
“Autocracy Inc.” | Strategy Session Live w/ Anne Applebaum
What this covers
This is a half-hour Strategy Session conversation, held on the publication day of her book Autocracy, Inc., between Anne Applebaum and the show's hosts, Rick Wilson, Stewart Stevens and Joe Trippi. Applebaum describes how today's autocracy works as a Global Autocratic Network rather than a set of isolated regimes. She points to a visible military alignment: North Korean ammunition and Iranian drones going to Russia, and Chinese components helping rebuild Russia's defense industry. She also describes a shared narrative that casts autocracy as safe and stable and democracy as weak and degenerate. Viktor Orbán appears as the case of a leader who treats eliminating independent media as the foundation of control, and Russia's disinformation about the Ukraine invasion, which obscures its colonial aim, is another example.
The conversation then turns to the United States. Applebaum argues that Donald Trump is more extreme and less constrained than European far-right figures such as Le Pen and Wilders. She says he rejects moderation and coalition language, and that he commands media attention through Fox, Newsmax and social media allies even without state media. She treats the choice of J.D. Vance as further evidence. She also blames social media algorithms that reward anger and division. These claims, along with her view that parts of the Republican Party and mainstream US media have adopted autocratic narratives, are the most contested points in the talk.
The second half is about what works. Applebaum credits Poland's 2023 result, France's cross-spectrum anti-far-right coalition, and Labour's disciplined campaign under Starmer. She emphasizes Pre-Election Grassroots Mobilization and campaigning in red districts where victory is unlikely. She says campaigns should use every platform, including TikTok and Truth Social. The hosts and Applebaum also discuss Joe Biden's withdrawal, which she reads as a democratic act, and the generational shift that followed. She closes by rejecting pessimism as irresponsible and urging local civic participation.
Modern autocrats operate as a coordinated transnational network united by transactional self-interest rather than ideology, using narrative dominance and media control to delegitimize democracy while positioning themselves as stable alternatives; defeating this requires grassroots democratic movements, broad anti-autocratic coalitions, and sustained engagement rather than top-down campaigning.
- Autocrats prioritize personal power and wealth over ideology and coordinate internationally to undermine democracies through shared anti-democratic narratives
- Trump represents a more extreme and less constrained version of global autocracy than European far-right leaders because of unprecedented media command and lack of institutional guardrails
- Successful democratic resistance (Poland, France, UK) required pre-election grassroots organizing, broad coalitions across ideological lines, and candidates willing to campaign in hostile territory to demonstrate inclusive leadership
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Social media algorithms structurally advantage emotional content, anger, and divisive material, which has become a primary information source for many people including journalists and media shapers, fundamentally altering political discourse toward polarization.
“social media um plays a role in this in that the way most the big social media platforms work is that they're you know there the what spreads and what gets attention and what you see is determined by algorithms that that favor emotion and anger and division U and ultimately um polarization and so that you know that that is now for many people and even for many for many journalists and for many people who who shape other media their main source of information I think that's changed the way that we talk about politics quite a lot”
Autocratic regimes have constructed and continuously reinforce a coordinated trans-national narrative framework depicting autocracy as safe, secure, and stable while portraying democracy as weak, divided, and sexually degenerate, which is now being adopted by parts of the Republican Party and mainstream US media.
“they've created a kind of autocratic narrative um that is designed to you know create an image of autocracy is safe and secure and stable and democracy is weak and divided and and actually degenerate even sexually degenerate and and to and and they and they and they they they use this Nar this and this narrative links together all of their news coverage all of their descriptions of the world are seen through that lens and there is a there is a version of that which is now not just available in the United States and it's not just I don't know on Russia today or Chinese State media it's very much it's repeated and used by a part of the mostly of the Republican Party”
Modern autocrats are fundamentally transactional rather than ideological, primarily concerned with their own power, wealth, and personal advantage rather than governing ideology, even when their regimes maintain ideological facades like those in Iran or China.
“the nature of modern autocrats is that they are transactional so most of them aren't ideological in the oldfashioned sense I mean they have ideologies you know obviously the Iranians have an ideology the Chinese have the Communist party but mostly they're interested in themselves and their power and their money and that's their priority”
Orbán explicitly prioritizes eliminating independent media and preventing criticism as foundational to authoritarian control, stating directly that maintaining power requires ensuring no media opposition exists to challenge corruption or provide transparency.
“orbon controls all the media so that's a he doesn't have there isn't I mean there are some websites and there are a few other things but he doesn't really have any media opposition at all in fact I once heard him speak at a at a conference where he was asked by some kind of sycophantic actually unfortunately American um uh who Americans who are President you know oh Mr orbon how do you how do you stay in power so long and one of the first things he said was well it's very important not to have any media who are against you um and by that he meant he doesn't want any criticism he doesn't want any transparency he doesn't want anybody writing about corruption and he doesn't want any any real opposition”
Russia, North Korea, and Iran have formed an operationally visible military alliance, with North Korea supplying ammunition to Russia, Iran providing drones to Russia, and China enabling Russia's defense industry recovery by supplying components.
“the collaboration between just between Russia North Korea and Iran which wasn't wasn't visible uh previously I mean you can see it now I mean the North Koreans give ammunition to the Russians and the and the Iranians are making drones for the Russians and the Chinese are enabling the Russian defense industry to recover by supplying them with components”
Donald Trump is more extreme and less institutionally constrained than contemporary far-right leaders in Europe (Marine Le Pen, Geert Wilders, others) because he rejects coalition-building language, refuses moderation signaling, and exhibits increasingly radical rhetoric while maintaining extraordinary command of media attention.
“Trump is far more extreme than any of the current far-right leaders who are in politics now... Mar P or guilt Wilders in in the Netherlands or um you know all of those are people who claim at least to want to work with allies I mean there's it's a different political system but they they talk they have Coalition partners and they talk about working within coalitions they talk about working within institutions a lot of them in order to get elected have made um attempts to sound more moderate or they've put surrounded themselves with more moderate people um so there's a you know there's a there's a clear effort to move to somewhat to the center and really all of them have done it and and Trump has done the opposite I mean he's more and more extreme”
Russia has deliberately muddied interpretations of the Ukraine invasion through disinformation campaigns portraying it as NATO aggression or about American biological labs rather than as explicit colonial occupation aimed at erasing Ukrainian sovereignty and recreating Russian Empire.
“he's done a lot to muddy the waters so you know offering people alternate explanations for the War I mean this is this is a colonial war of occupation it's War it's about imposing it's about erasing Ukrainian nationality and it's about imposing recreating some kind of Russian Empire um in its place and he's done a lot to muddy that to convince people that it's really about NATO or it's really about you know American biolabs that were in Ukraine that's a conspiracy theory it's not true”
Global autocratic networks are bound together by ethnonationalism and shared commitment to undermine democracy internationally, with varying degrees of difficulty defending Putin as model given Ukraine war disconfirmation, particularly among European far-right who feel territorial threat.
“This Global Network of authoritarians they are bound by a kind of of nationalism and a kind of ethnonationalism in most of these cases”
Despite not controlling state media like Orbán, Trump maintains extraordinary media loyalty through Fox News, Newsmax, and social media boosters who provide platform support independent of institutional appointment, sustaining his influence as an out-of-power ex-president.
“Trump doesn't have that I mean he has um we have opposition politics and opposition media here but but but but it's but it's true that even as a out of power ex-president and one who's you know who was not that long ago quite disgraced he does have these boosters and you know in the media whether it's in social media or whether it's through fox or whether it's um Newsmax I mean he does have these Outlets that are extraordinarily loyal to him um for you know for reasons of their own”
Individuals should engage in civic participation by working for political parties, campaigns, local organizations, poll working, or running for local office to strengthen democracy.
“I tell people to do you know get engaged you know work work for a political party or work on a campaign or work for a local organization or going going be a pole worker or um you know or run for office or do something in local politics and and I think the more we can encourage people to do that the the better the future gets”
There is no historical inevitability in democratic success or failure; outcomes depend entirely on whether people actively engage in public life, making the difference between democratic resilience and autocratic capture a function of collective human action, not structural determinism.
“I honestly believe that there is no Arc of history there is no inevitability there's no reason why the United States will fail or will succeed you know these things only happen when people are engaged in public life and make them happen”
Trump's selection of J.D. Vance as running mate represents choice of extreme running mate, further demonstrating commitment to escalating extremism rather than moderating for electoral viability.
“he picked an extreme running mate um his his language is not at all consiliary it's not at all Coalition building”
France's defeat of the far-right required forming an explicit coalition stretching from far-left through center-right, with rapid informal agreements between first and second electoral rounds to prevent far-right victory, demonstrating necessity of ideologically-diverse anti-autocratic alliances.
“the the defeat of the French far right was possible because of a coalition that stretched from really quite extreme left all the way through this you know the center left and the center right you know and it was a very big wide group and they made a kind of packed and I don't want to go into the details of the French electoral system there was a kind of pack made informally and really rapidly I mean within a few days in between the first and second rounds of their elections right where they essentially agreed to cooperate and and make sure that they didn't win”
Biden's decision to resign from the 2024 race, despite initial resistance and political pressure, demonstrates a fundamentally democratic value system distinct from autocratic behavior because he prioritized the national interest and democratic concerns over personal power retention.
“one of the arguments of the book is that the nature of modern autocrats is that they are transactional... there was something about Biden's decision to resign because it was good for the country that was that was rather moving I mean I know he was under pressure I know he at first argued against it he didn't want to do it and then as it became clear that the his age was a huge problem for voters he decided that that was more important than him insisting on trying to remain and I I it was it was admirable”
High stakes of 2024 election concern whether US remains leader of global alliance of democracies committed to transparency and rule of law, or becomes transactional autocratic power pursuing leader's personal advantage.
“this is a this is a moment when you know the question of whether the United States is going to remain a leader of an alliance of democracies I don't just mean in Europe but around the world and whether the United States will continue to speak for values like transparency in the rule of law um whether whether we will continue to have that role or whether we will become you know a part of the autocratic world you know another yet another transactional Power who you know whose leader looks for his own advantage in in any in any at any diplomatic meeting you know whether whether political or financial for himself some of his close business partners”
Biden's resignation has catalyzed a broader generational shift in Democratic leadership, elevating governors like Whitmer, Shapiro, and others into prominent roles, which energizes younger voters who previously lacked engagement with the older Biden campaign.
“he isn't just passing the torch to col Harris but I think you're we're seeing um a whole lot of other a new generation of democratic leaders get get some focus and Spotlight on them I mean everybody from Whitmer and we know them but Whitmer Shapiro uh and so many others Steve Basher thiser um West Moore they're I think they're all going to be a major part of this uh this campaign now and and and that's I I think it's really important I think you're seeing that energy particularly with younger voters um and it's going to get even bigger”
Democratic Party demonstrated institutional discipline and party management over the past week, learning lessons from British Labour under Keir Starmer about running campaigns as coordinated winning machines rather than ideological debating societies.
“actually the British lesson what Kier starmer who's now the labor prime minister did right really ruthless party management I mean the party itself oh yeah kind of winning machine instead of being a talking shop kind of ideological debating society and maybe the Democratic party has learned that too I don't know we'll see you know I mean but that's that's another that was another piece of what they did that changed their image”
Democratic and pro-democracy campaigns should engage voters in red states and red districts where they are unlikely to win, following the Polish prime minister's strategy, to demonstrate care for those communities and create knock-on effects in other states.
“the Polish prime minister who won the the the the election October he made a point of campaigning in places where he wasn't going to win so it's as if Harris were campaigning in red States you know I'm not going to win here but I'm going to show people here that I care about them too and I want to be also their prime minister and there's something that I I honestly think Harris should think about campaigning in red States in red districts in places where she might not win”
The book 'Autocracy Inc.' should be read as a warning about what can happen if democracy is not actively defended, with the hope that awareness of the dangers can prevent the worst outcomes.
“I mean I I I get asked this all the time I've written some very gloomy books um you know partly I do it you know because I feel it's very important to be you know go to the darkest things that are happening or have happened and explain them um and explain how we can prevent them from happening again and start start the conversation”
It is irresponsible to embrace pessimism about democratic futures because doing so discourages younger people who have their whole lives ahead and should be encouraged toward public engagement rather than resignation.
“I I I've said this many times I mean I think it's very irresponsible to be pessimistic I mean who am I to say you know it's all darkness and everything is Gloom I mean there are a lot of younger people who who still have their lives in front of them and I I can't I can't tell them not to do anything”
Stewart Stevens was part of a Lincoln Project Zoom meeting with Applebaum where they discussed how pro-democracy movements need to position themselves as movements and reinforce that there are more democratic supporters than autocratic ones
“I was um interested I when we spoke in 20 as part of a little link Lincoln project Zoom that we had you were uh I was fascinating you were talking about the how these movements position themselves as movements with and how they rally people to them and you you were arguing that we need we those of us against Trump needed to do that more you know to reinforce that there's more of us than there are of them”
Polish ruling party spent eight years in power undermining institutions and degrading the judicial system before being defeated, providing a cautionary example for America
“you had a you know kind of autocratic ruling party was in charge of the country for eight years and went a long way to undermine institutions and to degrade the judicial system and and you know and so on I mean much as you can you can see beginning to happen here and you can imagine getting getting much worse”
Pro-democracy campaigns must use every available social media platform to reach voters where they are, including platforms like Truth Social (Trump's platform) and TikTok, even if the speaker would personally ban them
“a lot of it is about um this Grassroots campaigning you know you can't reach people from above um a lot of it is about using every single form of social media possible even the I that hammer Harris's campaign has opened an account on Truth social I mean and that's that's what you need to do I mean you need g go everywhere people are reading stuff fight them where they are wherever people are you have to be there I mean even if I mean I would myself I would ban Tik Tok but if I were running for president I would have a Tik Tok account and and I would be really engaged there”
Democratic movements succeed not through top-down campaigns but through pre-election grassroots mobilization and mass organizing that creates visible coalition energy before voting begins, as exemplified by Poland's 2023 election victory.
“I've learned a lot from the people who fight real autocracies I mean that's not obviously what we have um and also I learned a lot from watching the most recent polish election where you had a you know kind of autocratic ruling party was in charge of the country for eight years and went a long way to undermine institutions and to degrade the judicial system and and you know and so on I mean much as you can you can see beginning to happen here and you can imagine getting getting much worse and and the campaign against that party and the re which which ultimately was Victorious began with a huge amount of Grassroots campaigning kind of on the ground campaigning”
Autocracy Inc book emerged from expansion of earlier Atlantic article 'The Bad Guys Are Winning' after publishers recognized broader scope; subsequent years of story evolution, particularly Ukraine war and visible Russia-North Korea-Iran-China coordination, made the book even more urgent.
“I I it was only after I wrote it that that you know actually one of my Publishers and some the people I work with said that should be a book because it's a it's a bigger subject you know you know in the Atlantic you have what you have a lot of space you get 6,000 words or 8,000 words or something but right there's a lot more of that story and it and actually in the couple of years that have passed since I wrote it I wrote it before the war in Ukraine and so since since I wrote it the story has evolved and it's become more serious”
Democratic people want different kind of politics than Trump offers—not fear, chaos, disaster, and rambling speeches, but something positive they can actively support, creating opening for pro-democracy coalition around Harris candidacy.
“people want something different that they can that they can support and and I and I and I see a lot of that around me and I see it at book events I do I see it all the time people come up to me and say what can I do how can I help um and I tell people to do you know get engaged you know work work for a political party or work on a campaign or work for a local organization”
Many members of the younger generation are more informed, more aware of political and world events, and more engaged than previous generations were at their age, suggesting grounds for democratic optimism.
“I teach a little bit and I know a lot of younger people through my kids I'm pretty impressed by a lot of people in the younger generation they seem they seem to know more than we did they seem a lot of them are more engaged they're more aware of the um you know of what's happening in politics and what's happening in the world than we and they they're better informed”
Joe Trippi anticipates that Harris's campaign will feature an 'next gen tour' where multiple younger Democratic governors campaign together across states, passing the torch to the next generation of leadership.
“no I I think it's very likely you'll see an nextg tour I mean where they literally two or three of them go with her to this state go with her to that state and it really is about the torch being passed to the next generation of leadership and including trying to pull in some Adam kensingers and others”
Young people using 'coconut memes' and creating music videos around Harris indicates emerging grassroots cultural energy—the type of pre-campaign movement building that successful pro-democracy campaigns require
“I have young I have young adult children and I can see them already online whatever it is the coconut memes and the and the music videos I mean there seems to be a feeling that maybe now we could create something like that or we could um there there I mean you were speaking earlier about this team of people”
Harris's campaign raising awareness of the dangers of authoritarianism and what is at stake would represent a great service to the country
“if if if this campaign can just raise some awareness of the dangers and and of what's at stake if the Harris campaign can do that then it'll have done a great service to everybody”
Trump's acceptance speech at 2024 Republican National Convention demonstrated his inability to stay on message, maintain unity rhetoric, or discuss even his own assassination attempt without veering into divisive tangents about Hannibal Lecter and Venezuela.
“I went back and reread his uh his acceptance speech from the Republican National Convention um on Monday and it's it's remarkable I mean it's uh he couldn't stay on the script he couldn't talk about Unity he couldn't talk about even his own assassination the attempted assassination he couldn't talk about it without veering off in other directions and then of course if you stayed up to watch the whole thing the end of the speech was his rants about chaos and disaster and and crime and insane asylums and Hannibal Lecter and something about Venezuela that I didn't understand”
The American far-right still views Putin as an admirable figure to emulate, unlike European far-right leaders who have become more wary of him due to geographic proximity to the Ukraine war
“most of the European farri right have become more wary of him in recent years but I don't think the American farri right has it all I think they still see him as an admirable figure you know one to one to follow and admire”
US democracy movement lacked grassroots energy and visible youth engagement prior to Biden's resignation, failing to generate the pre-election coalition organizing that successful democracies employ in fighting autocratic takeovers.
“the so called democracy movement in America had had that or was wasn't a movement and I I mean there's not I mean we're we're in now when we're speaking on day two of the camel Harris presidential campaign it's a little early to make any predictions you know but I have young I have young adult children and I can see them already online whatever it is the coconut memes and the and the music videos I mean there seems to be a feeling that maybe now we could create something like that”
Stewart Stevens was impressed by Democratic Party's ability to execute Biden succession crisis without institutional failure, though the situation could have derailed into wasted time and strategic catastrophe.
“I I'm shocked that the Democratic party um didn't screw it up and very pleased and grateful um I think that this could have gone sideways in a lot of different ways um and wasted another three weeks that would have been very difficult to get back”
Wilson interviewed Applebaum about her book approximately one week before this show, and they reflected on the interview while contemplating Biden's withdrawal from the race.
“I want to I want to say first off you and I spoke about a week ago on podcast about the book um and and I thought a lot about it uh in the last few days and I'm glad you're back with us because I think we have an interesting example to today or this weekend of of a true small deed Democratic style president”
Rick Wilson, Stewart Stevens, and Joe Trippi are analyzing Biden's resignation as a moment that revealed whether the Democratic Party could move decisively without internal fracture.
“well I I'm more interested in what Ann has to say um I think um it's been an extraordinary period I'm shocked that the Democratic party um didn't screw it up and very pleased and grateful um I think that this could have gone sideways in a lot of different ways um and wasted another three weeks”