What this covers

Shane Parrish talks with Josh Kaufman, author of The Personal MBA, in a conversation that moves from how that book came about to how people learn, decide, and handle risk. Early on they discuss Charlie Munger's influence and Mental Models as frameworks that let a practitioner mentally simulate how a system works. From there the talk turns to the difference between knowledge and skill. Knowledge is information and concepts; skill is the reliable, repeatable ability to produce a real-world result.

The middle stretch is about speeding up skill. Kaufman argues for making mistakes early, after learning just enough to know what good performance looks like. He cites the Suzuki piano method, where students listen first so they can hear their own wrong notes. The discussion ties this to Deliberate Practice, the Fast Feedback Loop, and the role of reflection. They ask whether coaching shortens the learning experience, and they note that candid feedback has largely vanished from workplaces, which leaves Logging your own performance as a substitute. Parrish contributes the more contested claim that organizations praise failure but punish it, which creates an opening for individuals willing to iterate.

The later sections cover fear, risk, and status. Kaufman suggests formally acknowledging that an ambitious goal is uncertain and might fail, which takes away fear's power and prompts better preparation. The two also cover Loss Aversion, the effect of peer groups on what feels possible, and Combinatorial Effects, illustrated by Steve Jobs and calligraphy. The final third turns to status. It examines the Status Malfunction, with business school as a pointed and contested example, the way social media widens comparison, and the case for setting your own scorecard for success.

Sharpest takeaway

Josh Waitzkin argues that deliberate learning and experimentation—particularly in low-stakes domains—compound into exceptional capability, and that avoiding high-stakes mistakes while embracing calculated low-stakes failures is the optimal strategy for growth both personally and professionally.

  • High-stakes decisions require careful research to minimize irreversible damage; low-stakes domains reward rapid experimentation and mistakes as tuition for learning
  • Mental models and deliberate practice with fast feedback loops accelerate skill development far more than passive knowledge acquisition
  • Status-driven decisions often override rational evaluation and lead to poor life outcomes; consciously defining success independent of social comparison is essential

The claims · ranked45 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

The early steps in pursuing ambitious uncertain goals require formal acknowledgement that you are signing up to do something difficult, uncertain, and risky that might not work; this acknowledgement robs the fear of its power because much compensating behavior in cognitive and psychological domains appears when we try to suppress acknowledging accurate statements about reality.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Josh Waitzkin

“i think a lot of it the the early steps are a formal acknowledgement of you are signing up to do something difficult and uncertain that might not work that's a very real possibility and so i think a lot of people early on in the process will either let that stop them right there like if i if i can't be guaranteed that this works i'm just not going to do it that is not necessarily a constructive response for a lot of the bigger more ambitious things that we want to do but then also by recognizing it you rob it quite a bit of its power so instead of it trying to be this inconvenient truth that you are trying to to push to the corners of your mind and ignore and a lot of the compensating behaviors in in terms of cognitive and behavioral psychology that that appear when we're dealing with these sorts of things they tend to appear when we're trying to suppress acknowledging an accurate statement around the world or about the world and so by acknowledging exactly what it is you're trying to do acknowledging that it's uncertain and risky and you don't know exactly what what you're going to need to do or how you're going to need to grow at the start that puts you on a very firm footing with reality”

0.78

Beyond affecting risk tolerance, peer groups violate your expectations about what's possible by modeling behaviors you wouldn't expect to work; when peers successfully try things and share their learning, you accumulate a richer set of possibilities and can trust their honest feedback about experimentation processes.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Josh Waitzkin

“sometimes your friends or your peer group can violate your expectations about what's possible in a particular area and so you know it one of the most valuable things that your peer group can do or the people you surround yourself with they can have experiences that you wouldn't expect would work they can try things that you've never tried before they can do experiments that maybe don't work out and you can learn from that and so just just having a group of people who are able who are who are trying to do roughly the thing that you're trying to do and they're doing they're making their own risks they're doing their own experiments they're collecting data and then sharing back there's an enormous amount of value in that and so having having a group of people that you can trust to be honest about the process and supportive of you and your own attempts to push in this particular direction that's something that is very difficult to replicate or replace there's enormous value in that”

0.78

Social status—the perception that something will make you look good or improve how others see you—is at the root of both business success (when integrated into products as positive signaling, e.g., Rolex watches) and major life mistakes when status considerations override rational decision-making ('status malfunction').

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Josh Waitzkin

“i've i've been thinking about social status for many years now and it's it's one of those it's one of those things it came up very early in my research because fact of the matter is from a business context if you build positive social signals into your business in some way shape or form if if people if the people who you want to become your customers look at your offer and say yeah this is going to make me look really good then the offer is immediately more enticing than it would be without that social status you know and the value of that to a customer is astounding classic example a rolex does not tell time better than timex in fact it's probably worse but that's not the reason that people buy rolexes people buy rolexes for the status signal because there's something they're they're trying to communicate an intangible quality about themselves in a visible way so something making something that would otherwise be invisible visible to other people in a way that they can understand and appreciate and value so there's there's a there's a value in understanding social status being able to use it being able to um to apply it consciously to produce a particular result the other part is that social status is at the root of sometimes the biggest mistakes or the dumbest investments the things that we look back in our lives and say yeah i really wish i wouldn't have done that i call that status malfunction”

0.76

Skill development is best accelerated by quickly starting to make mistakes in the domain: learn enough to understand what performance looks like, then practice in a way that allows self-correction when mistakes are made, so you can recognize and fix errors in the moment.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Josh Waitzkin

“in general the best approach is um i really like this phrase how quickly can you start making mistakes how quickly how can you get to the point of yeah learn a little bit about the topic whatever it is that you're trying to do because that helps you understand what performance looks like it helps you self-correct so as you're doing the thing you're trying to do if you make a mistake you're capable of recognizing and correcting that mistake in the moment but skill is always gained in the context of practice”

0.75

The best way to do well involves avoiding avoidable mistakes in high-stakes contexts where consequences are severe and difficult to reverse, while in low-stakes contexts where you have more latitude, making more mistakes is a way to increase your rate of learning and knowledge acquisition, which has compound returns.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Josh Waitzkin

“going back to our conversation of monger he has a a lot of very good quotes about you know the the best way to to do well is to avoid making avoidable mistakes there's a certain context in which that's true and those are the high stakes things that are difficult to reverse that are very expensive that are very destructive yeah those are the things you absolutely don't want to screw up and on the other end of the spectrum where you have more latitude screwing up more is a way to increase your rate of learning and to increase your knowledge and and that gathering of knowledge has compound returns in and of itself and so in many areas of both life and business more experimentation means more mistakes but it also means more results and more growth”

0.74

Charlie Munger's concept of mental models—frameworks for understanding how something works—enables mental simulation, which allows skilled practitioners to understand complex systems and make better decisions by having more accurate and comprehensive mental representations of their domain.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Josh Waitzkin

“mental models are concepts or ideas or representations about how something in the real world works and they are useful because of this wonderful capability that we have in our minds which is mental simulation”

0.74

Status is emotionally difficult to pass up; people experience giving up high-status options as a real loss despite rational evaluation suggesting better outcomes through lower-status paths, making conscious deliberate evaluation a necessary practice.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Josh Waitzkin

“and making those trade-offs for people on the mental and emotional side is really difficult because you know passing up a high status option that's in front of you often feels difficult it feels like a very real loss people have a hard time giving up status when it's offered to them and so yeah i've been thinking about this for a very long time and uh it's an intrinsically difficult problem but i think it's it's a problem that's very valuable to think about”

0.74

Loss aversion—our deep hatred of feeling like we're losing or making bad decisions that others will notice—drives excessive conservatism in exploration, leading people to avoid the low-stakes failures that would generate learning.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Josh Waitzkin

“this this gets back back to loss aversion right we hate to feel like we're losing we hate to feel like we're making bad decisions uh in the context of an organization looking bad in front of other people giving them a reason to question our judgment about future things that might be more important and there's there's also a scale in which failure is more or less acceptable and so yeah for it for the big important life or organizational decisions that you can't if you can't you can't screw up because the consequences of screwing up are so big that just indicates that you need to have a bigger research budget or or experimentation budget information collection budget in order to optimize that as much as you can by the time a decision absolutely needs to be made but yeah i think it's one of those things that people are too conservative when it comes to doing that exploration bit because the mistakes because the waste were too emotionally attached to wanting to avoid those things”

0.74

Acknowledging uncertainty and risk leads to better preparation: identifying gaps in knowledge, anticipating what could go wrong, assessing those risks, and developing mitigation strategies for known risks—which doesn't eliminate uncertainty and risk but makes pursuing ambitious goals much easier and less stressful.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Josh Waitzkin

“because it helps you acknowledge there are ways that i need to grow in order to face this challenge there are things that might get in the way of accomplishing this goal let me figure out what they are there are risks that if something goes a certain way i'm not going to get what i want what are those risks and what are the things that i can do to alleviate at least the known risks the things that i can do something about and i think all of those things they don't solve the problem in the sense of removing the uncertainty removing the risk making it a 100 guarantee that you're going to get what you want but they make the project much easier to approach and your experience of doing the things you need to do to get what you want becomes much easier much less stressful uh much more approachable in a way that the the big nebulous project is not”

0.74

No one—including successful entrepreneurs—is born with the ability to know what will happen in advance; everyone is dealing with fundamental uncertainty and omniscience is not an achievable capability; accepting this as a fact of reality rather than expecting to eliminate uncertainty is necessary for functioning.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Josh Waitzkin

“there are no born people who know exactly what's going to happen and yeah so we we another way of putting it is we expect ourselves to be omniscient and omnipotent and we are not and neither is anybody else and and so i think dropping that as much as we can or at least acknowledging our preference of like we would we would like to know what's going to work or what's not going to work before we do it that would be a wonderful capability to have every business person every investor on the face of the earth would give up their entire um everything that they own in order to have that capability because with it you could do anything um i i think just coming to terms with these are fundamental aspects of reality they can't be run around they can't be hacked they can't be eliminated in the context of anything that we want to do with our lives these these are inherent facts about the world that we live in and so accepting that that's the the way things are um it's it's the first part of the battle”

0.74

You must set your own scorecard for success independent of comparison to others; without this, status-driven decisions will continue to undermine actual wellbeing regardless of objective achievement.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Josh Waitzkin

“you have to set your own scorecard i think that's a great place to end this conversation”

0.74

Status dynamics also keep people compliant within organizations: the prospect of climbing the corporate ladder (a status symbol through titles and position) creates tacit agreements to avoid ruffling feathers and go along with organizational direction, even when this compromises their own interests.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker (appears to be interviewer)

“status also keeps us in organizations it keeps us compliant you know in all of these subtle ways right there's just almost like tacit agreement that when i'm in a meeting and my boss is there that if i go along and get along i'm gonna be i have a chance at that chair one day but if i ruffle ruffle some feathers or you know uh cause difficulty then i'm not gonna be able to climb this corporate ladder which is largely a status symbol the titles the all of these things”

0.73

The emotional reality of quality of life is decoupled from objective conditions: even people living far better than historical royalty (due to antibiotics, technology, comfort) often feel worse because social status is relative and always visible through media, making absolute improvements invisible to emotional experience.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Josh Waitzkin

“in the absolute when you look at your life um in the grand scheme of things the vast majority of us that are are listening to this podcast we live better than the highest status people lived as early as like 100 years ago there's there's no question like would you choose to be a king or an emperor in an era before antibiotics or after antibiotics like it's it's crazy and yet the emotional experience that we have does not reflect the reality of what we could feel if we defined status in a different way or if we were more careful about or careful deliberate intentional about how we think about success and status”

0.69

The Suzuki method of learning piano—starting by listening to music so that students know what correct performance sounds like before attempting to play—creates a fast feedback loop where performers can immediately recognize wrong notes and self-correct, enabling much faster progress than traditional methods.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Josh Waitzkin

“both of my kids are learning how to play the piano and the method that that they are using which has worked phenomenally well it's called the suzuki method of of music you don't even start by playing notes on the keyboard you start by listening to music and the reason is by the time you sit down in front of the keyboard to play a piece you already know what it's supposed to sound like and so while you're playing you know you hit a wrong note you know immediately that that note is not correct and you need to go back a little bit and fix it and so that that form of fast feedback allows you to progress far more rapidly than you otherwise would because you are able to make those fine variations in the act of practicing it's like the first thing you're learning is how to correct yourself when you make a mistake or how to acknowledge that you've made a mistake”

0.69

Social comparison visibility has increased dramatically with digital media: rather than comparing to neighbors (one reference point), people now see unlimited others across Instagram, Facebook, and other platforms doing things in each aspect of life, creating constant feelings of inadequacy and making relative status more salient.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (appears to be interviewer)

“it's never been so visible that other people have more status and it's really interesting because it's on particular variables now too right like it used to be you sort of lived on your street you could see that joe got a new car or whatever and you know it's this one reference point but it's your your little tiny community but now you're inundated with instagram and facebook and you're connected in a way that everybody is always doing something that you want to do in one particular aspect of your life somebody's got a new car or somebody's going on vacation somebody's uh you know got a really found a really attractive partner you sort of like and then you're you're constantly feeling less about yourself”

0.68

Deliberate practice—focused, undistracted practice with attention to performance and self-correction, plus active experimentation with small variations—combined with fast feedback loops, is what separates good practitioners from great ones.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Josh Waitzkin

“there's been a lot of research over the years about what effective practice is what it looks like how you do it it's often called deliberate practice so you are not distracted you're focusing exactly on what's going on you are paying attention to your performance and correcting yourself as you go and then you are also paying explicit attention to small variations in what you're doing trying little experiments if i do it this way how does it turn out if i do it that way how does it turn out and i think back to your question what separates people who are good at something in a skill context versus people who are great something is that they are much better at doing that very fine experimentation in the moment paying attention learning the variations learning the exceptions and that's what allows them to develop great skill in a wide variety of circumstances”

0.68

Steve Jobs' exposure to calligraphy and typography (outside traditional computer science) led directly to the design excellence of the original Macintosh; this exemplifies combinatorial effects where domain knowledge from one field (design) combined with computer science capability to produce something neither field alone could create.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Josh Waitzkin

“i i think that the classic business example of this is um in the founding of apple when steve jobs takes a calligraphy class and then typography and and that element of design becomes an instrumental part of the very first macintosh computers that's an example of bringing something that seems completely out of left field right like what did computers and calligraphy have in common but it turns out when you do some experimentation and you apply what you learn in one area to a completely different area you can unlock a lot of value”

0.68

Instructors and coaches accelerate skill development by providing fast feedback loops: they can objectively observe performance, notice fine variations and small mistakes the performer might miss, and provide immediate feedback that allows in-the-moment correction, which is superior to learning without external observation.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Josh Waitzkin

“usually when you're when you're learning a skill one of the things that allows you to learn that skill faster or pick up that skill faster is what's called a fast feedback loop and so there should be a very short period of time between making a mistake or not performing in the way that you want to perform recognizing that there's something to be improved and then making the adjustment making the improvement and so when what an excellent instructor or coach or someone who is a teacher somebody who's helping you develop the skill what they give you primarily aside from having some knowledge and experience about what performance looks like is they are a party that is outside of yourself who can take an objective look at exactly what it is that you're doing and they can notice the fine variations the the small mistakes the things that you might not even notice and then the feedback loop that so they can they can stop you they can call it out they can help you correct it in the moment”

0.66

Knowledge and skill are completely different: knowledge is information and concept formation (teachable in school, but not all knowledge is useful), while skill is the reliable, repeatable ability to perform a specific action to produce an objective result in the real world.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Josh Waitzkin

“the the first thing to delineate is knowledge and skill are two completely different things so knowledge in the learning sense gathering information forming these concepts so like the personal mba is a book of business knowledge it is not a book of business skill in the sense that skill is being able to perform in a particular way with an objective that you care about so you should be able to see yourself in the real world doing something to produce a particular result in a reliable repeatable way that's what skill is i think a lot of people conflate the two um so going to school often gives you knowledge some of that knowledge is useful some of the knowledge is not”

0.66

Reflection—the work of thinking through what happened, how you performed, and what to do differently—is largely misunderstood but is the actual mechanism of learning; without reflection or pain, learning doesn't really occur or occurs much more slowly.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker (appears to be interviewer)

“i think reflection is a largely misunderstood component of learning and i think that without reflection we don't really learn uh as maybe the uptake of learning is much slower without it i would almost say we don't really learn without some sort of pain or reflection angle to learning i mean if you put your hand on a hot stove you learn really quickly because you have a pain response in your in your brain and you know but reflection is the work of learning i i honestly i think of it as that”

0.66

Peer group and the people you surround yourself with dramatically affect risk tolerance: different social groups have vastly different expectations about what's possible, and spending time with people who are themselves experimenting and taking risks (and being supportive of your own risk-taking) provides enormous value that cannot be easily replicated.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker (appears to be interviewer)

“the people you hang around make a huge difference for your risk tolerance too so if you're sort of like five closest friends or very intolerant of any risk it's going to be that much harder for you to take a risk and and i noticed this sort of when i left government everybody was like oh my god you're crazy right because nobody wanted to leave you're you're leaving this guaranteed well-paid job you know extremely well paid great job i love my job but you're leaving this to do something so uncertain and being around people at work was one thing and then my parents also thought i was crazy but my friends were like what took you so long and you know it was it was very different my reactions being and where my brain tended to go”

0.65

Feedback in modern workplaces has largely disappeared due to fear of hurting feelings and competitive dynamics (colleagues rarely provide candid feedback since they compete for the same promotion), making external feedback unavailable and leaving self-feedback through logging and recording as the primary tool for workplace skill improvement.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (appears to be interviewer)

“it seems like the ability of other people to give you feedback in the workplace is largely gone away for various reasons whether they don't want to hurt your feelings or whatever is going on or you know in some ways they compete with you your colleagues rarely come up to you and say hey josh here's the one thing holding you back from getting a promotion uh that i want to get to right so you have this semi-competitive environment but you know your boss is busy and they're not always able to coach you”

0.62

Organizations generally have low tolerance for failure, even when they rhetorically celebrate it; cultural expectation is that failures must be small, and bold ideas with high failure rates are discouraged—creating an arbitrage opportunity for individuals willing to suffer through iterations to find optimal solutions.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (appears to be the interviewer/host, not Waitzkin)

“in organizations there's definitely an expectation that we're not going to fail experimentation is sort of i mean as much as they talk about celebrating failure uh you know there's not a big tolerance especially for sort of like big failure right if you're going to fail it's got to be a little failure and you can't try these big bold ideas but also personally like there's a there's as you were saying that i'm like there's something about that that we just don't want to admit to ourselves whether it's an ego thing or or whatever it is like there's a niche there and almost an arbitrage if you will for people who are willing to do that and suffer through a few iterations to find something”

0.62

Business school functions primarily as a status signal—communicating that you're a serious, qualified business person—rather than as a primary source of business knowledge; everything taught in business school can be learned independently, yet people pay 400,000+ dollars for the signal, making it a potentially ruinous status malfunction for those who cannot recoup that investment.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Josh Waitzkin

“i make an argument very early on in the book that that business school in in very many senses is primarily about status signaling it's it's about signaling that you are part of a group of serious qualified business people um sophisticated operators people who are competent people who know what are what's going on people who can make big things happen in the world um there is nothing that's taught in business school classrooms that you are not capable of learning and understanding and applying on your own there's there's not full stop even so people are willing to spend so the the latest estimate that i've that i've heard when you when you calculate all of the costs of going to a top program so tuition fees um cost of living opportunity cost of lost wages when you calculate the whole thing there are if i'm remembering correctly nine schools that have just passed the 400 000 mark in terms of total cost of a program that's a very expensive status signal and there are some some people in some circumstances for whom that will be a good or at least neutral investment and there are a lot of people in the world for whom that will be a millstone around their neck for the rest of their life”

0.56

Synthesizing information across broad domains requires two key steps: (1) consuming input from a wide variety of sources across many domains rather than narrow specialization, and (2) performing frequency analysis on recurring ideas, concepts, names, and relationships that appear repeatedly across diverse sources, which signals importance and warrants deeper investigation.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Josh Waitzkin

“in terms of of technique or process there's two steps to it one is the more input that you have from a wide variety of sources the more material that you have to work with so i think if if we invert that into what a lot of people don't do is they pay attention to a very narrow set of sources or all of their their reading their research their experimentation their investigation is in one very narrow domain and they don't really stray outside of that the wider you look the wider the the variety of sources that you have coming into your brain the more access to interesting insights and connections you would you would have”

0.56

Once accepting fundamental uncertainty, the path to acting is exploration and experimentation in ways that are 'informed risks' (not reckless) that probably won't cause permanent damage or death, but might represent real breakthroughs—and any result generates more information and improves capability regardless of whether the discrete experiment succeeds.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Josh Waitzkin

“that's where the exploration and experimentation trying new things taking informed risks so so pushing in ways that probably aren't going to kill you or do permanent damage but might represent a real breakthrough in this area that that you care about um you you start to see when when the fear stops and and there's there's an idea that i talk about in the personal mba called threat lockdown it's it's our our minds defensive mode when when we feel like our world is out of control or there's there's some scary risky bad thing that can happen to us our natural response is to lock down we go into defensive mode we try not to stick our neck out we try to we get super conservative yes we're we're minimizing exposure and it's important to understand that's a physiological response and it's built in there very very deeply and so if you recognize that that that is something that is a part of all of us what are all of the things that you can do to debug or disable that threat lockdown response long enough to do the exploration to do the experimentation to do the things that will actually get you closer to where you want to be from where you are now and i think the more you're able to focus on i don't know if this is going to work but i'm going to try it and any any result gives me more information gives me more data about the world it improves my skills and improves my capabilities of acting in the world that is a win regardless of whether or not that discrete experiment actually moves things forward or not you are becoming a better more skilled person by virtue of doing the thing that you're trying to do”

0.56

Status malfunction can be mitigated by examining lower-status options and evaluating whether they help achieve actual goals in a faster, more direct, less expensive, or less risky way than high-status alternatives.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Josh Waitzkin

“i was noticing this subtext in a lot of my work both in in the personal mba in the first 20 hours in how to fight a hydra where you can often get much better results if you're willing to examine look at and take seriously the lower status option and evaluate that in terms of does this help me get what i want in a faster more direct less expensive less risky less uncertain way”

0.52

The experimentation and research process in pursuit of optimization involves a certain amount of 'malinvestment'—purchasing products that don't work, trying approaches that fail—which should be understood as tuition cost for gathering domain knowledge rather than waste to be minimized.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Josh Waitzkin

“when you're doing this sort of research there's always a certain amount of malinvestment like you buy you buy a microphone that doesn't work for you you you buy a water bottle that's highly reviewed and it ends up leaking or being annoying in some way and there's a certain amount of waste in the process of of doing this exploration which which is really annoying like you would hope to avoid most of that but i think in a lot of domains where you're doing synthesis or you're doing optimizing sort of research that malinvestment is a form of tuition it's the price that you're paying to gather information about this domain that you care about and so if the problem is worth solving at all it's probably worth having an experimentation budget where you know in the process of trying things you'll find some things that work in some things that don't and hopefully you can minimize that cost for sure but you're always going to have a certain amount of part of the process or part of the materials or part of your sources that just aren't going to work out and that that's there's nothing wrong with that that's to be expected”

0.52

Side projects are dramatically undervalued; they often produce unexpected enormous value (as demonstrated by the Personal MBA starting as a side project) and are the source of combinatorial effects and skill building, yet they're often deprioritized in favor of linear career advancement.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Josh Waitzkin

“there's there's one of one of the the way back xkcd cartoons was like the value of things to my career like this degree that i went to school for for whatever or the the weekend in high school that i spent hacking together a perl script that form of experimentation like just trying a bunch of things learning how certain things work sometimes it's the side projects sometimes it's the things that you were doing just because you were interested or just because you cared about it or just because you wanted to see if you could push the state of the art in a particular area those are the things that end up providing an unexpected enormous amount of value from my own life the personal mba was a side project i planned on you know at that point in my life i had a really good job”

0.52

When seeking to learn from others, ask them about their reflections on experiences and their mental models—how they thought about decisions, what variables they saw as important, and how they anticipated outcomes—rather than asking what to do; this allows triangulation across multiple people's experiences to identify which variables actually matter.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (appears to be interviewer)

“it changes the questions you ask other people too because it now you're you're not asking other people what to do you're asking them to to basically open their mind about the reflections on their experiences they've had so you have an experience and they reflect on it so i want to learn from you i'm not going to say like what do i what do i need to do in this case i i want to say like how did you think about it what did you see what were the raw inputs how did you see those kind of aggregating and playing out over time if you had models and analytic models about how you thought about it what were those models um and then how does that to your point earlier about time right like how does that fast forward in time and how can we anticipate that playing out and if you do that with three or four different people in a certain domain you can triangulate on the variables that really matter in a given decision”

0.52

The difference between a line cook and a chef is not recipes but experience and reflection: both follow the same recipe, but when something goes wrong the chef can diagnose the problem almost instantly because they've done the work of reflecting on their experience, while the line cook has a much harder time diagnosing failures.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker (appears to be interviewer)

“it's like our friend tim who's got the there's a line cook and a chef right they both can follow the same recipe but when something goes wrong the chef can diagnose almost instantly why because they've done the work they've reflected on the line cook has a much different level of experience and level of reflection and so it's much harder for them to diagnose”

0.52

Pursuing side projects through experimentation and iteration allows you to distinguish between lottery tickets (no information) and informed bets (data from the world); the more information you collect through experiments, the more confident you become that additional investment will pay off.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Josh Waitzkin

“i think a lot of people don't understand sort of linear versus non-linear and exponential upside i mean you traded a very linear probably stable but great career for uh you know in some ways a lottery ticket on a non-linear outcome yeah and i think yeah maybe maybe a little bit more than a lottery ticket because the the lottery ticket you have no information at the beginning yeah yeah and so the nice thing about all these side projects because you're doing experimentation and because you're doing iteration all of those experiments give you data from the world about is this working for me is this working for other people and the more information you collect the more confidence you have about you know if i do more in this area is it going to pay off and you could affect your outcome too so like yeah it's not a pure lottery ticket but it's definitely you know uh not guaranteed either”

0.52

Using status malfunction as a decision filter—asking whether pursuing a high-status option would actively make life worse—helps avoid expensive status-driven mistakes despite the emotional difficulty of rejecting prestige.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Josh Waitzkin

“i found it really helpful to to think about this idea of status malfunction to use that as an opportunity to take a step back and evaluate and say no like there are certain brass rings that if i decided to pursue them i would be actively making my life worse in ways that i care about and that's i found it a very valuable check step to to before committing to something be like is this really going to improve things or is is this something that feels enticing because of millions of years of human psychology and evolutionary development but in the end is leading to an outcome that i don't want”

0.52

Combinatorial effects occur when you bring together unrelated skills or knowledge domains in novel ways, creating value that neither domain could produce alone; diverse experiences and side projects are therefore undervalued because their payoff is often delayed and relies on unexpected combinations.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Josh Waitzkin

“combinatorial effects are things that happen when you bring other sometimes unrelated things together in a new and valuable way skills have combinatorial effects so the the more experiences the more capabilities that you have in sometimes wildly different areas each of those capabilities brings the possibility of combining it with something else in your wheelhouse in in a way that works particularly well”

0.50

When selecting sources for cross-domain research, prioritize books that teach how to think about a subject from a practical application perspective (e.g., 'Influence' as a guide to cognitive biases in persuasion, 'On Writing Well' as a guide to clear nonfiction) rather than trend pieces or biographical entertainment, as application-oriented sources reveal consistent patterns and commonalities across approaches.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Josh Waitzkin

“i try to narrow down what i'm reading to mostly books that that you could fit into the framework of how to think about fill in the blank and so i'm not reading a bunch of biographies i'm not reading a bunch of you know entertainment or or um call it trend pieces like you know here's uh i just i remember a book from a couple years ago of like the rising trend of of twitter like that's not a good investment in terms of this kind of research i want to read something like influence which is how to think about cognitive biases in this in the specific application of persuasion in sales i want to read on writing well by william zinser to to get in my brain like how to convey nonfiction material in a clear concise way”

0.50

Risk can be categorized into additive, subtractive, and multiplicative types; most people overestimate multiplicative risk (going back to zero) when in reality failure in most ventures is additive or subtractive in nature, and understanding this distinction reduces the psychological burden of risk-taking.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (appears to be interviewer)

“i often think of this as like when you're talking about risk there's there's sort of additive subtractive risk and then there's multiplicative risk and you know that's a helpful framework to sort of be like well if it fails like what's the worst case outcome you know rarely is it multiplicative and you're going back to zero”

0.48

The Personal MBA identifies five essential parts of every business: value creation (making something valuable), marketing (attracting attention), sales (converting interest to payment), value delivery (fulfilling what was promised), and finance (ensuring inflows exceed outflows and compensate for invested time and energy).

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Josh Waitzkin

“the organizing principle in the first part of the book about business is something that i call the five parts of every business which is is essentially a working definition of what a business is and what a business does and uh just very briefly a a business has five parts they create something valuable for other people which is value creation marketing is attracting attention and getting people interested in whatever it is you have to offer sales is about the process of taking someone who is interested a prospect and getting them to pull out their wallet checkbook credit card and give you money for this thing that you've made uh value delivery is the uh the part of the process where you actually give your customers what they have paid for because if you don't you're not running a business you're running a scam and finance is just the the process of looking at the inflows and outflows of money and answering two very important questions a is more money flowing in than flowing out because if not you have a problem and b is it enough is it enough to compensate you for the time and attention and energy that you're continuing to invest in the business because if it's not then that business has a sustainability problem”

0.48

Waitzkin's approach to acquiring knowledge about consumer products (water bottles, microphones) follows the same research process: identify a specific problem you care about solving, collect examples and test them systematically against each other, and through comparison and experimentation discover which solutions work better and which have drawbacks—which typically requires less time than reading or asking others.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Josh Waitzkin

“in those other domains i usually have a specific problem that i want to solve there's a reason that i'm doing it or there's a reason that i care about it and that's where the exploration and experimentation piece comes in i don't necessarily know what's going to work in advance but i do know that i have a problem that i care about and a way to solve it which is i can collect a whole bunch of different examples and test them out or put them through a process of comparing a versus b over and over and over and over again if you do that for any significant length of time you start noticing which are the things that solve your problem better and which are the things that have some significant drawbacks”

0.48

For high-significance decisions, Waitzkin employs value-of-information reasoning: the benefit of research and experimentation (better signal for decision-making) must be weighed against the cost (time, attention, energy), and he personally biases toward maximizing the time and energy budget for decisions involving tools, environment, or outcomes he cares deeply about.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Josh Waitzkin

“you can think about this in terms of value of information and so if you go through for example a research process or an experimentation process trying to collect as much information about this particular decision as you can there's a value of information in the sense of the more information that you collect that can give you good signal to help you hone in on on what looks to be the best decision you can make at a point but there's also a cost of information of all of that research all of that experimentation you're spending time you're spending attention you're spending energy in order to collect it”

0.48

The book 'How to Fight a Hydra' addresses ambition, fear, uncertainty, and risk in the context of wanting to do something big or never done before; it uses fiction as the medium to help readers have accurate mental simulations of what it looks and feels like to navigate these difficult topics rather than presenting advice in list format.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Josh Waitzkin

“the book that you're referencing how to fight a hydra is a book a lot about many interesting difficult to approach topics so it's it's about ambition in the sense of wanting to do something big or wanting to do something you've never done before it's about fear it's about fear of the unknown not knowing what to expect not knowing if you're going to be able to do this thing that you want to be able to do it's about uncertainty so not having all of the answers in advance not knowing exactly what you're going to need to do or how you're going to need to grow in order to get to the end result and it's about risk it's about facing the the very real possibility that you're going to invest your time your energy your money your life in something that might not produce the results that you're hoping for in the process of of writing that book my my process is very research based i'm i'm reading i'm trying things my inclination is is to to take a non-fiction attack on explaining how to do all of this well and when i was working on the book subjects like risk or uncertainty lack of locus of control uh all of those things if you if you think about it too much if you consider it too accurately they become very uncomfortable very quickly because it it's it's really like coming to terms with the things that you control and the things you can't and and you know the very real possibility that this thing that you want to do is a dead end that's not going to work for you and and so there are things that we can do to minimize uncertainty to minimize risk to maximize our locus of control and so the process of writing a book how to write a hydra is fiction and and what i was trying to do in that book is instead of explaining how to do it in a list format or advice you know do a b c d e f g what i was trying to do is is help readers have a more accurate mental simulation of what it looks and feels like to use these sorts of ideas on a practical level so show someone doing it instead of explaining necessarily how to do it”

0.48

Waitzkin left a well-paid corporate job to pursue the Personal MBA as a full-time project because: (1) he had demonstrable evidence the project was valuable to many people, (2) he had data suggesting investment would pay off, and (3) the upside was nonlinear compared to the linear but stable corporate career.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Josh Waitzkin

“i remember um so my my dad was an elementary school principal and then towards the back half of his career he was a principal he was a teacher first and then a principal my very first year out of college i had a job where i was making more than he had made in 25 30 years in education and i remember when i went home and i told him that i was quitting my job to start my own business like what are you doing that's crazy like why would you give up this sure thing in order to do this thing that you have no idea whether it's not going to work or not the reason i did it was because the project was valuable demonstrably valuable to a lot of people i had data to suggest that if i i invested more time and energy here it would pay off and yeah there was uncertainty there there was risk there um i was giving up something that was valuable in exchange for something that i didn't know the value of but the only reason it was a possibility in the first place was because i decided to invest a portion of my time and energy in this crazy side project that i had no idea how it was going to turn out but the upside of it happens to be a lot more than than i could have expected at the beginning”

0.48

Logging—writing down what you accomplish, the decisions you make, and the places where you get stuck—is a technique for debugging your own mind and generating actionable self-insight by creating a record to reflect on and improve from.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Josh Waitzkin

“i think it's helpful to understand one of the things that that i've found in terms of a technique that i use a lot is uh is logging so just trying to pay attention to what it is that you're doing what you're trying to do and then writing down both what you accomplish in the course of the day but also the decisions that you make and the places where you get stuck”

0.48

Self-generated feedback mechanisms—logging of meetings with notes on what was said and how participants felt, recording yourself speaking and reviewing the recordings—provide a substitute for external feedback in soft skills development by creating an external view of your own performance.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Josh Waitzkin

“one of the most valuable tools we were talking about logging earlier this is another one of those areas where keeping a daily log of what you're doing and how your internal understanding of how you did what went well what didn't go well what you would try the the next time just having that reflection loop is one of the best things that you can do for yourself to both capture what's happening in the moment how you did as well as go back and look at it later so maybe you're a manager and you have a few direct reports you have a one-on-one meeting with one of them and you take some notes about what you talked about how it how you were feeling during the meeting how it seems like they were feeling how they were reacting and then if you get feedback from the outside world later like your direct report comes back later and said yeah that thing that you said during our meeting the other day that really didn't work for me or that made me feel a certain way or all of that you can contrast your contemporaneous experience with what you're doing at the point when it happened to the feedback and the information you're getting from the outside world and you can use that contrast to experiment in certain ways or do things differently the next time around it's it's that reflective loop that lets you get better at some of the soft skills that are otherwise really difficult to improve the same thing goes for something like speaking and so when you speak even if it's just for yourself make a recording you give yourself the opportunity to see yourself from the outside doing this thing that you want to get good at”

0.46

Waitzkin defines his own success as working on projects he values, with people he likes, in a way that allows him to take care of himself and his family; if any of these elements slip, something needs to change. This definition was developed as a reaction to observing corporate contexts where people pursue status and advancement at severe personal cost.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Josh Waitzkin

“for me success is working on projects that i value and i think are important with people that i like in a way that allows me to take care of myself and my family that's it and so if i'm doing those things i'm being successful if one or more of those things are slipping then something needs to change and part of that was a reaction to the realities of working in a big corporate environment so i i saw a lot of people who were working on projects they didn't care about i saw a lot of of people who were trying to get into the upper rungs of management and they weren't particularly enjoying the role or the the company of the people that they were working with and i saw a lot of people who didn't spend time with their family and invested all of their waking hours in in pushing the organization forward even if they were carrying severe personal costs to do so”

0.43

High-quality information sources are those recommended by trusted sources who explain the problem they were trying to solve and how the resource helped solve it; internet reviews are generally low-quality unless they include this problem-solution mapping rather than vague hedonic judgments like 'interesting' or 'enjoyable'.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Josh Waitzkin

“this is where recommendations are worth their weight in gold so if there's a source that you trust that talks about a specific thing in a specific way that's a very good signal reviews can be good signal if they include the information that this is what i was trying to do and this is the problem i was trying to solve and this is how this particular resource solved this problem or helped me with this provide a solution in in a very concrete way i don't pay much attention on the review front to oh this was really interesting this was this was enjoyable this was a fun use of my time”