion: America is irredeemably unjust and must be fundamentally transformed).

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“i call them free america smart america real america and just america and they are in a way there's a chronology here free america was the reagan era and here it was thatcher it was the idea that government should get out of the way that there is no such thing as society they're only individuals that lower taxes and deregulation will create both freedom and prosperity”

0.59

Ukraine puts pressure on Republicans who had been saying positive things about Putin (admiring his strength, his Christianity, his anti-gay positions) to stop because these statements are hard to maintain now given Putin's invasion and war crimes.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· George Packer

“on the republican side it really does put pressure on anyone who wants to say what good is nato um i admire putin he's strong he's a christian he's anti-gay these were all the things that republicans were saying while trump was president they're very hard to say right now”

0.57

Democrats made a 'terrible terrible mistake' by allowing internal divisions to prevent passage of their own legislation in the first term; the public doesn't know what they've accomplished because Democrats were too busy fighting each other, meaning Republicans will likely gain control of at least one chamber in the midterms and the renewal agenda becomes impossible.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· George Packer

“they've made a terrible terrible mistake in allowing their inner divisions to keep them from passing their own legislation they should have found a way to compromise and instead the public looks and says what have you done we don't know what you've done”

0.57

Trump is likely to be the Republican 2024 nominee because the Republican Party has become a personality cult around him, and elite Republicans cannot block him without facing political death from their base.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· George Packer

“i think if he doesn't keel over and die he probably will be because it's a personality cult”

0.57

Kamala Harris is not the future of the Democratic Party; she appears opportunistic, lacks a coherent philosophy, has not impressed as vice president, and hasn't shown ability to speak to the whole country and accomplish things—so Democrats would be foolish to treat her as heir apparent.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· George Packer

“she appears not to know what she stands for she moves from one thing to another she seems opportunistic and has has not been impressive as a vice president she has not shown that she knows how to speak to the whole country and to get things done”

0.57

Eric Adams made enemies on the left by opposing elimination of gifted programs (despite racial imbalance) and by supporting school choice/meritocracy, because he wanted to reward students who aspire and do well rather than eliminate programs based on demographic proportionality.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· George Packer

“he said i'm not going to get rid of gifted and talented programs in the schools simply because there's an imbalance of white and black in those programs i'm going to try to make them better i'm going to create more of them but i'm not going to get rid of them because i want to reward students who do well and who aspire”

0.55

The political right is exploiting left-wing censorship and cultural orthodoxy (about race, gender, identity) by passing laws banning certain speech, accelerating the cycle of culture war and mutual recrimination rather than solving the underlying problem.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“the republican party is exploiting it by passing these laws that are banning certain types of speech uh their own form of censorship and it just speeds up and worsens this cycle of culture wars”

0.54

The restoration of authoritarian populism via Republican control of Congress represents a real existential threat to American democracy, making the stakes of the 2022 midterms and 2024 general election fundamental to the country's future rather than normal political oscillation.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· George Packer

“now we have a republican party that is a threat to our democracy a direct threat to our democracy and so so much rides on these elections and yet i am afraid they're going in the direction that could lead to to a restoration of that kind of authoritarian population”

0.53

Democrats will face political difficulty in not making Harris the heir apparent if Biden steps down because she is a woman and a woman of color, even if she would be a weak candidate and other candidates could be stronger.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· George Packer

“people are going to say number one she has the right to be the heir apparent because she's vice president number two she's a woman and she's a woman of color and my goodness that puts the party in a difficult place”

0.52

Both Biden and Eric Adams are trying to move the Democratic Party away from non-stop cultural warfare and back toward delivering concrete things for ordinary people—a return to what Democrats used to do well, speaking to and improving ordinary people's lives—which is the only path toward Democratic renewal.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“i think biden and adams have a real allegiance they're trying to get the democratic party away from non-stop cultural battle and back towards something it used to do very well which was to speak to ordinary people and to say we're the party that cares about you and that will improve your lives”

0.52

The debate over social media regulation has been poisoned by false dichotomies (hatred versus censorship) that prevent actual problem-solving, but there is potential bipartisan agreement on regulating Big Tech because both Republicans and Democrats are suspicious of tech corporations, even though Big Tech money prevents politicians from acting.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“like everything else the debate over social media quickly devolves into a well you're for hatred well you're for censorship when you put it that way there's no debate to be had”

0.49

Just America (woke progressivism) frames the United States as permanently unjust with an unchangeable hierarchy of oppression based on group identity, and believes the system will never work for oppressed groups unless it is fundamentally dismantled, leading to existential rather than negotiable political conflict.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· George Packer

“just america and that's in the crude parlance of the day it's woke america it's the idea that we are a permanently unjust country with a hierarchy of oppression from white straight men that you are defined by your group your racial group your sexual identity gender etc and this has never really changed no matter what tinkering we've done with laws and with habits and customs it's never really changed and there's something fundamentally malign about america the system doesn't work for those people and it will never work for them as it is so it has to be gotten rid of”

0.45

Nikki Haley has demonstrated the ability to work with Trump without completely upsetting him, was a female governor of South Carolina, is a cold warrior on foreign policy, and could potentially combine Trump's supporters' interests with more conventional Republican internationalism, especially if Ukraine shifts the political landscape.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Justin Webb

“nikki haley who was trump's uh un ambassador she's a considerable woman consider a politician in her own right she was the first female governor of south carolina um a very able woman a real cold warrior”

0.43

Smart America is the narrative of the professional class (Clintons, Barack Obama) that if you attend college and enter post-industrial professions, you will prosper, become part of the global cosmopolitan world, and achieve upward mobility; this became the base of the Democratic Party in the 1990s.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“smart america is the narrative of the professional class uh the clintons barack obama it's that if you go to college and enter one of the post-industrial professions and don't get stuck in one of these dying fields of farming or industry you will uh you will prosper you'll be part of the global world you'll be a cosmopolitan and that became the base of the democratic party in the 90s”

0.40

George Packer wrote his book 'Last Best Hope' between the 2020 election and Biden's inauguration, a period that was exceptionally dramatic compared to the typical lull between administrations, as the country was on a trajectory toward civil conflict.

factualestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· George Packer

“i wrote the book last best hope between the election and the inauguration of of joe biden which normally is a kind of lull period in american politics where everyone's waiting for the new administration in this case it was practically the road to fort sumter uh in the run-up to the civil war so it was a dramatic period and we survived it”

0.20

Packer was never on social media and avoided it throughout his career, paying a price by being a 'non-entity' in social media terms, but this allowed him to preserve his judgment from being corrupted by the platform's logic.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“amen i'm not on it justin but are you not i'm not i avoided it uh all my career and and you know i paid a bit of a price because i'm sort of a non-entity as far as social media goes”