What this covers

This episode of The Daily is a single-guest conversation with Jim Tankersley, who covers economic policy at the White House for The Times. It begins with the headline number: the deficit nearly doubled over a year, only the third time the country has hit $2 trillion, after two pandemic-era years. Tankersley notes that spending did not rise much, Ukraine aid included, and that deficits normally shrink in a growing economy. He then works through why that did not happen. Tax revenue fell 9%, which he attributes to the 2017 tax cuts, weaker capital gains collections, lower tariff revenue from reduced imports, and disaster-related filing delays.

The middle of the conversation turns to borrowing. After years of low interest rates following 2008, the government now pays around 5% on 10-year Treasury bonds. Tankersley describes a feedback loop in which interest payments force more borrowing, and explains crowding out, where interest costs displace spending on infrastructure, health, or education. He is pointed about both parties. Republicans' focus on non-defense discretionary spending is a small slice of the budget, and their record under Donald Trump cuts against their rhetoric. Democrats, including Joe Biden, avoid naming a deficit target and rely on taxes on corporations and the wealthy, which he says would not stabilize the debt at current borrowing costs.

The episode also looks backward and forward. It recalls the 1990s, when tax increases under Democrats and later spending cuts negotiated by Bill Clinton and Newt Gingrich produced a balanced budget. It explains Rubinomics, the idea that lower deficits bring lower rates and faster growth, and speculates that 5% rates might make it appealing to Democrats again. Tankersley is gloomy about solutions, calling the serious proposals Hail Marys. He suggests that only a market disruption, such as yields climbing higher, might break the political impasse, and even that is uncertain.

Sharpest takeaway

The U.S. federal deficit has doubled to $2 trillion in a growing economy due to sharply falling tax revenues and rising borrowing costs, creating a fiscal crisis that neither major political party is willing to address with the tax increases and spending cuts that experts say are necessary.

  • Tax revenues fell 9% despite economic growth, driven by Trump tax cuts, lower capital gains taxes, and tariff reductions
  • Federal borrowing costs have surged to ~5% on 10-year Treasury bonds, creating a feedback loop where higher interest costs require more borrowing
  • Republicans refuse tax increases and focus only on discretionary spending cuts that won't solve the problem; Democrats refuse Social Security/Medicare reform and propose only tax increases on the wealthy—neither approach is sufficient

The claims · ranked20 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.79

Budget experts and think tanks broadly agree that stabilizing deficits requires a combination of two things: tax increases (which Republicans refuse) and reductions in Social Security and Medicare spending (which Democrats, Biden, and most Republicans refuse), creating a political impasse preventing any real solution.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jim Tankersley

“the sort of Think Tank industry around stabilizing the budget in Washington basically agrees that you need a mix of two things to stabilize deficits the first is some tax increases which Republicans refuse to do and the second is a thing that President Biden has unilaterally ruled out all Democrats basically rule out and most Republicans also rule out including former president Trump which is reducing government spending on social security and Medicare”

0.75

Federal government borrowing costs have shot up in the last few months, with 10-year Treasury bonds hovering around 5%, significantly higher than recent years, creating a feedback loop where higher interest payments require additional borrowing to pay those interest costs.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jim Tankersley

“borrowing costs for the federal government have shot up in the last few months and if they stay high that is going to become this sort of feedback loop for deficits we pay a lot more on interest and therefore the we have to borrow more to pay the interest and that could become a really bad cycle for the government and the economy”

0.75

Republicans have consistently advocated for reducing government deficits but excluding the Trump presidency, during which Republican-controlled Congress passed large tax cuts that increased deficits, revealing inconsistency in their fiscal discipline rhetoric.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jim Tankersley

“Republicans have been warning for more than a decade that America deficits were too high and that we needed to bring them down with the exception of when Republicans were president and that is an important thing to keep in mind here they passed a large tax cut under President Trump right and deficits went up and they didn't complain in the way they are complaining now”

0.75

Republicans focused on reducing deficits primarily target non-defense discretionary spending, which is a small portion of the budget and not a major driver of the deficit, making Republican deficit-reduction proposals unlikely to meaningfully address the problem.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jim Tankersley

“what those Republicans who are clamoring about deficits are talking most about is a very particular type of spending which is non-defense discretionary spending”

0.74

Rubinomics is the economic theory that reducing the deficit leads to lower interest rates, which stimulates economic growth through increased borrowing for homes, cars, and businesses, creating a virtuous cycle where growth further reduces deficits.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Jim Tankersley

“the sort of engine behind Clinton's efforts to do that was an actual economic theory that has now become associated with the guy who was his treasury secretary Robert reuin Reuben AMX and the idea of romics was if you can reduce the deficit and maybe even balance the budget then you can actually Stoke more economic growth MH and you do that because lower deficits help to relieve pressure on interest rates they can help interest rates fall in the economy and the idea being lower interest rates mean more people borrow money to buy houses or cars or whatever there's more economic activity you can get a growth bang for deficit reduction”

0.69

Despite the deficit doubling, government spending did not increase significantly in the past year, including during the period of Ukraine war spending, which was mostly short-term emergency aid and not a major driver of overall budget expansion.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jim Tankersley

“spending didn't actually go up very much last year even with what we spent in Ukraine I know Republicans like to talk about this a lot but this type of sort of emergency defense spending Aid to foreign countries it's mostly short-term and it's not very big in the context of the overall budget and certainly not very big in the context of our Long Haul budget problems so spending didn't go up by nearly as much as tax revenues fell the Big Driver here is taxes”

0.69

Higher interest costs on the federal deficit create a 'crowding out' effect where money spent on interest payments is unavailable for productive investments in infrastructure, healthcare, education, or other programs that would benefit the broader economy and population.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jim Tankersley

“this is one of the worries about higher interest costs is that that interest cost starts to what's called crowd out other spending so maybe we can't build more bridges because we have to pay this interest or maybe we have to reduce Medicaid benefits and health care to people who really need it”

0.66

The 1990s under President Clinton achieved both deficit reduction and a balanced budget through a combination of tax increases (passed under Democrats) and subsequent spending cuts (negotiated between Clinton and Republican Speaker Newt Gingrich), followed by strong economic growth.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Jim Tankersley

“the last time we had a fiscal trajectory that got itself not just to stabilized deficits but an actual balanced budget was this magical time you might remember Michael called the 1990s... first he and Democrats raised some taxes and then when Republicans took over the House of Representatives Clinton worked with them and agreed on some spending cuts”

0.63

Tax revenue dropped 9% year-over-year due to multiple factors: the Trump tax cuts of 2017, lower-than-expected capital gains tax collection, reduced tariff revenue from lower imports, and natural disasters that pushed some tax filing deadlines.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Jim Tankersley

“the biggest reason is the amount of tax revenue that we brought in last year as a country was just way down down by like 9%”

0.61

Deficits normally decrease when an economy is growing because the government brings in more tax revenue as people earn and spend more money, but this did not occur in the past year despite rapid economic growth.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jim Tankersley

“usually when an economy is growing rapidly like our economy has been over the last year deficits go down but this one did not”

0.61

Over the past year, the federal deficit doubled to nearly $2 trillion, marking only the third time in American history that the U.S. has had a $2 trillion deficit, and the first two occurrences were in the depths of the pandemic.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jim Tankersley

“over the past year the federal deficit the gap between what the US spent and what it earned doubled to nearly $2 trillion”

0.55

Political dysfunction and fiscal dysfunction are deeply intertwined: poor political compromise on fiscal issues leads to worsening fiscal conditions, which then makes political compromise even harder because the stakes are higher and positions more entrenched.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jim Tankersley

“I really think that the fiscal problem is so wrapped up in the great political impass that we are in in this country and the sort of inability of law makers to find common ground that it seems very difficult to imagine anything close to a resolution for this anytime soon right what you're really getting at is our political dysfunction begets our fiscal dysfunction and then our political dysfunction ensures that there's no solution for our fiscal dysfunction yeah I think that's exactly right”

0.52

Rubinomics fell out of favor among Democrats in recent decades because economic conditions changed—interest rates were low and there was no room for deficit reduction to drive rates lower—but rising interest rates back to 5% could make a Rubinomics-style approach viable again.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jim Tankersley

“that theory totally fell out of favor among Democrats in particular in the last couple of decades why because economic conditions changed interest rates were low and there wasn't going to be much of a bang for deficit reduction in reducing rates that were basically zero across the economy but now that they're climbing again now that that 10-year treasury is back around 5% you start to hear some Whispers from some people around Washington about could Ruben obic make a comeback”

0.50

The amount of tax increases on high earners that the Biden administration has proposed is insufficient to stabilize the national debt and deficits in an environment of higher borrowing costs.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Jim Tankersley

“very few budget experts think that's possible entirely with tax increases on the rich and Cly certainly the amount of tax increases that the president has proposed now is probably nowhere close to enough to actually stabilize the debt and deficits in a world where borrowing costs stay really high”

0.49

Democrats as a party do not emphasize deficit reduction in their messaging or policy proposals, and the Biden administration avoids specifying an ideal deficit target, instead framing deficit reduction as 'fiscally sustainable' while proposing tax increases on corporations and wealthy individuals as the primary mechanism to reduce deficits without cutting social programs.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Jim Tankersley

“if I'm being honest I don't feel like Democrats as a party talk all that much about the deficit yeah the Biden Administration has been really tough to pin down on this the the president and his advisers won't tell you exactly what they think the ideal deficit number should be they just say they want it to be fiscally sustainable”

0.44

Economic disruption, such as rising bond yields from 5% to higher levels (6%, 7%, 8%), might force changes in political positions by creating a crisis that overrides normal partisan resistance, though even this outcome is uncertain.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Jim Tankersley

“I think probably what you're really looking at is more economic disruption as possibly the only thing that could be a forcing agent by which I mean if you think of 5% Bond yeld is bad wait till it goes higher if borrowing costs go from five to six to 7 to eight you might see people's positions change a bit but I don't even know then”

0.43

There are no easy, low-hanging fruit policy solutions to the deficit problem; the serious deficit-reduction ideas on the table from policy experts are essentially 'Hail Marys' to actual progress given the political constraints.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jim Tankersley

“there are not easy loow hanging fruits to pick that actually make a difference in these deficit issues and the ideas that smart people have on the table are at best hail Mar's to actual progress”

0.34

The United States achieved a truly balanced budget—same money coming in as going out—for several years at the end of the 1990s, a rare and notable achievement in modern history.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Jim Tankersley

“and then we got a bunch of great economic growth and all of that combined to actually balancing the budget for several years at the end of the 90s right a truly balanced budget same money coming in as went out yes for the kids out there it once happened it once happened”

0.34

The government borrows money to cover deficits by issuing Treasury bonds, which are securities that promise to repay the borrowed principal with interest at a specified date in the future.

definitionestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Jim Tankersley

“when the government takes in less money in tax revenue than it needs to spend on Government Services it has to borrow the money and there's a way that it borrows the money it issues bonds treasury bonds”

0.29

Interest rates being low for a long time since the 2008 financial crisis meant that the federal government's cost of borrowing was manageable, as it could issue Treasury bonds at low interest rates and not face significant interest payment burdens.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Jim Tankersley

“when interest rates are low in the economy which they have been for a really long time since the 2008 ccial crisis the cost of borrowing for the government is not very much”